Uncategorized

The Best School Systems in the Country

Where are the country’s best schools? A recent study collected data to answer this very question. Their methodology includes data collection on two main data points: quality (determined largely by school rankings and dropout rates) and safety. Massachusetts ranked first on the list, followed by New Jersey. Ranking at 51 was New Mexico, right under Louisiana and the District of Columbia. Here are the top five states with the best public school systems, and the top factors that contributed to their ranking.

Massachusetts

Massachusetts ranked first in math and reading test scores. It also ranked first in median ACT scores (along with Connecticut) and has the lowest percentage of threatened/injured high school students (tied with Oklahoma and Vermont). For lowest bullying-incidence rate, Massachusetts came in fifth.

New Jersey

New Jersey ranked second in the lowest dropout rates and highest reading test scores. It ranked third in highest math test scores.

Connecticut

Connecticut tied for first with Massachusetts in highest median test scores. It came in fourth for highest reading test scores, and fifth for lowest pupil-teacher ration.

New Hampshire

New Hampshire ranked third for highest reading test scores and tied for third in highest median ACT scores.

Vermont

Vermont placed fifth in highest reading test scores and has the lowest pupil-teacher ration. It tied for first in the lowest percentage of threatened/injured high school students.

Lori Czop Assaf, Ph.D., offers her insight into what makes schools systems succeed. Her list of determining factors include teacher knowledge and expertise, instructional time, and the teacher-student ratio per classroom.

Merrimack College Assistant Professor Laura Hsu also discussed which factors she sees as increasingly important when considering the quality of a school system. “I will say that from literature I have read, more than any factor within the school, teacher quality seems to be the strongest predictor of student achievement.

Thus, recruiting and retaining strong teachers would ideally be the priority for every school,” she says.  Districts with lower compensation packages for teachers will find it difficult to recruit the quality teachers they need to improve their school system, especially as we see education students changing majors because of grim salary outlooks.

Hsu’s remarks could support the idea that school districts with larger budgets in proportion to their student population could achieve more. Economists at the University of California–Berkeley and Northwestern University found that after states were required to increase their funding of school districts, students’ test scores improved.

Education experts across the board agree that higher test scores do not necessarily indicate the higher total quality of a school. Much of what appears on standardized tests like the SAT and ACT is not explicitly taught inside the classroom. Other strongly influential factors of school quality include school leadership, discipline statistics, teacher turnover, and student happiness.

As these are qualitative variables, instead of quantitative, they are more difficult to measure and therefore incorporated less into school rankings. We should take these results at face value, and understand that not all factors that contribute to the success and quality of public school systems can be reduced to a statistic.

The Ultimate Guide to Data Collection in the Classroom

For some teachers, data collection is a source of frustration and annoyance. That doesn’t need to be the case – data collection can be an insightful and fun journey to improving as an educator. Here is everything you need to know to become the effective data collector your students need:

Standard Dissection

Before you can begin collecting any data, you need to know exactly what you are trying to learn from the data that will be gathered. This begins with an intense dissection or “unpacking” of the standards. Break the standards down into nouns, verbs, and big ideas. This will allow you to identify exactly what the students need to know, be able to do, and the larger skill(s) the standard contributes to.

Assessment Development

Based on your dissection, you will need to develop a pre-assessment. Identify the final assessments you will use and a few formative assessments that will reveal progress before the final assessment. Create a reliable and valid rubric that will allow for consistent grading across all assessments. These can be informal or formal assessments, but they must measure the standard and be consistent. If you aren’t doing so already, consider working with your grade-level partners to develop assessments. This will not only create less work for all of the teachers, but your school will have the benefit of a large amount of data on the growth and progress of your students.

Instruction and Assessment Practice

During instruction, be sure that you are providing modeling and practice that will prepare the students to take the final assessment. This doesn’t mean to engage in the practice of “teaching to the test,” but rather being sure that students are prepared to demonstrate the new knowledge they have gained. If you have designed your assessments properly, by teaching this way, you will also ensure that your instruction is aligned to the standard you are targeting.

Data Review and Collection

Data collection does NOT have to be done entirely by the teacher. Teach students to take agency over their progress and learning by creating student data binders to record their own data. You can print out simple tables with the week or standard at the top, and have students fill in their score accordingly. There are plenty of free and inexpensive templates for data binders as well if you don’t feel up to creating your own. For your own records, create an Excel sheet that will automatically create and update bar charts of each student’s progress through a standard. Print out whole class data (never post individual data in the classroom) and refer to it often. Explain the chart to students and celebrate when the data shows the class is doing well.

Using Data for Instruction

Never collect data just for the sake of collecting data or appeasing school administration. Data collection takes effort, so it would be foolish not to use it. Leverage the data to improve your instruction and teach with precision. Place students performing at similar levels in small groups and have them work together, or provide small group instruction for students who didn’t perform well on a formative assessment. Through the data, you may be able to identify exceptional or gifted students or students that need evaluation for SPED services. Data can be a powerful tool when requesting additional resources for a student. If you notice that the class as a whole is struggling with a standard or concept, it could be a signal that you need to try a different strategy during instruction. 

Data collection is an essential part of an effective classroom. While the road to data collection may seem long and tedious, teachers will benefit from a deep exploration of the standards they teach, and from the rich data they gather. By following this guide and researching other data collection strategies, teachers can transform the way they approach instruction and provide even more opportunities for their students’ success. 

The Best Education News Resources

Whether you are an educator, administrator, advocate, work in policy, or the hundreds of other education adjacent positions, you need to stay updated on the developments in the education sector. We have compiled a list of the best resources to make sure you know about important policy changes, government appointments, and current news.

Chalkbeat.org

“Chalkbeat is a nonprofit news organization committed to covering one of America’s most important stories: the effort to improve schools for all children, especially those who have historically lacked access to quality education. We are mission-driven, in that we believe that every child deserves an excellent education and that a strong press is vital to making that happen. Yet we are also fiercely independent, in that we do not take a position on the best path for achieving equity.”

Chalkbeat is a unique education news source because while they focus on big ideas and the larger trends and issues in education, they report on these trends through the lens of local education environments. They have reporters currently located in Chicago, Colorado, Detroit, Indiana, Newark, New York, and Tennessee.

Education Week

Education Week provides new on all 50 states and their education systems. You can click on a state to view the most recent news and policy debates that are affecting that state’s communities.

Inside Higher Ed

“Inside Higher Ed is the leading digital media company serving the higher education space. Since our founding in 2004, we have become the go-to online source for higher education news, thought leadership, careers, and resources. Our mission is to serve all of higher education – individuals, institutions, corporations and non-profits – so they can do their jobs better, transforming their lives and those of the students they serve.”

Inside Higher Ed also publishes data and reports in addition to their coverage of higher education. Their reports are extremely insightful. Their most recent report covers best practices to diversify graduate schools and faculty.

Edsurge

“EdSurge provides independent news and resources to help readers understand the role of technology in education.”

Edsurge covers issues and advancements in education and technology. They provide product reviews, event coverage, news, and job postings.

Eduwonk

“Eduwonk is a blog written by Andrew J. Rotherham, Co-founder, and Partner at Bellwether Education Partners. Occasional guest bloggers will also contribute, and the author(s) of these posts will be clearly identified. The blog focuses mostly on education policy and politics.”

The Eduwonk blog features entertaining and insightful posts concerning recent education news and debates. Its content is a mix of humor, news, and opinion pieces. Readers enjoy the clarity the blog brings to confusing and complex education topics. This is a resource you could check multiple time a day to find new posts and information.

We have also compiled a list of local education news in larger cities:

New York City: The New York Times, New York School Talk

Washington, DC: The Washington Post

Boston: CBS Boston

Denver: A+ Colorado

Chicago: WBEZ

These resources can supplement the coverage you already receive on education. Whether you are looking for local news, news on education technology, or want to hear how policies are impacting local communities, these resources will keep you informed.

These College Majors Will Earn You The Highest Salaries

As college tuition costs rise, more students may use salary predictions to determine their course of study. We have compiled statistics from studies performed by PayScale, the Georgetown Center for Education and the Workforce, and theUnited States Bureau of Labor Statistics to rank the highest paying degrees based largely on starting salaries. Unsurprisingly, the list is dominated by the fields of science and engineering. This can be contributed to several factors, including the increasing rate at which we are discovering new technological advancements, and the skills gap that leaves many engineering positions unfulfilled. Here are the top 10 highest paying majors:

1. Petroleum Engineering

Petroleum engineers develop the most profitable ways to extract oil and gas from the earth safely. They evaluate the production of wells, develop extraction plans, and design ways to extract deposits of these hydrocarbons from older reserves. The median salary of a petroleum engineer is $137,170. Petroleum engineers typically have a bachelor’s degree in engineering, specifically petroleum engineering. Civil, mechanical, or chemical engineering could also meet the requirements of employers of petroleum engineers.

2. Aerospace Engineering

Aerospace engineers design, simply put, airborne machines. These include aircraft, missiles, satellites, and spacecraft. They also design prototypes and test equipment to ensure it meets safety standards and engineering principles. They engage in system engineering, safety and environmental testing, and mechanical and structural design. The median salary of an aerospace engineer is $115,220.

3. Computer engineering

Computer engineering encompasses both electrical engineering and computer science. It is focused on the development of computer components such as memory devices, hardware, and processors. Some computer engineers also work in the software development and systems testing fields. The median salary of a computer engineer is $114,600.

4. Pharmacy, Pharmaceutical Sciences, and Pharmaceutical Administration

The pharmaceutical industry involves the discovery, development, testing, and administration of new and existing drug therapies. It is a dynamic field that is challenging and rewarding. Work environments include hospitals, retail pharmacies, and research labs. The median salary in this industry $112,519, but vary depending on the specific career track. Related undergraduate majors include biochemistry, chemistry, pre-medicine, and pharmaceutical sciences.

5. Chemical Engineering

Chemical engineers use materials and chemicals to create products like food, drugs, and fuel. They develop and design processes to create or improve products. They also conduct research, evaluate equipment, and establish safety procedures. Chemical engineers make $104,910 annually on average. The majority of chemical engineers studied chemical engineering during their undergraduate career.

6. Metallurgical Engineering

Metallurgical engineers take metals and extract, combine, and transform them for many uses. They study ore mines, design parts and develop plans for working with materials like iron, aluminum, copper, steel, and zinc. Metallurgical engineers can work at mine sites or in research labs. The median salary for a metallurgical engineer is $97,743.

7. Mining and Mineral Engineering

Mining and mineral engineers develop plans and infrastructure for the safe and effective transportation of minerals from mines to processing sites. The majority of this work happens at mines or worksites. Mining and mineral engineers earn a median salary of $97,372. Few schools offer mining and mineral engineering courses, but many institutions offer the opportunity to specialize in this field underneath a general engineering degree.

8. Electrical Engineering

Electrical engineers learn how to create and service electrical systems and products. They work on equipment of all sizes, from as small as cell phones to as large as supercomputers. Electrical engineers work in industries such as robotics, consulting, telecommunications and microelectronics. The average salary for an electrical engineer is $95,230.

9. Geological and Geophysical Engineering

Geological and geophysical engineering combines geology and civil engineering to safely and efficiently extract minerals, precious gems, gases, and other natural resources from the earth. Geological engineers are generally focused on the earth’s resources, while geophysical engineering includes how the earth interacts with the moon and sun. Daily work in these fields includes the evaluation of construction sites, tunnels, and mines. On average, geological and geophysical engineers earn $92,250 a year.

10. Mechanical Engineering

Mechanical engineers design equipment and tools such as engines, electric generators, machines, and turbines. They find solutions to engineering problems using mathematics and physics that relate to the functioning of mechanical equipment. Mechanical engineers work with both power-producing equipment as well as power-using products. Because mechanical engineering is a broad field, these engineers can work in many industries including auto research, heating, and cooling, electronics, manufacturing, and biotechnology. Mechanical engineers earn a median salary of $87,370.

What do you think will be the highest paying careers in the future?

How to Cure the K-12 Education System’s Addiction to Testing

Standardized testing has long been dreaded in classrooms. Teachers, students, and administrators alike suffer from the strain testing puts on the education system. On average, classrooms are spending 14 days of valuable instruction time on test preparation alone. In low-income schools, teachers report spending twice that. The average student is taking over 100 assessments from kindergarten to graduation. This number doesn’t include assessments delivered by classrooms, schools, and districts. It would almost seem as if the education system has an addiction to testing. Here are three solutions that address some of the most common complaints from teachers and students concerning standardized testing:

  1. Create Valuable Tests

One way to prevent students from testing fatigue is for test creators to remember the core purpose of assessment. Assessments are developed to collect data that should inform classroom instruction in one way or another. If the assessment is not going to influence a decision that impacts students directly, the value of the assessment may need revisiting. There are ways to create assessments that answer multiple questions to reduce the total number of tests that students are required to take. By creating valuable exams, we would also decrease testing time dramatically. 29% estimate that their students spend more than a month in total on state-mandated tests, and several tests are over three hours long. If the tests had targeted questions that address multiple data points, we could decrease the time students spend in front of the computer for testing.

  1. Use Computer Adaptive Testing

In many ways, our education system has yet to leverage the advanced testing technology that exists.  Computer Adaptive Testing is a way of testing that tailors the questions to the student. This means that the system identifies when the student is struggling with the test items and lowers the difficulty of the questions. CATs also identify when a student is not being challenged and adjusts the difficulty level accordingly. This relieves much of the stress and anxiety that affects students and teachers when it comes time to prepare for tests. About three-quarters (76 percent) of school psychologists in New York say their students experience greater anxiety over state tests than for local assessments. If states utilized testing systems that allowed for students to spend more time engaged with the assessment and less time bored or frustrated, this would reduce the test anxiety felt through the entire school ecosystem.

  1. Use one assessment across grade levels

In many states and school districts, students across grade levels are taking entirely different tests with separate scoring structures. It can be incredibly difficult and time-consuming for teachers to analyze a student’s standardized test scores from the previous year and compare them to their scores in the current year if they are two completely different data sets. The solution to this is to encourage classrooms, school districts, and even states to use the same assessment system across all grade levels. This would also track student progress across districts – meaning if a student were to move to a different school district that their time spent testing would still be valuable and usable in their new classroom.

If we are going to continue with standardized testing in America’s schools, we need to create a highly effective system that is sensitive to the needs and well-being of each school’s community. This includes reducing the time spent on testing and preparation as well as easing the anxiety that tests cause teachers, administrators, students, and parents. Finally, if our students are going to spend time on assessments, their data needs to be clear and useful for teachers and administrators. Assessments of many forms are valuable and necessary for evaluating student progress and proficiency, but the efforts of our schools to perform well on assessments should be matched in the quality of the data provided by the assessments.

Are For-Profit Schools a Scam?

While Congress has dismantled their investigation of for-profit colleges, there are still questions that need to be answered concerning their motivations and practices. Betsy DeVos, the current Secretary of Education, has drawn scrutiny over her support of for-profit colleges and schools, as did the addition of a former dean of DeVry University to the investigative team.

Educators are still critical of corporations such as DeVry, Bridgepoint Education, and Career Education Corporation with good reason. DeVry has already paid the Federal Trade Commission $100 million “for tens of thousands of students harmed by DeVry’s conduct.” What exactly is the conduct that the FTC considers harmful? Thankfully, investigations and former employees have exposed what is really happening at these for-profit schools.

Aggressive Recruiting Tactics

Tressie McMillan Cottom, the author of Lower Ed, discusses the aggressive recruiting tactics that for-profit colleges use. Recruiters have quotas to meet and are encouraged to enroll students who qualify for the maximum amount of financial aid. Recruiters are reminded by training material to “poke the pain a bit and remind them who else is depending on them and their commitment to a better future.” A Kaplan University training document also states (in all capital letters), “It is all about uncovering their pain and fears. Once they are reminded of how bad things are, this will create a sense of urgency to make a change.”

Targeting of Low-Income and Minority Students

For-profit colleges are known to target low-income and minority students who may not understand the difference in the quality of education between non-profit and for-profit schools. These potential students may also encounter obstacles when applying to traditional colleges or universities. During one investigation, the government found a list of ideal students most likely to enroll in courses from a training manual at Vatterott, a now-closed for-profit school. This training manual stated explicitly that recruiters should enroll: “Welfare mom w/kids, pregnant ladies, recent divorce, low self-esteem, vocational rehabilitation, experienced a recent death, physically/mentally abused, drug rehabilitation, fired/lay off.”

Many for-profit schools focus on the number of enrollments, and the student’s best interests are not kept in mind. This is largely because they operate to produce returns for investors and shareholders and not necessarily for their students.

The Worth of a For-Profit Degree

Employers have been known to say that if they see two candidates, one with a for-profit degree and one from a traditional institution, they will most likely choose the candidate with the non-profit degree. Out of the programs that for-profit schools like DeVry and University of Phoenix offer, 72 percent produce graduates who earn less than high school dropouts.

Are all for-profit colleges a scam? For-profit schools do provide students who may find it challenging to apply to non-profit schools, but many times, these corporations as schools come with a cost. Be sure to consider the cost of the program versus non-profit institutions (for-profit universities tend to cost more). It is also important to confirm that the program they are offering is accredited and accepted by employers.

If you are planning on transferring to a different institution, you will need to make sure that the credits will transfer. Understanding your loan terms is critical as well. Make sure it is understood the amount you will be paying per month and in total, including interest. There are success stories from graduates of for-profit schools, but their internal operations indicate that they are concerned more about revenue and enrollment numbers than the students they serve.

Need STEM Teachers? Recruit Retired and Former STEM Professionals

STEM is ever-present in all parts of daily life in the modern world.  STEM jobs are more in demand every day and expected to grow exponentially over the next few years. However, STEM education in the U.S. has a long way to go. It’s become a well-known fact that most high school students are woefully unprepared for careers in science, technology, engineering, and math (otherwise known as STEM). Students in the United States regularly score low on math and science tests, lagging behind the scores of students in other developed nations.

Why is this happening?

STEM education in most K-12 schools around the U.S. is abysmal. At the core of this problem is the fact that there are not enough quality STEM teachers to go around. Why? Because STEM careers are in high demand, and college graduates with degrees in and a high aptitude for STEM can make hundreds of thousands of dollars working in private industry. If they decided to become a teacher, they would be lucky to start out at a salary of forty thousand dollars. The overwhelming majority of them decide on the private sector, as it will allow them to live a comfortable upper-middle-class existence.

Because of this, schools often find themselves scrambling to find qualified STEM education teachers to fill their classrooms. Some even end up filling these positions with long-term substitutes or teachers with emergency licenses. At the end of the day, students lose, as they are deprived of a quality STEM education. Of those that end up in college, many are not ready for the rigors of STEM courses at the higher education level and end up taking remedial courses to help them get back on track. If this epidemic does not end, we will have a workforce that lacks the STEM skills to lead our country in the global economy.

One possible solution

I have an idea for ending this crisis. What if we recruited retired STEM professionals to the teaching profession? If they started their careers after college, many would likely still be in their forties, and still vibrant, ready for a new challenge. Maybe they always wanted to become a teacher, but financially they couldn’t consider it as a viable career. Or maybe at this stage of their lives, they are looking to give back.

Districts could create a “Teach for America” type program to help retired or former STEM professionals get prepared for the rigors of the classroom and obtain licensure. Who better to teach students about STEM fields, than people that spent 1/3 of their lives working in one? It could be a match made in heaven. This is just a suggestion and would need to be fleshed out, but I think that it could pay dividends and help us with the STEM teacher shortage that we are experiencing in the United States.

What do you think? Do you think that this idea could work? Why or why not?

Are You Teaching Reading the Wrong Way?

Literacy is the most important skill that elementary school students can learn. Without the ability to read, it will be very difficult for a student to succeed in other academic subjects. Because of this, teachers cannot afford to make mistakes during reading instruction. The stakes are just that high. Prison officials calculate the number of cells that they will need based on the number of children that cannot read on grade level by 3rd grade. Think about that for a moment.

Why do they do it? Because if you cannot read on grade level by 3rd grade, you are at a very high risk of falling behind academically. If you can not read the subject matter presented to you, chances are you won’t be able to succeed academically. You will never catch up, and eventually, you will probably drop out, and end up in the school to prison pipeline. All because your reading ability never quite caught up with your grade level.

How can teachers help?

Teachers who are “reading” this need to ask themselves, am I teaching reading the wrong way? If you are, you could be setting your students up for a lifetime for failure. To find out, answer these questions honestly, and use your responses to inform your practice.

Am I using a balanced approach?

A balanced approach is a pedagogical method that emphasizes different aspects of literacy instruction at different stages appropriate to students’ needs. It is important to realize that there is no one way to teach reading. So, if you are using a one size fits all approach, you need to stop immediately. Different students respond will to different methods and strategies. Also, students will pass through the various stages of literacy development at a pace that is developmentally appropriate for them.

Am I utilizing best practices?

Educators have been teaching students to read since humans began writing pictograms on cave walls. In modern times, we have researched and confirmed which methods of teaching reading work. Because of this, there are a multitude of methods, strategies, and resources that can be used for literacy instruction. The question is, have your methods of teaching reading been proven to work? If they have, keep up the good work. If they have not, consider researching evidence-based literacy practices and use those instead.

Is a bottom-up approach at the core of my reading instruction?

A bottom-up approach is a pedagogical method that emphasizes the subskills associated with reading and writing, as well as the testing for proficiency in those subskills. No matter what methods you use in literacy instruction, they need to be taught in the correct sequence to be effective. This simply means students learn the fundamentals first, then intermediate literacy skills, and then more advanced skills.

What did I miss? What questions should teachers ask themselves if they want to know if they are teaching reading the right way?

These Countries Offer Free College Education

While the amount of student debt in the United States rises to over 1.5 trillion dollars, several countries offer their citizens (and in some cases, foreigners) free college tuition. Those countries are:

Argentina, Austria, Brazil, Czech Republic, Denmark, Egypt, Finland, France, Germany, Greece, Iceland, Kenya, Luxembourg, Malaysia, Morocco, Norway, Panama, Poland, Scotland, Slovenia, Spain, Sweden, Turkey, Uruguay

Free tuition has been a hot debate in the United States for many years, with attention to the issue growing as the student loan debt crisis has worsened. Those that support the idea of providing free education to Americans believe that this policy will help lessen the severity of student loan debt. They also point to the fact that after the GI Bill was passed (the policy that allows veterans to attend college for free), nearly half of all college students in 1947 were veterans. This includes over a million highly-skilled workers such as doctors, engineers, accountants, three Supreme Court Justices, and three presidents. An estimated 40% of these veterans would not have been able to attend college if they did not have the funding of the GI Bill to support them.

There are US states that currently offer their residents free tuition for college. These include Oregon, Nevada, Arkansas, New Jersey, Maryland, Tennessee, New York, Rhode Island, Delaware, Kentucky, and Indiana. Most of these states provide “last dollar” programs – meaning that they will cover the remaining tuition balance after other means of financial aid and grants are exhausted. These programs also typically cover tuition costs for 2-year and vocational schooling. New York’s tuition program is unique in that it is the first to cover tuition for 4-year institutions like the City University of New York and the State University of New York without being tied to students’ academic performance.

There are some that question the viability of a national tuition-free program. For one, these tuition-free programs do not cover all the costs of higher education. For the majority of the existing programs, students are still required to pay for room and board and textbooks. The federal or state funding of education also implies an increase in taxes for our citizens.

While some may believe that higher education is a cause worthy of higher taxes, others don’t feel it is fair to have to pay to cover someone else’s tuition. Those opposed to this policy also worry that funds will be taken away from other government responsibilities, such as infrastructure and military funding. They also argue that by funding higher education, we are decreasing the worth of diplomas and giving students that would not succeed in college the opportunity to use funds to enroll just to drop out without a degree.

Teacher Pay: Which States Pay Teachers the Most and Least?

Being a teacher is hard work, but unfortunately, many teachers don’t get paid enough for what they do. The pay for an average teacher greatly varies based on which state you are in though, so which states pay teachers the most and the least?

The Average Teacher Salary

The salary of a teacher varies greatly based on experience and location, but overall the average salary of a teacher is lower than it should be. For new teachers, their salary is typically less than $40,000 a year. However, for all teachers combined, the median salary is about an average of around $60,477 for the 2017-2018 school year.

Each state has its own average, which varies based on which article or study you look at, but these averages by state can range anywhere from $40,000 to $85,000.

Here’s how the states ranked during the 2017-2018 school year:

  1. New York: $83,585
  2. California: $81,126
  3. Massachusetts: $79,710
  4. District of Columbia: $76,486
  5. Connecticut: $73,113
  6. New Jersey: $69,917
  7. Maryland: $69,761
  8. Alaska: $69,474
  9. Pennsylvania: $67,398
  10. Illinois: $66,778
  11. Rhode Island: $66,758
  12. Oregon: $63,143
  13. Michigan: $62,702
  14. Delaware: $60,484
  15. Wyoming: $58,578
  16. Vermont: $58,572
  17. Ohio: $58,000
  18. New Hampshire: $57,833
  19. Hawaii: $57,866
  20. Nevada: $57,812
  21. Minnesota: $57,782
  22. Iowa: $56,790
  23. Georgia: $56,329
  24. Wisconsin: $55,895
  25. Washington: $55,175
  26. North Dakota: $54,421
  27. Indiana: $54,846
  28. Nebraska: $53,473
  29. Texas: $53,167
  30. Kentucky: $52,952
  31. Montana: $52,776
  32. Colorado: $52,389
  33. Maine: $51,663
  34. Virginia: $51,265
  35. South Carolina, $51,027
  36. Tennessee: $50,900
  37. North Carolina: $50,861
  38. Kansas: $50,403
  39. Louisiana: $50,256
  40. Alabama: $50,239
  41. Idaho: $49,225
  42. Missouri: $49,208
  43. Arkansas: $49,017
  44. South Dakota: $47,944
  45. New Mexico: $47,839
  46. Florida: $47,721
  47. Arizona: $47,746
  48. Utah: $47,604
  49. Oklahoma: $45,678
  50. West Virginia: $45,642
  51. Mississippi: $43,107