Uncategorized

Prison Education Programs Reduce Risk of Reoffending

The issue of prison education has always been a contentious one from the financial aspect to the moral one. Prison funding tends to be heavily scrutinized and subject to public outcry as many believe prisoners should not be given certain opportunities, items, etc. which connects to the moral issue of should the prison system be built around rehabilitation or should it be punitive? 

Role of Legislation

One of the best examples of these competing approaches was the Kids Before Cons Act that was proposed in 2015 to push against the Department of Education’s pilot program of extending the Pell Grant to prisoners after a two-decade ban. The Education Secretary Arne Duncan during this time stated:

“America is a nation of second chances. Giving people who have made mistakes in their lives a chance to get back on track and become contributing members of society is fundamental to who we are — it can also be a cost-saver for taxpayers.”

Effects on Recidivism and Economic Benefits

First, let’s take a look at the general stats on recidivism. John H. Esperian from the Correctional Education Association released a report titled The Effect of Prison Education Programs on Recidivism and showcases the general trend of recidivism is between 50-70% within three years of prisoners being released. When he took a look at how prison education programs affected this the results were staggering:

  • A study was done on prison education programs in Maryland, Minnesota, and Ohio that led to 29% reduced re-incarceration
  • 6.71% recidivism compared to 26% of women who did not participate in education programs in a Colorado
  • A study was done on prison education programs in Florida, Maryland, Massachusetts, New York, Ohio, Texas, Utah, and Virginia resulted in recidivism going from 49% to 20%

Esperian’s research is supported across the board from the studies done by other organizations such as the 2013 RAND Corporation’s findings of a 43% reduction in recidivism. Research done as far back as the 1980’s, such as William L. Hiser of Portland State University report The Effects of Correctional Education on Recidivism which compiled research from the 1950s and 1960s, still showed a 20% reduction in recidivism rates. 

Furthermore, in the RAND Corporation study, which was funded by the U.S Justice Department, their meta-analysis on programs that provide education to incarcerated adults also found that for every dollar invested in these programs result in the saving of $4 to $5 on future incarceration costs. 

The question isn’t can prison education programs reduce reoffending but why don’t we implement more of these programs? The answer lies in the fundamental approach to the prison system. Once a change in the philosophy shifts from punitive to rehabilitative only then may we see a push for more prison education programs that not only help the prisoners but society as a whole.

Mental Health in High School: The Teacher’s Perspective

When it comes to dealing with student’s mental health, which includes specifically diagnosed mental illness, teachers can sometimes be left feeling inadequately equipped and supported to help their students as much as they’d want to. This can be caused by a variety of reasons such as the school’s services and interventions being lacking or completely absent, ever-rising amount of students wrestling with major depressive episodes, or simply not knowing which students are having mental health problems. 

The Rise of Mental Health Issues

With mental health issues in teens ages 12 to 17 rising to about 13% an average class size of 30 students will typically have around 3-4 students with major depressive problems which mean on a given day, a teacher will, either knowingly or unknowingly, interact with at least 15 students overall with major mental health problems. This becomes a pivotal issue when between 2009 and 2017 there was a 25% increase in high school students seriously considering suicide which is the second leading cause of adolescent death. 

For teachers, the issue has two-prongs; identifying students with major mental health issues and helping them. One of the obstacles for teachers in identifying these students is knowing what to look for. On the surface, it might be hard to differentiate between a student having a string of bad days to them genuinely suffering from crippling depression, anxiety, suicidal thoughts, etc. 

The symptoms can be easily masked behind the student saying that they simply didn’t eat breakfast or didn’t get enough sleep last night. Sometimes, it is too late for intervention to take place as these mental health issues result in the worst case scenarios of suicide, school shooting, and especially the growing problem of drug/opiate abuse and overdose. 

Finding the Solution

When teachers identify students with these issues, the next question is what do they do next? Teachers are not mental health professionals and are not equipped to be the interventionalist for the student. For schools that do have adequate student health services equipped with counselors and other professionals who can help integrate school-based and at-home initiatives to help the students the teacher can simply inform the appropriate individual and continue to help the student(s) in a more supplementary/support role. Theresa Nguyen, vice president of Mental Health America, states as such:

“It’s best that they [teachers] be seen as partners—with parents, the administration, the community—in helping students with mental health challenges.”

Benefits of Intervention

Teachers can be left feeling in limbo when a school does not have this type of support which makes it seem that the teacher is the only one who can help the student. Thankfully, more and more schools are starting to focus on the mental health of their students not only because of the need for their individual safety but also how connected mental health and academic success are. 

When students receive positive behavioral health interventions their test scores, learning behavior, time management, goal setting, and problem-solving skills all improve according to a 2013 study done by the Center for Health and Health Care in Schools. 

For schools to be able to reach these students there needs to be a systemic change in how student mental health is addressed. These are changes that can only happen from the administrative level as these intervention programs and support systems are implemented. For teachers who are left to their own volition until their school districts do so are in a harrowing position but in the eyes of their students, they might be the only ones there for them. 

School Leaders at Every Level: 5 Ways to Create a Culture of Leadership

The differences between high-performing schools and low-performing schools within the public education system are stark and varied, yet it’s the culture of leadership which is either cultivated or not by school leaders which serve as a catalyst for either growth or utter, inefficient chaos. With that truth in mind, here are 5 effective ways school leaders can build a culture of leadership within their institutions.

Do not be afraid to embrace the duality 

The best leaders in any business field understand both their own duality and the duality necessary to lead. Equal parts modesty and will, humility and fearlessness, a true school leader must never be afraid to take control but must also never be afraid to concede control and learn when the situation requires such. A true leader’s example must be one of flexibility, malleability, but a singular resolve that will take on any problem with appropriate force and fire.

Be professional, not a savior

Education is a hard field because there is an inherent structure of altruism within it which can cause some school leaders to misappropriate themselves as saviors rather than business leaders. To try and save every student and/or try to maximize the talents of every teacher is a Herculean task which will end up crushing a school leader under its weight. To build a culture of leadership, school leaders must be able to delegate and organize in such a way that other leaders are built up and their own reserves of energy aren’t depleted.

Understand your importance

Studies show that one transcendent classroom lecture or interaction with a member of the school leadership can change a young student’s life trajectory completely! School leaders must remind their entire staffs of the importance they have in shaping children’s lives. A true culture of leadership in the public education system embraces the power of simple moments of genuine connection, cultivating compassionate leadership who keeps the best interests of the student populace at the forefront of their everyday efforts. 

Leave your ego at the door

School leaders who wield their positions of leadership as weapons in hopes of boosting and placating their own egos create cultures of distrust and resentment which can permeate all levels of an institution.  Confidence is key. Ego is not. A school leader must remain confident as to maintain the respect and trustworthiness necessary to make the tough decisions, but drop the ego in favor of the betterment of the school. A culture of leadership is built upon confident actions removed from personal ego and gain.

Walk how you talk 

In business, brand respectability and loyalty are cultivated through being genuine and transparent with your customer base. That same transparency and genuine nature must serve as the backbone of school leadership. If you are humble, people will view you as such. If you are fair, people will view you as such. School leaders must stress to all faculty and members of leadership that it’s their actions which carry the weight, not the words they use to describe such actions. This pushes other school leaders to act with equal parts thoughtfulness and clarity, building a culture of leadership immune to the toxicity which can bring institutions down in short order.

Concluding Thoughts

While building a culture of leadership may not be the top priority amongst many educators, it should be. It can make a team easier to run, which will help students feel more comfortable and perform better. This leadership can help develop the school into the education system that a district is proud of. 

Schools Are Using AI to Track What Students Write On Their Computers

There are over 50 million K-12 students who will be headed back to school in the United States this fall, and a vast majority of them will be tracked every time they type a word on a school computer. Per the Children’s International Protection Act, a United State school which receives federal funding must have an internet-safety policy in place.

The guidelines of such a policy vary from simply blocking sites with potentially inappropriate content to much more comprehensive initiatives which use help from software companies such as Securly, Gaggle, and GoGuardian to bring troublesome student communications to the attention of school leadership.

These companies use Safety Management Platforms which utilize natural-language processing to sift through millions upon millions of words being typed by students on school computers. These companies have all made case studies available linking these SMPs to intercepted messages which helped prevent a potential school tragedy before it started. As mass school-shootings and suicide rates rise, such interception has real intrinsic value. But, it also blurs the line between student safety and student privacy.

What do SMPs really do?

Girard Kelly, director of privacy review for Common Sense Media, believes that the advent and implementation of Safety Management Platforms normalize the idea of surveillance from a young age. His worry is that such normalization leaves kids vulnerable when it comes to learning the importance of protecting their online data and privacy – a type of vulnerability which has been exploited before by data-mining companies in such controversial ways as that which set off the Cambridge Analytica scandal at Facebook.  

Balancing the safety of students and their privacy is a high wire act that has yet to find a compromise which satiates critics on both sides of the aisle. With school violence, bullying, and charted mental illnesses on the rise in the student populace, it’s more essential than ever that schools find ways to protect their students from potential tragedies. However, a balance must be struck by administrations and the companies who implement such initiatives as Safety Management Platforms which respects student freedoms while also finding a way to ethically supervise and identify potential problems.

Informed consent and its effects

Should students know that they’re being monitored when they use technology on campus? Proponents believe that such transparency would be fair to student privacy and freedoms, but critics believe the trade-off would be self-censorship and a compromise of actual, useful data. Companies such as Securely and Gaggle stand on the prevention side of the argument, believing unfettered surveillance without informed consent saves lives.

They argue that the intentions and machinations of troubled students (and troubled teachers in some instances) won’t have the clarity and truth required to take preventative action if they know they’re being watched. Thus, potential tragedies are kept under wraps and off school communication systems – leaving institutions in the dark when a potential problem arises. However, a balance must be struck as such surveillance can go overboard and take away safe, digital spaces for students to be themselves without fear of reprisal. 

Schools Weren’t Built for Tomorrow’s Leaders

The modern public education system in the United States is behind the curve in so many areas, eschewing innovation and the cultivation of tomorrow’s leaders (and their untapped emotional and intellectual potentials) in favor of an outdated system which places the onus on assignments and grades. For a school to really give tomorrow’s leaders a fair shake in becoming fitting to the roles they will assume as they grow older, it has to look at its practices and agendas and how one-size-fits-all education and bureaucracy is stifling growth in our student populace.

A culture of following blanket directives in fear of discipline isn’t one which promotes the individuality necessary for a student to take their own initiative and become a leader. Sacrificing creativity for rigor, innovation for the grades necessary to make the next level, our students are placed into stifling educational environments which punish deviation and reward groupthink. 

What fear does to tomorrow’s leaders

One high school in Washington D.C., known to be one of the hardest schools in all of the United States, has built such a culture of fear that students skip class to hide in the library in hopes of acing the next big test on the docket. It’s a grading culture which tells students that their entire futures are predicated upon the approval of the system. Top-achievers live in constant fear of slipping up, watching their potential careers vanish as others race ahead of them who are much more adept at playing the game.

While testing and its consequences have their place, such a culture of fear turns students into anxious followers rather than potential leaders. The best entrepreneurs aren’t afraid of failure. In fact, they embrace the potential of failure in hopes of the next successful venture. Students who are afraid of their own shadows in school aren’t given the opportunity to embrace such an entrepreneurial spirit. They’re taught that their fears are always valid and worth fearing. That’s no way to build a future leader.

The Mark Cuban effect

Schools aren’t changing their didactic ways anytime soon, or not fast enough to really cultivate a culture of budding leadership in their student populace. So, it behooves students (and concerned parents) to look at sources outside of the educational system which reflect how success can be achieved without playing the follow-the-leader games of public education. Billionaire entrepreneur and media personality Mark Cuban was once suspended from high school for wearing a shirt with the word “bullshit” on it. He constantly got into trouble, unable to reconcile his own desire to lead with the bureaucratic structures of the educational system.

“It doesn’t matter how many times you fail. You only have to be right once and then everyone can tell you that you are an overnight success,” Cuban once said. If students can find a way to experience and learn different modes of grading success and failure, especially with their own ethics and wants and needs into account, they can break from the backward nature of the public education system and build themselves internally as confident leaders unafraid of a bad grade or a bad decision.

Relying on the 30 Million Word Gap To Shape Early Childhood Policy

Around 25 years ago, Betty Hart and Todd Risley put together an influential study which quantified a stunning 30 million word gap between the number of words a wealthy child hears before the age of three and the number of words heard by a poor child within the same span. The findings of this study shocked many early childhood advocates into action, with multiple research initiatives and initiatives at the school/community level being funded in hopes of educating low-income parents on how to expose their children to richer language and what communication styles work best to increase vocabulary potential in their children.

Hart and Risley’s study has been cited a staggering 8,000 times and has served as the impetus for initiatives such as Clinton Foundation’s Too Small to Fail and funding increases to Head Start and Early Head Start. However, the study now finds itself at the center of controversy after a new study conducted last April attempted and failed to reach the same conclusions. 

Is there really a stratified word gap?

The new study, Reexamining the Verbal Environments of Children from Different Socioeconomic Backgrounds by Sperry, Sperry and Miller observed children in households of differing socioeconomic statuses and their interactions with family members. Rather than coming to the conclusion of a direct 30 million word deficit between children of high-income households and children of low-income households, the study found that when multiple caregivers were brought into the equation (which is a high-probability situation in a household of working-class parents), the gap narrowed and sometimes disappeared.

One of the key criticisms of the Hart and Risley study is that their narrow sample of 42 families eliminated the nuance and idiosyncratic variance that a larger study would have shed light on. The study’s lack of scope not only misidentified a problem in terms too simple, but it also opened the door for racial, cultural, and linguistic bias. In short, language quality and types of communication were earmarked for high quality if they coincided with white middle-class ways of speaking. Variances based on differences in race and culture were often written off as inferior through the lens of the Hart and Risley study.

Did the original study still do some good?

Those who still attribute merit to the 30 million word gap believe the new study wasn’t actually a replication of the original at all. Advocates point out that the original study compared families from “professional” backgrounds and those within the “welfare” system, while the new study stratified high-income families and low-income families. Believers in the Hart and Risley methodology still contend that the home is the crucial space for early language development and that low-income children remain on the wrong end of things regardless of racial or cultural backgrounds.

Regardless, both studies come to a middle ground when it comes to the importance of facilitating proper and complex language development in early childhood. Both studies stress the importance of building a dialogue with children from an early age, regardless of socioeconomic status, in hopes of getting them to think critically about language and employ it on their own accord. However, it’s the type and tenor of support for low-income families in regards to early childhood language development which is now under scrutiny from both sides.

School Leaders Can Help Reduce Minority Teacher Turnover

One of the biggest problems in the United States’ public education system is the sheer amount of turnover – a near-epidemic which is harming our students and wasting valuable and limited resources on the training and evaluation of teachers who aren’t sticking in the profession. An example of the harm it’s having on our student populace lies in data compiled by Charlotte Mecklenburg which chronicles a sharp decline in student math achievement every time an effective teacher leaves the job or the profession entirely.

The problem becomes even more troublesome when you consider the departure of minority teachers. As those of minority are sorely underrepresented in our public schools’ faculties, to begin with, the loss of a minority teacher can serve as a major loss for minority students who identify with a teacher who may look like them instead of the vast norm of white middle-class teachers on public educational dockets. 

Why minority teachers are so important

Data points surrounding the pairing of minority teachers with minority students show a direct increase in the exertion of personal effort in the classroom, a much better chance for minority students to gain acceptance into gifted-and-talented programs, and a greater likelihood that students from underrepresented backgrounds will complete high school and enroll in higher education. These data points have led to a concerted effort to add to the ratio of minority teachers in public school education. 

However, the increase in minority teachers hasn’t been sharp enough to weather the impact of turnover.    While strategies to diversify the teaching workplace such as recruitment efforts focused on colleges which are doing a good job of graduating students of color have been implemented by many school districts, such recruitment efforts are costly and aren’t feasible when budgets are taken into account. Thus, it’s critical that we shift our focus to retaining minority teachers, putting the onus on our school leaders to make the efforts necessary to do so.

How school leaders can reduce the turnover of minority teachers

One of the key things principals can do to reduce the overall turnover of minority teachers is to consult with minority teachers about what administrative practices they feel will help foster a work environment they can thrive and be happy working in. School leaders must work alongside their minority teachers to identify any cultural dissonance within the institution which could indirectly promote race-based stereotypes or serve as a counterbalance to inclusivity efforts.

In addition to this, school leaders have to show their minority teaching staff members that there are equal pathways for them to enter leadership positions and enter them with the same preparation as anyone else. It is up to our school leaders to give appropriate opportunities for advancement to the entirety of their staffs, rather than leaning on minority teachers to be liaisons for minority students.

A safe, inclusive work environment will help reduce teacher turnover as a whole, but it could have a particularly huge impact on minority teacher turnover if school leaders cultivate the right working conditions and policymakers help to give school leaders the tools to ensure such working conditions are in place.

School Resource Officers Can Prevent Tragedies, But Training Is Key

While there are a host of legitimate concerns regarding the potentially negative effects of hiring school resource officers in our nation’s schools, the benefits of having such staff members in place could be a tangible increase in lives saved. Back on March 20th of 2018, school resource officers Blaine Gaskill rushed straight towards a shooter who had opened fire in a common area of Great Mills High School in Maryland. The shooter had already wounded two students.

Gaskill’s act of instinct and heroism effectively kept the incident from becoming a tragedy akin to the Marjory Stoneman Douglas High School shooting in Parkland, Florida back in February 2018. Video footage of that shooting shows school deputy Scot Peterson inactive and standing outside of the school as a mass shooting was underway. 17 people, most of them students, were killed. While it is unfair to place blame on Peterson for the tragedy itself, it is indicative of a divide between those school resource officers who are well trained for such situations and those who fail to act.

The need for universal training standards

There are no national standards in place for how student resource officers are trained for their jobs. Incredibly, there are is litany of states who also do not have standards in place. With a lack of regulation and coherent oversight, there is a massive lack of consistency when it comes to how student resource officers are prepared for situations such as the two aforementioned shootings. 

Furthermore, a student resource officer is crucial not only for how they respond in such situations but for their adeptness and awareness when it comes to their prevention. The current SRO training which does exist throughout our nation’s schools tends to focus on legal issues and security. A more comprehensive and nuanced take on training is necessary for these officers to spot warning signs such as symptoms of trauma, along with learning de-escalation techniques, issues surrounding bullying and cyberbullying, key factors of child development, and the care needed to work with special needs students.

A lack of training, or proper training

While there is a concerted call by researchers and criminal justice experts for extended and specialized training for our nation’s school resource officers, the fact remains that very few of the 19,000 or so school resource officers in our schools are trained. This alone could explain the difference in the responses by the officers of the Maryland and Florida shootings. Universal specialized training could spell the difference between life and death, near-death, and actual tragedy.

Furthermore, additional training in the use of and access to specialized equipment used to gain forcible entry to locked buildings and classrooms would help our school resource officers to be action-oriented as the moment happens, rather than having to wait for help and it potentially being too late. But, the key remains in prevention. If we can build an adequate training system for our school resource officers which helps them identify students at risk and act accordingly, tragic shootings like the one in Parkland can potentially be avoided altogether.

Rethinking the Education Paradigm

The problem with our 24-hour news cycle and the inherent urgency crises which tend to focus heavily on the fights between partisans is that such noise can drown out the really important issues plaguing our nation, along with the policy issues which play a role in such. There are a host of problems with our public education system in the United States which never make air, thus decreasing the perceived importance while leaving our students, our teachers and the very state of our educational system out in the cold.

That doesn’t stop political parties from using “education” as a buzzword, offering platitudes about how better education will solve a litany of societal and structural problems in the nation – including creating a better governmental system as a whole, adding strength to the institution of democracy, better candidates for elected positions, potential booms in economic activity, a drop in unemployment, greater tolerance for diversity, and potentially less extremism as a whole.

Why the buzzword falls flat

The problem is that there is a massive difference between talking about educational reform in vague terms and really coming out with strong ideas which can facilitate such reform and give it shape. The actual dialogue about reform in the educational sector is exceedingly sparse when it comes to the actual content, sacrificing potential answers to real problems for sensationalism which uses “education” as a buzzword to capture people’s attention in a swirling 24/7 news cycle.

To truly rethink the educational paradigm, we have to rethink education. We have to look at the untapped potential of the students in all of our schools, not just the ones in our relative proximity or even just the ones considered problems to the greater whole. We have to ask ourselves whether or not our public education system is really giving each student the chance to maximize their potential. We have to be okay with the fact that the answer is “no,” and then institute a shift in thinking which goes past sensationalism into action.

What would mean to truly rethink the educational paradigm?

Due to the ever-present swaths of bureaucratic red tape wrapping our public education system, our schools are unable to truly innovate or be forward-thinking enough to meet the ever-changing needs of our student populace. That’s not only trouble for education itself, but it could very well spell danger for tolerance as a whole as outdated methods of teaching history or other disciplines sometimes reinforce bigoted stereotypes and cause irrevocable harm as students take such information as unquestioned fact.

To rethink the educational paradigm as a whole, we have to look at the regulations surrounding our schools and see which ones are suffocating our student populace and which ones are actually benefiting our students. Thusly, we can slowly but surely eliminate outmoded and outdated structural dissonance and really put the evolution and well-being of our students, teachers, and very futures at the forefront of the national conversation. Fewer buzzwords and fiery rhetoric in favor of more concerted and thoughtful action is the first step to a true rethink of our nation’s educational paradigm.

Rethinking Regulations in K-12 Education

Many teachers and educators are frustrated with the regulations that are in place in K-12 education. There have been many that say if the schools were deregulated and freed from the strict rules put in by the government, they would excel with their students. However, it’s not always that easy. Deregulation may not be the answer, but rethinking regulation could be.

Why are these regulations in place?

We first have to understand why regulations are there in the first place. Public schools are funded with taxpayers’ dollars, which is why there are standardized tests and other regulations to ensure that this money is being well spent. However, these tests lead to organizations that believe that the tests are the final say. They do not take into account the struggles of individual students or the school as a whole. Still, regulations are in place to make sure money is being handled correctly and that our children are getting a good education. 

Changing regulation could change education

One study performed by Innosight Institute found that many teachers are spending a significant amount of time doing tedious documentation for the required regulations currently in place. Instead of dedicating those hours to bettering curriculum and engaging with the students, they have to mindlessly document things like how many hours each student spends learning. If regulation could be changed, it could impact how well students are learning.

There are many complex rules when it comes to running a school, and while that’s not usually a bad thing, it wears on teachers who are already tired and underpaid. The key to making a better education system happen may not be getting rid of regulation, but changing it. Many believe that a few small, simple rules are much easier to follow than a long set of complex ones.

The guidelines could be better

 The education system could always be improved, but it doesn’t have to be left up to one political party or the other. This is an issue that affects every child, which in turn, affects everyone’s future. Implementing a handful of simple rules that teachers could follow would allow for more flexibility in the curriculum. Teachers are trained to teach children, and when they spend hours with these children, they know how to educate them best. What works for one school may not work for the other, but only the local educators will understand what works for them.

Simple rules can be implemented as general guidelines that have to be followed. However, it doesn’t have to rule the teacher’s day as it does right now. Education in the public school systems should have an overarching goal, one that teachers will want each of their students to hit and succeed. However, it’s unrealistic to think that one test or one set of guidelines can cover the vast socioeconomic and educational disparity that exists within the United States. Funding, lack of support, and the daily life struggles of each student vary depending on the state and city that these children are in. While taking away regulation may not be the best choice, rethinking regulation as a whole could help our students to better succeed.