Uncategorized

A Guide to Subject-Centered Curriculum

In this model, the syllabus is segmented into subject areas, with a limited amount of flexibility for any activities outside the core curriculum. With subjects being siloed, great importance is given to gaining knowledge of, and memorizing each content area. This curriculum places a strong emphasis on teaching, proper teacher-student explanations, and precise strategies. Some of these strategies include lectures, clarification of concepts being taught, and teacher-student conversations. 

The curriculum encourages students to commit concepts that have been thought to memory and be ready to regurgitate facts/ideas when required of them. Conventionally, students have not been able to decide what they want to study under this type of curriculum, but in recent times, students can now choose their own electives as well as pick a topic for personal project work from a list of key topics provided.   

If, for example, a curriculum is centered around a certain subject area (e.g., World War II), pertinent facts, ideas, and concepts around that subject area are discussed, with learning objectives focused on the attainment and commitment to the memory of these concepts and ideas. In this curriculum, the instructional methods often include oral discussions, lectures, and clarification of questions asked by students. 

The spiral curriculum is a good example of a subject-centered curriculum. Emphasis is placed on the material to be taught (concepts, facts, and ideas), and less attention is paid to the actual discipline structure. This means the knowledge structure is what is focused on, instead of the comprehensive information that ought to be provided.  

In the spiral curriculum, emphasis is drawn away from the specific learning topics to be understood within a certain time span, while students are repeatedly exposed to a wide variety of ideas. Because the spiral curriculum involves moving from topic to topic in a circular manner, students can be reached as soon as they are ready to understand a concept. Additionally, the spiral curriculum endlessly tries to reinforce the rudiments of the concept being discussed, so that these fundamentals are archived in the students’ knowledge base and the loss of students who are unprepared for the new lesson is ultimately avoided.   

This technique, known as spiraling, allows students to work on the same skill over and over, with a gradual increment in the level of difficulty of taught concepts.  Practically, spiraling refers to placing emphasis on core topics in a specific subject, which is then repeated over the years, with added layers of complexities. For example, instead of teaching “division” in the first semester of a mathematics class, the concept can be broken into bits, with simple division taught in the first semester and taught again in the second semester, but this time, using double figures. 

A Guide to High Schools

A high school usually admits students from Grades 9-12. Courses taught in high school carry Carnegie Units (CUs), and students are expected to accrue a specific number before they can graduate.  The Carnegie Unit measures the number of hours a student is expected to study, for a particular course, and most courses have 1 CU. However, some elective courses carry half a Carnegie Unit. Each state and district has a specific number of CUs required for graduation. 

In high school, classes remain departmentalized, and high schools could either follow year-long class schedules or use the block-scheduling approach. In the year-long class scheduling approach, students are required to attend between six to seven class periods daily for two semesters, with each period being approximately 50-60 minutes long.  Per school year, students could earn up to 7 CUs. 

The block scheduling approach allows students to attend four classes daily for one semester, with each period being approximately 90-minutes long. Per school year, students can earn up to 8 CUs. 

The block scheduling model has a variation, which allows students to attend classes every other day, over two semesters.  After graduating high school, students are expected to possess the necessary skills to either enter college or join the workforce. 

High school settings are able to transform kids into adults and help refine the current study skills students possess while also planting necessary seeds to help the kids become excellent in college or trade school.  It must be capable of helping the students weather the tempestuous mood changes and the uncertainty that is often present during this stage of their lives. It has to help them find and stay on the right paths that will lead them to success and fulfillment in their future endeavors. It must be simple enough that they can go through it successfully without losing confidence in their abilities but challenging enough that it forces them to push beyond their limits and grow, thereby gaining both competence and confidence. 

A high school must be structured carefully so that the needs of the students are met. It is important that students receive all the assistance needed to navigate the complexity of the high school experience. This includes everything from selecting classes to building the skill and discipline they will need to succeed in their further educational pursuits. The structure of the high school must be holistic so that the students can come out of it, competent individuals capable of going through life as adults and contributing meaningfully to society.

A Guide to Elementary Schools

Elementary school usually refers to grades one to six. However, this is not always the case as there are variations. Classes in elementary schools are usually self-contained and have just one teacher taking all subjects. Although there are variations, and in some cases, a class may be taught by a team of two teachers, and in some districts, upper elementary grades are departmentalized. For many students, the fourth grade may be more challenging than the third grade because prior to this class, they had been learning to read and must henceforth read to learn. 

This is also the class where students stop learning basic math and have to start applying the basics they have learned to advanced and multi-step math problems. This increase in the complexity of their learning activities also applies to other subjects. Students will do less reading for pleasure and more reading to gain information; in other words, students will begin content-area reading. Though the students will likely have some experience from reading to learn in the first grade, students who have never had to read to gain information may initially find content-area reading to be quite challenging. In grades 3-12, achievement test scores are given more importance and students spend more time and effort in preparation for tests.    

There is increasing skepticism about the testing system and its potential merits and demerits. This has caused a lot of parents to feel uncertain about allowing their children to be exposed to testing. The reason testing seems rampant is that it is essential for monitoring the progress of the students and learning how they can be helped to thrive academically. Testing helps teachers learn whether their students are ready to move on to the next class.  

This is especially important because it is in elementary school that the disparity in academic performance begins to show quite strongly. This is why it is important that teachers pay careful attention to the academic progress of each student to make sure that none are falling behind their peers and in the case that any student is having a hard time keeping up, it is the teacher’s responsibility to support that student and help them catch up.   

A Guide to Middle Schools

It isn’t uncommon for students to remember their middle school years as awkward and difficult, but in reality, it is the time when most students begin to thrive academically. By this time, students would have gotten through the difficulty of the shift from learning for pleasure, to learning for information and growth. Students, if the goals of elementary school are achieved successfully, should have been fully equipped with the skill and discipline they need to start working within a more challenging, defined, and goal-oriented academic structure. By the time they enter middle school, then, they can start walking on a clearer path which will prompt them to participate more in their academic growth and take increased responsibility for their success.  

Middle school is usually from the sixth grade to the eighth grade. A challenge that most middle school students experience is the sudden shift from the simple schedule they became accustomed to in elementary school to a block or departmentalized schedule. Block scheduling is an academic scheduling system that typically features a reduced number of daily classes for students, with each class having a significantly longer duration than students are used to. 

A class could be as long as 90 minutes, and unlike in elementary school, where one teacher could teach a class all the subjects, a middle school teacher would teach the same subject to different classes. In other words, block scheduling makes sure teachers teach by subject area. To achieve this, each teacher would have to rotate classes all day so they can teach the same subject.  

Some middle schools also schedule using an interdisciplinary team. The way this usually works is that a team of what is typically four teachers share 80 to 100 students and rotate according to a schedule, taking turns to teach their assigned group of students. These teachers meet at least once every week to discuss the progress of their students and any issues or problems that some students might be experiencing, and what steps they can take to help.  

When students enter middle school, they are presented with the option of taking electives. Electives give students the chance to select courses that they find interesting. Some common elective classes include graphic art, service learning, music, computers, film production, etc. The range of electives that are made available to students depends entirely on what their respective schools offer. Additionally, students that have courses that need remediation have the option of taking an extra course required in the specific area. 

Students that are flourishing academically have the option of taking advanced classes such as foreign languages or pre-algebra. As mentioned earlier, there is a greater emphasis on test scores and preparation for tests.

At the start of middle school, students will be introduced to extracurricular activities that will help them get ready for life in high school. The extracurricular activities are usually sports or clubs that are often unrelated to the basic academic courses, but are school-sponsored and held on school property. These extracurricular activities are not held during normal class hours and usually take place before or after school, sometimes during weekends. In grades seven and eight, schools begin to focus more on preparing their students for high school and helping them choose and actively start working towards a career path.  

Junior high school is a delicate time for students and is aimed at preparing students for their future by helping them strengthen their skills and develop unique personalities. Junior high school should enable students to gain an eagerness for exploration, pushing limits, understanding and accepting diversity, developing a desire for self-improvement and personal growth, etc. Junior high school helps students to learn to adapt to a disciplined and goal-oriented schedule during what is typically a chaotic period in their lives. This will help them prepare for the challenges of high school and tertiary education by enabling them to form the habits they will need to navigate the complex structures awaiting them.

What Role Does Your GPA Play in Graduate School Admissions?

Admission committees give a lot of importance to your high school GPA because it shows how you have been performing academically over a long period in school. It reflects your ability and motivation to do well consistently. Usually, a cumulative GPA of 3 to 3.3 is needed to gain admission into doctoral programs. However, this GPA may not be enough for getting admittance into graduate school because other factors, like course quality, may also come into play.

All grades do not have the same value. Admission committees also see the courses that you have taken. For instance, if you get a B in Advanced Statistics, it has more value than if you study Introduction to Pottery and get an A in it. The context of the grade point average has a lot of significance. The admission officers see where you obtained the GPA and the courses that you completed. So it is better to tackle a challenging academic course and have a low GPA than take an easy school course, such as Basket Weaving for Beginners and get a higher grade point average.

Admission committees look at your transcript closely. They see the overall GPA and the grade point average for courses related to the academic programs you want to join. For instance, your GPA in math and science courses if you have applied to a graduate program in the faculty of science or medical school. So make it a point to study those courses relevant to the graduate programs you intend to join in the future.

So now you know that your GPA plays a vital role in whether or not you get admitted into graduates school. To increase your chances of getting in, remember to always give 100% in your classes and keep an eye on your GPA. If you have any further questions, let us know in the comments section below.

Oh, and I almost forget, good luck and Godspeed.

Using the MCAT, LSAT, GMAT, and GRE to Get Into Graduate School

Admission officers know that it is not possible to compare the applicants’ weighted GPA meaningfully. Trust me, they have done this for a long time and have tried every trick in the book.

The value of the final grades may differ from one university to the other. For example, an A from one university might be equal to a B+ from another university. Besides this, the grading may be different among professors within a single university. All of these things make it more difficult to judge admissions applications

So the admission committees look at the scores of the standardized exams, such as MCAT, LSAT, GMAT, and GRE, to compare the applicants from various universities. If your GPA is low, you should try to do well in these exams.

How to Ace the MCAT, LSAT, GMAT, or GRE

You may be asking yourself, how can I do well on these exams so the admissions committee can overlook my GPA? Well, the first thing you need to do is learn as much as you can about the exam and what it is designed to measure. Make sure that this information comes from reputable sources, such as the website of the actual exam.

Next, set up a study regimen based on the skills and knowledge bases assessed on the exam. Again, you can find this info on the exam creator’s website. The test creator will also have study guides available to help you student for the exams. Also, check if your university has a course or program that prepares students for the exam. If not, ask around to see if there are any student-led programs or groups you can join.

Once you have thoroughly studied the material on the exam, you need to take several practice tests to gauge your level of readiness. This may be something that is provided by your university, so ask your academic advisor. Also, most test creators offer free and paid practice tests for students. The best of these simulate the actual exam and will help you definitively gauge whether or not you are ready for the exam.

Now you are ready to take the actual exam. Good luck. If you have any questions, leave them in the comments section below.

9 Things You Can Do If Your GPA is Low

Having a GPA that is below your level of aptitude is a tough pill to swallow. Trust me, as I have been there more times than I can remember during my high school and college days. What did I do to get out of my academic slump? I got serious about my studies and cut out most of my extracurricular activities. I was that devoted to increasing my GPA and finishing my bachelor’s degree.

If you are a high school or college student, you also can make an effort to improve your GPA. If you take additional credits, it will be harder to increase your grade point average. So it is necessary to take some action early before much damage.

Below you will find some sure-fire ways that you can use to increase both your course grades and your cumulative GPA.

  1. Make an effort to perform well in your class.
  2. Learn how to keep track of and calculate your high school and college grades by using a grade calculator.
  3. Learn how to keep track of and calculate your GPA by using a GPA calculator.
  4. Pursue high-quality or more challenging courses.
  5. Join the debate team. Tackling debate topics can help increase your critical thing skills, which will help you perform better academically.
  6. Take several courses. Do not study only those courses of study required to graduate.
  7. Take summer classes. They give you a chance to focus on one or two classes and perform well.
  8. Delay your graduation. Study for one or two extra semesters in school and take courses that can potentially improve your grade point average.
  9. Take some high-quality undergraduate courses or graduate courses after graduation to exhibit your academic abilities.

I am not going to lie to you. Increasing your GPA is not the easiest thing in the world, and it is no fun. You won’t be able to live the life of a socialite; you will need to begin living the life of an academic. However, if you listen to my advice and take action before it is too late, your GPA will increase semester after semester.

So what are you waiting for? Go ahead and get to work. If you have any questions about increasing your GPA, leave them in the comments area below. Good luck and Godspeed!

10 Reasons Why Critical Race Theory is Perfect for Confronting Racism

Emerging in the early 1908s, Critical race theory (CRT) was used to study the emerging identity politics in which people identified with personal characteristics rather than a movement or a political party. Later on, the theory was extensively discussed in the context of the strengths and weaknesses in the social fabric of modern American society. The approach has become controversial amidst the country’s struggle with race, civil rights, immigration, and civil conflict  (McPheeters, 2021). De LA Garza and Ono (2016) describe CRT as an intellectual movement seeking to understand the reproduction and maintenance of white supremacy as a cultural, legal, and political condition in the U.S. context. Moreover, they state that CRT is a unique approach. Since its origins are traced back to legal studies; it intends to be an agent for political and social change; it has an interdisciplinary utility including education and is often used as the umbrella term for race and racism studies.

Despite being in the discussion domain of academic and law circles, a considerable amount of ambiguity still lingers over the exact meaning and definition of the theory, which is one of the prime reasons why the theory’s strengths are alien to a majority. Another major issue with the theory is that it is perceived with a seemingly stereotypical approach which advocates that the theory: is gainst free societies; limits racial issues to socially constructed groups; doesn’t trust anti-racism initiatives; associates science and reasons with white people and storytelling with black people; and as a totalitarian theory that considers itself as the only honest approach. This essay offers the reader ten reasons why CRT is not any of the things mentioned above and why it can treat the race issue perfectly.

Defining Critical Race Theory

Critical Race Theory is based on the thought that the concepts of race and racism are produced by social thought and power relations (Rollock & Gillborn, 2011). CRT can also be described as a framework that can be used to examine the practices of racism in the society that disadvantage people for being black or a minority and, in turn, privilege whiteness. The theory challenges the concept of race-neutrality in policy, practice, and values the usually marginalized “black voice” (Hylton, 2008). Stovall (2005) refers to CRT as a multidimensional discipline since it draws from several relevant disciplines to incorporate an interdisciplinary approach in developing theory and practice in the context of racism in society.

According to Zalaznick (2021), CRT is based on the following concepts:

  • Race is a sociological construct and not biological.
  • Racism is a systemic mechanism through which racial profiling and racial inequalities are maintained in society.
  • Race and racism privilege the dominant class. So only those measures of racial equality or racial advancement will occur that cater to the interest of the prevalent course.
  • Racial identity changes according to the needs or interests of the dominant class. This means that different racial groups are radicalized in different ways for various reasons at other points in time.
  • Because of this dynamism, marginalized and radicalized people develop a unique perspective about the nature of the structures, systems, and institutions used to oppress them.

Having established how scholars define CRT and its conceptual base, it is important to show what the theory is not and what it does not imply.

According to Gray (2021), CRT does not assert any of the following:

  • A race or sex is superior to another race or sex by default.
  • People are privileged, oppressive, sexist, or racist because of their race or sex.
  • People should receive adverse treatment, be marginalized, or be discriminated against because of their race or sex.
  • People’s race or sex has anything to do with their moral character.
  • People bear responsibility for the past actions of members of the same race or sex.
  • People should feel guilt, discomfort, anguish, or psychological distress because of their race or sex.

This essay identifies and elaborates on why CRT is relevant and a perfect discourse of dealing with racism.

  1. CRT confronts the omnipresence of racism

CRT asserts that racism has become a part of everyday life and is taken normally. This behavior and “acceptance” creates situations where people, white or black, can unintentionally fuel racism by making certain choices. Racism is so deeply rooted in American culture that it is taken as natural and normal, and the legal and political systems are plagued by the concepts of White supremacy (Taylor, 1998).  As a result, the norms of the White, Cristian, and the dominant middle-class group have become the yardsticks used to judge others, to determine the definition of right and wrong, and other groups are expected to follow them as standards (Goodman, 2011). Thus, racism is not only about the prejudicial attitudes and actions of individuals but is also a state of mind deeply entrenched in the culture, psyches, systems, and institutions (Bonilla-Silva, 2015).

Essed (1991) argues that racism is pervasive in society because it has become a convenient occurrence in our daily life, especially for people of color. Additionally, incidents of racism and radicalization are experienced by all members of society and are affected by it regardless of their racial identity or affiliation.

CRT emphasizes the real-world impact of Race and Racism. CRT openly challenges the racist discourse and highlights the effects of race and racism on the identities, bodies, and life experiences of people of color. That way, it also explains the magnitude of the impact of racism because it, as a social condition, goes above ad beyond the scope of individual and intentional acts of racism and must, therefore, be understood at social, institutional, political, economic, and historical levels (De La Garza & Ono, 2016).

In this context, CRT adopts the strategy of exposing racism exactly the way it is. Critics, however, argue that people associate any disparity favoring the dominant class with racism and take CRT as a torch to look for racism in all walks of life. They also argue that teaching CRT in schools will profoundly affect the thought process of children who will look for racism in their daily interactions and situations. On the contrary, CRT emphasizes that racism is woven into the culture so that people don’t even realize that what they perceive as normal behavior is derogatory towards a certain race or ethnicity. The theory states that race is a social construct, not a biological reality, that forms the basis of racism.

  1. CRT challenges bigoted ideologies

CRT challenges all concepts, including meritocracy, objectivity, colorblindness, equal opportunities, and race neutrality. According to McCoy & Rodricks (2015), the proponents of CRT argue that these concepts camouflage the privilege, power, and self-interest of the dominant culture in America. Lindsay (2020), in his criticism of the theory, argues that CRT completely opposes the idea that racism is diminished when race is not in focus all the time. He argues that by challenging the concept of colorblindness, CRT encourages the practice of looking for hidden racism everywhere, including school, workplace, neighborhoods, food, hobbies, relationships, faith, and other aspects of life.

CRT challenges the concept of colorblindness and suggests that institutions are practicing a colorblind approach in tackling racism, create racial hierarchies that are as rooted as those established under slavery, apartheid, and colonialism. CRT scholars argue that even though intended as an answer to color-conscious racism, colorblindness has not only failed to uproot racial disparity but may itself be guilty of upholding it (Collins, 2015).

CRT unequivocally recognizes White supremacy as an oppressive and dominant force in society and emphasizes that it must be challenged. Generally, White supremacy is associated with Individual or group behavior and attitudes demonstrating White extremism. CRT, however, takes it further and incorporates the countless ways in which White supremacy is normalized, privileged, and given a center stage through social structures, policies, and cultural norms and values. For example, D’Rozario & Williams (2005) point out that redlining is a practice that systematically denies products and services to people residing in a particular area based on their race or ethnicity. They argue that such practices are doing no good and negatively affecting the lives of people of color.

Knowledge of Racism is based on the lived experiences of people of color. These experiences of oppression are critical to understanding and analyzing the dilemma of these groups disadvantaged by racism.  The presupposition is common among the dominant class members that ethnic or racial inequality exists because of the cultural problems of the minority groups or the inadequate enforcement of the discrimination laws. However, moral and social realities are subject to interpretation from different standpoints because they are socially constructed. One way of demonstrating the difference between the interpretation of ethnic and social realities is to tell stories and present a narrative. CRT realizes the importance of the lived experiences of non-white people and advocates that they should be brought into the limelight through biographies, family histories, reports, and storytelling (Yosso & Solorzano, 2007).

CRT proponents use stories and counternarratives to oppose the claims of racial neutrality and to highlight that race and racism are neither frequent nor sporadic in the lives of people of color but rather deeply interwoven into their daily lives. Proponents of the theory thus use storytelling and counternarrative to raise awareness about the fact that racial biases have deeply penetrated the unstated U.S. culture and law (Brown & Jackson, 2013).

  1. CRT works well with Bell’s interest convergence theory

Proponents of CRT postulate that the interests of non-white people are only advanced when there is a convergence of the interests of those belonging to the privileged groups (McCoy & Rodricks, 2015).  Interest convergence was coined by Derrick Bell, a law professor and a very strong proponent of CRT. His theory argues that black people are given their civil rights only when white people have a vested interest. The Brown vs. Board of Education case is a classic example of this argument. Bell argued that whatever gains were made in that particular case was only because it was also a way of advancing the white interests. Bell’s argument is strengthened because desegregation was pursued. After all, it promoted the country’s image during the Cold War and was abandoned when the interests diverged again. Bell also saw the subsequent triumphs of the black people in terms of civil rights as a convergence of interests (Shih, 2017).

However, critics of the theory do not share the same view. Lindsay (2020) believes that Bell’s interest convergence theory makes it impossible for any racially privileged person to do the right thing because anything they do will be seen as a way of advancing self-interest. He asserts that because of this particular thesis, CRT becomes manipulative and impossible to satisfy. However, his stance can be countered with the arguments of Goodman (2011), who stresses the concept of interest convergence and explains that the dominant culture is self-focused, consider others as threats, and feel superior and privileged because society encourages them to do so. Therefore, CRT proponents oppose and focus on eliminating racism, sexism, and the empowerment of non-white people (Yosso & Solorzano, 2007).

  1. CRT considers the intersectionality of oppression

Although CRT has race and racism at its core, it also considers other determinants of origins of experiences of privilege and oppression. According to McCoy & Rodricks (2015), intersectionality is an analytic framework attributed to CRT. It is based on the assumption that race is not the only reason people of Color experience oppression. It also happens because of other identity factors such as class, gender, disability, religious beliefs,  and sexual orientation.  It also suggests that pressure has other different forms, such as ableism, sexism, and homophobia. According to Poole et al. (2021), intersectionality captures the dynamism and fluidity of race by recognizing the importance and role of other social constructs in changing how race and racism are expressed, perceived, and experienced.

Another important aspect that is covered by intersectionality is how overlapping social stratifications underplay the way oppression and privilege are experienced. However, intersectionality is often grossly misinterpreted by its critics, believing that overlapping social stratifications only exaggerate and strengthen the experience of privilege and oppression. According to Poole (2020), the effect of overlapping social stratification on the lived experience can only be understood clearly through critically interrogating the underlying structural elements. This is important because otherwise, class, gender, race, and other social identities will become cemented, fixed, and mutually exclusive.

  1. CRT has an overwhelmingly positive impact on students

The impact of CRT has been a subject of debate for decades, with those in opposition to the theory making continuous efforts to get it banned in schools. According to Gertsmann (2021), In nearly half of the states, including Florida, the Republican legislators have successfully introduced bills intended to regulate the way race is taught in schools. He acknowledges that the way CRT is perceived is highly subjective and carries different meanings for different people. He defends the move by stating that states and local governments must push back excesses and determine the values that public education should instill in the students. He supports his argument by making a comparison between CRT and slavery as a positive institution. He says that the ban on CRT will be as justified as it will bar teachers from teaching slavery as one of the fundamental characteristics of the foundation of America. Proponents of CRT believe that racism is one of ten founding principles of America and that the country is racist in its very foundations.

The issue of how race should or shouldn’t be taught has been extensively debated lately. However, the debate has missed the critical point: the actual effect of exposure to CRT on the students in schools. Conner (2021), a researcher in youth activism, identifies three important outcomes from teaching CRT to young people.

5.1: Nurtures Passion

Contrary to popular belief among CRT critics, teaching CRT does not fuel divisiveness among young people but rather helps them apply the theory in the real world context and think critically. According to his findings, Conner (2021) states that CRT encourages the youth to collaborate and work towards achieving social change based on equity. Her research suggests that when youth find out about the origins of power and privilege and how they are transferred through generation by implementing radical policies such as housing discrimination, redlining, or school funding based on property taxes that favor schools in the upper class, they are motivated to take corrective actions to eliminate unfair conditions. Her study based on the youth of color concluded that youth of color realized that their life struggles were not their fault. That realization gives them hope that reforms are possible if the policymakers are convinced to adopt equitable policies. Hoping for positive social change, they set out to advocate for fair procedures.

CRT framework helps youth understand societal oppression and its effect on people, such as racial minorities. Individuals from these groups internalize the negative stereotypes and act accordingly, leading to further pressure, such as increases supervision and surveillance by the police and state violence. Students have been reported to express that learning about the CRT framework was empowering as it helped them make sense of what they saw happening, consider how they could break the wheel, and rather than seeing themselves as oppressors or victims, they saw themselves as agents of change who were committed to social change.

5.2: Academic Improvement

The second outcome is the significant academic improvement observed in youth organizers when they are taught CRT. Conner (2021) found in her studies that two-third of active youth organizers from the lowest-performing schools in Philadephia showed significant improvement in their grades. This is endorsed by the findings of other scholars who found that youth organizers mostly receive A or B grades in high schools and attend college for four years at a higher rate. Ironically, the more young people become aware of the prevalent inequalities at schools, the less alienated they are and more committed to academic excellence.

5.3: Lifelong benefits

Research shows that the third outcome for youth exposed to CRT is not limited to high school or college only, but the formative experiences that youth go through are instrumental in shaping their choices and lives as adults. Alluminies have reported that CRT education helps them adopt pro-social careers such as counselors and educators and participate constructively in civic life or their respective communities. Studies have also shown that former youth organizers are more likely than their peers to volunteer, work on issues challenging their community, participate in civic organizations and register to vote. These results imply that CRT, when taught well, can support long-term professional, educational, political, and civic outcomes.

  1. CRT is not a narrative; it’s rooted in critical legal studies

The recent controversy created around CRT and the drive to ban it in schools indicates how badly misunderstood the theory is. According to Collins (2021), the bill presented in the Rhode Island state legislature, which failed to pass, stated that it was intended to prohibit the teaching of divisive concepts intended to make any individual feel guilty, discomforted, distressed, or anguished on account of their sex or race. He argues that the bill reveals white fragility, the longing for myth-making, blatant denial, and an attempt to defend racism by stereotyping any anti-racism move as racist itself.  As far as anguish and discomfort caused by teaching history are concerned, it is bound to happen because, unfortunately, U.S. history has an ugly side. The ban on CRT is not only baiting to label teaching inclusive U.S. history as racist. Still, it reinforces the divergence of interest argument because teaching CRT is not in the interest of the privileged white class; they are making every effort to get it banned.

Moreover, it also shows that the theory is grossly misunderstood as some believe it is just an attempt to infuse Black and other Indigenous histories into U.S. history. Contrary to this belief, CRT is a complex theory originating from law school critical legal studies. CRT was intended to expose the systematic racism woven in every aspect of American society, be it the law, policies at every level, and the customs and norms of the culture. CRT boldly questions the very basics and roots of American society through direct intellectual debate as well as allegory, biography, and storytelling (Collins, 2021).

  1. CRT exposes and examines institutional racism

The American youth needs to know about their history and how it has shaped their society. This is important because racism and the relevant discrimination practices can only be uprooted from American society once the origin of the problem is identified. As mentioned earlier, CRT is a way of understanding how and why racism and its aspects, including White supremacy, anti-Blackness, and other types of racialized inequality, are rooted in legal practice, policy, and social institutions (Alvarez, 2021). Linsey (2020) argues that CRT is against free societies and the idea of freedom at its center. Ironically, the current winds of labeling CRT as unprogressive and demanding banning it in schools is snatching freedom of speech from all. Lukianoff et al. (2021) argue that banning CRT makes no sense since ideas, right or wrong, have always been a part of the curriculum and that curricula have always been political. They suggest that instead of banning ideas like CRT, the opponents should let them stand the test of time and application. Bills intended to exclude concepts taught at schools will most certainly be challenged legally and are highly likely to be struck out.

Alexander  (2021) elaborates that attempts to ban CRT are an open demonstration of the racist attitudes prevalent in society today. The theory works to incorporate the contributions of people of color into the history textbooks so that they can be recognized and given their due. In addition to that, it strives to emphasize that racism is present everywhere and an ongoing crisis. By banning the teaching of CRT in K-12 schools, only those who attend higher education will have an opportunity to be taught the theory, which will be detrimental to those who do not pursue higher education. This will have serious implications for students of color who are exposed to racism in one way or another in their life. They should know how to fend for themselves, and CRT gives them that ability.

Students who are taught CRT early on in their lives grasp it better and fight against racism and relevant discriminatory practices that they see or experience. CRT also had a significant role in the Civil Rights Movement, which is a testament to its importance and impact. Therefore, CRT is very useful to systematically introduce the complex history of the U.S. to the current generation.

  1. CRT questions history

The supporters of CRT opine that because they believe race to be a social construct and not a biological fact, they have science behind them. Scientists support this by stating that research on the human genome shows no difference between Europeans and Africans. CRT scholars believe that race has been used to create a power hierarchy, which has moved the debate from educational to political realms. Graham (2021) reports that Stanley Kurtz, a senior fellow at the Ethics & Public Policy Center, based in Washington, D.C., argues that CRT poses a threat to the status quo through its presuppositions which are at complete odds with the principles of individual freedom at the roots of the U.S. constitution. Kurtz also states that if most Americans accept CRT, the government’s constitutional system can not be sustained. Gonzalez at the Heritage Foundation asserts that CRT has penetrated the attention of mainstream America in part because white people feel guilt-ridden about what has been endured by Blacks and other racial and ethnic minorities. They are increasingly made to evaluate and think about their white privilege (Graham, 2021).

  1. CRT does not promote division

CRT has been a victim of misinterpretation, misunderstanding, and even deliberate distortion. Those criticizing it and seeking to ban it can barely define the theory the way it is. Several Republicans accuse CRT of rewriting history, manipulating white people into thinking they are inherently racist, and feeling guilty for their privileges. In addition, critics of the theory continuously hold it responsible for spreading divisiveness and creating a wedge between races. Critical race theory is not anti-American, divisive, or hostile. This portrayal is a deliberately politicized misrepresentation of the idea intended only to stop and discourage any discussion about systemic racism, which is present in American society. What CRT does is highlight the cause and effect of slavery that are deeply embedded in the institutions of America and their role in ensuring that white dominance is maintained.

Moreover, it scrutinizes the role of federal laws in the preservation of unequal treatment of people of color (Hobbs, 2021). While the theory does that, there is nothing anti-American about acknowledging that racism and inequality have always existed in American society. It is perfectly normal to love America and still be critical of structural racism in the community.

The longstanding inequities in economics, education, health care, housing, and the justice system are a testament to the truthfulness of the theory. Racism in America continues to be experienced by most people of color. This truth can not be changed by any effort of denial, distortion, rewriting, or other sweeping under the rug tactics.

The history of slavery and the inhumane treatment of the enslaved people is a genuine part of American history. The enslaved people were abused, raped, and forced into free labor, which was the bedrock of the economic prosperity of slave owners and their descendants. It is disheartening to see that the African Americans have toiled very hard to make right the wrongs of inequality for years, but their efforts have been countered with distortion and lies by those who felt their success might threaten them.

  1. CRT challenges the ability and neutrality of Civil Rights in Law

One of the most important aspects of CRT is its focus on revealing how traditional legal discourse understands racial subordination and racism is not neutral and not sufficient to nullify the effects of a very long history of discrimination, abuse, and oppression of people of color. In addition, because the definition of discrimination is very narrow, remedies can not account for all of its forms.  CRT has triggered and influenced debates in fields outside the scope of legal studies, including women studies, gender studies, American studies, education, and sociology. CRT has also profoundly impacted Asian Americans, Muslims, LGBTQ, Latinx, and Native Americans, leading to spin-off movements. In the early 21st century, critical race theorists have focused on criminal justice, police brutality, hate speech and hate crimes, health care, affirmative action, poverty and the welfare state, immigration, and voting rights.

Conclusion

CRT lays the foundation of the discourse that sees racism as a much broader problem than individual bigotry and prejudice. It sheds light on the fact that racism, in reality, is a systemic feature of the American social structure and is present in every aspect of society. The theory emphasizes that racism is rooted in the social network to the extent that racial inequality is treated as a normal occurrence without anyone batting an eye. White supremacy is at the heart of the laws, policies, and social norms in America. This has created an environment where people can unintentionally be racist because racist practices and racial inequalities are normal and natural. CRT challenges racial prejudice by arguing that racial segregation is a social construct and not a biological fact. It is the norms, values, and practices prevalent in a society that assigns racial identities.

CRT stresses the importance of storytelling and counternarrative to present both sides of the picture. It uses counter-storytelling to highlight the experiences, truths, stories, and narratives of marginalized communities. A dominant cultural narrative shadows every society in the world. The dominant cultural narrative pushes the lived experiences of minorities to the background and centers history, textbooks, academia,  movies, fiction, and media around the lives and experiences of the dominant culture. CRT adopts a revisionist approach so that the narrative is balanced and free of unilateral bias.

Another aspect of CRT is the interest convergence theory which states that the interests of people of color are only pursued when it is in line with the interests of the dominant White society. There are many instances in history where significant developments in the rights and interests of the non-white people were made because it also advanced the agenda of the privileged demographic. Once their claims were satisfied, the issues were put on the back burner.

CRT draws attention to other aspects of racist experiences that people of color go through, including being discriminated against based on class, gender, sexual orientation, disability, and religious beliefs. CRT calls for examining these overlapping social stratifications to ensure that segregation based on gender, race, class, and other identities are challenged and softened up gradually.

The recent drive to ban the teaching of CRT in K-12 education is based on false assumptions and misinterpretations of the theory. The arguments put forward by the opponents are based on the fear of losing the privileged status rather than their claims that teaching the theory will promote divisiveness in society. Research suggests that teaching CRT in K-12 education helps young people develop a comprehensive understanding of their history and how it has shaped the community they live in today. It entices them to question what they observe and get motivated to eradicate social inequality and injustice from society.

Opponents see CRT as anti-American as it questions the way history is narrated. Scholars believe that CRT can not be banned just because it draws attention to some of the ugliest parts of American history. They argue that these facts have shaped culture and society in America, and that is why new generations should know the roots of their social institutions. They reject the presupposition that CRT makes the privileged class feel uncomfortable or guilty for their privileges. On the contrary, CRT wants people to see the inequalities in society and question why a certain type or race has more advantages than others.

To conclude, CRT encourages us to understand how races are translated into social hierarchies, the root cause of society’s unequal distribution of resources. In addition, it not only questions how history has embedded racism into social norms and values and the laws of the American judicial and governance systems. Despite its unapologetic and sometimes radical stance, CRT is integral to the discussion about race, racism, and its effects on the lives of people of color.

 

References

Alexander, C. (2021, July 2). Alexander: We Need Critical Race Theory. The Daily Utah Chronicle. https://dailyutahchronicle.com/2021/06/01/alexander-critical-race-theory/

Alvarez, B. (2021, May 27). We Need to Teach the Truth About Systemic Racism, Say Educators. National Education Association. https://www.nea.org/advocating-for-change/new-from-nea/we-need-teach-truth-about-systemic-racism-say-educators

Bonilla-Silva, E. (2015). More than prejudice: Restatement, reflections, and new directions in critical race theory. Sociology of Race and Ethnicity, 1(1), 73-87.

Lynn, M., & Dixson, A. D. (2021). Handbook of Critical Race Theory in Education (2nd ed.). Routledge.

Collins, P. H. (2015). Science, critical race theory, and colorblindness. The British Journal of Sociology, 66(1), 46-52.

Conner, O.J. (2021, June 22). Critical race theory sparks activism in students. The Conversation. https://theconversation.com/critical-race-theory-sparks-activism-in-students-162649

De La Garza, A., & Ono, K. A. (2016). Critical race theory. The International Encyclopedia of Communication Theory and Philosophy, 125-31.

D’Rozario, D., & Williams, J. D. (2005). Retail redlining: Definition, theory, typology, and measurement. Journal of Macromarketing, 25(2), 175-186.

Essed, P. (1991). Understanding everyday racism: An interdisciplinary theory (Vol. 2). Sage.

Graham, J. (2021, May 27). Why conservatives oppose critical race theory. Desert News. https://www.deseret.com/2021/5/27/22444504/why-conservatives-oppose-critical-race-theory-glenn-beck-tucker-carlson-heritage-foundation-gop

Gray, M.D. (2021. June 30). Critical race theory: What it is and what it isn’t. The Conversation. https://theconversation.com/critical-race-theory-what-it-is-and-what-it-isnt-162752.

Gertsmann, E. (2021, June 21). Should The States Ban Critical Race Theory In Schools?. Forbes. https://www.forbes.com/sites/evangerstmann/2021/07/06/should-the-states-ban-critical-theory-in-schools/?sh=41a8e270111a

Hobbs, G.B. (2021, August 19). Critical race theory does not promote hatred. Rocky Mount Telegram. https://www.rockymounttelegram.com/opinion/letters/critical-race-theory-does-not-promote-hatred/article_5739b492-d9ad-532f-b792-e1508e30ce7b.html

Hylton, K. (2008). Race and sport: critical race theory. Routledge.

Lindsay, J. (2020, June 12). Eight Big Reasons Critical Race Theory Is Terrible for Dealing with Racism. New Discourses. https://newdiscourses.com/2020/06/reasons-critical-race-theory-terrible-dealing-racism/

Lukianoff, G., Goldstein, A.,  Snyder B.,  and Weiss, R. (2021, June 28). Thirteen important points in the campus & K-12 ‘critical race theory’ debate. Fire. https://www.thefire.org/13-important-points-in-the-campus-k-12-critical-race-theory-debate/

McCoy, D. L., & Rodricks, D. J. (2015). Critical Race Theory in Higher Education: 20 Years of Theoretical and Research Innovations. ASHE Higher Education Report, Volume 41, Number 3. John Wiley & Sons.

McPheeters, R. (2021, August 12). What is Critical Race Theory?. Voice of America. https://www.voanews.com/student-union/what-critical-race-theory

Poole, S. M., Grier, S. A., Thomas, K. D., Sobande, F., Ekpo, A. E., Torres, L. T., … & Henderson, G. R. (2021). Operationalizing critical race theory in the marketplace. Journal of Public Policy & Marketing, 40(2), 126-142.

Rollock, N., & Gillborn, D. (2011). Critical race theory (CRT). British Educational Research Association.

Shih, D. (2017, April 19). At theory to better understand diversity, and who benefits. NPR. https://www.npr.org/sections/codeswitch/2017/04/19/523563345/a-theory-to-better-understand-diversity-and-who-really-benefits

Stovall, D. (2005). A challenge to traditional theory: Critical race theory, African-American community organizers, and education. Discourse: Studies in the Cultural Politics of Education, 26(1), 95-108.

Taylor, E. (1998). A primer on critical race theory: who are the essential race theorists, and what are they saying? The Journal of Blacks in Higher Education, (19), 122.

Yosso, T. J., & Solorzano, D. G. (2007). Conceptualizing a Critical Race Theory in Sociology. The Blackwell Companion to Social Inequalities. The University of North Carolina at Charlotte.

Zalzanick, M. (2021, June 1). Operational disruption: Why critical race theory benefits all students. District Administration. https://districtadministration.com/critical-race-theory-benefits-white-black-all-students/

What Is Critical Race Theory? A Definitive Guide

Critical Race Theory has become the biggest controversial issue pitting conservative America against the liberal left and Critical Race Theory legal scholars. At the grassroots level, school boards and educators are defending themselves against accusations of, among other things, indoctrinating young children with racist ideas that are turning them against white people and America.

Despite the extensive coverage, a Reuter/Ipsos poll found that 57% of adults are not familiar with the term Critical Race Theory (Lawrence, 2021). As Republican legislators scramble to ban CRT from K-12, many educators insist that their curricula don’t include CRT-related discussions, and scholars maintain that the debate is too complex. As the battle rages on, the question remains, what exactly is Critical Race Theory?

Critical Race Theory: A Brief History

In the post-Civil Rights era of the mid-1970s, several lawyers, legal scholars, and activists were realizing that the advances made during the Civil Rights era of 1960 were either stalled or, in some cases, rolled back (Delgado & Stefancic, 2017). Additionally, while reducing in number, the incidents of overt racism were not the only problems people of color were facing. The incidents of racism were more subtle, something that the systems in place we’re unable to handle.

To these individuals, there was the need for new strategies and theories to combat this subtle form of racism, which was gaining ground (Delgado & Stefancic, 2017). The early proponents of Critical Race Theory (CRT), among them Derrick Bell, Kimberlé Williams Crenshaw, Mari Matsuda, Alan Freeman, Richard Delgado, Angela Harris, among others, all had been in one way or other involved in legal frameworks involving race before the official institutionalization of CRT in 1989.

Derrick Bell, a tenured professor at Harvard School of Law from 1970 to 1980, quit his position because of the university’s resistance to hiring more faculty members of color. The university scrapped the course “Constitutional Law and Minority Issues,” following his exit, sparking outrage from the Black Law Students Association. Students launched protests to get the school to reinstate the course, and in the process, hire a Black professor to teach the class. In response, Dean James Vorenberg launched a three-week mini-course, which the students boycotted. In 1983, Kimberlé Williams Crenshaw and Mari Matsuda instead found a way to receive the education they wanted, launching the “Alternative Course” (Jackson, 2021).

In the summer of 1989, 20 legal scholars, lawyers, and activists received an invitation to attend a conference in Madison, Wisconsin. On July 8, 1989, Kimberlé Williams Crenshaw, Neil Gotanda, and Stephanie Phillips, the conference hosts, welcomed the attendees at St. Benedict Center, a convent. Other participants included Anita Allen, Angela Harris, Benita Ramsey, Derrick Bell, Elizabeth Patterson, Harlon Dalton, Isabelle Gunning, John Calmore, Kendall Thomas, Kevin Brown, Linda Greene, Mari Matsuda, Patricia Williams, Paulette Caldwell, Philip T. Nash, Richard Delgado, Taunya Banks, Trina Grillo, Teresa Miller, and Robert Suggs (Onwuachi-Willig, 2009).

In an interview with the members of the Transactional Law & Contemporary Problems editorial board, Richard Delgado recalled the 1989 conference, saying, “I was a member of the founding conference… we gathered at that convent for two and a half days, around a table in an austere room with stained glass windows and crucifixes here and there – an odd place for a bunch of Marxists – and worked out a set of principles” (Delgado & Stefancic, 2011, p. 225).

Thus, Critical Race Theory was born.

So, What is Critical Race Theory?

According to Delgado & Stefancic (2017), CRT tries to understand and change the social situation by exploring the organization of the society along racial lines and hierarchies and transforming it for the better. CRT emerged in the legal framework, with the progressive scholars looking past the overt racism to try and understand the systems that enable the existence of racism, especially in the legal system, and look for ways to employ the same justice system to protect civil rights. Janel George (2021) explains that critical race theorists understood that while the law could be a tool used to deepen racial inequality, it also had the potential to be used as a tool for emancipation and the achievement of racial equality.

To better understand CRTand its goals, we need first to understand its core tenets:

  • Racism is ordinary, not aberrational; CRT maintains that racism is not determined by the blatant acts of racism. Instead, it is a part of our usual way of life and is a common experience for most people of color. Because of this, it becomes difficult to address or cure racism (Delgado & Stefancic, 1995).

Within this tenet are the concepts of “colorblindness” and “meritocracy,” which, according to CRT, serve two primary purposes. “Colorblindness” calls for the equal treatment of all persons regardless of color, clears white people of any responsibility for the hardships people of color experience. “Meritocracy” allows the empowered to maintain elitist control and still claim neutrality (Hartlep, 2009).

  • Theory of Interest Convergence, also referred to as material determinism, maintains that whites have little reason to address racism since it advances their interests. They allow and support social justice and progress when there is something in it for them.

For example, in regards to Brown v. Board of Education (1954), Derrick Bell, in a 1980 Harvard Law Review opinion piece, called into question the Supreme Court’s ruling, which ordered the desegregation of schools. Bell pointed out that the ruling came during the Cold War when desegregation would cast a favorable light on the country. Additionally, Black soldiers were coming home from WWII to experience further discrimination, a notion that would discredit the country’s superior stance on equality. Therefore, Bell theorized, it was in the white elites’ interest to ban segregation, which happened to match up with the minorities’ interests at the time.

  • The race is a social construct; this has been the hallmark of CRT, with Delgado & Stefancic explaining that race is a consequence of social thought and relations. It is not objective, and race categorization does not correspond to any biological or genetic reality. Instead, races are inventions of the society and are manipulated, or retired, when it is convenient (1995).

Hartlep (2009) writes that the Bracero program saw millions of Mexican nationals brought into the U.S. as agricultural workers to fulfill the labor requirements needed to produce food during WWII. They were promptly deported back to Mexico, with Operation Wetback launched in 1954, deporting over a million Mexicans from the country’s southwest region.

Other policies included the “one-drop” rule, the 1934 housing program benefiting whites and locking nonwhites out, the Wagner Act, and the Dred Scott v. Sandford.

  • Storytelling and counter-storytelling, the “voice of color theory,” calls for challenging the beliefs and narratives assumed to be true. CRT maintains that the experiences of people of color may be fundamentally different from the record that whites have perpetrated.

For example, indigenous Indians have a very different account of events about the white settlers and the “discovery” of America. In the same way, Hackman and Rauscher (2004) point out that “mainstream” school curricula are structured around mainstream white, middle-class values, effectively marginalizing the minority students and impeding their achievements.

CRT calls for minorities to express their experiences and be factored into the policies created, legal or otherwise.

  • Civil Rights legislation has primarily benefitted Whites; CRT contends that white people benefit from civil rights legislation than minorities.

For example, even though affirmative action has been slammed for years for giving nonwhites an unfair advantage over their white counterparts, statistics show that white people are the ones who have gained more from affirmative action. According to Guy-Sheftall (1993), white women have primarily benefited from affirmative action hiring practices. Hacker (1992) noted that even after affirmative action had been in place for 20 years, African Americans only made up 4.5% of the professorate.

Delgado (2009) simply stated, “I am expected to tell the kids that if they study hard and stay out of trouble, they can become a law professor like me. That, however, is a very big lie: a whopper” (p. 112). He added that while the faces of other minority colleagues changed over the years, the number maintained the same. “Despite this, I am expected to tell forty kids in a crowded inner-city classroom that if they work hard, they can each be among the chosen twenty-five,” he continued.

Critical Race Theory and K-12 Education

Even though CRT originated in the legal framework, by the 1990s, it had spread into other fields, including education. During the Living History Interview at the University of Iowa, Jean Stefancic explained that educators first heard about critical race theory in the mid-1990s, and several of them studied the theory’s essential writings, hoping to find ideas that could be applied to the problems they were trying to solve (Delgado & Stefancic, 2011).

For the past several years, teachers all over the country have taken to social media and other platforms to complain about the lack of resources in their classes, with some teachers crowdfunding just to get essential supplies for their students. However, K-12 teachers are now facing a different issue – tackling current issues without being accused of “indoctrinating” students. At the center of this controversy is Critical Race Theory, which the Heritage Foundation, a conservative organization, blames for the Marjory Stoneman Douglas High School 2018 shooting. The foundation’s argument starts: “What do school safety and the devastating school shooting that took the lives of 17 students and staff at a high school in Parkland, Florida, have to do with CRT? Quite a bit, in fact” (Butcher & Gonzales, 2020, p. 63). Butcher & Gonzalez argue that because the school was among the first in the district to adopt the PROMISE program, which aims to reduce the exclusionary discipline of minority students, the shooter avoided interaction with police, thus was able to obtain a gun, leading to the devastating consequences.

Critical Race Theory has always been a hotbed of controversy, no matter what field it is applied in. Recently, the focus has been on the teaching of CRT in K-12 schools, sparking heated arguments from both sides, at the grassroots and national levels. Despite the extensive coverage of the discussions, it remains unclear what the argument is about and what teachers are expected to do.

Research by Media Matters for America shows that from April to mid-June 2021, conservative T.V. network Fox News mentioned Critical Race Theory over 1,900 times, with 901mentions in the first half of June alone (Power, 2021). In the same time frame, CRT was mentioned 250 times on CNN and 264 times on MSBC (Wong, 2021). By June 2021, 22 states had introduced bills seeking to ban the teaching of CRT in schools, with Idaho, Iowa, Oklahoma, Texas, and Tennessee signing them into law (Adams, Smith & Tambe, 2021).

This fight against CRT has received extensive media attention, but supporters of the CRT maintain that critics are fighting against something that they don’t understand. Jonathan Chism, co-editor of Critical Race Studies Across Disciplines, argues that most people condemning critical race theory have no clue what the theory is about since they have not read the relevant materials. He surmises that this condemnation is a reaction drawn from fear of losing their power, influence, and privilege. Adams, Smith & Tambe (2021) assert that the criticism against CRT is a product of the critics’ desire to deny the truth about America and its history of racism.

For supporters, teaching aspects of CRT in schools is a way of equipping students with information that considers multiple viewpoints instead of whitewashing. Jania Hoover (2021), an 11th grade U.S. History teacher, explains that there is a clear advantage to teaching students the value of evaluating information from different perspectives; it makes them better at other facets of their lives. For teachers like Hoover, providing students with the relevant information is the right thing to do, especially when said students ask questions regarding “sensitive” issues like race, sexuality, and social justice. When I worked as a social studies teacher, there were always times when students would seek clarity on sensitive topics, and like Hoover, I felt like it was my duty to help them understand these issues. The classroom was a safe space, and they were allowed to express their opinions, and the only requirement was that they respect differing opinions.

Last year, I was contacted by a few teachers I’d trained, many of whom were wondering how best to explain the Black Lives Matter protests that erupted across the country following the murder of George Floyd to their students. Melissa Statz, a fourth-grade teacher in Burlington, Wisconsin, used worksheets to help her students understand the Kenosha protests, which were sparked by the fatal police shooting of Jacob Blake. After hearing her students discussing the protests, Statz found age-appropriate material to help the students understand the Black Lives Matter movement and systemic racism. An outraged parent accused Statz of “indoctrinate our kids,” which saw other community members demand that the school district discipline Statz (Kingkade, 2020). Similar headlines have popped up, with well-meaning teachers finding themselves vilified for trying to help students understand their world.

I own an EdTech company, and as a former professor of social studies, I received several requests to help my former trainees find the relevant material to help their students better understand the protests and the Black Lives Matter movement. Their main concern was addressing the issues from a neutral position to equip the students with the relevant facts and spark a discussion to critically examine the situation and offer possible solutions. However, it seemed that any discussions of race, discrimination, and diversity were being slammed as CRT indoctrination, with the conservative media pushing for politicians to call out this “evil.” Conservative state legislators are scrambling to ban CRT. At the same time, teachers are trying to find ways to help students understand issues like discrimination, systemic racism, and how the country’s history has culminated in deep-rooted racial problems. However, there is still one fundamental problem – whether it is possible to teach CRT in schools.

For many supporters of CRT, the current debate is mostly misguided, and many school boards accused of teaching CRT maintain that this is not the case. In April 2021, Harford County Public Schools board, following complaints by parents, argued that it had not incorporated any aspect of CRT in its curriculum. The district has its program, “culturally responsive teaching,” which seeks to address racial inequality in the school system. While the programs share the same acronym, Paula Stanton, the district’s equity and cultural proficiency supervisor, admitted that she had no idea what Critical Race Theory was when parents started calling the board to complain about their program (Anderson, 2021). Per the state’s upcoming changes to History and Social Science SOLs, Prince George County School Board plans to revise its history and social studies curriculum to include more diverse perspectives. Following this announcement, Dr. Lisa Pennycuff, Superintendent of Prince George County Schools, felt the need to assert that while the school district had not adopted CRT, there were plans to include African American SOLs in the curriculum (Rath, 2021).

While supporters champion for the adoption of CRT in K-12 curricula and opponents move to ban it from schools completely, there is a fundamental question that needs asking:

Is CRT being taught in K-12?

For some experts, the simple answer to this question is “no.” Gary Peller, a Georgetown Law Professor and co-author of Critical Race Theory: The Key Writings that Formed the Movement, maintains that K-12 schools are likely not teaching CRT (Zalaznick, 2021). Rodney Coates, a global and intercultural studies professor at Miami University, echoes Peller’s response, with both experts maintaining that CRT is too complex for K-12 students. According to Coates, CRT-related discussions were conversations better suited for college-level students (Mitchell, 2021). Explaining his stance, Peller wrote that the notion that K-12 students could easily be taught CRT made no sense as it was a complex subject. “It’s asking you to critically examine assumptions that we all make. And so if it were being taught in K-12, I would think it would be a cause for wild celebration that teachers (were) doing such a fantastic job” (Mitchell, 2021, p.25).

As an educator, I’m inclined to agree with Coates and Peller. As the controversy has raged on, no one has taken the time to understand CRT, and the arguments showcase this. Even the 1619 Project, slammed as CRT countless times, primarily focuses on CRT’s storytelling and counter-storytelling aspect. It provides an alternative way of looking at the inception of slavery and focuses on the narratives of the enslaved people. Dr. Janice Jackson, the CEO of Chicago Public Schools, explained the district’s decision to include the 1619 project in its curriculum. She maintained that the country’s history needed an honest explanation for students to better understand the issues arising in the present. She lauded the 1619 Project, a product of the New York Times, and curricular resources from the Pulitzer Center, as compelling new material that revisited the impact of slavery on our modern society (Da Silva, 2020).

The answer to whether CRT is being taught in K-12 is unclear, but what’s evident is that in its entirety, CRT is not in our schools. Still, aspects of it are making their way into curricula aimed at educating students to explore the country’s history without skipping over the brutal, undesirable experiences that minorities were, and keep being, subjected to.

Is it worth it?

According to Jean Stefancic, CRT expanded into education in the 1990s because educators searched for ways to address the inadequacies prevalent in curricula, disciplinary actions, school funding, tracking, standardized tests, canonical debates, and power dynamics (Delgado & Stefancic, 2011). Essentially, Brown v. Board of Education was considered a legal win, but as Derrick Bell observed, desegregation did not eliminate the need to address other systemic racial inequalities in schools. Following the ruling, many Black faculty and administrators lost their jobs as retribution for calling for and supporting desegregation and white flight. White families moved from areas with a considerable number of nonwhite residents (George, 2021).

These legal shortcomings culminated in the issues of racial inequality present in education today, including:

  • Curricula dominantly feature the white narrative of history and exclude the experiences and history of people of color.
  • Inadequate instruction, mainly fueled by lack of resources and poorly-qualified teachers in public and urban schools, leading to the characterization of students of color as those in need of remediation (Darling-Hammond, 1998).
  • Disciplinary policies, implicit bias, and teacher-student racial mismatch that sees students of color disproportionately impacted. In his research, Teachers’ Perceptions of Students’ Disruptive Behavior: The Effect of Racial Congruence and Consequences for School Suspension, Adam Wright notes that it is less likely for a black student to be suspended for misbehavior the more the student is matched with a black teacher (Startz, 2016).
  • Inequitable school financing disproportionately affects minority students. According to Darling-Hammond (1998), 10 percent of the wealthiest U.S. school districts have expenditures of almost ten times over what the poorest 10 percent spend, and in the same states, spending ratios of 3 to 1 are common. Schools, where minority students make up a sizeable chunk of the student body are more likely to receive less funding than schools with a significant white student population, even within the same school districts. This persistent underfunding means that students of color have significantly fewer resources, which dramatically impedes their chances of academic success.

Fundamentally, instead of blaming individual students for their academic failure, CRT explores the systemic practices that make it almost impossible for minority students to achieve academic success. For example, by exploring various discriminatory practices, like redlining, students can understand how the legal system perpetuated discrimination that had a lasting impact on their education.

I can appreciate the potential benefits CRT has on students. Dr. Janice Jackson stated that educators, to help students conceptualize and understand the world around them, are always trying to find new tools and strategies with the hopes of assisting them to become informed and influential citizens (Da Silva, 2020). Vida A. Robertson, the Center for Critical Race Studies director, maintains that educators need to provide appropriately-aged students with insight into how race can be used to organize the power, resources, and opportunities in society. According to Robertson, CRT aims to help students gain the ability to bring about change to the systems, structures, and institutions that propagate racial inequities (Zalaznick, 2021).

It is imperative to note that introducing CRT into K-12 curricula is not a magical remedy that will solve every problem in K-12 schools. However, the current system is undoubtedly not working, and something needs to be done. CRT in education is a tool geared towards giving our students a chance to peek behind the curtain. To allow them to look beyond themselves and understand how the system impacts them, positively or negatively. Educators, on their part, are made aware of their individual, unconscious bias and their contribution to the inequities propagated by their schools.

Political Backlash against CRT

CRT has drawn intense criticism from scholars, parents, media personalities, and politicians. In one infamous school board meeting, deputies arrested a parent after an anti-LGBT and anti-CRT speech sparked chaos. On June 22, 2021, the Loudon County Public Schools board was forced to end their meeting prematurely following a crowd’s chaotic response during the remarks section of the forum. One attendee, former Virginia State Senator Dick Black, accused the school board of “teaching children to hate others because of their skin color” by including CRT into the curriculum (Battiston, 2021, p. 8). The school board has repeatedly denied these allegations, but this has not stopped critics from pointing out that parents need to stand firmly against CRT and speak out just like the Loudon County parents.

Black’s statement echoes the common criticism against CRT, with Dr. Greg Ganske (2021) writing that CRT underpins racial stereotypes, discounts meaningful dialogue, and threatens race relations. Critics of CRT maintain that it focuses on race and pushes students to focus on their differences rather than their shared values and beliefs. One of the most prominent critics of CRT, Christopher Rufo, is said to have been the catalyst behind former President Donald Trump’s Executive Order on Combating Race and Sex Stereotyping, which banned the teaching of “divisive concepts” to federal employees and government contractors.

However, in his own words, Rufo’s criticisms are not lobbied against Critical Race Theory itself, but rather, a diverse set of diverse concepts which he’s lumped into CRT in a bid to deliberately mislead citizens. Writing to Benjamin Wallace-Wells in May 2021, Rufo explained the need to use a new language to explain the issues, as political correctness was outdated and not applicable anymore. According to Rufo, the new politics of race were more invasive than ‘correctness.’ He discounted broad terms like ‘cancel culture and ‘woke,’ explaining that these would not have the right impact in the political sphere. He concluded, ” ‘Critical race theory is the perfect villain” (Wallace-Wells, 2021, p. 6). This statement was a reiteration of his March 15, 2021, tweet reading: “We have successfully frozen their brand—”critical race theory”—into the public conversation and are steadily driving up negative perceptions. We will eventually turn it toxic, as we put all of the various cultural insanities under that brand category.” For Rufo, he’d found a perfect political weapon.

In an interview on Tucker Carlson Tonight on September 2, 2020, he urged conservatives to wake up, calling CRT an existential threat to the country. He called on the President and the White House to issue an executive order abolishing critical-race-theory training from the federal government “to stamp out this destructive, divisive, pseudoscientific ideology” (Wallace-Wells, 2021, p. 8). The next day, Rufo received a call from then-President Donald Trump, Mark Meadows, and soon after traveled to Washington, D.C., to help draft the Executive Order on Combating Race and Sex Stereotyping, issued on September 2, 2020. Later, Rufo claimed, “This entire movement came from nothing” (Wallace-Wells, 2021, p. 9), when in fact, he was the one who started it.

As the conservative media slammed CRT, parents’ concerns snowballed, and school districts found themselves defending their curricula amidst accusations that they were teaching something a majority of school officials had no idea existed. While Trump’s executive order was overturned by President Joe Biden shortly after he took office, several states have rallied to propose bills seeking to ban teaching CRT in schools, with some looking to ban CRT even in higher education classrooms. As of August 2021, Idaho, Oklahoma, Tennessee, Texas, Iowa, New Hampshire, Arizona, and South Carolina have passed legislation banning the teaching of what many of these bills call “divisive concepts,” a term present in Trump’s executive order. Of the eight states, only Idaho has mentioned Critical Race Theory in the legislation. Most of the bills passed, proposed, or rejected ban any discussion or teaching that asserts that the U.S. is inherently racist, conscious or unconscious bias, any discussions of privilege, oppression, discrimination, and in some cases, even gender discussions (Ray & Gibbons, 2021). About 20 or more states have introduced or have plans to introduce similar legislation.

State and local school boards are also taking action to ban CRT-related materials in classrooms, with Florida, Georgia, Utah, and Oklahoma school boards introducing guidelines that ban CRT- related discussions. Some local school boards, including Georgia, North Carolina, Kentucky, and Virginia, have criticized CRT in schools.

Addressing the Misconceptions

Perhaps the biggest argument against Critical Race Theory is that it is anti-White and anti-American. Rufo called CRT anti-white, anti-Asian, anti-rational, and anti-democratic. (Greer, 2021). Following the banning of CRT in Florida schools, Governor Ron DeSantis tweeted: “Critical Race Theory teaches kids to hate our country and to hate each other. It is state-sanctioned racism and has no place in Florida schools” (Lawrence, 2021, p.11).

However, supporters of CRT maintain that this is a gross misconception of the truth, explaining that CRT just calls for a critical examination of racism in the country, looking beyond the individuals and focusing on the institutions that allowed the permeation of racist, discriminative practices through policies. Rayshawn Ray, professor of sociology and executive director of the Lab for Applied Social Science Research at the University of Maryland, claims that most people admonishing CRT don’t want any discussions of racism. They were people who want to see the country America as perfect, even though they were hurting their children. He added that when these students get to college, they are usually angry with their parents because they did not receive an accurate view of their world. He urged people to stop seeing CRT as an attack on individual identities (Lawrence, 2021).

Many parents maintain that K-12 kids are too young for CRT-related discussions. Still, many teachers who had to field questions about police brutality, racism, and Black Lives Matter in 2020, believe that students need the information about their world. Speaking anonymously to Huffpost, one teacher explained that she teaches special education. A big part of her work requires answering questions and helping students work through their general education assignments. Inevitably, she’s had to discuss racism, especially with high school students, including discussing systemic racism when students read about internment camps and segregation in their history classes. She has also had to discuss police brutality with the students, as she works in a school with many students of color. This means that many of her students have experienced racism and an unfair justice system and are familiar with these concepts (Wong, 2021).

Emily Glankler, a history teacher in Austin, Texas, maintains that kids are not too young to understand these concepts. Gankler tells parents that even if they do not discuss race in their home, the children are still noticing from an early age. Therefore, teachers put in the effort to guide them in discussions that make them feel safe (Lawrence, 2021).

Other parents, outraged by stories of misguided teachers asking their children to apologize for their “white privilege,” believe CRT is to blame. Harvey Goldman, an NYC businessman, was outraged to learn that his 9-year-old daughter had been learning about the Black Lives Matter Movement, and he slammed Heschel School in Manhattan for its “anti-racist” obsession. In a letter to the school dated September 2020, Goldman wrote, “First and foremost, neither I nor my child, have ‘white privilege,’ nor do we need to apologize for it. Suggesting I do is insulting. Suggesting to my 9-year-old child she does is child abuse, not education” (Kennedy, 2021, p. 6). Many CRT critics falsely believe that CRT requires white students to apologize to their nonwhite counterparts for slavery and other historical atrocities.

However, supporters maintain that this is not what CRT is. Rachel Wilder, a special education middle school teacher in Colorado, told HuffPost that she was confident that teachers do not commonly shame white students or teach that white privilege is the cause of all of society’s problems. There is no conspiracy to brainwash students. Wilder explains that teachers are doing their best to equip the kids with the relevant facts and ensure that they are all treated with equity and respect, no matter their skin color or cultural background (Wong, 2021). Many CRT supporters share this sentiment and maintain that the teachers forcing students to apologize for their privilege have misunderstood the message. CRT, they contend, only calls for whites to realize and acknowledge how their privilege has served them and find ways to dismantle the systems that afford them these privileges.

What Happens Next?

Many educators, including experts in the education niche like myself, have no idea what these laws plan to ban. For the most part, social studies discussions are nuanced and usually involve a myriad of related topics. For example, discussing a historical topic like the Tulsa race massacre requires delving deeper into the history of racism in the country and how some of the perpetrators were deputized. This conversation morphs into a discussion about the embedded racist history in law enforcement. Does a debate like this fall under the CRT-related umbrella ban, or is it allowed because it is a discussion based on historical events? These are the questions teachers are raising, but no one seems to have an answer.

Currently, there seems to be no clear boundary on what can be discussed and what constitutes “indoctrination.” The legislature casts a wide net, and some educators are hesitant to address controversial topics like racism throughout American history because they are afraid of backlash and facing disciplinary actions. Virginia Beach County Public Schools Superintendent Dr. Aaron Spence is concerned that legislation banning CRT can have a chilling effect on teachers. This is not conducive to the learning environment because teachers need to feel comfortable while teaching the curriculum. He revealed that some teachers were calling their principals to ask, “Am I allowed to teach this? Is this OK to teach?” (Watson, 2021, p. 71).

All we can do is wait to see how it plays out for educators and other players in the education system.

 

References

Adams, C., Smith, A. & Tambe, A. (2021, June 17). Map: See which states have passed critical race theory bills. NBC News. https://www.nbcnews.com/news/nbcblk/map-see-which-states-have-passed-critical-race-theory-bills-n1271215

Anderson, D. (2021, April 15). Harford parents say schools are teaching ‘critical race theory,’ but officials stress ‘culturally responsive teaching.’ The Baltimore Sun. https://www.baltimoresun.com/maryland/harford/aegis/cng-ag-crt-schools-20210415-wcj7dkdgefgi5n3rgynwoswg7y-story.html

Battiston, J. (2021, June 23). One was arrested as LCPS controversies come to a boil at School Board meeting. Loudon Times-Mirror. https://www.loudountimes.com/news/one-arrested-as-lcps-controversies-come-to-a-boil-at-school-board-meeting/article_1baeebf2-d42c-11eb-8aec-8f96b4f5a37a.html

Bell, D. (1980). Brown v. Board of Education and the Interest-Convergence Dilemma. Harvard Law Review, 93(3), 518-533. doi:10.2307/1340546

Butcher, J. & Gonzales, M. (2020, December 7). Critical Race Theory, the New Intolerance, and Its Grip on America. The Heritage Foundation. https://www.heritage.org/civil-rights/report/critical-race-theory-the-new-intolerance-and-its-grip-america

Da Silva, C. (2020, September 7). U.S. Schools Have Openly Taught the 1619 Project for Months. Newsweek. https://www.newsweek.com/u-s-schools-have-openly-taught-1619-project-months-1530138

Darling-Hammond, L. (1998, March 1). Unequal Opportunity: Race and Education. Brookings. https://www.brookings.edu/articles/unequal-opportunity-race-and-education/

Delgado, R. & Stefancic J. (2011) Living History Interview with Richard Delgado & Jean Stefancic. TRANSNAT’L L. & CONTEMP. PROBS. 19: 221. https://digitalcommons.law.seattleu.edu/faculty/40/

Delgado, R. & Stefancic, J. (2017). Critical Race Theory (Third Edition): An Introduction. New York, USA: New York University Press. https://doi.org/10.18574/9781479851393

Delgado, R. (2009). Affirmative Action as a Majoritarian Device: Or Do You Really Want to be a Role Model? In Foundations of Critical Race Theory in Education 109-116. New York: Routledge.

Ganske, G. (2021, May 22). Opinion: Understanding critical race theory reveals how it’s harmful to race relations. Des Moines Register. https://www.desmoinesregister.com/story/opinion/columnists/iowa-view/2021/05/22/critical-race-theory-harmful-race-relations/5076052001/

George, J. (2021, January 11). A Lesson on Critical Race Theory. Human Rights Magazine 46(2): Civil Rights Reimagining Policing. Retrieved from https://www.americanbar.org/groups/crsj/publications/human_rights_magazine_home/civil-rights-reimagining-policing/a-lesson-on-critical-race-theory/

Greer, S. (2021, June 27). Critical Race Theory Is Just Anti-White Racism. American Greatness. https://amgreatness.com/2021/06/27/critical-race-theory-is-just-anti-white-racism/

Guy-Sheftall, Beverly (1993). A black feminist perspective on transforming the academy: The case of Spelman College. In Stanlie M. James & Abena P. A. Busia (eds.), Theorizing Black Feminisms: The Visionary Pragmatism of Black Women. Routledge. pp. 77–89.

Hacker, A. (1992). Two Nations: Separate, Hostile, Unequal. New York: Ballantine Books

Hackman, H. W., & Rauscher, L. (2004). A Pathway to Access for All: Exploring the Connections Between Universal Instructional Design and Social Justice Education. Equity & Excellence in Education (37), 114–123.

Hartlep, N. D. (2009, October 11). Critical Race Theory: An Examination of its Past, Present, and Future Implications. ERIC. Retrieved from https://files.eric.ed.gov/fulltext/ED506735.pdf

Hoover, J. (2021, July 9). Critical race theory hysteria overshadows the importance of teaching kids about racism. Vox. https://www.vox.com/first-person/22568672/critical-race-theory-crt-education-racism-teachers

Jackson, L. M. (2021, July 27). The Void That Critical Race Theory Was Created to Fill. The New Yorker. https://www.newyorker.com/culture/cultural-comment/the-void-that-critical-race-theory-was-created-to-fill

Kennedy, D. (2021, April 24). Inside the growing underground network of parents fighting ‘anti-racism’ in NYC schools. New York Post. https://nypost.com/2021/04/24/how-parents-are-fighting-critical-race-theory-in-nyc-schools/

Kingkade, T. (2020, October 24). How one teacher’s Black Lives Matter lesson divided a small Wisconsin town. NBC News. https://www.nbcnews.com/news/us-news/how-one-teacher-s-black-lives-matter-lesson-divided-small-n1244566

Lawrence, T. E. (2021, July 21). 3 Myths About Critical Race Theory That Parents Need To Understand. Romper. https://www.romper.com/life/what-is-critical-race-theory-in-education

Mitchell, M. (2021, July 25). Critical race theory: What is it, really? Cincinnati Enquirer. https://www.cincinnati.com/story/news/2021/07/25/critical-race-theory-definition-meaning-education/8026552002/

Onwuachi-Willig, A. (2009). Celebrating Critical Race Theory at 20. Iowa Law Review 94:1497-1498. https://scholarship.law.bu.edu/faculty_scholarship/320

Power, L. (2021, June 15). Fox News’ obsession with critical race theory, by the numbers. Media Matters for America. https://www.mediamatters.org/fox-news/fox-news-obsession-critical-race-theory-numbers

Rath, Z. C. (2021, August 5). Prince George School Board prepares to teach more African American history after denying teaching critical race theory. The Progress-Index. https://www.progress-index.com/story/news/education/2021/08/05/prince-george-prepare-teach-african-american-history-despite-crt/5472255001/

Ray, R. & Gibbons, A. (2021 August). Why are states banning critical race theory? Brookings. https://www.brookings.edu/blog/fixgov/2021/07/02/why-are-states-banning-critical-race-theory/

Startz, D. (2016, February 22). Teacher perceptions and race. Brookings. https://www.brookings.edu/blog/brown-center-chalkboard/2016/02/22/teacher-perceptions-and-race/

Wallace-Wells, B. (2021, June 18). How a Conservative Activist Invented the Conflict Over Critical Race Theory. The New Yorker. https://www.newyorker.com/news/annals-of-inquiry/how-a-conservative-activist-invented-the-conflict-over-critical-race-theory

Watson, E. (2021) Critical Race Theory: What’s the truth and why are we talking about this now? 13News Now. https://www.13newsnow.com/article/news/local/13news-now-investigates/critical-race-theory-the-truth-why-are-we-talking-about-this-now/291-af3014dd-f7fa-4565-85c3-90f8b36b867b

Wong, B. (2021, July 14). ‘Critical Race Theory? Here’s What Teachers Say They’re Actually Teaching. Huffpost. https://www.huffpost.com/entry/teachers-talk-critical-race-theory_l_60ec85cae4b01f1189519da6

Zalaznick, M. (2021, July 12). Are schools teaching critical race theory? No, says one expert. District Administration. https://districtadministration.com/schools-teaching-critical-race-theory-crt-us-history/

 

Preparing for the Challenges of the Post-Pandemic Kindergarten Bubble

Delayed enrollment, disruptions, contingency plans: COVID-19 has created an unusually diverse 20201-22 kindergarten class.

By Jennifer Torres

While children always bring a wide range of varying early childhood experiences with them as they enter kindergarten, the pandemic has amplified that variety for the upcoming school year. Some families chose to delay enrollment of their kindergarten-aged children, magnifying the age differences teachers will see at a time when children grow and develop new skills and abilities so quickly.

Whether they delayed enrollment or not, families were forced to find creative ways to solve their childcare needs as preschool centers were closed and enrollment in programs was reduced. The reality is that economic differences and varying accessibility to support systems impacted the options families had available to them. Some families created learning pods, others moved grandparents into their home to support their children, and others looked to home-based childcare providers for help. The most economically advantaged families were able to work from home and manage their child’s learning with private tutors and creative online classes, while those with fewer resources struggled to maintain jobs that required them to be onsite, with care coordinated between relatives, friends, and providers. With many preschools shut down and parents worried about the health of their children, many families chose to skip PreK schooling altogether.

As a result of these disparities, children entering kindergarten will begin with an even wider range of past experiences than usual—and that will mean varying levels of vocabulary, content knowledge, and academic skills. The challenge for educators will be learning how to build upon all of the skills children learned this past year, whether they relate to navigating technology, working independently, demonstrating self-control, or mastering foundational academic skills.

Meeting Students Where They Are

Personalizing education to meet the needs of all learners will be essential as children go back to school. Educational technology is a powerful tool that can be used to support teachers in their efforts to personalize instruction. A highly qualified teacher can use the data provided by the use of digital solutions to guide and improve classroom instruction and small-group interventions.

Technology that uses a self-paced, mastery-based approach to provide students with instruction and practice for foundational skills will help to fill in gaps for all children. Those ready to move ahead in particular areas will be able to do so. Students needing repeated instruction or more opportunities for practice will get help with specific skills. Teachers can group students according to their areas of need and help them master skills.

This targeted practice will help all students continue to progress on their own path of learning and assist teachers with better understanding of the areas of opportunity where they can find ways to motivate and reinforce learning with their students. Teachers can also then use their class time to help students learn to communicate with each other and collaborate in new ways.

Emphasizing Social and Emotional Learning

Kindergarten is a time for children to learn not only important early literacy and numeracy skills, but also how to be thoughtful and supportive members of a classroom community. Research points to the importance of establishing a classroom culture built on love and trust. Children learn best when they feel safe and their brains can relax into the learning. 

Kindergarten teachers are experts at establishing routines and practicing them with the students in their classroom. This year, this social instruction will be an even greater challenge than usual, since many of the entering kindergarteners have spent a year at home with little or no peer interaction.

Children may surprise teachers with new strengths such as technology use and working independently. They may also need much more support on foundational academic skills. It will be essential that teachers take the time to learn about each child, each family, and the needs that exist in their class. This will take time and preparation.

Teachers can design community-building activities for their class and their families. They can ask families to share what they learned about their child from the past year and work together to set goals for each child. Teachers will also need to build relationships with other teachers and support each other through this transition back to school. Leveraging the power of educational technology to cultivate connections with families will also help. 

Teachers will need to spend more time establishing expectations and practicing interactions at a time when even many adults are finding themselves re-learning how to interact in social settings. Administrators will need to provide time and set goals appropriately to allow teachers to spend significant time on social-emotional learning.

This fall, teachers need to be prepared for an unusually wide variety of experiences, skills, and degrees of social-emotional development that children will bring to kindergarten. District and school administrators will need to be prepared to support teachers through harnessing digital tools, providing time and resources for SEL, and establishing clear avenues for ongoing family involvement.

Jenni Torres is Waterford.org’s senior vice president of curriculum and instruction. During 15 years in the classroom, Jenni was selected by the U.S. State Department as a Fulbright Exchange Teacher for Uruguay and was awarded Teacher of the Year honors at the school, county and district levels. She has led the design of Waterford.org’s new social and emotional learning curriculum and innovative Mentor app, designed to help parents engage more deeply and authentically with their child to learn skills at home. Jenni earned her master’s degree from the Harvard Graduate School of Education and her bachelor’s degree from the University of Maryland, College Park. You can connect with her on LinkedIn or follow her on Twitter.