Uncategorized

Public vs. Private: What Education Is Right for Your Kids?

**The Edvocate is pleased to publish guest posts as way to fuel important conversations surrounding P-20 education in America. The opinions contained within guest posts are those of the authors and do not necessarily reflect the official opinion of The Edvocate or Dr. Matthew Lynch.**

A guest post by Anica Oaks

While there is a current push toward private education in many circles in today’s society, the reality is that there are many happy, well-rounded, and well-educated children from both private and public institutions. It really does come down to choosing what’s best for your child. However, that choice isn’t an easy one. As you weigh the decision of private versus public, it’s important that you consider the advantages of each as well as your child’s actual needs. You should also ask some important questions before making the decision so that you are fully informed.

Benefits of Public Education

The news is often touting the shortfalls of the public school system; however, it actually offers a number of benefits that you might not otherwise recognize. If you’re considering private versus public education, be sure to include these benefits in your deliberation:

  • More qualified teachers: Teachers in the public sector are more likely to have master’s degrees and to have spent more hours pursuing continuing education courses.
  • More time on core subjects: A national report found that students in public schools actually spend an additional three hours every week studying the core subjects of English, math, social studies, and science compared to their private school counterparts.
  • More diversity: Public schools are available to students of any race and socioeconomic status, which creates more diverse student population.

Advantages of Private Education

That being said, the private school system also offers a number of advantages to its student population. While you are likely more aware of many of the benefits of private education, it is still important to keep these in mind:

  • Smaller schools and class sizes: Statistics indicate that private schools on average are half as large as public schools. Just as schools are smaller, so are the class sizes, offering an average student-teacher ratio of 9:1 compared to 17:1 in public school classrooms.
  • Less bureaucracy: Private schools aren’t mandated by all of the state regulations that public systems are, which results in less bureaucracy.
  • High parent involvement: Parents who invest in private education typically have a strong say in their children’s educations, so private schools lend themselves to high parent involvement.

Finding the Best Fit for Your Child

It’s tempting to rely on what everyone else is saying about a school when you are making your decision. But, you truly need to focus on what is best for your child. Consider the options, which range from your typical brick and mortar public schools to more contemporary charter schools, and be sure to visit and ask questions to find what works best for your child.

As you make your decision, ask about the curriculum, student-teacher ratio, and even the school’s expectations for parents. Having all of this information up front will help you make an informed decision for your child.

Selecting the right school for your child is important. Take the time to consider the advantages of public and private options and ask questions to find the right fit for your child.

___

Anica is a professional content and copywriter who graduated from the University of San Francisco. She loves dogs, the ocean, and anything outdoor-related. She was raised in a big family, so she’s used to putting things to a vote. Also, cartwheels are her specialty. You can connect with Anica here.

Will Bernie Sanders’ college plan kill HBCUs?

Presidential hopeful Bernie Sanders wants to help students by giving them a free ride to college. Sanders’ plan calls for making public colleges and universities tuition free. It is, to him at least, a way to make American students the most educated in the world by making the way to college easier.

But some are criticizing Sanders for his plan because it would force states to pick up the extra tab; something that many states are struggling with currently. State legislatures have cut k-12 and higher education for years and don’t seem to be slowing down, even with improvements in the economy.

Another criticism being levied towards Sanders and his plan for college is that it will potentially destroy HBCUs. Representative James Clyburn (D-S.C.), who is supporting former Secretary of State Hillary Clinton for president, has taken issue with Sanders’ free college plan.

Talking to the press earlier this week, Clyburn said that private HBCUs will begin to shut down because states will start to offer free tuition to public colleges. He continued his hits on Senator Sanders by saying that nothing in life is free including college.

For what its worth, Clyburn said that he believes in making college more affordable for anyone who wants to attend, just not free.

Clyburn’s assessment of Sanders and his plan for college was devoid of what it will cost as he is attempting to bolster Clinton’s stock with black voters.

To the point of what it may cost to make college free, Sanders has said that he will have to raise taxes to pay for covering college tuition. He wants to place a larger tax on Wall Street speculators which is likely to be a tough sale.

But for what he’s at least attempting to do, it’s not a bad idea. Cost for college has spiraled out of control and many students have been priced out of even thinking of going to college. He’ll also have to deal with the potential consequences of what this may do to private colleges, including HBCUs.

Promethean Expands ClassFlow™ Capabilities for Teachers

Ready-to-teach lessons, enhanced collaboration tools, and reward badges among new features available for free

(ATLANTA, GA) February 25, 2016 – ClassFlow, an award-winning, free collaborative learning application from Promethean, today released a host of new resources and tools for teachers and students. ClassFlow helps teachers create interactive lessons and assignments that encourage the active participation of every student. The latest expansion includes thousands of ready-to-teach interactive lessons curated by experts, extended collaboration opportunities for students, free student accounts, and rewards to reinforce students’ positive behaviors.

“Teachers asked and we listened,” said Promethean’s CEO Jim Marshall. “We added the most-requested capabilities based on what our teacher users said would have the greatest impact for them and their students. Everything a teacher would do inside and beyond a classroom is now available for free. We also opened the door for parents to be more involved in their student’s learning through ClassFlow student accounts. As in any other educational endeavor, parents are one of the greatest driving forces behind student success.”

With the latest release, ClassFlow now offers:

Thousands of free, teacher-approved interactive lessons: The latest release of ClassFlow helps teachers get started quickly by offering thousands of free interactive lessons through the new ClassFlow Marketplace. New widgets and interactive content will be added weekly.

Free teacher and student accounts: Both teachers and students now have the option to create accounts to foster a deep level of collaborative learning. With the introduction of free student accounts in this version of ClassFlow, teachers can create assignments and assessments for students to complete independently or collaboratively in small groups—both inside and outside of class.

ClassFlow Desktop available at no cost: Teachers can now download ClassFlow Desktop for free. With ClassFlow Desktop, a native app for Windows® and Mac OS®, a teacher can capture anything displayed on his or her computer and share it with students as interactive lesson content.

Rewards for exemplary student behavior: ClassFlow now includes a rewards capability that enables teachers to send digital badges to students who display exemplary behaviors in class. Teachers can select a badge from the existing options or create customized rewards with unique messages and looks.

Collaborative lesson building: Students can now simultaneously build projects together as a team. They can also create lessons together, demonstrating mastery of concepts—an especially useful tool for flipped classrooms and blended learning environments.

“ClassFlow is designed to help teachers give amazing educational experiences personalized for each student’s unique needs,” said Marshall. “It unites the elements of pedagogy, technology and the learning space—what we call the Modern Classroom. When these three elements intersect, teachers operate with the efficiencies of technology, students are motivated to own their learning and continually improve, and students develop skills needed for work, higher education, and life in general.”

Teachers can experience the benefits of ClassFlow today by logging into their account or signing up at ClassFlow.com.

About Promethean

Promethean is a global education company that improves learning productivity by developing, integrating, and implementing innovative 21st-century learning environments that help make everyone more engaged, empowered, and successful. Promethean’s main corporate offices are located in Blackburn, UK, and Atlanta, USA. Promethean is a member of the NetDragon Websoft, Inc. (HKSE: 0777) group of companies.  For more information, please visit PrometheanWorld.com.

About NetDragon Websoft Inc.

NetDragon Websoft Inc. (HKSE: 0777) is a leading innovator and creative force in China’s mobile Internet industry. Established in 1999, NetDragon is a vertically integrated, cutting-edge R&D powerhouse with a highly successful track record which includes the development of flagship MMORPGs such as Eudemons Online and Conquer Online, China’s number one online gaming portal, 17173.com, and China’s most influential smartphone app store platform, 91 Wireless, which was sold to Baidu (NASDAQ:BIDU) in 2013 as the largest Internet M&A transaction in China at the time. Being China’s pioneer in overseas expansion, NetDragon also directly operates a number of game titles in over 10 languages internationally since 2003. In recent years, NetDragon has become a major player in global online and mobile learning space as it works to leverage its mobile Internet technologies and operational know-how to develop a game-changing learning ecosystem. For more information, please visit NetDragon.com.

Read all of our posts about EdTech and Innovation by clicking here. 

Alabama scientist proves need for more minorities in STEM

Dr. Hadiyah-Nicole Green is a physicist from St. Louis, Missouri who teaches physics at Tuskegee University. Earning her bachelor’s degree from Alabama A&M University and her master’s and Ph.D from the University of Alabama at Birmingham, Green is the living embodiment of what Historically Black Colleges and Universities (HBCU) are capable of producing.

But more than that, she finds herself in rarefied air. There are less than 100 black women physicists in the nation, and she’s one of them.

She was recently awarded a grant of more than $1 million to continue development of a new treatment for cancer. Instead of using radiation and chemotherapy to target and kill cancer cells, she cultivated a way to mark only the cancer cells in one’s body instead of the healthy ones that surround them.

Green did this using lasers.

She’s been advancing this proposed treatment for more than seven years, and the grant will allow her to continue to work on it.

Yet even with her success and potential breakthrough in finding a new treatment that’s safer for cancer patients than radiation, she’s still just one of less than 100.

Black women have a place in science–more specifically STEM (Science, Technology, Engineering, and Math education). Showcasing Green’s achievements and how she’s carving her own path in the field proves that we need more black women in the field.

But it’s hard, and not because black women lack intelligence, it is because we fail to give them the proper opportunities. By way of information provided by mic.com, there was a jump in the number of black women who received Ph.D’s in computer science from 2002 to 2012. The number went from eight to 16.

For white men in the same field, there was an increase from 198 to 436.

Those numbers aren’t much better in other areas of STEM and are only slightly improving.

To combat the problem, we have to continue to showcase the success of black women like Dr. Hadiyah-Nicole Green and the close to 100 others who are making a way in STEM.

It is at least one pathway to show little black girls that there is room for them in STEM.

Read all of our posts about EdTech and Innovation by clicking here. 

Harvard to offer free online classes to promote religious understanding

Making religion palatable isn’t easy but Harvard is going to give it a shot. Starting March 1st, professors from Harvard Divinity School and Wellesley College will host free online classes to better explain world religion and enrollment is open to the public.

Did I mention that the classes are free?

The classes are being offered to give depth and better understanding of different religions around the world, and to potentially make them more appetizing. But not for reasons of acceptance, more for compassion.

Because of geopolitical behavior in the Middle East and other parts of the world, many believe the instability is due to religion. Religious intolerance abounds — mainly as a result of those who describe factions of Islam as radical and apply it to the entire faith. There are misconceptions about other religions too, even mainstream ones in the U.S. like Christianity.

The courses will not only talk about the history of each faith, but what makes each distinct and complex.

 

Students of all ages, and mainly adults, should be encouraged to register for the free courses. During a presidential year where the history and point of Islam is being debated as if its the breakfast special at a local diner, the course on the topic of the Islamic faith is needed.

To combat that religious bigotry, Harvard is will present courses on five different faiths including Buddhism, Hinduism, Judaism, Islam, and Christianity.

Each class will run four weeks and the first one will start March 1st. For more information on each course, or to register, visit courses.edx.org. The courses are being offered through edX, an online learning tool developed by Harvard University and Massachusetts Institute of Technology (MIT).

Why BMI is not a smart health measurement for teachers

**The Edvocate is pleased to publish guest posts as way to fuel important conversations surrounding P-20 education in America. The opinions contained within guest posts are those of the authors and do not necessarily reflect the official opinion of The Edvocate or Dr. Matthew Lynch.**

Guest post by Rick Osbourne

Anyone familiar with Operation Pull Your Own Weight already knows we contend that using BMI as the measurement tool of choice represents a major obstacle when it comes to making any progress on the ongoing obesity epidemic. I’ve personally railed against BMI on one too many occasions – particularly when it relates to kids.

But I recently received an email from a friend named Dr. Wayne Wescott of Quincy College in Quincy, MA which made the case against BMI when used on adults so eloquently that I thought our readers would find it compelling. Allow me to quote Dr. Wescott:

“Take for example a 65 year old male who has performed no resistance training and weighs the same 165 pounds that he did at age 25. Of course his BMI would be the same and his physician would say that he’s in great shape. However, his body composition has actually changed by at least 50 pounds (25 pounds less muscle – at 6 pounds/decade reduction rate from sarcopenia – and 25 pounds more fat).”

Let’s dig into this example a little deeper just for fun. Let’s say this male teacher’s percentage of body fat was 20% back when he was 25 years old. That means 33 of his 165 pounds of body weight was made up of fat back then (165 lbs. X .20 = 33 lbs.). So he’s in pretty good shape.

Four Decades Later…
Now as Wescott suggests, let’s flip the calendar ahead forty years and see that this teacher’s body weight is still the same 165 pounds. And his height is also the same. That means his BMI will be exactly the same at age 65 as it was when he was age 25. No change at all!

But now we learn that this gent has done no resistance training during those four decades. This means he’s lost a bunch of muscle mass (approximately 25 pounds, at six pounds per decade due to sarcopenia). In order to weigh the same 165 pounds he’s replaced the lost 25 pounds of muscle mass with 25 pounds of body fat. That’s the only possibility.

That means at age 65 this gent now carries 58 pounds of body fat instead of the original 33 pounds of body fat (33 + 25 = 58). Since his body weight remains exactly the same, 165 pounds, his actual percentage of body fat has now ballooned from the original 20% to over 35% (58/165 = 35%). In other words, he’s actually gone from being in pretty good shape at age 25, to being OBESE (30% body fat or higher) at age 65…despite what his BMI indicates.

A HUGE Discrepancy!

Let me say it this way. That’s no small discrepancy! That’s a huge discrepancy!! This guy is now carrying 25 MORE POUNDS OF BODY FAT and he has 25 FEWER POUNDS OF MUSCLE MASS (horsepower) with which to carry it. To make matters even worse, this 25 pounds of muscle mass loss has caused his metabolism (his ability to burn calories) to drop like a rock. That means in order to maintain his 165 pounds, he can’t eat as much as he used to eat.

Is it any wonder this guy can no longer get up and down a flight of stairs the way he could when he was 25? He can’t run, jump, climb, or do anything with the same efficiency as he was able to do forty years ago. Yet BMI DETECTS NO DIFFERENCE AT ALL!!! *

The big question in the minds of many of us non-bureaucrats out here on Main Street is how in the world can anyone expect to make any progress on the obesity epidemic if the powers that be continue to endorse a measurement tool that’s unable to distinguish ten pounds of body fat from ten pounds of muscle mass from ten pounds of dog food, or bubble gum?

You may as well attempt to play the Super Bowl without any yard lines on the field, and a game clock that doesn’t work. If we’re unable to measure changes accurately and we continue to do nothing about it, why don’t we just confess out loud that we really don’t give a damn about beating the obesity epidemic? After all, many major corporations are making boatloads of profit because of the epidemic. And the bottom line after all…is the bottom line.

*There is a cost effective alternative known as a FORE Score (Functional Obesity Risk Evaluation Score) in case anyone is actually interested in accurate body comp measurement without breaking the bank.

**UCLA recently published a longitudinal study of over 40,000 people which is described by its author, Dr. Janet Tomiyama as “The final nail in the coffin of BMI.” This development certainly represents a step in the right direction.

_____

Rick Osbourne is a former physical educator and a pioneer in the field of functional childhood obesity prevention. He currently serves as President of the Pull Your Own Weight Foundation which is an Illinois based, 501c3, not for profit organization whose focus is functional childhood obesity prevention. He’s written and published three books in this field, the latest of which is entitled Beating Childhood Obesity Now: A Simple Solution for Parents and Educators. He’s the Examiner’s national childhood obesity prevention correspondent. He writes an online column for The Edvocate. And you can connect with Rick via Twitter, Linkedin, or Facebook.

4 Tips for Creative Writing in Class

**The Edvocate is pleased to publish guest posts as way to fuel important conversations surrounding P-20 education in America. The opinions contained within guest posts are those of the authors and do not necessarily reflect the official opinion of The Edvocate or Dr. Matthew Lynch.**

A guest post by Michael Yarbrough

What it’s like to be a teacher? You present new material to students, keep track of their academic progress, and manage their behavior in the classroom. If that’s all you did, you might be considered a good teacher. But if you want to be a great teacher, you have to add something to that list: inspiring students to be creative. When it comes to writing instructors, this is an especially important thing to cultivate.

Creativity is the most essential thing for writing classes. Here students learn where to find new ideas, how to structure their story, what writing techniques to choose, and so on. Students certainly can learn all these things, but if they aren’t inspired, if they don’t see how you personally love writing with all your passion, they won’t learn to love it themselves.

The starting point for you to assist students in releasing their creativity is to show them your own love to writing. Teachers are models for their students, so it’s absolutely fine if students imitate their educator and treat writing the way their teachers do. In cases where the classroom environment is friendly and pleasant, and a teacher is a good mentor to every student, there’s a strong chance students will be happy to follow the example of their educator and adopt positive attitudes about writing.

Also, you should certainly let students know about great authors and their best works. Talk about what inspired famous writers, how they gained their writing success, what strange habits they had, how they treated writing, and many other interesting details. Always emphasize that students must not try to copy the writing manner or style of other authors. Each student must develop and cherish his or her own unique writing voice.

And of course, suggest that your students do a few helpful writing exercises. Choose any of the following:

Free Writing. Introduce your students to a topic and tell them they will free-write during some specific period of time (such as five minutes). Students are supposed to write without stops and without over-thinking – they write whatever is in their heads at the moment. They can disregard punctuation and spelling as well as storyline. They shouldn’t edit anything at the time, though you’ll have enough time to discuss their free-writing a bit later. This exercise is perfect as a writing warm-up, and you should do it at the beginning of the class.

Associations. Distribute sheets of paper among your students on which you have written a list of words. Their task is to write the first association that comes to mind for each one. Again, students mustn’t think about it at all, they should note immediately what image they see or whatever association pops into their minds. Since this exercise is good for increasing imagination and expanding vocabulary, use it at the beginning of the class as another warm-up that gets them ready to work.

Group Writing. Have your students write a story together. You will be the first to start. Jot down a thought provoking sentence and let your students continue the story. Each student contributes one sentence to the story. The rule is that every single sentence should move the plot forward. Finally, read your group writing aloud so students can enjoy the work they created together.

Role-playing. In this exercise your students get the chance to become fictional characters for a while. Your task is to choose characters for each student. Don’t take just protagonists or antagonists, use plenty of minor characters from well-known novels as well. Students need to describe some of the novel’s major events from the point of view of the character they take on. Thus, you will be able to see alternative points of view concerning events in the plot.

A few final tips: Don’t be afraid to experiment while teaching how to write, listen to the unique writing voices of your students, and don’t forget that if you love what you do, students will love it too.

________

Michael is a former school teacher, currently working as an ESL tutor. Teaching is his favorite way of finding inspiration. In spare time he enjoys volunteering and provides a lot help to wild and homeless animals. Connect with Michael via Twitter and Linkedin.

Reading Horizons Incorporates the Lexile® Framework for Reading in K-3 Literacy Platform

North Salt Lake, UT- Feb. 23, 2016 — Reading Horizons and MetaMetrics® are thrilled to announce the expansion of their partnership with the addition of Lexile® measures in the Reading Horizons Discovery™ program. Reading Horizons and MetaMetrics, developer of the widely adopted Lexile® Framework for Reading, first announced their partnership in May 2015 when Lexile measures launched in the Reading Horizons Elevate reading program.

Reading Horizons Discovery is a strategy-based reading solution designed for students in Kindergarten through third grade that incorporates multi-sensory, Orton-Gillingham principles of instruction and a unique marking system that delivers superior results. The effective, easy-to-use software utilizes the most current technology and instructional best practices to deliver assessments and skill-based lessons for each grade level, K-3. Initial assessments ensure that teachers have an accurate measure of each student’s ability and the software adapts to meet the needs and skill levels of those students and provides differentiation as they progress through the program.

The software includes formative assessments as well as vocabulary, games, and activities. Reading Horizons Discovery fulfills 92% of the standards for foundational reading skills for students in K-3, as well as other standards outlined by the Common Core State Standards, and is correlated to the findings of the National Reading Panel.

“We consistently strive to provide the most robust literacy solutions possible for our customers, including the ability to adjust instruction in order to meet readers where they are,” commented Reading Horizons’ President and CEO Tyson Smith. “Adding the Lexile® Framework for Reading in Reading Horizons Discovery immediately provides educators with yet another layer to truly assess where their students are at and how to best support their learning moving forward.”

The assessment’s initial Lexile measure serves as a benchmark for gauging both a student’s reading ability and the complexity of text so that appropriate reading materials can be matched to the student as they progress. Reading Horizons Discovery automatically unlocks reading passages in the software library as additional skills are mastered. Each book in the library has been measured by MetaMetrics and has an official Lexile level. 

“I applaud Reading Horizons for extending their use of Lexile measures to K-3,” stated Malbert Smith III, Ph.D., president and co-founder of MetaMetrics. “More than that, Reading Horizons is measuring their readers at the start of their academic career. This allows for early detection of struggling readers, and then immediate intervention to strengthen the reader’s ability before they fall too far behind their peers. The power of Lexile measures also allows educators to seamlessly track their students reading growth throughout their K-12 progression.”

About Reading Horizons

Founded in 1984, Reading Horizons provides teacher training, direct instruction materials, and interactive software that empower teachers to effectively teach beginning readers, intervene with struggling readers, and provide instruction and support to English Language Learners. To learn more about Reading Horizons, please visit them online at www.readinghorizons.com or follow them on twitter https://twitter.com/ReadingHorizons.

About MetaMetrics

MetaMetrics is focused on improving education for learners of all ages and ability levels. The organization develops scientific measures of academic, achievement, and complementary technologies that link assessment results with real-world instruction. To learn more about MetaMetrics, please visit them online at www.metametricsinc.com.

Read all of our posts about EdTech and Innovation by clicking here. 

Why music education needs to incorporate more diversity

Jacqueline Kelly-McHale, DePaul University

As presidential candidate Donald Trump continues to insist upon banning Muslims from entering the U.S. and espousing a need for a wall along the Mexican border, heating up anti-immigration and racist rhetoric, it’s essential we consider this: one in four students under the age of eight in the U.S. has an immigrant parent.

Classrooms are getting more diverse as the percentage of minority students increases. In the fall of 2014 there were more minority students in the the public education system. According to a report from the Pew Research Center, 50.3 percent of students in 2014 were minority, whereas 49.7 percent of all students were white. By 2022, 45.3 percent are projected to be white, and 54.7 percent are projected to be minority.

How can classrooms become more culturally responsive in their teaching practices in classrooms and foster respectful behavior?

As a music educator and music teacher educator focused on culturally responsive teaching, I believe a music classroom is an ideal place to begin. Music is an experience found across all cultures, and music classrooms are a logical place where difference and respect can be recognized, practiced and celebrated.

Music programs lack diversity

Music education programs in the high school setting typically bring to mind the images and sounds of bands, orchestras and choirs. In the elementary context, general music classes are viewed as places where children sing, dance, and play the recorder and other classroom instruments.

Each of these experiences is rooted in either a Western view of music that is focused on placement of Western classical music as the highest form of musical experience, or on methods of teaching that grew out of European music education practices.

In my research, I found that the reliance on a method of general music instruction within a classroom where the majority of the students were the children of Mexican immigrants resulted in a the creation of an inherent bias against the students’ culture and a sense of isolation for the students. This bias was the result of the the teacher’s views, which created an environment that did not support the integration of cultural, linguistic and popular music experiences.

This finding was supported by music education professor Regina Carlow, who found that when the cultural identity of students in a high school choir setting was not respected or even acknowledged, students developed a sense of isolation.

This isolation can result in an unfair learning environment.

Teachers lack diversity

So why don’t classrooms engage students in musical practices that are rooted in their cultural and musical backgrounds? The answer can be found in the traditions of American music education.

In 2011, music education researchers Carlos Abril and Kenneth Elpus found that 65.7 percent of music ensemble students were white and middle class; only 15.2 percent were black and 10.2 percent were Hispanic. These data demonstrate that white students are overrepresented in high school music ensembles. Students for whom English was not their native language accounted for only 9.6 percent of ensemble members.

The majority of teachers are white and middle-class.
Andy Bullock, CC BY

Additionally, Elpus found that the majority of music teachers – 86.02 percent – entering the profession were white and middle-class.

Adding to this reality is the fact that the process of becoming a music teacher is rooted in the Western classical tradition. Though the National Association of Schools of Music (NASM) does not stipulate a classical performance audition, it is required in a majority of cases.

Based on my experience as a music education professor, aspiring music teachers must pass a Western classical performance audition with an orchestral instrument, classical voice or classical guitar in order to even begin down the path of becoming a music educator, even though no school explicitly states that.

Given this, music education programs not only primarily reflect Western European classical music, but they also create a self-perpetuating cycle.

Start with understanding music

In fact, music curriculum can be an ideal place to start culturally responsive teaching. Music crosses cultures and is an experience that can be considered universal.

Education researcher Geneva Gay describes culturally responsive teaching as a practice that supports learning through and about other cultures.

This includes cultural values, traditions, communication, learning styles, contributions and how people relate. It is not just taking a week or month to study the folk music of Mexico. It is about building a curriculum that enables students to experience, discuss, and perform music that is culturally and socially relevant.

This happens when teachers draw on musical styles and genres that are varied. For example, learning to sing the folk song “Frog Went a Courtin’” based on its American variant, then comparing and contrasting it to the Flat Duo Jets’ rock version of the song.

In this regard, music education researcher Chee-Hoo Lum recommends that music teachers start with the students’ cultural and musical background in order to get them to better understand and interact with different musical experiences.

The cultural values and contributions of diverse musicians and genres provide the perfect avenue to explore and learn about the “other” in a classroom environment. Additionally, the chance to sing, play and listen to the music of other cultures creates an understanding that transcends personal experience, and creates a more global perspective.

Reimagine and reconfigure

This is not to say that we should forgo the current practices. Band, orchestra, and choir programs provide wonderful educational experiences for students throughout the country.

And these programs should continue.

However, there are other music programs that focus on guitar as a popular and folk instrument. Such as this one:

And there are programs that run rock bands within the school day. Then, there are programs where students learn to write songs, sample and compose. In addition, there are music education blogs that celebrate the many “other” ways that students learn about music, outside of band, orchestra and choir.

These programs can help us reimagine and reconfigure.

Building walls and excluding groups do not engender respect and democratic growth in our classrooms or in our political arenas. Rather, they foster fear and prevent equality and opportunity. Music classrooms can and should become the places where diversity is embraced and integrated.

The Conversation

Jacqueline Kelly-McHale, Associate Professor of Music Education, DePaul University

This article was originally published on The Conversation. Read the original article.

Is your child taking a test? When is the right time?

Francesca Gino, Harvard Business School

Standardized tests have become the primary tool for determining a student’s academic ability. Legislators and administrators use test data to evaluate the effectiveness of schooling on children and create curriculum.

Their use is supported by two fundamental assumptions: that the tests do not have a bias, and that they accurately assess a student’s academic knowledge.

A typical standardized test assesses a student’s knowledge base in an academic domain, such as science, mathematics or reading. When taking a standardized test, it is assumed that the substance of the test and its administration will be the same for all takers. The tests are identical, with identical degrees of difficulty and identical grading methods.

Despite these goals in the creation of standardized tests, recent research I conducted in collaboration with Hans Henrik Sievertsen (of the Danish National Center for Social Research) and Marco Piovesan (of the University of Copenhagen) identifies one potential source of bias: the time at which students take the test.

Why timing matters

We used data from a context in which the timing of the test depends on the weekly class schedule and computer availability at the school. Thus, students and teachers do not choose when the test occurs: the test time depends on factors outside of their control. Though our data come from Denmark, the same conditions often exist in the case of tests in other countries across the globe.

But does the time of the day when students take the test make a difference in terms of their performance on the test? We thought it would.

After all, people’s ability to perform effectively on various tasks is not constant across the day but shows temporal variation. In fact, research has argued that individuals’ cognitive functioning (e.g., memory and attention) is at its peak at their optimal time of day and decreases substantially at their nonoptimal times. Others have suggested that time-of-day effects on performance depend on external factors that occur at particular times (e.g., meals) or vary depending on the nature of the task itself.

Students become increasingly fatigued as the day wears on. This affects test results.
CameliaTWU, CC BY-NC-ND

Given these various theories about how time of day affects performance, we had a unique opportunity to put these hypotheses to a test as we gained access to data on the full population of children in Danish public schools from 2010 to 2013.

As the day wears on, students (as we all do) become increasingly fatigued. So, we reasoned, “cognitive fatigue” (i.e., when the brain has to work harder to concentrate on tasks) can lead students to perform worse on tests taken later in the day and that breaks can recharge students’ energy.

So, “cognitive fatigue” negatively impacts test performance. But a break can counterbalance this negative effec. For example, during a break, children in school can have something to eat, relax, play with classmates or just have some fresh air. These activities recharge their energy.

How timing matters

Our results are consistent with these hypotheses.

To test whether our intuition was right, we linked two million standardized tests taken in Denmark by children between the age of eight and 15 with the time the test was administered.

In Denmark, these tests are computer-based: to test the students, teachers have to prebook a test session within the test period (which runs from January to April of each year). Therefore, the test time is determined by the availability of a computer room and students’ class schedules. And, in fact, our analysis confirms that students are allocated to different times randomly.

Our analyses led to three main findings: 1) The later in the day the time of the test is, the lower the performance on the test; 2) breaks cause a significant improvement in performance; 3) the effect of time of day and of breaks are not homogeneous – low-performing students are more affected by breaks (and also by the time of the day when the test is taken) than high-performing students.

Here is how to think more concretely about the size of our results:

We found that when the standardized test is taken an hour later in the day, it causes a deterioration in a student’s test score that corresponds to parents having about US$1,000 less in their household annual income or students going to school for 10 fewer days every year. A break causes an improvement in a student’s test score that corresponds to parents earning about $1,900 more in their household annual income or students going to school for 19 extra days every year.

We were able to identify these estimates based on additional analyses of our data that we conducted to better understand the impact of taking the standardized test later in the day to find concrete numbers to compare our effects to.

The effect sizes may seem small, as these estimates suggest, but they are quite sizable compared to the influence of individual characteristics on students’ test performance and the implications of these findings.

When’s the right time?

In reading about these results, one may be tempted to interpret them as evidence that the start time of the school day should change to later thus allowing students to sleep in – a topic that is currently debated quite often in the United States among other places.

Results are better if students are allowed to sleep in.
Alberto G., CC BY

One may reach this conclusion since, by starting the school day later and getting some more sleep (which is well-known) to be a way to restore one’s mental energy), students may be able to perform better on their tests and other school activities throughout the day.

Our results should also not be interpreted to say that schools tests should be administered earlier in the day.

Rather, the message of this research for policy-making is twofold.

First, when policymakers or schools administrators make decisions regarding the length of the school day and the frequency and duration of breaks, “cognitive fatigue” should be taken into careful consideration. Longer school days can be justified, our research suggests, as long as they include an appropriate number of breaks. Second, it is important for school accountability systems to control for the influence of external factors on test scores.

We rarely ask the question of whether it is the right time to take a test. But, our research suggests, this may be an important question to ask going forward given that, as the day wears on, students (like all of us) become increasingly fatigued and consequently more likely to underperform on a standardized test.

The Conversation

Francesca Gino, Professor of Business Administration, Harvard Business School

This article was originally published on The Conversation. Read the original article.