Uncategorized

Public Attitudes Towards the Gifted: Myth and Reality

Gifted and talented students are defined as:

“Students, children, or youth who give evidence of high achievement capability in areas such as intellectual, creative, artistic, or leadership capacity, or in specific academic fields, and who need services and activities not ordinarily provided by the school to fully develop those capabilities. – The federal Elementary and Secondary Education Act”

However, that definition fails to highlight the day-to-day realities of what it truly means to be a gifted student in modern America. So, let’s discuss some commonly believed myths vs. realities.

Myth: Teachers love gifted students and favor them.

Reality: Research shows that gifted students are actually often less favored by their teachers.

Why this is a problem: Gifted students who are deemed “teacher’s pets” are subject to bullying and more.

Myth: Gifted kids love school.

Reality: There is a lot of evidence to suggest that gifted students feel misunderstood, sad, and unsupported in school.

Why this is a problem: Gifted students may not be getting the mental and emotional support that they need from their teachers.

Myth: Gifted students are boastful.

Reality: Research shows that gifted students often try to hide or deny abilities in social settings, especially with peers.

Why this is a problem: Children are less likely to want to be identified as gifted for fear of seeming conceited or arrogant.

Myth: Gifted children are highly sensitive and emotionally fragile.

Reality: There is no evidence to support this stereotype – which persists even amongst educators.

Why this is a problem: This is obviously troubling because being gifted somehow has become correlated in society with being fragile emotionally which causes kids not to want to be identified as such and teachers to regard them as different and difficult to deal with.

Myth: Gifted students are inherently different from their peers.

Reality: Many factors contribute to giftedness, and gifted children are not dissimilar from their peers, aside from their unique abilities.

Why it is a problem: Gifted students are treated differently and should not be.

Myth: Gifted students all go on to be doctors, lawyers, and/or wildly successful.

Reality: There is a disparity between childhood giftedness and adult eminence.

Why this is a problem: This assumption leads to a wide array of problems and causes kids to feel bad when they do not feel that they meet expectations. Moreover, it keeps change in gifted education from happening.

Myth: Giftedness is all about ability.

Reality: Ability is necessary, but not sufficient. Students need to be motivated and committed and must be given appropriate resources from teachers.

Why this is a problem: Teachers and parents often leave gifted kids to “fend for themselves” when they require support.

Myth: Gifted and talented programs are highly funded, and educators focus a lot of energy toward these students.

Reality: Gifted students are not protected in the ways that children with disabilities are. That is to say that if they are not appropriately challenged, there is no legal recourse as there would be if a disabled child did not get his or her needs met. The funding and interest in such programs are actually quite low, as well.

Why it is a problem: Gifted students need protections in place, and the lack of funding and research has led to lackluster programs that aren’t developing children to become successful adults.

Myth: Gifted students don’t need to be taught, and everything is effortless for them.

Reality: Gifted children who excel typically do work very hard and have high levels of commitment. They are not just effortlessly brilliant.

Why it is a problem: Students do not feel appreciated or understood, and their commitment and hard work is dismissed as “natural talent.”

What does it mean to be gifted? How do we decide who is “gifted?” Aren’t we all gifted in our own ways? How do we define and identify giftedness? It is an abstract concept. There is no doubt about that.  But, when we dispel myths, we get one step closer to fully understanding.

School Administrator Must Reads for Personalized Learning Communities

Fewer than 40 percent of graduating students scored at college- and career-ready levels in recent years. – National Assessment of Educational Progress

Successfully implementing personalized learning has never been more important. Jobs are becoming more highly skilled, and students must be prepared to think critically. To ready kids for what is to come, teachers more and more must become facilitators of learning – rather than instructors who simply give information.

 The most effective instructors in personalized learning programs have a true understanding that all students can, and will, learn given what they need. These teachers have high expectations of their students and don’t settle. They are comfortable taking on the role of “instructional facilitator” rather than a lecturer.

Unfortunately, by no fault of their own, many teachers’ experience in the classroom and education are not in line with that type of facilitation. The need for professional development in this area is huge. Making the leap to personalized instruction will take time and commitment. This type of teaching and learning is hugely different from more traditional teaching methods.

Personalized learning is designed to meet the educational needs of all types of learners. The main goal is the optimization of learning for each and every student. Flexibility in the amount of time students are allowed to master concepts is a key difference. This is because the emphasis is on mastery of skills rather than how long kids sit in the classroom. Therefore, changes must be made both throughout the district as well as the school.

In short, the changes that must be made are wide-ranging and vast. But, they are doable and have been done many times before. If you are interested in implementing this kind of learning in your school community,  here are three amazing must-reads for principals looking to create a personalized learning community:

This e-book entitled “The Ultimate Personalized Learning Guide” is a resource full of the “nuts and bolts” of the personalized learning and how to implement this type of learning in your school community.

Schools that Learn by Peter Senge is all about changing the way we educate America’s kids.  It is “…a rich, much-needed remedy for the standardized, assembly-line, industrial-age institutions that comprise too much of our school system today. Chock full of useful tools, ideas, and exercises, this book is ideal for the many teachers and parents who are intent on resurrecting and fostering students’ innate drive to learn. An essential resource.” (Daniel H. Pink, author of DRIVE and A WHOLE NEW MIND)

Designing Personalized Learning for Every Student by Dianne Ferguson, Cleo Droege, Hafdís Guðjónsdóttir, Jackie Lester, Gwen Meyer, Ginevra Ralph, Nadia Sampson, and Janet Williams challenges schools to reimagine schools as more flexible communities. It offers tips for creating a school environment that is responsive to the broadest range of student diversity.

Do you have a book recommendation for personalized learning? We would love to hear about it. Leave us a review in the comments!

Protecting Brains, Stimulating Minds: The Early Life Roots of Success in School

Early childhood education is sometimes dismissed as unimportant – or at the very least considered far less essential than later education in primary and secondary school. The truth, however, is that early education and learning might just be some of the most essential learning children ever do.

In recent years, the education community has begun to call for evidence-based curricula and a better grasp on the science of early learning. A plethora of research on the biology of stress provides strong evidence that healthy development can be slowed or halted due to excessive activation of stress response systems in a child’s body and/or brain.

There are 3 Types of Stress Responses

Positive stress responses are totally normal. In fact, they are an integral part of development and learning. These responses are brief – something like an increase in heart rate when coming in contact with a stressor. Stressors might be things like getting a shot or the first day of school.

The next type of stress is tolerable stress. This type of stress activates the body’s stress systems to a higher degree than a  positive response. It is often a result of more severe, longer-lasting stressors like a natural disaster or frightening injury. , such as the loss of a loved one, a natural disaster, or a frightening injury. As long as the stress response is of a limited length, and the child has the support of adults, he or she will recover from what might otherwise have had extremely detrimental consequences to the developing brain.

 

The final type of stress is toxic stress. This is often due to negative childhood experiences that create frequent and extreme stress. Types of trauma that may cause toxic stress are: physical or emotional abuse, chronic neglect, parental substance abuse, mental illness in the family, exposure to violence, family financial hardship. When kids are not given enough adult support, toxic stress can derail the development of the brain and other organ systems. These children also possess an increased risk of stress-related disease and cognitive impairment. These issues are likely to follow them throughout the lifespan.

Toxic Stress’ Long-Term Effects

A fully evidence-based approach to the curriculum of early learning must include strategies to prevent toxic stress as an experience of toxic stress at a young age can cause lifelong problems in learning, development, and behavior. It is not hard to imagine why prolonged and/or extreme stress could affect a small child’s ability to develop and learn. The question, then, is “What types of tactics can be used to reduce or eliminate this type of stress?’

Check out this awesome video from the Harvard Center on the Developing Mind to learn all about what experts believe are the best practices to protect and stimulate young minds:

Did you learn a lot? It is an incredibly informative and interesting video, so please be sure to share your thoughts, comments, or questions with us. The commitment to creating truly wonderful and edifying early childhood experiences requires a broader and deeper view of childhood and an appreciation for the beauty and value of preschool learning.

Keeping Kids with Developmental Differences Safe

When working with students with disabilities and differences, professionals must take specific steps to foster a sense of respect and community in which other students are helpful and kind toward children with differences. There are many ways in which teachers need to keep disabled students safe, but those are often personalized to the child and will require one-on-one time as well as conversations with parents.

However, one very important and simple way to keep “different” kids safe is by having open and honest conversations about what it means to be different. Being different can be a wonderful thing, and we are all different in one way or another. Framing differences carefully can help both “typical” and “different” kids understand and embrace difference.

Here are some ideas for talking to kids about developmental differences: When talking to preschoolers, give brief and direct (and honest) answers. However, do not add your own feelings or interpretations. For example, do not tell them how being different must feel because you will be planting ideas in the young child’s mind about other people’s inner worlds – which you cannot know about.

Here are some simple ways to talk about differences:

  • Lucy sees a specialist twice a week because she has trouble saying the “r” sound.
  • Matthew uses a wheelchair because he was born without the use of his legs.
  • Donna does not use words to speak, so we find other ways to communicate with her.

Perhaps the most important lesson to teach young children is that staring, pointing, laughing, or mocking other students is wholly unacceptable and that they may come to you with questions privately.

When having conversations with older primary school kids, encourage the children to focus on similarities rather than differences. These older children will likely pick up on less obvious developmental differences or disabilities. For example, they may notice a classmate whose behavior is unusual.

Encourage honest discussion but focus on the many ways in which the child is no different from his classmates. Remember to use language that puts the person first before their disability. Lucy is not speech impaired, she has a bit of trouble with speech. Matthew is not wheelchair bound, he has some trouble walking. Donna is not nonverbal, she uses other means to communicate.

For example:

  • Lucy has trouble with speech sometimes, but she loves to write poems… just like you!
  • Matthew cannot use his legs, but he loves to shoot hoops on the playground. Have you ever asked him to play?
  • Donna cannot use words to communicate, but she dances beautifully, and that is her way of expressing herself. Do you like to dance?

Aside from these important conversations, it is vital that all professionals understand the differences in their students and how to serve them best. For example, does your nonverbal student need a whistle when on the playground so that he or she can let you know they need you? Do you have a “runner” in your class? Be sure to consider how you can keep him or her safe on field trips. 

In short, be aware and respectful. These students need patience and kindness more than anyone. Keep your students safe by keeping them enmeshed with your class community and by fostering acceptance of diversity amongst their peers.

Race, Education, and Social Mobility: Why Pre-K Matters for Children of Color

What do you think of when you think about preschool? Naps and snacks and playing on the playground? Storytime, lunch, and coloring books? Do you think of it as an important educational milestone or as a free-for-all for little ones?

If you are like a lot of people, you probably don’t place as much value on early childhood education as it deserves. You likely grew up in a time when Kindergarten fulfilled many of the needs that are now reserved for preschool.

In the last couple of decades, Kindergarten has changed. Dramatic play centers, costumes, and puppet shows have been replaced by rigorous learning, testing, and academic work. Kindergarteners today are expected to do far more than you probably were.

Because of this shift in elementary school, early childhood education is now wildly crucial for academic success. This is because preschool is all about learning how to learn and how to function in a school setting. It is where kids will develop their attitudes toward school and teachers and where kids practice social skills. 

It cannot be emphasized enough that small children’s “play” is essential to their learning. It is how they assimilate new information and try and figure out where they fit in this big world. Kids running around in costumes are not simply enjoying revelry.  Playing dress up is all about becoming creative, considering career paths, working on self-awareness and body awareness, and much more.

Children of color

Kids from minority homes may start out with certain factors stacked against them. They might not live in a home where English is the native language. They may not have access to quality learning materials and books. Their parents may work longer hours or have less education themselves. Preschool attendance is also correlated with parental education level. Parents with higher education levels themselves are more likely to have their children enrolled in an early childhood program.

Compared to their Caucasian peers, Black and Latino children are about a year behind their counterparts in math and reading.  They often enter Kindergarten at a considerable disadvantage. This gap can cause lifelong disparities.

Research has provided evidence that prioritizing early childhood education has lasting intergenerational effects on minority communities. It can help rectify inequities in society by giving children of color a “leg up.”

Becoming Socially Mobile

Being socially mobile is essential for minority kids because they must have opportunities to change their communities if real cultural change can be expected.

There is an unfortunate bias in America that stereotypes black children as being troublemakers. This also has grave effects on their education. Black boys are overwhelmingly more likely to be punished in preschool… and beyond. 

According to a recent report, black children make up about 20 % of preschoolers, but almost half of all out-of-school suspensions. Similar disparities across age groups. Another study showed that black male children are often punished more harshly because they are perceived as being much older than they actually are.

If we have hope for children of color to have upward mobility in society and find equity in our culture, then we must work diligently to see to it that they have access to education at all levels. However, a preschool with its foundational nature just might be the most important.

How To Solve The Segregation That Plagues Gifted-and-Talented Programs

The sad truth about the majority of gifted-and-talented programs throughout the United States is that there are thousands upon thousands of high-ability students from minority and disadvantaged backgrounds are excluded from these programs due to a multitude of factors. This fact was highlighted with disappointing clarity in a recent study by Raj Chetty, Alex Bell and others at the Equality of Opportunity Project. The study laments the “lost Einsteins” from minority and disadvantaged backgrounds who are left out of gifted-and-talented programs due to such factors as residential segregation and exposure to these programs via family and neighborhood.

By taking a look at the quality of the schools where those with disadvantaged and minority backgrounds study, along with the education opportunities available at these schools, we can see a clear gap which has left many low-income children out in the cold. Gifted-and-talented programs tend to thrive in middle- to high-income educational environments, and there needs to be a concerted shift in approach and available opportunities to bring low-income “Einsteins” to the table.

The illusion of equal opportunity 

The structure of our current education system either cannot or won’t put in the resources necessary to develop and nurture the potential of thousands of students from modest backgrounds. The degree of this structural rift was detailed in a recent Fordham study, highlighted by the sheer dearth of disadvantaged students (especially from African-American or Latino households) who make it into gifted-and-talented programs.

This lack of representation happens in all gifted-and-talented programs regardless of the financial health of the school. Schools in lower-income neighborhoods still show a wide proliferation of gifted-and-talented programs, but enrollments are typically low at these programs and still tend to lack representation when it comes to talented students from disadvantaged and minority backgrounds. 

What can we do to narrow the gaps?

To avoid “excellence gaps” between the top achievers at educational institutions separated by financial circumstance and overall availability of opportunities, there must be a paradigm shift in how we approach schooling across the board and give everyone a fighting chance at being included in the top gifted-and-talented programs there are to offer. Universal-screening practices which screen all students across the board for the potential to benefit from gifted services is one recommendation which has been made by researchers who have studied these excellence gaps.

Using such a screening process will help identify students from all backgrounds who can maximize the societal and true return from the best gifted-and-talented programs out there. With that in place, school systems could help bridge the diversity gap by identifying high achievers on a school-by-school basis, rather than by district. This would be a fantastic systemic shift which will operate under the assumption that all schools, regardless of socioeconomic status, have potential top achievers in their ranks. Working under this assumption, we can give students from minority and disadvantaged backgrounds a fair shake and eliminated the structural segregation which does a disservice to our nation’s schools and gifted-and-talented programs.

How We Could Radically Rethink The Core Curriculum In Higher Education

The rise of so-called “soft skills” has rendered the general education requirements of colleges and universities across the United States virtually useless when it comes to priming students for the job markets they will encounter once school is over. Hard-to-define skills such as communication and problem-solving are at the top of most major companies’ hiring wish lists, so it behooves higher education institutions to create new a core curriculum which cultivates these skills. 

By building a Liberal Arts core which adapts to a rapidly-changing media culture, shifts the focus to a more civic-minded approach, and finds a way to integrate journalism at every potential turn, we can both help businesses find workers with the right set of tools for their needs and help students sharpen said tools to be better assets in the workforce. 

Why our current curriculum needs overhauling 

The current state of general education in colleges and universities offers an unfocused and inconsistent array of disciplines and classes which are decades behind the curve when it comes to giving students what they need for both a fulfilling four years in school and careers afterward. Not only that, but a recent report indicates that students who fulfill the requirements for a college degree are becoming less and less motivated to engage in civic-minded activities which function for the betterment of the community – be it niche or global. 

A Bachelor’s degree or more isn’t a guarantee that a citizen will put their experience to use in the greater community, even when it comes to voting. In fact, there may not be much difference between those who do garner degrees and those who don’t which it comes to civic engagement. Changing the core curriculum to focus more on the community on a macro and micro scale while invigorating it with a sense of relevance to the rapidly-changing culture gives us the opportunity to motivate a greater number of college students towards looking outside themselves for the greater good.

What would a new core curriculum look like?

One huge centerpiece of a new core curriculum which could benefit students, colleges, and businesses alike would be media literacy – defined as, per the National Association for Media Literacy Education, the proficiency and skills it takes to properly and effectively analyze, evaluate, create and act using all forms of communication. With journalism’s role in a democratic society being so pivotal, along with the ethical questions which arise daily from its proliferation on social media and elsewhere, such a core discipline would be a critical start.

From there, we could build other disciplines which bring the core curriculum into the present with vital force and import – disciplines centered on such things as data fluency, citizenship in a new digital age, social and personal wellness, global communication, and the power of information within politics and global markets. There are many other correlative disciplines which could be created to fit a new core curriculum, all with the express purpose of giving students the proper education necessary to survive and thrive in a changing world and job market.

Promoting Multisensory Learning Experiences That Benefit All Brains

No two kids learn in the same way, and the ability to cater to their primary learning modalities is a key way to ensure that you are hitting as many little brains as is possible.

What’s a learning modality, you ask?

A learning modality is how students employ sensory information to learn new information.  Some people have one predominant modality. Others have a combination between two or three of them.

There are three basic modalities:

  1. Visual students learn from seeing 
  1. Auditory learners learn from hearing 
  1. Kinesthetic students learn from touching, doing & moving

Some experts also add “tactile” to the list but, for the purposes of this article, we will keep it simple with the 3 main types of learning.

The following chart outlines the characteristics of the learning modalities so you can look for them in your students.

Characteristics of Learning Modalities

Auditory learners…

  • are talkative
  • talk to themselves aloud (especially when studying or reading)
  • enjoy music
  • are great with names
  • can be easily distracted
  • hum or sing often

Visual learners…

  • like to read
  • spell well
  • have nice handwriting
  • find verbal instructions difficult to understand or follow

Kinesthetic learners…

  • dress for comfort rather than style
  • tap feet or pencils when ready or studying
  • touch people during conversation
  • do not like to read
  • are poor spellers
  • enjoy physical rewards
  • express emotions physically

Children are too often expected to rely on their visual skills and sight to look and read information. Hearing is sometimes integrated when teachers speak. However, multisensory learning is much more than that.

Multisensory teaching attempts to employ all of the senses. It is not possible that every single lesson will use all of a child’s senses but engaging in at least more than one way is the goal.  In multisensory teaching, the instructor shares information through as many senses as possible.

Here are a few examples…

Suggested Aids for Learning Modalities

Visual learners may benefit from….

  • note-taking
  • mind maps
  • acrostics
  • color codes
  • flashcards

Auditory learners may enjoy…

  • discussion
  • rhythmic sounds
  • theatre
  • mnemonics
  • rhymes and poems

Kinesthetic learners will like…

  • walking as they read
  • dancing
  • role play
  • stretch breaks

It is essential to note, however, that teachers shouldn’t build in a sensory activity for the sake of adding it but to rotate through the modalities as they make sense in the context of the subject matter. You want to keep the instruction varied and exciting but don’t throw in a movement activity (for example) for no good reason. It is also essential not to instill any concrete ideas into kids’ heads about what type of learner they are. This can limit their growth and development.

When done right, multisensory instruction helps kids tap into their learning strengths because it allows them to make connections and form memories in their own way. It also allows them to utilize a variety of ways to demonstrate mastery over what they’ve learned.

Multisensory teaching, at its heart,  takes into account that all students learn in different ways, and it helps meet the varying needs of all kids.  Multisensory lessons allow every student to learn and succeed in your classroom.

How To Get The Teachers We Want

When you break down the success or failure of any educational institution, be it in the edtech or traditional sectors, it all boils down to the cost/effect ratio of the institution’s teaching staff and whether or not those teachers are connecting with and reaching students in such a way which produces the desired results and interactions. Budgets play a massive role in securing and retaining top teaching talent, as an inability to pay a worthwhile wage will drive good teachers away to other institutions who are able or willing to pay them what they are truly worth on the market.

However, there are ways to find and retain good teachers on your ledger regardless of your institution’s financial situation. While teachers are always looking for a higher pay scale (like anyone would in any particular field, they’re also looking for greater overall rewards and a working environment which makes their time and effort investment worth it. Building an environment which rewards the teacher emotionally and professionally is just as important as being able to provide the right numbers on their paychecks. 

You’re not just competing with other educational institutions

Talented people are talented people. Just because someone has a teaching certification doesn’t mean they’re married to teaching, especially if there is a related or peripheral field which can offer them better pay and overall quality of life. Per a recent study, the ability to staff and keep good teachers is very much dependent on how desirable the teaching profession itself is compared to other potential job opportunities on the overall market.

While you have major work to do convincing the right teachers to join your institutional ranks, you also have work to do convincing talented people to stay within the teaching profession itself and not ply their trade in other fields which could potential pay more or offer a set of overall rewards which outstrips their perception of the teaching field itself. Only the most focused and ethically aggressive hiring strategies are able to work on both sides of this fence, getting the best talent to work for them regardless of whatever other job opportunities lie out there.

So, how do you get the right people in such circumstances?

If you have sufficient financial backing, you’ve got to pay your teachers the right ethical wage for the work they’ll be doing. One of the key criticisms which arise among teachers either switching jobs or wavering over their commitment to the profession is overall dissatisfaction with salary. 55% of public school teachers in a recent study expressed overall displeasure with their wages. Those numbers vary based on the type of institution, but the fact remains that lower pay (or the perception of it) leads to a lack of top talent vying for these jobs and/or being available in the first place.

The other huge key is simply to listen to your teachers and teachers in similar institutions. Find Twitter chats and educational Facebook groups where these teachers go to vent about their current circumstances. Most are looking for support systems which listen to their concerns and help them hone their craft while carrying out the requirements of the job. Also, look into alternative teacher education programs to find talented teachers who may have been unwittingly marginalized and taken off your radar. The way to secure and keep the best teaching talent is to give them a job environment which compensates them fairly and addresses their concerns either before or as they arise. If you can do that, you’ll have a leg up in getting the right teachers for the right jobs.

If We Started From Scratch What Would Schools Look Like?

Debates rage on about the quality of our public school system in the United States, with a wide variety of opinions on the matter range from “our schools are broken” to “our schools are the best in the world.” In truth as with most things, the actuality of things lies somewhere in the middle. One unifying concern among critics of the public school system is that, at its core, it is antiquated and fails to properly prepare students for the rigors of higher education or the job market.

So, hypothetically, what would happen if we decided to blow apart the public school system and start from scratch? What would schools look like? How would a core curriculum set itself up? What would the face of education look like if we wiped all vestiges of the old system off the map and replaced it?

A student-centered school

One K-8 public school in San Diego, California has taken on this challenge on a micro-scale. The mission of Poway Unified School District’s 39th school, Design 39 Campus is to create an environment less predicated on the systemic aspects of other public schools and much more focused on creating a nurturing environment for students and teachers alike. Using research done on schools around the United States, guidance from educational leaders, and the thoughts of local residents, the school is thinking outside of the box by giving students more say in their school days, giving teachers more power to make decisions on lesson plans, and even has erased the concept of a principal’s office.

There’s also a huge predication on technology and the role it plays in both leisure and education for students. Proponents of this argument that we can take some of the traditions and existing knowledge base from our current public school system, but retool them and rethink them to be malleable to new developments in technology and how information is accessed. With the proliferation of smartphones, keeping education up to speed with what students are seeing daily in that arena could help to increase student engagement across the board.

Other ideas to push public schools into the future

Another way to look at things when it comes to the idea of starting our school system from scratch is to focus the natural evolution already happening in public schools and pushing ahead of the curve. A key aspect is the belief of many that traditional education’s current hierarchy of top-down, do-what-you’re-told teaching heavy on texts and reading is already primed for an overhaul.

Rather than building new schools in the image of old schools which utilized this approach, new schools could be on the cutting edge and embrace innovation in all of its myriad forms. In short, teachers and administration members of these new public schools would be tasked with quickly adapting to trends in  learning and learning efficiency, bucking the current bureaucratic slowness of changing lesson plans and directions in favor of a more fluid approach which takes students’ concerns and performance into account with much more efficiency and systemic innovation.