Uncategorized

Pass or Fail: Teacher Professionalism and How to Boost It

In this multi-part series, I provide a dissection of the phenomenon of retention and social promotion. Also, I describe the many different methods that would improve student instruction in classrooms and eliminate the need for retention and social promotion if combined effectively.

While reading this series, periodically ask yourself this question: Why are educators, parents and the American public complicit in a practice that does demonstrable harm to children and the competitive future of the country?

It’s clear that the teaching profession has plenty of unresolved issues. It’s impossible to apply one blanket group of standards to an entire industry and then hope for the best.

Teacher professionalism, or lack of it, impacts student success, and failure.

Part of the challenge is identifying what exactly constitutes a qualified teacher. How are their qualifications determined and how can we verify those qualifications? First, we need teachers to facilitate the process of reforming the education system and ending grade retention and social promotion, as outlined in previous articles. Teachers must take ownership of certain standards and ensure that they are effectively managed.

In one sense, we’re charging teachers with implementing core curriculum elements for students and with managing some aspects of assessments to determine how well students retain the core knowledge. We’re also expecting teachers to manage classrooms, considering certain aspects of the classroom dynamic to assess and ultimately support the learning needs of all students, not just the “typical” ones.

Teachers are partly responsible for overseeing communication between home and school and between themselves and school administrators and policymakers who may have some bearing on whether or not a child is retained or socially promoted, whether they are deemed to be falling behind academically or whether there are other issues that are not being adequately addressed.

Because of specific expectations about what students learn and how they learn according to age, we’ll also assume that teachers need special knowledge to teach certain subjects, depending on the type of teaching job they take on. For instance, math teachers should have a degree in math or math education. Someone teaching English at a higher level should have an English degree. Elementary school teachers should have degrees in either elementary education or early childhood education, depending on which grade they go into. It’s important to place teachers on a track and then stick with it – most teacher qualifications do not easily translate to different grades or topics.

More specification is important to teachers having the necessary skills to adequately educate the exact students in their classrooms – and it’s essential to promoting those students accurately.

Pass or Fail: Teacher Qualifications for Standardized Education

In this multi-part series, I provide a dissection of the phenomenon of retention and social promotion. Also, I describe the many different methods that would improve student instruction in classrooms and eliminate the need for retention and social promotion if combined effectively.

While reading this series, periodically ask yourself this question: Why are educators, parents and the American public complicit in a practice that does demonstrable harm to children and the competitive future of the country?

Teachers are held to a higher standard than other professions – both in the classrooms and in their personal lives. Fair or unfair, it’s just part of the job. When it comes to documented “standards,” it seems like the rules are constantly changing for American educators – but is it for the betterment, or to the detriment, of students?

To get a sense of where teacher qualifications are right now, let’s consider the National Center for Educational Statistics (NCES) and their study of teaching qualifications and other trends among teachers of mathematics, English, and science. According to the NCES report for 2010, only about 80 percent of teachers teaching English or science had majored in their main area of teaching. Only about 70 percent of mathematics teachers had majored in their main assignment, and only 60 percent of these were certified.

Thus, only 42 percent of secondary level math teachers both majored in math and have a certificate to teach it. Although substantially more English and science teachers had at least majored in the subject they taught, it is still somewhat disconcerting that fully one on five English and science teachers had minimal exposure to the material they were attempting to teach. One of the first areas of concern, therefore, is the actual qualifications of teachers. Not only should we be concerned about teachers’ qualifications to teach; we apparently need to look into the degree to which they have mastered the material they are tasked with teaching.

It is also of no small concern that 12 percent of mathematics teachers have neither a teaching qualification nor a math specific qualification in schools in which at least half of the students are African-American. This suggests a racially based disparity.

Before considering the preparation of teachers to teach specific age-groups or subjects, we also need to consider what core aspects of knowledge and core skills teachers should be able to demonstrate to be considered competent.

Because of the importance of standards in the educational setting and the current reliance on state testing, several researchers have concentrated on the importance of accountability strategies.

Mathison and Freeman, for instance, discuss some of the current accountability strategies for school reform relying heavily on measured outcomes and especially student achievement linked to specific levels of performance. Their discussion also addresses research on elementary and middle school competencies targeting classroom experiences and involving conversations with teachers.

The results of these extended studies point to a tension between teachers’ desire to be professional, on the one hand, and their desire to give students the best chance to succeed within standardized testing scenarios, on the other.

Their research also suggests that the centralized curriculum mandates and high-stakes testing scenarios force teachers to act in ways that they consider to be lacking in integrity. Teachers feel that some of their actions, designed to support student success in examinations, do not fit within the scope of what they consider to be professionally ethical or reasonable.

Aaronsohn goes so far as to suggest the removal of grades from teaching all together. She suggests this as a means of overcoming the notion of “teacher-pleasing” among students and teaching for memorization. Aaronsohn outlines efforts to investigate student perceptions discussing the extent to which students indicated that they tended to focus on “figuring out the right answers and the correct behaviors each teacher required of them for them to get top grades or, at best, merely survive each class session.”

In a national study examining effective literacy teaching practices in early school years in Australia, researchers found that students with learning difficulties in literacy and numeracy benefited from certain teaching patterns that could well be transferable to different learning scenarios. In considering the problems of teaching literacy and numeracy, however, the study also outlined some of the underlining struggles in education, in teaching specifically.

The National Reading Panel of 2000 in the United States has also had some impact on Australian models. The Australian study mentioned concentrates on building an evidential link between children’s development in English literacy in early school years and their teachers’ classroom teaching practices. Specifically, the study showed that value-added analysis of student assessments showed teachers pushing six dimensions of literacy in their teaching practice: participation, knowledge, orchestration, support, differentiation, and respect.

 

Pass or Fail: Preparing Teachers for At-Risk Students

In this multi-part series, I provide a dissection of the phenomenon of retention and social promotion. Also, I describe the many different methods that would improve student instruction in classrooms and eliminate the need for retention and social promotion if combined effectively.

While reading this series, periodically ask yourself this question: Why are educators, parents and the American public complicit in a practice that does demonstrable harm to children and the competitive future of the country?

In classrooms with traditionally at-risk students – like minority, English-language learners and those from low socio-economic brackets – teachers can feel overwhelmed at the amount of work it takes to adequately teach students who have less advantages than others.

Preparing teachers to meet the needs of a diverse student base is absolutely necessary to student success long-term.

In an article targeting the importance of experiences and training on effective teaching to meet the needs of diverse learners, Edwards, Carr, and Siegel outline a specific component of an ongoing project to explore differentiated instruction (DI) as an approach for meeting the academic and related needs diverse learners in schools.

The 3 Dimensions (3D) of Diversity for Inclusion, as the project was known, emerged as a result of a September 2001 faculty meeting of the Department of Teaching and Learning at Southeastern Louisiana University. In the meeting, it came to light that the results from the prior academic year’s annual student teacher exit survey indicated teacher candidates wanted more intensive preparation to be able to work more effectively with diverse learners in schools.

A core problem within the teaching profession, as these findings suggest, is that few professionals have the knowledge, skills, or even basic training to determine the best pedagogical practices for many typical classroom scenarios. In fact, the survey conducted by Edwards et al. concentrated initially on ascertaining how regularly teachers were using specific strategies or techniques to plan for and accommodate individual differences in the classroom.

When interviewers asked about how often candidates’ strategies related to diversity, inclusion, differentiated instruction, accommodations, and modifications in the classroom, most indicated that they rarely employed instructional strategies to differentiate instruction, use tiered assessments, differentiate lessons using major concepts and generalizations, or use instructional materials to promote diversity. Rather, the focus was on using teaching materials rather than standard texts, allowing for a relatively wide range of product alternatives, including oral, visual, musical, and spatial; using cooperative and flexible grouping strategies, and varying questions based on student readiness, interest, and learning styles.

While these strategies go some way toward supporting students with atypical needs, the lack of focus on instructional strategies to differentiate instruction supports the idea that most teachers do not go far enough in their instructional approach. That is, they do not use instructional strategies to specifically and thus effectively target students with diverse needs. Their cut-and-paste, plug-the-hole solution is to use a range of learning materials to try to make up the difference. The transference of actual knowledge and skills to students falls by the wayside.

More than this, it appears that most teachers do not have an adequate range of experience before undertaking a formal teaching position. Edwards et al. touch on this issue at some length in their study. Indeed, they cite the educational and training background of survey respondents. The majority was female, Caucasian, and university-educated via a traditional undergraduate program. Most had no prior teaching experience, and only 40 percent of respondents said they had any kind of specific teacher training.

This tells us that teachers simply aren’t getting enough training before they enter classrooms and certainly not enough support when they are there. Further, diverse student bodies do not identify with the people influencing their educations, which is certainly not the fault of the teachers, but should be a wake-up call to all educators to recruit a more diverse teacher population that better reflects the students sitting at the desks.

 

Pass or Fail: Beyond Basic Teacher Requirements

In this multi-part series, I provide a dissection of the phenomenon of retention and social promotion. Also, I describe the many different methods that would improve student instruction in classrooms and eliminate the need for retention and social promotion if combined effectively.

While reading this series, periodically ask yourself this question: Why are educators, parents and the American public complicit in a practice that does demonstrable harm to children and the competitive future of the country?

Are the current education and teaching models for student teachers sufficient to prepare them for their jobs as teachers?

Perhaps teaching in general is not a field we need to redesign but one that we need to redefine to support the needs of diverse students, targeting those at risk of retention or social promotion.

First, all teachers should receive a certain level of core education and training in instructional practices and areas of classroom management, curriculum management, and the like. This training should address some of the clearly apparent gaps in understanding. One study conducted in 2007 examined the issue of teaching practices in rural schools and confirmed the need for improving the professional practices of teachers.

In a five-year study of rural schools in Missouri, Harmon et al. also determined that the challenges for rural schools, while similar to urban schools, were even more pronounced. Specific weaknesses include low fiscal capacity, fewer management support services, greater per-pupil costs, higher numbers of teachers teaching outside their specialty area, less competitive salaries and benefits, less specialized space and equipment, less availability of planning support services, and fewer evaluation support services.

Harmon, Gordanier et al. discussed the situation of rural teachers and district leaders in the Missouri Ozarks, a region including all ten school districts in the Ozark Rural Systemic Initiative (ORSI). Funded by the National Science Foundation (NSF), the proportions of students managed by ORSI who are eligible for free or reduced price lunch programs exceed the state average of 40.7 percent. Within these ten districts, two districts also had eligibility rates of 72.5 and 73.4 percent.

The study considered the implementation of new curricula as a means to encourage teachers to review their teaching practices. Even without new curricula, though, the study found that teachers should regularly review curricula with a view to identifying potential improvements or developments they could use in their own practice. Teachers were encouraged to review curricula in the context of teacher-focused training and development, immersing themselves in the insights of national experts in order to learn how to implement standards more effectively in their own classrooms.

Various policy recommendations for high-quality professional development for teachers also outline the need for extensive, long-term professional development that focuses directly on the classroom work of teachers, the curriculum actually taught, instructional materials to be used with students, and necessary assessments.

Although all teachers need not major in education, it makes sense to require a certain number of educational credits at an undergraduate level. Any teacher or prospective teacher of kindergarten or first grade student should clearly have academic training in early childhood development or elementary education. Being able to understand and track the development of children between the ages of five and eight is critical to kindergarten and first grade teachers, who are charged with helping to identify those students who are struggling with some aspect of their development and are therefore putting themselves at risk of being held back.

Teachers working in higher grades need to demonstrate a certain level of formal education in their target subject or subjects, as well as in the art and science of education. But some degree of familiarity with child development and psychology is necessary for even higher-grade teachers if they are to be sufficiently alert to students whose academic struggles suggest they may need additional support.

Teaching certification should be a requirement for public school teaching. It is a standard for education already and, by state, it provides at least some means of assessing the individual teacher’s commitment to their work and their preparedness to invest in the work they are doing.

These “paper” certifications are just that, though. They are important but we can’t wrap a teacher’s worth completely around them – and we also can’t assume that the basics of certification and licensure is enough. It isn’t – and our students deserve more.

Pass or Fail: Defining Teacher Competence

In this multi-part series, I provide a dissection of the phenomenon of retention and social promotion. Also, I describe the many different methods that would improve student instruction in classrooms and eliminate the need for retention and social promotion if combined effectively.

While reading this series, periodically ask yourself this question: Why are educators, parents and the American public complicit in a practice that does demonstrable harm to children and the competitive future of the country?

WHO a teacher is as a person impacts HOW he or she educates

Beyond specific teacher qualifications and the alignment of teachers with particular training to undertake specific teaching assignments, we must also consider and define teacher competence apart from any credentials they may have. This is so because, unfortunately, even a considerable amount of academic and professional training does not necessarily result in the acquisition of the competence necessary to the meet raised expectations for student learning.

As an alternative to retention and a suggested best teaching proactive, Glasser proposed that teachers should model and relate schoolwork directly to student interests and needs as a means of motivating students to work harder. Merit promotion was also a viable strategy to encourage students to work harder, to be motivated to study and perform well on a specific test or on several specific tests, especially when testing is the principal criterion for retention.

Another strategy, outlined by Siegel and Hanson, involves the use of remedial aids to support students who have difficulty in a specific skills area. Supplementing instruction but requiring minimum absence from the classroom (compared to special education pull-out supports) can also be effective.

Glasser considered a somewhat proactive approach: having teachers specifically insist on superior work from students who are not performing well. Although this strategy might seem self-defeating for students already struggling academically, a good, competent teacher should be able to recognize instances in which this, or any of the other strategies outlined here, might be effective at engaging a struggling student.

Being able to gauge when it is appropriate to employ optional instructional strategies or practices is an important skill we might reasonably expect to find in competent teachers. Teachers should be able to facilitate cooperative learning, mastery learning, direct instruction, adaptive education, individualized instruction, peer tutoring, and curriculum-based assessments as instructional strategies whenever appropriate.

A core teacher competency should not only be the ability to identify and implement specific teaching strategies to support individual learning needs but the ability to make a sound judgment about strategies from the available range. The best teachers should be able to recognize those measures that would be most effective at supporting an individual student and inspiring him to be accountable for his education.

Because of the importance of home–school communications, teachers must be good communicators. They must be able to engage parents as well as students, and should encourage parents to support their children while also addressing potentially sensitive issues with them.

Positive social-communication and interpersonal skills are also important competencies. Teachers should be comfortable and competent at encouraging student responsibility and self-evaluation. Beginning as early as first grade, Glasser suggests; teachers should encourage students to undertake self-grading. He also argues that teachers shouldn’t even accept class work until both teacher and student have agreed on its quality.

When these “gray” areas start to come into play, it further emphasizes the futility of a pass/fail system. There are so many nuances to learning – and to teachers and students as individuals. This is such an important concept to embrace if we are to move forward from a pass/fail mentality into one that actually works for every student in the classroom.

Pass or Fail: Consistent Standards to Rise Above Retention and Social Promotion

In this multi-part series, I provide a dissection of the phenomenon of retention and social promotion. Also, I describe the many different methods that would improve student instruction in classrooms and eliminate the need for retention and social promotion if combined effectively.

While reading this series, periodically ask yourself this question: Why are educators, parents and the American public complicit in a practice that does demonstrable harm to children and the competitive future of the country?

Consistency is the key to overcoming social promotion and retention issues in our K-12 schools, and that will take a shift in the way our school systems view pass/fail standards.

Without consistent standards, student motivation will continue to deteriorate, and there will be a further undermining of educational goals in themselves. The common assumption, when a strategy like retention is applied, is that holding back students who are underperforming is a viable way to ensure that they go on to master expected skills. The assumption has been that a student who fails to show mastery of specific skills simply needs more time to grasp curricular concepts.

Despite the fact that they are struggling already, retained students are expected to not only achieve the required knowledge and skill levels they previously failed to but also to master a higher standard of knowledge and skill if they graduate and move up to the next grade after a year.

The absurdity of this expectation is not lost on the education system, but that has not prevented the deployment of these policies since roughly 1850. Instead of working to have clear, consistent policies to support student development throughout their school career, the shifts in educational policies have determined that effective grading policies for students do not exist. The traditional grading scheme was instituted at a time when “only an advantaged few”were allowed to advance to the higher learning opportunities.

As Brookhart points out in his assessment of the application of grading in this sense, one of the larger failings of common grading practices is that they do not account for the needs of the teacher either. They do not recognize that individual teachers need to manage their classrooms and motivate their students.

“Traditional grading does not so much ignore motivation theory as much as it simply predates it,” says Brookhart, and it certainly makes little provision for struggling students, who are often labeled “uninterested” or “lazy,” when the issue may rather be that they are subjected to too much motivation in the wrong direction.

It is worth noting that many students impacted by retention and promotion policies which are regarded as having poor academic performance are not necessarily just having issues with the content that they are expected to learn. Many researchers have suggested that at least some of the problem is due to the grading and assessment system in use across the country. In other words, poor grading systems perpetuate the problem of poorly performing students.

James and Powell argued that “merely abolishing social promotion will not solve the problem.”  I believe we should be emphasizing intended progress toward individualized learning, as well as the promotion of greater parental involvement through government support of poor and disadvantaged families. What are your thoughts?

 

Pass or Fail: Don’t Dumb Down Learning

In this multi-part series, I provide a dissection of the phenomenon of retention and social promotion. Also, I describe the many different methods that would improve student instruction in classrooms and eliminate the need for retention and social promotion if combined effectively.

While reading this series, periodically ask yourself this question: Why are educators, parents and the American public complicit in a practice that does demonstrable harm to children and the competitive future of the country?

When I talk about getting every kid from one grade to the next on schedule, I’m not talking about making anything easier for kids. If anything, our standards should continue to rise as our pedagogy improves.

So how do educators combine high standards with ensuring student achievement?

Establishing viable educational standards must include the development of a solid, valuable curriculum. One study that assessed students in Chicago classrooms showed an average of one-year learning gain when students were routinely given challenging assignments compared to those in Chicago classrooms where the intellectual quality of the assignments was low. For the same group, test results were also higher than national norms among those who received challenging assignments.

The intellectually stimulating assignments also appeared to lead to children posting learning gains 20 percent greater than the national average. Where assignments were less challenging in Chicago classrooms, students gained 25 percent less than the national average in reading and 22 percent less in mathematics.

Considering this example, the development of consistent standards should also involve the development of consistently challenging standards so that children of all abilities are encouraged to learn and inspired to learn.

The report by the Northern Central Regional Educational Laboratory also emphasizes that skilled teachers are crucial to intensifying learning; that these teachers were, in the Chicago classrooms studied, providing authentic instruction and meaningful assignments while holding high expectations for all students.

As a strategy, the provision of challenging assignments to students also helped to adopt habits of disciplined study, and to elicit higher-order thinking skills and their connection to the “real world.” Successful teachers allowed substantial time for discussion and idea sharing among students. Teachers also employed several learning models to create “active learning” and an “active learning environment.”

The environment helped to support a shift in the relationship among teachers, students, and knowledge. The active environments required collaboration and communication and encouraged more analysis, synthesis, and evaluation of information than traditional classrooms. One of the key effects was that students were forced to take ownership of their learning. It encouraged students to develop their learning and develop strategies for learning.

These approaches should be incorporated into an educational policy as well. Indeed, based on the identified benefits, it should be standard for schools to work to design instruction within “active environments,” emphasizing depth of learning rather than breadth of learning.

Pass or Fail: Get Students Involved, Be Flexible

In this multi-part series, I provide a dissection of the phenomenon of retention and social promotion. Also, I describe the many different methods that would improve student instruction in classrooms and eliminate the need for retention and social promotion if combined effectively.

While reading this series, periodically ask yourself this question: Why are educators, parents and the American public complicit in a practice that does demonstrable harm to children and the competitive future of the country?

Educators have a big stake in what they present in classrooms. The material is, after all, hand-picked by them to help get students from Point A to Point B. For most of the history of public education, a prescriptive form of teaching the masses has been widely accepted but that’s changing, and quickly. Any teacher who has spent more than a day on the job knows that students who have a say in how they learn are more engaged — and more invested in the end result. 

A study conducted by Apple tracked the benefits of high levels of student involvement in learning. Apple’s study found that with active classrooms, high levels of student involvement occurred. Encouraging students to frame their questions and urging them to take the initiative to follow up and essentially learn independently is a positive strategy.

The collaboration was also considered a key point and was particularly beneficial because of the diverse population of students in schools today. There is a clear need for education standards to support a system that also reflects and celebrates diversity and allows children to reach high standards.

Encouraging educators create new pathways to learning by providing more opportunities for students also makes allowances for the fact that not all children learn in the same way, or at the same time. By offering more routes to achieve learning standards, teachers enable more children to reach them, which should also be reflected in new education standards and learning criteria.

The challenge of expanding pathways is particularly significant because it determines that there must be some guidelines as to how this expansion should take place, how it could work, and how it should be supported as a policy.

One of the strategies for expanded learning, according to the North Central Regional Educational Laboratory, is to incorporate flexible scheduling. By reorganizing the school day or even the school year, the report suggests, educators can more effectively use the time to support all learners and participants in ongoing professional development.

Block scheduling, in which classes are lengthened (often ninety minutes, rather than the usual forty-five or fifty) can also be effective for helping schools to meet the unique needs of students. Various models exist for this, as well. There are numerous advantages to block scheduling, including that students can be exposed to a variety of instructional techniques.

When students are exposed to various types of learning, they often experience improved grades, test scores, and attendance. Block learning can also mean that students have longer lunch periods and the opportunity to get extra help with their schoolwork. Teachers can have longer prep time and increased opportunity for teamwork and integrated professional development activities.

Reorganizing the school year is another a strategy that has gained some general popularity around the country, with several models available for year-round schooling, all of which involve modifying the school calendar so that learning occurs more consistently throughout the year.

The basic premise of the year-round learning calendars is that the school year can be reorganized to shorten the long summer break and schedule more frequent breaks throughout the year.

Specific advantages of this strategy include reduced summer learning losses, which typically require substantial catch-up and review time every fall. Reducing the length of breaks through reorganization can also help to increase student achievement because of the reduced catch-up time in the fall.

The various additional benefits of year-round schooling include supports for diverse populations of students, improved student and teacher attendance, and fewer discipline problems. These benefits alone would seem to suggest that year-round schooling might be an optimal approach to support the needs of minority students and other students who fall into high-risk categories for retention or social promotion.

Improved student and teacher attendance, fewer discipline problems, reduced teacher stress, increased student and teacher motivation, and increased opportunities for enrichment and remediation during breaks are further benefits.

Reorganization or differentiation of instruction can also expand learning opportunities. As Tomilson points out: “At its most basic level, differentiation consists of the efforts of teachers to respond to variance among learners in the classroom. Whenever a teacher reaches out to an individual or small group to vary his or her teaching to create the best learning experience possible, that teacher is differentiating instruction.”

Teachers can also more effectively differentiate with at least four classroom elements – content, process, products, and the learning environment – based on student readiness and interest. Supporting flexible grouping, cooperative learning, multiple intelligences, and brain-based learning, an emphasis on differentiation in teaching, supported by reorganization of the school year, would be a viable means to align resources and create clear expectations to overcome retention and social promotion.

 

Pass or Fail: Hiring Teachers Who Can Beat the System

In this multi-part series, I provide a dissection of the phenomenon of retention and social promotion. Also, I describe the many different methods that would improve student instruction in classrooms and eliminate the need for retention and social promotion if combined effectively.

While reading this series, periodically ask yourself this question: Why are educators, parents and the American public complicit in a practice that does demonstrable harm to children and the competitive future of the country?

How can teachers rise above the ingrained system of pass/fail standards?

Kyra Shugt felt called to be a teacher: She was ashamed that her home state of Minnesota had one of the largest achievement gaps in the country, and wanted to do something about it. She had some teaching experience under her belt, as a preschool teacher and part-time art teacher. Hoping to get a teacher’s license as quickly as possible, she enrolled in Teach for America’s five-week summer program in Chicago.

At the TFA institute, she trained to be an ESL teacher, but when she received her teaching practice placement, it was in sixth-grade mathematics. She hoped her final placement as a teacher would be in the ESL field for which she had received training, but that was not to be: She ended up at Bethune Elementary in Minneapolis, teaching fourth grade. Though she was excited to have a job, she soon realized she was hopelessly unprepared.

“It was challenging,” she commented. “It was the hardest position I had ever taken on. I consider myself to be a dedicated teacher and just have a strong work ethic, but it was overwhelming.”

Not only had Shugt ended up in a position for which she was not prepared; she was also teaching in one of the worst-performing schools in the state. She noted that Bethune was “considered a lemon school. Students from the district that are kicked out of other public schools are sent to Bethune.” About half of the teachers at Bethune were newbies like Shugt, and they were paired with more experienced mentors. Though Bethune was designated a Priority School and received extra funding and had smaller classes (there were just fourteen students in Shugt’s fourth-grade classroom), teaching there was nevertheless an ongoing struggle.

In particular, Shugt felt unequipped to deal with the significant behavioral issues that cropped up on a daily basis. When fights broke out in the classroom, she would try to intervene, but felt that her involvement was endangering her. Finally, in consultation with the school management, Shugt decided to leave the school in the middle of the year.

“I loved the staff and the students,” she said, but “it just wasn’t the right fit. It was hard to leave my students but at the same time it just felt like it was not in their best interest for me to stay.”

A Familiar Teacher’s Tale

Kyra Shugt’s story may be extreme, but her experiences are all too common: under-trained teachers with little to no classroom experience are sent to some of the most difficult schools in the country. In the end, not only the teachers, but the students and the parents are left hurting.

In the not-so-distant past, public schools represented the central building block in the education and socialization of students outside of the home. Young minds were molded by the teachers, administrators, and friends they met at school.

Modern classrooms, unlike those of the past, are full of sophisticated youngsters that show up with a detailed view of the world formed from more than home life experiences. Instant access to knowledge from the age a child can press a touchscreen on a smartphone and widespread socialization from as young as six weeks old mean that kids arrive at kindergarten with less naivety than previous generations. Teachers are not handed a clean slate but rather one that is already cluttered with random knowledge that must be fostered or remediated.

Pass or Fail: Teacher Training Impacts Student Success

In this multi-part series, I provide a dissection of the phenomenon of retention and social promotion. Also, I describe the many different methods that would improve student instruction in classrooms and eliminate the need for retention and social promotion if combined effectively.

While reading this series, periodically ask yourself this question: Why are educators, parents and the American public complicit in a practice that does demonstrable harm to children and the competitive future of the country?

What’s the true value of teachers? What are they worth to the education system and what we should be doing to make the most of their skills and time?

The relationship between teacher expertise and student success is vital to the success of this generation of students, and the next.

So, how do we go about creating qualified and competent teachers?

Teachers are usually the stakeholders we hold accountable for transferring standards, knowledge, and skills to our students. And whether or not this accountability is fair, if teachers themselves are not adept at the transfer of knowledge and skills then it hardly matters what sort of standards or curriculum an education system has developed.

We assume that teachers play a role in assessing the strengths and weaknesses of individual students. Part of being an effective teacher is having some insight into students – when they are excelling or likely to excel, when they are likely to need help, what sort of help they are going to need, and how they can make the most out of their natural abilities.

In our discussion of retention and social promotion so far, we noted that teachers play a part in deciding whether to retain struggling students or promote them. Teacher assessment is another of the core elements in this decision. Not only do teachers decide how to support students needing help, provide the support, and assess the student in their progress; teacher assessments also tend to make up a big part of the overall assessment process when it comes to retention decisions.

A lot depends on teacher quality. If teachers are not appropriately qualified and trained to meet these expectations and handle this responsibility, what is the price we end up paying? What is the consequence of this structuring?

The simple reality is this: not all teachers entering the classroom, whether at the elementary or secondary level, have adequate training and experience to meet raised expectations for student learning. Although effective teachers are the best defense against retention and social promotion, because they can make up for much of what individual students might lack in natural ability or capacity for knowledge or skills development, we have to be clear about what teachers need to do in the classroom. We have to establish all of our expectations, not just the ones that have the weight of officialdom.

A strong teacher, at the end of the day, is an invaluable classroom tool, although the education system has yet to define what constitutes a strong teacher. Certainly, we have yet to figure out exactly how to produce strong teachers with any degree of consistency.

The challenge is to think about the qualification standards for teachers – what should they be able to demonstrate regarding academic training, professional training, and professional experience? We also have to consider what it is that constitutes teacher competency – what practices should a teacher be able to implement in a classroom setting? What models for teaching should they be able to use? Considering these and related questions about quality teaching, we can then begin to identify the nature and causes of problems that are undermining teacher quality.