Uncategorized

Are for-profit colleges in trouble?

Two for-profit higher-education institutions have announced the closing of multiple campuses nationwide. The Education Management Corporation and the Career Education Corporation will shutter the doors of more than 25 campuses across the country.

The Art Institute, Sanford-Brown College, Sanford-Brown Institute, and maybe soon, Le Cordon Bleu culinary school, are all set to close soon.

According to the Chronicle.com, the Art Institute has almost 5,500 students enrolled and the shutdown process will likely take three years.

All students impacted will have the choice of remaining enrolled in an effort to graduate prior to the schools closure or transfer to another college.

Due to massive debt, both corporations can no longer afford to keep many schools open and have been forced to layoff employees.

The for-profit college industry has received biting criticism lately. Earlier this year Corinthian shut its doors due to heavy fines and probes from the federal government. Everest College, maybe its most popular campus, is included under the Corinthian umbrella as well as Heald and WyoTech.

Students from Corinthian are in the process of fighting the United States Department of Education to have their student loan debt wiped away.

That process just got a little tougher as Corinthian has filed for bankruptcy protection, so if the students, or the Corinthian 100, plan to sue for debt forgiveness, Corinthian’s bankruptcy protection filing would potentially shield them from being held liable for the students debt.

This news of more for-profit colleges closing will hopefully spring Congress into action regarding how these institutions operate. Corinthian received nearly 90 percent of its revenue from federal student loans because tuition to attend these schools was astronomical.

Because student loan debt has become so burdensome, individuals are having to defer large purchases like a home or car. Any student who attends a for-profit institution and the school decides to shut down, those students should have their loan contracts reviewed with the real possibility of having their entire debt forgiven.

Pull Your Own Weight: FORE Score and accurate body composition feedback

**The Edvocate is pleased to publish guest posts as way to fuel important conversations surrounding P-20 education in America. The opinions contained within guest posts are those of the authors and do not necessarily reflect the official opinion of The Edvocate or Dr. Matthew Lynch.**

A column by Rick Osbourne

When it comes to body composition changes there are six possible scenarios including:
1. A person can gain body fat (body comp deteriorates)
2. A person can lose body fat (body comp improves)
3. A person can gain muscle mass (body comp improves)
4. A person can lose muscle mass (body comp deteriorates)
5. A person can replace body fat with muscle mass (body comp improves)
6. A person can replace muscle mass with body fat (body comp deteriorates)

A Huge Problem Created
Of these six scenarios, BMI (Body Mass Index)* is accurate ONLY WHEN MUSCLE MASS REMAINS UNCHANGED. That is to say, because it treats all weight as body fat, BMI is accurate only 33% of the time (scenarios 1 and 2) while it’s INACCURATE 66% of the time (scenarios 3 thru 6). This presents a huge problem for anyone requiring accurate feedback in body composition change, which is all that matters in obesity related issues.**

A Huge Problem Resolved
By contrast, ALL activities in which a participant’s own body weight is the primary resistance factor (including running, jumping, skipping, hopping, climbing, crawling, etc.) accurately reflect changes in body composition through changes in functional performance.

For example, lose body fat, gain muscle mass, or replace body fat with muscle mass (body comp improvements) and your running performance automatically improves. On the other hand, gain body fat, lose muscle mass, or replace muscle mass with body fat (body comp deterioration) and your running performance automatically deteriorates. Mother Nature built us this way.

Pull Ups Qualify
Now, since they use a person’s own body weight as the primary resistance factor, conventional pull ups, as well as modified leg-assisted pull ups accurately reflect changes in body composition through changes in functional performance. Thus when body comp improves, pull up performance improves. When body comp deteriorates, pull up performance deteriorates.

So instead of being accurate 33% of the time, both conventional and leg-assisted pull ups yield accurate body composition feedback 100% of the time making them THREE TIMES AS ACCURATE AS BMI.

Introducing FORE Score
With that said, a new concept called a FORE (Functional Obesity Risk Evaluation) Score uses conventional pull ups as well as leg assisted pull ups in order to give doctors, nurses, educators, and parents a practical and an affordable tool with which to ACCURATELY measure and document changes in body composition. Implementation costs and time are the same as BMI, but as we said previously, the accuracy of a FORE Score is three times better.***

Meaningful and Motivating
It’s also simple enough that even kids understand WHAT they’re doing, WHY they’re doing it, and HOW to generate positive changes in their FORE Score. In other words, an abstract and meaningless BMI score is suddenly made understandable and meaningful when it’s replaced by a FORE Score.

The feedback on body comp changes is also frequent (i.e. weekly), continual (for weeks and months), and tangible, all of which cultivates and encourages motivational momentum, the single most important factor when it comes to childhood obesity prevention and rehabilitation. To learn more about FORE Score check out this link.

 

*The US Center for Disease Control’s endorsement of BMI is one gigantic roadblock in the ongoing efforts to reduce the obesity epidemic.

** The bureaucrat’s response to BMI’s well known accuracy problem is, “Yes, BMI is invalid for individuals. But for mass measurement purposes, BMI is valid.” The logical reply to that contention is, “If it’s invalid for one individual, how does it suddenly become valid for ten thousand individuals? Doesn’t that just exacerbate an already confusing issue?”

***Let’s also point out that, by refining one’s mechanical technique (practice), functional performance can improve without body comp improving. But this factor only adds to the motivational virtues of this highly practical orientation to obesity prevention and rehab.

___

Rick Osbourne is a former physical educator and a pioneer in the field of functional childhood obesity prevention. He currently serves as President of the Pull Your Own Weight Foundation which is an Illinois based, 501c3, not for profit organization whose focus is functional childhood obesity prevention. He’s written and published three books in this field, the latest of which is entitled Beating Childhood Obesity Now: A Simple Solution for Parents and Educators. He’s the Examiner’s national childhood obesity prevention correspondent. He writes an online column for The Edvocate. And you can connect with Rick via Twitter, Linkedin, or Facebook.

 

 

Why we should teach our students digital marketing skills

**The Edvocate is pleased to publish guest posts as way to fuel important conversations surrounding P-20 education in America. The opinions contained within guest posts are those of the authors and do not necessarily reflect the official opinion of The Edvocate or Dr. Matthew Lynch.**

A guest post by David Cutler

“It is time for schools to stop blocking Facebook, Twitter, Instagram, and other social networks that students love and already use daily outside of school.”

So writes Mark Barnes in his book, Teaching the iStudent: A Quick Guide to Using Mobile Devices and Social Media in the K-12 Classroom. Ad nauseam, schools advertise how they use technology to prepare kids to excel in an increasingly global 21st century, as if no other school is doing the same thing. Meanwhile, too few schools teach students how to make effective use of not just Facebook and Twitter, but also other popular online tools, instead preferring teacher-friendly alternatives that few use in the real world.

It may be true that plenty of students know how to create digital media, but too few know how to produce high-quality content, the kind that makes them stick out to not only college admission officers, but also potential employers. If you think “marketing” is a dirty word, and that educators have no business teaching students how to do this, you need to reconsider your role. We need to teach and encourage students to post original, quality content to brand their unique identities in a sea of increasingly indistinguishable resumes—which are going the way of the typewriter.

In fact, right now I’m teaching my freshman European history students how to create and maintain a WordPress site. Throughout the year, they will post their thoughts and creative responses. Moreover, students will learn to feel more comfortable sharing their work, crucial for successful collaboration in the digital age. As a next step, students will register for a Twitter handle, to be used for sharing and discussing topics related to European history. If they choose, Tweets can be embedded on their sites.

When it comes down to it, I do more than just teach history. I encourage students to use evolving digital skills to explore, develop, and express their own passions and interests. Of course, I’m fortunate to work at a wonderful school, whose ace technology department allows and fosters digital creativity.

I recently spoke with Barnes, curious to hear his thoughts. Not surprisingly, he agrees, adding that WordPress is the most powerful blogging platform in the world. “I always say…make sure that you give them the opportunity to do some niche-blogging, too, because ultimately, that’s what they’re going to do,” Barnes says. “That’s what we do. Our niche is education—we tend to write about education. Who knows what theirs is going to be, but they’re going to be creating content that’s going to be really important. I think teaching them at a young age how to do that effectively is really important.”

For the most part, I’ve found that when students share their work online, the quality of that work improves. I noticed as much in 2011, when I helped students launch The Falconer, the student news site of Palmer Trinity, a terrific private school in Palmetto Bay, Florida. Before submitting stories to me, students carefully reviewed each other’s work. Once their stories were posted, students felt even more excited about receiving feedback, not just from the class, but also from the wider school community.

More than anything else, I think, student excitement for online sharing stems from wanting to make a difference and having their voices heard. Nothing fulfills that yearning quite like the Internet, which allows students to use not just writing, but also photographs, audio, and video to tell stories that can elicit an immediate response and make an immediate impact.

Barnes tells me of one former student who blogged about Google Glass before the invention took off. “Here’s a kid, 12- or 13-years-old, and he writes this amazing post and does his own review of it, and includes pictures and outside links. It was just, you can comment on anything you want,” he says. “He wound up getting…150 or 170 comments on this one post. People were coming to him like he was the expert. It was such a great opportunity to share that with kids across all my classes and just say, ‘This is what writing and curating content is really about. You become an expert at something, and people come to you.’”

Last week, I also spoke with Eric Sheninger, whose courageous book, Digital Leadership: Changing Paradigms for Changing Times, echoes much of what Barnes and I believe so strongly in promoting. I asked Sheninger how best to serve students in the digital age, and his response leaves little to the imagination. “Adapting and evolving with the times and worrying more about learning than numbers,” he says. “When you focus more on learning, everything else falls into place.”

In that vein, more schools must develop the courage to teach how to leave behind a positive digital footprint.

This post originally appeared on spin.edu, and was republished with permission.

Read all of our posts about EdTech and Innovation by clicking here. 

____________________

David Cutler is a coach, history and journalism teacher at Brimmer and May, an independent school in Chestnut Hill, Massachusetts. He is the founder of Spin Education.

Infograph: How to stop procrastinating and deal with exam stress

Infograph provided by StopProcrastinatingapp.com

It’s that time of year when students are in the midst of cramming for final exams. Trying to recall all that you have learned over the past year is only half the battle. New research from productivity website  Stop Procrastinating has found that 64% of students believe that exam stress and anxiety is affecting them so much that it will lower their performance and affect their grades.

The poll of 2,000 undergraduates heading into their final exams found that 66% of students believe their stress levels are greater than in the past due to modern day problems, such as the difficult jobs market. They cited stress over the ways a lower grade could affect the rest of their lives, closing doors to opportunities and missing out on jobs.

The survey found that procrastination was a major cause of stress. Students today have more opportunities for distraction with the rise of the internet, smart phones and social media. Forty-five percent said they wasted time on the internet or social media instead of studying.

There is good news, however. The survey also found the strategies and solutions that students find most effective. From using an internet blocker when revising, to taking more exercise or breaking down studying into bite sized-chunks, students are finding ways to cope and succeed.

The full survey and effective strategies can be viewed below in the Exam Stress Infographic, or viewed online at www.stopprocrastinatingapp.com/exam-stress.

 

Exam Stress

Charter schools aren’t necessarily better than traditional public schools

**The Edvocate is pleased to publish guest posts as way to fuel important conversations surrounding P-20 education in America. The opinions contained within guest posts are those of the authors and do not necessarily reflect the official opinion of The Edvocate or Dr. Matthew Lynch.**

By Anthony Owens

Evidence on how well charter schools are working to solve perceived problems in traditional public schools is mixed and still coming in. Nevertheless, beginning in the Fall of 2014, all New Orleans public school students began attending a charter school, as a major US city does away with all traditional public schools for the first time.

Charter schools are free, public schools contracted to run with greater autonomy over what they teach and how they teach than traditional public schools. In theory, the charter school model encourages flexibility in the use of innovative curricula and teaching approaches to improve student learning and graduation rates.

That increased autonomy comes by freeing schools and their administrators from the allegedly restrictive and harmful demands of teachers’ unions (read teachers) and elected school boards (read the public), two groups of stakeholders long vilified as the causes of a perceived mass failure of public education.

Some early data from the New Orleans experiment suggests that the city’s post-Katrina lover’s embrace of charter schooling and rejection of school turnaround (school improvement) is paying off. For example, nearly 80 percent of the high school class of 2012 graduated on time, versus a graduation rate of only 54 percent for the class of 2004, reported Stacy Teicher Khadaroo, education reporter for the Christian Science Monitor.

Some of those new charter schools, such as the Sci Academy in Eastern New Orleans, have respectable goals and seem to have found innovative ways of achieving them. For example, all Sci Academy staff has the authority to enforce disciplinary policies, even in the hallways.

Further, students at the high school enjoy an increasing amount of academic freedom that, by the senior year, is said to closely model the typical university learning community. One student’s senior project involved, for example, petitioning his public defender’s office to take specific steps to reduce the negative impacts of imprisonment on juvenile defenders who were wrongly convicted, reported Khadaroo.

Supports such as increased funding, stricter discipline policies and enforcement, and psychological counseling for troubled students appear to have helped many of those New Orleans charter school students. But what might have happened at the traditional New Orleans public schools that the charters replaced had those older schools tried similar innovative approaches to learning and discipline and received the same additional resources?

“You have the same children in the [charter] school … What’s going to be the difference? Put in the services that are going to make the [traditional public school] better,” protested Tanya King, the concerned grandmother of a former student of a now closed New York City traditional public school.

Indeed, 2012 data collected by Daily News on former New York Mayor Michael Blooomberg’s pioneering close-and-replace experiment seems to rebut increasingly shrill claims that charter schools necessarily lead to better outcomes for students.

The take away is this: whether they be charter, traditional public or private schools, great schools share similar traits, according to the 2007 book by Karin Chenoweth entitled “It’s Being Done: Academic Success in Unexpected Schools.” Chenoweth, a writer-in-residence at The Education Trust, found that successful schools and districts, even those serving many at-risk students, such as Union City Public Schools in New Jersey, do many things right. In part, great schools promote teacher collaboration and innovation and emphasize reading, vocabulary development and math over teaching to state tests.

Hence, the belief that charter schools are always superior to traditional public schools is more of an ideological tenet than a scientific finding.

_____

Anthony Owens is a freelance writer whose online articles on topics in education have appeared in Global Post, Seattle PI, E-How, and Examiner. Formerly he taught language arts and literature at secondary and post-secondary institutions, and he currently works full-time for the State of Maryland’s Department of Human Resources. He holds a Master of Education in instruction and learning from the University of Pittsburgh and a Master of Fine Arts in literature and creative writing from Bennington College in Vermont.

 

How Common Core levels the K-12 playing field

By Matthew Lynch

Inequality of resources and opportunities for American K-12 children runs rampant and effects every member of society. When children are not given basic access to the same education as their peers, the country cannot progress the way it should.  One way that access can be assured is through federally-encouraged programs like Common Core Standards.

Developed by state governors, Common Core Standards are about creating a baseline of knowledge and skills that translates across all states in the nation. It is NOT about forcing children to all study the same curriculum or to be expected to learn the exact same ways.

The Committee for Economic Development, or CED, has put together a great short video (just about 3 minutes long) that explains exactly WHAT Common Core is meant to achieve. It also delves into some of the misnomers that surround this hotly-debated educational initiative. Take a look:

There is a reason why an economic organization would be so supportive of Common Core initiatives. There is clearly a belief that Common Core WILL make a difference when it comes to our future workforce and that matters NOW — not in another 20 years when we realize that the previous generation of K-12 students was not adequately prepped for the global workforce. There are a lot of educators who support Common Core initiatives but I think its vastly important that supporting groups, like the CED, speak up to its merits as well. It truly does take a village to raise and educate our nation’s youth. That’s the only way our kids will be able to compete, and succeed, in the global job market.

You can read the rest of my commentary on the CED video series here. 

Check out:

Why the business community cares about Common Core Standards

A look at how strong educational standards help the U.S. economy

Education reform in New Orleans may serve white interests and not African Americans

**The Edvocate is pleased to publish guest posts as way to fuel important conversations surrounding P-20 education in America. The opinions contained within guest posts are those of the authors and do not necessarily reflect the official opinion of The Edvocate or Dr. Matthew Lynch.**

By Derek Black

Adrienne Dixson (University of Illinois), Kristen Buras (Georgia St.), and Elizabeth K. Jeffers (Georgia St.) have released the paper, The Color of Reform: Race, Education Reform, and Charter Schools in Post-Katrina New Orleans, 21 (3) Qualitative Inquiry (2015).  They argue that

By most media accounts, education reform in post-Katrina New Orleans is a success. Test scores and graduation rates are up, and students once trapped in failing schools have their choice of charter schools throughout the city. But that’s only what education reform looks like from the perspective of New Orleans’ white minority — the policymakers, school administrators and venture philanthropists orchestrating and profiting from these changes. . .

From the perspectives of black students, parents and educators — who have had no voice in the decision-making, and who have lost beloved neighborhood schools and jobs — education reform in New Orleans has exacerbated economic and cultural inequities.

Get a summary of their research here and the full article here.

___

Derek Black is a Professor of Law at the University of South Carolina School of Law. His areas of expertise include education law and policy, constitutional law, civil rights, evidence, and torts. The focus of his current scholarship is the intersection of constitutional law and public education, particularly as it pertains to educational equality and fairness for disadvantaged students. His earlier work focused more heavily on intentional discrimination standards. His articles have been published in the California Law Review, Vanderbilt Law Review, Minnesota Law Review, Boston University Law Review, William & Mary Law Review, Boston College Law Review, and North Carolina Law Review, among various others. His work has also been cited in the U.S. Circuit Courts of Appeals and by several briefs before the U.S. Supreme Court.

 

Why the business community cares about Common Core Standards

By Matthew Lynch

In the education community’s frantic pace to stay accountable with each other and the government, I think some other aspects of our society get inadvertently left out of the education process. The business community is one. If you think about it, business organizations SHOULD be very concerned with the quality of education in our schools, starting as young as preschool and stretching through the college process. These students are, after all, our future workers and the drivers of the American economy.

That’s why I’ve really enjoyed a new video series put together by the Committee for Economic Development that emphasizes the importance of educational standards, like Common Core, on America’s future economy. Education and business, the videos argue, are forever intertwined and should rely on each other for success. Spend a few minutes watching this particular video on “Education Through the Lens of Business.”

What is being taught in our schools today matters to the business community and it should. I’ve heard the argument that teaching our kids in a way that prepares them for the competitive global workforce is treating them as “commodities” and not like children. I suppose there would be some merit to that if science hadn’t proven time and time again that kids thrive in learning environments and that the economic status of your life impacts its quality immensely. Setting our kids up to succeed economically on the world stage not only benefits our nation as a whole, but provides those kids with lifelong skills that will elevate their own quality of life through adulthood.

I look forward to seeing more initiatives like this one in the business community. You can view the rest of my commentary on the CED video series here.

Check out:

How Common Core levels the educational playing field

A look at how strong educational standards help the U.S. economy

Pull Your Own Weight: Functional childhood obesity prevention and rehabilitation – A practical definition

**The Edvocate is pleased to publish guest posts as way to fuel important conversations surrounding P-20 education in America. The opinions contained within guest posts are those of the authors and do not necessarily reflect the official opinion of The Edvocate or Dr. Matthew Lynch.**

A column by Rick Osbourne

Instead of addressing childhood obesity in the conventional ways (as a nutritional, physiological, psychological, socio-economic, or an environmental issue – all of which have their own validity), the functional childhood obesity prevention and rehabilitation specialist addresses childhood obesity as a functional disability, no different than a torn rotator cuff, or a case of planter fasciitis. In these instances the injury/condition hinders or prevents its victims from functioning in ways they otherwise could if it were not for the injury/condition.

A torn rotator cuff for example, hinders or prevents (depending on the severity) a person from climbing or throwing in ways they otherwise could without the injury. Planter fasciitis hinders or prevents a person from walking, running, jumping, or skipping in ways they otherwise could without the injury. By the same token, excess body fat (depending on the severity) hinders or prevents a person from walking, running, jumping, skipping, climbing, crawling, or even getting in and out of an easy chair in ways they otherwise could without the excess body fat.

Directly Addressing Kids’ Functional Ability

In all three instances, directly addressing and gradually improving a participant’s functional ability over time effectively reduces and/or hopefully eliminates the problem, the injury, the functional disability. One simple example of treating obesity as a functional disability begins with the common knowledge that children (and adults) who can perform at least one conventional pull up are almost never obese.*

That being the case, giving participants regular access to a set of height adjustable pull up straps (a.k.a. suspension training straps) and a technique called leg assisted pull ups (jumping and pulling at the same time) allows anyone a place to begin successfully, as well as the way to make frequent, highly-motivating progress.

So, from a relatively easy starting point the grips are gradually raised (one inch every other week) over time, until participants finally run out of leg assistance and they’re able to perform conventional pull ups. Once achieved, simply maintaining the ability (which requires decent eating and exercise habits along with 30 seconds/week to practice) means they’ve armed themselves against obesity, and a myriad of related problems that follow in its wake, for life.

Prevention versus Rehab

With those who are not yet obese (over 90% of elementary school age children), but who may fall victim to obesity in the future (33% of adults are currently obese), there’s no need to alter their eating or exercise habits. At this preventative stage all they need is access to the above mentioned equipment and technique and most will not only master pull ups within a matter of months, but they’ll understand it and be motivated by the process of growing stronger (being strong is always cool, while being weak is always uncool) along with their friends.

If they’re among the 10% who currently suffer from obesity (the rehab phase) THEY WILL HAVE TO IMPROVE THEIR EATING AND EXERCISE HABITS in order to develop the ability to do conventional pull ups. But, once they understand that developing the ability to do even one single pull up eliminates perhaps the biggest problem in their young lives, they can become motivated enough to make the necessary changes (of their own accord) in order to achieve this goal. Its simplicity and its ability to cultivate kids’ natural, intrinsic motivation (no carrots or sticks, no positive or negative reinforcements are necessary) is the functional approach’s strongest suit.

*The same strategy works using parallel bar dips, handstand push-ups, or rope climbing, etc.

___

Rick Osbourne is former physical educator and a pioneer in the field of functional childhood obesity prevention. He currently serves as President of the Pull Your Own Weight Foundation which is an Illinois based, 501c3, not for profit organization whose focus is functional childhood obesity prevention. He’s written and published three books in this field, the latest of which is entitled Beating Childhood Obesity Now: A Simple Solution for Parents and Educators. He’s the Examiner’s national childhood obesity prevention correspondent. He writes an online column for The Edvocate. And you can connect with Rick via Twitter, Linkedin, or Facebook.

School Community Collaboration and Peer Observation as Levers to Student Success

A guest post by Mark D. Benigni, Ed.D., Thomas W. Giard III, and David Levenduski

Meriden Public Schools, Connecticut

We are in an unprecedented era of accountability, a new teacher evaluation and development system, the Common Core State Standards, Smarter Balance Assessments and increased scrutiny from big business, the press and public. Our public schools face decreasing financial resources and additional federal and state mandates. Therefore, creating opportunities for our educators to work together in meaningful ways needs to be a priority for every district. School districts must create systems that encourage our educators to observe, reflect, collaborate, and enhance their instruction.

In Meriden, our deliberate and thoughtful steps to promote peer collaboration at the district and school levels has been a five year journey working with our teachers’ union to design and implement true teacher support programs. Together, union and management are breaking down the barriers that have isolated educators from their colleagues and peers. We first developed a comprehensive approach at the district level to begin having teachers spend time in each others’ classes as a strategy towards instructional improvement. The development and implementation of three distinct programs took shape: our Peer Coaching Program, our Learning Walks Program, and our Meriden Teachers Sharing Success Team.

Peer Coaching Program

Our peer coaching program provides educators with an opportunity to observe other educators in action. The premise of our program is that our best teachers are our best teachers and that educators can help educators improve student learning. The major roles of a peer coach are to collaborate, provide beneficial feedback, share effective teaching strategies, and reflect on teaching and learning. Peer coaches are matched with peers by grade level or content area with someone outside their building. Peer coaches receive training from the National School Reform Faculty and use an established protocol to share honest and open feedback with their peer coach and to guide their reflections regarding what they learn from each other.

The program expectations include peer coaches spending a minimum of one full day in the peer’s classroom. While the minimum is one day in the peer’s classroom, many do more and many have formed lasting professional relationships that continue long after the one year in the formal peer coaching program. Over the last five years, we have sent a clear message to the teachers that this is important work and vital to their own growth as an educator.

Learning Walks Program

Three years ago the district launched a learning walks program in all twelve schools. The learning walks program involves having teams of teachers, with an administrator, observe classroom instruction in their own building using an evidence-based protocol for data collection and debriefing. We collaborated with The Connecticut Center for School Change to develop a model, based on instructional rounds, which could be adapted to the building level and inclusive of teacher teams as opposed to simply teams of administrators. Two teams of four to five teachers visit up to six classrooms for about 15-20 minutes each, using a descriptive evidence data collection strategy. The classroom visitations are centered on a problem of practice or focus area and teachers are there to observe teacher and student actions. Teachers use data collection sheets that ask them to observe within the context of these three questions: What is the teacher saying and doing and to whom? What are the students saying and doing and to whom? What is the content/task? These data-gathering questions are used in a comprehensive debrief process of the classroom observations. Data is shared as common instructional patterns observed, not individual teacher critiques.

Our teachers constantly tell us that the learning walks debrief is an exceptional professional development experience. The debrief is a three-step process. It starts with an individual debrief where the teachers review their classroom evidence in the context of the focus area and select key pieces of evidence from each of the rooms visited. Evidence may only contain what they actually saw occurring in the classroom and cannot include any judgment or assumptions. Teacher names are not used. The second step of the debrief process entails having teachers share their evidence with their team and evidence is organized into patterns by the two respective teams.

The third step in the debrief process is each team reports out to the whole group and evidence is discussed, challenged, and reflected upon by all teachers in attendance. The whole group then answers three questions that will be shared with the faculty at a future meeting. The questions answered by the teachers are: What did your group observe as strengths? What did your group observe as possible areas for growth for our school? What questions/suggestions can you pose that will help our school move instruction related to our focus area to the next level? Are their implications for future professional development? Any teachers observed on a learning walks day become part of the learning walks classroom visitation team next time. This process helps us promote an atmosphere and cycle of continuous improvement in our schools.

Meriden Teachers Sharing Success Team

As Meriden rolled out their new teacher evaluation and development process, a commitment was made to provide educators with additional development and growth opportunities. As a result, union and management created the Meriden Teachers Sharing Success Team (MTSS) to recognize our exemplary educators and to provide support and growth opportunities for teachers. MTSS team members are tenured Meriden Public School teachers who open their classrooms for peer visitations and avail themselves for discussion and reflection with their peers who visit.
At the elementary level, MTSS teachers are educators who have led their students to substantial student growth for four consecutive years. We have MTSS teachers at all grade levels from kindergarten through grade 5. At the secondary level, our major instructional focus has been on creating student-centered learning environments. Secondary MTSS teachers are teachers who are effectively implementing student-centered learning in their classrooms. These teachers are identified by their principals and are vetted by a group consisting of central office administration, teachers’ union leadership, and administrators’ union leadership. All MTSS teachers are trained by the National School Reform Faculty to assist their colleagues in their continual growth process.

Teachers can self-select to go observe an MTSS teacher or it might occur after a conversation with a coach or supervisor about how best to enhance their classroom instruction. Regardless of how a teacher decides to observe an MTSS teacher, all who take advantage of this program have shared that it has improved their instructional practice.

The School-Based Launch

Initial conversations: There are two words that can have a negative impact on educators, and leave any good idea or intention on the cutting room floor: initiative and mandate. In the dynamic world of education, initiatives and mandates are thrown at educators with the speed and fury of a tsunami. Wave after wave of expectations crash in from legislators, state departments, districts and administrators. If these initiatives and mandates are not carefully presented with connections to improvement in practice, they are doomed from the onset.

So the school principal presented the idea in a way that connected the practice to what was being implemented across the district, and explained how staff can improve and learn from each other. Prior to beginning to have teachers observing one another, every opportunity, from faculty meetings to data team meetings to individual conferences, were used to emphasize and highlight the importance of collaboration and sharing of best practices. Beyond data teams, the principal worked in conjunction with the staff to develop an intervention and enrichment system which increased opportunities to collaborate to plan instruction, and allowed teachers to share students and begin to blur the lines regarding who “owned” the students. Their own data was utilized to build confidence and exhibit the instructional strengths that were being cultivated within the school. Staff came to realize that they did not need to always look outside the school for professional development opportunities; the professional expertise was among them. These conversations built the foundation for the next stage; creating the system.

Creating the system: With the foundation laid to enable staff to increase collaboration, peer observations as a supportive tool for strengthening instructional practices was a natural extension of our efforts. The next step was to share the idea of utilizing an observation to connect a teacher who shows a strength in an area to a teacher who exhibits a weakness in that particular area; all based on student achievement data and on the premise of supporting, not evaluating. These conversations were accomplished through the district’s process of goal setting meetings, which occur at the beginning of the year when student-achievement goals are set for the school year. These meetings became the catalyst to connect teachers for observations with an instructional focus in mind.

With building leadership’s support, time was re-engineered to create opportunities within the schedule for the teachers to conduct their observations. A reflection sheet, which the observer used to document the experience and reflect on what they observed and how the observation would impact or influence their future instruction, was developed. Then came the light bulb moment at a state-run professional development workshop regarding adaptations to the data team process during which a new mandate was presented for developing a SMART goal for the teachers. While other districts and schools expressed concern, the staff conferred and decided that instead of adding another mandate or initiative to teachers’ already full plates, the peer observations would be used as the new mandated adult SMART goal.

It was at this point that peer observations became “officially mandated”. This was viewed in a positive light by the staff because it involved the utilization of a practice which had already begun instead of adding yet another initiative or mandate. The system for peer observations was now created and in motion, and the teachers were supportive because they were involved and part of the decision to mandate the practice.

Releasing Responsibility: The overall goal was to begin a practice that would ultimately become a natural part of our professional routine. Through the creation of a schedule in the office where teachers could sign-up for times to observe others, we quickly began releasing responsibility to the teachers. Securing sub coverage at the beginning of the year assured a successful release of responsibility to the teachers. Another change that provided momentum was the adoption of a new district evaluation plan. Like the teacher SMART goal that was originally linked to the peer observations, the new evaluation plan contained a professional practice goal for teachers. This goal required the teacher to collect and present artifacts and evidence which connected to the identified practice the teacher selected. The peer observations and accompanying reflection sheet served as valuable artifacts for this professional practice goal.

Culture of Collaboration: A wonderful transformation began to unfold as the staff progressed; teachers were not only scheduling times for the peer observations, but teachers were also conducting observations on their own during preparation periods. The teachers were now viewing the peer observations as important for improving their instruction, and were using their own time to conduct them. The school was also beginning to see improvements in student achievement, which provided tangible evidence of improvements in practices. The staff was also becoming much more comfortable with the practice of observing each other to improve their own teaching practices. It was not “taboo” for teachers to admit they had areas for growth, and more importantly they realized there were available resources in their own building to assist. In essence, the school was fast-becoming a learning community. As the school was progressing with its own internal observation system, staff saw the connections to the district’s initiatives of MTSS and learning walks, and the value in their own internal peer observation system. The connections between the district initiatives and the school-based observation initiative provided a level of comfort with opening classroom doors that did not exist previously.

Moving Forward: As the journey of sharing best practices through professional collegiality and peer observations continues, the plan will be to have all teachers within a grade level conduct “vertical” observations. This would include visiting and observing instruction of classrooms one grade below and one grade above the grade they teach. This will allow the teachers to understand the rigor of instruction at those grade levels, and how it impacts their own instructional practice at their grade level. Wherever the school proceeds to next with observations, the idea is to build upon the level of trust, support and collaboration that has been established. The “culture of collaboration” has been instrumental in improving the way the staff operates on a day to day basis, and the results seen in student achievement and teacher development have validated the efforts.

As a district, we are moving forward together with a foundation of trust and open-mindedness. We are a collaborative team that has created a unifying vision for our district. We believe that every child is entitled to a high quality education, that teachers and leaders impact every child’s achievement, and that collaboration improves student learning and sustains our mission to see our students make positive progress.

Just this past year, we achieved the highest scores in district history in grade 3 reading, grade 5 science, grade 6 math, grade 7 reading, and grade 8 reading and writing. Our school climate data were equally impressive. Since 2010–2011, suspensions have decreased by 58%, expulsions are down 88%, and school-based arrests have been reduced by 77%. In the Meriden Public Schools, we know that in this era of accountability, our approach has to be more than simple compliance; we have to create a professional learning community where teachers learn from one another. We must create schools where students and staff want to be.

___

Mark D. Benigni, Ed.D. ([email protected]) is Superintendent of Meriden Public Schools and is Co-chair of the Connecticut Association of Urban Schools Superintendents. Dr. Benigni also serves on the American Association of School Administrators (AASA) national Governing Board.

Thomas W. Giard III ([email protected]) is Assistant Superintendent for Personnel and Staff Development of Meriden Public Schools and is an adjunct professor at Sacred Heart University in the Educational Leadership Program.

David P. Levenduski ([email protected]) is Principal at Ben Franklin Elementary School in the Meriden Public Schools and is the architect of Meriden’s school-based peer coaching model.

___
Resources:
City, E.A., Elmore, R.F., Fiarman, S.E., & Teitel, L. (2009). Instructional Rounds in Education. Cambridge, MA: Harvard Education Press.

Govindarajan, V. & Trimble, C. (2010). The Other Side of Innovation: Solving the Execution Challenge. Boston, MA: Harvard Business Review Press.

Kelly, M. (2007). The Dream Manager. New York, NY: Beacon Publishing

Sinek, S. (2009). Start With Why: How Great Leaders Inspire Everyone to Take Action. (2011 ed.). New York, NY: Portfolio/Penguin Group (USA) Inc.

Teitel, L. (2013). School-Based Instructional Rounds: Improving Teaching and Learning Across Classrooms. Cambridge, MA: Harvard Education Press.

Wei, R. C., Darling-Hammond, L., & Adamson, F. (2010). Professional Learning in the United States: Trends
and Challenges. Dallas, TX: National Staff Development Council.

Wong, K., & Nicotera, A. (2006). Successful Schools and Educational Accountability: Concepts and Skills to Meet Leadership Challenges. Boston, MA: Pearson Education.