Uncategorized

Using Technology to Inspire Reluctant Readers

Every teacher has dealt with students who don’t like reading. These students, often called “reluctant readers”, can present a real challenge for even the most experienced teachers. As the old saying goes, you can lead a horse to water, but you can’t make it drink. So it goes for reluctant readers—you can’t force them to read.

You can, however, get them excited about reading. One way teachers are getting reluctant readers engaged is through technology. Technology has produced several alternatives to the traditional style of reading. By using technology, many teachers are able to get students who hate reading to do it.

E-readers motivate and assist reluctant readers

The biggest change that technology has brought to reading is the shift from print text to digital text. Many students are excited by the idea of using tablets or e-readers to read. While the mere sight of a chapter book makes certain students groan, those same students’ eyes light up when they see an electronic device. Although reading on a Kindle or Nook is almost exactly the same as reading a traditional book, the simple change in medium can make it feel more fun for students.

For students who struggle with reading due to dyslexia, e-readers can help in a major way. A new study suggests that readers with dyslexia have an easier time with e-readers. Students can also change the font size and type on an e-reader, which may make it easier to read for students with dyslexia or vision problems.

E-readers also offer a variety of helpful tools. Most e-readers allow users to click on a word and get a definition. Apps designed with students in mind often include features like read-aloud or translation to other languages. These features can make reading less intimidating for struggling readers and allow them to enjoy reading with less frustration.

Such features help teachers scaffold their instruction. While a particular text may be too difficult for some students to read on their own, teachers can push students to read using the assistive features on an e-reader. For example, a student who is an English language learner might be too advanced for some texts, but not quite ready to move on to a higher level text due to the difficult vocabulary. With translation features on most e-readers, that student could try a more advanced text, using the translator for difficult vocabulary words.

Audio books get students reading

Another option for reluctant readers is to listen instead of read. While the ultimate goal should be to get students reading on their own, audio books can be a good start. The popular app Audible offers thousands of audio books that users can listen to on their computer, tablet, or smartphone.

Teachers can encourage students to follow along with a print or digital version while listening to the audio. Listening and tracking text is a strategy teachers have been teaching for decades. With audio books, students can do it even when there’s nobody there to read to them.

Enhanced e-books for elementary students

E-books aren’t always just a digital version of the same text. Reading apps that are designed for kids, like Meegenius, are changing the way we think about e-books. These apps offer a variety of illustrated children’s books in digital format. Students can read the text themselves, or follow along with word-by-word highlighting while the app provides audio.

Some apps also offer enhanced versions of books. Illustrations can come to life on the screen, or students can play interactive games that relate to the text. These extra features can help reluctant readers get excited about books.

How do you use technology to inspire reluctant readers? What cool apps and devices can get students excited about reading?

What is Digital Literacy?

Every educator is familiar with the concept of literacy—the ability to read and write. A person who is illiterate, who cannot read or write, will inevitably struggle to get along in society. It’s impossible to go on to higher education or get a high-paying job without the ability to read and write. Even daily tasks, like reading a newspaper or filling out job applications, are difficult for an illiterate person.

In today’s world, literacy goes beyond just the basic ability to comprehend text. Today’s students will also need to master a new skill—digital literacy. Cornell University defines digital literacy as “the ability to find, evaluate, utilize, share, and create content using information technologies and the Internet.”

Digital literacy, by this definition, encompasses a wide range of skills, all of which are necessary to succeed in an increasingly digital world. As print mediums begin to die out, the ability to comprehend information found online becomes more and more important. Students who lack digital literacy skills may soon find themselves at just as much of a disadvantage as those who cannot read or write.

Because digital literacy is so important, educators are increasingly required to teach students digital literacy in the classroom. In many ways, this is similar to what educators have always done in teaching students to read and write. In other ways, however, digital literacy is a brand new skill.

Most students already use digital technology, such as tablets, smartphones, and computers, at home. Many students already know how to navigate the web, share images on social media, and do a Google search to find information. However, true digital literacy goes beyond these basic skills.

One of the most important components of digital literacy is the ability to not just find, but also to evaluate, information. This means finding the answer to a question or a bit of needed information and then judging whether the source is reliable. Educators can, and should, teach students how to tell whether information on the internet is true. The ability to weed out false information and find reliable sources is a key part of digital literacy and a crucial life skill in the 21st century.

Educators can start by teaching students how to find author information, dates of publication, and other information that can reveal whether an online source is reliable. Students should also learn to tell the difference between different types of websites. For example, a .com site may be less reliable than a .edu site. Understanding these differences is one example of digital literacy.

Learning how to locate information is just one part of digital literacy. Knowing how to share information is another. Students today are constantly warned about the dangers of posting inappropriate images or text online, but it’s still important for teachers to discuss. The ability to create and share online is considered a part of digital literacy and should be taught in schools.

Students should know how digital writing differs from traditional writing—for example, how to include images and links in writing. They should also have an understanding of what kind of audience they’re sharing with online. Just like a personal narrative essay differs from a research paper, a post on Facebook is different from an article for a website or blog.

As technology becomes a part of daily life, it’s more important than ever for educators to teach digital literacy. Whether they plan on going to college or not, students will need digital literacy to be successful in their personal and professional lives.

How can educators help their students navigate the digital world? Let us know what you think about digital literacy and education!

 

Why Digital Learning is Reshaping Education

Technology has changed just about every field, including education. Digital learning is reshaping education in unprecedented ways. The ways in which students learn are changing rapidly thanks to technology, and both students and teachers will benefit from it.

There are several specific changes that we can expect to see as digital learning takes over education. For one, the way teachers present information and how students work with that information has changed. Students are asked to be more hands-on and collaborative than ever before. There are also new skills that students must learn, such as digital literacy.

The Flipped Classroom

The traditional model of teachers lecturing in the classroom and students completing practice and homework on their own is changing. Instead, students are learning on their own and using the classroom as a place to dig more deeply into what they’ve learned. This model, known as the flipped classroom, is gaining popularity thanks to the rise of EdTech.

How does the flipped classroom work? Students watch lecture videos or complete readings at home. The following day in class, the teacher clarifies anything students didn’t understand. Students then work with the information to answer questions, complete projects, and do other activities that used to be reserved for homework.

The flipped classroom provides benefits for students and teachers alike. Teachers spend more time helping students with the content they don’t understand. This means more one-on-one help for students and less time listening to boring lectures in class.

Emphasis on Collaboration

Another change brought about by digital learning is a new emphasis on collaboration. Thanks to increased technology in the classroom, students able to collaborate online and work on projects together. With a flipped classroom model, teachers can spend less time lecturing and devote more time to collaborative activities and projects.

Technology has also created a more connected world, where everyone is reachable almost any time of day. Cloud-based apps, like Google’s Drive, allow students to share work and collaborate outside of school. Many teachers are already using social media or education apps to encourage students to communicate about class content or ask questions from home. As digital learning becomes more popular, this kind of after-hours collaboration will only increase.

More Higher-Order Thinking

Thanks to technology, students have instant access to all the information they could ever want or need. There’s no longer a need for students to memorize facts or dates. Today, there is much more emphasis placed on higher-order thinking.

Higher-order thinking occurs when students are asked not just to know a piece of information but to do something with that information. At the most basic level, this can mean analyzing information—comparing and contrasting, for example. At the highest level, students are asked to create something on their own that shows their understanding.

In nearly every classroom today, students are asked to do these types of higher-order thinking tasks. Gone are the days when teachers lectured and students regurgitated information for a quiz or test. Today’s students are learning how to be critical thinkers, a skill that is in-demand in today’s job market.

New Skills

There are other skills that students will need to stay competitive in the 21st century. Digital literacy, the ability to use the internet and other digital technologies, is increasingly important for a wide variety of jobs. As technology becomes a bigger part of education, teachers will devote more time to teaching digital literacy.

In some states, digital literacy is already a part of the curriculum. More states are creating standards for digital literacy just as they would for reading or math.

These are just some of the ways that digital learning is reshaping education. As digital learning becomes a bigger part of the world of education, you can expect to see more changes in classrooms around the world.

How do you envison technology changing education?

Pass or Fail: Social Promotion Abolishment — A Case Study

If a student hasn’t meet the material-based learning criteria, they face one of two options: retention or social promotion. So, what happens when a school suddenly decides to ditch social promotion practices? Read on to see how this real-world scenario plays out:

Long Beach Preparatory Academy in the Long Beach school district in Southern California had been hurriedly cobbled together from prefab structures in about five months. It was in a difficult neighborhood, and the school district had recently decided that social promotion, which moves students up based on age rather than test scores, had to go. Unlike other schools in the area, Long Beach Prep had plenty of money, sieved from budget reserves.

They had manageable classrooms of twenty kids or fewer. They had ninety-minute classes, rather than the standard forty. The district would spend $6,300 per pupil to educate the students. (Note that this is just shy of the national average – California has had longstanding educational budget woes). The principal, Miguel Lopes, even had the funds to hire a dean of discipline to keep the kids in line.

Adrian Chavez, his hair bleached blond from long afternoons at the shore, had been told by a teacher that he was “wasting taxpayers’ money”—and it could be argued that he was. He and many other students were getting terrible grades. His classmate Brandon Perkins, an inherently bright student, had turned in a dire report card at the end of the previous year and, according to his mother, had “the attitude to go with it.” Clearly, the school needed to pull itself together.

The district-level abolishment of social promotion, which in the case of Long Beach Prep meant that any eighth-grader with two F’s on his or her report card would be held back, had a dramatic effect on the school. Four hundred and twenty-five students flunked, possibly the largest group in any school in recent Californian history. By the end of the year, only 292 students remained at the school.

But in the meantime, something extraordinary happened. Of those remaining students, just a handful failed to pass. Adrian Chavez was finally free to dream about becoming a boat captain and was engaging with his teachers for the first time. Brandon Perkins’ mother was astonished by his “complete turnaround.”

In the case of Long Beach Prep, cutting back on social promotion clearly created better results for the students who remained. However, what about the hundreds of kids who were expelled or sent elsewhere? Is abolishing social promotion the best way to go for everyone in the community?

Social promotion, of course, is the option that allows otherwise “failing” children to move on to the next grade level. They move on even though they have not mastered everything required, and they may even have other identified issues with skills-based learning. Social promotion, however, also allows that students may lack the expected knowledge and skills to function well at the promoted grade level. It allows their promotion regardless, always in spite of a common and reasonable concern that this approach places already struggling students at risk of future failure, rather than addressing their academic or personal needs at the moment.

Retention takes the opposite approach and tends to be the harsher of the two options. It is usually the most difficult option for the student to deal with on a psychological, social, and academic level.

Retention puts a child back a year, determining that they should remain in a specific age-grade level if they have not mastered the appropriate knowledge or skills to graduate to the next level. It focuses on the academics at hand and is less likely to take into account the feelings or potential social shortfalls of holding a child back. The positive angle is that it allows students to take additional time to master materials that they have struggled with.

The question of whether social promotion or retention is best, or whether one is more appropriate than the other, continues to be central to the educational challenges of this country. In most school districts, the more overt practices of social promotion appear to be in decline. However, although retention is emerging as a preferred policy, many districts still rely heavily on social promotion.

Do you agree with the move toward retention over social promotion within American schools?

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

Pass or Fail: A Spotlight on Social Promotion Responsibility

In this multi-part series, I provide a dissection of the phenomenon of retention and social promotion. Also, I describe the many different methods that would improve student instruction in classrooms and eliminate the need for retention and social promotion if combined effectively.

While reading this series, periodically ask yourself this question: Why are educators, parents and the American public complicit in a practice that does demonstrable harm to children and the competitive future of the country?

Would you really want your child to move on to the next grade level if he or she hadn’t mastered the skills and concepts necessary in their current grade level? Perhaps social promotion makes sense from a social perspective, but how does this set a student up for academic success?

The Clinton Administration had strong objections to social promotion in the late 1990s. In a 1999 report that continues to influence views on the subject, Taking Responsibility for Ending Social Promotion: A Guide for Educators and State and Local Leaders, social promotion was tied not only to the child’s inability to perform at the next grade level but also to the clear negative effects of social promotion on a child’s future. The key points of the report emphasized that students allowed to progress to the next grade through promotion, rather than achievement, would be ill-prepared to enter college or the workforce.

Although there are some who continue to tout social promotion as a strategy, even the majority of supporters now rarely endorse it as a preferable, standalone practice for students who struggle to achieve. Rather, they take an oppositional stance, offering social promotion as an alternate or better choice for children than retention.

One obvious problem with this “better than the alternative” mindset is that it clearly emphasizes some of the less than savory reasons for social promotion. As was the case in the past, social promotion becomes the practice of choice when the numbers don’t look good; when a proposed retention policy requires too many children being held back. Districts may fear the political and economic ramifications of a high retention rate.

While supporters of social promotion believed that retention undermines the social and psychological well-being of students, today there is also a focus on the achievement-related repercussions of retention. Many believe that retaining children will not result in academic gains, particularly if a child experiences the same curriculum and instructional methodologies as in the previous year. Some students appear to gain more from exposure to new material in the next grade, and others find new experiences motivating. Even so, the more positive impacts of social promotion are difficult to track, primarily because schools rarely distinguish between regular and social promotion.

Critics of social promotion believe the practice deceives both children and their parents. Children may conclude that their efforts in the learning environment do not matter when they can pass to the next grade regardless of their current grade performance. Observing their children progressing from grade to grade, parents may fall under the mistaken impression that their child will be prepared for college, or to enter the workforce upon graduation.

On the flip side, it’s worth noting that a series of supports specifically impact the success of retention. These include support among parents and educators; processes that identify students at risk for retention and provide high-quality interventions and support; systems that set criteria for promotion that balance local and state measures; strategies that build the capacity of teachers to support students at risk for retention; and systems that monitor the effects of implementation of the policy.

There’s a fair chance that teachers end up having to provide too much attention to students who are not ready for coursework at a certain grade level. Although the effort may have the best intentions, the process can interfere with the teacher’s ability to focus on the other students who are ready to learn at that grade level.

Retention and social promotion policies, have a long and complicated history in the United States. Most of the traditional solutions to the challenges of education have proven problematic, and their results have been limited. Social promotion and retention divide opinion. Both policies have their critics and supporters.

Put yourself in the position of a student, teacher, or parent and imagine facing one of these options. Which strikes you as the better solution? Which strikes you as better for future academic success? Which is likely to help the student feel greater confidence about his or her potential to make progress?

Pass or Fail: Standardized Testing and Education Problems in the U.S.

In this multi-part series, I provide a dissection of the phenomenon of retention and social promotion. Also, I describe the many different methods that would improve student instruction in classrooms and eliminate the need for retention and social promotion if combined effectively.

While reading this series, periodically ask yourself this question: Why are educators, parents and the American public complicit in a practice that does demonstrable harm to children and the competitive future of the country?

How much do you think education laws and policies impact our educators? Are students receiving the very best instruction when such a great emphasis is placed on standardized testing?

Supporters of standards-based teaching and learning use standards and standardized tests as a basis for identifying which students have mastered required material and which have not. Promotion or retention, when based on standardized test performance, leaves little room to quibble about whether a child should move to the next grade level. Some educators and policy makers, however, question the logic of basing promotion solely on standardized test performance. And here we see one of the fundamental problems of standard-based teaching – the inevitable adoption of standardization and its associated element, the standardized assessment.

With the passage of the No Child Left Behind (NCLB) act, schools had to make annual yearly progress (AYP) toward federally generated achievement goals in reading and math (both overall, and for students in various socioeconomic, race/ethnicity, language minority, and special education categories). NCLB also mandated that the total student population in a school district must reach proficiency in both subject areas, or, through a “safe harbor provision,” reduce by a rate of 10 percent annually the number of students not reaching proficiency on state exams. All this to achieve progress demanded by 2014. School leaders, teachers, and scholars overwhelmingly perceived these achievement goals as unattainable, and, of course, the deadline has passed, with little evidence of progress.

A great many authorities have spoken out about the problems of the NCLB legislation, and some even tout it “the worst legislation ever passed by Congress.” Complaints emphasized the challenge for teachers to help struggling children met standards when their efforts were overshadowed by the specter of the sanctions to be doled out should schools not reach AYP. Many well-meaning educators working under the guise of accountability for student learning have gone on to evaluate children’s knowledge based on narrow information provided by test scores.

This has made “teaching to the test” a necessary option for many educators under extreme pressures. In short, responsibility for removing social promotion has lost out to a focus on accountability for ensuring that students pass state assessments. Reports also suggest that teachers inevitably waste a lot of instructional time struggling to meet the demands of these assessments. Class time, which might otherwise have served to enrich student learning, is now primarily focused on preparing children for upcoming state assessments.

Some administrators have determined that the use of standardized tests to decide promotion was problematic. The use of standardized tests, in fact, resulted in a narrowing of the curriculum so that there would be alignment between the test administered and the curriculum taught. Students would learn less, but more would be able to reach required scores for promotion. This is, of course, the problem at the heart of the “teaches to the test” conundrum.

Although retained students do tend to perform better on assessments the second time around (although related achievements and academic advancements also tend to be short-lived), schools can often show improved AYP when retained children reach proficiency on state assessments. Correctly or not, most stakeholders deem the improved results in retesting to be sufficient evidence of improvement.

At the end of December 2015, President Obama signed the Every Student Succeeds Act (ESSA) into law, effectively sweeping away NCLB. The new bill made major changes to federal education policy. One thing that changed with the ESSA was how teacher performance is evaluated. States now have the ability to individually appraise how well its teachers are doing performance wise. Another alteration under the new law will allow states “to come up with their own way to determine the quality of their local schools.” This means that test scores are no longer the sole deciding factor for school performance.

ESSA lists music as a component of a well-rounded education and gives it more support than previous policies when it comes to access and funding. The law also means federal grant funding is opened for states and local school districts to support music education programs and further train music teachers. ESSA has been a long time coming. Considering that NCLB had needed an update since 2007, it is shocking how long it took to sign this new law.

As far as the effect that ESSA will have on social promotion and retention, only time will tell. Do you feel that American education has improved since ESSA was passed, or are we still fighting an uphill battle?

Pass or Fail: Did you Know that State Policies Impact Retention Rates?

In this multi-part series, I provide a dissection of the phenomenon of retention and social promotion. Also, I describe the many different methods that would improve student instruction in classrooms and eliminate the need for retention and social promotion if combined effectively.

While reading this series, periodically ask yourself this question: Why are educators, parents and the American public complicit in a practice that does demonstrable harm to children and the competitive future of the country?

The state you live in determines retention policy and procedures. Do you think state level mandates are a fair and appropriate way of addressing the challenges we face in education? Does it make sense that a student in one state may be promoted to the next grade, yet retained in another state based on differing policies?

The first point of consideration for state retention policies is the Taking Responsibility Report that suggested that children lacking reading skills should not be promoted beyond the fourth grade. The report precipitated the move by some states to establish “no social promotion” policies in the form of retention laws. In most instances, however, and at a state level, this policy established third-grade reading skills as a benchmark for promotion beyond third grade. The first of these policies emerged quickly.

The second point of consideration is the so-called benchmark for educational progression. Indeed, a basic state-level policy review shows that most states require the retention of children who do not meet stated promotion requirements. Colorado’s statute, for instance, recommends retention when students do not meet learning standards. West Virginia’s statute also allows for but does not require, retention.

So-called model retention laws, such as those passed in Florida, still allow for “good cause” retention exemptions. Schools can promote children if they pass an alternative state-approved reading assessment or demonstrate they have met the state required level of mastery based on their student portfolios. Limited English speakers – those students with less than two years of English instruction – are also exempt. So too are special needs students whose Individualized Education Plans, or IEPs, state that standardized testing is inappropriate.

Florida students with IEPs or 504 plans who were retained in kindergarten or first or second grade, and who continue to have deficiencies after two or more years of reading remediation; and students who continue to have deficiencies after two or more years of reading remediation or who were retained in kindergarten or first or second grade for a total of two years are exempt, as well. Basically, no special education students have to meet state standards.

Most states with retention and exemption laws include categories similar to those included in the Florida law to get around the issue of those with special education needs. Other states, however, allow for teacher or principal recommendations as an exemption category. Georgia is the only state that allows for a parental appeal of retention. Many state policies also include contingencies for retention. They may, for example, require that the child is retained if he or she does not participate in a summer school intervention plan. A child may also be promoted only if he or she receives remediation at the next grade level.

Most retention takes place in kindergarten through third grade. Some states do not have policies that allow retention at higher grade levels. Of those that do, it’s notable that West Virginia’s statute also requires retention in the third through eighth grade. Texas children can be retained in grades three, five, and eight if they do not perform at required levels on reading and mathematics exams. Although the state of New York does not have a retention policy, New York City established a policy for grades three, five, seven and eight with proficiency required in English Language Arts or mathematics.

In the United States, there are two identified spikes in retention rates by age. Students are statistically most likely to be retained at the age of six or at the age of twelve. Retention takes place at the high school level, too, precipitated by performance on high school exit exams. In this case, young people unable to pass an exam by the time they complete twelfth grade do not receive a diploma. This is a form of retention, too, in that students are not able to move to the next level, whether it is career or college entry. Currently, twenty-six states have high school exit exams.

Although high school exit exams vary from state to state regarding content tested and opportunities for retakes, most states administer exams that cover reading, writing, and mathematics at levels that should have been addressed by tenth grade. Some states allow students to retake these exams and some allow for alternative exams, alternative routes to graduation, and remediation programs for students who are unable to pass the initial administration of the exam. Minnesota, Oregon, and Texas have specific alternate routes to graduation for English Language Learners who have been in the United States for a limited number of years. All states provide for modified or alternate assessment for students with disabilities, as well as waivers.

How does your state compare to others in terms of retention? Do you agree with the current policy in place for your particular state?

Pass or Fail: Too Much Focus Placed on Early Literacy?

In this multi-part series, I provide a dissection of the phenomenon of retention and social promotion. Also, I describe the many different methods that would improve student instruction in classrooms and eliminate the need for retention and social promotion if combined effectively.

While reading this series, periodically ask yourself this question: Why are educators, parents and the American public complicit in a practice that does demonstrable harm to children and the competitive future of the country?

What fundamental skill do you think is the most important for students in elementary grades to master? If you said reading, the state of Colorado agrees with you. Below is how Colorado is leading the pack by placing primary focus on literacy skills.

Generally speaking, state-level emphasis on reading is one of the most prevalent trends for retention. Although retention is not the only (or even the main instrument) for addressing problems concerning the achievement of expected knowledge levels or skills at particular education phases. Other so-called “intensive interventions” include pulling struggling readers out of class for individual or small-group tutorials. Yet, retention for reading deficiency has become increasingly popular.

So far, thirteen states have adopted retention policies for kindergarten to third grade where there are significant concerns regarding literacy. Colorado is one of the key states shifting emphasis to early literacy, and it is looking to incorporate retention as a mainstream policy where there are literacy concerns by third grade. The passage of the Colorado READ Act marked the state’s official transformation to early literacy emphasis. Many Colorado educators hailed the bill as one of the most significant pieces of education legislation to pass in 2012.

Provisions of the Colorado state legislation are complex, however. It is, at the end of the day, a comprehensive effort to apply reading standards to education and implement retention as one strategy for addressing reading concerns. The Colorado READ Act calls for districts to report to the Colorado Department of Education on the number of students demonstrating problems with reading in kindergarten to third grade. The State Board of Education defines the criteria for significant reading deficiencies for the purpose of law. The state’s education department must also create and maintain a list of approved instructional and professional development programs that districts can use to address literacy problems as early as possible. Educators must develop individual READ plans for students with significant deficiencies, which allow parents, teachers, and administrators to have a say in grade promotion versus retention.

With the literacy focus, assessments shifted and teachers became more involved and interested in evaluations and their outcomes. Evaluations were tied more closely to what was happening in the classroom, and what teachers saw among students. It may be more time consuming, but also can be more effective. Perhaps the key aspect of the change was a dramatic altering of perspective. “We’ve shifted from focusing on ‘what students can’t do’ to what we need to do,” explains Dr. Montina Romero, Director of Exceptional Student Services for the Fountain-Fort Carson School District. “Now, we’re much better at improving all students’ progress because we look at our whole system and what all children should learn.”

Although the current legislation offers parents the final say on retention for children in kindergarten to second grade, by third grade and beyond that, the law shifts the control to superintendents or designated administrators. Special services are available, on paper, for any retained third grader, and diverted interest revenue from the state schools is set to provide approximately $16 million in per-pupil funding (about $700 per student) for districts working with significant reading deficiencies. The law also creates $5 million in funding for CDE administration costs (about $1 million) and professional development grants to districts. How efficiently and effectively the state uses these resources is a different matter.

Inevitably, there are various protections and exemptions for students with disabilities, limited English proficiency, and those who have already been retained. Specific interventions in Colorado, before retention, include enrollment in full-day kindergarten, enrollment in summer school, and access to tutoring.

Although this Colorado legislation is groundbreaking in many respects, we shouldn’t get carried away by thinking it is the only state legislation focused on literacy and retention. As of 2012, in fact, the District of Columbia and fourteen other states can retain students based on lack of reading proficiency alone, suggesting that states are making grade-specific learning expectations and their subsequent interventions even more core to education.

How important do you feel early literacy intervention is for mastery? Does Colorado have the right idea or do you feel a more conservative approach should be taken in regards to retention?

Pass or Fail: Implementing Early Literacy Interventions

In this multi-part series, I provide a dissection of the phenomenon of retention and social promotion. Also, I describe the many different methods that would improve student instruction in classrooms and eliminate the need for retention and social promotion if combined effectively.

While reading this series, periodically ask yourself this question: Why are educators, parents and the American public complicit in a practice that does demonstrable harm to children and the competitive future of the country?

What type of interventions would you want provided to your child if they were struggling with early literacy? Based on the state you live in, various early interventions are not only offered, but in some cases required.

Colorado leads the way for early literacy interventions and a 2014 follow-up study was conducted to evaluate progress. Colorado’s READ Act and mandated Response to Intervention (RtI), which was especially concerned with students who had learning disabilities, showed that the initiatives focused on literacy did have a dramatic effect.

Colorado had intentionally moved the initiatives out of the realm of special education. As Dr. Ed Steinberg, former Assistant Commissioner and State Director of Special Education, explains: “We took bold action, but knew from the beginning that for RtI to be effective on a larger scale, it could not ‘live’ in special education. Instead, it had to be seen as integral to improving student achievement.” In other words, the focus encompassed the entire educational system, and literacy and retentions were better incorporated into a comprehensible structure based on defined principles.

Six states – Delaware, Colorado, Florida, Iowa, Maryland, and Missouri – allow exemptions for literacy levels, and these exemptions apply to students who have already been retained based on reading deficiencies alone. In North Carolina, a student can be exempt from retention for the third time. Eleven states exempt special needs students. Seven exempt English language learners or those who are not fully proficient in English.

Some states bypass state assessments and go with local ones to determine reading proficiency. Those states include Maryland, Missouri, Vermont, and Virginia, which only test students in literacy in or after third grade. Since most testing begins in third grade, we have to keep in mind that there is a missed opportunity for early identification of children with learning issues. Retention is not effective in increasing learning if the ability is absent, or other outside factors are strongly impacting the individual student’s learning potential. By contrast, Arizona and Florida test students beginning at pre-kindergarten.

Many states have recommended interventions specifically aimed at reading, to try to avoid retention on the basis of reading issues. Specific interventions vary by state, however, and there are even differences regarding the number of interventions required before retention is allowed. Some states require the use of up to four interventions. Connecticut, for example, tries to minimize retention by requiring the use of a certain number of interventions first, before educators can consider retention. Idaho requires instruction outside of normal school hours as the only specified intervention. Arizona and Florida, however, are the only states so far to enforce annual reading assessments for prekindergarten to third grade. The idea behind this approach is that initial assessments might help identify those who are struggling early on to receive prompt assistance.

Mandated reading assessments are commonplace among the states. The District of Columbia, Georgia, Iowa, Louisiana, Kentucky, Minnesota, North Carolina, New Mexico, North Dakota, Oklahoma, Texas, Utah, Washington, Wisconsin, and Wyoming have annual reading assessments from kindergarten to third grade. Idaho, Ohio, and South Carolina have opted for assessments from first to third grade; California from second to third; Delaware, Maryland, Montana, New York, Rhode Island, Tennessee, Vermont, Virginia, and West Virginia have reading assessments for third grade. New York and Rhode Island opt to screen students before entry to school. Again, the goal is to assess reading skills up front and thus establish reasonable expectations, targeting struggling students early on.

Fifteen states require supplemental reading instruction during regular school hours, and another three recommend it. Six states require summer school as a means of literacy intervention, and eleven states, plus the District of Columbia, just recommend it. Five states require academic improvement plans (AIPs) for struggling readers. Five states require parental involvement in choosing intervention strategies, and the District of Columbia is making this a recommendation. Eleven states and D.C. recommend individual or group tutoring as an intervention and North Carolina requires it, again as a means of actively trying to prevent retention being necessary for struggling students. Since these policies demand that the school districts or the state education departments provide the resources, including tutoring resources, the benefits should not be overlooked.

Eight states also require instruction tailored specifically to student deficiencies. Two states, plus D.C., also recommend tailored instruction. Arizona requires online or computer-based instruction, and three states recommend it. Three states also require assignment to a different teacher if retention takes place. Ohio and D.C. recommend this strategy as well.

If you’re the parent of a student who struggles with literacy, you no doubt want as many interventions offered to them as possible. Do you feel honing in on concerns early on will allow more students the chance to improve enough for grade level mastery?

Pass or Fail: Effective Retention Polices – The Chicago Case

In this multi-part series, I provide a dissection of the phenomenon of retention and social promotion. Also, I describe the many different methods that would improve student instruction in classrooms and eliminate the need for retention and social promotion if combined effectively.

While reading this series, periodically ask yourself this question: Why are educators, parents and the American public complicit in a practice that does demonstrable harm to children and the competitive future of the country?

The goal of retention policies is to ensure that students who move to the next level of learning have mastered the required knowledge and skills. The accompanying exemptions and alternative paths surely beg the question: do retention and the various related supported elements thwart social promotion?

The problem is simple: some children may progress from grade to grade without reaching state required benchmarks. Most states and school districts worry about the number of students who are retained without alternative avenues for promotion being made available. The consensus, spoken or not, is that retention does very little to solve the underlying problem of retention and social promotion.

The retention policy path in Chicago, for instance, provides an overt example of the challenges associated with the implementation of retention policies, and how social promotion can creep into well-intended policies meant to discontinue the practice.

The Chicago Public School System (CPS) developed a retention policy where none existed at the state level. CPS believed that a retention policy would result in students working harder, receiving more attention from parents with respect to their schooling, and experiencing more focus from teachers when at risk for retention.

Initiated in 1996, the CPS policy required students in the third, sixth, and eighth grades to reach specified scores on standardized tests for reading and mathematics, or face retention. The policy also included a summer school attendance requirement for students – the top method for avoiding retention and a transition program designed to improve reading skills of eighth-grade students. The goal was to ensure that upon entering high school, students would be able to read high school level textbooks. By 2011, the retention rate had shrunk from 15 percent (at the time the policy was initiated) to 4 percent.

However, reduced retention rates have reportedly not been the result of improved achievement among students. Both implementation and structural components of the policy have weakened over the years, which in effect compromised the policy’s original intent. CPS did not have effective means to enforce consequences for children who were not meeting policy promotion requirements. Students who were obligated to pass summer school to avoid retention were allowed to enter the next highest grade, without attending summer classes. High school freshmen were required to pass all freshmen level classes, however, and to achieve certain scores on standardized tests, or attend summer school to escape retention. Following later adjustments, all students who did not meet the freshman promotion requirements after their summer school attendance went into a class for failing students when they returned to school in the fall.

Given that summer school was an instrumental component of the CPS’s policy, there was concern that if too many students were scheduled for retention, the number of summer school slots would be insufficient to handle the volume of students required to attend. The number of students performing below grade level was already substantial at the inception of the policy. Setting unattainable expectations for performance on standardized tests would simply result in an imbalance in the number of students required to attend summer school and slots available to accommodate them. Ultimately, the CPS made it easier for students to avoid retention despite poor academic performance. Achievement test scores needed for promotion were lowered so that more students were eligible to move ahead.

In the end, summer school and other interventions outlined in the CPS retention policy proved insufficient to support the number of children affected – which was somewhat inevitable, based on early number projections. Further disaster followed, with budget cuts that reduced the impact of the policy even further. As a result of the CPS budget cuts, summer schools were in session for fewer days. Summer school class sizes also increased, undermining the potential for teachers to give proper attention to students. Budget cuts also meant a redistribution of funds initially slated to add additional teachers to schools with high numbers of retained students. Various tutoring programs were either cut or discontinued through the process. As is the case with many retention policies today, educators went ahead and promoted students if the alternative was retention for more than one year.

Social promotion was not the primary problem facing CPS, though. Replacing social promotion with retention did not address the paramount and critical objective of the system: to increase learning among more students.

The CPS retention program is a good example of noble intentions gone awry. What can we learn and apply from the CPS initiative moving forward?