Uncategorized

Teachers are Nation-Builders: Developing Countries Must Invest in Them Properly

Malala Yousafzai in her book I Am Malala: The Story of the Girl Who Stood Up for Education and Was Shot by the Taliban powerfully writes:

“His sisters — my aunts — did not go to school at all, just like millions of girls in my country. Education had been a great gift for him. He believed that lack of education was the root of all of Pakistan’s problems. Ignorance allowed politicians to fool people and bad administrators to be re-elected. He believed schooling should be available for all, rich and poor, boys and girls.”

Malala’s story is as heartbreaking as it is empowering. The overarching message that education should be a basic human right to everyone, regardless of gender, speaks loudly. Her quote above about her father sheds light on an important fact; poor education systems hurt a country on nearly every scale. An uneducated populace stagnates growth and innovation and affects a country from its economics to its human rights. 

Setting the Stage

The Global Partnership for Education compiled a tremendous amount of data from across the world utilizing UNICEF, the World Bank, and numerous other organizations to take a look at the impact education has on countries. All of this helps builds the case that Malala’s story is a part of that teachers are an invaluable resource to developing countries but are woefully swept the side. Consider some of the following facts:

  • According to UNESCO Institute for Statistics in their 2017 study on out-of-school children, there are 262 million (1 out of every 5) children between the ages of 6 and 17 out of school
  • 420 million people would be lifted out of poverty with a secondary education which will reduce the number of poor worldwide by more than half.
  • TheEducation Commission’s report The Learning Generation found that for every $1 invested in education creates an increase of $10 in low-income countries
  • UNESCO’s International Literacy Day paper found “a person without basic literacy lacks real opportunities to effectively engage with democratic institutions, to make choices, exercise his/her citizenship rights and act for a perceived common good. […] only then can a nation be brought closer to peace. However if literacy is to become an enabler of democracy it cannot be confined to basic skills, and thus to functional literacy.”

The Role of Teachers

While it is obvious how vital education is to radically change a country not only as a whole but on the individual level, it cannot be forgotten that to educate the students you need qualified and supported teachers. Sadly the reality of teachers, and teacher training, in developing countries leaves much to be desired. 

The EFA Global Monitoring Report found that in one-third less than 75% of teachers were professionally trained. The countries referred to are the undeveloped/developing countries that lack not only the resources to adequately train their teachers but also the infrastructure and even sometimes general desire to do so. 

In these types of countries, the teaching profession is not always viewed positively in addition to suffering from extremely low salaries (which in turn means that teachers need to attain a second job) among numerous other issues. For example, The World Development Report 2018 found astonishing levels of teacher absenteeism in sub-Saharan Africa not only within their classroom but the school itself which gives a closeup view on some of the issues going on in these types of countries and why quality education continues to be a large hurdle to overcome. 

Teachers are the nation-builders but for a country to grow and thrive from an educated and literate population, they need to be invested in, supported, and celebrated. There is no silver bullet solution for such a change to happen. It will take many years of concerted efforts on a social, political, and legislative front to make such a shift but the benefits are indescribable. 

The Benefits of Learning Science in Early Childhood

For many when the subject of science is brought up images of the cell, frog dissections, and planets come to mind. While these are important topics for students to learn and become familiar with there is underlying importance to the subject in terms of critical thinking, [scientific] inquiry, raising questions, making observations, and coming to conclusions. The Center for Childhood Creativity compiled research in their report The Roots of STEM Success: Changing Early Learning Experiences to Build Lifelong Thinking Skills and found 6 key facts about early STEM (science, technology, engineering, and mathematics) education and its importance:

  1. STEM thinking naturally begins in infancy
  2. To become strong STEM thinkers, children need more play
  3. STEM amplifies language development; language enables STEM thinking
  4. Active, self-directed learning builds STEM skills and interest 
  5. Mindset matters to STEM success
  6. Children’s abstract thinking potential can be unlocked through both adult support and executive function skill development

Building the Case for Academic Success

These types of findings help bolster the building research in terms of academic success exposure to learning science has on young students. The most basic foundations of science and the scientific method (ask a question, observation, hypothesis, experiment, test results, come to a conclusion) are not only accessible to young kids but something that they naturally already do. 

Deann Kuhn and Susan Pearsall of Columbia University focused on tracking the developmental origins of scientific thinking and found that children as young as 2 or 3 are strongly showing these behaviors. Harnessing that natural curiosity into an educational foundation that leads to future success is a pivotal period of time that should be taken advantage of. 

Integration in the Classroom

This has led to the push for standards, such as Next Generation Science Standards(NGSS), to be developed and used as a basis for early childhood science education due to the severe lack of specialized focus on the subject itself. This gives science-based standards to teachers and helps them build this important foundational knowledge for their students. 

Challenging students to interact with the world around them in a tangible way, ask inquisitive questions, and encourage independent thought and experimentation can be integrated with cross-curricular content and benefits the students unilaterally. National Geographic Learning’s Best Practices in Science Education research led by Dr. Kathy Cabe Trundle found that students are able to transfer these skills to other academic domains easily.

In a world with STEM becoming more important for future job prospects the more vital to raise our students to be scientifically inclined. According to the National Assessment of Educational Progress (NAEP) student achievement in science has been at a near standstill for the last 15 years. During this time, more countries eclipse the United States in scientific achievement. This is a huge issue as between 2017 and 2027 STEM-related jobs will grow faster than non-STEM jobs which is a pattern that has been consistent since around the early 2000s. 

Unless we place a larger focus on scientific-based thinking the United States will continue to be outpaced by other countries but more importantly, we place our students in a disadvantageous position that can affect the course of their entire lives.

Stop Letting Disruptive Students Steal Everyone Else’s Education

If you’ve ever been in a classroom setting, whether as a student, teacher, parent, or administrator, you have probably witnessed an all too common phenomena: one or two students who have no desire to learn behave disruptively, ignore and disobey the rules and the instructor, and ultimately negatively impact the learning and even the safety of the environment for everyone else in the room. 

Teachers already wear so many hats – they create lesson plans, enforce discipline, tutor, come up with new ways to share information when lessons aren’t working, interact with parents, and much, much more. On top of all this, now teachers in many schools face violence, threats, shouting, and other forms of abuse from their students – and there is nothing they can do about it. This article will discuss what constitutes a disruptive student, why it is so detrimental to everyone in the classroom, and what has to change. 

What is a disruptive student?

Unless you have been an educator or student in a classroom with truly disruptive students, it can be difficult to understand the deep effect they have on learning for the entire class. A disruptive student is not just one who chats or passes notes during class, although this does constitute rule-breaking and misbehavior. The disruptive students this article refers to are the ones who threaten teachers or other students, shout and scream at the teacher or other students in the class, or are so loud and aggressive that it makes classroom learning impossible and even unsafe. Stories from educators like this one are all too common. Yes, this is really what many teachers deal with on a daily basis, at all grade levels. 

What makes disruptive students so harmful to learning?

When one student requires the full and immediate attention of the teacher, it becomes impossible to continue the lesson. This becomes a greater drain on classroom time when there or more disruptive students or more frequent interruptions. It is simply impossible to continue teaching over a screaming or violent student and stopping the lesson to implement disciplinary actions (such as instructing the student to switch seats, taking them into the hallway for a one-on-one discussion, or calling for an administrator). 

Not only does it make it impossible for other students to learn, but it can also make them feel unsafe coming to class or school. School is supposed to be a safe environment for children, but teachers simply are not given the support they need to ensure this safety, nor should they have to be the only ones responsible for correcting this behavior. According to this article, many qualified teachers transfer schools or leave their jobs due to unacceptable, outrageous behavior from students. 

What has to change?

Teachers cannot be the only ones responsible for defending not only the education but also the safety of themselves and other students from overly disruptive students. Parents, administrators, social workers, and others need to support teachers so they are able to do their jobs. According to this article, the lack of support is the main reasons teachers quit or change schools. Students have all the rights in the classroom, not the teachers, and disruptive students know this and take advantage of it. The education system is failing teachers and students by keeping these students in a typical classroom setting. 

Inclusive Education: Definition, Examples, and Classroom Strategies

In 1990, the United States Congress revamped the All Handicapped Children Act (EHA) into what is now known as the Individuals with Disabilities Education Act (IDEA). This has helped guarantee the rights that individuals with disabilities have to the education that they deserve. 

This legislation has been bolstered in 1997 and more importantly in 2004 with the No Child Left Behind Act of 2001 to give greater access to general education classrooms to those with disabilities. The goal is to include these individuals as much as possible into the general education environment to help give opportunities to them. This is regarded as Inclusive Education. 

Implementation

How this typically works in schools is that individuals with disabilities will be in general education classrooms periodically throughout the day with usually one to two support classes to ensure their success. According to the National Center for Education Statistics in their 2015 study on individuals ages 6-12 under IDEA 95% were placed in regular schools and of that 95 %, 62.% spent at least 80% of the time inside general classes.  

It is vital for teachers to take a closer look at their instructional methods and ensure that they’re not only meeting the Individualized Education Plan (IEP) of these students but making sure a creative and inclusive environment is made. One of the biggest fears with creating an inclusive classroom with individuals who have disabilities is that it will negatively affect the general education students is one that, on the surface, might seem realistic at first glance but the research shows the exact opposite. 

Results

Gail McGregor of the Allegheny University of the Health Sciences in her study Inclusive Schooling Practices: Pedagogical and Research Foundations. A Synthesis of the Literature that Informs Best Practices about Inclusive Schooling. She summarizes some of the additional research done in this area with the following:

“Results indicated no difference in engagement rates between classrooms, suggesting no negative impact on instructional opportunities. Similar findings are reported by McDonnell et al. (1997) in another direct comparison of classrooms with and without students with severe disabilities. […]. In each case, the general education students and students with disabilities that were part of small cooperative groups demonstrated academic gains.”

In McGregor’s abstract she states “although many teachers are initially reluctant about inclusion, they become confident in their abilities with support and experience” which shows the other major fear, this time on the side of the teachers, is also alleviated. Once teachers realize that many of the best classroom strategies and practices to create an inclusive learning environment are nearly identical to regular best classroom strategies then this daunting idea becomes less so. Some of these practices are:

  • Peer Tutoring and Cooperative Learning
  • Focus on Small Group Activities
  • Independent Practice (allows for individualized attention)
  • Tiered Lessons
  •  Universal Design for Learning (UDL) 
  • Differentiated Instruction

Inclusive classrooms are becoming more common as schools try to integrate special education into regular classes. Thankfully due to the mounting research showcasing the benefits of doing so not only for individuals with disabilities but for regular students as well, there is less resistance to such integration. Teachers just have to continue utilizing their educational best practices and they’ll continue to be just as successful when their classes weren’t as integrated.

Improving Teaching and Learning Through Student Feedback

One of the hallmarks of a great educator is one who utilizes feedback to the betterment of their teaching. The difficult part is getting the correct type of feedback that allows the teacher to grow. The Federation University of Australia provides a breakdown of the four primary constructive feedback types:

  • Negative feedback – corrective comments about past behavior. Focuses on behavior that wasn’t successful and shouldn’t be repeated.
  • Positive feedback – affirming comments about past behavior. It focuses on behavior that was successful and should be continued.
  • Negative feed-forward – corrective comments about future performance. It focuses on behavior that should be avoided in the future.
  • Positive feed-forward – affirming comments about future behavior. Focused on behavior that will improve performance in the future.

Ryan Balch of Vanderbilt University in his paper The Validation of a Student Survey on Teacher Practice outlined the significance of student surveys in the K-12 environment and their increasing commonality as part of teacher evaluations. Many parts of teacher evaluations rely on research-based teaching practices but as student feedback, and success becomes more vital to a teacher’s evaluation it is important to be able to see how the focal points of these types of evaluations are mirrored in student survey questions as seen on page 25 of the above-mentioned paper.

Using the Feedback Types

Tailoring the four types of feedback into corresponding student surveys is a vital strategy for teachers to utilize and allows them to gauge the effectiveness of their teaching directly by those who it is directed towards. The ASCD (Association for Supervision and Curriculum Development) defines feedback as “all the kinds of comments made after the fact, including advice, praise, and evaluation. Feedback is information about how we are doing in our efforts to reach a goal.” They go on to outline the seven key features of effective feedback:

  • Goal-Referenced
  • Tangible and Transparent
  • Actionable
  • User-Friendly
  • Timely
  • Ongoing
  • Consistent

Benefits of Student Feedback

Keeping these features in mind when creating student surveys will create a two-fold benefit to educators; keep ahead of the increasing relevance of student feedback in terms of official evaluations and get insight on how those you are teaching are receiving your instruction. Blach further shows this connection with a sample that shows the correlations between [student] survey total and academic engagement and self‐efficacy (Table 19) and explains his results.

“…we see very high correlations between a student’s total score for a teacher and their level of reported academic engagement and self-efficacy. The correlations are slightly 46 higher for engagement than academic self-efficacy […] students with teachers who adopt the practices asked about by the survey have students that are more engaged in the class and report a greater level of confidence in the subject.”

Increased academic engagement and self-efficacy directly lead to increased learning and academic success. As students become more a part of the learning process and see that their feedback is valued, respected, and useful it is no surprise that this type of growth is seen and is important to improving teaching and learning.

Teacher Burnout or Demoralization? What’s the Difference and Why it Matters

A study led by Dr. Ingersoll of the University of Pennsylvania showed the staggering reality of the American education system; 15% of teachers leave the profession every year and 45% of new teachers leave within the first five years. The burning question behind these results is why?

When talking with educators, a common discussion topic is the soul-crushing, depressive, and futile nature of the profession. Now, many teachers are lucky enough to be in school districts where they are supported, listened to, valued, and not scapegoated by the administration, parents, and students for items that are not under their control but it seems this is becoming few and far between. In Ingersoll’s study, he focused one portion on first-year teachers who left their current school and polled them on the reasons why. The results, as seen in Figure 15 of the study linked above, are as follows:

  • 32% → School Staffing Action
  • 39.7% → Family or Personal
  • 31.7% → To Pursue Other Jobs
  • 44.4% → Dissatisfaction

Ingersoll and Perda state “On the other hand, high levels of employee departures are worrisome not only because they can be a symptom of underlying problems in how well organizations function, but also because departures can entail costs and other negative consequences for organizations and for the larger system (Ingersoll & Perda, forthcoming).”

Understanding the Difference

The important distinction to make is that these statistics are focusing more on teacher burnout than teacher demoralization. At first glance, these words may seem to be two ways to say the same thing but there is an important distinction to be made. When a teacher is burnt out it more than likely means that they are done. Gassed. Finished. Nothing left. Whether this burnout happened within those first five years of entering the profession or is the culmination of decades of their willpower, desire, and love of teaching being ground down the result is the same; leaving the profession. Ingersoll’s study focuses primarily on this issue.

What is not often discussed, is teacher demoralization which is really what goes on before teacher burn out happened. Teacher demoralization results in teacher burnout. This distinction is vital in addressing the problem within the profession because it allows intervention to be focused on the problem, teacher demoralization, instead of the symptom of the problem which is teacher burnout. 

Doris A. Santoro, an associate professor of education and chair of the education department at Bowdoin College, in her publication Is It Burnout? Or Demoralization? addresses this sentiment by saying “we know that teachers are experiencing dissatisfaction (Keigher, 2010), but, like doctors, we must be careful to look for the true source of the problem in order to properly treat it. […] similarly, school leaders need to get to the root of teacher dissatisfaction so it can be diagnosed and treated properly.”

Finding the Cause

The underlying problems that Ingersoll and Perda refer to are precisely the issues that result in teacher demoralization whether it is unruly parents with no administrative support, absurd class sizes with no mandated support, low pay, general lack of administrative support, forced to follow a rigid curriculum, overarching desire for better test scores at all costs, lack of autonomy, etc. The list is nearly endless and is what results in teachers having self-reported stress amounts equal to nurses and physicians according to Gallup’s 2013 State of America’s Schools Report. 

Once the difference between teacher burnout and teacher demoralization is made more clear, it can be more easily addressed. It will not be a quick change nor one without growing pains as the profession continues to suffer from these systemic problems but as the reality of these problems become more apparent and felt more by those outside of education, the policies and legislation hamstringing many of these ailments felt by teachers can be changed. 

Kids are Born Creative Geniuses But the Education System Destroys Imagination

One of the growing concerns of the education system, from parents, teachers, and students alike, is the increasing amount of mandated testing. While standardized tests have been used for decades, the passage of 2002 NCLB (No Child Left Behind) and 2009’s RTTT (Race to the Top) legislation connected to the Common Core Curriculum, has led to a skyrocketed usage of them as it became mandated that all 50 states need to use them. 

The National Center for Education Statistics released a study showing the drop of the United States from 18th in the world to 40th in math, 14th to 25th in science, and 15th to 24th in reading from 2000 to 2015. While these results are worrying, there is an often underlooked at issue; the detrimental effect it has on kids being continually and incessantly tested from elementary school through high school.

The Decline in Creativity

Dr. Kim of the School of Education at The College of William and Mary conducted a study called  The Creativity Crisis: The Decrease in Creative Thinking Scores on the Torrance Tests of CreativeThinking which found that while test scores at increasing on assessments such as the SAT (Scholastic Assessment Test) general creativity decreased especially between kindergartners through third graders and fourth through sixth graders.

It isn’t until adulthood is reached that some amount of creative thoughts and originality begin to climb back up. This connects back to the NCLB and RTTT as school funding becomes increasingly connected to test scores which, in turn, are focused primarily on reading, writing, math, science, etc. Creative programs such as music, band, and visual arts become the first ones on the chopping block. 

Cutting Creativity

NPR released an article using data from Oklahoma’s State Department of Education that in the span of 4 years (2014-2018) over 1,000 fine arts classes were cut and almost 30% of students in public schools are at schools without any fine arts classes. This approach is mirrored across the country as reported by the U.S Department of Education as, for example, music and visual arts in elementary and secondary schools being offered in only 4% of schools. 

The effects of this reduced creativity couldn’t be better outlined than by Sir Ken Robinson who was the Director of the Arts in Schools Project and Professor of Arts Education at the University of Warwick in his 2006 TedTalk titled Do School Kill Creativity? He brought up the example of Gillian Lynee, a now-famous choreographer, and her education experience growing up:

“…she went to see this specialist. […] she sat on her hands for 20 minutes, while this man talked to her mother about all the problems Gillian was having at school. But as they went out of the room, he turned on the radio that was sitting on his desk. And when they got out of the room, he said to her mother, “Just stand and watch her.” And the minute they left the room, she was on her feet, moving to the music. […] and he turned to her mother and said, “Mrs. Lynne, Gillian isn’t sick. She’s a dancer. Take her to a dance school.”

Kids naturally have an instinct towards creativity, drawing, movement, and many other outlets but that instinct gets suppressed as testing, testing, and more testing take priority. The main question becomes what is gained and is it worth the cost?

Is Teacher Education Too Theoretical?

One of the first things beginning teachers recognize is how underprepared their education preparation programs actually made them. Educators for Excellence did an incredible nationwide study capturing the views and opinions of educators from across America from new teachers to veterans, public schools to charter, and from every grade, subject, race, religion, and numerous other demographic breakdowns. Their methodology can be found here. 

Teachers responded with 34% or less in regards to their programs preparing them very well in the following categories:

  • Provide rigorous academic instruction
  • Differentiate your instruction to reach students at different levels in your classroom
  • Integrate technology in the classroom
  • Support the social and emotional wellbeing of students
  • Provide culturally responsive instruction
  • Effectively teach unique learners (e.g., special needs, English learners)
  • Use data to inform instruction
  • Successfully manage student behavior in the classroom
  • Understand key policy issues impacting teaching and learning
  • Engage parents/guardians in students’ learning

When looking at this list, most teachers will point out that this makes up the bulk of their real classroom responsibilities which begs the question of what is being taught in these education preparation programs? How are the day-to-day realities of teaching somehow slipping through the cracks? 

How Teachers Feel

It seems almost counterintuitive but somehow that is the reality felt by a growing majority of teachers. TNTP Teaching Fellows conducted a study that showed only 57% of teachers agreed or strongly agreed that the teacher preparation they received prior to obtaining their first full-time teaching job improved the quality of their instruction or helped them be a better teacher which placed that activity at the very bottom of 11 other activities mentioned. 

Out of Touch with Reality

This trend leads to the conclusion that teacher education is becoming too theoretical and not based enough on the realities of teaching in the classroom itself. The cause of this isn’t exactly clear though. 

It could stem from the instructors of the education classes being so far removed from the actual K-12 teaching environment for however many years and slowly moving their curriculum away from those realities and more into theories, philosophies, and research. This isn’t to say that the various theories, philosophies, pedagogies, etc. are not important to teach future educators, because they are, but as they come to dominate the preparation for them it becomes a serious issue. 

A Systemic Problem

The fault might not lie entirely on the instructors but on the underlying approach of a given university’s College of Education that, in many cases, does not get teachers out into the field until their teacher assisting/student teaching semesters which are typically later in a student’s academic career. 

A paper was done by the Journal of Philosophy and History of Education [Volume 5] that underlines the history of this problem and makes the point that teacher preparation programs “must create reflective, field-based opportunities that assist preservice teachers in making connections between educational philosophies and classroom practices.”

Without direct first-hand experience in the educational preparation programs, teachers will continue to feel out of touch with the realities of the classroom when they realize all their theories and philosophies that they thought would form the basis of their educational approach are chipped away by what it means to actually be in the classroom.

Is Civics Education The Key To Mobilizing Young Voters?

According to Child Trends, one of the nation’s leading research organizations focused on improving the lives of children and youth, who released a dedicated study on youth research trends from 1972 to 2016 on youth ages 18 to 24 which showed a decrease in reported voting from 50 to 39 percent. 

The issue of low voter turnout is one that is continually discussed and debated but with the central focus on “how and why is there such a low voter turnout?” The cause of low civic engagement is still one shrouded in mystery as are the solutions. Mandatory registration? Force businesses to close on voting day? Provide free travel for everyone to the voting booths? 

Searching for the Real Problem

What if these solutions are just band-aid fixes trying to deal with the symptoms instead of the root of the problem? If the core of the issue is that people simply don’t want to vote, or at the very least are too apathetic to vote, that is something that is most likely starting at a younger age. 

It is easy to see how there is a systemic problem with civic education as seen in a survey conducted by the Annenberg Public Policy Center (APPC) of the University of Pennsylvania which showed that only 26% of Americans could name all three branches of government. How can there be the expectation of high voter turnout when the majority are lacking some of the most basic civic knowledge? 

The Current Situation

The American Federation of Teachers compiled research from all the state Department of Education and found the following: 

  • Only nine states and the District of Columbia require one year of U.S. government or civics, while 30 states require a half year and the other 11 states have no civics requirement.
  • State civics curricula are heavy on knowledge but light on building skills and agency for civic engagement

While these statistics are saddening, they did find one glimmer of hope:

“States with the highest rates of youth civic engagement tend to prioritize civics courses and AP U.S. government in their curricula. The 10 states with the highest youth volunteer rates have a civics course requirement for graduation […]. Seven out of the 10 states with the highest youth voter participation rate score higher than average on the AP U.S. government exam.”

It seems like maybe the root of the problem is the disservice we’re doing to our kids by continually sweeping under the rug civic education and engagement. We are raising eligible voters to be uninformed, uncaring, and uninvolved towards a foundational right that countless have died for in the past. 

Civic education is shown to be one of the most useful tools in stopping this trend but as schools continue to cut classes, for a variety of reasons reserved for another post, civics tends to be one of the biggest victims that has implications much further than many might think.

School Segregation Is Worse Than It’s Ever Been

The narrative may have changed in the greater populace, but a chilling fact remains that school segregation has gotten markedly worse over the past few decades. While this is a bold assertion, it has been repeatedly backed up by data which illuminates a growing divide in where students from disadvantaged and minority households go to school. In a society where black children are now more likely to grow up in a low-income neighborhood than 50 years ago under the ghost of systemic segregation, this data has scary weight.

In a country where black students were purposefully placed in segregated, low-income schools and forced into second-class citizenship from the get-go, African American students were left in situations with a very low chance of situational transcendence. This hasn’t necessarily changed much for the better, considering the disproportionate amount of African American citizens in low-income neighborhoods and research which shows that growing up in such neighborhoods can have a negative impact on everything from future earnings and educational opportunities to simple happiness.

The segregation truth

Research by Cornell sociologist Daniel Lichter concludes that actual segregation between white families and non-white families hasn’t changed much since the 1980s. Furthermore, while segregation within urban areas has gotten better, segregation between municipalities has become much, much worse. In short, your town itself may be less segregated as a whole. But, comparing your town to another town will likely show a greater rate of segregation.

This is extremely troubling for our nation’s schools as the way districts and school attendance are drawn up is based upon where the students are physically residing. With segregation at such a high point between municipalities, it naturally follows that segregation is at a high point in United States schools where school enrollments (and their overall diversity) are a direct reflection of the racial gap between municipalities. By sending kids to the nearest schools, our school districts are entrenching segregation as a reflection of a growing residential divide.

The sad truth of reactive segregation

Per research completed by Southern Methodist University’s Meredith Richards shows that while some neighborhoods don’t show many shifts in their demographics, these neighborhoods still draw school attendance zones in such a way as to segregate and resegregate. Furthermore, neighborhoods which do experience demographic change on a regular basis tend to draw attendance zones which promote further segregation as a response. This causes increased isolation for predominantly Black and Hispanic students in both our nation’s public and charter schools.

While this criticism and truth have been brought up time and time again in research, school districts are doing very little, if anything, to fix such segregation. By holding onto tried-and-true ways of drawing attendance zones and defensively redrawing districts to enforce and reinforce the divide between students of different colors and backgrounds, our nation’s schools are facilitating institutional segregation which is causing irrevocable harm. Unless schools counterbalance growing residential segregation with new ways of drawing up school attendance zones, this sad truth will remain true.