Uncategorized

The Problem with Education That’s Driven by Sanctions

Legislature passed during the 20th century was well-intentioned but has left 21st century education with a system featuring many nonviable aspects, and educational reform is only just now starting to figure out how to even begin to remedy history’s mistakes.

A major problem facing the nation’s school systems is that our children are over-tested, sometimes to an extreme. Still, the nation relies heavily on standardized testing as an indication that students are progressing toward established goals. Nationwide testing creates the risk of losing a broad variety of learning experiences and critical thinking instruction so valuable in high-quality education.

Testing often tends to focus on a narrow spectrum of items that can be easily assessed. However, higher-order skills such as analysis and reasoning are more critical in the real world and at the college level. Progressive teachers now are engaged in cooperative learning with students. The emphasis is on producing students who can think at a critical level and is a reflection of society’s influence.

The effectiveness of the NCLB sanctions is debatable. With so much pressure on schools, administrators, teachers, and students, it is important to understand whether the sanctions really facilitate improved performance. State tests that place teachers or administrators in some type of jeopardy—such as job retention, prestige, and income—have been compared to assessments such as the National Assessment of Educational Progress (NAEP), which has no potential penalties. Results seemed to indicate that state assessments generally showed an upward trend, but when compared to the NAEP, the results did not correlate well.

Even states that have modest rigor in their expectations of their school system are found to be failing under the NCLB Act. Simple, cookie-cutter assessment requirements and mandatory sanctions do not allow enough flexibility in achieving improvement. It is telling to observe that, in a relatively short amount of time, most state education systems have turned away from high-pressure and serious sanction methods such as those required by NCLB. These systems now propose a method whereby moderate pressure is used to extract desired changes. This appears to produce much better results.

To learn more about why NCLB was passed in the first place and where modern educational reform is headed, check out our series of articles on the history of America’s school system and where it’s trending towards now.

The 21st Century’s Alternative Approaches to Education

The 21st century has seen a boom in alternative schooling. But what are these other educational systems? How do they work? What is their draw? In this article, we talk some of the most common alternative schools that have come to prominence over the recent decades.

Charter schools are K–12 schools that receive government money but are freed from the usual constraints of public schools in exchange for increased accountability for academic achievement, delineated in the school’s charter. Charter schools were originally conceived by Ray Budde, a professor at the University of Massachusetts Amherst, in 1988. Minnesota was the first state to develop a charter school law in 1991.

In the early 2010s, charter schools began receiving great deal of attention as an alternative to traditional public schools. Although many have lauded charter schools as emblematic of reform and possibility, several factors are important to consider when discussing them. One of those points is accountability. Even though charter schools receive public funds, they are not accountable in the traditional manner. They must meet specified standards of performance, but have no agreed-upon level of performance across state lines, so the levels of evaluating and monitoring these types of schools vary widely across the country (this will change with the implementation of CCSS, especially for states that receive Race to the Top funds). Many local, state, and federal standards must still be met, but some are waived.

Another learning environment that is taking hold in the 21st century is the online format. Standards for judging the effectiveness of this type of teaching and learning environment have not been established, primarily because this form of education is so new. Charter schools have embraced online learning and often use this method of education delivery (in part or as a total mode). Because this mode of education is growing in popularity, a method of tracking performance is being developed.

Yet another educational option is homeschooling, with parents providing instruction to their children at home. According to the National Center for Education Statistics, an estimated 1.1 million children are being homeschooled. State-by-state standards for homeschooling need to be addressed. As it stands, very few states choose to exercise control over homeschools. Those states that do show some control may require homeschooled children to pass state-appropriate grade-level assessments.

Lastly, the voucher program has been toyed with since the 1950s. Practical problems make it difficult to implement the use of vouchers. It is difficult, for example, to come up with an equal system when private schools and public schools may have widely varying costs per pupil. And eligibility requirements for particular categories of students have never been established. Currently, students can fall into widely divergent categories, depending on the school system involved. Categories could range from autistic students to disabled students to students grouped by age, income, or residence.

The use of private vouchers, as it turns out, is less popular than the vouchers associated with public systems. In the private voucher systems, monies are typically collected from individual donors, such as religious organizations or corporations. The funds are then awarded through grants to low-income families. A similar program to the voucher system involves tax credit programs.

Expenses for schooling are credited through the tax system with reimbursements. While the voucher and tax credit programs may appear to be controlled by market forces, that is not the case in practice. Issues have arisen during the administration of these types of programs, including limits on particular students allowed to participate, the entanglement of bureaucracy, and monetary limits.

Public schooling may still have some issues to sort out, but that statement is true for alternative schools, too. New methods may bypass some of public school’s problems, but they are not yet flawless. Hopefully, as schools move forward into the 21st century, powerful educational reform will help school systems of all types shape up and shoot forward.

Comprehending How The Great Depression Influenced American Education

Education has always been influenced by the social, economic, and political conditions existing during various historical periods. During the 20th century, education in America was greatly influenced by changes in the economy, like the Great Depression.

The period after the crash of the stock markets in October 1929 was marked by the closure of banks, businesses, and factories. There was massive unemployment, particularly among minorities, and the markets were flooded with unemployed young people. The government’s focus shifted and placed the priority on providing relief measures and aid to the affected.

Social and economic circumstances adversely affected education. Schools closed in some instances or shortened their academic year, because districts could no longer bear the burden of teacher salaries and administrative costs. The crisis was more acute in the South and the Southwest, but by the beginning of 1934, almost 20,000 schools nationwide had been closed down. The crisis was so pervasive that students were required to bring their own supplies and, in some extreme cases, even pay for tuition.

Districts were unable to pay teacher salaries on time, and some districts resorted to issuing promissory notes instead of checks. This drastically reduced the number of teachers, resulting in increased class sizes. To manage with scarce resources, some school districts also resorted to stripping the scope of the curriculum.

Under his New Deal policy, President Franklin D. Roosevelt created two organizations to assist in the work relief programs. These programs played an extensive role in federal intervention directed toward education during the Depression. The Civilian Conservation Corps (CCC) and the National Youth Administration (NYA) were established in 1933. The CCC administered a temporary work assistance program, and the NYA administered two programs—the first a work relief and employment program for the needy and those out of school, the second a part-time employment assistance program for needy high school and college students. At one point, approximately 750,000 students were enrolled in the NYA program. But it slowly dawned on officials of both the CCC and the NYA that many of the participants lacked basic skills like reading, writing, and arithmetic, as well as vocational skills. For the first time in the history of the nation, the federal government began to offer education courses, primarily in the basic skills.

Other programs were initiated that brought some measure of relief to school districts experiencing financial difficulties. The Public Works Administration (PWA) allowed for the construction of many public buildings, including around 13,000 schools. At the same time, the Works Progress Administration (WPA) facilitated the employment of 100,000 teachers and engaged them in adult education and art education in some 1,500 WPA-operated schools. Combined, these programs educated around 1.5 million adults, including a large portion of the African American population, during the period between 1933 and 1938. The Department of Agriculture initiated a unique program of supplying surplus food to schools. This program is believed to be the forerunner of the National School Lunch Program that was launched much later.

The Great Depression was a time of massive need across the country, and changes to education reflected that. While many of the changes occasioned by the Great Depression have since faded away with the recovery of the country, many of the programs have remained, or at least provided the foundation for modern developments that you may be employing in your classroom today.

Uncovering the Devastating Impact of World War II on American Education

War may be good for a nation’s economy, but it’s horrible for a nation’s education.

In the United States, World War II, like the Great Depression, had a devastating effect on education. Much united effort was directed toward war resources and away from social programming. School funding was not immune, and much of the budget reserved for schools was redirected to support the Allied war effort. Both teachers and youth left the classroom to enlist. Dropouts became common, and school enrollments declined even further. High school enrollments were down from 6.7 million in 1941 to 5.5 million in 1944. By 1944, only two thirds of the pre-war teaching force was still teaching.

Military enrollment had another, more unexpected, consequence on education in America. Enrollment required academic testing, and many enlistees failed examination. Many military officers strongly criticized both the progressive education movement and the lack of a formalized curriculum focusing on subjects beneficial to defense. These vocal criticisms contributed to progressive education falling out of favor and the adoption of more formalized curricula in postwar years.

Employment and education opportunities increased for women during World War II. Because men were leaving their ordinary occupations to fight in the war, women stepped in to fill the gaps. More women were offered opportunities for education, and many found employment in the teaching field. One harbinger of hope for many schools was the Lanham Act of 1941, which provided aid to school districts that were overburdened with an influx of children from families employed in defense.

Higher education incomes fell, and the ability to generate income would have been much worse had it not been for specialized training and research needs of the federal government. Moreover, with colleges and universities playing a major role in educating people for the war industries and for wartime essential services, a sort of balance could be achieved in terms of income to these institutions.

During the postwar years, with veterans returning from the war, there was a coordinated effort to provide assistance to them, especially those whose education had been stopped as a result of military service. The Servicemen’s Readjustment Act of 1944, also known as the GI Bill, assisted nearly 8 million World War II veterans in a number of areas, including funds to attend school.

To learn more about how war and economic turmoil impacted education in the 20th and 21st centuries, check out our other articles on topics from the influence of the Great Depression on modern American schooling to how the Obama Administration has handled the effects of NCLB and where government is moving education toward now.

The 20th Century and Growth of Federal Involvement in Curriculum

The 20th century saw a big increase in the amount of federal involvement in educational matters. World War II and the Cold War put the country on edge, and the government became increasingly worried about ensuring the United States measured up on a global scale.

The launch of Sputnik by the Soviet Union in October 1957 turned out to be a landmark in the history of American education. There was a realization in the United States that in both technology and the military, the nation was slowly falling behind. In addition to the concerns over the nature of the curriculum, the shortage of well-trained teachers and engineers emerged as an additional area of concern. Major curriculum reforms were undertaken in 1958 with the passage of the National Defense Education Act (NDEA).

NDEA encouraged federal funding for improved instruction in the areas of mathematics, science, and foreign languages. For the first time, the federal government intervened in the content of elementary and secondary education curriculum with the goal of directing the curriculum toward the needs of the future. NDEA stressed the dissemination of the latest theories and modern technology. New materials and methodologies were developed, and summer programs were organized to train teachers on their use and implementation. The NDEA also extended financial help in the form of student loans and fellowships for college attendance, particularly for students with interest and ability in mathematics and science.

Schools during this period were pressured into a curriculum based on the structure of the disciplines. This curricular approach required students at all grade levels to engage in inquiry in various fields of study. It was generally accepted that a subject needed to be presented in a sequenced pattern over a number of grades, with complexity and abstraction increasing with each passing grade. The basic premise of the structure of the disciplines approach to the curriculum was that students engaged in inquiry would experience a more in-depth understanding of the tenets that served as a foundation for the subject they were studying. The federal government supported and advanced this specific curricular approach.

The growth of federal involvement in education has brought mixed results. With the 21st century moving forward, the United States government is in the process of reevaluating its role and what sort of strictures it should hold in place for schools in the future.

The 20th Century and Education’s War on Poverty

The 20th Century was a period of massive cyclical decline and growth. The Great Depression, World War II, and the Cold War all had a huge impact on not only the morale and psychological status of the country, but also on its socioeconomic makeup.

As the 1960s dawned, the postwar prosperity had eluded a large section of the population. The President’s Council of Economic Advisors estimated that nearly 20% of the nation’s population lived in poverty in 1962. President Lyndon B. Johnson believed that the government should play a more extensive role in reducing poverty and introduced legislation to expend social welfare programs in a number of areas, including education. Federal initiatives were directed toward affordable and subsidized housing for low-income groups and improved healthcare services.

Government support became available as well as to ensure food security (through school breakfast and food stamp programs), adequate housing (housing projects), health care (Medicaid), supplemental security income, and employment insurance. It was believed that improved healthcare and housing, and the ability to be “food secure” would relieve families living in poverty of stress and increase children’s ability to learn.

Legislation to improve the everyday living circumstances of the poor only partially addressed Johnson’s War on Poverty goals. Legislation also targeted efforts to improve educational circumstances of the poor. A basic premise of the War on Poverty was that education played a major role in eliminating poverty. The Vocational Education Act of 1963 was significant legislation that provided financial assistance to vocational programs and technical trainings in high school and postsecondary institutions. The act more than quadrupled federal funds for vocational education. A supplemental vocational education legislation, the Manpower Development and Training Act, focused on providing reskilling opportunities for the unemployed.

In 1964, the federal government enacted the Economic Opportunity Act (EOA) and established the Job Corps, with the objective of training 16- to 21-year-olds in literacy and employment skills so that they would be more prepared for employment. A groundbreaking outcome of the EOA was the Head Start program, which sought to provide disadvantaged children access to education on the same terms as those from advantaged homes. Of all War on Poverty legislation, the Elementary and Secondary Education Act (ESEA) of 1965 was the most far-reaching, and has turned out to be the most longstanding.

The ESEA provided more than $1 billion of federal funds to improve education for minorities and children from low-income families. Funding was allocated for purchase of textbooks and instructional materials, libraries, research on education, supplemental education centers, and for the education departments. Title I, federal educational funding for districts with a high number of low-income students, is also a part of ESEA.

Congress passed the Higher Education Act in the same year ESEA was passed. This legislation provided funds to assist higher education institutions to improve their libraries, as well as financial assistance to students in the form of loans and scholarships. In the end, the period between 1963 and 1969, under the Johnson presidency, saw a flurry of legislation that influenced the course of education by providing massive financial assistance to elementary and secondary schools, vocational training centers, colleges, and universities.

The 21st century has continued onwards with reforms aimed at helping close the socioeconomic gaps in educational access. To learn more about where education has come from and where it’s headed, check out our other articles on the history of American academics and the state of modern schooling.

Three Important Benchmarks in the History of Educational Equity and Equality in the U.S.

The fight for equality in education has been longstanding, influenced by social, legal, and political situations of various historical periods. As a result, the benefits of a free and equal education have not been available to all children at all times throughout the history of education in America. Race and gender have been two major areas where issues of equity and equality have arisen most prominently.

1. Racial Equality

In many ways, the refusal of slave owners to allow slaves to be educated is evidence of the historical perception of the power of knowledge possible from education. Slave owners believed that educated slaves were more disobedient and prone to unruliness and violence. They used fear and the law to ensure the ignorance, and hence the servility, of slaves. Education of African Americans was a low priority until Lincoln issued the Emancipation Proclamation in 1863. However, once barriers to education were removed, the stark contrast in education levels was evidenced by an increase in literacy rates of less than 10% in the 1860s, to 55% by 1890, and 89% around 1940.

The practice of segregation in Southern schools has previously been discussed. Even though laws to support segregated schools did not exist in the North, the practice of segregation was just as prevalent. In many Northern schools, segregation was facilitated by school district attendance policies. Because neighborhoods were segregated, children attended segregated schools in their respective neighborhoods. Because school district funding was dependent on the area’s tax revenues, and black neighborhoods of the time tended to be lower income, segregation resulted in differences in the quality of education received by White and Black students. On the whole, White schools had better facilities and teachers who were paid better than their counterparts in Black schools.

2. Brown v. Board of Education of Topeka

The Supreme Court ruling decision in the Brown v. Board of Education of Topeka in 1954 changed the course of education in America, and indeed American society, forever. In its landmark decision, the Supreme Court ruled that segregation of African American and European American children in public schools was unconstitutional. The court overturned the previous decision given in the Plessey v. Ferguson case, which allowed states to establish separate public facilities, including separate public schools.

In its ruling, the court opined that separate was inherently unequal and therefore a violation of the Equal Protection Clause of the Fourteenth Amendment. States were ordered to integrate public schools and also to remove laws and statutes that required other segregated public facilities. The case became a beacon of hope for the civil rights movement, which sought to achieve equal opportunities for all, irrespective of race, ethnicity, and gender.

In 1955, the Supreme Court ruled in Brown II that schools be integrated “with all deliberate speed.” States and school districts moved slowly in response to the second ruling, and it was not until the 1980s that the federal courts were able to eliminate legalized segregation in schools.

3. Gender Equality

Throughout American history, and especially in the 17th and the 18th centuries, women were discriminated against in education. There was practically no encouragement for women’s education beyond the basic reading and writing skills. Beyond that, they were taught homemaking skills, which were thought to be important to maintain a household. In colonial days, the general feeling was that girls did not need the same level of education as their male counterparts. Girls from upper-class families had the opportunity to attend Dame schools, but their education concentrated on instruction in dance, music, French, and other skills that were thought important for girls to get suitors.

In French colonial Louisiana, however, greater importance was given to education of girls, even in preference to education for boys. The general perception here was that educating girls was important, because educated females would bring sophistication to society. Boys, it was thought, needed to be trained only for future trades. Overall, however, discrimination against women in American schools was widespread, and even in co-educational establishments, little encouragement was provided to girls. This situation began to change in the late 19th century, when prominent women educators began to encourage the education of women, especially at the higher education level.

Prominent women, including Catharine Esther Beecher, Emma Willard, Mary Lyon, Jane Addams, Susan B. Anthony, Margarethe Schurz, and Mary McLeod, proclaimed the value of having highly educated women. The first women-only college, Vassar College, opened its doors in 1861. The first institution to offer graduate degrees to women was Bryn Mawr College, which was founded in 1885.

In 1972, sex-based discrimination in public and private schools receiving federal funds was prohibited by federal legislation in the form of Title IX. Title IX has been interpreted, reinterpreted, and misinterpreted in many cases to refer (more or less) to athletic programs and the scholarships associated with them, but the law also covers discrimination in academics.

Before 1972, high schools typically segregated classes according to sex. Boys were encouraged to take advanced math and science courses, while girls were dissuaded or even prevented from enrolling in those courses. Although Title IX had a profound impact on girls in athletics, the law also influenced the academic experiences of girls. Today, participation in high school athletics programs is nearly 50% female. Largely as a result of Title IX, there are currently no restrictions on course enrollment for female students.

Gender equity continues to be complex. For girls to benefit from education on par with boys, multiple dimensions of equity in education must be addressed. These include attention to access to education, equity in the learning process, equity in educational outcomes, and equity in external results. Interestingly, these areas have historically been issues in gender equity.

Access to education has been given much attention, and today, girls outnumber boys in college enrollment. Much has been written about the disparity in male and female participation in math and science courses; equity in the learning process ensures that girls receive the necessary support and resources to be able to participate in all aspects of the curriculum.

The outcome of education should be based on students’ efforts and talents. Equity of educational outcomes ensures, that gender bias does not exist on measures of students’ achievements and talents. Measured biased toward boys could result in inaccurate evaluation of the ability and talents of girls. Girls should have career opportunities and pay equivalent to their qualifications and achievements. Equality of external results ensures that once girls complete their education, they have opportunities on par with that of boys who have similar talents, qualifications, and achievements.

Four Diverse Educational Models Born from Reform Discontent

While many alternative schools have sprouted from discontent around efforts to reform public schools, some of these new schools feature entirely new models. Why keep trying the same failing pathway? Or so goes the rationale of four of the most pioneering of new schooling forms:

1. Virtual Schools

Instruction is delivered in virtual schools without the need for a physical space or infrastructure, because learning takes place primarily via technology. Virtual schools also offer everything available to students in physical schools, such as rules that must be followed, a teaching staff, organized field trips, and parent–teacher conferences. Although they didn’t surface until the 1990s, the popularity of virtual schools is evidenced by the fact that half of all states in America now offer some type of online learning program. Almost three quarters of a million students incorporate online learning into their education. In fact, due to the need of the current generation to possess online literacy, Michigan recently made it compulsory for students to include online learning as part of their education.

One of the most significant characteristics of virtual schools is their ability to offer specialized programs not offered at conventional high schools. Another unique feature of virtual schools is the 24/7 accessibility, a quality that has proven very attractive to students. There are no set times for class. Virtual classrooms not only tailor classes to students’ individual learning interests by offering specialized courses; they also make it easier for students from anywhere in the world to take part in offered classes and programs.

The initial rationale behind establishing virtual high schools was to supplement conventional high school programs. But the convenience and unique qualities possible with virtual learning formats resulted in the development of fully functioning high schools. From a personnel perspective, the virtual school is a solution to teacher shortages. Perhaps the greatest benefit of the virtual high school model is that it has opened up new possibilities for certain student groups, such as those with disabilities, those who are homeschooled, and even students who attend schools that lack the funding to provide specialized courses.

The virtual high school model has not been without its skeptics. Opponents suggest the virtual model alienates students. They maintain that schools teach social skills as well as academics and that social skills cannot be taught online.

2. The For-Profit Model

The for-profit model exists as a result of discontent by parents and other education stakeholders with the seemingly inability of traditional schools to address achievement and other educational needs of students. The model is based on the notion that a different approach to management of schools would lead to better educational outcomes. Education management organizations (EMOs) are for-profit companies that manage schools from a corporate model. They’re guided by the belief that they must deliver the “product” (i.e., student achievement) to clients (i.e., parents, students, and school boards) to stay in business. And because EMOs receive the same per-pupil funding from states as traditional schools, they must be able to use those funds more efficiently to make a profit. Some schools have been unable to raise achievement levels; EMOs believe they must do so in order to remain viable. EMOs primarily manage charter schools, but they also collaborate with school districts to manage traditional schools.

Edison Schools, Inc., is currently the largest EMO in the nation. EMOs like Edison contend that competition brought about by privatization of schooling would serve as motivation for improved schools that would subsequently lead to improved achievement among students. Given the choice, parents would send students to successful schools, causing organizations unable to run successful schools to go out of business. That’s not the case with government-run schools, EMOs would suggest, because some state- or district-run schools are allowed to operate year after year without improving student achievement.

Edison Schools manages 150 schools with 85,000 students across the United States. Their schools rely heavily on technology, and they often supply both teachers and students with computers. Edison Schools also have longer school days than traditional schools, with students normally attending schools for 8 hours a day. Teachers have more preparation time than is normally granted in regular public school settings. Researchers at Columbia University found that teachers at Edison Schools possessed higher morale than teachers in public schools and were passionate about teaching in Edison-run schools. But EMOs like Edison Schools are not without critics. Some education advocates believe that if schools were privatized, companies might focus more on profit than on the education and well-being of students.

3. Homeschooling

Discontent with traditional schools is also the impetus for the popularity of homeschooling. This is an educational model on the increase, with approximately 1.5 million students being homeschooled across the United States in 2007. That’s an incredible increase when compared to a population of 13,000 homeschooled students 30 years ago. The advent of the Internet has been one of the leading drivers behind this popularity. Apart from discontent over the perceived lack of effectiveness in traditional schools, parents may choose to homeschool their children for other reasons, including perceptions that traditional schools are unsafe and/or a desire for religion to be a larger part of their children’s education than is possible in public schools.

Generally, research suggests that homeschooling is an effective way to educate children. Student performance tends to exceed that of students in traditional schools. Skeptics of homeschooling refer to the negative consequences of social alienation and other social benefits that only a conventional school can offer, such as mixing with children of different backgrounds. This criticism is unfounded, because homeschooling does not appear to have a negative impact on students’ socialization. Homeschooled students appear to be well prepared to continue education beyond their homeschool learning environment and also appear to be more autonomous.

4. School Vouchers

The voucher program, in which school education vouchers allow parents to use federal funds for private tuition, has been toyed with since the 1950s. Many agree with the use of vouchers in theory, but practical problems make it difficult to implement their use. It’s tricky to come up with an equal system when private schools and public schools may have widely varying costs per pupil. And no one has agreed on the requirements for eligibility for particular categories of students. Currently, students can fall into widely divergent categories, depending on the school system involved. Categories could range from students with autism, to students with disabilities, to students grouped by age, income, or residence.

The use of private vouchers, as it turns out, is less popular than the use of vouchers associated with public systems. In the private voucher systems, monies are typically collected from individual donors, such as religious organizations or corporations. The funds are then awarded through grants to low-income families.

A program very similar to the voucher system involves tax credits. Expenses for schooling are credited through the tax system with reimbursements. The voucher and tax credit programs may appear to be controlled by market forces, but that’s not the case in practice. Issues that arise during the administration of these types of programs include limits on particular students allowed to participate, the entanglement of bureaucracy, and financial limits.

There are pros and cons to alternative schooling, but the new systems at least are trying to solve new problems with innovative approaches. Are you up-to-date on the latest news in alternative schooling? How can you use information on its successes (and failures) to help guide your own teaching?

Understanding The State’s Role in School Reform

School reform is a process that occurs on many levels and involves several layers of responsible parties. While the U.S. government is the largest entity involved in school reform, state government often spearheads local decision-making. The role of states in school reform is in two main areas:

1. First Phase: Results-Centered

In the 1980’s, states’ education reform actions were focused on straightforward policies and practices that could be easily be implemented and measured to determine effectiveness. Policies for teacher qualifications and the introduction of testing models fit into what can be described as “results-centered” initiatives. Nevertheless, problems—perceived or real—resulted from the first phase of reforms. Despite the desire of many groups to move away from homogeneity, the end result was a move toward standardization. Another setback of first-phase reforms was due to the reward system offered for high test scores. One example of this involved a teacher who had given students questions on an upcoming test to learn. Other teachers were instructing students with test questions from past exams or giving students similar tests to complete as student activities. Instead of teaching to educate their students, teachers were providing materials that would enable themselves to achieve highly. This meant that students were deprived of a holistic education, exposed to limited knowledge, and provided simply with means to pass the tests.

Despite these problems, reform efforts continued, and many associated problems were largely ignored by the governors of the states. Education reform was so important that governors during the 1980’s strived for the label of “education governor.” This honor was so highly regarded that, following their tenure as governor, many “education governors” ended up in top-rank political positions. And during the 1980s, states were also taking regulatory power away from the federal government. Although conservatives suggested this shift would help reduce regulatory burden, in time, states were perceived as being just as bad at placing demands and directives on local educational units as the federal government. During this same period, federal funding was also more restricted. States now had more power over how funding would be spent but a lot less funding to disperse.

2. Second Phase: Relieving the Regulatory Burden

The second phase of state school reform involvement took place in the latter part of the 1980s. States’ actions were in response to discontent that had arisen from first-phase involvement in the early to mid-1980s. The states’ main goal was to liberate schools from an overabundance of regulation and control from higher authority. Discontent emerged, however, as this reformed model of school administration was short-lived, lasting only a decade and then losing all support.

The method used to reduce regulatory burden was to increase management at the school level. Administration and organization were now the school’s responsibility. This promoted decentralization, as opposed to the top–down, centralized model. The power to make decisions passed predominantly to those on the ground (e.g., teachers and parents). As a working model, it gathered much support from education professionals and was seen as a model of inclusion where power shifted from bureaucratic decision makers to immediate stakeholders.

This site-based model was still centered on the leadership and direction of the school principal. From a state perspective, decentralization was apparent, but on a working level, the inclusive model was merely a shift of responsibility from one layer of administration to another, without providing adequate personnel support. An additional flaw in the model also surfaced. The personnel support was intended to come from staff working under the principal, even though these individuals already had duties and engagements that were not alleviated to allow them participate effectively in the process. Teachers viewed the model as infringing on time they needed to plan and teach. The end result of this lack of coherent, well-communicated reform was that this reformed model of school management received as much criticism and resistance as the previous model with burdensome regulation. Consequently, the site-based model was discontinued in most districts within a decade.

Educators: Why You Need To Know About The 1990s And School Restructuring

Over the past few decades, reform trends have risen and fallen from prominence. However, one early system has had long-lasting effects that likely still resonate in your classroom today. What was this long-lasting change-up? School restructuring.

The notion of restructuring became popular in the late 1980s and early 1990s, primarily in reaction to the failure of previous attempts to improve existing education structures through reform. The goal of restructuring was to change the organizational structure of schools in ways that supported student learning. Three main areas were the focus of restructuring school reform efforts during this period.

First, teachers were to have a larger role in school management functions and also to have greater autonomy and flexibility in choosing instructional methods and materials. With more input into school management, teachers would also have a forum in which to contribute to using the learning environment, school resources, and time at school to improve student learning. Second, student learning and achievement was another area of focus for restructuring efforts. With changes in teacher roles and responsibilities in the learning environment, proponents of restructuring believed students would have increased opportunities to learn and could learn at higher, more rigorous levels. Third, restructuring was to make schools more inviting places that would be more aware of and responsive to the needs of students and their families.

A number of reforms were implemented during the 1990s that were consistent with the notion of restructuring. Stricter requirements for graduation were implemented, which included increases in the number of high school credits as well as changes in course requirements. For example, all students were required to complete courses in math and science, even though levels of difficulty in courses existed. There was general agreement that longer days with more quality instruction were needed to improve student achievement, and a number of schools pursued reforms focused on increasing the amount of time available for students to focus on learning.

Standards-based education also emerged during this period. Based on the requirements of postsecondary education, which were established at the time, specific standards were set regarding what academic and practical knowledge students were required to gain during their time at various stages of school. These requirements have changed since standards-based education was introduced, and accordingly, the test content requires continuous review and updating. Students are tested based on these standards using standardized measures. Student and school performance is used as an indicator of the success or effectiveness of that school, the staff, and the state.

Higher expectations of teachers were also an outgrowth of the reforms of the 1980s and 1990s. It is important for states to ensure teacher competency by determining the knowledge and skill levels of new teachers as they enter the profession. Requiring new teachers to pass tests at the end of training or before receiving a teaching license is one method currently used to evaluate and ensure teacher knowledge. The testing of teachers is surrounded by debates relating to how and what material to test teachers on, as well as whether or not standards are high enough to render teaching licensure meaningful.

The meaning and purpose of restructuring changed in the 2000s, as No Child Left Behind (NCLB) came into being in 2001. Restructuring now refers to an action taken by states for schools consistently unable to meet annual achievement targets as required by NCLB. In this instance, schools are required to develop restructuring plans designed to improve student achievement. Reorganization of the governance structure is required, with options available to the schools such as adopting a charter and becoming a charter school; replacing some or all school staff, including the principal; or contracting with an outside entity (e.g., EMO) to operate the school.

States are required to sanction poorly performing schools under NCLB regulations, although some also feel it prudent and motivating to reward high-performing schools. These actions are likely based on the fact that recognition and reward have been shown to lead to improved performance among teachers, which is more positive and may have more of an effect than extending sanctions. Other states, however, sanction poorly performing schools, even when they are not required to do so under NCLB. In many ways, rewarding schools and providing assistance to poorly performing schools is more in keeping with the teacher empowerment goals of the school restructuring efforts implemented in the 1990s.

Restructuring was an idea that shook up the American school system – and not in an entirely good way. As an educator, you need to be aware of what it was and what it did so that you can deal with any residue still dusting the classrooms of your school district.