The U.S. Court of Appeals for the Fifth Circuit has made a significant ruling that affects the merger and acquisition landscape in the United States. On March 15, 2026, the court denied a motion by the Federal Trade Commission (FTC) to stay a federal district court’s decision from February 2026, which vacated the revised Hart-Scott-Rodino (HSR) rules that had been implemented just a year prior, on February 10, 2025. This ruling has implications for companies navigating antitrust compliance and the merger filing process.
Background on the HSR Act
The Hart-Scott-Rodino Antitrust Improvements Act of 1976, commonly referred to as the HSR Act, is a crucial piece of legislation that requires parties involved in certain mergers and acquisitions to file notification with the FTC and the Department of Justice (DOJ) before completing a transaction. The goal of this law is to allow regulatory bodies to assess the potential competitive effects of proposed mergers and acquisitions prior to their finalization.
Changes to the HSR Rules
In February 2025, the FTC revised the HSR rules to update the filing requirements and procedures. These changes were intended to enhance the efficiency of the merger review process and align it with current market practices and conditions. However, the revised rules faced immediate legal challenges, culminating in the February 2026 federal district court decision, which vacated these changes on the grounds that they exceeded the FTC’s authority and did not adhere to the necessary regulatory procedures.
The Fifth Circuit’s Ruling
The Fifth Circuit’s recent ruling to deny the FTC’s motion to stay the lower court’s decision effectively reinstates the pre-2025 HSR rules for the time being. The court’s decision emphasizes the importance of adhering to proper legal and procedural standards when implementing significant regulatory changes. As a result of this ruling, the FTC has announced that it will accept filings using the HSR Form and Instructions that were in place before February 10, 2025.
Voluntary Use of New Form
Interestingly, the FTC has also indicated that filers may voluntarily use the new HSR form if they choose, even though it is not mandated under the current legal framework. This dual approach allows companies to maintain some flexibility in their filing strategies while the legal landscape remains uncertain.
Implications for Companies
The Fifth Circuit’s denial of the FTC’s motion to stay the vacatur of the revised HSR rules has immediate and long-term implications for companies engaged in mergers and acquisitions. Here are some key points to consider:
- Increased Compliance Complexity: Companies must now navigate the return to the pre-2025 HSR rules, which may differ significantly from the revised rules they had begun to adapt to. This may lead to confusion and increased compliance burdens.
- Strategic Considerations: Companies that are in the process of negotiating mergers or acquisitions will need to reassess their strategies to align with the reinstated rules. This includes understanding the thresholds for filing and the timing of submissions.
- Ongoing Litigation: The FTC’s appeal of the district court’s decision remains pending, with the agency’s brief due on April 20, 2026. The outcome of this appeal could further reshape the regulatory environment for mergers and acquisitions.
- Potential for Future Rule Changes: Depending on the outcome of the ongoing litigation and any subsequent regulatory efforts by the FTC, companies may need to remain vigilant about potential future changes to the HSR rules.
Next Steps for the FTC
The FTC’s decision to appeal the district court’s ruling indicates its commitment to pursuing regulatory changes that it believes are necessary for effective antitrust enforcement. The agency has historically been active in updating its rules to reflect evolving market dynamics, and the pending appeal may provide an opportunity for the FTC to clarify its authority and the rationale behind its regulatory decisions.
Conclusion
The Fifth Circuit’s ruling marks a pivotal moment in the ongoing evolution of antitrust regulation in the United States. As companies navigate the complexities of merger filings under the reinstated HSR rules, they must also keep an eye on the developments in the FTC’s appeal and the potential for future regulatory changes. In this fluid legal environment, the importance of compliance and strategic foresight cannot be overstated for businesses looking to engage in mergers and acquisitions.

