Uncategorized

Can Small Data Improve K-12 Education?

With the No Child Left Behind Act, yearly students in grades 3-8 and once in high school are tested in mathematics and reading using standardized testing. In addition, states required their own testing for school and teacher evaluation. The information gleaned from these tests are then analyzed and the goal was for data to aid policy-makers in making improvements to our education system. Unfortunately, there is now more data available than can even be consumed and student outcomes have not made any significant improvements in over a decade.

Big data is a term used to describe large amounts of collected information that can only be analyzed via computers. Big data has become a cornerstone of our education system in the U.S. but it doesn’t seem to be working, according o experts. Pasi Sahlberg, a professor at the Harvard Graduate School of Education and one of the leading experts on education practices and school reform tells the Washington Post that he believes a focus on “small data” could make vast improvements in education.

With big data not doing much to fix education in America, a new focus on small data, or a focus on what is happening in individual schools and classrooms, is emerging. As the Washington Post article points out, a better understanding of what quality teaching is and how it leads to enhanced learning in schools should be the concentration of policy-makers. Small data observes the details or small clues that uncover large trends. The idea is that by honing in on the elements that make up relationships and narratives in schools, education can be enriched.

By getting away from student assessments, more energy and resources could go to teacher training and formative school assessments. More autonomy and accountability for students would increase and improve their outcomes.

To improve teaching and learning nationwide, reformers may need to examine small data trends to gain insight into what is occurring in the classroom and how those outcomes can lead to better-quality education. If the standardized method of understanding students on a large scale isn’t working, it must change.

 

Is Competency Based Education the next big thing?

The popularity of Competency Based Education (CBE) programs has increased markedly over the past few years. CBE is self-paced, mastery oriented programs that often include the use of technology. Students must master and demonstrate competency in various tasks and skills, in order to obtain their degree. CBE offers an alternative to traditional courses, whether held in-person or online, for a set amount of time with the goal of earning a passing grade and credit hours that apply toward graduation.

There are close to 600 U.S. institutions working on rolling out CBE programs currently. Though the programs have gained notoriety, they aren’t all eligible for federal financial aid, as the Department of Education doesn’t have appropriate measures in place for evaluating credentialing structures.

Developing entire CBE programs is labor and time intensive, as well as requires a large allocation of resources from a college or university. The question now becomes, is CBE a worthwhile investment? And is CBE as good as or even better than traditional higher education models?

A 2015 study conducted by Hart Research Associates found that employers place most value on a prospective employee’s proficiency of communication, teamwork, decision-making and critical thinking skills. Therefore, an evaluation of these skills is necessary to determine the effectiveness of CBE. In order to determine the worthwhileness of CBE programs, it has been suggested that employers rate employees who have graduated from a CBE program on various work related skills. The College for America in Southern New Hampshire has already begun this evaluation process as a means to determine program effectiveness. The study is needed to determine if the investment of time and resources by the students and university is valuable.

Ideally, data from employers of traditional college graduates will eventually be compared to that of CBE graduates to determine which group has demonstrated the essential workforce skills best.

 

Lessons Gained From Learning to Physically Pull Your Own Weight

**The Edvocate is pleased to publish guest posts as way to fuel important conversations surrounding P-20 education in America. The opinions contained within guest posts are those of the authors and do not necessarily reflect the official opinion of The Edvocate or Dr. Matthew Lynch.**

A column by Rick Osbourne

Question #1: Why would anyone ever feel any need to learn to do pull ups?

Answer #1: It’s always cool to be strong and pull ups are always associated with being strong. It’s also common knowledge that people (including kids) who can do even one conventional pull up, are ALMOST NEVER OBESE. Maintain the ability (which requires decent eating/exercise habits and 30 seconds of practice per week) and you’ll AVOID OBESITY FOR LIFE.

Question #2: If you’re currently unable to do conventional pull ups, how can you systematically go about learning to do them?

Answer #2: First you LOWER THE BAR to a point where you can easily do 10 leg assisted pull ups – jumping and pulling at the same time. Work at that level every other day (1 set per day) until you can do 15 repetitions. At that point RAISE THE BAR ONE INCH and work at this new level until you can do 15 repetitions.

Continue this process of raising the bar one inch, working until you can do 15 reps, over and over again until you finally run out of leg assistance. At that point you’ll have mastered the art of doing pull ups. And at the risk of being overly redundant and repetitious, people who can do even one conventional pull up are ALMOST NEVER OBESE!* That’s really important!

Question #3: Other than being strong, cool, and avoiding obesity for life, what will you have gained from this very tangible, hands-on, physical learning experience?

Answer #3: You will have learned how to SYSTEMATICALLY ADDRESS ANY CHALLENGE by finding a place to begin successfully, increasing the workload in small increments, over time, until you’ve finally mastered the task.**

The task could be academic like learning how to read, write, do math, physics or chemistry. It could be social like learning to get along with people. It could be psychological, aesthetic, or economic. It matters not. You can address any and all challenges, and EXPECT TO SUCCEED by employing the same approach used in learning to do pull ups.***

An Experiential Reference Point

In terms of educational theory, this pull your own weight learning experience qualifies as what Professor David Ausubel calls an “Advance Organizer.” Ausubel contends that when learning anything new, the most important factor is WHAT YOU ALREADY KNOW that can serve as an experiential reference point to which you can compare and contrast the new experience (i.e. it’s similar to or different than). That reference point gives the new experience a context and meaning, as it gradually becomes assimilated into your knowledge base.

More specifically, kids who learn to do pull ups using the method described above will have gained a very tangible experience which they can use to approach any and all new learning experiences. Find a place to start successfully. Gradually increase the workload in small increments over time. And eventually they’ll master the task, no matter what it is.

The Most Important Lesson

In this light, the most important lesson gained from learning to physically pull your own weight is that you NEED NOT PASSIVELY ACCEPT the cards (in this case the inability to do pull ups) that fate has dealt you. Instead you can ACTIVELY CHOOSE to find a place to start successfully (in this case with leg assisted pull ups). Work at it regularly in order to improve gradually, over time until you have finally mastered pull ups, reading, writing, arithmetic, physics, chemistry, law, economics, history, philosophy, art, or love.

In other words, you’ll learn to pull your own weight, to take responsibility for yourself, your actions, and your life. It’s not easy. And it’s not quick. But it is simple. And it is straight forward. That said, learning to do pull ups serves as an excellent “advance organizer” for living, for becoming, and for fulfilling your potential, whatever it may be.

* This is just like lowering the rim, and gradually raising it in small increments, over time, in order to learn how to slam dunk a basketball!

**“Nothing in this world can take the place of persistence. Talent will not: nothing is more common than unsuccessful men with talent. Genius will not; unrewarded genius is almost a proverb. Education will not: the world is full of educated derelicts. Persistence and determination alone are omnipotent.” Calvin Coolidge

***We’re staunch proponents of self-competition (Johnny this week vs Johnny last week) instead conventional competition (Johnny vs Jimmy).

—

Rick Osbourne is former physical educator and a pioneer in the field of functional childhood obesity prevention. He currently serves as President of the Pull Your Own Weight Foundation which is an Illinois based, 501c3, not for profit organization whose focus is functional childhood obesity prevention. He’s written and published three books in this field, the latest of which is entitled Beating Childhood Obesity Now: A Simple Solution for Parents and Educators. He’s the Examiner’s national childhood obesity prevention correspondent. He writes an online column for The Edvocate. And you can connect with Rick via Twitter, Linkedin, or Facebook.

Is North Carolina A&T losing its identity?

North Carolina Agricultural and Technical State University, a historically black college and university (HBCU), is in a bit of a crisis.

The school, formed in 1891 under the name “Agricultural and Mechanical College for the Colored Race,” A&T was recently restructured by the North Carolina Committee on Education Planning, Policies and Programs.

Reorganizing for the school means that the College of Arts and Sciences will be no more along with the School of  Technology. The other school that will partner with NC A&T is the University of North Carolina at Greensboro.

UNC-G and NC A&T came together last year for a joint nursing program, partnered in 2011 to form the Joint School of Nanoscience and Nanoengineering, and in 1997 did so for the Joint Master of Social Work Program.

A history of working together, it makes sense on the surface for the schools to continue its partnerships. But as A&T continues its stride towards efficiency, many have concerns that the school’s rich history will soon be too diluted to notice.

Liberal arts seems to be on its way out and one instructor, Derick Smith, at A&T believes that the school is being marched towards focusing on STEM (Science, Technology, Engineering, and Math) majors, which receives a good amount of funding.

Smith makes a good point about STEM and how the local and federal government has pivoted towards pushing students to a career in the field.

President Obama notoriously chided liberal arts as economically impractical compared to attaining a skill like being a mechanic or painter. He was, for lack of a better term, being pragmatic when it comes to choices in education.

STEM isn’t for everybody, though. Pushing more students to a field that may not fit their interest or skill set is just as dangerous as removing focus from allowing students a vocational education.

It’s also unfortunate that we may be seeing the slow end of NC A&T. As more HBCUs look for ways to increase enrollment and remain culturally viable, each one will also try to straddle the line between keeping its history and moving towards a more diverse future.

Career Exploration – Determining Your Interests and Strengths

**The Edvocate is pleased to publish guest posts as way to fuel important conversations surrounding P-20 education in America. The opinions contained within guest posts are those of the authors and do not necessarily reflect the official opinion of The Edvocate or Dr. Matthew Lynch.**

A guest post by Rachelle Wilber

These days, the pressure of choosing a career looms on students’ minds as they try to decide just what they want to do with the rest of their lives. While this is a difficult task, it’s not impossible. If you look at what you like to do, consider where you excel, and try to obtain practical experience in various fields, you’ll be more likely to know which career is right for you.

Do What You Love

The most important thing to consider is whether or not you’ll enjoy your career. If you simply can’t decide, pay attention to what you do while you procrastinate. Do you paint to relieve stress? Maybe you’re a future graphic designer. Are you a bookworm? You might make an excellent literature professor. Do you strive to understand how machinery and technology works? Engineering could be the right choice. Overall, look at the big picture of your life to observe which subjects you have found most engaging.

Play to Your Strengths

Consider where you’ve achieved the highest grades in your history of schooling to obtain an indication of what your core skills are. Of course, you don’t have to be skilled in your future career choice before college. That’s why higher education exists. Some schools know that electricians and HVAC techs benefit from module-based learning. Similarly, painters and sculptors may find training at an atelier or simply from their classmates in university. There are even trade schools for welders who hope to forge their futures with hot metal. If you take into account your strengths, you’ll gain insight into your career possibilities.

Gain Experience

You won’t know if you truly enjoy something until you’ve experienced it first-hand. You’ll want to be sure you aren’t afraid of blood if you wish to work in the medical field, or that you truly enjoy researching the morphology of insects if you’re pursuing a graduate degree in biology. Sometimes, if you’re lucky, an internship or volunteering experience will be exactly what you need to solidify your pursuit of a career.

Although figuring out your future is complicated, it’s not impossible. If you focus on what you enjoy, pay attention to your skills, and pursue practical experience, you’re sure to gain insight into what careers are ideal for your personality.

_________________

Rachelle Wilber is a freelance writer living in the San Diego, California area. She graduated from San Diego State University with her Bachelor’s Degree in Journalism and Media Studies. She tries to find an interest in all topics and themes, which prompts her writing. When she isn’t on her porch writing in the sun, you can find her shopping, at the beach, or at the gym. Follow her on twitter: @RachelleWilber

Chicago State University posts 11% graduation rate

Bad news continues to beset Chicago State University (CSU). The school revealed that its graduation rate is just 11 percent; a number well below the national average.

CSU has faced budget problems as of late due to a budget impasse between state lawmakers and Illinois Governor Bruce Rauner. Because of it, the school was forced to cancel spring break and move up commencement. The school was forced to layoff staff and may only survive through the summer as the state legislature agreed to a stopgap funding measure of $600 million.

But that only keeps the school operating and doesn’t address the issue that students aren’t graduating on time. CSU has always taken on students who may have a hard time getting into other schools. Admitting students who have financial problems, come from low-income areas, and students that have low GPA’s will have an impact on who graduates on time. It’s also worth noting that CSU is a predominately black school.

Because of that, CSU’s graduation rate is low and isn’t likely to improve if the issue isn’t directly addressed. But 11 percent is low even for CSU as the school has seen its rate of graduation go as high as 21 percent in recent years.

With no money to possibly keep the school open, and news of low graduation rates, there should be a greater emphasis on CSU’s need for student assistance. A Chicago Tribune editorial pointed to the school’s improving infrastructure as lawmakers poured millions into building improvements. But they failed to invest anything into improving student success and graduation rates.

CSU has come to a crossroads or maybe we’re just realizing that state political leaders have placed the school in a no win situation. Vital to students from underprivileged backgrounds, CSU’s survival is essential to Chicago and those on the Southside.

But without funds and resources to help improve the graduation rate and for students who need guidance, the state’s politicians are leaving CSU to die.

Segregation in Schools Continues to Persist

Segregation in schools was outlawed six decades ago, yet separation of students by race still exists in our schools today. The Government Accountability Office (GAO) recently released a report outlining the segregation of black and Hispanic students at high poverty public schools nationwide.

The report found that over 20 million minority students are racially and socioeconomically isolated in schools. Three districts in the South, Northeast and West were examined as part of the study. Each took measures to increase both economic and racial diversity, yet were hindered by lack of involvement from parents and the community, as well as transportation issues.

Statistics show that during the 2013-2014 school year, 16 percent of schools had large concentrations of economically poor and black or Hispanic students. In 2000, this segment was only 9 percent of the nation’s public schools. The student population at these schools were at minimum 75 percent black, Hispanic and poor.

The high poverty minority schools regularly offer less math and science course overall. Algebra, calculus, biology, chemistry and physics classes were all lacking in comparison to more affluent schools. Less than half of the poor, minority-heavy schools offered AP math courses.

Students attending high-poverty, minority concentrated schools accounted for 7 percent of U.S. ninth grade public school students, yet comprised 17 percent of students held back. Hispanic students were found to be the largest minority group, at 25 percent, with black students at 16 percent during the 2013-2014 school year. Poverty rates for both groups were two to three times higher than that of white students.

If nothing else, the GAO report is a call to action. Appropriate steps must be taken so that schools are able to reach and celebrate every type of student. If not addressed, resource disparities will continue to plague minority and lower income students.

Why Asian Minority Data Needs Better Division

Certain minorities carry with them stereotypes associated with education. The idea that Asian students regularly excel academically is a myth that at times prohibits students from receiving the support they may need, according to experts and the students themselves.

Asian American Pacific Islander students include but are not limited to Chinese, Cambodian, Vietnamese, Laotian and Samoan Americans, yet are all placed under the racial group “Asian” by the Department of Education. This often makes it difficult to compile academic statistics associated with each subgroup.

Coinciding with AAPI month, the U.S. Department of Education just announced a $1 million grant to encourage states to differentiate data on Asian students. Education secretary, John King states in a recently released video that the minority myth “has prevented AAPI communities from fully benefiting from federal programs and resources that can support vulnerable and underserved people.”

Many Asian immigrants do not have access to economic privileges and may be glossed over in terms of education. If a student has undocumented immigrant parents the possibility of detainment does not allow the student proper headspace to effectively learn. Often times completion of college courses may be in jeopardy when these types of issues come into play.

There is a significant difference in degree completion between subgroups. In California alone, one study documented a 60 percent variation across subgroups in the Asian American population. Though 70 percent of Indian adults have obtained a bachelor’s degree or higher, just 10 percent of Laotian adults have achieved this level of education. Comparatively, Asian American students have much higher college completion rates than Native Hawaiian Pacific Islander students.

The initiative is important, to ensure that at-risk AAPI students receive the academic opportunities necessary for success. By focusing on the specific needs of AAPI students directly, changes can be made to enhance educational interventions.

Trump planning higher education plan rollout

Donald Trump, the presumptive Republican nominee for President, is preparing to rollout his plan for higher education. In speaking with Inside Higher Ed, Trump’s campaign co-chair Sam Clovis said that Trump’s plan will include student loan reform and a potential policy that will make it tougher for students to get loans for liberal art degrees.

Trump’s full plan will not be revealed until later this summer or potentially the fall, but he’s already taking hard lines against Hillary Clinton, and Bernie Sanders’ plan to make public college free.

Clovis said that free college isn’t attainable because the country can’t pay for it and beat back talk of Obama’s idea to make community college free. Saying that community college is close to free now, Clovis doesn’t believe in the idea of making community college tuition free.

But remaining with Clovis’ point about community college, he’s not entirely right. A recent report by the Institute for Research on Higher Education at the University of Pennsylvania detailed how expensive college is for poor Americans.

Poor families in Mississippi making $30,000 or less would have to spend nearly half of their yearly income to send kids in their family to a community college.

That’s not exactly affordable or close to free.

Another aspect of Trump’s plan for higher education is to shift student loans back to private banks and remove the government from the process entirely. Believing that the process should be market driven, Clovis said that students should receive loans from local banks and not the government.

Trump will likely want to alter the way colleges admit students, mainly steering them away from degrees that do not produce worthy jobs and decent incomes.

Clovis touched on many themes of higher education but didn’t detail much as Trump is still putting his plan together. But from what he did say–like his statements on liberal arts and student loans–the plan is sure to cause controversy when it is full available to the public.

Strong Kids Arm Themselves Against Obesity For Life

**The Edvocate is pleased to publish guest posts as way to fuel important conversations surrounding P-20 education in America. The opinions contained within guest posts are those of the authors and do not necessarily reflect the official opinion of The Edvocate or Dr. Matthew Lynch.**

A column by Rick Osbourne

Let the fast food joints and the junk food industry advertise to kids all day long. Let the video game gurus continue manufacturing their mind numbing, thumb exercising gizmos. Let the sugar and fat pushing vending machines stay in the school hallways. And let science, math, and technology dominate school curriculum at the expense a real life education.

This is Really Easy

Let all the culprits continue doing all the evil things they can dream up. But if your kids can physically pull their own weight (do at least one conventional pull up) odds are absolutely spectacular that THEY’RE NOT OBESE! And if they maintain the ability (which requires decent eating and exercise habits and less than 30 seconds a week on the closest tree limb) odds are equally spectacular that THEY’LL NEVER BE OBESE!*

Furthermore, if parents, school board members, and educators are able to think preventatively and address the problem BEFORE the obesity seeds take root, (just like we’ve done with polio, diphtheria, small pox, and measles, etc.) it’s really quite easy to help kids learn to physically pull their own weight and to arm themselves against obesity (and the myriad of related problems that follow in its wake) for life.

It’s All About Self-Motivation
And the most important part of this functional orientation to childhood obesity prevention is that most kids love the process of growing systematically stronger, especially when it happens in the company of their peers. That is to say, the motivational aspect of childhood obesity prevention takes care of itself because most kids just plain love to grow stronger every week, every month, all year long. After all, being strong is cool and being weak is un-cool. And what kid wants to be weak at anything?

Let me say this in another way because it’s really important. YOU WON’T HAVE TO BRIBE YOUR KIDS TO PARTICIPATE because they naturally value the opportunity to grow stronger along with their friends. It’s built into the genes!

On the contrary, rewarding kids with extrinsically valued garbage (including stars, stickers, grades, and contrived positive reinforcements) undermines the intrinsic value that’s built into this functional orientation by its very nature. In other words, it’s a huge mistake to employ extrinsic rewards. Your kids are not pigeons or rats that need operant conditioning!

Strong Kids Arm Themselves Against Obesity
If you set the stage right, it matters not what all the bad guys are doing to undermine your kids, as long as you raise them to be strong enough to see through all this foolishness. Done correctly, kids naturally grow strong enough to fend off all the evil influences (including tobacco, alcohol, and drug abuse – they make you weak not strong) we expect them to grow up with in the 21st century. It’s really that simple. You decide!

*The same claims can be made for other full-body-weight exercises including parallel bar dips, rope climbing, hand stand push-ups, and single legged squats just to name a few other functional obesity prevention options.

_____________

Rick Osbourne is a former physical educator and a pioneer in the field of functional childhood obesity prevention. He currently serves as President of the Pull Your Own Weight Foundation which is an Illinois based, 501c3, not for profit organization whose focus is functional childhood obesity prevention. He’s written and published three books in this field, the latest of which is entitled Beating Childhood Obesity Now: A Simple Solution for Parents and Educators. He’s the Examiner’s national childhood obesity prevention correspondent. He writes an online column for The Edvocate. And you can connect with Rick via Twitter, Linkedin, or Facebook.