Uncategorized

Black Boys in Crisis: Manhood Development Classes

In this series, appropriately titled “Black Boys in Crisis,” I highlight the problems facing black boys in education today, as well as provide clear steps that will lead us out of the crisis.

One of the most innovative and promising new programs for black male students is what Oakland Unified School District terms “Manhood Development Classes.” More formally known as “Mastering Our Cultural Identity: African-American Male Image,” this elective course is offered to black males in third through twelfth grade at twenty schools in the Oakland school district. The courses vary for each grade, but in general, they teach students about African-American history and prominent black individuals, the civil rights movement, current cultural events such as the #blacklivesmatter movement, and even business and economics topics.

For high school students, the course also involves college visits and college mentoring. Most importantly, black male teachers teach all of the courses. While the topics covered in the curriculum are important, the courses are effective because they give black boys positive role models who consistently support them and promote the importance of education—and they can connect to their students on a personal level. Over half of the teachers in Oakland are white women, so having a teacher who looks like them and can relate to them is especially important.

The Manhood Development Courses are part of Oakland’s Office of African American Male Achievement, a division of the public school system that provides services to black boys such as leadership councils, conferences, peer mentoring, and tutoring, as well as these elective courses. While the office’s initiatives are still in their infancy, there have been many early successes that show promise for the future. For example, more than 50 percent of the students who started the Manhood Development courses as ninth graders got into college with a scholarship. By comparison, only 54 percent of all African-Americans graduate from high school.

Other school districts around the country are following suit in offering programs specifically for black male students. Minneapolis public schools have created the Office of Black Male Student Achievement and Washington, D.C., has supported a $20 million campaign entitled Empowering Males of Color. Other school districts, like New York City, have made commitments to hire male teachers of color.

What do you think; are manhood development programs a viable solution for dealing with the crisis amongst black boys?

Black Boys in Crisis: Do After-School Programs Work?

In this series, appropriately titled “Black Boys in Crisis,” I highlight the problems facing black boys in education today, as well as provide clear steps that will lead us out of the crisis.

After-school programs are also effective at reducing the impact poverty, and race have on academic achievement. The Afterschool Alliance, an organization aimed at educating the public on the importance of high-quality after-school programs, has compiled numerous statistics and examples of programs that work. Here are a few examples of successful programs from around the United States:

When compared to students not participating in the program, students enrolled in Los Angeles’ BEST after-school program are 20 percent less likely to drop out of high school. Sixty-five percent of eighth graders who took part in Citizen Schools Eighth Grade Academy enrolled in a high-quality, college-preparatory high school, compared with 26 percent of peers who did not participate.

After a statewide study of a variety of programs in New Hampshire, researchers concluded that students that took part in after-school programs that focused on academics improved their behavior and academic performance by more than 50 percent.

Low-income students who enroll in after-school programs have increased attendance during the school day, higher graduation rates, greater gains in reading and math proficiency, better engagement in school, fewer behavioral issues, and a greater likelihood of taking college preparatory courses. Students who are engaged in consistent after-school programs are less likely to experiment with drugs, alcohol, or criminal behavior, and may even reap health benefits like lower rates of obesity.

Finally, parents who have children enrolled in after-school programs are more productive at work; in fact, they are able to work approximately eight additional days per year. Because they don’t have to worry if their children are in safe environments, they are better able to stay on the job. For parents who often have low-wage jobs, lack job security, or do not have job benefits like vacation time or sick leave, eight days can make an enormous difference.

The federal government recognizes the positive impact of these after-school programs for low-income youth. There are several funding sources available to organizations and states to support the efforts of after-school programs. One of the largest sources is the 21st Century Community Learning Centers Program. This funding is awarded by the Department of Education to states who can then distribute the money to different after-school programs. Federal Food and Nutrition programs also add funding to after-school programs by providing aid for food to these organizations so their funding can be spent on other resources. Some of the aid trickles directly down into the hands of low-income families. For example, the Child Care and Development Fund, in addition to funding child-care programs in the states, provides child-care vouchers to low-income families.

What do you think; are after school programs a viable solution for dealing with the crisis amongst black boys?

 

Black Boys in Crisis: Was Johnathon Ogbu Right?

In this series, appropriately titled “Black Boys in Crisis,” I highlight the problems facing black boys in education today, as well as provide clear steps that will lead us out of the crisis.

In 2003, educational anthropologist John Ogbu published Black American Students in an Affluent Suburb: A Study of Academic Disengagement. The book was based on Ogbu’s research in an Ohio suburb, which examined the reasons African-American students were not achieving the same academic results as their white peers. Ogbu concluded, as he had previously done following research in a Washington, D.C., school district, that part of the reason for the academic disengagement was a disdain for “acting white.” In general, he claimed, African-American students were hampered by a tendency toward anti-intellectualism.

Ogbu’s book and conclusions generated enormous controversy, and are still cited and argued over today. Subsequent researchers have both found evidence in support of Ogbu’s claims (e.g., “An Empirical Analysis of ‘Acting White’” by Fryer and Torelli) and comprehensively debunked them. Among the latter group is Ivory Toldson. In a recent article in The Root, Toldson analyzed data from a CBS News poll of a thousand students across the US. His analysis indicated that there was indeed a bias against academic achievement. For example, less than half of all students said that their friends would be supportive if they chose to study rather than hang out.

Similarly, less than a fifth of all students said that they viewed high academic achievers as “cool.” However, when Toldson looked at how the different racial groups responded, he found that African Americans were, in fact, more inclined to support studying and view good students as “cool.”  In other words, anti-intellectualism is not confined to the black population: it is a nationwide educational problem. There is an inclination among all students to shun the nerd and denigrate those who spend all their free time on academic work.

Though writers have expended a lot of energy debunking Ogbu’s research, what gets lost is that, whether or not it is primarily an African-American problem, anti-intellectualism remains a significant obstacle to a black boy seeking education. I know this from firsthand experience, both as a student and as a teacher: there is a vibe among a certain echelon of young African-American males that disdains academic achievement.

I am not claiming this vibe is absent among white students; the research indicates that white students are possibly more susceptible to anti-intellectualism. What I am saying is that if we are to achieve gains in educating black boys, the anti-intellectual element will have to be counteracted.

A key way anti-intellectualism manifests itself is in the lack of general knowledge that African Americans have on topics outside their immediate needs. In The Age of American Unreason, Susan Jacoby talks about the disturbing trend of record-high numbers of US college graduates coupled with Americans who seem to lack basic, foundational knowledge.

A 2009 study conducted by Harris Interactive and commissioned by the California Academy of Sciences and Citizens discovered that most Americans cannot answer basic science questions correctly. Not surprisingly, the study also indicated that African-American students scored even lower than the national average. Despite these dismal results, 80 percent of Americans surveyed insisted that science education is “absolutely essential” for the US economy, healthcare system, and global reputation.

The numbers tell us that the intellectual impoverishment of African Americans starts in childhood. A 2010 survey by the US Bureau of Labor Statistics found that while white children spent 31 minutes reading for leisure during the week, and 37 minutes on weekends, black students spent just 17 and 18 minutes, respectively. These numbers may not seem all that troublesome, but a lack of literacy has been found to have a strong correlation to crime: around 70 percent of US inmates rank in the lowest brackets for reading comprehension and ability.

So, was Johnathon Ogbu right? Only time will tell.

Black Boys in Crisis: Everyone Wants to “Be Like Mike”

In this series, appropriately titled “Black Boys in Crisis,” I highlight the problems facing black boys in education today, as well as provide clear steps that will lead us out of the crisis.

The adulation of athletes is common throughout the United States but approaches religious fervor in many African-American communities. Part of the reason for this is that a majority of athletes in certain sports are black. For example, nearly three-quarters of players in the National Basketball Association are black. The percentage in the NFL is just under 70 percent.

Young people today may not remember the phrase “Be Like Mike,” which had a catchy accompanying song and was all the rage during the height of the Chicago Bulls three-peat championship runs in the 1990s. You couldn’t turn on a television in the mid-nineties without catching a Gatorade, Chevrolet, or Fruit of the Loom commercial starring Michael Jordan. Chicago’s United Center is often called “the house that Michael built,” and the National Basketball Association’s total television revenue grew to $877 million over the course of Jordan’s career. Jordan was a goldmine for the products he endorsed, in part because of his prowess on the court, but also because people really liked him: as well as being a supremely gifted player, he was handsome and charming.

The story of Jordan getting cut from his high school basketball team and then ascending to become the best basketball player of all time, with six championship rings to prove it, resonated with young black boys who were facing their own adversity. He was a symbol of how the great American characteristics of hard work, determination, and rugged individualism could combine to create a superstar. That his talent on the court was incredible goes without saying. But the deep adoration he enjoyed from fans around the world ran deeper than the points he tallied on the scoreboard or the number of times in a season he achieved the elusive “triple double.”

In a 2013 column “Do I Still Want to Be Like Mike?” Kelly Scaletta took a retrospective look at the absurdity of an entire generation putting Jordan on a pedestal. His gambling addiction, paternity lawsuits, and what was, at the time, the most expensive divorce in sports history (complete with millions in hush money for a mistress) all pointed to a man who was not a model of integrity.

Even during his Hall of Fame speech, Jordan showed a petty, narcissistic side by devoting much of his podium time to criticizing his naysayers and airing old grudges. Scaletta admitted that Jordan was a great basketball player, but pointed out that his “character flaws are many.” He summed up the Jordan idolization, which was part of a larger cultural phenomenon, by saying: “Jordan is fascinating in that he’s a perfect example of what the problem has become the way we view the American athlete. We demand them to be more than what they are, then we despise them for being what they aren’t. If they win, we forgive them for not being what they never weren’t”. Other African-American athletes who became role models and subsequently fell from grace include Tiger Woods. The problem with athletes as role models is not the fault of the stars like Jordan or Woods.

The issue with the adulation of sports figure goes beyond the hypocrisy, however. The more trenchant problem is that, for the black boy who emulates an NBA or NFL athlete, the chances of achieving the same success is minuscule: similar, in fact, to the chances of winning the lottery. There are less than five hundred professional basketball players in the NBA, for example. Many more do play in college, of course, and some of those are able to snag college scholarships, but college sports present another set of problems.

Currently, the highest paid public official in forty of the fifty states is either a football or basketball coach. In fact, the highest paid public official in the country (earning $7 million a year) is the coach of Alabama’s Crimson Tide. This indicates precisely how much money is tied up in college sports. The coaches, for the most part, are worth the money: the games and merchandise bring in many times their salaries.

However, the question we should be asking ourselves is whether sports at this scale even have a place in the educational setting. Though athletes are ostensibly required to maintain certain grade-point averages to stay on the team, college sports have become such a money mill that teachers are routinely prompted by authorities to change students’ grades or provide them with “second chances”; opportunities other students lack.

Though there are, of course, stellar students among athletes, grade fixing for student-athletes, even in high school, is a commonplace. For example, at Miramar High in southern Florida, authorities “removed two math courses from one player’s transcript; entered three classes from the wrong year for another player; and incorrectly substituted a weight-training elective for a state-required course for a third player.”  The discrepancies were discovered, and the school was forced to implement changes, but similar issues are widespread around the country, and it must be presumed that most go unnoticed.

For a black high-school student who is, say, a star running back on his football team, his future may appear bright. He’s getting plenty of female attention, his coach and parents praise him, and he revels in the hollers of the crowd on game nights. However, maintaining a position on a sports team requires a lot of time in the weight room or traveling to games. This is time that is taken away from studying. He may be good enough to get into college on a scholarship. But even if he is able to maintain the grades he needs in college, chances are vanishingly slim that he’ll get picked for the NFL. So, what is he left with? A second-rate education eroded by grade fixing, a few memories of the bright lights . . . and very likely a nasty case of chronic traumatic encephalopathy—a disease caused by recurrent head trauma.

The core problem lies with Americans’ blind faith where athleticism is concerned. When was the last time you heard an African-American boy name an astronaut or leading genetic researcher as his role model? Where is the love for philosophers, authors, and Nobel Prize winners?

 

Black Boys in Crisis: Avoiding the Entertainment Trap

In this series, appropriately titled “Black Boys in Crisis,” I highlight the problems facing black boys in education today, as well as provide clear steps that will lead us out of the crisis.

As they have in sports, African Americans have had an outsized impact on the American entertainment industry. Much of what we currently recognize as popular music stems directly from African-American roots: from blues, gospel, and jazz emerged rock ‘n’ roll, disco, and everything in between. In fact, many of the early popular music legends, including Elvis Presley and Led Zeppelin, were co-opting African-American musicians’ work.

The rise of Motown as a musical genre and industry in the 1960s and ’70s brought black artists into the mainstream in unprecedented numbers. Acts such as the Supremes, the Jacksons, Stevie Wonder, and Marvin Gaye took the music world by storm. The Motown label had seventy-nine top Billboard top ten records during the sixties, and scores more the following decade. By the mid-eighties, Michael Jackson had become the biggest pop star in the world, and other Motown-spawned artists such as Lionel Richie also strode atop the charts.

Even as Motown was surging, a new genre, hip hop, was gaining traction in the inner cities. Hip hop was at some level a reaction to the sanitized, watered-down entity disco had become. Hip hop was brash, talky, jerky, and abrasive; in short, it was electrifying. It provided a vehicle and creative outlet for inner-city voices that had previously been unheard, most of them young black men.

One of the many strands to emerge from hip hop was so-called gangsta rap, which echoed and detailed the violence and abuse rife in the impoverished inner cities. N.W.A.’s single “Fuck tha Police” epitomized the early years of the genre. With a bluntness the American public had not heard before, the song discussed police brutality and racial profiling, with lyrics that still resonate today:

“Fuck the police coming straight from the underground

A young nigga got it bad cause I’m brown

And not the other color, so police think

They have the authority to kill a minority . . .”

There was an immediate and prolonged backlash against gangsta rap from the mainstream, and presidents George H. W. Bush and Bill Clinton both decried the genre from their political pulpits. Though many in the establishment tried to shut down the genre and ban albums such as Body Count, these efforts largely failed, and in fact tended to boost the credentials (and sales) of the artists. Even African-American luminaries such as jazz musician Wynton Marsalis and author Stanley Crouch lambasted the genre. In a widely read opinion piece for the New York Post, Crouch decried hip hop as “cultural pollution that is too often excused because of the wealth it brings to knuckleheads and amoral executives.”

Though current gangsta or hardcore rappers such as Lil Wayne and Young Thug consistently reference violence and drug use and denigrate women, I do not concur with those mainstream writers who suggest that “rap music” is destroying young black men. I incline, rather, toward the analysis of sociologist Michael Eric Dyson of Georgetown University, who says, “Hip hop music is important precisely because it sheds light on contemporary politics, history, and race. At its best, hip-hop gives voice to the marginal black youth we are not used to hearing from on such topics.”

What rappers such as Lil Wayne are doing is holding up a mirror to their culture. “Look,” they say, “this is what life is really like where I grew up.” These cultural entities should be listened to and preserved: in the future, we’ll look back on them with interest, and view them not as the progenitors of black violence and anti-intellectualism, but as creative prodigies and truthful commentators on a fraught period in America’s history.

I am not claiming that there is not a problem with idolizing musicians, however. Similar to sports figures, wealthy rappers are worshiped with a near-religious fervor. Young black boys watching music videos think, “Hey, look at those cars, those women that lifestyle . . . all I need is just one record deal, and I’ve got it all!” So they hunker down, churn out a few beats and rhymes with their friends, and pin their hopes on striking gold. However, just as with sports, a vanishingly small percentage of aspiring rappers and musicians actually end up making a living from their art.

Musicians like Jay-Z, Sean Combs (P. Diddy), and Dr. Dre are idolized for their quick rise to wealth. Yes, Jay-Z is an innovator who is rightly regarded for his business acumen, but the emphasis on his monetary worth often overshadows his actual accomplishments. Instead of a cultural acknowledgment of the way Jay-Z used his intellectualism to grow his brand and company smartly, the belief that all it takes is the ability to rap and “one record deal” to achieve extreme wealth and prestige is attached to his story. That theory bases its validity on luck and fate and “being in the right place at the right time.” This does not create a thirst for knowledge or a genuine love of creativity, but a desire for dollar signs.

The trappings of the entertainment industry are obvious to most. However, directly pointing this out to black boys may not be the best course of action. Remember, when adults are against something, it only makes teenagers gravitate to it even more. With this in mind, how do we convince black boys from blindly placing all of their eggs in the entertainment basket?

Black Boys in Crisis: The Poverty Paradox

In this series, appropriately titled “Black Boys in Crisis,” I highlight the problems facing black boys in education today, as well as provide clear steps that will lead us out of the crisis.

At night the rats would run along the top of the couch where he slept, and he’d be so scared he couldn’t sleep. The boy was crying as he said this: as he told his teacher why he was always so tired in class, why he sometimes fell asleep, why he hadn’t done his homework. He had recently moved into the school district. His parents had divorced, and his mother had custody of him and his sister. They were staying with his mom’s relatives in a rundown house in a poor neighborhood, and he couldn’t find anyone to help him do his homework.

The boy was well-behaved and charming, but as the year progressed the teacher noticed that he was falling behind academically, and seemed lethargic. So she spoke to him privately one day, and that’s when she gathered his story. Alarmed, the teacher called the boy’s mother in for a joint conference. The mother began to weep in front of her son, saying that she worked nights and was simply not able to make ends meet. She felt terrible that she wasn’t able to help her children, but couldn’t see a way out of the hole she was in.

The teacher, who was also a single mother, sent the boy back to class and told the mother that she needed to get back in control. She offered the mother advice on managing her time, told her to find a pastor who could help her and wrote down concrete steps that she could take at home to help her children.

The mother followed the teacher’s advice. She spoke to a pastor, who helped her find a daytime job. At that job, she was able to save up for a down payment on a small apartment. She started spending time with her son in the evenings, helping him get caught up on his homework. And it worked: the boy passed second grade and went on to become a successful student.

The Statistics of Poverty

A startling number of black Americans live in poverty. These are members of families that have an annual income at or below the federal poverty level, which is adjusted annually to account for inflation and price changes. The poverty level is the income that economic research suggests is needed to meet basic needs. As of 2016, the federal poverty level for a family of four was $24,300. African-American families and especially African-American children live in poverty at significantly higher rates than other Americans. As of 2014, 27 percent of all African Americans lived below the poverty line, compared to 11 percent of all Americans. This figure increases to 33 percent for black children.

In America today the federal poverty level does not provide enough income for a family to do more than survive. Therefore, it is perhaps a more accurate representation of the income inequality in America to also consider those who qualify as low-income. Individuals are considered low-income if they earn less than two times the federal poverty levels. The federally established levels are good baselines for comparison, but it is important to remember that the cost of living varies based on location and region. Urban areas are on average more expensive than rural areas for families. For example, in 2011, it cost on average $64,000 per year for a family of four to meet basic needs in Los Angeles, California, while it would cost the same family only $42,000 if they lived in Jackson, Mississippi. Even though urban areas require more income for families to survive, rural areas (which include much of the Southern and Western United States) have the highest rates of children living in low-income families.

Regardless of geographic location, children under the age of six make up a disproportionally large percentage of low-income individuals. Not surprisingly, African Americans comprise a majority of this group. Sixty-five percent of all black children under the age of six live in low-income families, compared to only 31 percent of white children.

Race is not the only factor that contributes to African-American children living in poverty. Family structure also plays a significant role. Families with two adults have more opportunities for income, and therefore avoiding poverty, but unfortunately, this is not the reality for a large percentage of black children. Single mothers are raising over half of black children, and 39 percent of these single-parent households live in poverty. Despite some positive trends in the early 2000s, these rates have hovered between 40 and 50 percent for the better part of a century.

What are your thoughts on the poverty paradox? How can we help black boys who are trying to succeed in school while dealing with extreme and debilitating poverty?

Black Boys in Crisis: Affordable Housing and Low-Income Families

In this series, appropriately titled “Black Boys in Crisis,” I highlight the problems facing black boys in education today, as well as provide clear steps that will lead us out of the crisis.

The effects of being raised in poverty or a low-income family can be staggering. Household income has an effect on children’s physical, mental, and emotional health on a daily basis. Children in low-income environments often have more stress and health issues than their higher-income counterparts. These hardships contribute to educational deficits that begin when the children are young and continue through high school and even college. The effects of poverty on African-American children are complex and difficult to address individually, but their causes are more easily outlined. Many of these negative effects stem from one root: a lack of safe and affordable housing.

Housing is a major expense for American families, especially those that live in poverty. In fact, 25 percent of low-income families spend over two-thirds of their salaries on rent and utility bills. For many families, salaries are not guaranteed. Of children who are classified as low-income, 75 percent live in families where at least one parent works part time or for just part of the year.

Furthermore, despite the stereotypes on television and disparaging political ads, most low-income families do not receive any public housing or housing assistance. In fact, of all of the families that would qualify for assistance, only a quarter receive any aid. When high prices are coupled with a lack of job security, the result is increased mobility due to rent changes and eviction for low-income black children. Not surprisingly, the subgroup most at risk is African-American women.

Being constantly forced to uproot has a negative impact on African-American students in school. Studies have shown that students who move frequently have lower achievement in school than students who do not. Furthermore, children who attend some schools throughout their educational career are more likely to drop out of high school.

In addition to forcing families into frequent moves, the lack of affordable housing in America contributes to health hazards for low-income families. Detroit, Michigan, is a perfect example of this issue. Detroit has extremely high levels of poverty and high populations of African-Americans. In some areas, around half of residents live below the poverty line. The houses in these areas are mostly old and contain lead paint and piping, leading to greater risk of lead toxicity.

Lead is especially dangerous for young children, and high levels of lead in the body can lead to delayed brain development, nervous system issues, a decrease in school achievement, and even a reduction in IQ. Since the cost of removing lead paint from homes is prohibitive—approximately $10,000 per home—many municipalities are unwilling or unable to make the improvements, leaving low-income families with no choice but to continue living in unsafe environments even if they are aware of the risks.

How can we help a critical mass of black boys to thrive, while dealing with so many obstacles?

Black Boys in Crisis: Income Disparity in Public Schools

In this series, appropriately titled “Black Boys in Crisis,” I highlight the problems facing black boys in education today, as well as provide clear steps that will lead us out of the crisis.

 In the United States, the majority of public schools are neighborhood schools. Schools, like neighborhoods, are for the most part separated according to social class. For low-income African-American children, the consequences are inferior schools and lack of access to high-quality education.

Before students even enter the public school system, low-income students are at a disadvantage. Low-income students are less likely than their wealthier peers to have access to high-quality preschool or pre-K programs, and they often have fewer opportunities for literacy development. Many low-income parents have jobs that require them to work at night, and on the weekends, so they are not as available for play-based education.

Many researchers highlight the “word gap” as a symptom of the disparity in early childhood education among low-income and higher-income children. According to a 1995 study out of the University of Kansas, children whose parents have professional, degree-requiring careers hear as many as 45 million words by the time they are four years old. Children whose parents are on welfare, conversely, may only hear 13 million words. Over the years, celebrities and politicians from President Obama to Hillary Clinton to Sesame Street’s Elmo have heralded the need for closing the word gap. Unfortunately, however, the challenges facing low-income African-American children can’t be solved by simply introducing them to a greater variety of words before kindergarten.

Once students do enter the public school system, their location will likely determine the wealth of their school. For students who live in the Southern United States, schools are most likely to be low-income if they live in rural areas. Students who live in the Northeast or Midwest are more likely to attend low-income schools if they live in a large urban area.

Race is a significant indicator of the likelihood a student will attend a low-income school. Nearly half of black students in this country attend schools with high rates of poverty. In fact, black students are about six times more likely to attend a low-income school than white students, regardless of their socioeconomic status. In some geographic areas, the ratios are so pronounced that schools are essentially segregated between low-income black schools and higher-income white schools. For example, in Cook County, Illinois, home of Chicago, less than 10 percent of white students attend low-income schools, while 75 percent of black students do.

In addition to the numerous problems associated with segregated schools, low-income schools do not provide the same educational opportunities for children. These schools tend to offer fewer extracurricular sports and academic opportunities, hire less-experienced teachers, and have larger class sizes.

The federal government recognizes that schools with high populations of low-income students often need additional resources to offer quality education. The remedy comes in the form of Title I funds. These funds are designed to supplement local allocations to provide the additional resources, staff, and services to low-income schools. However, there are loopholes in the oversight of local spending that undercut the equality efforts of Title 1.

A 2011 Department of Education report on the 2008–09 school year noted that more than 40 percent of schools that receive Title I funding spent less state and local money on teachers and support personnel than schools that didn’t receive Title I money. The result is that these low-income schools had high percentages of less-experienced teachers. As the effectiveness of the teacher is the most important element to a child’s success, the consequences of misallocation can be dire.

Black children from the inner city are more likely than any other group to be educated in subpar schools. If the education that they are given is substandard, why are we surprised that they struggle academically? Why do we continue to stand by and do nothing?

 

Black Boys in Crisis: What Does the Growing Income Gap Mean for Black Boys?

In this series, appropriately titled “Black Boys in Crisis,” I highlight the problems facing black boys in education today, as well as provide clear steps that will lead us out of the crisis.

 As we have seen, more African-American families than ever are living in poverty or low-income situations. More black children are living in single-parent households, usually with their mother, where there are fewer opportunities for economic advancement. The statistics are staggering, and they are not improving. For African-American boys, the growing income gap between families living in poverty and the highest economic sector means fewer opportunities than ever before.

Lack of Educational Opportunities

The lack of educational opportunities for African-American boys begins in early childhood. It is not the result of uninterested parents; in fact, the opposite is true. In today’s society, middle-class and affluent parents are spending more money on books, toys, trips, experiences, and schools for their children. They have recognized that in today’s increasingly competitive global market, their children need richer experiences, such as language lessons and cultural immersion, to develop the skills that will help them get into top colleges and secure high-paying jobs.

However, low-income families simply can’t keep up with the Joneses. Most of these experiences cost money—payment for private lessons, tuition to private schools, and even museum admission—that low-income families don’t have at their disposal. In fact, as wealthier families are spending more on their children, low-income families are spending less. Parents in the lower 50 percent of the income distribution are spending less on their children over the last fifteen years than they did in the 1990s—likely as a result of inflation, increased cost of living, and decreased job security.

Critics of state and federal aid programs assume that these low-income parents are not working, and are spending their aid money on drugs, alcohol, or other luxuries instead of on their children, but the research indicates that this is not true. According to two separate studies, one in the US and one in Great Britain, researcher Jane Waldfogel found that parents’ disposable income is more often than not spent on items for children or items for work, like professional clothing or transportation.

While the ability of families to provide extracurricular enrichment for their children is not tied to any particular race, it does affect African-American children the most because a disproportionally high number of black children live in poverty. The effects are clear when you look at the school performance of African-American children, especially boys. Having a variety of early-childhood experiences is directly related to the development of children’s vocabulary, and having a strong and rich vocabulary is linked to reading skills.

In 2009, fourth-grade African-American boys living in US cities scored significantly lower in reading and math achievement than white boys. While 38 percent of white boys were proficient in reading, only 11 percent of black boys were. The differences are even more glaring when comparing achievement in math. Of this same group, 53 percent of white boys were proficient in math, compared to only 14 percent of black boys. This lack of proficiency, coupled with inadequate schooling for many low-income students, follows African-American boys through middle and high school and ultimately results in only 54 percent of African-American students graduating from high school.

Even if they do manage to graduate from high school, African-American males do not tend to fare well in academia. In 2008, black males comprised only 5 percent of the college population. Compare this to the fact that in 2008, black males made up 36 percent of the prison population. While failure in college or incarceration cannot and should not be directly linked to a lack of early childhood experiences, there is no denying that the income gap has an effect on the situation of African-American boys.

Lack of Employment Opportunities

Once African-American boys reach an employable age, their opportunities to earn income to support themselves or their families are not as prevalent as they were in previous generations. Cities in the historic “Rust Belt”—the older cities found in the Northeast and Midwest—have large concentrations of African-Americans. In the last thirty years, job growth has stagnated or plummeted in these cities as technology-based jobs are replacing traditional manufacturing jobs. While employment between 1991 and 2001 increased by 25 percent in the US, it only increased by 3 percent or less in these Rust Belt cities.

For African-American men who have limited experience and education, entry-level jobs are primarily in the service industry. For black males, this means that not only is race potentially holding them back; so is gender. Women fill most of the service jobs, such as wait staff, sales clerks, and nursing aides. Instead of being perceived as friendly, inviting, and welcoming to customers, young black men are perceived as threatening or dangerous regardless of their actual skills, perceptions that employers do not want in their service staff.

The pervasive stereotype of the African-American male is preventing them from obtaining and retaining employment in these customer-service jobs. Without opportunities for employment before earning industry experience or advanced education, which statistics say is unlikely for many black boys, there are few chances for them to change their social situation.

Even for African-American boys who secure stable employment, their earning potential is less than similarly educated white men. According to a 2006 study conducted by the US Department of Commerce, black males will earn less on average than white males with similar levels of education, regardless of what that education is. For example, white males who have master’s degrees will earn an average yearly salary of $88,427, while black males with the same degree will only earn $64,456. For men who have a high school diploma or GED but no college degree, white men will earn on average $35,307 while black men will earn $25,418.

Downward Social Mobility

In the wake of inadequate education and employment opportunities, African-Americans, particularly those in the middle class, are experiencing a period of downward social mobility. Research conducted by Richard Reeves of the Brookings Institution and a 2014 study by the Federal Reserve Bank of Chicago concluded that black children born into middle-class families are likely to be in a lower socioeconomic tier than their parents when they are adults.

As this article has articulated, the income gap has dire consequences for black boys, who are already at the bottom of the economic totem pole. Who is to blame for this income gap? Is it centuries of oppression and institutional racism? Is it the culture of victimology that causes some black boys to engage in self-sabotage? We can keep pointing figures and engage in the blame game, or we can take action. In the comments below, let us know what you think should be done to close the income gap in the black community.

Black Boys in Crisis: The Effects of Living in a Low Income Family

In this series, appropriately titled “Black Boys in Crisis,” I highlight the problems facing black boys in education today, as well as provide clear steps that will lead us out of the crisis.

In previous articles in this series, we have looked at large-scale hurdles hampering the advancement of African-American boys, such as housing disparities, lack of employment opportunities for their parents, and the cycle of poverty. Each of these issues is serious and should be addressed at a national level. However, African-American boys also face many challenges closer to home. In fact, parents and the home environment may play the most significant role in the academic success of African-American boys.

Social and Emotional Effects of Low Income

Children who grow up in low-income families are more likely to have stunted emotional and social growth compared to higher-income peers. The home environment of children aged three and under greatly determines how they will behave emotionally as adults. Part of this emotional growth happens during infancy. Parents in poverty, particularly mothers, often suffer from depression, are overstressed, and do not have access to adequate healthcare, making it more difficult for them to bond with their infants. I experienced this firsthand: my mother had significant mental-health issues, and our poverty meant that she was unable to get the health care she needed.

When babies form weak attachments with their primary caregiver, it can lead to a sense of insecurity in childhood and prevent their brains from forming a full range of emotions. Not surprisingly, living in poverty is one of the major predictors of children developing depression as teenagers.

Low-Income Homes and Chronic Stress

Growing up in low-income environments is also linked to chronic stress, a condition that has serious and long-lasting effects on children’s cognitive function, as well as their social and emotional health. Chronic stress is stress that repeatedly occurs over long periods of time. Some of the major causes of chronic stress for low-income children include living in substandard, unsafe, and overcrowded houses and neighborhoods; family instability, such as divorce or loss of a family member; and limited access to resources such as utilities, refrigerators, or ovens. Physical abuse, physical neglect, and sexual abuse are major stressors. Unfortunately, children from low-income environments are more likely than higher-income children to experience at least one of these forms of abuse.

A scientific research study conducted by the University of Rochester on children aged two to four found that children in low-income families were more likely to have excessively elevated or low levels of cortisol, the stress hormone. Higher-than-normal cortisol levels can lead to decreased cognitive function, meaning that low-income children could have deficits in memory and problem-solving even before entering kindergarten. In addition to abnormal cognitive function, chronic stress is linked to difficulty concentrating and paying attention, loss of motivation and perseverance, decreased creativity, and impaired social skills and judgment. All of these skills directly correlate to success in school, and for African-American boys who already score lower on standardized achievement tests, the results can be devastating.

Lack of Resources

As we saw the previous section, the opportunity gap between the haves and have-nots is widening, as affluent parents are spending more on experiences and activities for their children that low-income parents simply can’t afford. But the effects of poverty on students are even harsher when you consider the basic resources that they lack.

One major but a seldom-considered resource that low-income parents cannot afford is time. In the first two years of a baby’s life, he or she needs between ten and twenty hours each week of positive interaction with a parent. This time, whether it is spent reading books, singing songs, asking and answering questions, or just playing, helps children develop the variety of emotions they will need later in life. Low-income parents (especially single parents) who work long hours at one or more jobs may not have the time to spend with their children. Once children are school-aged, they need daily interaction with books and words to become skilled readers. According to a 2002 study of kindergarteners’ interaction with their parents, only 36 percent of low-income parents read to their kindergarteners each day, compared to 62 percent of high-income parents.

Lack of access to physical resources presents another problem. Low-income students live with far fewer items than their higher-income peers. In low-income neighborhoods, the ratio of books to children is approximately one to three hundred, while in middle-income neighborhoods there are thirteen books per child. Though we live in an era when books are not as prevalent as they once were, the differences are still staggering.

But perhaps the most glaring inequity for low-income children is in their access to technology. Regardless of their school environment, low-income students have less access to technology than middle- or high-income students. According to data collected from the 2000 census, only 15 percent of homes where the annual income was between $20,000 and $25,000 (roughly the amount a family would earn if they lived in poverty) had a computer. Furthermore, of the 15 percent who had computers, well over half did not have access to broadband Internet.

To use computers with Internet access, low-income children have to rely on public resources, such as libraries or afterschool programs. But these resources are not without flaws. Computers at these sites are precious commodities. There are usually in far greater demand than supply, and the wait to use them can be long. In some afterschool programs, even if the computers are available, students may not be allowed to use them if there is no teacher available to supervise. Additionally, the public facilities often do not have funding to fix the computers if they get a virus or the hardware breaks, and sometimes the equipment is outdated and cannot perform the necessary tasks.

What the lack of technology means for low-income students is that, in addition to trailing in academic achievement, they are missing out on opportunities to learn the technical skills they will need to succeed in a highly competitive global workforce. Having limited access to Internet-connected computers means that they don’t have time to tinker or explore. They don’t have time to practice basic skills like typing or writing emails, or more complex skills like researching or coding. To compound the issue, teachers in low-income schools don’t use technology as effectively or as often as teachers in high-income schools.

Instead of using computers to design, create, and explore, many teachers in high-poverty schools use them to reinforce or practice academic skills. While study games and practice quizzes are excellent activities, they don’t make up for the creative computer time that many higher-income students enjoy at home. Students in richer families often learn to code on their own or start blogging or creating their own websites, tools that will be useful as they move into the job sphere. They learn to type and pick up word processing and image manipulation at home, whereas students from lower-income families must take classes to learn these skills. Many never do.

Lack of Parental Involvement

It is not breaking news that parents of low-income students are less involved in their children’s education than middle- or high-income parents. Teachers, school administrators, and parents recognize that the lack of parental involvement is an issue for students who are likely already at risk, but it is important to understand why many low-income parents are uninvolved.

An obvious reason for the lack of parental involvement is a lack of availability. Many low-income parents work one or more jobs, often outside of a typical nine-to-five workday. These low-paying and low-skill jobs often don’t allow for time off or flexibility to meet with teachers or attend school programs. Some parents may physically have the time away from work, but spend the majority of their time taking care of other children or family members.

Another obstacle is a lack of reliable transportation to get to school events. Add the physical difficulty of getting to school with many parents’ lack of confidence in the school system, and it is easy to understand why taking precious time to attend school events, teacher conferences, or field trips is not a priority.

A deeper-rooted obstacle to parental involvement is the cultural belief that schools don’t want low-income, minority parents to become involved. For many parents, the home and school operate in two disconnected spheres: parents are responsible for children at home, and teachers are responsible for children at school. Parents feel it is not their responsibility to teach their children what the school should be providing. Often, teachers in high-poverty schools do not do much to alleviate this cultural belief. Whether stated or just implied, many middle-class teachers of low-income students alienate parents through their language, sense of power, and lack of knowledge about their students’ cultures. When parents perceive a power difference between them and school staff, they often step away from the school system entirely.

Finally, some low-income parents purposefully disengage from their child’s schooling when they sense that the teachers do not respect them or their children. In a society where African-American males, a large percentage of the low-income demographic, are two and half times more likely to be suspended as white students, it is important for parents to see teachers focus on more than just negative behavior.

As you can see, living in a low-income household, with parents who are working hard to keep the bills paid, can be a stressful experience. How can we help black boys from low-income households succeed? How do we help their parents, who often work multiple jobs, balance being fully engaged with their child’s education while also keep food on the table?