Uncategorized

Surviving and Thriving in a Teacher Preparation Program

A teacher preparation program does exactly what you think it should do- it prepares teachers to teach. However, the details are a little more complex.

There are two main routes taken by those individuals wishing to become teachers. The first and most common route is that of earning a degree in Education from a four-year University. This option is rather straightforward. The second option, however, is made for individuals who did not earn a college degree in Education. Instead, these individuals will complete what is called an Alternative Certification Program.

Who participates in teacher preparation programs?

Alternative Certification Programs have increased in popularity in recent years. Many states are currently suffering from teacher shortages and have therefore introduced such programs to allow individuals without an Education degree to still become teachers. People who choose the alternative certification route often did not grow up wanting to become a teacher but decided this later in life. Those in these teacher preparation programs can be:

  •         Workers in industry who want to utilize their practical knowledge in the classroom
  •         College students who want to teach but do not want to change their major to Education
  •         Individuals who have worked in another field but are looking for a career change
  •         Anyone who desires to become a teacher

Most elementary teachers choose the traditional route to certification, but most secondary teachers choose an Alternative Certification Program.

What is required in a teacher preparation program?

The alternative certification route does not require a degree in Education, but a college degree is required, usually in a major related to the subject you want to teach. For instance, someone with a B.A. in History could join a teacher preparation program with the goal of becoming a Social Studies teacher.

The requirements of different teacher preparation programs vary by state, but in general, you will be required to complete some variation of the following:

  •         Classroom observations
  •         Short preparation coursework (usually online)
  •         Pass at least one teaching certification exam

How can I survive and thrive in a teacher preparation program?

The requirements of a teacher preparation program can seem overwhelming, but certain best-practices can help alleviate unnecessary stress:

  •         Complete your teacher observations before summer starts. It may seem obvious that you won’t be able to observe teachers teaching in their classrooms when school is not in session, but many people overlook this, especially if they plan to complete all of their teacher preparation requirements over the summer. Many school districts are strict about their observation hours, so make sure you contact the schools well in advance of your observation hours being due.
  •         Pass your certification exam(s) as soon as possible. If you have passed your certification exam but are still needing to complete your observation hours and coursework, it is still possible for some school districts to hire you. However, if you have not yet passed your exam, you will certainly not be hired for a teaching job, so make sure passing this exam is your top priority.
  •         Attend job fairs. Most teacher preparation programs will give you exclusive access to teacher job fairs in your area. Almost all new teachers are hired this way, so take the job fairs extremely seriously. Dress professionally, bring your resume and certification exam scores, and attend all of them! Finding your first teaching job can be stressful, but you are much more likely to be hired quickly if you attend every job fair possible. Some job fairs even hire on the spot!
  •         Take your certification requirements seriously. If you slack off on completing your certification coursework and other requirements, you may find yourself without a teaching job when the school year begins. Regardless of whatever else is going on in your life, you must persevere and be dedicated to completing your certification requirements as fast as possible. It may be stressful for a few months while you juggle a full-time office job and your multiple children at home while trying to complete all of your certification requirements, but it is imperative that you finish them in a timely manner so that you can begin interviewing for teaching positions before the school year begins.

Overall, the key to not only surviving but thriving, in a teacher preparation program is your level of dedication to completing the requirements and learning as much as possible about the profession in the time you’ve got.

Teacher Compensation vs. Professions with Similar Education

It’s no secret that teachers have been historically underpaid, even when one fails to consider the additional, unpaid work time spent outside of the classroom grading papers and writing lesson plans. However, many individuals fail to realize just how bad the teacher pay gap has been growing recently; compared to other professions that require a Bachelor’s degree. Teachers across the country earn, on average, 18.7% less. Even compensating for the fact that teachers generally are afforded better healthcare and vacation benefits, this wage gap still hovers around 11%.

Have teachers always been paid less?

While the average weekly wages of other college-educated professionals have risen steadily over the past 20 years, the average American teacher weekly wages have fallen when adjusting for inflation. The 18.7% average American wage gap is simply that, an average. 

The data is more telling when each individual state is examined. Wyoming, for instance, compensates their teachers relatively well compared to similar professions, with teachers in Wyoming earning only 3% less than their college-educated peers. However, in states such as Arizona and Colorado, the wage gap reaches 36%.

In Michigan, for instance, the average starting salary of teachers is around $36,000 per year, substantially lower than almost every other profession which requires a Bachelor’s degree. In 2017, public school teachers across America earned an average of $1,137 per week, while other full-time workers with college degrees earned an average of $1,476 in the same amount of time. Over the past decade, the average American teacher salary has increased by 15.2%, but when inflation is accounted for, teacher salaries have actually decreased by 3%.

With such a large wage gap amidst such a stressful job, is it any wonder that at least 30 out of the 50 states have reported significant teacher shortages?

Do teachers work less than other professionals?

While admitting that these wage gaps are high, many individuals believe teachers earn less simply because less work is required of them. For instance, critics may point out that teachers have the summer off of work, which means they should be paid less because they spend less time working. However, simply because teachers are not in their regular classroom during summer, does not mean that teachers are not working. 

Many teachers opt to teach summer school or take on a second job to use their “time off” to gain financial stability. Many teachers also use summertime to study for and take their certification exams for additional subjects and grade levels or to update expiring certifications. Teachers may also plan for the upcoming school year, including spending an average of $500 per school year on supplies out of their own pocket. Many teachers also earn graduate degrees during the summer to advance their careers. This extra time working during the summer is not compensated for.

Clearly, teachers must be dedicated professionals in order to stay with their current jobs under such financial hardships. Still, many dedicated teachers simply cannot afford to continue with their current careers given the financial circumstances. They have families to support and bills to pay. Can we blame them for wanting their efforts to be recognized?

Teacher Education Needs a Structural Change

Teacher education is the education a teacher receives in order to prepare for the teaching profession. Teacher education programs can be combined with a university degree in Education, or they can be part of an Alternative Certification Program in which an individual with a degree in something other than Education is prepared to become part of the Education career field. Apart from pre-teaching requirements, teacher education also includes the many hours of continuing education and professional development required of teachers who are already working in classrooms.

Why does teacher education need to change?

The issue is, many teachers feel extremely unprepared upon entering the classroom for the first time, even if they have completed their teacher education requirements with flying colors. In one study done by the National Center for Education Statistics (NCES), teachers who had recently completed a teacher education program or professional development in a particular topic with high levels of engagement did not feel more adequately prepared to implement what they had just learned than the teachers who had not recently completed such requirements. 

In addition, studies done by the NCES and The Civil Rights Project have found that, upon completing teacher education requirements, a majority of secondary-school teachers still feel unprepared for the classroom, especially when it comes to helping students who are English Language Learners or who have special needs.

The National Council on Teacher Quality, which evaluates the efficacy of teachers and teacher preparation programs, rated 134 teacher education programs across America, about 10% which prepared Elementary teachers and 90% which prepared Secondary teachers. They found that three-fourths of those 134 programs did not meet the five basic standards that constitute a high-quality teacher preparation program. 

A large part of this problem exists simply because these programs are not well-regulated. For instance, many teacher preparation programs require student teaching as part of the curriculum. Student teaching consists of a soon-to-be-teacher observing and assisting a certified, veteran teacher in an actual classroom setting. 

But the National Council on Teacher Quality found that most of the teacher education programs they rated did not have requirements for the length of time the student teacher must be with the students, nor did they have vetting programs or quality requirements for the cooperating certified teacher who would be acting as a mentor by facilitating the student-teacher experience.

Teacher education needs a structural change

Despite the high levels of teacher unpreparedness arising from lackluster teacher education programs, it is often teachers that get blamed for education’s ills. Teachers quit their jobs at the highest rates on record, especially during the first few years of being in the classroom. Perhaps this is because most teachers aren’t fully aware of what they are getting into. 

When teacher education programs fail to reconcile the “ideal” classroom with that of reality, teachers are often shocked to find how difficult the profession can prove to be on a daily basis, especially in regard to classroom management. This is especially ironic considering that the NCES study found that soon-to-be-teachers felt most prepared in the area of classroom management, possibly because they were not shown the realities of modern American classrooms. Even many classroom observation requirements for Alternative Certification Programs can be completed in online classrooms in many states. 

This is hardly providing naive student-teachers with an accurate picture of reality. Perhaps if teacher education programs were more open about the difficulties of the profession, teachers would be able to rise to the standard that school districts expect of them. Under the current circumstances, however, many teachers are not taught how to improve. If we want our nation’s teachers to be the best they can possibly be, it is only fair to teach them how to do so.

Teacher Effectiveness: How to Develop What Matters Most

Bill Sanders, a teacher effectiveness researcher, gained astonishing insight into the overall outcomes of effective teachers and their students. He found that, among third-grade students who performed similarly academically, those that were subsequently placed with three highly-rated teachers in a row out-performed those students who were placed with three poorly-rated teachers in a row by a 52nd percentile point difference. 

The Rand Corporation has even claimed that teacher quality is the single most powerful influence on student achievement, with three times the effect on test scores as any other educational factor.

How do we define effective teachers?

Obviously, teacher quality is important. But how do we define and measure great teachers? Well, according to students, great teachers are those that make learning fun and those that truly care about building personal relationships with their students. Students are more likely to strive for academic success in class when they know that their teacher respects them as a whole person- not just as an academic data point.

Effective teachers foster a sense of community in the classroom where mistakes are used as learning opportunities rather than reasons for ridicule. And, when the teacher is enthusiastic about learning, the students are more likely to feed off of this enthusiasm as well. Additionally, effective teachers set high expectations for all students- they do not group all low-performing students together or call on them less frequently than their high-performing peers. 

In the classroom of an effective teacher, every student is treated as an equal, and every student understands that they have the potential to accomplish whatever they set their mind to.

 

How to improve teacher effectiveness

Unfortunately for many students, great teachers are not in every classroom. This is partially due to the fact that many teachers do not know what skills they should be improving upon, let alone how to improve those skills. 

The New Teacher Project found that, in the year 2009, 98% of the teachers out of the 14 evaluated school districts were given a rating of “satisfactory.” This rating system is hardly beneficial to teachers or their students. In the last decade, some school districts have taken it upon themselves to improve teacher rating systems by creating more detailed evaluation systems with room for improvement on every front, even for the most veteran teachers.

For instance, many school districts are now using the updated TES rating system in which five levels- needs improvement, developing, proficient, accomplished, and distinguished are used to evaluate teachers on multiple factors from classroom management, to lesson planning abilities, to teacher involvement in the student community. With this rating system, a genuinely good teacher is rated as “proficient,”  implying that there is still much room for growth on the path to becoming a truly outstanding teacher.

It is important to remember that becoming an effective teacher takes both time and effort- teachers don’t become great right away, nor do they become great if they simply slide through the school year without a determined effort to improve every day. But teachers who consistently focus on improving those skills- such as relationship building- that seem to have the highest effect on student achievement, without becoming distracted by the non-essentials- such as a perfectly decorated classroom- are destined to become the teachers that students will thank for the rest of their lives.

Reinventing the Way We Measure Family Outcomes

The lack of family focus and inability to measure family outcomes has many people wondering if we need to reevaluate this entire process. Connecticut’s Office of Early Childhood recently publicly proclaimed their initiative to reinvent how government organizations can interact with families. The goal of this new method is to measure the outcomes of voluntary at-home visits and acknowledging when financial incentive is reasonable.

Connecticut has been at the forefront of many advancements in the past, and they are once again leading the country in a more positive direction. As the first program of its kind, the department is working to join parental programs and welfare policies while incentivizing success. 

What are Home Visitation Services?

These services include any involvement of a trained professional nurse, peer educator, or social worker. Previously the Office of Early Childhood had different policies governing each aspect of home visitation services.

Now, the focus is on working with families, not just the children. During home visitation services, the professionals involved will observe, interact, and report on child and parent well-being. Even medical aspects such as brain development and growth milestones, which seem limited to the child involved, can impact the parent’s daily life as well.  

Programs which provide home visitation services include:

  •     Healthy Families of America
  •     Nurse-Family Partnership
  •     Parents as Teachers

The programs all strive to provide parents with professional help to:

  •     Develop parenting skills
  •     Support social development
  •     Support emotional development
  •     Build the relationship between parent and child

Home visitation services have had a substantial impact on family outcomes. When families can access these programs and develop within their homes, children show increased well-being. Parents also show improvement in returning to work or school.

What is the Best Way to Measure Family Outcomes?

At-risk people and families, which contain at-risk individuals, need guidance. They also need tangible metrics to identify successful outcomes from program failure. The Office of Early Childhood now uses a rate card system.

What defines success and what is available for the state to “purchase” for families? There are four metrics on Connecticut’s rate card:

  1.     Healthy Birth
  2.     Safe Children
  3.     Family Stability
  4.     Caregiver Employment

The rate card system comes with two sides. First is a clear standard of expectations for families. Second, it’s a type of menu which the state will “order” from, and the family should deliver in exchange for a financial initiative.

Where is this funding coming from? Although some of it is through government funding, much of it also comes from the philanthropic community.

Those deemed “at-risk,” including infants, children, and parents have access to services through the Connecticut Office of Early Childhood. Since Connecticut announced their initiative, many private programs, and regionalized county or state offices outside of Connecticut have adopted similar initiatives. 

Racial Justice is Education Justice

From talks on equal opportunity to seeing it in action, racial inconsistencies are still woven deep throughout the educational system. Lower-income minority families typically have a harder time accessing everything that higher-income white families receive from their education systems. Why? Private schools, better local funding, and more involvement from philanthropic entities make it difficult for government-funded schools to compete with schools in higher-income areas.

Traditionally, low-income regions have a higher percentage of minorities and a more diverse mix of racial groups. Racial justice is having a substantial impact as the term equality is changing, and it’s impacting how people think about balance within the education system.

Discussing Race in School

Is it okay to consider race in school? Is it not? Not discussing race and racism does not make the thoughts or actions of any individual go away. However, addressing race, specifically in school, can create the opportunity to cultivate a conversation within an environment of understanding.

Discussing race doesn’t have to come from a counselor or the principal. However, the topic is so sensitive that many teachers and administrators feel they are not the right person to broach the subject.

Suggestions for discussing race in the classroom are:

  •     Proactively plan for all students involved to have the opportunity to speak about their background and first-hand experiences with racism.
  •     Have planned reactions to slights or insults which are bound to happen in any school.
  •     Know which topics present relevant and insightful learning opportunities for race discussions and which do not.

When discussing race and racism, carefully steer the conversation back to equality as the overarching goal. Don’t allow students to cycle through blaming or shaming after the point has been made.

Supporting New Policies and Making Change

How does change happen? Most often, change happens on a personal level before it becomes integrated with policies. The teaching staff, even reading assignments, can become part of personal transformation. 

However, we must focus on the critical part, reaching students. Ultimately policy support comes from people personally involved and supportive of the changes. With many policies and proposals in motion, you can become personally involved too.

The Current Funding System – Is It Fair?

Although it varies from state to state, there is a formula for funding in nearly every education system within the U.S. Schools often receive funding from the U.S. Federal government, state programs, and local funding through property taxes. Funding formulas take these funds and then distribute them based on various factors.

Is the system fair? Not necessarily. Different areas come with different needs; however, setting one flat rate in funding per student is probably the fairest approach. The question is, is there a way to use a flat rate system to ensure that all students receive the education that they deserve, without getting into affirmative action debates?

Recognizing Specific Subtypes of Reading, Math, Spelling, and Written Language Disorders in Children

While parents will primarily focus on physical or social milestones in their child’s development, learning milestones are left mainly to educators. Administrators and teachers can play critical roles in identifying various subtypes of learning disorders in children. Early identification can be vital in helping the individual overcome the challenges of the disorder and assisting the family in understanding it as well.

Reading and Spelling Disorders

Reading and spelling disorders will often stem from a type of dyslexia. The various types of dyslexia, however, are impossible to treat equally.

Phonological dyslexia can make it difficult for children to decode words and will often lead to reading issues but not spelling issues. The challenge that is unique to this subtype of reading disorder is that children cannot match the written symbol with the appropriate sound.

Surface dyslexia is a spelling disorder that can put significant strain on children as they learn various spelling syntax. For example, the difference in spelling height and bite can be difficult to remember to spell and to sight-read.

Math Disorders

Although it’s not as well-known as dyslexia, a subtype math disorder called dyscalculia impacts about 3 to 6% of students. Similar to dyslexia, dyscalculia makes it difficult to understand the language of math. 

Math disorders will often go undiagnosed. However, if your child or a student in your class seems to have significant struggles with calculations and mathematical reasoning, consider testing them.

Identifying subtypes of math disorders can lead to a more patient approach, and the use of different teaching methods. The combination of the change in practices and patience can lead to successful outcomes.

Written Language Disorders

Written language disorders will often impact both reading and spelling abilities in students. This confusion, particularly among education staff who aren’t medically trained to diagnosis subtypes of learning disorders, can lead to a false and informal diagnosis of “dyslexia” without any given subtype.

Sentence and discourse stand as the lesser diagnosed subtype of written language disorders. This disorder has roots in writing composition and projects as an inability or struggle to grasp concepts such as commonly bound morphemes, or the conjugation of a verb.

What Can Early Identification Do for Children?

Within the educational and sometimes legal system, a learning disorder is the umbrella term applied to many disorders that impact learning ability. Identifying the specific subtype, however, often comes with a medical diagnosis or diagnosis from a qualified professional such as a speech pathologist. 

When the child involved receives a formal diagnosis of a specific subtype of a learning disorder, we can approach their education in different ways. Innovative learning techniques, more understanding or dedicated educational staff, and parents who take a hands-on approach to learning should be the response to this diagnosis.

Without the early identification of specific subtypes of a learning disorder, children may continue to feel that they can’t succeed. There are also issues of handling rejection from academics-based activities and not being able to participate in afterschool activities because of a mounting workload. 

Identification is critical to give children with learning disorders of any type a fair chance at educational success.

Improving Assessment in eLearning Programs

The nuances of assessment, measurement, and teaching are grossly interdependent. No one is measuring what is being taught; instead, what is being measured is what is taught. The importance of assessment has taken precedence over many other factors that are part of quality education.

Because assessment directs teachers, it’s vital to ensure that it’s a stable pillar within the educational system. So why is assessment one of the weakest components in eLearning?

Out-of-Date Skills Assessments

Most schools need to reassess how they structure eLearning assessments. The out-of-date evaluations, such as STAR testing and tests that stem from that model, are causing all manner of issues.

Of course, assessment is necessary. Assessment is simply any procedure which gathers or obtains information about the extent of student learning. The mindset around assessment, however, and needs to change. There must be strict components that make up an evaluation of eLearning programs as well as student performance. 

When considering assessment in an eLearning program, it may be critical to involve both summative and formative assessments. These together can deliver the whole picture, rather than an insight into hard-skills alone.

Hesitancy to Assess with Transparency

eLearning programs often cater to those in continuing education, which can bring some hesitancy in transparency. Programs may not want to assess whether students have shown sufficient progress summatively. It is possible that testing may expose ineffective teaching or delivery methods.

However, transparency is necessary. Without knowing if the student is making progress, it’s unfair to say that eLearning is a better option. Although eLearning has proven to be a saving grace to some, it may be exchanging success for convenience for other people.

Transparent assessment often relies on progress tracking. Using a student’s progress, you can answer questions such as, “Is the program working?” and “Is the student gaining everything they can from the material?”

Focusing on Retaining Facts v. Focus on Conceptual Knowledge

Elearning programs have had a long-time struggle assessing conceptual knowledge. Conceptual knowledge can be thought of as the ability to calculate, versus the ability to understand the concept behind a mathematical model. It’s the difference between memorizing a set of numbers and understanding why something is useful and essential.

For many students, especially those in eLearning programs, they are tired of traditional learning environments. In some cases, they feel that the memorize and pass tests model has set them up for failure. ELearning programs must adapt their assessments to focus on conceptual and factual knowledge. Testing for facts is essential. However, memorization is not enough to lead to long-term success.

A lot of study and investigation goes into learning how to assess conceptual understanding. Generally speaking, more work goes into crafting these assessments as you must provide a context for the student to use throughout the test. Giving students something to think about might include an excerpt of introductory text, a scenario, or resource material.

Overall there is a substantial amount of room to improve assessment within the eLearning environment. Using concept knowledge assessment and assessing with transparency will likely yield the best results.

Private Colleges in Peril: Financial Pressures and Declining Enrollment May Lead to More Closures

Financial pressure is leading to more and more colleges closing or considering closure. To those who work closely with the financial health of their financial institutions, closure is becoming a genuine possibility. Between 2016 and 2018, the confidence from private college’s CFO’s about their institution’s financial future dropped from 54% to 44%.

Where is this financial pressure coming from, and why are the student’s not enrolling? There are many factors contributing to these two issues, and it doesn’t look like there is a single solution for both problems. 

Affordability and Recruitment Efforts

Public colleges are not receiving substantial funding, and their budgets are shrinking. So how are they still attracting more students and at lower prices? The model they’re using is playing on a concept that is so hard for private colleges to understand.

Lower tuition prices bring in more students. It’s like ordering higher education off the dollar menu. However, the affordability isn’t the only contributing aspect to consider in this bit. Public colleges are also able to put more effort into recruitment.

Where private colleges may advertise online, through content marketing, or even on TV, a public college has an entire region. They have the name of the state behind them, are often deeply connected with high schools throughout the area, and they reach students before they graduate. Their recruitment efforts make it seem like the natural next step for high school students.

The Free Tuition Movement

Even throughout the early 1960s, tuition was affordable in most states. Now, almost 50 years later, tuition has hit an unattainable amount. Students who graduate now will live in debt for years if not decades. It’s gotten so extreme that many politicians who remember the days of affordable higher-education, are trying to make changes. 

Numerous states are involved in setting the stage of a free-tuition movement. New York, leading the nation, began offering “tuition-free” education for lower and middle-class students.

Do Private Colleges Stand a Chance?

While there have been significant fluctuations in private colleges ability to thrive before, they may likely bounce back from this decline. However, financial management is only one aspect of repairing the private college’s standing.

Not only do private colleges need to put greater consideration into their financial management but they also need to keep their tuition affordable as well. These contradicting needs put CFO’s and other financial managers in a tight spot. 

Many recommend that private colleges increase their efforts in recruitment and become more involved with their students and high schools in the region. Working with local schools will no doubt increase exposure, but it also means entering a highly competitive market.

While private colleges struggle with navigating these troubled waters, there seems to be little hope for their recovery.

It is Necessary to Disseminate Multicultural Standards in Higher Education

Multiculturalism, particularly in higher education, can come with substantial payoffs for the students. So, is it necessary to spread this concept, or to forcefully integrate multicultural standards? Is it happening on its own?

Correcting Concepts of Inferiority in Education Environments

One of the many problems that occur when disseminating multicultural standards is that many individuals may believe that their culture is superior to others. Often this stems from a sense of ancestral or cultural pride. Attempting to dampen that pride hardly ever has a positive outcome.

How can higher education leaders ensure that they are correcting concepts of superior and inferior cultures? When working with students in a higher learning environment, you’re often interacting with young adults who are capable of analysis and critical thinking.

Relying on those two skills, it is possible and reasonable to expect adults from various cultures to develop cultural relativism. The underlying idea is that cultural relativism will lead adults to understand that cultures are different, but not better or worse than any other culture.

The university environment is the perfect platform for these discussions. It is in a multicultural environment focused on learning, where people can assess the cultural norms they grew up with and learn from others who had different experiences.

The Case for Blending Cultures

Thought leaders Sleeter and Flores who have published research on the topic of multicultural teaching, both note that social interactions within multicultural education environments have fewer instances of prejudice. It is possible that multiculturalism, with its ability to blend cultures and define similarities between outwardly opposite cultures, leads to less social stereotyping. 

There are many benefits of blending cultures. Among the many cultures worldwide, there are underlying themes of self-esteem, actualizing self, identifying personal potential, rights, responsibility, and a community. However, not every culture is as individualistic and focused on the themes mentioned here.

That doesn’t mean that in a community-based culture the self is without mention. For example, in a culture that places family above self, the individual’s self-confidence may be lesser in exchange for strategic interdependence within the family unit.

When blending cultures, the result often leads young adults to take the best of both worlds. Those raised in individualistic cultures may find great joy in community-based atmospheres, whereas those who contributed to a community-based culture may find strength in working on themselves. 

Taking Conscious and Purposeful Action

University leaders, staff members, teachers, and administrators must all take note of the spread of a multicultural presence within their institution. Although many are happy to see the emergence of young adults coming into their own, there is the possibility of adverse effects.

Bring staff together to determine conscious and purposeful ways to impact the multicultural environment within your school. Are multicultural codes in place to ensure ethical conduct from students and staff? Do students and staff have the tools to make decisions regarding a student’s intrinsic value of their self and community?