Uncategorized

A Look At High-Stakes Tests: The Pro’s and Cons

Education today is run rampant with evaluations. Classroom tests, national standardized assessments, even scores that reflect international performance – students from elementary school through high school face all of them. Of the most important of today’s educational assessments are a set known as “high-stakes tests.”

High-stakes tests are assessments that have a high-impact outcome, where, for example, passing the test would allow the student entry into a grade or permission to graduate. The assessments that are part of NCLB are considered standardized high-stakes tests. The act states that if state-run schools are to receive federal funding, students should be given (and must pass) certain assessments. Ultimately, students’ futures and school funding rely on these standardized test scores. Some subjects, such as foreign languages and humanities, are not included in the tests.

Those in favor of high-accountability tests claim that there is no serious method of measuring student achievement other than standardized tests. They assert that this is the best way that equality in education can be ensured across the United States. Supporters cite the fact that NCLB was created to raise the standards of achievement and close the gap between students of different races and class distinctions. NCLB has gained many advocates in congress, who all make the point that failure should also be measured, to detect areas that need improvement.

On closer examination, a clear gap between reality and federal educational goals still exists. NCLB might be overlooking the disparity that exists in America’s educational system, because many students are not reaching the standards that the tests are evaluating. Some of the reasons people oppose high-stakes tests include:

1. Unfairness

The same test is administered in a well-supplied, sophisticated school and in an under-funded, ill-equipped school, and all students are expected to measure equally regardless of race, poverty, access to resources, and language differences. Wealthier students may not be more intelligent than deprived ones, but they are more likely to have access to resources that contribute to the acquisition of the competencies that are required to pass the tests. National data show that minority groups tend to have a higher chance of failing high-stakes standardized tests.

2. Dropouts increase

High-stakes testing is likely to result in increased numbers of dropouts among less-confident students or students with special needs. To make a good impression and avoid being sanctioned by the state, teachers tend to focus on students who are likely to reach proficiency on standardized tests. They often forsake weak students, who are at risk of becoming dropouts. The National Research Council found that low-performing elementary and secondary school students who are not promoted do not achieve better standards the following year. In fact, they generally become resentful and, as a result, are much worse off. Some states have chosen to implement high-stakes tests as a requirement for graduation, which has resulted in a higher dropout rate.

For example, in Massachusetts, 71% of African American students graduated the year before the tests became a graduation requirement, but only 59.5% did so the next year. For Latino students in Massachusetts, the rate went from 54% to 45%, and for Asian students, it dropped from 89% to 81%.

3. Redefinition of Teaching

Teaching is now inclined to focus on preparation of students for these tests. This technique may show an increase in high grades, but it does not ensure acquisition of knowledge. And subject syllabuses suffer changes. Some subjects are clearly given less attention in these evaluations and are sacrificed in favor of extra time for test practice. A study by the Center on Education Policy found that about 62% of school districts increased the amount of time spent in elementary schools on English, language arts, or math (these are the subjects to be tested by order of the state), while 44% of districts cut time on science, social studies, art, music, physical education, lunch, or recess. Teachers admitted that they spent a fair amount of their time instructing for test-taking skills and using mock exams for this purpose, instead of applying formative assessment techniques to gain an understanding of student motivation, level of knowledge, abilities, or grasp of the subject. Research has shown that when teachers devote more time to test preparation, students may become more efficient on standardized tests, but other test scores often drop.

4. Low Reliability

Even expert-constructed tests may contain flaws. Sometimes responses are keyed in incorrectly and not revised, which may result in inaccurate scores.

5. Teacher Stress

Studies have shown that 7 in 10 teachers have complained about becoming stressed due to test-preparation activities, which are generally nonmotivational and not aligned with the objectives of a class. The incessant drills students have to endure make them more inclined to lose interest and complain about boredom, fear, or isolation. Preparing students for a test is not the only stressing factor; teachers must guarantee that students are sufficiently prepared to face the tests and that all the techniques have been mastered. Many teachers have become frustrated by not being able to practice high-quality teaching and have therefore chosen to leave state-run schools and apply to private schools, where high-stakes tests do not rule the curriculum.

In the midst of all this controversy, teachers at state-run schools need to find ways to meet federal requirements while fostering motivation and learning among students. Many may contend that high-stakes tests are not efficient or reliable enough to measure student achievement; however, they continue to be part of teacher concerns these days. In the light of their reality, teachers have come to terms with NCLB, by finding ways of engaging students, combined with mastery of the material and techniques that will help when preparing students for standardized exams.

Educators: Do You Know About These Alternatives to High-Stakes Tests?

How to best quantify educational achievement and recognize academic progress is a continually hot debate. Standardized tests are too uniform and broad in scope to consistently measure individual competence, and high-stakes tests can put too much importance on a single data point of success or failure.

Many believe that authentic assessments, and not high-stakes standardized tests, are the most appropriate tools to collect information on student learning and progress. They argue that assessing student responses to real-world scenarios or tasks is more meaningful than standardized testing. Authentic assessments provide the additional benefit of pin- pointing where and why a child may be struggling. It is important to take into account that learning is developmental and therefore will occur in any circumstances. Learning occurs naturally when the learner finds there is a purpose behind it. When the subjects being taught are seen as isolated pieces of information, without association or context, learning becomes meaningless.

Much of the current thinking regarding alternative forms of student assessment derives from the concept of higher-order thinking skills first introduced in Benjamin Bloom’s 1956 taxonomy of educational objectives. Bloom noted six levels of thinking skills: knowledge, comprehension, application, analysis, synthesis, and evaluation. Higher-order thinking skills are those skills in the top three levels: analysis, synthesis, and evaluation.

For deep and meaningful learning to occur, teachers must create lessons and activities that develop and routinely assess these skills. Higher-order thinking skills are used when people run into unfamiliar problems. When a person can apply higher-order thinking skills to these occurrences, their decisions are much more likely to engender positive results.

For students to develop higher-order thinking skills, they must first have the ability to use prerequisite lower-order skills such as retaining facts and discriminations. You can help your students develop higher-order thinking skills by providing supportive, effective lessons and structuring assessments that allow them to use those skills.

Authentic assessments encourage students to analyze and interpret their own learning experiences. They generally require students to use higher levels of thinking, integrate the knowledge they have constructed in different areas, and use it for problem-solving situations. It is important to realize that these assessments, while very useful in the classroom setting, may not be appropriate for wide-scale testing, because they are suited for comparatively limited content. They are, however, very well suited to more frequent use than ordinary standardized tests.

Two important authentic assessments are portfolios and exhibitions. A portfolio allows the display of a particular set of skills and knowledge in response to a realistic set of requirements. Often students will be given a chance to prepare in advance for portfolio submissions, which gives the teacher a chance to adequately communicate what is required from the student in the portfolio. The selection of portfolio content and material should be based on goals and standards, and should include a broad range of accomplishments (including products, essays, quizzes, hobbies, etc.). Student portfolios can take many forms, including paper or electronic.

An exhibition requires students to display their understanding of a course or experience as a whole, often without defined requirements. This work is often judged (evaluated) by a panel, or may even be displayed in front of the student’s parents or peers, and thus requires a great deal of preparation. These forms of assessment require teachers to be highly objective during grading, because each portfolio or exhibition will be assessed individually, rather than against set criteria. The teacher will establish a reliable rubric for the assessment of individual work during planning and will communicate the parameters for assessment to the students clearly and unambiguously.

Assessments that are designed to be more individualized or specifically focused in structure can give a much more authentic read of how an individual student is doing. They may take more effort, but the more accurate results they yield also seem to be well worth the extra work.

Integrating Standardized Test Preparation into Your Curriculum

In this age of accountability, teachers are responsible for ensuring that their students learn. To measure what students know and don’t know, states all over the country administer standardized tests. Many new teachers are clueless about how to best prepare their students for these high-stakes tests, and this can cause a lot of anxiety. Most are left with one simple question, “What can I do?”

Experienced teachers will tell you that standardized test preparation should be part of the day-to-day curriculum, but you shouldn’t teach to the test. Here are some tips that will help you incorporate standardized test preparation as part of the regular day at school:

  • Before you can help your students prepare for the standardized test, understand the components of the test yourself. Check the specific areas that the test emphasizes. If you haven’t received the test guidelines from the school administration, you can get the guidelines, as well as older versions of the test, from your state department of education’s Web site.
  • When you know the areas that are covered on the standardized tests and the amount of emphasis that each section receives, you can ensure that you cover those areas well in advance.
  • Don’t spend time on a specific section just because it’s a favorite of yours.
  • Use the older versions of the standardized tests, and incorporate typical questions into unit tests and weekly quizzes. This ensures that the students get used to the format and don’t dread the unfamiliar format when it appears on the standardized test.
  • A typical aspect of the standardized test is the assessment of higher-order thinking skills. If you teach your students to think critically, you can be sure that they’ll be able to handle any question that appears on a standardized test. Raise the bar by creating class discussions that allow them to evaluate, analyze, synthesize, and apply what they’ve learned.
  • Cross-curriculum connections help students learn information more authentically. You can use your language class to teach about historical personalities and more.

If you can integrate standardized test preparation into the daily curriculum, you’ll help alleviate your students’ apprehension regarding these once-a-year tests. Good luck!

Teachers: Make the Most of Your Classroom Assessments

While it’s usually outside the scope of a teacher’s responsibilities to make decisions about standardized testing in school, it is every teacher’s responsibility to perform classroom assessment.

Not every classroom assessment looks the same. There are several steps to take when deciding which assessments you will use. First, decide what information you want to retrieve from this assessment. Choose a technique or tool that is consistent with your teaching style and that offers no extra complications to students. Second, always inform your students about the purpose of an assessment activity before conducting it. Finally, after giving the assessment, review the results and make any necessary adjustments to teaching or lesson planning. Always inform your students of the results of an assessment.

Formal assessment implies that a test will be administered, and afterward students will receive a mark or grade. Informal assessment, or monitoring, on the other hand, is evaluated by descriptive criteria. You will come across many ways of assessing students, because each teacher will have his or her own system. For instance, experienced teachers will try informal approaches, such as observing students’ oral production or asking them to complete self-assessment sheets. This will help teacher’s spot diverse types of learners, and they will consequently gain a perception of the group style. This impression will then be further investigated with the aid of other forms of assessment, such as quizzes or brief essays.

It can be difficult to assess whether the student can apply the knowledge in contexts other than a multiple-choice task. Authentic assessments clearly show a student’s grasp of the knowledge and skills associated with a subject. As a consequence, there is a growing tendency for schools to ask for student portfolios (a summary of the student’s work over a certain grading period), which go hand in hand with state-of-the-art assessment methods, and clearly shows stages of progress in students’ work and feedback written by the teacher, the learner’s, or classmates. These should be specially designed to document students’ efforts, progress, and achievements.

Bear in mind that students and parents naturally expect feedback after an activity, whether formal or informal, carried out in class or sent as homework. Teachers are obliged to mark and analyze work critically, in order for their students to have a valuable learning experience. Feedback about what students can do to improve is essential. Through clear and conscientious feedback, teachers will convey the message that there’s always room for improvement, and this will generate a positive attitude toward work. Remember that assessment affects the learner’s motivation.

For learners to feel comfortable contributing in class or confident when completing a task, a grading system should convey fairness. Well-trained teachers analyze what is appropriate for the learner or the situation. Designing grading categories for every class may become a way to show more transparency and fairness when evaluating. Using simple rubrics, followed by short definitions for each category, will make it easier for students to understand their progress in class. Performance-based curriculums are a great way to encourage students to be creative, innovative, and constructive. Assessing student projects, however, can sometimes be a problem because often there is no clear-cut answer. For this reason, rubrics have become increasingly popular. Some have suggested that, instead of the traditional A, B, C, D, and F grades, a rating scale of between three and five elements could be implemented. Following is an example of a basic rubric rating scale:

1. Excellent Progress

The student shows no difficulty in using the language area. (Remember that if this rating is used too frequently, it may lose its value.)

2. Expected Progress

The student is using the language according to the expectations set for his or her age.

3. Unsatisfactory Progress

The student is not keeping up with the content planned for the class. 
Students should be presented with rubrics at the beginning of the project unit, which will allow them to be more autonomous when analyzing their own work and to understand the reasons for the teacher giving them one rubric score instead of another. Explaining rubrics at an early stage transmits a message of transparency and consistency to students.

Part of your job as a teacher will be to give low marks when work is below par. This is sometimes a very unpleasant task. As mentioned, there’s always room for improvement, and it’s also part of your job as a teacher to make that happen. Learners will be able to perform better and achieve at the desired level, aided by an effective assessment program and remediation.

When creating a classroom assessment, it is important to remember that “assessment” is not the same as “evaluation.” Though assessment and evaluation are generally used interchangeably, there are subtle differences between the terms. 
For example, a chemist inspects some liquid he has collected in a test tube. At first glance, he can describe its density, smell, and color. He is assessing the material. After the assessment, he takes a sample and analyzes the combination of particles the liquid contains. He is now evaluating the material. 
Let’s take an example related to education.

A teacher might assess the level of interest in environmental matters in her classroom by asking for a show of hands or encouraging students to brainstorm topics. To switch her planning accordingly, she then uses the information to think of exercises more likely to capture her students’ attention. But if this teacher gives a test on recycling and assigns a mark to it, she is evaluating her students in terms of academic achievement. So, assessments are not necessarily considered evaluations.

Think about what kind of progress your students need to make, and what would make the best benchmarks to look for would be. Classroom assessment is a chance for you to exercise your autonomy as a teacher – make the most of it.

Seven Major Strategies for Creating Formative Assessments

Classroom assessment is a chance for teachers to put their creative and evaluative skills to the test. The structure and content of classroom assessments are entirely up to you. However, if you’re unsure of where to start, there are some precedents you could follow. We’ve got articles on them all, but to start, we’ll take a look at formative assessments.

Formative assessment occurs during a learning situation. For example, while reading a short story, a teacher might want to check for understanding by asking questions focused on the topic of concern. Formative assessment implies ongoing communication between the teacher and students, in the form of observations, questioning, and discussions. These interactions provide valuable feedback about students’ communication skills, social skills, and level of achievement. Classroom interactions are rich sources of information, and certain techniques can help make the most of these opportunities for assessment.

Checking for understanding during the presentation of a topic will allow you to get an impression of your students’ grasp of the matter at hand and to avoid long explanations at the end of the session. Close monitoring during written activities, whether in individual, paired, or group work, will foster the students’ confidence in completing the task, and this will also be a helpful tool in assessing whether any changes or extra explanations need to be done. In addition to checking understanding and levels of knowledge, teachers should focus on students’ attitudes, feelings, and interests. Surveys can be an effective means of assessing student attitudes.

Monitoring provides the information needed to adjust teaching and learning while they are happening. It helps teachers make informed decisions and become aware of the extent to which students are learning what is being taught and whether the methods they are using are fostering or discouraging learning.

Formative assessment is the assessment of students’ progress toward a goal, conducted at regular intervals, with the teacher issuing feedback to help to improve the students’ academic achievement. To carry out a formative assessment, you might want to ask open-ended questions and check your students’ understanding of the task. Some students will be eager to answer, while others will choose not to speak in front of their peers. This can result in the same students responding to every teacher query during class discussions. If this is the case, you might want to direct your questions to particular students to foster commitment. Remember that their reticence may be due to lack of understanding, or simply a lack of confidence in speaking in front of their peers. Rephrasing the question or asking another student for assistance can be helpful.

A different approach to formative assessment is giving anonymous written tests, such as quizzes, which give the teacher a notion of the group’s understanding of what is being taught. It is important to keep records of formative assessment and include them in planning; this will allow you to analyze student progress through a grading period. Assessments must have a clear focus and reflect the content and methods the teacher has been using. In other words, the assessment should respond to the questions what, why, and how. The first thing teachers must do is to properly answer the questions themselves. There is no point in assessing when the purpose and the content are not clearly defined from the very beginning, just as there would be no point in testing students on a topic they have never explored.

Some of the top formative assessment strategies that could be carried out in class are:

1. Sharing Goals and Criteria

As mentioned, the more teachers make students a part of their learning process, the more they will engage with class work, because they will consider it to be meaningful. To have a successful year and achieve your objectives for your students, you should share your evaluating criteria and goals for the year with other teachers. Using examples of what behaviors will and will not be tolerated can also prove highly effective.

2. Observation

Teachers use observation to determine whether students need clarification. Making yourself available for consultation by walking around the class will help avoid disruptive behavior and will provide all students—not just the ones who are confident enough to ask a question in class—with necessary information. Observation also helps teachers to make any necessary modifications in lesson plans. Instant feedback generates an environment of communication and trust, where students are allowed to ask for help and feel that the teacher is not bothered by their lack of understanding.

3. Questioning

Teachers can use questions, in the form of a quiz, in place of a verbal review, after introducing a new topic in class. This type of strategy elicits immediate information about what students know related to the material being presented. Questions also foster critical thinking and debating, which in turn serve as prompts for speaking in class and help with fluency.

4. Checks for Understanding

These actions are a chance to survey if students are following your explanations. Examples of this type of assessment include:

  • Asking open-ended questions
  • Asking students to provide examples, either oral or written
  • Asking students to identify the pattern that is being taught (signaling with thumbs up or 
down, saying yes or no, holding up response cards, etc.)

Asking one of the students to explain it to the rest of the class. 
Teachers can either monitor one student at a time or all students at once, depending on the traits of the group, the time available, and the size of the group. Bear in mind that, for the assessment to be effective, all students should have an opportunity to produce their own answers without being prompted by others. Only by giving their own answers will they experience the learning process.

5. Self-Assessment and Peer Assessment

This formative assessment strategy helps build bonds among students and provides individual students with an understanding of their learning process (metacognitive thinking).

6. Record Keeping

Making students keep a record of their grades gives them ownership of their learning process. They will be able to understand where they are and where they should be in relation to classroom goals.

7. Supervised and Extended Practice

Another way to carry out consistent monitoring is to prepare extended practice worksheets to reinforce what has been explained and checked. These activities could either be designed for completion in the classroom or given as homework.

Remember, each student is an individual. As you learn about each of your students, you can tailor your instruction. This will ensure that all students have opportunities to learn and to demonstrate what they know.

Summative Assessments: Do You Know These Basics?

Classroom assessment is a chance for teachers to put their creative and evaluative skills to the test. The structure and content of classroom assessments are entirely up to you. However, if you’re unsure of where to start, there are some precedents you could follow. We’ve got articles on them all, but to start, we’ll take a look at summative assessments.

Summative assessment in K–12 learning environments is often a test given at the end of distinct periods of time and is meant to evaluate what students know. Authentic assessments can also be used as summative assessments. Summative assessments can be administered at the end of a learning module, grading period, or school year. They are also given at certain points in time that are not necessarily an end point; for example, a standardized test for fourth graders may be given halfway through the school year and is meant to test educational knowledge to that point—not for the entire grade level. Summative assessment differs from formative assessment because educators do not adjust their teaching methods for that particular group of students based on the results. But teachers may use summative assessment to remediate students who failed to garner a satisfactory score. K–12 scholar Paul Black compared formative assessment to a cook tasting soup during the preparation process, while summative assessment takes place when the customer tastes the same soup.

Summative assessment methods are sometimes controversial, but are a very real part of the current K–12 learning environments. Terms like “teaching to the test” exist because of this part of the educational process that emphasizes end results. These consequences, whether good or bad, are considered a reflection on individual teachers, administration, schools, and districts. High-stakes tests, like standardized tests, fall into this category as an example of a blanket summative assessment meant to rank students after instruction based on a common curriculum. Summative assessments happen too late in the educational process to provide teachers with the information needed to make adjustments on a specific learning goal for a specific group of students.

Information gained through summative assessment is helpful to instructors, however, because it can redirect the future of a particular subject or course based on student outcome. Ideally, improvement in summative assessments after a change in teaching methodology or materials encourages teachers to stay on the same path for the next group of students. On the flip side, summative assessment can pinpoint weak areas in the learning process and help the teacher understand what subjects need more attention the next time around.

Many factors, in addition to what students actually know, go into students’ success on summative assessments. Things like the type of test (written, oral, etc.), timing of the test, and other environmental aspects can influence the way students perform on summative assessments, regardless of their knowledge of the subject.

While potentially overwhelming to encounter, summative assessments can be a powerful tool in examining student knowledge. Think about what kind of scope you need to test your students’ learning on, and decide whether a summative approach would work best for you. If the jury’s still out on your answer, check out our other article on the subject: “The Five Major Points of Summative Assessments.”

The Five Major Features of Summative Assessments

Creating a classroom assessment that best quantifies your students’ learning can be tricky business. Because of their broad scope but specific content focus, summative assessments can be a powerful tool to quantify student learning. However, in order for a summative assessment to be most effective, five aspects must be in play: authenticity, reliability, volume, validity, and variety. Here’s how each fits into the summative assessment equation:

1. Authenticity

A test should examine real-world applications. For example, a math test with equations alone is less effective than one with story problems or ways to associate the skill outside of the testing environment. It’s one thing for students to memorize a fact or answer; it’s another for them to comprehend the material in order for it to be helpful later in life.

2. Reliability

Tests given as summative assessments should hold up in another setting, or with another set of students. In other words, the reliability of an assessment implies that it consistently produces similar results when given under similar conditions. Standardized tests are an example of assessment meant to be reliable in every setting.

3. Volume

Educators should avoid the urge to over-test. Summative assessments should be used only when absolutely necessary to determine the level of learning that has been achieved. Too much volume leads to testing fatigue for both students and teachers and can inadvertently cause the quality of the testing to suffer.

4. Validity

As closely as possible, testing needs to reflect the objectives taught in a certain period of time. Educators should already know learning goals before teaching a particular topic or in a certain time frame. Validity does not exclude valuable student-led discussions from teaching modules, but educators should test strictly on the aspired outcomes. It’s unfair to test students on information that was not addressed during a certain teaching episode.

5. Variety

This factor has perhaps the largest impact on student success in summative assessment. Every student demonstrates his or her knowledge in a specific way, and giving a one- dimensional test can adversely affect individual learners. Testing should always include cognitive, psychomotor, and affective learning domains. These include group presentations, work portfolios, research papers, and timed pencil-to-paper testing.

A comprehensive, effective assessment plan for students is one that engages them throughout the learning process by way of formative assessment and then gauges the success of those activities with a summative assessment. Both aspects are needed to better measure student learning and adjust teaching when necessary. By allowing students to influence the learning process along the way, educators will see increased scores on summative assessments.

Thinking about the major points in play for summative assessments as compared to formative assessments can help teachers new and old decide which better serves their classrooms’ needs. Both summative and formative assessments are equally necessary and effective, but have different goals. They are supplementary in the learning process. Although the information gathered by using summative assessments is of great importance, some aspects of the learning process will be left uncovered. While formative evaluation shows the learner’s progression toward the objective, summative evaluation shows whether the student has met the objective. To learn more about summative assessments’ counterpart, check out the article “Seven Major Strategies for Formative Assessments.”

Establishing Order In Your Classroom: Five Common Approaches to Classroom Management

This article introduces different classroom management approaches, with the self-discipline and the desist approach at opposite ends. There’s no single method for managing a classroom effectively, because different situations require different approaches. The root of the problem should be the key factor in deciding which approach should be used.

The Self-Discipline Approach

This approach is based on the belief that students are responsible individuals who can assess and correct their own misbehavior, and that teachers and students have trusting relationships built on respect. With its self-governing style, the self-discipline approach has four models, which are discussed next.

Inner Discipline

Developed by Barbara Coloroso, inner discipline takes a longer route in correcting student misbehavior. As the name indicates, the goal here is to help students develop inner discipline. When students have self-discipline, they will have control and responsibility for their own actions. Whether or not it’s a choice with a positive outcome, unless there is a threat to the student or others, teachers should let students make their own choices.

Using inner discipline, when students misbehave, teachers should ask what students and teachers could do together to change. Students and teachers cooperate to build a community where they share the power. An underlying premise of this approach is that students do not have lasting discipline when quick solutions such as reward systems are used.

According to Coloroso, there are three types of teachers: “brick-wall,” “jellyfish,” and “backbone.” As the names suggest, “brick-wall” teachers are strict, demanding students to follow the rules without questioning and there are no exceptions. “Jellyfish” teachers enforce the rules like the way a jellyfish moves. The rules are not clear, and teachers often change the rewards and punishments, so students cannot expect consistency from these teachers. Last, “backbone” teachers give strong support, but from behind.

Assertive Discipline

Although assertive discipline is based on the fact that teachers have the power to ask and require specific actions from students, this approach still has students’ best interests in mind. Canter found that teachers who use this discipline are not authoritarian, because they are forceful yet calm in enforcing the rules and limits. This discipline allows teachers to present clear rules. It gives students the clear idea that misbehaviors have consequences and that, if they want positive consequences instead of negative ones, they can make choices that will lead to positive consequences.
The Desist Approach

This approach is often used due to its easy implementation. Unlike the self-discipline, where students are responsible, the desist approach makes teachers the responsible party. This approach can be viewed as a power system, because teachers have the power, and they set the specific rules to give students discipline and correct student behaviors. The approach focuses on assertive discipline and behavior modification, as outlined next.

Behavior Modification

This approach centers around four types of punishment/reinforcement:
1. Positive reinforcement: Giving extra credit for a question answered with much thought

2. Positive punishment: A meeting with the principal

3. Negative reinforcement: Removal from list of students who have 
to answer questions

4. Negative punishment: Decrease in free time

In behavior modification, positive reinforcement is the most effective, while punishments are comparatively ineffective. It goes without saying that teachers are expected to encourage good student behavior instead of criticizing misbehavior.

Have you tried out any of these models? How did they go? What model works in one classroom may not be as effective with a different set of students. Think about the flow of your classroom and the needs of the children in it, and then decide what model would most effectively manage your classroom. If the models here don’t sound appealing, check out our two other articles on approaches to classroom management.

Reality Therapy: What Educators Need to Know About Glasser’s Approach to Classroom Management

This article discusses another classroom management approach: reality therapy. While there’s no single method for managing a classroom effectively, because different situations require different approaches, the root of the problem should be the key factor in deciding which approach should be used. Read on to learn about reality therapy and to decide whether or not the approach is for you.

Developed by psychiatrist William Glasser in the 1960s, reality therapy is used to guide students in becoming responsible individuals who are able to satisfy their own needs for the benefit of themselves and others. Despite its maturity, this approach has stood the test of time and is still in use today. This approach was developed with the idea that students know their own needs and wants and will make changes to get closer to where they want to be. Teachers are supposed to help students with making the right choices, while avoiding the wrong choices. Rational students should make the final decision themselves. If students opt for the wrong choice and misbehave, teachers and students work together to first evaluate the misconducts. They should then devise an applicable plan for students to make amends.

As trust and responsibility are given to students, students should work on their own to correct their misbehaviors. If students fail and break the trust, engaging in misbehaviors, teachers should remove them from the class until the students are committed to trying again to earn back the trust. This approach notes that the different styles of parenting should not be the acceptable reasons for misbehaving. When misbehavior occurs, ask what the students are doing instead of asking the students for reasons, because students should be trusted to analyze their own misbehavior and seek plans to correct their bad behaviors.

In the reality therapy model, holding classroom meetings and discussions are necessities. Students are encouraged to set the class rules and consequences. Once students agree, the rules will be adhered to at a higher level. When you hold these meetings, ensure that students understand that the meetings are held for everyone’s benefit because rules and consequences might require adjustments. As trust and responsibility are the essential components of the self-discipline approach, teachers and students should be able to communicate without barriers.

The reality therapy approach to self-discipline implies that people who can’t adhere to the rules are the cause of receiving the consequences. When students are not prepared as expected, students are the cause for their receiving consequences. Given that this approach respects everyone, and encourages students to be responsible individuals, if unsatisfactory action takes place, anyone and everyone should express their opinions and dissatisfaction accordingly. Possible solutions should be decided by open discussions.

Have you seen the reality therapy approach before? How did it go? What model works in one classroom may not be as effective with a different set of students. Think about the flow of your classroom and the needs of the children in it, and then decide what model would most effectively manage your classroom. If the model here doesn’t sound appealing, check out our two other articles on approaches to classroom management.

Kounin vs. Jones: Dissecting the Battle Between Two Popular Approaches to Classroom Management

When it comes to effectively managing the classroom environment, no one model has pulled ahead as the way to do it. Disciple, desist, reality – and now, Kounin and Jones are all potentially valid approaches. Our past articles have talked about the categorical approaches, but what about the two with names? How do they stack up against each other?

The Kounin Model

Research by Jacob Kounin, who was inspired by William Glasser, found that the difference between teachers is not how they deal with misconduct, but how they prevent it in the first place. His conclusion listed four factors that underlie classroom management success.

First is “with-it-ness,” which refers to the teacher’s alertness and awareness of the classroom at all times. Teachers should let students know that they have the full view of the classroom, and as soon as the teacher spots misbehavior, the teacher indicates visually (with facial expression) to the student that he or she has seen the misbehavior. This is usually enough to stop the behavior without the rest of the class being aware. Although such a look is enough in many cases, some cases will require more action than that, with the teacher addressing the situation with everyone who was involved in the misconduct.

The second factor is “overlapping,” which really is just another word for “multitasking.” When the teacher has divided the class into working groups to look at different topics and activities, this allows teachers to have easy access to every student, provide specific help if needed, and, at the same time, keep an eye on the other students. The “overlapping” of activities in the classroom allows efficiency, and the teacher controls all these activities.

Third is “group focus,” which means getting every student involved and concentrating on the classroom activity. One way of achieving group focus is to attribute a portion of students’ grades to participation. Teachers can ask students questions that are open for anyone to answer. Students will thus all be concentrating and thinking about the question, eager to respond in order to get a good grade. Another method that is often used is randomly selecting students to answer questions. Because they don’t know who will be selected next, and to avoid embarrassment, students’ focus is on their teacher.

The fourth and last factor is “movement management,” which includes momentum and smoothness. Teachers have to ensure that students are continually working and are not sidetracked or distracted. Students can raise their hands if they have questions, and this ensures the smooth flow of the class without interruptions. If the class is held often, another way could be for students to write down questions and/or concerns about the class materials on pieces of paper and turn them in at the end of the session. In the next class, materials can be reviewed, with assistance from the questions previously written down by students. Teachers may also prepare more challenging questions.

The Jones Model

In a 1979 study, Frederick Jones found that nearly 50% of teaching time was wasted due to children’s misbehavior, of which approximately 80% was spent talking in class. Jones suggested that teachers could work on not losing the valuable time by implementing the following techniques: set limits, effective body language, incentive systems, and resourceful help.

Setting limits will help students know what to do in every situation, from small matters like pencil sharpening to big matters like being sick. By setting limits, teachers allow students to find their own ways of dealing with situations without major disruptions to other students. An incentive system concentrates on taking away benefits from students when they misbehave. Efficient help is important because students start to misbehave when they start to fall behind. Jones found that teachers use an average of 4 minutes to discipline students when they misbehave. That, he says, can be reduced significantly (F. Jones, 1979). One of the ways to do this is getting others who are more settled to help the students who are struggling.

None of these methods will work in all cases, so teachers should always have back-up plans such as isolation from class. To learn about other potential approaches you can use, check out our other two articles about models for classroom management.