Uncategorized

Pass or Fail: Reforming U.S. Education Approaches

In this multi-part series, I provide a dissection of the phenomenon of retention and social promotion. Also, I describe the many different methods that would improve student instruction in classrooms and eliminate the need for retention and social promotion if combined effectively.

While reading this series, periodically ask yourself this question: Why are educators, parents and the American public complicit in a practice that does demonstrable harm to children and the competitive future of the country?

If the multiage classroom is the initial target model for a reformed education system, what alternatives might coincide with the multiage approach?

Streaming Model

A method that deserves consideration is the internal streaming approach used in the British education system. Although the British educational system as a whole has its problems, and definitely should not be blindly imitated, several features of the British system warrant consideration, especially in connection with possible reforms made to the U.S. educational system.

For instance, the practice of streaming (or “grouping” or “banding” regarding some common factor) common to the British system merits some consideration. In fact, many American schools already use one level of streaming – internal streaming, streaming within class or age tiers – for certain subjects like mathematics, English, and the sciences. As one study of the history of pupil grouping policies in England points out, there have been three levels of grouping since the state began providing education around 1860: organizing students among schools, grouping students within schools, and grouping within classes.

The selection between schools has sometimes been called “secondary selection,” because it usually takes place between the ages of eleven and eighteen. In England, this age range is referred to as the “secondary education phase.”

Prior Student Assessment Model

The school-based selection was determined at the age of eleven when a student was assessed based on his or her intelligence and capacity for academic work, as opposed to abilities in either a particular style of education or curriculum area. The types of education included academic and more technical models. Traditionally, students with high academic abilities measured at age eleven were sent to grammar schools, which went on to prepare students for higher education. Students deemed to have more technical abilities were sent to either a technical school or a comprehensive school, which offered a broader balance between the academic and the technical areas of a standard curriculum.

Modern Day Streaming

Today, this first mode of selection is nearly extinct, with only a small number of local education authorities still continuing with the policy of streaming in this manner. It is a model we should be aware of, but not one we should adopt. The two other modes of streaming, though, are worth considering, and the third mode is particularly promising. This mode of “vertical” or “family” grouping keeps a group of children together in the same classroom for more than one year, especially in larger infant (preschool) and primary (elementary) schools. This is essentially the multiage classroom.

For teachers, these types of groupings can be helpful, but can also be frustrating. As an elementary-school teacher, Renee Goularte writes: “For a multiage classroom to survive and flourish, support is needed from the parent community as well as central and site administration.”

By the time a student enters high school, the educational system should begin to acknowledge that students are approaching the point of beginning some form of higher education, or the job market. This emphasis is needed to reinforce the student’s awareness that the purpose of schooling is to produce educated, moral, and dedicated citizens.

What do you see as the primary pros and cons to the aforementioned methodologies?

Pass or Fail: Classroom Organization Redesigns

In this multi-part series, I provide a dissection of the phenomenon of retention and social promotion. Also, I describe the many different methods that would improve student instruction in classrooms and eliminate the need for retention and social promotion if combined effectively.

While reading this series, periodically ask yourself this question: Why are educators, parents and the American public complicit in a practice that does demonstrable harm to children and the competitive future of the country?

If your child was excelling academically, would it matter that they were doing so in a nontraditional classroom?

Breaking Down the Walls

Renee Goularte was originally a third-grade teacher whose classroom was adjacent to that of first-grade teacher Ziem Nguyen. They often collaborated and finally asked to have the wall between their classrooms removed. Materials were shared among all students, and students were encouraged to move back and forth between the classrooms. For two years their informal collaboration continued, with little or no pushback from students, administration, or parents. But then Goularte and Nguyen decided to make their relationship formal and get the official designation as a multiage classroom.

She says: “Within a month of a presentation to our staff, describing what we had been doing and how we planned to continue to develop our program, a few concerned parents began disseminating incorrect, negative information about our proposed program.” Goularte and Nguyen had to spend the entire summer in meetings, trying to counteract the false information that had been passed around. When fall came, seven parents requested that their children be moved out of the multiage classroom. Three students ended up moving; the rest stayed.

But the story has a happy ending. Parents quickly saw how well their students were doing, and they called the teachers to give them their support. Goularte mentions one parent in particular who had gone so far as to contact the district office to try to get her daughter moved. Goularte asked her just to come into the class to observe. Once the mother did so, she began offering to volunteer.

And then, at the Back-to-School Night, when some parents began questioning the multiage classroom decision, this mother stood up and gave a speech in support of Goularte and Nguyen’s work. Goularte says: “Over a year later, during her daughter’s second year with us, she came to me to tell me that they were thinking of moving to another state, but she wanted her daughter in another multiage class—that she didn’t want her in a single grade class again.”

Classroom Organization

Streaming, setting, and banding are different models used within the school system to organize classrooms beyond just age. The streaming approach allows students to be divided into classes based on a measurement of intelligence or attainment, or even their developmental level. For instance, students who are achieving “A” grades or similar on testing or assessments can be grouped together for certain subjects. Those who achieve “B” grades or similar can be grouped together, and so on.

The setting is also used to organize the teaching of certain subjects based on ability, even though many schools otherwise operate with mixed-ability classes. Streaming can be used for English, mathematics, sciences, and modern languages, allowing classes to be organized in terms of ability groups. Such homogenous ability groups allow teachers to concentrate on addressing key knowledge areas pertinent to the students’ particular needs.

Multiage Learning Advantages

Grouping children together by various attributes unrelated to age or grade can increase efficiency and productivity by allowing the teacher to concentrate on teaching to a specific level. If for instance, a large group of children was tested for writing aptitude and various individuals fell out into the first through fourth quartiles, it might make sense to group or “band” students by the quartile of achievement for further instruction. Again, doing so would allow the teacher to fine tune a presentation for a specific audience.

Based on the available research, and in light of the current issues with the graded system, the multiage approach appears to be the best option for redesigning the organization of classrooms. Even so, we would be well advised to consider alternative organization strategies that still make use of age. Multiage classrooms appear to work particularly well for elementary-school-age students, giving younger children time to familiarize themselves with the classroom environment and the learning experience. At the same time, there is a need to recognize that all students are different, and some of these differences in interest, ability, and aptitude are clearly associated with age.

With this in mind, grouping students into educational units based on common ability level would support the needs of the individual at all levels of accomplishment. The goal of each tiered classroom would not be simply to teach the student or the class at some prescribed level. Rather, the goal would be to find each student’s areas of weakness and strength, so that teaching methods could be adjusted to challenge, as well as support.

How apprehensive would you be if your child’s school adopted the multiage approach?

Pass or Fail: Support for Struggling Students

In this multi-part series, I provide a dissection of the phenomenon of retention and social promotion. Also, I describe the many different methods that would improve student instruction in classrooms and eliminate the need for retention and social promotion if combined effectively.

While reading this series, periodically ask yourself this question: Why are educators, parents and the American public complicit in a practice that does demonstrable harm to children and the competitive future of the country?

With multiage classrooms in mind, how do struggling students fit into the equation? What supports would students receive if it was determined they were experiencing academic difficulty?

Though the needs of all students must be considered and addressed fairly within the classroom setting, research shows that the students most affected by graded classrooms and associated retention and social promotion policies are those who, for whatever reason, struggle with the academic demands of school.

Multiage Assessments

Students who struggle to perform on standardized tests may or may not have significant learning disabilities. Those students who do have such challenges must, however, have to be matched to a thoughtful program of emotional/intellectual support and supplemental instruction.

At the outset, it must be clearly understood that the method of providing educational support contemplated here has only a very rough correlation with chronological age or grade. Clearly, the support needed by a third grader with math problems should not be the same as that offered a high school student with similar problems. But to identify the exact measures that will be most beneficial to a specific individual could very well entail an assessment made under the conditions of a multiage classroom.

Early Intervention

Studies have shown the value of early intervention in preschool and kindergarten settings. Early intervention is one of the best strategies for identifying and addressing developmental delay. Moreover, the earlier specific cognitive, social, emotional, physical, and linguistic delays are identified, the more easily they can be overcome.

As Leeds and Marshak point out, positive early experiences are essential prerequisites for later successes in the workplace and the community, as well as in school. Well-conceived interventions have been shown to have positive impacts across developmental domains, resulting in improvements in such diverse areas as health, language and communication, cognitive development, and psychosocial interactions. It is also clearly worth mentioning that early intervention reduces the economic cost to society of caring for individuals who drop out of high school without the knowledge and skill needed to support themselves.

Classroom Support

Intervention and support should be integrated into the regular classroom environment. Taking measures to support the developmental needs of a particular child during regular class time may well be less embarrassing and stigmatizing than pulling a child out of the classroom to minister to him in secrecy. Moreover, including other teachers and classmates in such interventions can be positive for everyone involved, often producing intended benefits with maximum effectiveness and reducing the need for future support.

Overall, assessments should be targeting analytical thought processes, the quality of written expression, the demonstration of understanding, and flexibility of thinking. Rigid, multiple-choice testing should not be used for student assessment. To take advantage of the multiage scenario and the potential for collaboration and peer tutoring, assessments conducted in the form of group projects are a better option.

If you’re on board for redesigning the U.S. education system, how do you feel about the continued use of classroom assessments?

Pass or Fail: Intervention for Struggling Students

In this multi-part series, I provide a dissection of the phenomenon of retention and social promotion. Also, I describe the many different methods that would improve student instruction in classrooms and eliminate the need for retention and social promotion if combined effectively.

While reading this series, periodically ask yourself this question: Why are educators, parents and the American public complicit in a practice that does demonstrable harm to children and the competitive future of the country?

What measures can be taken to swiftly and effectively address difficulties students may be experiencing academically?

Arguably, multiage classrooms can deliver developmental support more effectively than graded classes because teachers will have had the time to get to know the needs of individual children, and will have had the time to put together remedial lessons carefully tailored to the particular needs of specific students.

Schools must, however, organize interventions into levels that represent an increase of support where warranted, including universal interventions when available, but extending to tutoring and other intensive interventions.

Tiered Interventions

Having effective tiered intervention strategies depends on having accurate diagnostic information and data. One of the targets for multiage classrooms at the elementary level could be the gathering of diagnostic information and data over a period of several years, the goal being not only to support struggling learners in the earlier stages of their education but to use the earlier stages of their education as a diagnostic phase to interpret future developments. Students with learning disabilities and other developmental problems could be better supported in a school system that allows them to develop a strong relationship with a given teacher or group of teachers. Such teachers, perhaps in collaboration with specialist support staff, could direct early diagnostic efforts and targeted interventions to prepare a child for high school and beyond.

One widely used approach for interventions is to provide tiered levels. The first level begins with evidence-based instruction and support, provided to all students. Students receive more specialized prevention or remediation within the general education setting when a teacher notes that they are struggling academically, socially, or behaviorally. The second tier of support is provided to students who have not been successful with the universal interventions. More intensive, targeted interventions may be used at the second level, including progress monitoring.

Supplemental Instruction

A key need, though, is to provide struggling students supplemental instruction –modified teaching strategies, and other modes of specially designed instruction. Moreover, remedial learning resources are tailored to individual students, with the understanding that different students benefit from different types of strategies and interventions.

The available resources would need to be put in place in the multiage classroom, taking advantage of the resources available, including peer tutoring and the possibility of developing a deep, long-term relationship with the teacher. A teacher should never teach down to the student or change the material to make it possible for a student to master just enough content to pass a certain test. Rather, teachers should be able to work within the school system to teach the student. Teachers must be able to recognize how each student learns and be able to find ways to apply the right teaching methods to reach the student with content – including higher-level content.

Intended Curriculum Outcomes

The emphasis of the curriculum would also need to be on the outcome rather than on a limited, grade-like parameter. Unlike the No Child Left Behind Act, which only requires that students be able to read at a “graded” level, the goal should be to develop literacy to allow students to take ownership of the skill and be able to apply it, developing themselves as citizens and as individuals. Speaking more practically, the goal should be to inspire students to take ownership of literacy so that they can apply their reading comprehension skills throughout their education and in their professional and personal lives, to truly enjoy and appreciate works of literature as works of art.

Do you think a redesigned classroom model could ultimately support altered learning outcome goals that focus on developing the individual?

Pass or Fail: Alternative Assessments for Redesigned Schools

In this multi-part series, I provide a dissection of the phenomenon of retention and social promotion. Also, I describe the many different methods that would improve student instruction in classrooms and eliminate the need for retention and social promotion if combined effectively.

While reading this series, periodically ask yourself this question: Why are educators, parents and the American public complicit in a practice that does demonstrable harm to children and the competitive future of the country?

Is it possible to completely redesign the American public school system? What assessment models and strategies might be integrated into a multiage, multi-ability system?

Multiage Classroom Assessments

One of the key benefits of the multiage classroom and one of the key reasons for placing it at the foundation of the design structure for a new school is that it reduces the need to assess students for the purpose of determining whether they should be promoted or retained. Although assessments do not need to be linked to retention or promotion policies, they do fulfill important functions within the education system. Not least, they let teachers know whether students understand what they are being taught. They also assess the students’ ability to apply the skills they are being taught.

How to Assess Each Student Groups

Particularly in the elementary school setting, assessments need to be as nonintrusive as possible to the everyday experience of the students and teachers. Assessments should target students who need additional support, and those who are not doing well academically after the universal interventions have been utilized. They also need to identify those students who are excelling and could benefit from additional support aimed toward gifted students.

For students who are meeting expectations and falling within that vast group of typical students, assessments are also important. The results aid in communicating with parents, reinforcing a positive learning experience for children, and helping to amass data that future educators. Assessment information can be used to tailor instruction to specific individuals, using their documented history of strengths and weaknesses.

High School Assessments

In high school, there is a need for some mode of standardized assessment, or preparation for standardized assessments. Universities and colleges need to be able to measure student abilities, so they know whether an individual is prepared for entry to a particular higher education course. In this environment, standardized tests are entirely appropriate and necessary. They should not, however, be the only form of assessment, or even the primary form of assessment used.

Above all, students should benefit from assessments. Academic progress should be able to be made without factors such as the ability to understand the content of the test, or test-related stress, having an impact upon the evaluation.

At the same time, high school assessments should be preparing students for college and employment. The ability to manage stress, to work under pressure, and to complete tasks within a time limit is important in the workplace, though less important in an educational environment.

Academic Tiers

With a diminished concern for retention and promotion policies, one of the better uses of assessment is the assignment of students to particular tiers or academic groupings. For instance, a student who is in the second set for science or modern languages, scoring well on a series of assessments and receiving positive teacher reports, could be rewarded with a promotion to the first set, and thus an opportunity to learn at a higher level. Alternatively, a student who did not score well within the second set could be allowed to go to the third set for additional support, to tackle areas of weakness, or knowledge gaps that might have emerged.

The retention or promotion issue would not have the same negative connotations as is present in our current system. The incentive for students if they were concerned about their current achievement level, to improve performance and work their way back up to a higher set, would always be available. Appropriate assessment methods must be coupled to appropriate teaching methods and supports, to make the system truly effective.

Progress Monitoring

There would be a need for student progress to be carefully monitored over time, using measurements that are tied to local curricular and state content and achievement standards. The assessments, however, need to be sensitive enough to pick up the benchmarks that will lead to mastery of specific content. Moreover, there is an obvious need to do away with current local and state-level curricula, to provide a less rigid model for assessing students based on assumptions related to developmental stage.

Even within a multiage classroom, students should demonstrate certain knowledge and skills by age. That demonstration, however, could be relatively flexible, and the mastery of content and skill should still be something that is assessed from several different angles and with the recognition that different students mature at different rates. While one student may be able to master certain knowledge and skills earlier than expected, another might require an additional year or more to reach the same level.

When closely examined, how does the multiage, multi-ability classroom look in comparison to our conventional system?

 

Pass or Fail: Redesigned Teaching Strategies for Redesigned Schools

In this multi-part series, I provide a dissection of the phenomenon of retention and social promotion. Also, I describe the many different methods that would improve student instruction in classrooms and eliminate the need for retention and social promotion if combined effectively.

While reading this series, periodically ask yourself this question: Why are educators, parents and the American public complicit in a practice that does demonstrable harm to children and the competitive future of the country?

What do you feel needs changed the most in our current public school system? If assessments need to be redesigned, then instructional practices must support those changes.

In considering a redesigned school system, teaching itself must be examined. Just as many of the existing assessment models would have little place in a redesigned school system that embraced multiage strategies and multi-ability streaming, traditional teaching models clearly are not appropriate for a multiage classroom or a school system that embraces multi-ability grouping.

Multiage Teaching

The multiage model requires flexibility and creativity in the teaching process itself. Retraining teachers would certainly be necessary to ensure necessary competency. Moreover, educational authorities would need to determine universal instruction models across content areas, and there would need to be a clear definition of what constitutes high-quality, universal instruction in each area.

Professional development would be important for every level of education, but most particularly in elementary school and high school, to target preparation of students at an appropriate level, with advanced learning models. Teachers should also receive special training to be able to effectively monitor the progress of students with special educational needs. Although regular education teachers need not expect to necessarily take over the role of special education teachers, they should have the ability to participate as a key team member within a special education team. General education teachers should at the very least be able to help support targeted instruction.

Professional Development Training

With a redesigned school system, teachers would also need to receive training and support so they can develop stronger relationships with parents as well as students. Because teachers could expect to work with students over an extended period, this type of training and support would be crucial. Moreover, if students are to be expected to participate in learning at a higher level, a base curriculum that could be modified by the state, would be necessary. This curriculum must emphasize a higher level of critical thinking and knowledge. Teachers should be encouraged to educate parents on becoming participating team members in the support of their child’s learning.

Teachers should be supported to explain the function of the multiage classroom and the purpose of different assessment models and strategies, beyond what is currently in place. They should also be able to share resources with students and with parents to promote higher levels of learning. There are models for this type of engagement employed in schools across the country, including, for instance, the use of reading lists and incentives to have students undertake math assignments over the summer months. More of these efforts could be employed to support the higher-level learning objectives in a redesigned education system.

Hands-on Learning

Given the relative importance of actual skills, teachers should receive support to provide students with opportunities to apply practical knowledge or otherwise learn through experience. Assessment opportunities should allow for the same type of learning opportunities as well, strengthening the connection between classroom experiences and the real world.

Can you imagine schools welcoming multiage strategies and multi-ability streaming? How quickly do you feel teachers would be able to alter course instruction to reinforce these models?

An Open Letter to District Administrators

Dear School District Administrators,

Most open letters are written as a passive criticism or open critique of a large institution. I have no wish to be passive in my critique and observations.  They are intended to spur conversation and reflection.  These are the tools of our trade as teachers.  I was hired to critique and foster reflection.

 

 

 

After studying and researching in your administrative offices over the previous year, you have embraced personalized learning as a targeted result, as we deploy technology throughout the district.  It is a goal widely acknowledged to be systemic in scope and paradigm shifting by its nature. So with all sincerity, I applaud your willingness to step bravely into a well-reasoned approach to 21st-century learning.

It is widely agreed that personalized learning is also a new pedagogical mindset that must extend beyond the classrooms; that fact pushes forward my primary question “How does the leadership of a personalized learning environment shift itself to accommodate the new network of change?”

pass or failAs I continue learning to apply a more personalized approach to my teaching. I have found that many of those same skills can be used to reflect and evaluate options. So I have tried here to apply a similar cognitive approach, an open critique and sincere question on eight observations I have noted as my school, and our district has embarked on a journey of blended and personalized learning.

In the classrooms we are, approaching the close of another school year, you at the District offices are approaching the hiring season. As you do so, I would ask that you perhaps take some time to consider the qualities your prize as you develop a leadership team for the future.  It is commonly understood that there is a shortage of new teachers in the US, as well as a disconcertingly high number of experienced professionals leaving our classrooms. But that is not the case for program administrators and principals. The number of people earning Masters Degrees’ in educational leadership or seeking an administrative endorsement is higher now than at any time in the past 25 years. According to the US Bureau of Labor Statistics

You have the opportunity to look broadly and consider carefully those that will help lead us through this systemic paradigm shift.

Personalized learning achieved through a blended curriculum keeps students engaged; it pushes them to grow and demands that they understand both themselves as learners and our curriculum as it pertains to their lives. In a very real sense, PL embodies the vision that led so many of us into teaching as a profession. The opportunity to connect not just with a child, but with a child through teaching and learning.

Personalization is full of hard data, human connections and an intricate web of lessons, apps, and projects. Peel back that top layer and the overwhelming nature of the idea begins to surface, PL disseminates the control of the learning within a classroom, the students practicing to take control of their own path. The teacher building supports and taking them away.

That complex dance of adding and subtracting scaffolding while it is being used is being successfully done. But it is severely limited when it has to fall within blocks of time and for a set number of minutes each week.

  • Where once our administration needed to be skilled at defining, defending and delineating blocks of time we are now asking them to find flexibility within a rigid structure and extra time where the was never enough.

?  How do we as a district support the required complexity of a school schedule while still offering the time to rigorously dig deeply into an area of study?

Underneath the popular jargon and interview buzzwords that you will hear, like Grit and Mindset, are classrooms where those life skills are being developed.  In those rooms, both students and teachers are failing, examining their efforts and sometimes failing again.  Learning to fail and from failure is important for real success.

  • As an institution, we are built to reward success and admonish failure. As a culture of educators, we are largely populated by those that thrived in that climate exemplifying their own successes and hiding their failures.

? How do we insure ourselves and reassure others that our district leadership understands the role of failure and exploration as we move into a new mindset?

We do not work in an industry where taking chances, innovating or finding a creative alternative is celebrated, least of all at the administrative level. Rather we as a profession, are accurately profiled as safe, steady, stable, predictable types.  Our administrators even more so than those of us in the classroom.

  • We are now in an era where we will need to be inventive, take calculated chances and create new ideas. We will need to look for those traits in our leaders as we move into uncharted paths with impressionable cargo.

? What are the important character trait of a 21st-century school administrator, and how do we ensure that the status quo does not continue to be the status quo?

?  How will the changing power dynamic in classrooms impact both our schools and our district as a whole?

One of the most powerful aspects of personalized learning is that it is, out of necessity, powered from the classroom up.  Teacher-leaders are the ones moving the bar and setting the standards. Those classroom maestros will need strong support and stronger feedback.

  • Please remember as you consider the next steps for those that will be leading the dwindling number of magnificent classroom teachers that we are a profession built on the artful combination of personal connections, honest feedback, and transparent agendas with all of our students, not simply those in the most need.

?  How can we use our transition into personalized learning, as an opportunity to both support and capitalize on the prowess of our teacher-leaders?

The devices, the web resources, the alignment of lessons and project to a standard, all of these pieces are new and as unfamiliar as they are integral to this shift.  As a teacher, I know there is no shame in saying I don’t know, and that I will not be able to master all of those elements of the job I love without support.  I am confident and comfortable say that my principal and school as a whole will need support as well.

It is not an uncommon critique to observe that the current structure of our educational system was built with management in mind rather than support and growth. Nor is it an uncommon refrain for teachers ask for support. It is uncommon, however, to have the opportunity to create the needed change.

?  What structures of support can we enhance or establish to best help our schools thrive as centers of blended and personalized teaching?

?  How do we find a way to structure and support creativity while still managing growth and learning?

If you are overwhelmed by the questions and standards set before you if you feel as though the task is disproportionate to the tools available. Please know that I, and every classroom teacher, that works for you is familiar with those insecurities. We grapple with them every fall, we understand, from experience I can tell you that the while the challenge never fades the overwhelmed feeling does.

With sincere thanks for all that you do to move us forward,

Brian Cleary  @oldbrainteacher

 

Continue reading

Empowering Students: The 5E Model Explained

When choosing an instructional model, teachers seek strategies that help students gain a complete understanding of new concepts. They aim to engage students, motivate them to learn, and guide them toward skill development. One of the ways to do that is by incorporating inquiry-based approaches like the 5E Model, which is grounded in active learning.

Research suggests that there is a set order of events that facilitates learning, known as a learning cycle. Educators J. Myron Atkin and Robert Karplus argued in 1962 that effective learning cycles involve three key elements: exploration, term introduction, and concept application. “In their scheme, exploration allowed the learners to become interested in the subject at hand, raise questions, and identify points of dissatisfaction with their current understanding. Introduction of new ideas and terms, primarily by the instructor, but negotiated by both instructor and students, followed. Finally, concept application provided learners with opportunities within the classroom to apply their new ideas, try out their new understandings in novel contexts, and evaluate the completeness of their understanding,” according to Kimberly D. Tanner in the article “Order Matters: Using the 5E Model to Align Teaching With How People Learn.”

Theoretical Foundations

The findings of Atkin and Karplus directly informed the creation of the 5E Model, which focuses on allowing students to understand a concept over time through a series of established steps, or phases. These phases include Engage, Explore, Explain, Elaborate, and Evaluate. The 5E Model, developed in 1987 by the Biological Sciences Curriculum Study, promotes collaborative, active learning in which students work together to solve problems and investigate new concepts by asking questions, observing, analyzing, and drawing conclusions. 

The 5E Model is based on the constructivist theory to learning, which suggests that people construct knowledge and meaning from experiences. By understanding and reflecting on activities, students are able to reconcile new knowledge with previous ideas. According to subject matter expert Beverlee Jobrack, “Educational movements, such as inquiry-based learning, active learning, experiential learning, discovery learning, and knowledge building, are variations of constructivism.”

In the classroom, constructivism requires educators to build inquiry, exploration, and assessment into their instructional approach. In many ways, this means the teacher plays the role of a facilitator, guiding students as they learn new concepts.

The Model Explained

The following is an overview of the five phases of the 5E Model.

Engage 

In the first phase of the learning cycle, the teacher works to gain an understanding of the students’ prior knowledge and identify any knowledge gaps. It is also important to foster an interest in the upcoming concepts so students will be ready to learn. Teachers might task students with asking opening questions or writing down what they already know about the topic. This is also when the concept is introduced to students for the first time.

Explore

During the exploration phase, students actively explore the new concept through concrete learning experiences. They might be asked to go through the scientific method and communicate with their peers to make observations. This phase allows students to learn in a hands-on way.

Explain

This is a teacher-led phase that helps students synthesize new knowledge and ask questions if they need further clarification. For the Explain phase to be effective, teachers should ask students to share what they learned during the Explore phase before introducing technical information in a more direct manner, according to “The 5E Instructional Model: A Learning Cycle Approach for Inquiry-Based Science Teaching.” This is also when teachers utilize video, computer software, or other aides to boost understanding.

Elaborate

The elaboration phase of the 5E Model focuses on giving students space to apply what they’ve learned. This helps them to develop a deeper understanding. Teachers may ask students to create presentations or conduct additional investigations to reinforce new skills. This phase allows students to cement their knowledge before evaluation.

Evaluate

The 5E Model allows for both formal and informal assessment. During this phase, teachers can observe their students and see whether they have a complete grasp of the core concepts. It is also helpful to note whether students approach problems in a different way based on what they learned. Other helpful elements of the Evaluate phase include self-assessment, peer-assessment, writing assignments, and exams.

Application and Effectiveness

The 5E Model is most effective when students are encountering new concepts for the very first time because there is opportunity for a complete learning cycle. According to co-creator Rodger W. Bybee, the 5E Model is best used in a unit of two to three weeks in which each phase is the basis for one or more distinct lessons. “Using the 5Es model as the basis for a single lesson decreases the effectiveness of the individual phases due to shortening the time and opportunities for challenging and restructuring of concepts and abilities—for learning,” Bybee explains. And if too much time is spent on each phase, the structure isn’t as effective and students may forget what they’ve learned.

According to The BSCS 5E Instructional Model: Origins and Effectiveness, “The sustained use of an effective, research-based instructional model can help students learn fundamental concepts in science and other domains.” The following research findings illustrate the positive impact of the 5E Model in classrooms:

The 5E Model allows educators to create a unique learning experience for students. Teachers who can incorporate instructional models like the 5E Model into their classrooms help students build a strong foundation of knowledge through active participation. 

Lesley University’s online Master of Education programs equip teachers with the knowledge and tools to effectively educate students in the modern classroom. With specialized degrees in mathematics education, science in education, and more, Lesley offers opportunities for educators to deepen their understanding of current approaches and hone their teaching skills and assessment strategies. Learn more about Lesley’s online education programs.

Pass or Fail: Rethinking School Design for Better Learning

In this multi-part series, I provide a dissection of the phenomenon of retention and social promotion. Also, I describe the many different methods that would improve student instruction in classrooms and eliminate the need for retention and social promotion if combined effectively.

While reading this series, periodically ask yourself this question: Why are educators, parents and the American public complicit in a practice that does demonstrable harm to children and the competitive future of the country?

If altering elements of the U.S. education system could make students less anxious and more inspired by the process of learning, would it be worth it?

The redesign of America’s schools, would involve many levels of change and would certainly take time. Nonetheless, there is immense potential and opportunity to learn about the aspects of the American education system that have been successful in the past and those elements that continue to be successful today. There is also the opportunity to learn from alternative education and assessment models, such as those found in other countries, like Europe. The multiage classroom approach has a great deal to offer the American public as a learning environment that reduces many negative elements of our current system.

Redesigned System

The ultimate goal of a redesigned system is the revival of learning as a passion within this nation. One of the qualities that the Founding Fathers cherished was curiosity and a love for intellectual development and study. The talent that existed among those who founded this nation is something that should, even today, help rekindle the nation’s passion to learn, innovate, and create. This ideal is becoming ever more crucial because of the importance of knowledge in our global economy.

Inspiring students to be creative, analytical, and resourceful in their thinking will likely have many additional effects. The cost of retention and social promotion policies includes high unemployment rates and reliance upon public benefits, high-school dropout rates that are disproportionately high, and many social and emotional issues that manifest as problems of poor self-esteem. Creating a passion and true capacity for learning would help to teach America’s students to work for themselves, boosting self-esteem.

A New Approach

It is a feature of our time that new ideas and new technologies are making old systems redundant. This can either be a depressing reality for the American worker, or an inspiring and challenging one. It seems reasonable to assume that the quality of one’s education might well tip the balance of perception. An individual who has enjoyed a high-quality, high-level education that teaches critical thinking and a true appreciation of knowledge in its various forms, will be able to apply innovation and creative thinking to new situations. This is the type of American who overcomes challenges, instead of being left out in the cold by change.

Inspiring Future Innovators

An interesting reflection of this notion is found in a report on the knowledge economy itself. In their assessment, Powell and Snellman suggest that the modern car is becoming less of a nuts-and-bolts machine and more of a smart machine that applies computer technology to offer better safety, economy, environmental friendliness, performance and even better entertainment. On the one hand, technology that supported the initial development of the car – the innovations of Henry Ford and the like – are now almost entirely obsolete. But on the plus side, innovations are happening all the time, and what was once a relatively limited piece of technology is now a sophisticated product with multiple functions.

The innovators of the future will be those who can take existing products and transform them to achieve new results, to perform different or enhance functionality. Ultimately, the American education system should be focused on making such innovations possible for American minds. Within the education system itself, we should be striving to do more with the resources that are available to us, supporting greater efficiency, greater results, and a higher purpose.

Could the next Henry Ford be so stifled and unmotivated in our current education system, that we as American’s miss out on the next big innovation?

Pass or Fail: Multiage Model for Improved Classroom Structure

In this multi-part series, I provide a dissection of the phenomenon of retention and social promotion. Also, I describe the many different methods that would improve student instruction in classrooms and eliminate the need for retention and social promotion if combined effectively.

While reading this series, periodically ask yourself this question: Why are educators, parents and the American public complicit in a practice that does demonstrable harm to children and the competitive future of the country?

Aren’t student’s individuals with varying merits and abilities? Doesn’t the notion that all 10-year-olds should master specific concepts and skills seem outdated?

Multiage Classroom Scenario

In a classroom with furniture loosely arranged around the teacher’s desk, and various nooks for reading or pursuing special projects, second-grader Michael is sitting with his teacher, reading a story he wrote about a watermelon. The teacher is enthusiastic, praising Michael and asking him if he would like to show the story to some of his classmates. He agrees, and they walk over to three third-grade girls who are sitting together at a table working on their stories. The teacher asks the third-graders if they would like to listen to Michael’s story, and they nod.

With plenty of confidence, Michael reads his story aloud, and the third-grade girls listen intently. One of the girls, Vanessa, comments on his choice of vocabulary: she liked his use of the adjective “juicy,” she says. They ask him to read the story again, and on the second pass, another girl, Karen, seems perplexed. The teacher asks if she has an issue with the story, and Karen says that she doesn’t understand the last line, which reads: “I like watermelon because when you make it.” She says that the sentence seems incomplete.

Michael is confused. He doesn’t know what Karen means when she talks about an incomplete sentence and looks to the teacher for help. The teacher encourages the girls to offer ideas. Vanessa thinks for a moment and then looks at Michael. “You can say: ‘when you make it, it tastes good,’” she offers. Michael thanks her for the suggestion, and he and the teacher return to their original spot. Michael decides he likes Vanessa’s proposed revision and changes the end of his story.

The Multiage Classroom Model

Multiage classrooms like the one depicted above are a growing phenomenon in the United States. The process of managing the organization of classrooms by grade is challenging. Even more challenging are the inconsistent policies of enforced retention and social promotion. If multiage classrooms are a starting point for reorganizing the American public-education system, there are models to choose from and the benefits of these models are quite clear.

The multiage classroom described by Leeds and others, operated according to the following principles: First, students were included in the classroom for at least a two-year span in chronological age. Second, each student in the classroom would remain with the same teacher or teachers for at least two years, and often longer.

With this model in place, teachers reported being able to perceive each student not as a member of a graded grouping but as an individual with multiple qualities and capabilities. There is no need to assess each child based solely on his or her level of development, with the graded standards and age-based expectations applied in that assessment context.

Multiage Learning Benefits

A report recently indicated that the main academic benefit derived from multiage classrooms was peer tutoring. This method involves having older students work directly with younger students to transfer skills and knowledge. Benefits to both the older and younger students, the tutor and the tutee, include more independence and greater confidence. In fact, peer tutoring, as a practice in the classroom, not only builds confidence in children but can help resolve learning challenges of students who struggle academically. Problem-solving skills are also easily developed through this approach.

As a teacher, wouldn’t there be a huge advantage to spending more time teaching and bonding with struggling students? This is achieved when the issue of grade retention or promotion is removed from the equation entirely, such as in the multiage classroom.