Uncategorized

We Need to Get a Handle on the School Funding Conundrum

America needs to get a handle on its school funding conundrum. To describe our issues with school funding as a conundrum seems a bit far-fetched, but is it really? Let me explain. In American the education reform arena, some pundits cite school funding as a threat to education equity and on a deeper level, the nation itself. They opine about the huge differences in funding that we see in high-poverty schools as opposed to middle class or affluent schools.

In short, they would like to see the school funding formulas that fund schools in a more equitable way. Meaning, they want all schools to receive the same amount of per school funding. And on the face of it, I don’t think that it is a bad idea, but it is not a panacea. Why, because fully funding all schools at an equal rate does not provide a solution to human error and fiscal mismanagement.

Let me give you an example. I once worked in a high poverty school district that was eventually taken over by the state of Mississippi, because of financial mismanagement. Albeit five years after I left. The thing that hurt students the most was not the amount of funding that the school district received, but what administrators did with it. I won’t provide conjecture as to why the school district basically went bankrupt but let’s just say some administrators were asleep at the wheel and some had their hand in the cookie jar.

Here is another example. I once worked at an elementary school in an urban school district where the administrators were honest, but asleep at the wheel. For instance, because this school had a high concentration of Title 1 students (low-income students), it was designated as a Title 1 school, and as a result, received Title 1 funding. Before I get to the meat of this example, I feel it is necessary for me to explain what Title 1 is.

Title 1 is the largest federally funded educational program. Essentially, it provides supplemental funds to school districts who have the largest concentrations of poverty. These funds are meant to close the school funding gap and help these schools meet their educational goals. The federal government uses the number of students who receive free or reduced lunch to determine how much money each school will be allocated. Title 1 funds can be used to improve curriculum, instructional activities, counseling, parental engagement, or to hire teachers and other staff members.

So back to my example. Unaware of all the things that Title one could be used for, or simply overwhelmed by the school year, my principal spent the bulk of her funds on instructional and curriculum materials. Sounds like a good idea, doesn’t it? Well, the problem is, teachers already had more materials than they could use in 3 lifetimes. As a result, these materials were housed in several storage closets in the auditorium and were never user. How do I know this?

As a special education teacher, my job was that of a floater, which meant that most of my day was spent visiting and supporting students that were mainstreamed into regular education classrooms. One day, my principal asked if I would help the janitors with some boxes of instructional materials that had just arrived. I did, and we moved the shipment into closets that where located in the auditorium. I was aghast to find two huge closets, filled with boxes of instructional materials that had never been opened. There had to be over $50,000 in instructional materials.

I never mentioned this to anyone in the building, but I frequently tell the story to colleagues. This money could have been put to good use, in a school that had students that lived in utter poverty. All in all, this was one of the best principals that I have ever seen, but she couldn’t see the fault in her stars.

I told you these stories to make a point; no amount of school funding will close the achievement gap, without people who know how to allocate resources correctly. In the end, the resources will not be deployed in a way that helps the most vulnerable students. There are countries whose per-pupil expenditure is 1/10 of ours, and yet their school systems are considered to be in the top five globally, and we can’t even crack the top ten.

As far as how we can crack this conundrum, I have my thoughts, but that will have to wait until another day.

Reading skills every teacher can use

When was the last time your asked students to read something in your class?

The chances are good that you gave them a reading assignment sometime this week. It might have even been today. Teachers regularly direct students to read for information, hoping that everyone in the class will comprehend the words and their message.

What happens when your students have difficulty reading the content?

It’s time for you to step up and teach reading skills in your classroom, especially if you don’t teach ELA.

Students who recognize that the skills learned in ELA are transferrable are likely to perform well in your class. Students who have difficulty applying reading strategies outside their reading classes need your assistance. You’ve got to provide reading strategies for accessing the content in your subject area.

Build from the foundation

Learning takes place only when you activate prior knowledge. Your students will have a difficult time learning anything new if they don’t have a robust platform on which to stack news idea and content.

Your job is to help them connect to your content and build on it. Ask your students to relate an experience they have had or predict what might happen next.

Interact with the text

Get your students engaged in reading.

As easy as it may be for you to distribute vocabulary lists among your students, resist the urge to provide your students with everything they will need. Instead, teach your students strategies like identifying and defining new vocabulary, that will help them understand their reading. Try these close reading strategies to improve reading skills. For example, have students make personal connections to the passage. Ask your students to keep a reading journal in which to write down:

  • Their observations and questions
  • Important phrases in headings and sub-headings
  • Gists and summaries
  • Doodles that enhance meaning
  • Curated information from sources

Retell what’s been read

Students retell events from their lives all day long.

Stop the class and ask students to turn to an elbow partner and retell what they just read. Give them 60 seconds and then have them switch so the second student can retell from their reading.

When students can retell what they’ve read, they are synthesizing their reading and learning content.

Include writing

Writing is nearly inseparable from reading, and yet some content area teachers shy away from it. They avoid it because they don’t want to grade compositions.

You don’t have to require your students to write long-form essays to make them better writers and readers. Authentic writing today includes writing summaries, email replies, and lists. Even a hand-written exit ticket requires synthesis between reading and writing. It’s a quick way to demonstrate – and check on – understanding.

Reading isn’t confined to the ELA classroom alone. Your students read every day. They will become more proficient if you help them practice their reading skills in your classroom.

Strategies like these help your students build comprehension and understanding in any content. Being able to comprehend what they’ve read is a skill students will use for the rest of their lives.

3 ways poverty influences learning

Every child deserves a quality education, regardless of race, religion, gender, or socio-economic status. Education provides students with the opportunity to gain equal access to the knowledge and skills they need to create a better life.

Unfortunately, many children come to school already at a disadvantage. Their families live below the poverty line. As a result, these children face challenges that can impact their education.

Poverty has a significant impact on education. In general,

  • Two out of every five children living below the poverty line come to primary school unprepared to keep up with their peers.
  • Children living in poverty are more likely to experience developmental delays.
  • Teenagers from low-income families are more likely to drop out of school.

Health and hardships

Living in poverty can take a toll on health.

Children from families living below the poverty line may suffer from lower birth weight and greater risk of disease. Low-income housing is more likely to have lead paint, calcified pipes, and faulty wiring, and of which places child safety in danger. The children may also develop mental issues.

These difficulties often present in the classroom. Children come to school hungry, ill, or depressed. Some suffer from PTSD and other issues.

It’s essential that low-income families know that there are resources to help them care for their children, including vaccine clinics, counselors, and meal programs.

The literacy gap

Children from low-income families are less likely to be immersed in the spoken and written language. In fact, they have seen and heard 30 million fewer words than children from more affluent families. Children from families living below the poverty line are linguistically anorexic.

Low-income parents are less likely to read to their children, sing to them, or talk with them. Their children are not exposed to language during their critical development years. Books and the Internet are luxuries that families living in poverty often cannot budget for. They aren’t a high priority.

To help low-income children close the literacy gap, teachers must immerse their students in language by reading, singing, and talking. Encourage students to check out resources that can help them catch up to their peers.

High mobility

Stable employment and stable housing go hand in hand.

Parents who follow seasonal work must move their families frequently. Rents go up. Workers must follow opportunity. Families move once again.

High mobility adversely affects the children who are forced to move frequently, withdrawing from one school and enrolling in another. Frequent moves disrupt children’s education.

If children in your classroom experience high mobility, you can help. Get to know and understand the conditions in which they live. Once you know what challenges they face, you can differentiate and scaffold lessons to help students meet high academic expectations.

Some teachers find themselves tempted to lower their expectations of children who live below the poverty line. That’s not what these students need.

The most crucial undertaking for teachers of students living in poverty is to show them empathy. Living in poverty isn’t easy. Let your students know that you understand just how hard it is.

Visit the families. Talk to the children and parents. Then be that ray of hope that points to a better future through education. Light their paths so they can make their way toward more successful and sustainable lives.

Keeping the arts in the curriculum

Children love to perform, and they love to create. Their parents like to watch them act and dance, read the poems they’ve written, and display their artwork. They encourage creativity in their children.

Schools also should encourage creative pursuits and engage students in the arts. Children connect more deeply with the lessons. They look forward to coming to school because they are excited about performing creatively. Increased attendance among students correlates directly to improved student achievement.

Our passion for keeping the arts in the curriculum tends to wax and wane according to accountability demands and funding levels.

The benefits of an arts education

Most educators know about the connection between arts education and academic rigor. Arts education not only inspires students, but it also motivates them. Students exposed to an arts education have:

  • Higher scores in math, reading, and writing
  • Fewer disciplinary referrals
  • Better school attendance
  • Demonstrated greater empathy for those in the community
  • Improved graduation rates

The arts spark creativity, and in doing so, may help to rewire the brain and how it thinks.

School districts dedicated to the arts

Some schools around the nation have made a commitment to revitalizing and reinventing themselves through art education. Large cities like Dallas and New York City are bringing the arts back into schools. Doing so has taken a village of artists, composers, visionaries, and philanthropists.

To ensure that the arts have a place in the curriculum, they must be sustainable. Chicago and Minneapolis have worked diligently to ensure that the arts become entrenched in the curriculum.

Unfortunately, not all schools have been able to sustain an arts program.

The arts-integrated curriculum

If your school cannot or will not make the arts part of the curriculum, you can do your part in your subject area. Integrate the arts into your lessons in these ways:

  • Perform plays instead of reading them. ELA classes can mount a production and invite the history classes to be the audience.
  • Include dance as part of PE classes.
  • Use call and response and a way to incorporate rhythm. Even handclapping can set the pace as students answer math questions or read aloud.
  • Create human sculptures by dressing up as historical figures.
  • Analyze sound waves from a guitar string, a drum beat, or a single note from a brass instrument.
  • Interpret paintings from a variety of perspectives. What are the mathematical properties? How does paint bond to canvas? What themes can students find?
  • Study plot development in operas and symphonies.
  • Create illustrations as summaries of chapters.
  • Listen to music from different historical periods.

Don’t stress over not being able to carry a tune in a bucket or paint anything on a paper. Let your students tap into some of their more creative multiple intelligences. They’ll do the creative part.

Children look forward to the opportunity to be creative, and they welcome lessons that include the arts. Your willingness to use the arts as a complement to your lessons will motivate and inspire your students.

Our students need the arts in their lives. We owe it to them to keep the arts in their curriculum.

Create a culture of learning in your classroom

Maybe you’ve witnessed a classroom where the focus on learning is intense.

A hum of excitement resonates in the air, and everyone, the teacher and students alike, goes about their work with a focused purpose. Everyone is engaged. The workflow is fluid. Routines are seamless. The students help each other succeed.

Maybe that classroom is yours.

If it’s not, it can be.

Explain the plan

A culture of learning consists of specific thinking habits.

What your students think about themselves and what they believe they are capable of are part of their thinking habits. Some of these habits have been formed in their home environments. Your thinking habits are part of your classroom, as well.

The key to creating your classroom learning culture lies in showing your students the high expectations you have for them. Talk with them about:

  • What does engaged learning look like?
  • What would the student be doing in this environment?
  • What would the teacher be doing?
  • How okay is it to make mistakes?
  • What kinds of things should be celebrated?

When you establish the model you have in mind for a culture of learning, it’s time to inspire your students.

Inspire your students

Your next step is to inspire your student to create a learning culture in the classroom. The word “inspire” means to breathe life into,” and that’s what you’re doing at this stage.

You can inspire your students in these ways:

  • Allow for student voice. Let your students express their opinions, even if they are different from yours or their peers.
  • Embrace failure. Failure is learning. As Thomas Edison observed, he learned many ways not to make a light bulb before coming up with one that worked.
  • Provide ongoing feedback. Your students need to know how they’re doing.

You’re breathing life into your classroom culture.

Sustain the culture

Once you’ve set a culture of learning in place, you’ll want to sustain it.

  • Encourage curiosity in your students by asking them questions that make them eager for discovery.
  • Invite students to problem solve so they can experience success, even if they fail first.
  • Find the positive and show that you value it. Especially reinforce the positive behaviors you agreed at the onset of your transformation.

Behind the scenes

What happens when you get a new student in the middle of the year?

Go back to step one and explain the plan. It’s how you “do business” in the classroom. A new student might not recognize the learning culture and the parameters you’ve set.

You must also plan for the times when you might not be in the classroom.

If you have to take a sick day, or you’re required to attend professional development, will your students be able to sustain the culture while you’re gone? Leave a plan in place for the substitute, and explain what the learning culture should look like, even to an outsider.

Once the workflow is in place, and the routines have become seamless, you are on your way. You and your students will travel an amazing path toward creating a sustainable classroom culture of learning.

Arts integration for any classroom

Teachers who are looking for ways to get their students engaged in thinking critically have another creative teaching option.

It’s called integrated arts, and it increases student achievement – by as much as 10%.

Students are better able to express themselves, they are more engaged in class, and they are less likely to be retained.

Rather than teach arts in isolation, schools have discovered real power in integrating the arts in core content areas. Best of all, you don’t have to be an art teacher to make it happen.

The arts encourage experiential learning

Many students find themselves drawn to the arts.

Music, dancing, drawing, painting, sculpting, and acting offer a different way of engaging with subjects. The real power of arts integration, however, lies in experience. The arts require that its participants experience content and interpret it to better understand subjects. The arts are the vehicle for communication.

Artistic creation invites curiosity, exploration, and calculated risk-taking. It also produces joy, especially for students who might otherwise not enjoy a subject.

To bring arts into the classroom, encourage your students to use their strengths in the visual and performing arts. Get them to make connections with the content you teach. Encourage your students to

  • Draw geographical or topographical maps
  • Create a pop music math video
  • Write a description
  • Build a costume
  • Design a coat of arms
  • Act out a critical scene from history

Full STEAM ahead

The arts make science, technology, engineering, and mathematics (STEM) more cohesive because the arts provide an innovative way to explore subjects formerly taught in isolation.

In a STEM + Arts classroom (STEAM), students engage in critical thinking as they follow their curiosity and collaborate with others. Perhaps most importantly, STEAM classes show students a new way to find value in artistic expression. The arts are a complement to STEM classes because they encourage communication through self-expression.

Without communication, STEM exists in isolation. Students must share their discoveries.

There are many ways to integrate the arts in STEM, including:

  • Writing journal entries as a patient who presents at the doctor’s office.
  • Create a comic strip using chemistry lab equipment as the characters.
  • Develop a dialogue between mathematicians discussing quantitative results from data collection.
  • Sketching drawings of from the invention process.
  • Preparing visual presentations for audiences.

Initiating integrated arts in your school

Teachers who are ready to integrate the arts into their content areas may find these strategies useful:

  • Create a vision of what the arts-integrated classroom looks like. Then take it schoolwide.
  • Attend professional development that will enrich your instruction and validate arts integration in your classroom.
  • Find a co-collaborator. New initiatives can be risky and exhausting. Have a partner with whom to share ideas can be energizing for you both, and you might inspire others to join you.

Too often the arts are being cut from school programs. The integrated arts are a way to bring art back to the classroom and let them flourish. Your students will be excited about the opportunity to create art.

You will, too.

How college and career ready is your child?

Preparing your child for college and career readiness is as much the responsibility of the parents as it is the school’s responsibility.

It takes years to prepare for college and career, and that’s what your child has been doing from kindergarten or first grade and on. You’ve been there every step of the way, making sure the homework got done. You bought supplies late at night because a project was due the next day. You even endured endless hours of practice and rehearsal.

Now the high school is talking about college and career readiness. How do you know if your child is ready?

What college and career readiness looks like

Parents, teachers and school counselors may have different definitions of what college and career readiness means.

Many people mistake college readiness for having the recommendation letters and well-written essay needed for acceptance into higher education. For that reason, educators have pushed for a common set of measurements and characteristics that determine the likelihood of future success in post-secondary studies or a career.

The National College and Career Readiness Indicators reveal whether a student is ready for college or a career. The good news is that readiness isn’t determined by a single score or characteristic. Readiness metrics for college, for example, measure achievement in several academic areas:

  • Grades earned in dual-credit courses like English and math
  • Advanced placement courses completed and exam results
  • Performance in remedial English and math courses
  • Algebra II
  • ACT/SAT scores

Career readiness, on the other hand, focuses on these measures:

  • Attendance (90% or better)
  • Community service hours
  • Workplace experience (industry credentials or internship)
  • Career pathway courses (taken for dual credit)
  • Participation in co-curricular activities

It’s critical to have a widely accepted definition of college and career readiness. That way, you know the goals you’re working toward.

What you can do to help

College and career readiness is about more than gaining acceptance into a university or the workplace. Readiness means having the skills to be successful in this new environment. Parents can help prepare their children in these ways:

  • Ask questions. Communicate with your child about expectations – theirs and yours. What do they think having a career looks like? What would a university experience be like?
  • Talk about money. Be upfront about the money that’s set aside for school or training. If it’s not there, say so. Complete the FAFSA application to determine eligibility for financial aid.
  • Let your child choose. Your son or daughter must chart their own course based on interest and aptitude.
  • Accept uncertainty. The next several years are for exploring options. The path to success may not be a direct one.

The secret ingredient to college and career readiness

It’s never too early to begin working on college and career readiness, especially if you know what’s expected in either trajectory.

Sometimes, however, plans go awry.

Just because your child has not met the criteria for college and career readiness, don’t give up just yet. There are multiple pathways leading to success, and it’s never too late to embark on the journey.

Teaching literary analysis

The writing assignments that matter the most are the ones that go beyond description and narrative formats. They are the ones that require scrutiny and reflective thinking while probing for deeper meaning. They are the literary analyses.

Students in almost any grade can write them, because they are rooted in literature.

Literary analysis is the close examination and occasionally the evaluation of a piece of literature. The reason teachers ask their students to write literary analyses is to engage them in critical thinking skills.

Students easily can find themselves overwhelmed when facing a literary analysis assignment. Unlike other content areas, written expression offers flexibility in communication. An analysis isn’t ever wrong because the writer offers his or her perspective on the topic.

Literary analysis requires advanced writing and thinking skills, so students need guidance in their critical thinking journey. Most literary analysis can be broken down into specific steps, and each one of these steps is the foundation for the next one.

Topic selection and focus

Literary analysis includes many facets of literature. Students can write about a story’s or book’s plot, setting, or use of figurative language. The options don’t stop there. Have younger students write about only one facet of the literature they read. Older students can incorporate multiple aspects.

Teachers seeking to differentiate instruction can adjust the number of topics to be addressed in the analysis.

When students know what they are to look for, it’s time to gather evidence that proves the point. For example, the student who writes about conflict in a short story will need to locate instances of conflict in the story.

Gather the evidence

The evidence for literary analysis comes from the text itself. Students find examples and prepare to incorporate them in their literary analysis.

Paraphrasing and summarizing works well when providing proof. Students also can insert quotes from the text as a way to prove what they are saying. As students work through this part of the process, they may inadvertently or blatantly plagiarize. Take time to teach citing and referencing.

Scaffold the writing experience

If students approach literary analysis as if they were following a recipe, they may find the writing process easier to complete. Although teachers may have variations, most literary analysis essays have four main sections. Have your students tackle each section one at time.

  • Introduce the main point. The introduction usually consists of a single paragraph that begins with a hook or lead – something to catch the reader’s attention. Next, students explain their point in one or two sentences.
  • Present the evidence. Any evidence must support the main point. Students incorporate their summaries or quotes, and they paraphrase what others have said. Presenting evidence often requires at least one paragraph per piece of evidence.
  • Offer analysis. In this section, students explain how they came to the conclusion that their point is correct. Persuading the reader may take several paragraphs.
  • Conclude the essay. Finally, the conclusion reiterates the main point in one paragraph. It also serves as closure to the literary analysis. Students should make a connection to the analysis by offering their own observations or relating a similar experience.

Writing a literary analysis promotes critical thinking skills in ways that other writing assignments cannot. Teachers willing to guide their students through each step of the writing process will discover just how capable of independent thinking their students are.

 

Calculating math success

Which is better: having students use pen and paper when working on math problems or allowing them to use calculators to find the answers?

Regardless of the level they teach educators don’t agree on the answer.

Elementary teachers straddle the fence on this issue. Some see calculator use as a way to build numeracy. Others see it as a replacement for strong math skills. Middle school teachers fervently debate the issue for their classrooms. Although high school students may use calculators on their college entrance exams, many math professors refuse to allow the handheld devices in their classes.

Johns Hopkins University Professor of math and education W. Stephen Wilson once wrote, “I have not yet encountered a mathematics concept that required technology to either teach it or assess it. The concepts and skills we teach are so fundamental that technology is not needed to either elucidate them or enhance them. There might be teachers who can figure out a way to enhance learning with the use of technology, but it’s absolutely unnecessary.”

He saw the calculator as nothing more than a crutch.

How students benefit from using calculators

Calculators make quick work of extended problem-solving as long as the numbers for each step are entered correctly and the user understands the order of operations on the device. Problem-solving with a calculator becomes a teachable moment, both in the importance of entering data with accuracy and in understanding the function keys.

Another benefit of calculator use in the math or science classroom is that students develop familiarity with different technologies.

Calculators have the added attraction of being fun to use, but using calculators in the classroom have many drawbacks as well.

Drawbacks to using calculators in the math classroom

The use of calculators in the classroom draws skepticism from teachers, and with good reason.

Some math teachers are hesitant to advocate for calculator use in the classroom. They argue that students become complacent, relying on the technology to think for them, even for the simplest of tasks. Teachers worry that overreliance on calculators will strip students of their numeracy skills.

In a BYOT (Bring Your Own Technology) district, the added expense of a graphing calculator may place math technology out of the reach of some families.

The solution

Students in ELA classes use keyboards to type their essays. Even with the writing apps available to assist writers, students are solely responsible for their word choice and sentence construction. The technology is only a tool.

If we think of calculators as tools to complete a task, math becomes less about the device and more about problem-solving. Calculators do not solve problems. People do.

Students who use calculators in the classroom may find them handy when working with large numbers, scientific notation, or square roots.

The calculator serves a purpose only when the student has developed numeracy skills. Students who understand how numbers work are more likely to spot input errors. Without numeracy skills, however, the math student might not catch mistakes any quicker than an ELA student would locate a usage mistake and correct it.

Calculators can be useful for solving tedious and complex problems. Their employment in the classroom depends on the skill of the students relying on them. Calculators should never be a crutch.

Calculators should be a tool for getting the job done successfully and as efficiently as possible. According to NTCM, they augment reasoning, not replace it.

Overcoming timed-test-induced math anxiety

Many students have anxiety when it comes to math. They find working with numbers stressful because of the extra care required for coming up with the correct answers during lessons. Taking a math test can cause students to lose focus, forget steps, and feel overwhelmed.

Timed tests exacerbate math anxiety.

Students feel pressure to perform quickly and accurately in timed math tests. If they fail at either, anxiety builds. The test-takers don’t want to be embarrassed in front of their peers. They don’t want to feel as though they are failing.

Timed tests

Setting testing time limits is nothing new. College entrances exams are timed. Professional certifications in several industries require that candidates submit to a timed test as a way to prove their knowledge and expertise.

Teachers often require automaticity in reciting math facts like the multiplication table because they know their students will need speed and fluency during timed tests. As a response to timed tests, teachers assign Mad Math Minutes to encourage automaticity in calculations.

Recognizing math anxiety

It seems like no other subject indices stress like mathematics. The anxiety surrounding math isn’t even limited to the classroom. If severe enough, this clinical condition can profoundly affect children and adults. As much as 6% of the population has math anxiety.

Math anxiety can be hereditary. Parents with math phobias can unwittingly pass them on to their children. That anxiety can last a lifetime.

Adults with math anxiety may experience stress when examining bank statements or paying bills. Students experience math anxiety in the math classroom, and also outside of formal math instruction, when figuring out grades and GPAs.

Some of the symptoms include:

  • Rapid heart rate
  • Increased blood pressure
  • Constriction of the pupils
  • Shallow breathing
  • Tension headaches

Students may try to avoid math class by finding reasons to visit the counselor or school nurse during class time. Prolonged trips to the restroom are also part of math avoidance. These absences, however, make the problem worse. By missing instruction, students with math anxiety get further behind, and their stress levels increase.

Time tests make the math anxiety worse.

Strategies to reduce anxiety

  • Practice in class by playing games. The focus is on playing, but gamification still requires correct answers in a timed environment.
  • Teach your students how to use growth mindset techniques. When students believe they power through math problems, they often will. Growth mindset helps them understand that the anxiety from hard work benefits them.
  • Take your students through visioning exercises in which they see and feel themselves answering test questions and being successful.

Timed tests aren’t going away.

To reduce math anxiety, help your students develop a positive attitude. Math seems overwhelming because of the multi-step processes and many formulas. Keep directions as simple as possible. One probability and statistics professors told students, “There are only four things you can do in math: add, subtract, multiply, and divide. You came to this class already knowing how to do these things. I’m here to help with the rest.”

By showing your students how to work through and perhaps overcome math anxiety, you’re changing their perception of themselves.