As an avid reader, I pride
myself on staying abreast of the latest advances in every human endeavor,
especially education. So when I read a magazine article
that discussed how researchers are using genetic data from students to
personalize their education, my curiosity was piqued. However, at the same
time, the ethical implications of using eugenics in the field of education
mortified me. As an African American man, I have studied the insulting eugenic research
that was used to back up claims that black people were just not as intelligent
as the other races.
Before I totally dismissed the idea, I decided to read the article
in its entirety before making assumptions. It seems that researchers are
attempting to personalize learning by giving schools the ability to create
individualized curriculum programs based on a student’s DNA profile.
I came to the conclusion that just like its predecessors,
this new wave of eugenics has the potential to perpetuate
reckless and harmful thoughts and conclusions about the genetic heritability
of intelligence. Even if the scientist’s intentions are pure, we need to discuss
how educational policy and law should regulate this new era of genetic
forecasting.
What will we see in
the next decade?
Over the last decade, studies in human genomics have
flourished. The subfield of educational
genomics attempts to isolate and identify the genetic factors that
determine individual differences in achievement, motivation, behavior, and intelligence. As we alluded to earlier, trying
to link genetics and intelligence is a dicey subject.
Recent genetic studies have found correlations between
intelligence test scores and certain genes, with more than 500 genes having a purported
influence on intelligence test scores. Historically, similar types of studies
have been used to suggest that certain races are genetically predisposed to be
intellectually superior, while others are genetically predisposed to be intellectually
inferior. Thankfully, these studies were debunked and proven to be untrue, but still, their legacy lives on, with many people
believing them to be sound.
Recent genetic studies of educational genomics do not attempt
to prove there is a specific gene or a genetic
factor that influences learning ability, or that their research can explain the
complexity of the learning process. Also, isolating someone’s genotype, which is a person’s complete genetic makeup,
and correlating it to intelligence, learning or student outcomes is too complex
for education researchers to unravel.
Education genomics today tries to find patterns in the genetic
data of millions of people in the hopes that they can use this information to explain
how genetics influence our cognitions, behaviors, motivation, etc.
Where educational genomics has a chance to do some good
Proponents of
educational genomics argue that there is nothing nefarious about their research
and that it can be used to personalize the teaching and learning process to respond
to each student’s unique needs. I admit that this is an intriguing concept, and if
it is genuine, then I could see where it could do some good.
The idea of “precision education” has started to disseminate itself
among researchers who engage with education, psychology, neuroscience, and genomics. In turn, they are using this information to fully understand how the
human brain learns new ideas and skills. This concept of precision education is
part of the growing field of brain science, which seeks to develop a nuanced
understanding of the teaching and learning process by using studying and
researching the human mind, brain, and
genome.
I am excited to see how education genomics will be used to
usher in a new phase of evidence-based policies and practices in education. One
new development in educational genomics that I find particularly interesting is
“genome-wide
polygenic scoring” (GPS). A polygenic score is derived by isolating
and analyzing a large number of genetic markers in an attempt to predict a specific
psychological or behavioral trait.
Thanks to the increased computer processing power of the
modern world, it may soon become possible to predict academic achievement in
schools. This turning point in education genomics is still in its infancy, but
it shows lots of promise, although it may be decades before this method is
perfected. I have read studies that claim to have perfected this ability, but
the data tells me otherwise.
The collateral damage
of educational genomics
Whenever a field of inquiry grows at a rate that outpaces
regulations, laws, and policies, there is a chance for gross abuses. On the one
hand, the field could help to personalize and differentiate instruction, but it
could also lead us to perpetuate a trope and narrative that intelligence is
fixed and solely determined by your genetics. This could lead to a dystopian
education system where students are
separated based on their genetic profiles, which will preclude them from having
their actual abilities and efforts supported or recognized.
The scenario reminds me of the movie Gattaca, starring Ethan Hawke
and Uma Thurman. The film presents a dystopian look inside of a future society
dominated and driven by eugenics, where children are created through genetic selection
to ensure they have the best hereditary traits of both parents. The film’s lead
character is Vincent Freemen, played by Hawke, who was conceived the old fashioned
way and fought to overcome genetic discrimination to fulfill his
dream of going into space. The film espouses
concern over the field of eugenics and
the possible consequences that scientific advances can have on our society.
Also, the idea of
education genomics is not without its issues. There is a reason to believe that intelligence tests based
on genetics may be woefully flawed. Also, the predictive power of methods such
as GPS is extremely weak. And when dubious research creates a public frenzy,
shady companies come out of the woodworks trying to make a quick buck.
This is certainly occurring
in the field of educational genomics and eugenics, as commercial companies
are already selling DNA tests that misleadingly promise to predict the future
intelligence of the owner of the assessed genome. This type of testing may take
our attention away from the things that truly shape intelligence, including nurturance,
school and teacher quality, diet, childhood trauma, stress, etc.
A more pressing concern arises as parents might want to use
this information to predict a child’s future academic and physical abilities,
and “artificially select future generations.” This is already being
done by parents worldwide but on a small
scale. Eugenic researchers seem to be obsessed with finding the genetic code
for high IQ.
This creates a scenario were selective-intelligence could be
used by world leaders to create a society of “Übermensch”
(supermen). This term was coined by philosopher Friedrich Nietzsche, in
his 1883 book Thus Spoke
Zarathustra. Hitler, in turn, used the concept of the “Übermensch” (Superman) to describe his idea of a
biologically superior Aryan or Germanic master race; a racial version
of Nietzsche’s Übermensch
became the central philosophical basis for National Socialist ideas.
Conclusion
The reality of it all is that the concept of using educational
genomics to personalize education is still in its infancy. We are right to
remember the dark past of educational genomics and eugenics, as those who do
not learn from the past are destined to repeat it. There is a need for regulated,
empirical research to be performed on the field’s viability as well as the
potential grim consequences of its work.
We need to ensure that we understand how the genetic datafication of student potential will affect how students are treated and influence
their self-esteem and motivation. If we are not careful, educational genomics could
become a repeat of the Rosenthal-Jacobs
Study, that ended in students performing according
to self-fulfilling prophecies (Pygmalion Effect), or the expectations of
their teachers.