Uncategorized

4 Issues that Competency Based Education Must Overcome

Over the last decade, competency-based education has become a growing trend (a slowly growing one) in higher education, because of its innovative approach to student mastery. Competency-based education is a self-paced, mastery-oriented program that usually includes the use of tech. Students must master and demonstrate competency in various tasks and skills, to pass courses and ultimately complete their degree. It offers an alternative to traditional courses, whether held in-person or online, which students take for a set amount of time with the goal of earning a passing grade and credit hours that apply toward graduation.

For all its potential, competency-based education will not become a viable educational model until it overcomes its flaws and issues.

Lack of Accreditation and Access to Financial aid. Although no one will deny its innovativeness, students that attend schools offering competency-based education are not eligible for financial assistance, mainly because The U.S. Department of Education doesn’t have a system in place for evaluating CBE credentialing structures. In essence, universities that feature competency-based education have a hard time becoming accreditated and maintaining accreditation, which means no financial aid for their students.

Parity. Specific components of competency-based education are subjective in nature, which leaves room for bias and discrimination. How can it overcome our educational systems history of bias, and realize educational equity? Also, CBE increases the achievement gap by seemingly setting students up to fail. For instance, a minority student who has a lackluster educational background will not fare well in a self-paced mastery-based system where they are left to their own devices and expected to produce quality work. They need institutional resources and supports to succeed.

Excellence. Competency-based education needs to demonstrate an uncompromising commitment to excellence. How will the movement ensure that the rigor and quality of CBE programs are equitable across the board? How will it realize this goal? If it doesn’t, I predict that it will continue a path of mediocrity and eventually endure the fate of other educational fads and trends.

Wariness. The American education system is always skeptical of change. Because of this, new innovations like CBE get treated like a passing fad that will wear off in a couple of years. Also, people are wary of change, especially since the current model is working just fine. Students are transitioning to the workforce seamlessly, and the business sector hasn’t lodged any significant complaints about worker quality.

In closing, competency-based education must fix its glaring issues and problems before it is considered a viable alternative to traditional higher education models.

8 Keys to Becoming an Effective Education Administrator

No one goes into their first principalship thinking, “I just want to be a mediocre principal.” No, you want to be a successful education administrator, who is recognized for their contributions to the profession. If this is true, then there are a few things that you should know. Some are common sense, and because of this, we take their importance for granted. To help you realize your goals, I want to give you the 8 keys to becoming an effective principal.

The teacher turnover rate is something that you own. If there is a high rate of teacher turnover in your school building each year, then you have a significant problem. If you don’t correct this, you will have difficulty convincing the best teachers to work in one of your classrooms. Your school’s high teacher turnover will scare them away like an apparition in a Stephen King movie. Only the teachers who have no other options will even entertain giving your school a try.

You need to take responsibility for the environment in which your teachers work. You are in charge of creating a culture where teachers feel safe, appreciated, and supported. It doesn’t matter if your school is located in the toughest neighborhood in the Bronx, Compton, New Orleans or Chicago; if you take the job, the buck stops with you. No one wants to hear excuses or see you play the blame game. If you follow my advice, your school will be a place where quality teachers compete for a chance to work. Remember having a quality teacher in each classroom is a foundational step to being an effective principal.

Don’t be intimidated by knowledge gaps. As a principal, there will be things that you don’t know or don’t understand completely. I know that everyone expects you to know everything on day one, but don’t put this kind of pressure on yourself. It takes effective principals years to learn about all of the nuances of the position, and all of the laws, policies, strategies, and methods that are at their disposal.

Also, most of the things that you don’t know can only be learned with experience and time. If you are in the position long enough, you will be able to say that you have seen it all. Just trust that what you have learned as a pre-service/in-service teacher and in your education administration program is sufficient to start. Once you get started, create a professional development plan that will help you acquire the skills and knowledge that you believe you lack. You will be just fine.

Communication is key. To be an effective principal, you have to learn how to communicate effectively. To begin the journey (it takes time to develop the skill) of being a good communicator, you only have to remember one rule; the foundation of good communication is seeking to understand and then seeking to be understood. When doing so, you can frame the conversation, but then give them a chance to express themselves before you chime in.

For instance, if a student is sent to your office for disrupting the class, explain why they are in your office, and what they are being accused of. Then allow them to tell their side of the story, and when it’s your time to speak, ask clarifying or follow up questions, and then use your part of the conversation to discuss expectations, consequences, preventive measures, etc. Even if you have to suspend the student, they will feel as though they were treated fairly.

Its ok to play devils advocate when mediating conflicts. Parents, teachers, students, etc. will all come to you complaining about one another. They will tell you their side of the story, but as we all know, there are three sides to situation, person A’s perspective, person B’s perspective, and the truth, which is sometimes in the middle. Bridge this gap by playing devil’s advocate, and playing the role of the other combatant. In this way, you can allow the other person to understand what the other person’s perspective may be and how they may be feeling. Sometimes forcing others to empathize with the plight of the person with whom they have a conflict with forces them to see the issue in another light.

Cultivate a school culture where all students are expected to reach their potential. As a principal, you should cultivate a school culture where everyone succeeds, up to their own potential and learning capacity. In this culture, teachers are expected to add value to all their students, helping them to demonstrate academic growth throughout the school year. But, how can you gauge student growth and teacher efficiency? By utilizing value-added assessment.

Value-added assessment Is designed to ensure that students are learning, by comparing their current level of academic performance against their previous level of academic performance. This type of assessment focuses on student growth, rather than comparisons to other students or accomplishments of specific achievement levels. Value-added assessment provides an objective way of evaluating teachers and is less about who a student is and more about what goes on in the classroom. With this info, you can create reasonable conclusions about each students learning potential, using student outcomes as your compass. Every decision that you make should be made with one guiding principle; how will this affect my students?

Always be organized and prepared. I know that this seems like common sense, but I cannot stress the importance of organization and preparation enough. Being organized and prepared is a prerequisite for all professionals. If you are not, it will cost you time, energy, and respect. People who are not organized, are inefficient, as it takes them much longer to complete tasks or track down files and documents.

For instance, a teacher needs travel requisition form (yes, some districts still use paper) to book a flight to a national conference, but you misplaced the forms. What could have been a 5-second task, will now take more time as you need to commander more from the central office, as the form is in triplicate, so you can’t just print out more.

Another example would be failing to thoroughly prepare for a principal’s meeting at your district’s central office as you believed that it would not be necessary. The other principals used the agenda your Assistant Superintendent’s emailed the week before to anticipate the talking points and were prepared to chime in. After the Assistant Superintendent introduced each item, he asked for thoughts from the attendees. Everyone, except you, was able to add something useful and timely to the conversation. You should have been more prepared.

Become the master of data-based decision making. Being able to analyze data and use it as part of your decision-making process is one of those skills that separate good principals from great ones. Data-based decision making can be defined as the process of acquiring and analyzing data, then using it to make decisions. For example, expanding the use of a piloted learning tool to an entire grade level, school or school district only if it can be shown by pre- and post-assessments to improve student mastery.

Provide high-quality professional development for your staff. You want to have the best team in the district, and I assume that you have hired qualified teachers, so you are all good there. However, the key to continued student success is providing your teachers with high-quality professional development. Since you have seen your teachers in action, you know what skills they possess, what skills that need to acquire, and which skills need a little retooling or updating. Just make sure you choose professional development providers who are highly effective and who have data to back this up.

What did I miss?

What Are the 13 Types of Literacy?

When we think of literacy, we usually think of the ability to read and write. However, the understanding of literacy that we possess is often curtailed by our educational experiences. Those of us in the field of education know that there are numerous types of literacy, all of which help us navigate life and fully engage in our democratic society. In this short piece, I will briefly define each of the 13 types of literacy, and I hope to cover each one in an upcoming article series.

Digital Literacy- By this definition, encompasses a wide range of skills, all of which are necessary to succeed in an increasingly digital world. As print mediums begin to die out, the ability to comprehend information found online becomes more and more important. Students who lack digital literacy skills may soon find themselves

Media Literacy- According to the National Association for Media Literacy Education, media literacy is the ability to access, analyze, evaluate, create, and act using all forms of communication. Media literacy means anything from interpreting emojis to understanding underlying messages in online advertisements to producing viral video content and recognizing native advertising.

Recreational Literacy- Independent activities that cultivate positive attitudes, interests, and literacy habits.

Disciplinary Literacy- The treatment by experts in various disciplines of students’ reading, writing, and critical thinking abilities specific to the different disciplines.

Civic Literacy- Knowledge of how to actively participate and effect change in the local community and society.
Multicultural Literacy- The ability to understand and appreciate the parallels and differences between customs, values, and beliefs.

Information Literacy- A transformational process first described by Abilock where the learner needs to find, understand, evaluate, and use information in various forms for their own personal gain. This can include personal, social, or global purposes.

Functional Literacy- The literacy skills required to navigate society successfully.

Content Literacy- The use of literacy in specific areas such as math literacy or science literacy.

Early Literacy- What a child knows about communication, reading, and writing before they learn to read and write.

Developmental Literacy- A form of literacy instruction that takes a child’s stage of development in consideration. In essence, it provides developmentally appropriate literacy instruction.
Balanced Literacy- A reading program that uses several different reading methods to offer differentiated reading instruction.

Critical Literacy- Is a collection of dispositions and skills that cultivate innovative teaching, critical thinking, and active inquiry. Critical literacy assists students in thinking critically about the things that they read, instead of just brushing the surface.

Did I miss any?

33 Microaggressions That Educators Commit Daily

First, let’s begin by defining what microaggressions are. They are the daily verbal, nonverbal, and environmental slights, brushoffs, or disrespectful comments; deliberate or accidental, which convey threatening, pejorative, or damaging messages to people predicated exclusively upon the fact that they belong to a disenfranchised group. For the purpose of this article, we will focus on how microaggressions manifest themselves in the classroom.

As teenagers, my friends and I complained of the unfair rules and routines that our school authorities forced us to comply with. We found ourselves being sent to in-school suspension for dozing off in class or wearing a hat in the school building. It was like being in the “Twilight Zone” where the things that were important to our teachers made no sense to us.

They seemed obsessed with teaching us “black boys” how to conform to and act according to middle-class values. To no avail, as we merely developed situated-identify conflict, behaving one way at school and another in our community. For some reason, they couldn’t conclude that these acts were microaggressions, and deliberately or accidentally discriminated against children of color.

Our teachers didn’t see the negative impact that this had on their relationships with minority students and the distrust that we formed for them. While I write this article, millions of teachers throughout the world are committing heinous microaggressions, that in the end will stifle student performance. Because of this, I want to discuss what microaggressions look like in the classroom, in the hopes that it will help educators recognize what they are doing, and ultimately stop them from committing these acts of discrimination. Now, let’s look at 45 microaggressions that teachers commit daily.

  1. Seeing a student’s dialect or way of speaking as an issue.
  2. Punishing Students for sleeping in class.
  3. Punishing students for wearing hats and hoodies.
  4. Pronouncing student’s name incorrectly, even after they have correct you.
  5. Scheduling assessments or due product dates on religious or cultural holidays.
  6. Ignoring religious traditions or their details.
  7. Having low expectations for students from particular groups, neighborhoods, or feeder patterns.
  8. Focusing on, or engaging and validating one gender, class, or race of students while ignoring other students during class.
  9. Giving student tasks or roles that reinforce particular gender roles or don’t allow all students flexibility across roles and responses.
  10. Interpreting students’ emotional responses based on gender, sexual orientation, race or ethnicity.
  11. Conveying inappropriate humor in class that degrades students from different groups.
  12. Conveying racially charged political opinions in class assuming that the targets of those opinions do not exist in class.
  13. Use of the term “illegals” to reference undocumented students.
  14. Having debates in class that place students from groups who may represent a minority opinion in class in a difficult position.
  15. Calling students out in class because of their backgrounds.
  16. Requiring students of any particular group to ‘represent’ the perspectives of others of their race, gender, etc. in class discussions or debates.
  17. Refusing to acknowledge the experiences of students by questioning the credibility and validity of their stories.
  18. Giving class projects or creating classroom or school procedures that are heterosexist, sexist, racist, or promote other oppressions, even inadvertently.
  19. Use of sexist language.
  20. Conveying heteronormative metaphors or examples in class.
  21. Categorizing the gender of any student based on your opinions or traditional gender norms.
  22. Misusing pronouns even after a student, transgender or not, indicates their preferred gender pronoun.
  23. Facilitating projects that ignore differences in socioeconomic class status and inadvertently penalize students with fewer financial resources.
  24. Believing all students have access to and are proficient in the use of computers and applications for communications about school activities and academic work.
  25. Believing that students of particular ethnicities must speak another language or must not speak English.
  26. Praising non-white students on their use of “good English.”
  27. Not allowing students from working on projects that explore their own social identities.
  28. Requiring people with hidden disabilities to identify themselves in class.
  29. Requiring students with non‐obvious disabilities to “out” themselves or discuss them publically.
  30. Turning a blind eye to student‐to‐student microaggressions, even when the interaction is not course‐related.
  31. Making assumptions about students and their backgrounds.
  32. Using pictures of students of only one ethnicity or gender on the school website.
  33. Requiring that students engage in required reading where the protagonists are always white.

I could go on and on, but I will stop here. What did I miss?

Effective School Leaders Are Approachable

To become an effective principal, your staff members must feel comfortable coming to you with their problems or concerns. Do you come off as someone that is approachable? If your staff members communicate their needs to you, ask questions and let you know when problems arise, then you probably have nothing to worry about.

However, if weeks pass by, and virtually no one asks you a question or complains about a problem or issue, then either your school is a utopia, or people feel intimidated by your personality, intellect, or both. Don’t worry, becoming approachable is not the most challenging thing to do, it just takes some practice and consistency.

Let’s look at how this plays out in real life. In the vignette below, a colleague offers to describe a few useful feedback tools to get communication flowing. How would you enable teachers at Principal Riley’s school to feel more comfortable sharing information? How can you incorporate your suggestions into your own professional practice?

Scenario: Principal Riley was frustrated. In her weekly staff meetings, she begged her staff to come forward with problems or issues they had, rather than griping behind her back. But almost six months of the school year had passed, and not a single teacher had come forward. Her administrative assistant, however, sometimes dropped hints that the teachers weren’t satisfied.

He would meet them in informal settings after school, where they’d confide that they were unhappy with Principal Riley’s management style.

“Then why don’t they come forward?” she raged, banging her desk. “Are they cowards? I ask them in every staff meeting to tell me their problems. Did I say ask? I meant beg! But they just sit there looking at their hands.”

Finally, Principal Riley approached fellow principal about her communication problems.

“Think about it from their side,” he told her. “You’re a powerful, intimidating woman, with a huge voice and a huge intellect. You’re standing in front of them, yelling at them to tell you their problems. Obviously, they aren’t comfortable in that setting.”

Principal Riley realized that she lacked the skills necessary to make the teachers feel comfortable. She asked her colleague if he could offer some suggestions, and he agreed to meet with her and provide some tools that would get the information flowing again.

As we can see, Principal Riley’s inability to create an effective feedback process hampered the development of the school. Her colleague might encourage her to try out different formats for staff meetings, including circular seating arrangements or meetings led by other staff members, in which Principal Riley would sit amongst the teachers and take notes.

Her colleague might encourage Principal Riley to have more one-on-one sessions with teachers, in less formal situations, and to make a genuine effort to listen to and learn from them. It would require a shift in thinking and tone but could have a dramatic effect on the school environment.

Effective School Leaders Understand That Everyone’s Input Has Value

Schools are a lot like companies, in the sense that innovation and creativity are vitally important. However, some principals believe that they know it all, and refuse to listen to others, even in dark times, which stifles the creativity of their staff. A great idea is a great idea, and the principals that embrace this logic are often the most successful.

Maybe some administrators believe that if they take advice from their subordinates, it will make them seem weak or unintelligent. Take it from me, the most intelligent people that I know ask a ton of questions. If they don’t understand something, they ask questions and add this new knowledge to their existing database. If you do the same, you will see your life and career flourish.

To illustrate my point, let’s look a scenario where a know it all principal finally admits that he needs help, and it changes his principalship for the better. Afterward, reflect and use your thoughts to inform your practice.

Scenario: Grover Cleveland Elementary was going through a difficult time. Its finances were in dire shape, and it seemed rudderless. The principal, Joe Alheusen, knew that it was up to him to get the school back on course, but he was having a hard time creating the required environment. Certain teachers came to his office from time to time with unconventional ideas that he would have to veto, but in the back of his mind he knew that he shouldn’t be stifling their creative thinking.

One of the parents at Grover Cleveland, Oren Milner, was a wealthy financier and advisor for tech start-ups. One Friday evening, at a social get-together, Alheusen told Milner that he envied the freedom and energy of the start-up companies he dealt with, and said he wished he could bring those qualities to his school. Milner asked him a few questions and realized that the school situation really wasn’t that different from a company: creative employees had ideas that needed to be heard, it required sound leadership, and the finances had to be managed effectively. He suggested that he meet with a few of the school leaders.

After a month of Wednesday-afternoon meetings, Milner made three suggestions. He offered Alheusen the services of his accountant for a few weeks, to look at areas where the budget could be trimmed. He recommended implementing a new structure for staff meetings, in which all ideas would be heard, no matter how crazy. The ideas would be discussed on their merits and vetoed or promoted by the staff as a whole. And he advocated building stronger relationships between the “customers” – the parents – and the staff, to listen to complaints and receive ideas.

Effective School Leaders Practice Invitational Leadership

To become an effective school leader, you must help all your staff members succeed. Let’s discuss a school management model that will help you accomplish that. Invitational leadership is a school management model that aims to “invite” all interested stakeholders to succeed. The leadership model utilizes “invitations” as messages communicated to people, which inform them that they are valued, able, responsible, and worthwhile.

The messages are sometimes transmitted by interpersonal action but are mostly disseminated through the institution’s policies, programs, practices, and physical environments. Invitational leadership is based upon four basic assumptions, which exemplify the characteristics of invitational leaders. These assumptions are optimism, respect, trust, and intentionality. Lets briefly discuss these assumptions:

  • Optimism – The belief that people have untapped potential for growth and development.
  • Respect – The recognition that every person is an individual of worth.
  • Trust – The possession of confidence in the abilities, integrity, and responsibilities of ourselves and others.
  • Intention – A decision to purposely act in a certain way to achieve and carry out a set goal.

Invitational leadership is a tough skill to master, so let’s look a scenario that illustrates how it operates in an actual school environment.

Scenario: Angela Murray, an art teacher at Blue Ridge Elementary, came to Principal Frank Anderson one day with a problem. While using a shared computer in the staff room, she had discovered an email exchange between two other teachers that made snarky comments about her off-putting mannerisms and even the way she dressed. Ms. Murray was hurt. However, even though she’d discovered the emails by accident, she didn’t feel comfortable confronting the teachers because of privacy issues.

Principal Anderson sympathized with Ms. Murray’s problem, but he also realized that she was not wholly blameless. The art teacher’s social skills were somewhat lacking, and her creative outfits were causing merriment among students and teachers alike. She was a relatively new teacher, and a few small changes, he thought, might make her job easier.

Principal Anderson had a dilemma. Should he just deal with Ms. Murray, and ignore the email exchange, which was certainly private? Or should he bring in the other teachers and lecture them on respect? Which direction would create the best future for the school?

In the scenario, Principal Anderson is faced with a situation in which trust has been breached, and there is a lack of open communication among the parties. The invitational model would suggest that he find a way to bring Ms. Murray and the gossiping teachers together in a non-threatening environment, to enable all sides of the conversation to be heard. As the vignette illustrates, invitational leadership has a highly personal and ethical character, which is included within its modular constructs.

Let’s look at the four assumptions (optimism, respect, trust, and intentionality) as they relate to the vignette. If Principal Anderson was cynical, he might dismiss Ms. Murray as a hopeless case, and laugh along with the other teachers. However, the invitational model shifts the focus from negative to positive.

Using the four assumptions (optimism, respect, trust, and intentionality), Principal Anderson would understand that Ms. Murray was still a work in progress, and he would believe in her potential. He would realize that her creativity and quirkiness were, if tapped appropriately, assets rather than liabilities, and would attempt to transmit that notion to the other teachers. He would work with Ms. Murray, helping her hone goals that would make her a better teacher.

Effective School Leaders are Reflective Practitioners

As a principal, not everything will go your way. You will make plenty of mistakes, and at times you will fail. There may even be times when you won’t be able to isolate the cause of a problem. In these times, you must rely on your skills as a reflective practitioner.

Being a reflective practitioner means that when problems arise and you feel confounded or unsure of yourself, you take some time to reflect. Reflecting on a situation or issue, allows you to think critically about it, thus allowing you to formulate a series of appropriate responses. Afterward, you just implement your series of actions, and take a breath a sigh of relief when you see results.

Let’s look a scenario in which a principal is facing a complex issue, with lots of moving parts. After reflecting on the situation, he formulates long-term solutions that end up bringing the community together. After you finish reading the vignette, think of two additional strategies that the principal could have used. Reflect on your answer, using your thoughts to inform your practice.

Scenario: During the great recession of the late 2000s, many families from poor socioeconomic backgrounds fled inner city areas and moved to thriving, middle-class cities nearby. Principal Joseph Gutierrez’s school was located in a district that straddled a middle-class area populated mainly by European Americans and a much poorer area, where the housing was relatively inexpensive. During the flight from the inner cities, many socioeconomically disadvantaged families, most of them African American and Hispanic, moved into the poor area, and the number of minority students at his school nearly doubled.

Faced with a sudden drop in test scores, frictions between the middle-class and lower-class students, and an increased dropout rate, Principal Gutierrez realized he had to completely overhaul his school. Quick-fix solutions like begging the community for mentors to help disadvantaged students study during testing periods were not going to do much in the long run.

After extended discussions with staff members and the school board, he instigated monthly meetings for parents. He got local restaurants and taxi services to commit to providing free food and rides to and from the meetings, and teachers volunteered to provide activities for the children.

The parents held directed discussions on issues such as nutrition, bedtimes, and homework, with an emphasis on creating structures that would assist each other. Out of the discussions grew a network that extended across the socioeconomic lines. Over time, students’ test scores stabilized, and the communities grew closer together.

Effective Education Leaders Focus on Continuous Improvement

A lot of education leaders wait until there is a problem before they make changes. This is not the optimal way to respond to challenges. You have to be proactive and practice a philosophy of continuous improvement. Continuous improvement means that instead of waiting for problems to occur, you regularly work on perfecting and updating your practices and procedures, no matter how well they are working. Essentially, you are always trying to be better. However, this does not mean that you constantly change things. In some instances, you are just monitoring the situation or process, and watching for possible signs that it needs to be improved.

For example, if school discipline referrals are at a historic low in their high school, most principals would toot their own horn, publicize their success and keep using the same process for handling discipline issues. Then they are caught off guard when discipline referrals suddenly spike the next year. If they were continuously monitoring the situation, they would see that the drop in discipline referrals was due to the hard work of two veteran teachers (grades 9th and 11th), and a football coach (20+ years).

The teachers and the coach required that students adhere to a level of decency in their classrooms and all others. Although she knew that they had an impact on school discipline, she never recognized the extent of their influence, as she placed too much faith in her own self-efficacy. Well, to make a long story short, these educators retired and left a leadership vacuum that went unfilled.

If the principal had recognized this beforehand, she could have asked these teachers to coach up their colleagues, helping them to develop the same type of influence, through tried and true measures. During their final year, they could have led professional development sessions that focused on just that. This is what we mean by continuous improvement. Now the principal is stuck spending most of their day handling student discipline, instead of being the complete leader that they would like to be.

To Be an Effective School Leader, You Must Be an Instructional Leader

As principal, you are expected to be one of, if not the best teacher in the building. You can’t be an effective principal if you were never an effective teacher. It’s like trying to fit a square peg in a round hole. It just won’t work. As the instructional leader, you must spend at least 20 percent of your time observing teachers, evaluating them, and helping them to grow.

You can’t do this unless you know what good teaching looks like, and as I have already established, this comes with experience. If you are up for the challenge, you will see your teachers blossom under your tutelage and instructional leadership. If you are not, then you will see your students suffer, all because you wanted to escape the rigors of the classroom and become a principal. Just calling a spade a spade.

Now let’s practice your ability to give teachers corrective feedback. In the scenario below, Principal Cho must confront Mr. Raffles about his lack of emotional intelligence. What are three constructive things she could say that would allow him to connect more solidly with his students? Reflect on your answer and use your thoughts to inform your practice.

Scenario: Jeremy Raffles was a physics and chemistry teacher at Elton Park High School. He had graduated with top honors from one of the most prestigious universities in the country, and the principal, Laura Cho, felt honored that he had chosen to teach at Elton. In his first two years, he’d transformed the science lab, bringing in new equipment and creating elaborate experiments, and he dazzled the staff with his impromptu lectures on new techniques in teaching chemistry.

Ms. Cho always gave teachers a bye their first year – she figured that it took a year to settle in and find their style. After the second year, she would evaluate their performance. When she looked at the grades of the older science students after Mr. Raffles’ second year at Elton Park, she was dismayed: nearly all of the grades, except for those of the extremely gifted students, had dropped since Mr. Raffles had begun teaching.

Ms. Cho called some of the students into her office and asked them to describe their learning experiences with Mr. Raffles. It emerged that, while they respected his intelligence, he had an off-putting, and at times wooden, manner. He would occasionally ignore or mock questioners if he felt he’d already covered the material. One student complained that when she went to the lab after school for assistance, he’d shouted at her to leave, because he was in the middle of an experiment. He seemed to talk only to the top two students in the class, and they were the only ones who could understand him.

Following the conversation, Ms. Cho realized that she would have to confront Mr. Raffles, and talk to him about the need to connect emotionally with his students. A brilliant academic pedigree was excellent, but it needed to be accompanied by empathy and good manners if learning was to take place.

To help Mr. Raffles develop the emotional intelligence skills that he needs, Principal Cho should consider creating a list of areas for improvement that would include academic skills and lab organization (at which he excels) as well as self-awareness, social awareness, and relationship management, three areas where he lacks skills. In evaluating his responses to the list, she might start by emphasizing his intellect and lab skills, and then move on to a detailed, point-by-point explanation of what social awareness entails. This method would appeal to his rigorous scientific nature and would allow him to work through the issues intellectually.