Mikita Brottman’s “Guilty Creatures” dives deep into the fascinating, often disturbing, history of animal trials. This meticulously researched work, more than just a historical account, offers a compelling exploration of the human-animal relationship and the way we project our own anxieties and desires onto the animal kingdom.
Brottman masterfully weaves together legal records, historical anecdotes, and philosophical insights, demonstrating how throughout history, animals have been put on trial, accused of everything from murder to witchcraft. From the pig of Falaise, charged with cannibalism in 1386, to the dog of Orléans, condemned for sodomy in 1586, these cases reveal a remarkable human fascination with attributing human-like agency and morality to animals.
The book explores the complex interplay of religious beliefs, legal systems, and social anxieties that led to these trials. Brottman argues that these trials were often a reflection of the anxieties of the time, with animals serving as scapegoats for societal fears and moral failings. She also examines the role of animals in folklore and mythology, showcasing how our perception of them has been shaped by both our fascination and our fear.
While at times unsettling, “Guilty Creatures” is a thought-provoking read. Brottman’s eloquent prose and insightful analysis challenge us to reconsider our assumptions about the relationship between humans and animals. By delving into the past, she prompts us to reflect on the present, urging us to question our own biases and the ethical complexities of our interactions with the non-human world.
“Guilty Creatures” is more than just a historical curiosity. It is a powerful exploration of human nature, a reminder of our often-unconscious biases, and a call for greater understanding and empathy in our interactions with the animal kingdom.
