Uncategorized

False Positives: Low Student Loan Default Scores

**The Edvocate is pleased to publish guest posts as way to fuel important conversations surrounding P-20 education in America. The opinions contained within guest posts are those of the authors and do not necessarily reflect the official opinion of The Edvocate or Dr. Matthew Lynch.**

Guest post by Bob Hildreth

Ask the “best” colleges about the student debt crisis and they are likely to trot out the very low default rates of their graduates, only 1 to 2 percent. Most of the defaulting students, they point out, come from for-profits. They also believe that the national default rate at 11.8 percent is at a manageable level.

But these rates hide more than they reveal. Default rates are managed to be low. It is in the best interest of everyone involved to keep them low: the government wants to keep the lid on its troubled policy, the government’s collection agents want to earn their fees by keeping debtors current, and the colleges want to keep the mother’s milk of government subsidies flowing in their direction.

The “best colleges” have little experience with debt defaults. They either don’t know or are reluctant to admit that, when it comes to the government’s loan program, colleges are all bunched together. Even for a college with zero defaults the only default rate that matters in a crisis is that of all debtors from all colleges.

The government is lenient, letting 9 months of no repayments pass before calling a student in default. Compare that to only 90 days on car loans or 3 months on mortgages. Students are also allowed to clear their defaults by switching from stricter repayment plans to easier ones. College lobbyists have convinced the government to measure default rates after only three years knowing that defaults accumulate over time. In fact, one in five students with over $15,000 in debt defaulted on his or her loan in the 10 years after graduation. That’s a 20% default rate.

The Federal Reserve of New York has created its own measure to gage student debt stress. Using consumer data the Fed measures how long students go without paying their debts. By this calculation in 2014 past due rates on student debt reached as high as 63%. 

That leaves the government like the famous emperor without clothes. If the future of our children and the solvency of our colleges were not at stake the government might have already stopped lending. But there is probably no default rate so high that the government would abandon these priorities. At the same time it is easy to guess that changes are afoot. One of the most likely targets are controls on tuition increases. That will cause a fire storm on Washington’s DuPont Circle, the home of college lobbyists. If these lobbyists can suggest a way to put clothes back on the emperor, they should speak now.

____

Bob Hildreth is the Founder and Chairman of the Board of Inversant, a Boston-based non-profit that helps families learn about, apply for and save for college without incurring student debt.

How Low-income Adults Access Affordable Education

**The Edvocate is pleased to publish guest posts as way to fuel important conversations surrounding P-20 education in America. The opinions contained within guest posts are those of the authors and do not necessarily reflect the official opinion of The Edvocate or Dr. Matthew Lynch.**

A guest post by Anica Oaks

In high school, teens are told that no matter where they come from, they can go to college. Unfortunately, many low-income adolescents don’t have the opportunity to even apply to universities, since they may not have the money for the application fee, funds for textbooks or enough money to cover the residual tuition not covered by FAFSA.

Many low-income adults began working while they were still in high school. After graduating, they are left struggling to make ends meet with a minimum wage job and wind up feeling suffocated and discouraged early on in life. Despite the fact that they may not be able to afford an Ivy League school, there are accessible education opportunities for low-income adults whether they graduated last summer or 30 years ago.

Free College Classes Online

Sites like Coursera and edX have teamed up with hundreds of renowned universities across the world to offer learners from all backgrounds access to a quality education free of charge. The courses that you can find range from introductory level English and math courses to digital marketing, science, languages, computer science and engineering, and more.

Each site gives students the option to purchase certificates of completion for less than $100 per course, and Coursera even offers financial aid for those who can’t afford the default price. Whether you just want to learn for personal benefit or to gain the knowledge necessary to pursue new career opportunities, getting started at Coursera and edX is an excellent way to do so for little to no cost.

Find a Vocational School

Many schools will teach you how to become a professional at a trade like cosmetology, electricity and HVAC installation and more for a very low cost. The Newgate School in Minneapolis turns donated trucks and cars from citizens into tools for low-income students to work on and learn how to become auto mechanics in under 2 years.

There are other many other vocational schools you can find that offer affordable financing options for low-income students and can provide you with the training you need to get a high-paying career in under 2 years.

Scholarships and Work Study Programs

Many low-income adults write off college before they fully explore all their options. Although it requires some extra research, many people can qualify for special scholarships that can be combined with federal student aid. In-state tuition for many colleges is less than $10,000 a year to residents. A scholarship can open the door to education, and a work-study program that provides you with some income as well as pays off your tuition while you work are all viable options for low-income adults looking to better themselves and expand their career options.

Even if you don’t have money for a traditional education, don’t give up! If you search hard enough, you can find opportunities for free or subsidized education.

___

Anica is a professional content and copywriter who graduated from the University of San Francisco. She loves dogs, the ocean, and anything outdoor-related. She was raised in a big family, so she’s used to putting things to a vote. Also, cartwheels are her specialty. You can connect with Anica here.

The Evidence-Based Athletic Department

 

A director of athletics details how a shift from paper to digital forms has saved his staff time and helped them gather actionable data about student injuries.

Guest post by Darryl Nance

Like many districts around the country, Greenville (SC) County Schools has been moving in the direction of data-driven decision-making in all areas, including our athletic department. While our athletic trainers have long been able to electronically document injuries, the bulk of other data necessary for injury prevention and effectiveness research has, until recently, remained out of our grasp.

A significant portion of the information came to the school via paper forms completed by athletes and parents, so there was no structured data. Now that we are using the extracurricular management platform PlanetHS, those athletes and parents can fill out forms online, so all inputs come in as structured data.

Data collection had also been a challenge because every Greenville County sports team is supported by a medical team. For many years, the Greenville Health System has hired athletic trainers who are assigned to each middle and high school on a full-time basis. Orthopedic physicians from the Steadman Hawkins Clinic of the Carolinas offer free weekend clinics, after-clinic open hours, and at-game coverage for the schools. The nonprofit Hawkins Foundation and the Center for Effectiveness Research in Orthopaedics work in concert with these medical and academic professionals to provide the necessary infrastructure and scientific insight to prevent injuries, improve treatments, and support the health of each student.

Another roadblock to gathering useful data was that coaches and school athletic directors had developed schedules in various formats that were difficult to assimilate into a data set. Without schedules of practices and games, researchers have no way to know exposures (the actual amount of time an athlete is involved in the sport and at risk for injury) for each athlete—and therefore are unable to conduct accurate assessments. Now, coaches and athletic directors place practice and game schedules directly into PlanetHS, so we have a uniform way to quantify participation levels.

Lastly, our athletic trainers used to manually input each athlete into their trainer software programs. This was extremely time-consuming and error-filled. Aside from taking valuable time away from their primary task, it was almost impossible to gather accurate information with paper forms where, for example, a student might write his or her nickname while the parent offered the full name—not to mention the fact that our trainers have no knowledge of grade promotion or eligibility. As the eligibility provider for the South Carolina High School League, PlanetHS has the accurate name and grade level for every athlete, and through a direct connection to our athletic trainer software, each trainer now has an up-to-date roster of participants without any time taken away from their trainer responsibilities.

After years of painstakingly slow manual effort, we now have a comprehensive data-gathering system that covers more than 20 different sports throughout the entire middle school and high school sports program.

Conclusions About Concussions

Through our manual processes, we’ve been able to reduce injuries in baseball significantly. And we’ve just completed a study showing a decline in the severity of concussions. So we know the basics of how to define projects, collect data for analysis, and generate evidence. With the new data access capabilities via PlanetHS, our ability to look at the specifics of injury history, student scheduling, and participation in relation to the development and prevention of injuries has been significantly enhanced. 

My biggest recommendation to other school leaders who want to adopt a data-driven approach to assessing, preventing, and treating student athlete injuries is to audit their current processes and work to eliminate paper. While our research team has greatly benefitted from moving much of our work online, we can only imagine the efficiency we could gain by eliminating the collation, filing, and overall management of paper.

As a result of our new capabilities, we’ve added a data scientist to our team and opened new grant opportunities. When it comes to protecting and caring for our student athletes, there is much more that can be accomplished, and with the right tools, researchers will be amazed at how fast they can accomplish it.

____

Darryl Nance is the director of athletics for Greenville County Schools in South Carolina.

Chicago teachers on strike, nation’s third largest school system shut down

Instead of students being in class, last Friday thousands of Chicago teachers went on a strike and marched and held signs at the city’s hundreds of public schools, according to The Washington Post. In some instances, parents and children were present at the school to show the teachers support.

The Chicago Teachers Union strikes means that the city’s nearly 340,000 students were not in the classroom.

President of the Chicago Teachers Union, Karen Lewis, said that she hopes the disruptions put pressure on the states Governor, Bruce Rauner. His standoff with the Democratic legislature has left the state with no budget for the last nine months.

The union recognized that the financially troubled school system faces limitations in its ability to bring on more teachers or increase their pay, and wants lawmakers in the state to reform its education funding.

The state of Illinois has the most unfair school funding formula in the United States, according to an analysis by the national advocacy group Education Trust. It found that schools with the highest level of those in poverty get around 20 percent fewer dollars per student than schools in the more wealthy communities.

Lewis stated in an interview that the city needs to do something major.

Chicago Public Schools and city officials agree that the Chicago school district faces a fiscal criss that needs the help of lawyers in the state’s capital, Springfield. Like the union, they blame Gov. Rauner for choosing not to aid the struggling system.

They call the union’s walkout unproductive and illegal, a breach of labor rules that forbid teachers from going on strike prior to the middle of May.

School system officials also call the strike illegal, and union leaders say it’s a way to bring attention to the dismal financial outlook of Chicago’s public schools and colleges.

The union believes its strike is legal because the district engaged in unfair labor practice when it chose not to increase salaries based on teachers education and experience.

I hope that the city and the teachers can resolve these issues soon. The children of Chicago deserve to be in the schools receiving education —  they should not suffer because of factors that are beyond their control.

Are Income Share Agreements the Answer to College Debt?

Student loan debt has become the talk of the political town as we approach Election Day. Candidates running for everything from president to school board have ideas on how to solve the nation’s student debt crisis.

The Green Party’s nominee for president wants to absolve all student debt if elected and Hillary Clinton–the presumptive nominee on the Democratic side–has a plan to sink $350 billion dollars into the hole in an attempt to plug it.

When it comes to finding solutions for the crisis, we swing like a pendulum as to how we may resolve the main problem of the debt crisis.

But one way that’s gaining popularity is that of Income Share Agreements (ISA). Students who take out loans to attain a degree that may be deemed worthless in the workplace are saddled with massive amounts of debt that they are unable to pay back.

This causes many to default on their loans and fall down an income hole that detaches them from the ability to obtain credit to purchase a home, vehicle, and etc…

Because it’s tough to section these students off–those who may be in danger of gaining a degree that’s economically barren–some may be eligible to take out an ISA loan.

These loans allow the student to pay back the cost of their degree in terms of its value. So if one student has a degree that has little to no worth, he or she will have a small amount, if any, to repay.

Inversely, if a student’s degree turns out to be of much value, then that student will pay back more.

Ostensibly this seems like a good deal for students. It’s affordable, colleges and universities seem open to it, and Congress is exploring ways to create a regulatory environment for ISAs.

Hopefully, once properly researched and vetted, the application of these loans are a win for students as the cost of tuition and school fees continue to rise.

NC Congresswoman introduces HBCU Innovation Fund Act

To advance the goals of HBCUs, North Carolina Congresswoman Alma Adams has introduced the HBCU Innovation Fund Act. The bill would create a fund that would make the availability of $250 million in grants open to Historically Black Colleges and Universities.

In an effort to improve viability, student achievement, rates of graduation, enrollment figures, and more, the accessibility of grant money to HBCUs would help to push them towards modernization.

As HBCUs continue to receive press regarding how some schools are doing financially, and if segregation regarding offered programs occurs, it is refreshing to see that all HBCUs may receive a boost if this bill passes.

The legislation, H.R. 4857, was lauded by the United Negro College Fund as innovative, and has over 15 co-sponsors in Congress.

If the bill passes, it will open HBCUs up to more than just money and opportunity. Grant money would be used to help remodel certain courses and create new programs. As with the new Queer and Cultural Studies program being offered at Bowie State University, more programs of this nature may be cultivated through HBCUs if H.R. 4857 is passed.

There will be more opportunities for inclusion and recruitment and retention efforts will certainly increase.

Some HBCUs struggle to maintain strong enrollment numbers, particularly in a culture where online learning often replace on-campus iniativies. This bill would hopefully help many HBCUs create stronger programs to go after more students.

But more than anything, this legislation would make HBCUs more competitive in an educational environment that has changed. Some schools have failed to keep up, through no fault of its own, and some are beginning to fall behind.

Stemming that tide and keeping HBCUs around so that more students of color are served, and the cultural importance of each school is maintained, an HBCU fund for innovation and is needed and welcomed.

New study predicts bad economic results for ‘selfie-generation’

Taking a camera and turning it on yourself for a picture is a fairly new fad. Selfies have become so popular with teens and young adults that they’ve been dubbed the ‘selfie-generation,’ or maybe just millennials (and younger).

While taking personal photos of yourself seems harmless, a new study suggests that there are more consequences than what meets the eye.

Researchers from Appalachian State University conducted a study of 400 undergraduate college students and looked at how narcissism impacts their performance. The results weren’t particularly kind.

Students who are self-absorbed enjoyed the teachings of professors who are also self-absorbed and even earned good grades in those classes. But those who are less self-involved — those that aren’t narcissists — struggled when taught by professors steeped in ego.

It is, on the surface at least, an interesting look into how some millennials may perform in the workplace. The ones who operate by being overly self-involved are able to understand superiors, or in this case professors, who behave in the same manner.

This seems like a positive for the selfie-obsessed but the study also found that self-absorbed students had trouble working within a team environment.

It’s important to note that the research focused on business students and not other academic disciplines. As suggested by the study, business students who are draped in conceit may be more prone to commit white-collar crime and may lack empathy.

Perhaps most importantly, though, is that the study showed the narcissistic students had more trouble assessing risk, which impacts the economy and their potential for future earnings.

Ask any millennial about being self-absorbed or selfish and many will tell you that they have been improperly labeled. The availability of new technology, and the onset of helicopter parenting, has allowed them to develop a selfish complex.

The good news is that all millennials aren’t this way and this was simply a study of a personality trait. It’s easy to see how these results can be extrapolated to have more weight, though.

There are now more millennials than baby boomers, so our economy, and future, depend their success.

Hopefully this study isn’t a peek into the not so distant future.

Obama administration overhauls loan repayment system

The U.S. Department of Education plans to overhaul how it collects federal student loan payments from millions of Americans, according to Insidehighered.com.

Under the U.S. Department of Education’s new plan, federal loan borrowers will log onto a single Education Department web portal where they make payments on student loans. This means borrowers no longer have to find their way through multiple loan servicers’ sites. The contracted loan servicing companies will use Education Department branding instead of their own logos during all communication with borrowers.

At the present time, borrowers make payments to one of many servicing firms that work with the Education Department. The major loan servicers include Great Lakes Educational Loan Services, Inc, Nelnet, Navient, and the Pennsylvania Higher Education Assistance Agency (FedLoan Servicing).

The goal of the changes is to eliminate the need to know the name of the loan servicer, according to Under Secretary of Education, Ted Mitchell.

Mitchell also said another goal is to build a state-of-the-art loan-servicing program that creates guidelines and incentives to make the single loan management platform more user-friendly. In addition, all borrowers will receive one-on-one customer service.

In 2010, the Obama administration made all federal student loans originate from the Education Department. For years, this has caused criticism from student activists for not properly overseeing the companies it hired to collect student loans.

The loan services that will be a part of the new system will be announced in the upcoming month. There is a competitive government procurement process prior to the decision. Loan servicers are required to submit bids for the project by May 9.

The Director of Washington, D.C., office of the Institute for College Access and Success, Jennifer Wang, feels the changes are a really important step. She said it should not matter who your servicer is – borrows should have consistent information.

These changes seem long overdue. I think borrowers will really appreciate the simplicity of logging on to a single portal to make loan payments.

K-12 Public School Facilities Underfunded

Several organizations, including the 21st Century School Fund, the National Council on School Facilities and the U.S. Green Building Council recently released a report titled The State of Our Schools: America’s K-12 Facilities. Education News documents that the findings of this report show that K-12 public school facilities are severely underfunded due to lack of federal involvement and limited state accountability. The report found that the federal government supplies almost no capital construction funding for school facilities, and that state support for facilities differs extensively.

It is up to the local school district and community to make investments to build upon and improve school facilities. Often time districts can’t afford these improvements and are forced to make repairs out of the operating fund that should be reserved for teacher salaries, programming and instructional materials.

The last time a report such as this was performed was 1995 via the U.S. Government Accounting Office. That report found that half of all federal schools had problems linked to poor indoor air quality. 15,000 schools were found to be circulating air deemed unfit to breathe in. Alarmingly, the recent report found that not a lot has changed since 1995.

Local districts and communities are responsible for funding and the federal government doesn’t contribute, even in lower income areas. For poor communities, the result has been major inequality. It was also determined that the average age of a public school building in 2012 was 44 years old, with the vast majority requiring significant repairs. Our nation is under spending by $46 billion or, 32 percent annually on school facilities.

With states expected to bear the brunt of the financial responsibilities in regards to school facilities, many are unable to do so and are clearly missing the mark. It will be up to federal, state and local entities to collaborate to create new solutions. An overhaul is necessary in order for school facilities to meet the needs of today’s students in order to keep Americans on par with global education.

How to Streamline Assignments for Teachers and Students

Educators – what is your system for assigning, grading, and giving feedback on work done in class and at home? Most contemporary educators have at least some digital elements involved in the process, whether they use an online planning application or just type up their notes on the computer.

How much time does your system actually take you to use? An hour per week? Two? More?

Teachers may not even realize how much time is poured into the logistics of planning, delivering, and grading assignments since it happens a little bit at a time. Those hours not only take away from free time but can impede what is actually dedicated to instruction in the classroom.

Technology is evolving with the power to change all of that, though. I recently had a chance to learn more about the Canary Learning system, a cloud service that allows teachers and students the ability to log in from any internet-connected device to see upcoming lessons, assignments, and due dates. Launched in early 2015, Canary Learning allows teachers to have all of their assignment details in one centralized spot – and allows them to grant access to students.

 

There are also native iOS and Chrome apps that allow educators and students to access a mobile-friendly version of the software. The best part? The individual teacher and student version are completely free. All of the synced changes are also available offline – which lends an equity of resources aspect for at-risk students who may not have the same internet access as peers.

So how does Canary Learning work exactly? First, it has two different experiences based on who is using it. A teacher, for example, has many more tools available for planning and grading while a student can only access his or her own classes and assignment details. The mobile versions of the software automatically sync anytime they are connected to Wi-Fi and the view is the same no matter what device is in use (mobile or PC). A teacher could create a lesson on his or her classroom desktop computer and then access it at home on a tablet and move items around. All of those changes save to the cloud and are visible on all devices immediately.

Teachers are shown a homework overview, like what you see below. Immediately they can see what homework they need to hand out, what homework they need to grade and what is overdue from students.

‘What we didn’t want was to make anything harder for kids or teachers,” Desiree Vogt, marketing communications for Canary Learning, said. “You don’t need to learn more than one version of this resource. It looks the same wherever you access it.”

For educators, the benefits of the Canary Learning cloud-based system go beyond the streamlining. There are collaborative elements that eliminate some steps when implemented among teachers. Teachers can share assignments with each other by granting access to each other. Each teacher can then tweak their own version of the assignment or exam without messing up the original. Those lesson materials are then saved in the system and can be tapped again the following year. Educators always have the option to edit the materials in their own profile meaning they never need to rewrite a class again.

“It’s sort of like reordering the scenes in a movie. Teachers can change the scenes individually, and move them around, without having to start over on the entire storyline,” Vogt said.

To sign up, visit Canarylearning.com to set up a free account. You can also use your Google sign-in to set it up more quickly.  For questions about the system or on implementation for schools and districts, contact Desiree Vogt at [email protected]. Follow @CanaryLearning on Twitter.

 

Read all of our posts about EdTech and Innovation by clicking here.