Uncategorized

False Positives: Low Student Loan Default Scores

**The Edvocate is pleased to publish guest posts as way to fuel important conversations surrounding P-20 education in America. The opinions contained within guest posts are those of the authors and do not necessarily reflect the official opinion of The Edvocate or Dr. Matthew Lynch.**

Guest post by Bob Hildreth

Ask the “best” colleges about the student debt crisis and they are likely to trot out the very low default rates of their graduates, only 1 to 2 percent. Most of the defaulting students, they point out, come from for-profits. They also believe that the national default rate at 11.8 percent is at a manageable level.

But these rates hide more than they reveal. Default rates are managed to be low. It is in the best interest of everyone involved to keep them low: the government wants to keep the lid on its troubled policy, the government’s collection agents want to earn their fees by keeping debtors current, and the colleges want to keep the mother’s milk of government subsidies flowing in their direction.

The “best colleges” have little experience with debt defaults. They either don’t know or are reluctant to admit that, when it comes to the government’s loan program, colleges are all bunched together. Even for a college with zero defaults the only default rate that matters in a crisis is that of all debtors from all colleges.

The government is lenient, letting 9 months of no repayments pass before calling a student in default. Compare that to only 90 days on car loans or 3 months on mortgages. Students are also allowed to clear their defaults by switching from stricter repayment plans to easier ones. College lobbyists have convinced the government to measure default rates after only three years knowing that defaults accumulate over time. In fact, one in five students with over $15,000 in debt defaulted on his or her loan in the 10 years after graduation. That’s a 20% default rate.

The Federal Reserve of New York has created its own measure to gage student debt stress. Using consumer data the Fed measures how long students go without paying their debts. By this calculation in 2014 past due rates on student debt reached as high as 63%. 

That leaves the government like the famous emperor without clothes. If the future of our children and the solvency of our colleges were not at stake the government might have already stopped lending. But there is probably no default rate so high that the government would abandon these priorities. At the same time it is easy to guess that changes are afoot. One of the most likely targets are controls on tuition increases. That will cause a fire storm on Washington’s DuPont Circle, the home of college lobbyists. If these lobbyists can suggest a way to put clothes back on the emperor, they should speak now.

____

Bob Hildreth is the Founder and Chairman of the Board of Inversant, a Boston-based non-profit that helps families learn about, apply for and save for college without incurring student debt.

How Low-income Adults Access Affordable Education

**The Edvocate is pleased to publish guest posts as way to fuel important conversations surrounding P-20 education in America. The opinions contained within guest posts are those of the authors and do not necessarily reflect the official opinion of The Edvocate or Dr. Matthew Lynch.**

A guest post by Anica Oaks

In high school, teens are told that no matter where they come from, they can go to college. Unfortunately, many low-income adolescents don’t have the opportunity to even apply to universities, since they may not have the money for the application fee, funds for textbooks or enough money to cover the residual tuition not covered by FAFSA.

Many low-income adults began working while they were still in high school. After graduating, they are left struggling to make ends meet with a minimum wage job and wind up feeling suffocated and discouraged early on in life. Despite the fact that they may not be able to afford an Ivy League school, there are accessible education opportunities for low-income adults whether they graduated last summer or 30 years ago.

Free College Classes Online

Sites like Coursera and edX have teamed up with hundreds of renowned universities across the world to offer learners from all backgrounds access to a quality education free of charge. The courses that you can find range from introductory level English and math courses to digital marketing, science, languages, computer science and engineering, and more.

Each site gives students the option to purchase certificates of completion for less than $100 per course, and Coursera even offers financial aid for those who can’t afford the default price. Whether you just want to learn for personal benefit or to gain the knowledge necessary to pursue new career opportunities, getting started at Coursera and edX is an excellent way to do so for little to no cost.

Find a Vocational School

Many schools will teach you how to become a professional at a trade like cosmetology, electricity and HVAC installation and more for a very low cost. The Newgate School in Minneapolis turns donated trucks and cars from citizens into tools for low-income students to work on and learn how to become auto mechanics in under 2 years.

There are other many other vocational schools you can find that offer affordable financing options for low-income students and can provide you with the training you need to get a high-paying career in under 2 years.

Scholarships and Work Study Programs

Many low-income adults write off college before they fully explore all their options. Although it requires some extra research, many people can qualify for special scholarships that can be combined with federal student aid. In-state tuition for many colleges is less than $10,000 a year to residents. A scholarship can open the door to education, and a work-study program that provides you with some income as well as pays off your tuition while you work are all viable options for low-income adults looking to better themselves and expand their career options.

Even if you don’t have money for a traditional education, don’t give up! If you search hard enough, you can find opportunities for free or subsidized education.

___

Anica is a professional content and copywriter who graduated from the University of San Francisco. She loves dogs, the ocean, and anything outdoor-related. She was raised in a big family, so she’s used to putting things to a vote. Also, cartwheels are her specialty. You can connect with Anica here.

The Evidence-Based Athletic Department

 

A director of athletics details how a shift from paper to digital forms has saved his staff time and helped them gather actionable data about student injuries.

Guest post by Darryl Nance

Like many districts around the country, Greenville (SC) County Schools has been moving in the direction of data-driven decision-making in all areas, including our athletic department. While our athletic trainers have long been able to electronically document injuries, the bulk of other data necessary for injury prevention and effectiveness research has, until recently, remained out of our grasp.

A significant portion of the information came to the school via paper forms completed by athletes and parents, so there was no structured data. Now that we are using the extracurricular management platform PlanetHS, those athletes and parents can fill out forms online, so all inputs come in as structured data.

Data collection had also been a challenge because every Greenville County sports team is supported by a medical team. For many years, the Greenville Health System has hired athletic trainers who are assigned to each middle and high school on a full-time basis. Orthopedic physicians from the Steadman Hawkins Clinic of the Carolinas offer free weekend clinics, after-clinic open hours, and at-game coverage for the schools. The nonprofit Hawkins Foundation and the Center for Effectiveness Research in Orthopaedics work in concert with these medical and academic professionals to provide the necessary infrastructure and scientific insight to prevent injuries, improve treatments, and support the health of each student.

Another roadblock to gathering useful data was that coaches and school athletic directors had developed schedules in various formats that were difficult to assimilate into a data set. Without schedules of practices and games, researchers have no way to know exposures (the actual amount of time an athlete is involved in the sport and at risk for injury) for each athlete—and therefore are unable to conduct accurate assessments. Now, coaches and athletic directors place practice and game schedules directly into PlanetHS, so we have a uniform way to quantify participation levels.

Lastly, our athletic trainers used to manually input each athlete into their trainer software programs. This was extremely time-consuming and error-filled. Aside from taking valuable time away from their primary task, it was almost impossible to gather accurate information with paper forms where, for example, a student might write his or her nickname while the parent offered the full name—not to mention the fact that our trainers have no knowledge of grade promotion or eligibility. As the eligibility provider for the South Carolina High School League, PlanetHS has the accurate name and grade level for every athlete, and through a direct connection to our athletic trainer software, each trainer now has an up-to-date roster of participants without any time taken away from their trainer responsibilities.

After years of painstakingly slow manual effort, we now have a comprehensive data-gathering system that covers more than 20 different sports throughout the entire middle school and high school sports program.

Conclusions About Concussions

Through our manual processes, we’ve been able to reduce injuries in baseball significantly. And we’ve just completed a study showing a decline in the severity of concussions. So we know the basics of how to define projects, collect data for analysis, and generate evidence. With the new data access capabilities via PlanetHS, our ability to look at the specifics of injury history, student scheduling, and participation in relation to the development and prevention of injuries has been significantly enhanced. 

My biggest recommendation to other school leaders who want to adopt a data-driven approach to assessing, preventing, and treating student athlete injuries is to audit their current processes and work to eliminate paper. While our research team has greatly benefitted from moving much of our work online, we can only imagine the efficiency we could gain by eliminating the collation, filing, and overall management of paper.

As a result of our new capabilities, we’ve added a data scientist to our team and opened new grant opportunities. When it comes to protecting and caring for our student athletes, there is much more that can be accomplished, and with the right tools, researchers will be amazed at how fast they can accomplish it.

____

Darryl Nance is the director of athletics for Greenville County Schools in South Carolina.

Report: Top Districts have more Security Officers than Counselors

New information posted to the 74million.org shows that three of the nation’s top five school districts employ more security officers than school counselors.

The problem is particularly bad in Miami-Dade, New York, and Houston where there may be one counselor for every 1,000 students.

That’s a startling number considering how many students these school districts host.

In Houston, the information compiled revealed that there is less than one counselor per 1,000 students and just a little over one per 1,000 in Los Angeles.

But the security personal numbers are plentiful, or at least better. In Miami-Dade, the school district employs at least six security officers per 1,000 students.

While the data for larger school districts isn’t shocking, it gives a glimpse into why so many black and brown students are targeted for suspension. Of course white students are caught in that net as well, but minority students represent a disproportionate number of those suspended.

Data presented by the United States Department of Education Office for Civil Rights shows that black students made up 31 percent of school-related arrests in the 2011- 2012 school year yet account for just 16 percent of the total student population.

If schools place a larger emphasis on security and safety by hiring police officers, security personnel, and resource officers, students and staff may feel a greater sense of safety but likely feel some form of fear as well.

Some security hired to work schools are untrained and not able to properly handle minor situations between students.

This all proves that we’re not doing enough to help and educate our students, rather we’re attempting to keep the status quo or make it worse. Grade school students are still kids attempting to learn, and when we alter that learning environment to one of fear littered with officers, we seriously harm a student’s ability to grow academically and socially.

Answering the problem of school violence may not totally lie with hiring more counselors, but it surely isn’t held in the hands of more police and security officers.

Kentucky Governor Bevin sued over education cuts

Kentucky’s Republican Governor Matthew Bevin has been sued by the state’s Attorney General Andy Beshear over the governor’s 4.5 percent cut to all education funding.

In an executive action to help the state’s pension fund, the governor ordered the cut because supposedly the state House and Senate couldn’t come to an agreement over the state’s budget.

As a response to the governor’s move, Beshear filed a lawsuit noting that Bevin’s move was illegal and was not in the purview of his powers as governor.

A point of emphasis about how Bevin views education and its role in the American economy, he believes that too many students invest time and money into liberal arts degrees and that Kentucky should pay more for STEM (Science, Technology, Engineering, and Math) majors.

Politicians have taken aim at liberal art majors as of late, including President Obama, noting that these types of degrees do not lead to jobs.

Unfortunately that information is not true. A study by the Association of American Colleges and Universities as recent as 2014 shows that students who graduate with a degree in liberal arts actually turn out better financially than those who majored in a field professional field.

That’s good news on the surface, but the survey revealed something else that may hold some students back from majoring in liberal arts. The financial payoff for liberal arts graduates doesn’t reveal itself until former students are in their mid-50’s.

Still–those older students see an economic return on investment even if it doesn’t come until later in life.

But this all reveals an attitude that many top leaders have about education through an ossified opinion. STEM education is important and we should absolutely encourage more students to study in that field. Yet it doesn’t mean that we should steer some away from liberal art degrees because we believe that it will not lead to jobs.

Additionally, if we want students to succeed in certain fields, then continuing cuts to education isn’t helpful. It only harms our ability to mold our economy for the future.

Houston ISD Adopts myON for All Elementary School Students

The largest district in Texas will use the personalized literacy environment to boost early literacy and assist English language learners 

(Minneapolis, MN) April 11, 2016 — myON, K-12 education’s leading provider of personalized literacy environments, today announced a large implementation in Houston Independent School District (HISD), the largest district in Texas.

The contract will provide thousands of students in 179 buildings online and offline access to more than 10,000 books. myON has been implemented in all early childhood centers and elementary schools, as well as several middle schools and one high school.

HISD will use myON as part of the district’s Literacy By 3 Movement and summer reading program. myON’s in-depth reporting functions will be used to track progress for all student users to make sure that their reading levels improve over time. myON’s wide array of Spanish and bilingual titles will be useful in supporting the growing number of English language learners (ELLs) in the district.

Since the district first started using myON in March 2015, 212,663 users have spent 103,834 hours reading more than half a million books—totaling more than 14 million pages.

“We are honored to work with Houston ISD to improve reading skills for all students, including ELLs,” said Todd Brekhus, the president of myON. “We are amazed at the implementation so far, and as a team we hope to continue motivating children and families to read.”

Since its launch in 2011, myON has earned national recognition for its innovative approach to providing students with 24/7 online and offline access to a library of books personalized to match their individual interests and reading levels. The company recently launched myON 3.0, which includes new student and educator interfaces, advancements in content recommendations based upon individual student interests and Lexile® reading level, gamification, and enhancements to the state-of-the-art monitoring and reporting functions.

About myON

myON, a business unit of Capstone, is a personalized digital literacy platform that creates collaborative learning opportunities. myON expands the classroom for teachers and students by providing unlimited access to a collection of more than 10,000 enhanced digital books with multimedia supports, real-time assessments, and close reading tools. myON empowers students and teachers with real-time, actionable data—number and type of books opened and read, time spent reading, results of regular benchmark assessments, and more—based on embedded Lexile® assessments that measure student reading growth. With myON, every student experiences the benefits of personalized literacy instruction. For more information, please visit myON.com. 

Math Education Should Focus on Visuals, Research Says

There is new evidence on how the brain functions when we think about mathematics that could alter the way the subject is taught in K-12 and higher education classrooms. According to youcubed.org at Stanford University, the new paper, “SEEING AS UNDERSTANDING: The Importance of Visual Mathematics for our Brain and Learning,” supports the use of visual mathematics. The paper explains developing finger discrimination in students is crucial for the development of the brain and long-term success in math.

Think about how we learn math. Our brains actually visualize a representation of fingers when we solve problems, even if we don’t count on our actual fingers. Training people on ways to perceive their own fingers results in higher math achievement, according to co-author Dr. Jo Boaler, professor of mathematics education at Stanford Graduate School of Education and the co-founder of youcubed.org, Stanford’s center that provides resources for teaching and learning mathematics.

Dr. Boaler says that schools don’t know about this brain research, so many won’t allow students to use their fingers to count while doing math. The latest research suggestions that by not allowing students to count on their fingers, we actually halt their mathematical development.

The paper explains that parents and educators can work in unity to combat the issues surrounding math instruction in the classroom, and provides resources to help strengthen the visual pathways in their brains and achieve at higher levels of mathematics. The research shows that all individuals use visual pathways when they study math, so it’s best that parents and teachers develop this area of children’s brains.

Some ways this can be done is through using visuals, providing the opportunity for students to use drawing and visualizations in mathematics, asking students how they see mathematical ideas, and allowing students to represent mathematical ideas in a variety of ways (pictures, graphs, etc.).

Dr. Boaler explains that visual math helps students at any level develop a further understanding of the subject.

The authors also place a sense of urgency on the need to change the ways math is taught to students to support and encourage them to function well in society. When today’s students are in the workforce, these skills will be essential to have. All jobs in modern society require employees to see data patterns visually.

I appreciate the urgency the authors place on changing the way math is taught to students. I hope parents and teachers utilize the provided resources to lead students to greater success in mathematics.

Illinois Governor’s Education Plan: Take Chicago Money, Give to Suburbs

Chicago Public Schools (CPS) stand to lose close to $75 million in funding under Illinois Governor Bruce Rauner’s education plan. Releasing the plan this past Tuesday, Rauner’s funding arrangement for Illinois schools seemingly sends more dollars to school districts in the state’s suburban neighborhoods.

Under Rauner’s plan, schools in the state stand to receive $120 million but its not given out in a balanced manner. Chicago schools, or schools within the CPS district, will see a reduction of almost eight percent while other districts may get a bump of nearly five million.

To explain the reasoning behind the dip in funding, the state’s school superintendent Tony Smith said that all districts are getting more, including Chicago. Under the state’s old funding formula, declining enrollment in CPS, and the amount of poor students, Smith and Rauner state that CPS would have lost almost $190 million. But with Rauner’s new plan, that number has been significantly lowered.

In response to the cut in money coming from the state, CPS Chief Executive Officer Forrest Claypool criticized Rauner’s plan and doesn’t understand how losing money helps students.

Claypool said that Rauner’s plan is comparable to education funding in Mississippi in the 1960’s as minority and poor children are left behind.

He continued by saying that Rauner is the inverse of Robin Hood by stealing from the poor and giving to the rich and even introduced an Alice in Wonderland analogy.

It seems that the fight over funding breaks along party lines as Rauner is a Republican and some of those lending criticism to his plan are Democrats. It shouldn’t, though, as kids attending CPS are some of the state’s most vulnerable.

They are black and brown and some live within or below the poverty line. A cut of $75 million means that students will receive less when they need more to help them succeed.

Money is not the magic bullet that cures failing schools, but taking dollars away from districts that need help surely doesn’t help.

Can Social Media and Classrooms Co-Exist?

Social media is so prevalent, but is it really effective in enhancing learning in an academic setting?

The Huffington Post reports that social media use in education increased by 21.3 percent from 2012 to 2013, according to Pearson’s Learning Solutions. The same survey found that 59 percent of education affiliates subscribe to the effectiveness of interactive electronic learning via social media.

A 2009 online survey of K-12 principals, teachers and school librarians found that librarians used social media the most and saw the highest value in its utilization. The value was seen in creating professional learning communities, peer networking and enhancing school-wide communications. The majority of principals believed social networking to be very valuable and saw the positives of using social media to create collaborative learning communities, improve communications among staff, students, and parents and share information and resources with an extended community of educators.

Social networking applications can aid in teaching across the curriculum, permit and encourage learning outside of school hours, enhance and facilitate communication between students, teachers and parents, and nurture the development of digital citizenship skills.

The difficulty of utilizing social media in education lies in the variety of social media resources available. With so many of them, it is difficult to pinpoint which will be the most effective to incorporate into curriculum. Blogs/wikis, podcasts, LinkedIn, Facebook and Twitter are the main sources used in education, with blogs/wikis being identified as the most useful social media tool. Students are able to enhance learning by creating, adding comments, reading and by watching and listening to content in electronic format.

There is also the comfort issue with students. These digital natives are used to social media in other areas of life — so using it in the classroom comes easily. For kids who struggle with traditional means of learning, social media incorporation can spark more interest and get them involved in the learning process. There’s also a danger of distracting from the lesson at hand though. On typical social media sites, there is a lot that can distract students.

Increasingly, there are answers to that distraction problem, though. The higher adoption of social media use within the classroom has resulted in the rise of social network apps designed specifically for educators. These apps allow teachers to easily distribute course information, provide a place for students to upload assignments and feature a community chat forum for students and educators to communicate freely. It’s a safe social media space that combines the interactivity of what students and teachers love, without all of those extra distractions.

Like any classroom trend, social media use will have its highs and lows. Savvy educators, from preschool through college, will find smart ways to implement social media in their lessons to give it the biggest splash.

Have you successfully incorporated social media use into your classroom? What tactics work and what ones do you avoid?

 

Tips to Help Students Cultivate Music Appreciation

**The Edvocate is pleased to publish guest posts as way to fuel important conversations surrounding P-20 education in America. The opinions contained within guest posts are those of the authors and do not necessarily reflect the official opinion of The Edvocate or Dr. Matthew Lynch.**

A guest post by Anita Ginsburg

Many young people have always felt a connection to music. From the Beatles to Woodstock, from heavy metal to rap, each genre speaks to its devotees. As a teacher, it may be seem difficult to cultivate an appreciation for music genres outside your students’ preference. However, it is possible to get young people to foster an appreciation for different types of music with a little creative thinking.

Lyrical Breakdown

One unique way to build an appreciation for music is to do an activity in which you “chunk” lyrics and analyze meaning. For many people (students included), songs have special meanings. By analyzing what certain words and phrases might mean, students can gain a better appreciation for what the songwriter may have been thinking and feeling.

Sense Meditation

Another idea for music appreciation is to encourage the engagement of all the senses. Turn down the lights and have students close their eyes. Play pieces of music and then give them a chance to describe what the piece made them think about. Encourage them to tell what they could feel, taste, smell, hear, and see in their mind.

Compare/Contrast

Getting students to think critically is one goal in education. Making this relevant is sometimes a challenge. One interesting way to get student’s thinking about music is to have them compare and contrast songs. Let them choose a song of their own and find similarities and differences between it and a song that you would like them to learn more about. This is a great way to help them see that the divide may not be as wide as they thought.

Mashups

One popular music trend is creative “mashups” that combine two or more songs. A fun activity that will help students identify and appreciate different types of music is to play a version of “Name that Tune”. There are several great already created mixes available. Play the songs once or twice while students try to identify elements of music or names of songs. This would be a fun way wrap up a unit.

Music in Film

There are many ways to use film scores to teach music appreciation. One way is to view example clips from different movies and discuss how filmmakers add drama and excitement to their favorite movies using music. They could even do choose music that they think helps to illustrate their own life story if they were to produce a film about it.

Music appreciation can be fun and engaging for students if their teacher is willing to get creative think outside the box a little. It is likely that students will develop their own appreciation for different genres if they are given the opportunity and exposure to excellent examples. Getting a Master’s of Music Education can help you to inspire students and become a better teacher. Using tips like these can make the educational experience fun for everyone.