Uncategorized

Do full-ride scholarships really increase college diversity?

The cost of going to college can be a deal-breaker. Even with Pell grants, scholarships, and some student loans, the overwhelming ticket price of higher education is a major deterrent. This is especially true for minorities, first generation college students, and those coming from low socio-economic backgrounds. There is both a legitimate concern over what that college degree will cost, as well as a cultural barrier that often tells these students a college education is just not for them (both within their circles, and outside them).

But what if colleges were to take away cost as a factor – completely? Throughout the country there are schools that are combatting low diversity numbers with a novel idea: full-ride scholarships for those who qualify.

Now full-ride scholarships are certainly nothing new. They’ve been given out to promising students, and those in financial need, and athletes for decades. What’s so different about this new slew of full-ride initiatives is that they acknowledge a lack of diversity and are targeting minorities, women and underserved students.

The University of Michigan recently rolled out a full-ride scholarship program that targets students as young as 7th grade. The Wolverine Pathways initiative seeks to find students of academic promise from racial and socioeconomic disadvantage and give them a chance to earn a full ride to the university by the time they graduate from high school. Students will be paired with tutors and mentors in three academic sessions per year. If they complete the sessions successfully, and are then accepted to the university, they will be given a scholarship for four years.

It’s certainly needed at Michigan, where only 12.8 percent of the 2015 freshman class are minorities. The school saw a dip from the height of its minority representation (which was only 13.8 in 2015) after affirmative action was struck down for college admissions. Since then, the university claims it has looked for ways to boost its diversity – and the Wolverine Pathways program could finally do just that.

Arizona State University also announced a full-ride program for new MBA students in the fall of 2016 that is designed to improve diversity. Based on the student’s residency, the scholarship could be valued as high as $94,000.

But will these and other full-ride programs actually work?

Finances are certainly an obstacle when it comes to creating diverse college campuses but it is not the only issue. College freshman from homes with no college graduates are at a higher risk of dropping out that first year. Students who have never learned basic life skills, including how to budget and pay bills, often get overwhelmed at college and drop out to start earning immediate money instead.

Then there is the whole idea of young people being handed something they don’t truly understand the value of – and squandering it. It’s usually a decade or more later when college dropouts of all races and backgrounds look back and realize that they probably should’ve stayed in school. That’s around the time their college-educated peers are finally paying off those student loans, advancing in their careers, and finally cashing in on the quality of life that a college education provides. It’s very difficult to explain to an 18 or 19-year-old student the total value of a college education, both in the immediate and over the long term. Not having to pay for that value could translate into students who do not respect that education the way they should. This is not a point specific to minorities, but to young people in general.

So how can colleges and universities bring in diverse students, retain them, and graduate them debt-free?

It starts with the teaching and mentorship structure, like the one Michigan has in place, but needs to continue to college campuses. Students who we know are statistically more likely to drop out need hands-on guidance counselors, and mentors, and professors who work hard to keep them engaged and learning. There needs to be retention programs in place that actively check in on progress and don’t simply offer an open-door policy. All of this is vital if colleges are serious about having a diverse student population that succeeds on its grounds.

For programs like the one at Arizona State, it also means more targeted recruitment. If you say you are lowering financial barriers in order to bring in a more diverse student group, then you must find that student group and offer them spots. That takes a lot of dedication but is well worth it.

The bottom line is this: Simply giving students free access to a college degree is not enough for those students to succeed. Colleges and universities offering these types of programs need to recognize how the financial constraints of college are simply one issue on the road to attaining a degree. Academic support, mentorship, cultural inclusion and so many other factors must also play a role in these incentives for them to truly be successful at boosting campus and workplace diversity.

Matthew

Pull Your Own Weight: Childhood obesity prevention and the light bulb

**The Edvocate is pleased to publish guest posts as way to fuel important conversations surrounding P-20 education in America. The opinions contained within guest posts are those of the authors and do not necessarily reflect the official opinion of The Edvocate or Dr. Matthew Lynch.**

A column by Rick Osbourne

So, how many psychoanalysts does it take to change a light bulb? Just one. But the light bulb must genuinely want to change. In this light (sorry) childhood obesity prevention is equally as simple as changing a light bulb. Calories in calories out, right? And in precisely the same way, the child must genuinely want to make the change in order for anything to work.

Of course that’s the dilemma isn’t it? We’ve spent the past two decades (as in over 20 years) and many billions of dollars trying to figure out how to reduce and eventually defeat childhood obesity. And after all this time, and all those billions spent, the one thing we know for sure is that kids must eat better and exercise more in order to solve the problem. What we’ve failed to figure though out is HOW TO MOTIVATE KIDS ENOUGH FOR THEM TO ACTUALLY EAT BETTER AND EXERCISE MORE! That’s the big challenge.

No Systematic Progress in Over Two Decades

We’ve raised awareness until it’s virtually impossible to be unaware of childhood obesity and all the problems that follow in its wake. We’ve made movies and documentary films on the subject. We’ve partnered with the NFL, the NBA, the PGA, the YMCA, the Boys and Girls Clubs, with Michelle Obama and Bill Clinton. We’ve employed public relations. We’ve created slick, 4 color brochures, TV ads and web sites. We’ve developed catchy slogans complete with Disney cartoon characters. But WE’VE FAILED to move the dial even one tick.

There Is One Simple Solution, If…

But that doesn’t mean there’s no answer to this dilemma. There is an answer that the American Society of Exercise Physiologists has described as “A simple, easily implemented, easily documented, and affordable solution to childhood obesity.” Yet the bureaucratic experts in this field have successfully ignored this solution for years now. It’s as if they want to avoid solving the problem. It’s as if too many corporations are making too much money in the wake of this ongoing obesity epidemic. Why kill the goose that lays the golden egg, right?

Think about this. Statistics show that kids who can perform at least one conventional pull up are ALMOST NEVER OBESE. That’s common knowledge. Everyone knows it. What’s uncommon knowledge however is the fact that most kids (95% of them) can learn to do conventional pull ups in a predictable amount of time, say 6 weeks to 6 months. And if they simply maintain the ability to do at least one pull up (which requires decent eating and exercise habits) odds are they’ll NEVER BE OBESE or have to wrestle with the problems that follow in its wake.

But Most Importantly…

Most importantly however is that most kids genuinely enjoy the process of growing stronger along with their friends. After all, strong is always cool and weak is always uncool. Right? So with this simple, easily implemented, easily documented and affordable solution the motivation dilemma is resolved. No arm twisting. No extrinsic rewards. Just get out of the way, let them do what they naturally love to do – get stronger – and watch them change their own light bulbs.

__________

Rick Osbourne is a former physical educator and a pioneer in the field of functional childhood obesity prevention. He currently serves as President of the Pull Your Own Weight Foundation which is an Illinois based, 501c3, not for profit organization whose focus is functional childhood obesity prevention. He’s written and published three books in this field, the latest of which is entitled Beating Childhood Obesity Now: A Simple Solution for Parents and Educators. He’s the Examiner’s national childhood obesity prevention correspondent. He writes an online column for The Edvocate. And you can connect with Rick via Twitter, Linkedin, or Facebook.

Math scores for 4th and 8th graders on the decline?

According to Edweek.org, math test scores for 4th and 8th grade students taking the NAEP (National Assessment of Educational Progress) exam might be on the decline.

The article notes that scores from the exam, which is taken every two years, are lower than they were in 2013.

“U.S. 4th and 8th grade students are performing worse in math, and somewhat worse in reading, than they were two years ago, according to new data from a national test.”

But Peggy Carr, commissioner of the organization that conducts the tests, said that the scores represented “an unexpected downturn.”

She also notes that the drop in scores isn’t considered to be a trend because the test is given every two years. In addition to the recent drop, EdWeek shows that math test scores are still higher than they were in the 1990s.

While the news isn’t all bad, it’s not necessarily all good. There is still an achievement gap between white and black students, and the majority of states saw a decline of some sort. The children who need the improvement the most are not seeing it, despite newer initiatives like those included in Common Core math.

So what does the drop in scores mean? That depends on how one looks at the scores and what they may represent. Perhaps this is just a temporary dip on the road to a rise overall. The test will be taken again in 2017, and if scores continue to decline, then we have a trend.

If the scores remain the same or increase, 2015 may be seen as an anomaly. Either way, its worth looking at what may have caused the drop this year.

 

Click here to read all our posts concerning the Achievement Gap.

Learning from successful learning: A look at the new NCLB

**The Edvocate is pleased to publish guest posts as way to fuel important conversations surrounding P-20 education in America. The opinions contained within guest posts are those of the authors and do not necessarily reflect the official opinion of The Edvocate or Dr. Matthew Lynch.**

A guest column by Brian Aull

Congress is now ironing out a revision of the No Child Left Behind Act.   This 2001 law mandated yearly testing with the goal of holding federally funded public schools accountable to yearly improvements on the scores.  The current bill gives states more latitude in determining learning goals and deciding what to do about schools that are failing by standard measures.

The renewed debate on the role of government brings to mind Onora O’Neill’s insight:  “Instead of working towards intelligent accountability based on good governance, independent inspection and careful reporting, we are galloping towards central planning by performance indicators, reinforced by obsessions with blame and compensation.”  This is an opportunity to reflect about how we judge success in education.   What does a good teacher or a healthy public school community look like?   Perhaps the answers come not from test score statistics but from the kind of anecdotal evidence that gives insight into what happens on the ground to make a school succeed.

In late June we said farewell to a giant in the field of elementary education. Marva Collins was a teacher in the Chicago public schools in the 1960’s.  Frustrated by bureaucracy and teacher apathy, she left the system and started a one-room schoolhouse in her attic.  She emptied her pension fund to pay for the needed construction work. She recruited a small group of students that the public schools had given up on.   After one year, these pupils’ test scores had improved by at least five grade levels.  60 Minutes aired a story about her remarkable classroom.  When Ronald Reagan became president, he unsuccessfully tried to convince her to be his Secretary of Education.

It’s instructive to look at the secrets of her success.  Rather than teaching students to regurgitate facts for a test, she taught them how to think critically, how to ask meaningful questions.   Her pupils would read Plato’s Republic, for example, and talk about the meaning of justice.  She viewed her work as nourishing the children’s souls as well as their minds.  She said that scholarship divorced from moral concerns is dangerous.   She created a genuine community in the classroom where the pupils learned from mistakes without fear of ridicule and applauded each other’s successes.  At the core of her motivation was love.   “There is no magic here,” she said. “I do not walk on water.  I do not part the sea.  I just love children.”

Marva Collins had the luxury of being both teacher and principal.   One might say that her success is a rare exception and could not be widely replicated in public schools.   But there are many success stories from which we might learn. One 2007 study highlighted Fraser Academy (a pseudonym), a failing elementary school in a high-poverty district of Buffalo, New York.   In 1997 a new principle came on board.   In a few years, Fraser changed from a place parents wanted to avoid enrolling their children to a place with a waiting list.

What did this new principal do?  Her work was about transforming the culture of the school, making it a genuine community that included parents, teachers, and students.   She encouraged strong patterns of parent involvement.  She had an “open door” policy, and listened to the concerns of all members of the school community.  She believed that the children could learn and set a clear expectation that they had a right to a school that served that purpose.  She supported the professional development of the teachers and staff, and encouraged them to experiment and to be active learners themselves.  She never expected the teachers to do things that she was unwilling to do herself.   The culture of the school reflected virtues of service, dedication to learning, and building community.  While her leadership was a big factor in this, there were material resources that also made a big difference; she was hired as part of a partnership with a bank that provided $500,000 a year in supplemental funds to improve the school.  It was an arrangement that gave her substantial autonomy to put her vision into practice.

What are the lessons to be learned from such success stories?  No Child Left Behind focused on standardized testing as the measure of school improvement, and punished schools that did not measure up.  This created powerful incentives to reduce the classroom to a test prep center, manipulate tests, lower standards, and otherwise game the system.

Most importantly, the law’s emphasis on “scientific” and quantifiable performance measures conceals the stories that tell us why schools succeed or fail.   “Teaching to the test” was the last thing on Marva Collins’ mind. Fraser Academy created a culture in which the school community worked collaboratively to evaluate its own success using measures that everyone agreed made sense.   When the school was working well, you could sense it within seconds of walking in the door.

Fresh thinking is needed about the role of both state and federal governments.  How can government be a resource rather than a regulator, facilitating the spread of best practices and providing funding to enable struggling school communities to adopt them?

_____________

Brian Aull is research scientist at MIT and the author of The Triad: Three Civic Virtues That Could Save American Democracy. His blog on civic renewal can be found at
http://www.AwakenDemocracy.com

Leaders in Louisiana want more money for higher education

Louisiana education leaders are asking for “twice as much money next year” after the state’s budget crisis this past year.

Currently state schools receive nearly $770 million in funding, but due to the shortfall and other needs, leaders are requesting $1.4 billion in funding for 2016-2017.

But the request is steeped in good news. While Louisiana may have budget issues, the additional money is needed to keep up with a growing workforce in the state.

“Higher education needs to add slots and expand programs at both two-year and four-year colleges to meet these needs, but doesn’t have resources to do so currently,” officials said.

According to NOLA.com, the state’s job market demands cannot be met if new money isn’t approved.

It will be tough sledding as education leaders had to fight just to get the current level of funding. In order to meet budget needs, many states–including Louisiana–will cut higher education funding to stay afloat.

NOLA.com reports that “[s]ince 2008, more than $700 million has been removed from Louisiana’s colleges and universities’ budgets — a larger cut than any other state higher education system in the country has had to endure.”

It’s why leaders are concerned that filling critical positions in the state’s workforce will be compromised if the new money isn’t approved.

A decision on when, or if, the request will be approved will not come until the state legislature meets for its next session in 2016. I don’t see how the state can deny hiring the right amount of educators for the students who need those instructors — but I guess we will wait and see what happens.

3 Important Themes of American Culture that Influence Our Schools

School culture can be defined as the shared beliefs, traditions, and behaviors within the school community. Considering the diverse nature of today’s society, it is sometimes difficult for students, parents, and/or teachers within a school community to understand their culture relative to that of the school, particularly when the two cultures do not easily mesh.

Although the United States consists of a population with a vast range of diverse cultural and ethnic backgrounds, a number of themes in American culture influence all Americans, regardless of background differences. Here are just three of them.

  1. Protestant Ideology and American Culture. Core values of American society are historically and fundamentally based on concepts of Protestantism, capitalism, and republicanism.

The influence of Protestant ideology dates all the way back to the first half of the 19th century. It was evident in school activities. For example, Bible reading and prayer were a normal part of schooling.

Back then, schools were the vehicle for Americanization. This was how immigrants were assimilated into the dominant culture. Schools were widely used to guide the morals, attitudes, and knowledge of American culture to all children attending American schools. They operated as a mechanism through which immigrant children were assimilated by learning American language, traditions, and beliefs that primarily reflected those of white Anglo-Saxon Protestants (WASPs).

Diversity has long been a central element of the American way of life. Diversity refers to differences in racial or ethnic background, age, gender, sexual orientation, and religion. The Constitution was designed to protect the rights of all American citizens. These rights provide members of society maximum freedom within the confines of established laws.

But throughout the history of the nation, certain groups of citizens have needed to wage campaigns to secure these rights. And today, there are still some groups whose rights aren’t protected by the Constitution. Individuals and groups who don’t reflect the WASP status quo have historically had more difficulty accessing rights in the United States.

  1. Personal Freedom and Individuality. Personal freedom originates from the idea of being free of government constraints, and it is an essential component of constitutional democracy. Personal freedom includes the right to live in dignity and security and to seek fulfillment. Members of society are given the opportunity to think for themselves and make their own decisions—values that emphasize individualism, creativity, and autonomy. Individuals are also entitled to a set of public freedoms including the right to vote.

The notion of personal choice is deeply embedded in American culture. An average American is forced to make hundreds of calculated decisions in a single day. As you know, each one is influenced by the external and social environment. Some choices are highly valued by society, while others are limited by inequities in social class, unequal access to education and wealth, and biases that include racism and sexism.

In addition, the quest for self-reliance and autonomy is an important part of culture in the United States. But some Americans experience conflict between autonomy and assimilation. In many ways, schools reflect this contradiction and the challenges it may present. Students are encouraged to conform to dominant cultural norms at school, which may not coincide with minority cultural norms students experience away from school.

  1. Political and Social Equality. Political and social equality, although ideal in theory, have been difficult to achieve. Inequities among groups persist even to this day.

Legislative actions at the national level have been necessary to ensure the realization of these American values. For example, the Nineteenth Amendment, ratified in 1920, gave women the right to vote and run for public office, and the National Voting Rights Act of 1965 prohibited discriminatory voting practices that had interfered with the right of African Americans to vote.

Social equality—with all groups or members of a community having the same status—has been one of the most elusive goals in American culture. To maintain social equality, every person is entitled to equality under the law. The law must be applied impartially regardless of the individual’s identity or status. Social equality includes equal access to a number of resources such as education, health care, equal opportunities to work as a means for avoiding the creation of a privileged class.

Despite our laws promoting social equality, socioeconomic stratification in the United States has resulted in differentiated access to resources. But the notion of social mobility, or the ability of individuals to move up the social socioeconomic ladder, is a tenacious ideal: the “American dream.” It is so embedded in American culture that blame for the inability to improve one’s station in life is often attributed to the individual.

What do you think? What other strongly held American ideals might affect the education given in our schools?

 

Educators: What You Should Know About Ethnic Minorities in the United States, Part I

The United States is truly a country of immigrants. People from countless ethnic groups have settled in since the nation’s early days.

Because of this, it is not unusual to discuss ethnicity in the US. These discussions often center on race—or characterizations based on physical characteristics. However, although racial classifications may be historically important, it is important to be aware that they can be based on prejudices. They should instead be avoided in favor of ethnic classification. Ethnicity can refer to the common bond within a group of people, based on their race, religion, customs, and cultures, but commonly refers to a mixture of all of these factors.

Ethnic and Cultural Diversity in the United States

Teachers need to be familiar with the various ethnic and cultural minority groups living in the United States today, including:

African Americans. Americans of African descent might be the first racial minority you think of when considering minority groups. African Americans were historically either forcibly brought from Africa between 1500 and 1800 to work as slaves for European American people in the New World or came as free immigrants, seeking a different life. Many African American families have been in the United States longer than many European American families.

African Americans have had a difficult history in the United States. As slaves, they were considered to be property, not people, and were largely kept illiterate. Their owners were afraid that if slaves could read they would begin to demand rights and freedom from slavery. Although some White people in the mid-1700s fought to educate Black Americans in the name of religion, laws were passed making it illegal to teach slaves to read or write in many Southern states. Eventually, support for the education of African Americans grew, and the first school for African Americans, the African Free School, opened in New York City in 1794.

Slavery was finally abolished in 1865. From that date until 1890, African Americans enjoyed equal education in their own schools and received funding to run the schools. Unfortunately, as the European Americans saw African Americans becoming educated and taking jobs they felt were rightfully theirs, this equality took a backward step, and in the early 1900s Black people were once again given fewer educational opportunities than their White counterparts.

Hispanics. Many Hispanic (or Latino) people in the United States, particularly in the Southwest, come from families that have been in California, Texas, Arizona, and New Mexico since the time these states were still a part of the Republic of Mexico. Many Latino families have been in the United States much longer than many families of European descent. Other Hispanics immigrated more recently from countries such as Cuba as well as countries in Central and South America. Historically, there are parallels in the educational experiences of Hispanic children and African American children, as both attended segregated schools.

Hispanic children were able to attend desegregated schools in 1973.

Despite that ruling, today, two of every five Hispanic students still attend intensely racially segregated schools. Almost 90% of Hispanic students attend public schools in urban centers, with almost absolute racial isolation.

The Hispanic population continues to grow in the United States, and their academic achievement will have a huge impact on society for years to come. American schools as a whole are not succeeding in educating Hispanic students. Recent statistics on the educational attainment of Hispanic students paint a bleak future, unless proper measures are taken. In terms of academic attainment, Hispanic students are not achieving a level of success comparable with that of their peers. More than 50% of fourth-grade Hispanic students are not skilled in math and reading, and by the time they are 17 years old, many exhibit math and reading abilities equivalent to those of 13-year-old White students. Only around half of Latino students finish high school, and the graduation outlook is even worse for Latino males. One predictor of academic success is school attendance. For whatever reason, Hispanic students are absent from school at higher rates than their peers.

Several issues contribute to these statistics. According to Fergus, these include the following: school structure, district/school resources, immigrant status/nativity, language barriers, home–school culture compatibility, teacher expectations, location, academic and racial/ethnic identity compatibility, and racial/ethnic identification. To boost the academic achievement of Hispanic students, American schools need to create interventions that can counteract the effects of these issues.

Native Americans. The original inhabitants of the land, Native Americans have been in the United States longer than any other ethnic group, yet their children comprise only about 1% of the student population in American schools. There are a number of reasons for this. One of the most profound reasons is that the Native American people lost a large percentage of their population to European diseases and wars with European settlers. While Native Americans were made slaves during colonial times, they were given the opportunity to become educated in the late 1800s.

Unfortunately, their education was a form of deculturalization, as they were sent to boarding schools with the goal of assimilating them into American culture. They were frequently physically abused when they spoke their traditional language and/or engaged in Native American cultural behaviors. Since the 1960s, Native Americans have been given an increasing amount of control over the education of their children on Native American reservations. They can hire their own teachers and create their own curriculum, and they still receive government funding. This has allowed them to create schools that keep their culture and traditions alive.

Today, Native Americans are often grouped with other indigenous groups to include Alaska Natives and Native Hawaiians. Each group is distinct, however, with its own histories, cultures, and languages. Their schooling experiences have differed as well.

As you can see, each of the major ethnic minority groups discussed has had a rough road to educational attainment. In Part II, we’ll look at other ethnic minority groups and their particular struggles.

 

7 Little-Known, Yet Important Facts You Should Know About Ethnic Minorities and the U.S Education System

It’s pretty much common knowledge to most Americans that this country is composed of immigrants who have settled in since this country was still just an idea. It is also fairly well-known that most immigrant groups have struggled in some way when it comes to things such as discrimination, equal access to opportunities, and assimilation. Let’s take a look today at major ethnic minorities in America and the specific struggles that they have had. And since this is an education blog, let’s specifically look at the challenges these groups have faced in pursuing a quality education in America. Without further ado, here are some very important facts you should know:

  1. African Americans enjoyed equal educational opportunities right after slavery ended. Before slavery was abolished in 1865, African Americans were prohibited from literacy by law in many states. However, from 1865 until 1890, African Americans enjoyed equal education in their own schools and received funding to run the schools. Unfortunately, as the European Americans saw African Americans becoming educated and taking jobs they felt were rightfully theirs, this equality took a backward step, and in the early 1900s Black people were once again given fewer educational opportunities than their White counterparts.
  2. Historically, there are parallels in the educational experiences of Hispanic children and African American children, as both attended segregated schools.

Just as many African American families have been in the United States for longer than many European American families, many Hispanic (or Latino) people in the United States have been in the United States much longer than many families of European descent.   Many Hispanic families in the Southwest come from families that have been in California, Texas, Arizona, and New Mexico since the time these states were still a part of the Republic of Mexico.

  1. Hispanic children were finally able to attend desegregated schools in 1973. Despite that ruling, today, two of every five Hispanic students still attend intensely racially segregated schools. And almost 90% of Hispanic students attend public schools in urban centers, with almost absolute racial isolation.
  2. American schools as a whole face a challenge in educating Hispanic students. Recent statistics on the educational attainment of Hispanic students paint a bleak future, unless proper measures are taken.

More than 50% of fourth-grade Hispanic students are not skilled in math and reading, and by the time they are 17 years old, many exhibit math and reading abilities equivalent to those of 13-year-old White students. Only around half of Latino students finish high school, and the graduation outlook is even worse for Latino males. One predictor of academic success is school attendance. For whatever reason, Hispanic students are absent from school at higher rates than their peers.

  1. Native Americans were made slaves during colonial times, but they were given the opportunity to become educated in the late 1800s.

Unfortunately, their education was a form of deculturalization, as they were sent to boarding schools with the goal of assimilating them into American culture. They were frequently physically abused when they spoke their traditional language and/or engaged in Native American cultural behaviors.

Since the 1960s, Native Americans have been given an increasing amount of control over the education of their children on Native American reservations. They can hire their own teachers and create their own curriculum, and they still receive government funding. This has allowed them to create schools that keep their culture and traditions alive.

  1. Like other minority groups, early Asian immigrants to America were made to attend segregated schools. This practice that declined after World War II as Asian Americans began to move into more integrated settings.
  2. Children who identify (orare identified by their parents) as multiethnic increased by 50% since 2000, making it the fastest-growing group among young people. This is especially interesting, considering that interracial marriage was still illegal in several states until 1967.

I hope you have enjoyed reading about these seven interesting facts. If you have any more valuable, less-known information about ethnic minorities and their access to education in the United States, feel free to leave a comment below.

 

 

 

 

 

 

At a Glance: Why We Still Have Educational Inequities

The Fourteenth Amendment to the U.S. Constitution has a clause which emphasizes the principle of equality under the law, and states that “No State shall . . . deny to any person within its jurisdiction the equal protection of the laws.” Under the equal protection clause, all persons, regardless of race, religion, gender, ethnicity, or socioeconomic status, are to be treated equally under the law. In the eyes of the law, equality means that every person has the right to access the education system provided by the government. So why do we still have educational inequities in the US?

But remember that any law can be interpreted to suit the needs of a community and the historical period in which they live. For instance, people have been excluded from U.S. schools based on their ethnicity.

The Plessy v. Ferguson case of 1896 illustrates this quite well. Plessy was one-eighth African American and seven-eighths European American. Because he had African American blood, he was required by law to ride in a railroad car separated from European American patrons, as all African Americans were required to do at the time. Plessy lost his challenge to racial segregation, and racial segregation continued to be legal until Brown v. Board of Education of Topeka in 1954.

Given the Supreme Court’s decision in Plessy v. Ferguson, it was legal for states to provide equal but separate education. In other words, as long as European Americans and African Americans were both receiving an education, they were being treated equally in the eyes of the law. In too many instances, however, the curriculum, materials, and facilities to which African American children were exposed were not equal to that of European American students. The decision in the Brown v. Board of Education of Topeka (1954) case determined that separate was not equal, and schools were ordered to desegregate.

The Civil Rights Act of 1964 was instrumental in speeding up school desegregation. Schools could lose federal funding if they ignored the civil rights act and continued to promote segregation. The act was highly effective in reducing the number of segregated schools in the nation. To support compliance with federal desegregation goals, criteria were developed to determine if schools still practiced segregation. Schools found to be in noncompliance had to develop desegregation plans.

Even though students were allowed to attend the same school regardless of ethnicity, religion, gender, or socioeconomic status, the mindsets of the children who attended these schools, their parents, and teachers and school staff did not change quickly. Today, more than half a century later, students in some learning environments continue to face ridicule because of their cultural, socioeconomic, and/or language background. They often face difficulty in school because their needs, if different from the average White American child, are not being adequately met.

 

Expert Advice: How to Teach about Racism

Despite legislative changes that have made schools accessible to everyone, the mindsets of individuals who attend or work in schools have been slower to adapt and change. Racism has been prevalent for so many decades that once students are put together, racist attitudes will be present in the classroom and must be dealt with. One effective way this is currently being done is through the Anti-Bias Curriculum: Tools for Empowering Young Children, which was developed by the National Association for the Education of Young Children. The key here is to begin educating young children so the level of prejudice is significantly diminished as they move through grades beyond preschool or kindergarten.

Did you know that children as young as 2 years old are keenly aware of racial intolerance?

Research has found the following progression:

  • Age 2: Children are aware of gender differences and the various names for different skin colors around them.
  • Ages 3 to 5: Children begin to define themselves and who they are by comparing themselves to those of different gender and skin color.
  • Ages 4 or 5: Children begin to select friends on the basis of race and begin to recognize and take on the gender roles that society has promoted (Derman-Sparks, Tanaka Higa, & Sparks, 1980).

With conscious effort, racism can be curbed by slowing down or halting the development of biased attitudes and behaviors.

Teaching Tolerance is an example of a program used to address prejudice and intolerance among older children and teens. This program was created after a 1988 attack on an Ethiopian man by a group of teens in Portland, Oregon. It focuses on racism as a psychological attitude and aims to promote tolerance, which is the capacity to recognize and respect the beliefs and practices of other groups. The main goal of the program is to ensure the availability of resources and materials that promote and teach an understanding of race and culture between White and minority groups in all schools.

One of the primary problems facing teachers and educators today when teaching about racism and tolerance is the psychological impact of such teaching on White students. With the knowledge of racism and the role played in perpetuating it, students often experience feelings of guilt and shame. Because these are strong and undesirable emotions, it is far easier for teachers to avoid teaching about racism than deal with the feelings that accompany a topic that continues to be difficult to discuss. The key is to help the students produce a positive self-image in dealing with racism, and to promote feelings of allied relations as various minorities fight racism together. This will counter the feelings of guilt that come with the realization that racism continues to exist.