Uncategorized

Teaching History Honestly: One Educator’s How-To

Being a social studies teacher was one of the most rewarding things that I’ve ever done, but it was also one of the most challenging. I found it especially difficult when it was time to teach students about subjects that were awkward or painful to discuss, such as America’s history of mistreating and disenfranchising minorities. To add to this, modern textbooks tend to downplay these elements of history and often neglect to mention them at all.

You owe it to your students to tackle with honesty and integrity issues such as the history of inequality in America. How can you do this without ruffling feathers? You have to be creative and come up with novel ways of getting the material across to your students, without causing an uproar.

For instance, I remember teaching my fifth-grade students about Brown v. Board of Education and the integration of Little Rock High School by first showing them a 5-minute clip of how African Americans were treated during the 1950s. I was a bit worried about how it would go over, because students are usually bored to death by videos, even if they are short clips. However, I was amazed by their reaction.

They were asking great questions, such as “Why did white America treat Blacks differently?” and “Why did we have slavery?” On the spot, I decided to swivel and go in a different direction. I spent the rest of the class giving them a primer on the history of African Americans in the United States. That afternoon, I brainstormed on creative ways to capitalize on this new direction. It turned out to be one the most popular units that I have ever taught.

The next year, we began with the introduction of slavery in the Americas in the 1600s, and subsequently covered the Dred Scott and Plessy cases; the Civil War; the Thirteenth, Fourteenth, and Fifteenth Amendments; Jim Crow; and Brown v. Board of Education and the integration in Little Rock. From there, we finished off the Civil Rights movement and continued up to the new millennium.

Teaching students about the history of inequality in the United States can be difficult, simply because you want to do it in a fair and unbiased manner, but you also don’t want to stir the class up too much. If you’re honest and respectful to your students and their reactions, you should be fine. Although many of the American history textbooks on the market today fail to fairly discuss America’s history of unfairly treating minorities, you owe it to your students to tell them the truth in an appropriate manner. Good luck!

How the 20th Century Changed American Education

At the turn of the 20th century, the basic principles and foundations for public education had already been set. The concepts of free, universal, and compulsory education had developed deep roots. States could persuade parents to provide education to their children, although they could not require parents to send their children to public schools. Parents continued to have the option to choose to send their children to religious schools, private schools, or public schools. Although the basic principles for public education formed the framework for educational evolution in America, private enterprise in education continued to flourish. In fact, under the Establishment Clause, the private parochial schools continued to receive public financial support.

The Establishment Clause is a provision of the First Amendment that prohibits the government from creating any law “respecting an establishment of religion.” This clause not only forbids the government from formally establishing a sanctioned religion, but also prohibits government actions that unfairly favor one religion over another. It also forbids the government from unjustly preferring religion over non-religion, or non-religion over religion.

The multiage, multigrade, single-room schoolhouse had virtually disappeared at the start of the 20th century but still existed in a number of small rural districts. During the early years of the 20th century, the prevalent model of schooling was an 8-year elementary school and a 4-year high school. In 1910, a different structure for schooling was introduced, based on a six–three–three system.

This schooling model entailed 6 years of elementary school education, 3 years in junior high school, and 3 years in senior high school. Early childhood education also underwent a massive change, with provisions made for preschooling and an increasing number of teachers, nannies, and daycare workers producing learning materials and teaching children aged 5 years and younger. This initiative remained mostly in the private domain but represented the first steps toward what we know as kindergarten education today.

The 20th century also saw a series of reforms that changed what schooling looked like. To learn more about how education grew over the 1900’s into the system it is today, check out our other articles on the history of the American school system.

How the 20th Century Introduced the Concept of Education for All Children

From its inception, America has focused on equity as related to citizens and their government. However, extending that idea that all individuals should have equal access and opportunity to other areas of life, like education, took a while.

The concept of equity in education was introduced in the first half of the 20th century. Issues of wealth, religion, race, sex, ethnic origins, and disabilities surfaced, and educators had to determine how best to provide education to diverse students. During the 1950s, the approach toward ensuring equity in education changed visible. The emphasis shifted from the theoretical and passive concepts of providing equal opportunity to taking affirmative action to ensure availability of education for all, irrespective of differences in sex, religion, ethnicity, or wealth. The impact of this shift was evident by the 1970s, when African Americans and other minorities first achieved significant, widespread gains in education.

The concept of equality embraced the idea that everyone, regardless of condition, should have access to education. Consequently, individuals with physical and mental disabilities were soon included in equal education discourses. In 1958, the federal government initiated measures to train teachers to teach children with intellectual disabilities. A million dollars in federal funds supported the effort. From that point forward, financial assistance in terms of federal aid for children with disabilities continued to rise.

The Education for All Handicapped Children Act of 1975 further supported initiatives to support equal education for children with disabilities, to include improved facilities and special programs. In 1990, the law was revised, and it was renamed the Individuals with Disabilities Education Act (IDEA). This legislation underwent massive revisions in 1997 and again in 2004. The objectives of the latest revisions were to integrate students with disabilities into the mainstream of regular schools as far as was feasible.

Introducing special education as a division of the American school system opened up opportunities not just for prospective students, but also for the prospective teachers that were needed to serve them. Without 20th century legislation, entire sets of students and teachers and jobs and classrooms wouldn’t exist today.

How State Government Involvement Shaped 20th Century Education

Much of today’s American school system precipitated from the reform and legislation of the 20th century. The importance of a good education became more and more apparent over the course of the century, prompting more endeavors on the part of the government to enforce oversight and direction.

In the 20th century, most states made it compulsory for young people to attend school until their 16th (or in some cases their 17th) birthday. Although the first compulsory school attendance law was enacted in 1852 in Massachusetts, more than a third of the states did not enact compulsory school attendance laws until the 20th. One outcome of compulsory school attendance laws was a substantial increase in the number of high schools in the nation. Although the Great Depression and other economic strains later raised doubts about the viability of compulsory education, students across the nation continue to abide by compulsory school attendance laws.

By the mid-20th century, states played a more active regulatory role in schools. Some states consolidated smaller school districts by combining them into one larger school district. Consolidation was an efficient means or states to establish uniformity across schools in the state. In 1940, there were a total of 117,000 school districts in the United States. By 1990, there were approximately 15,000 districts. States also began to take on more responsibility for financing education, from around 30% in 1940 to 47% in 1990.

The greater involvement of the states became more evident during the 1980s and 1990s. Interest in raising education standards was growing, especially after a 1983 federal report highlighted the low academic achievement of students in public schools. The report, titled A Nation at Risk, highlighted the falling performance of American students on international tests when compared to their international peers. The report precipitated a number of new reforms in the states that focused on both curriculum revisions and effective assessment.

Just how helpful increased state involvement in school affairs has been is up for debate, but there’s no question that the involvement has been in some way majorly impactful. To learn more about how the 20th century has shaped modern education and how governmental guidance has impacted schools, check out our other articles on the subjects.

How the 20th Century Changed Higher Education

The early years of the 20th century saw a massive focus on elementary education, although a similar focus on high school and postsecondary education was lacking. Many reforms in elementary education occurred in the 20th century. In postsecondary education, a number of colleges began to shift the focus away from pure academics toward the practical needs of students in the working world.

In 1921, Antioch College in Ohio instituted a curriculum requiring students to divide time equally between classroom-based traditional learning and activity-based on-the-job learning. In 1932, Bennington College for Women began staffing its faculty with artists, writers, and other professionals in the creative field, rather than only people from the core academics. The objective was not only to bring in a practice-oriented focus in academics but also to encourage students to exercise their judgment and freely express their creativity.

In the early 20th century, William Rainer Harper, president of the University of Chicago, first proposed the idea of community colleges or “people’s college.” John Grant and J. Stanley Grant were also instrumental in this movement. The founding of the American Association for Junior Colleges solidified this establishment and ensured state support.

As higher education expanded rapidly between the 1950s and the 1970s, there was unprecedented growth in the number of colleges as well as wide variety in curriculum. Different colleges had different views about curriculum, which was generally in reaction to demands of specific groups. Soon a plethora of reviews, standards, and subjects differentiated colleges. Management and governance of the curriculum had become very difficult, and the multiplicity of programs and financial difficulties resulted in a decline in quality that the 21st century is still in the process of sorting out.

To learn more about modern education, where it has come from, and where it’s going, check out our other articles on the history of American schooling and its status today.

Educators: What The 20th Century Progressive Education Movement Did For You

The American school system of today is the product of centuries’ worth of educational reform and revision. One of the biggest movements that laid the foundation for modern education was the progressive education movement of the 20th century.

The progressive education movement surfaced in the 1880s, and continued well into the 20th century. Progressive education in the 20th century embraced democratic concepts such as participation and engagement of all citizens, in ways that affected social, economic, and political benefits for all.

The underlying convictions of progressivism rested on respect for diversity and development of an engaged population that could effectively participate in community affairs.

John Dewey, the leader of the movement, was a fervent believer in education for human development and democratic participation. He tested many of his ideas at his Laboratory School at the University of Chicago published books, and gave lectures to advance the ideas of progressive education from 1896 to 1916. In 1919, the Progressive Education Association was founded. Progressive educators sought to advance a “reconstructivist” approach where students respected diversity and participated in their communities. Leading school reformers, like Francis W. Parker and Ella Flagg Young, as well as the Teacher’s College at Columbia University, lent support to this movement.

During the Cold War, cultural conservatism caused the disintegration of the movement. However, progressivism experienced a revival in the 1960s and 1970s. Concepts such as open schools, experiential education, and schools without walls are based on progressive principles. John Goodlad’s concept of “nongraded” schools, Theodore Sizer’s “essential” schools, Elliott Wigginton’s Foxfire project, and Deborah Meier’s student-centered Central Park East schools have elements of progressivism as well. Paul Goodman and George Dennison furthered Dewey’s ideas to give rise to the free school movement.

Maria Montessori was another prominent educational theorist, whose materials and methods are still in use today in Montessori schools. She emphasized observation of each child to determine how to best tailor their education and believed that education should be developmentally appropriate for each child.

The progressive education movement expanded the idea of whom schooling should be for and how it could occur. It moved education thoroughly away from the “one size fits all” approach of one-room schools from the days of the early settlers, and brought it closer to the diversified, increasingly individualized schooling of today.

To learn more about where education has come from and where it’s headed, check out our series of other articles on the subject.

How the 20th Century Shaped High School Reform

High school is one of the most important periods in education. However, what exactly that means for what high school should look like and what needs to be done for students going through those years has been highly contentious throughout the years. Over the course of the 20th century, high school went through a series of reforms and experiments that helped shape it into what it is today.

To start, the structure and purpose of the high school presented a challenge for 20th century educators, because they disagreed about whether to emphasize preparation for college or for a vocation. Life-adjustment education, which emerged in the mid-1940s, was the perfect solution, for its supporters, to the conundrum of the secondary school. Vocational education and life-adjustment advocates believed schools should prepare students for their role as responsible adults and that young people should be trained in a vocation and educated in life skills. In the case of the latter, schools would be responsible for teaching students in areas such as industrious habits of mind, personal hygiene, and sociability.

This vocational approach to education received strong opposition from a number of critics, including Robert M. Hutchins, who was the president and chancellor of the University of Chicago from 1929 to 1951. Hutchins believed that the intellectual tradition of education should rest on what he saw as the fundamentals: grammar, logic, rhetoric, natural science, philosophy, and mathematics. He believed it was unwise for education to focus curricula on knowledge that might become obsolete.

Historian Arthur Bestor was also highly critical of the anti-intellectual focus of life-adjustment education. Like Hutchins, he believed that a loss of intellectual training would cause a loss to the industrial prosperity of the nation. From Bestor’s perspective, the primary purpose of school was to develop the intellectual potential of young people. Bestor also placed a special focus on the education of teachers and the requirement that all receive a liberal arts education as part of their training.

Life-adjustment education was popular from roughly 1945 through 1958. A shift back toward the importance of math and science education occurred with the launching of Sputnik, a Soviet Union satellite, in 1957. In the Cold War era, the United States felt threatened by the visible scientific dominance of the Soviet Union. Immediate attention was turned to the math, science, and foreign language capabilities of U.S. students. In the meantime, life-adjustment education critics proposed that years of schooling based on that approach was to blame for the United States’ secondary educational position, when compared to the Soviet Union. This criticism contributed to the eventual demise of life-adjustment education.

To learn more about the history of American education and how it became what it is today, read on in our other articles about how U.S. schooling has changed since its inception back in the days of the early settlers into the system it is today.

Budgeting for Modern Academics: Educating in a Challenged Economy

Education is an ever-shifting field, but recent years have seen tension in what needs to change and the funding available to back those reforms. The Obama Administration’s educational agenda was hampered by the worst economic downturn since the Great Depression. Budget cuts forced school districts to curtail hiring of new teachers and developing incentives for teachers to retire. Additionally, teacher–student ratios expanded even as class sizes increased.

Studies show (and have been replicated several times) that the influence of high-quality teachers on students is significantly more important than any other factors that have been identified. The teacher’s ability to make a genuine connection with each student is vital; however, this important element is being severely undermined in today’s educational environments.

School budgets are not the only entities affected by the economic crisis. Financial difficulties within students’ families also play a huge role in educational problems in the United States. Many American homes are dual-income, with both parents working one or more jobs to try to meet their financial obligations. With more parents scrambling to make ends meet, less time is available for parental involvement in the education of their children.

Parents have less time to teach their children basic fundamentals that were often taught at home when only one parent needed to work. With less time for parents to connect with schools, students may become unmotivated and put less effort into their schoolwork. They also may exhibit behavior problems at school and require more time and effort from school administrators, which in turn detracts from administrators’ efforts to improve schools.

The past decade or so has seen economic turmoil and global upheaval. Having to simultaneously deal with multiple areas of financial stress has left the U.S. government budget stretched thin. Has unsteady economic status affected your school? Has it affected you personally? How have you seen financial strain affect the educators around you?

To learn more about how education has handled economic and other plights over the centuries and where it may be heading now, check out our other articles on the subject of education and its historical trends.

The Problem with Education That’s Driven by Sanctions

Legislature passed during the 20th century was well-intentioned but has left 21st century education with a system featuring many nonviable aspects, and educational reform is only just now starting to figure out how to even begin to remedy history’s mistakes.

A major problem facing the nation’s school systems is that our children are over-tested, sometimes to an extreme. Still, the nation relies heavily on standardized testing as an indication that students are progressing toward established goals. Nationwide testing creates the risk of losing a broad variety of learning experiences and critical thinking instruction so valuable in high-quality education.

Testing often tends to focus on a narrow spectrum of items that can be easily assessed. However, higher-order skills such as analysis and reasoning are more critical in the real world and at the college level. Progressive teachers now are engaged in cooperative learning with students. The emphasis is on producing students who can think at a critical level and is a reflection of society’s influence.

The effectiveness of the NCLB sanctions is debatable. With so much pressure on schools, administrators, teachers, and students, it is important to understand whether the sanctions really facilitate improved performance. State tests that place teachers or administrators in some type of jeopardy—such as job retention, prestige, and income—have been compared to assessments such as the National Assessment of Educational Progress (NAEP), which has no potential penalties. Results seemed to indicate that state assessments generally showed an upward trend, but when compared to the NAEP, the results did not correlate well.

Even states that have modest rigor in their expectations of their school system are found to be failing under the NCLB Act. Simple, cookie-cutter assessment requirements and mandatory sanctions do not allow enough flexibility in achieving improvement. It is telling to observe that, in a relatively short amount of time, most state education systems have turned away from high-pressure and serious sanction methods such as those required by NCLB. These systems now propose a method whereby moderate pressure is used to extract desired changes. This appears to produce much better results.

To learn more about why NCLB was passed in the first place and where modern educational reform is headed, check out our series of articles on the history of America’s school system and where it’s trending towards now.

The 21st Century’s Alternative Approaches to Education

The 21st century has seen a boom in alternative schooling. But what are these other educational systems? How do they work? What is their draw? In this article, we talk some of the most common alternative schools that have come to prominence over the recent decades.

Charter schools are K–12 schools that receive government money but are freed from the usual constraints of public schools in exchange for increased accountability for academic achievement, delineated in the school’s charter. Charter schools were originally conceived by Ray Budde, a professor at the University of Massachusetts Amherst, in 1988. Minnesota was the first state to develop a charter school law in 1991.

In the early 2010s, charter schools began receiving great deal of attention as an alternative to traditional public schools. Although many have lauded charter schools as emblematic of reform and possibility, several factors are important to consider when discussing them. One of those points is accountability. Even though charter schools receive public funds, they are not accountable in the traditional manner. They must meet specified standards of performance, but have no agreed-upon level of performance across state lines, so the levels of evaluating and monitoring these types of schools vary widely across the country (this will change with the implementation of CCSS, especially for states that receive Race to the Top funds). Many local, state, and federal standards must still be met, but some are waived.

Another learning environment that is taking hold in the 21st century is the online format. Standards for judging the effectiveness of this type of teaching and learning environment have not been established, primarily because this form of education is so new. Charter schools have embraced online learning and often use this method of education delivery (in part or as a total mode). Because this mode of education is growing in popularity, a method of tracking performance is being developed.

Yet another educational option is homeschooling, with parents providing instruction to their children at home. According to the National Center for Education Statistics, an estimated 1.1 million children are being homeschooled. State-by-state standards for homeschooling need to be addressed. As it stands, very few states choose to exercise control over homeschools. Those states that do show some control may require homeschooled children to pass state-appropriate grade-level assessments.

Lastly, the voucher program has been toyed with since the 1950s. Practical problems make it difficult to implement the use of vouchers. It is difficult, for example, to come up with an equal system when private schools and public schools may have widely varying costs per pupil. And eligibility requirements for particular categories of students have never been established. Currently, students can fall into widely divergent categories, depending on the school system involved. Categories could range from autistic students to disabled students to students grouped by age, income, or residence.

The use of private vouchers, as it turns out, is less popular than the vouchers associated with public systems. In the private voucher systems, monies are typically collected from individual donors, such as religious organizations or corporations. The funds are then awarded through grants to low-income families. A similar program to the voucher system involves tax credit programs.

Expenses for schooling are credited through the tax system with reimbursements. While the voucher and tax credit programs may appear to be controlled by market forces, that is not the case in practice. Issues have arisen during the administration of these types of programs, including limits on particular students allowed to participate, the entanglement of bureaucracy, and monetary limits.

Public schooling may still have some issues to sort out, but that statement is true for alternative schools, too. New methods may bypass some of public school’s problems, but they are not yet flawless. Hopefully, as schools move forward into the 21st century, powerful educational reform will help school systems of all types shape up and shoot forward.