Uncategorized

How to Talk to Your Children about Racism and Social Injustice, Part 1

Like other Americans, I was disheartened and moved to tears on August 12, 2017 after awaking to images of hate groups carrying torches in Charlottesville, Virginia as a part of a “Unite the Right” rally, which was comprised of white nationalists and other right-wing groups. They were gathered in Charlottesville, Virginia to protest the city’s plan to remove symbols and statues linked to its Confederate past.

As the day waged on, the protesters clashed with counter-protestors and 32-year-old Heather Heyer was killed, and 19 others were injured, when a car deliberately crashed into a group of peaceful counter-protestors.

Since that day in August, all of America has been dealing with the trauma of that violent weekend in Charlottesville, Virginia. We know that these events left adults dazed and perplexed — so imagine how our children feel. It’s moments like those that children need their parents to have a crucial conversation with them about an uncomfortable topic: racial tension and violence in America.

As an African American man and father of a nine-month-old boy, I was relieved to know that I didn’t have to facilitate this crucial conversation with him just yet, but I know that one day I will. Research shows that kids as young as two-years old are keenly aware of racial injustice, so that day is quickly approaching for me.

What about parents with school-aged children, though? They don’t have the luxury of putting these types of discussions off. How do they explain to their children that we live in an imperfect world, where tragedies like this happen quite frequently? How do they protect their children’s innocence and sense of safety while empowering them to stay safe?

Though I’m new to parenting, I’m not new to working with children. At this point, I realized that my background in child development and PreK-12 education was needed. I decided to pen a 2-part series that guides parents through the steps of helping their children to process traumatic events that involve the themes of race and social justice. In Part 1, I will discuss how to prep for and have the conservation.

Prepping for the Conversation

Before you talk to your kids about traumatic events involving race and social justice, make sure that you have conversations with people of different races and perspectives to gain a fuller understanding of the issue. By doing this, you will gain greater insight into the big picture of it all, and as a result, frame the discussion appropriately. There is no way that you can educate your children about something that you don’t fully understand yourself. Trust me, your kids will have plenty of questions, and they are expecting you to provide the answers.

If your own circle of friends includes people who are like you, look online for resources. Read a few articles from a different perspective or visit the Twitter feeds of people who represent a different background than you and see what things they share.

If you are initiating the conversation in response to a situation that your child may have faced directly, you need to be prepared. Make sure that you are ready to share resources that they can use for support when they are in a crisis. This includes providing them with strategies that they can use to navigate their environment safely. This is an especially poignant point for parents of color.

Having the Conversation

Make sure that you initiate the conversation in an environment that is free from distractions. When having crucial conversations about controversial topics with kids, you want to start off by finding out what they already know. A simple question such as, “What have you heard about what happened?” should suffice. Based on what they say, you can correct any misinformation, and supplement what they already know with additional details.

Help them activate their higher-order thinking skills by asking them questions like, “Do you have any idea why this occurred?” and “What are your thoughts on the matter?” Don’t forget to allow them to ask their own questions, as they are sure to have plenty. Allow them to express their thoughts openly and validate their feelings. It’s also acceptable to tell them how you feel and what your reaction is to an event or issue. However, when doing so, remain calm. Children are less likely to overact if you convey a mood of tranquility and security.

Well, that’s it for Part 1. In Part 2, I will discuss specific strategies that you can use to discuss racism and social justice with your children.

Click here to access both parts of the series.

How to Talk to Your Children about Racism and Social Injustice, Part 2

In this 2-part series, we are discussing how to discuss racism and social justice with your children. In Part 1, we discussed how to prep for and have the conversation. In Part 2, I will discuss specific strategies that you can use to discuss racism and social justice with your children. Below I have listed some age-based suggestions for shaping your discussion.

Younger Children (4-9)

When talking to children about topics such as race and social justice, make sure that the language that you use is simple and easily digestible. Don’t fall into the trap of saying “We don’t see color.” That’s too vague, and just an excuse to avoid an uncomfortable conversation. All parents should tell their children that sometimes people are mistreated because of the color of their skin and that this type of behavior is wrong. They should be taught to never engage in this kind of activity.

Children should be taught that they should not be bystanders to bullying and racism and that if they observe it, they should tell an adult. Encourage young children, and all children for that matter, to be empathetic to people of all racial and ethnic backgrounds. You must be a role model for them by practicing what you preach and having a diverse group of friends.

If you are still struggling, there are several children’s books that cover themes such as anti-Racism, anti-Semitism, and things like the Nazi movement. You can read these books with your kids and then have a discussion afterward. I have listed several below.

Come With Me by Holly M. McGhee; Illustrated by Pascal Lamaitre (ages 4 and up)

The Whispering Town by Jennifer Elvgren; Illustrated by Fabio Santomauro (ages 5-8)

The Youngest Marcher by Cynthia Levinson; Illustrated Vanessa Brantley Newton (ages 5-9)

Older Children (10-18)

With older children, you can have in-depth conversations about the KKK, white supremacy, homophobia, and anti-Zionism. While discussing these issues with them, bear in mind that although they may understand most of what they are exposed to, they may not understand the historical themes at play.

If older children feel helpless after your talk, there’s an opportunity to help them understand how to be active citizens, and become the change that they want to see in the world. They can join a social justice organization at school or even start their own. They can engage with activists and policymakers to influence legislation. The possibilities are endless.

If you need additional help, there are several young adult books that cover themes such as anti-racism, anti-Semitism and other anti-discrimination. You can give them a week to read the book at their own pace, and then schedule a time to have a book club style discussion with them. I have listed several options below.

Stella By Starlight by Sharon Draper (ages 10-13)

March Trilogy by John Lewis, Andrew Aydin and Nate Powell (ages 10 and up)

We Will Not Be Silent by Russell Freedman (ages 10-14)

Other Considerations

One of the primary problems that white parents face when it comes to talking about racism and intolerance to their children is the psychological impact of such teaching.  With the knowledge of racism and the role played by people who look like them in perpetuating it, your kids could experience feelings of guilt and shame, especially if they have a diverse group of friends.

Since these are undesirable emotions, it is far easier for parents to avoid teaching their kids about racism and social justice, instead of dealing with the feelings that accompany a topic that will always be difficult to discuss. The key is to help your children fully understand racism and its societal implications and to promote feelings of allied relations as white, and minority groups fight racism hand in hand. This will offset the feelings of guilt and shame that accompany the realization of the fact that racism continues to exist.

Conclusion

Events like those that took place in Charlottesville are not isolated, and the conversation should not be either. Crucial conversations about race and social justice are bound to be awkward, but nonetheless, they must be had. We can’t pretend that racism, violence, or our country’s history don’t exist.

The goal of parents must be to help their children become respectful of other races, cultures, and people that they’ll interact with during their lifetimes. This can be a daunting task for parents, given that the world is infinitely more complex and diverse than the community that their kids inhabit. All we can do is prepare our children for the present and the future, and hope that our efforts are enough. If we all work together, we can shape the future into an era of inclusion and acceptance. And it starts with what we teach our children now. In the immortal words of George Santayana, “Those who do not learn from history are doomed to repeat it.”

Click here to access both parts of the series.

 

Why is the U.S. Education System Still Failing?

A couple of years ago, I wrote a piece for my “Education Futures” blog entitled 10 Reasons the U.S. Education System Is Failing (Lynch, 2015). In it, I listed ten problems and issues that prevent the U.S. education system from living up to its potential. Even years later, this post still periodically shows up as one of the top-read blog posts of the day on www.edweek.org.

Because of this, Education Week thought it would be interesting to revisit this list in some way, and I wholeheartedly agreed. Since most of the reasons that I listed in the original piece still ring true, I decided not to rehash them. Instead, I decided to create a new list that discusses newly emerging problems and issues with the U.S. Education system. Without further ado, let’s get started.

  1. In this digital age, we need to rethink literacy. Historically, literacy referred to print texts, but it’s becoming increasingly complex as we transition to a digital age. To accommodate this generational shift, educators need to start incorporating curriculum that covers digital literacy. Beyond basic reading and writing, students should be able to use technology to conduct research and make their own judgments about what they read. Without these skills, students will be left behind in our digital age.
  2. The way we currently assess students is not working. The current testing system does not accurately measure the progress of individual students. In our digital age, we should be searching for testing options that can implement technology, gather information, and account for the differences among students who take the assessments. The initial cost outlay could be substantial, but we owe it to our students to create a fair testing system to help deliver brighter minds for the future.
  3. We do a poor job of educating boys of color. Black and Latino boys have consistently been a misunderstood demographic in America’s schools. Their behavior, learning styles, and social skills are often misconstrued as problems. Until this situation is remedied, boys of color will continue to slip through the cracks. They have higher dropout rates, poverty, and incarceration compared to their peers, and perhaps the education system is partly to blame (The Sentencing Project, n.d.).
  4. We continue to retain and socially promote students. The U.S. education system retains students at astronomical rates. The cost is outlandish at approximately $20 billion annually (Williams, 2007), even though research shows that holding children back has little effect on their academic achievement. Social promotion also poses a problem, as students will struggle to meet academic standards without extraordinary intervention (Hong and Yu, 2008).
  5. Anti-intellectualism and academic disengagement are running rampant. In this digital age, students are accustomed to instant gratification. In response, school districts water down academic standards to keep students on an equal footing, but the result is academic disengagement. Traditional education is undermined by this growing anti-intellectualism. Today’s students are less inclined to pursue academic achievement if it bears no direct effect on their daily lives.
  6. Why aren’t there more year-round schools? Most schools in America maintain the antiquated system of granting students the summer off, even though the economic reason no longer exists (Morin 2016). Unfortunately, the solid evidence that a switch to year-round schooling would improve our academic system is ignored because it’s too challenging make a change. Teachers and policymakers alike would have to agree to switch up the status quo to accommodate this drastic shift in scheduling.
  7. We are not able to consistently produce quality teachers. A child’s education is highly dependent upon the instruction they receive. The reality is straightforward: not all teachers entering the classroom have enough training and experience to foster student learning. A strong teacher is an invaluable classroom tool, but we have yet to discover what it takes to produce strong educators with any degree of consistency.
  8. We are not doing enough to foster digital equity. In the modern age, technology is an essential part of the world and academics. Students from wealthier backgrounds have greater access to the internet and technology in general than their impoverished counterparts. The result is that wealthy students end up ahead and another barrier is constructed for schools with high poverty rates. Digital equity could eliminate this gap and provide a more level playing field.
  9. We are not doing enough to get girls involved with STEM. Even with Beyoncé’s famous statement that “girls run the world,” there are still plenty of academic fields where females are under-represented. The booming STEM industry is primarily male-dominated with few opportunities for young girls to join. The issue is not a lack of interest but a lack of encouragement for girls to enter these fields or study the subjects at school. We must find new ways to promote STEM subjects to girls and help them foster a love for the mechanical and chemical.
  10. Teacher preparation programs don’t teach neuroscience. Most teacher preparation programs focus exclusively on education instead of providing a more holistic view. Truly great educators need to understand neuroscience to grasp how the brain and nervous system work fully. It can help educators to better understand how the brain learns new information and how stronger neural pathways are formed. Even the most basic understanding of neuroscience could influence and improve the way teachers perform in the classroom.

Conclusion

The underachievement of the U.S. education system is not the result of one problem. It is the confluence of issues that undercut the cultural importance of education equity and broad-based intellect. To achieve better results, we must put aside partisan politics and petty policy disagreements and try to improve the U.S. education system, no matter what. I am overjoyed that my last piece has resonated with my readers, and I hope this installment will also strike a chord. Now, let’s get to work.

References

Hong, G. & B. Yu. (2008). Effects of Kindergarten Retention on Children’s Social-Emotional Development: An Application of Propensity Score Method to Multivariate Multi-Level Data. Special Section on New Methods in Developmental Psychology, 44(2), 407–421.

Lynch, M. (2015, August 27). 10 Reasons the U.S. Education System Is Failing. Education Week. Retrieved from

http://blogs.edweek.org/edweek/education_futures/2015/08/10_reasons_the_us_education_system_is_failing.html

Morin, Amanda. (2017, October 19). The Pros and Cons of Year-Round Schooling. Child Parenting. Retrieved from http://childparenting.about.com/od/schoollearning/a/year-round-school-pros-cons.htm

The Sentencing Project. (n.d.). Racial Disparity. Retrieved from http://www.sentencingproject.org/template/page.cfm?id=122

Williams, D. L. (2007). Perspectives of Urban Parents Towards Student Grade Retention in Schools. Doctoral dissertation, The University of Wisconsin-Milwaukee. Dissertation Abstracts International, 69, 59–60.

 

 

 

 

Dyscalculia, Dysgraphia, Dysnomia, Dyslexia, and Dyspraxia: What are the Differences?

In my past life as a special education teacher, I worked with a variety of special needs students. These students were all unique, and so were their learning disabilities. As experts in the field, special education teachers are charged with providing classroom teachers and education administrators with information about the disabilities that their students were faced with. Among my favorite learning disabilities to discuss were dyscalculia, dysgraphia, dysnomia, dyslexia, and dyspraxia. Why? Because they are the hardest disabilities to explain, and since I loved a challenge, I enjoyed taking these complex disabilities and making it easy for people to understand them. In this piece, I will discuss the learning disabilities of dyscalculia, dysgraphia, dysnomia, dyslexia, and dyspraxia.

What is Dyscalculia?

Dyscalculia is a learning disorder that is marked by an inability to learn foundational math skills. Many people with this disability can learn very advanced mathematics concepts and principles, but it is hard for them to process formulas or do elementary math computations. Many people with this disorder also struggle with visual-spatial relationships or processing what they hear. Dyscalculia can differ from person to person.

What is Dysgraphia?

Dysgraphia is a learning disability that is marked by difficulty in performing handwriting in addition to having issues with fine motor skills. People who suffer from dysgraphia have problems forming letters correctly, putting thoughts on paper, zipping a jack, tying their shoes, etc. Many students who suffer from dysgraphia often develop solid verbal skills to compensate for their handwriting issues. Because little research has been conducted on this learning disability, it is often misdiagnosed.

What is Dysnomia?

Dysnomia is a learning disability that is marked by difficulty in recalling words, names, numbers, etc. from memory. The real problem stems from the fact that the words that they can not remember are essential, as they are needed for oral or written expressive language. The person may provide a detailed description of the word in question but is unable to recall its exact name. Dysnomia is often misdiagnosed as expressive language disorder. If your child is exhibiting any of these symptoms, take them to see a neurologist as soon as you can.

What is Dyslexia?

Dyslexia is a reading disorder in which a learner has difficulty recognizing letters and learning letter sounds, despite normal intelligence. It decreases the processing of graphic symbols, especially those related to language. Children who have dyslexia may experience late language development and have problems learning how to write and spell when they enter formal schooling. Symptoms include poor literacy skills, reversed letter and word sequences, and poor handwriting. The good news is that if the student is diagnosed with dyslexia early enough, more than likely they will learn to read.

What is Dyspraxia?

Dyspraxia, which is also known as Apraxia, is a learning disability that is marked by difficulty in carrying out routines that require the use of balance, fine-motor skills, and coordination. Usually, we think of these children as merely being “clumsy” or “awkward.” Children with dyspraxia need to treated by an occupational therapist to strengthen their fine and gross motor skills. Verbal Dyspraxia describes a lowered ability to use speech sounds, which is usually the sign of a developmental delay. Verbal Dyspraxia can be separate from or accompany dyspraxia. Children with dyspraxia may also suffer from slightly slurred speech and short-term memory loss.

What did I miss?

 

 

 

 

 

Expressive and Receptive Language Disorders: What are They?

Children all learn language and speech using the same acquisition methods, but they do not always learn at the same pace. Some children pick up language early and mimic and understand everything you say. Others may not express themselves through speech and have trouble understanding. This is called a language disorder. There are two main types of language disorders, expressive and receptive. In this piece, we will discuss them both.

Expressive Language is the ability to wield vocabulary and weave words together into sentences to get your point across. It covers literacy and communication (asking for things, making comments, getting people’s attention). People with expressive language disorder have difficulty expressing their thoughts and ideas.

Receptive Language is the ability to understand what is being said to you. In childhood development, understanding usually happens before expressive language. People with receptive language disorder have difficulty understanding what other people are saying.

To help you better understand expressive and receptive language disorders, we have included an informational video below.

How to Teach Your Children to Obtain Real Knowledge

Our children will never know the pain of having to hoof it to the library to use a giant set of encyclopedias for a school project or research paper. Everything they need to look up is possible, literally at their fingertips. Access to answers so quickly has made so many things easier in life, for parents and kids, but it comes at a cost. It can be difficult to determine what is accurate, what is opinion, and what is plain false when it comes to available information. And if adults have trouble deciphering it all, imagine the difficulty level for children.

The mismatch of knowledge became apparent during the recent Presidential election. President-elect Donald Trump pointed fingers at the media, calling it biased and untruthful. Democratic nominee Hillary Clinton scolded conservative media outlets that claimed to be middle-of-the-road – saying they are anything but moderate. Facebook saw a slew of fake news stories and sites pop up, some of which received more traffic and engagement than established media sites like The Washington Post and The New York Times. Following the election results, fake news writer Paul Horner admitted that he thought it was probably his fault that Donald Trump was elected.

False information not only exists – but people consume it and accept it as truth.

Given this context, how can we as parents raise children who are thinkers and able to determine what is truth, and what is a smoke screen? As you look in on your children’s learning, here are a few skills you really should be teaching them from a young age.

How to use real books

It’s true that digital information is abundant, but it’s important that our kids learn how to open, decipher, and absorb the content of real books. The books on library shelves are important, not just as historical relics, but as an active part of the current reading climate. This appreciation for books should start when your children are still small enough to look through picture ones while they sit on your lap. A child who has respect for physical books will be more likely to seek them out when it’s time to learn something new.

How to go beyond one click

If nothing else, kids should know this one thing about research and the internet: one source is never enough! To find the real truth takes many, many sources and plenty of reading, and re-reading. As your kids research topics, they may find opposing views and this is a good thing. It gives them a chance to see several sides of an issue and if it isn’t fact based, they can form their own opinion based on what they’ve read. Real, factual information will have more than one source stating it.

How to sort out what they read online

Not everything found on the internet is created equal. The fake news explosion is proof of this. People can and will post whatever they want – and our kids need to be aware of that fact. There are things to look for on sites to tell if they are trustworthy. Head to a few government sites and big-name news outlets and show your kids around. Then head to an opinion-based blog and point out the differences. You should also find a large site that offers sponsored content and show them how to spot it. While there is some truth in advertising, there is also a lot of bias.

How to have an online (moral) compass

It’s easier than ever to cheat, and that’s just a difficult truth. When kids are doing math homework, they can use phone calculators and online algorithms to find their answers. They can look up notes and summaries on the books they are reading and skip over the actual reading portion. They can send answers to friends via text and email. Just because they CAN do these things doesn’t mean that they should. That may seem obvious to us as parents but the ethical code of today’s generation isn’t always straightforward. Finding an answer online may not even seem like cheating to some kids who have been taught to “Google” everything. Parents have to state the obvious though. Finding answers in a way that is not sanctioned by a teacher or parent is cheating. Sharing information with friends instead of allowing those friends to find it themselves is also cheating.

How to stay safe

There are so many tools at parents’ disposal for keeping kids safe online but we can’t just set up privacy controls and call it a day. Part of teaching our kids how to obtain real knowledge is teaching them how to protect themselves when we aren’t around. Kids need freedom to flex their online muscles, without parents always looking over their shoulders, but that means we have to talk with them about the potential dangers of cyberspace. Kids need to feel comfortable telling their parents about anything they see online that makes them uncomfortable. If you’ve already told them what some of those things may be, then they won’t feel as awkward telling you. What does this have to do with vetting information online? When our kids can spot things that are “off” in digital spaces, they are demonstrating the skill of awareness to what they are reading and absorbing.

If we want to continue our nation’s path toward legitimate learning and growth, we have to help our kids obtain real knowledge in a misinformation saturated world. That takes work on the part of parents, but it’s good work because it will pay off in a more aware and informed next generation. Our kids will have to work harder than we ever did to obtain knowledge, even though it would seem at first that they have it easier. The overabundance of information available to them means they have a bigger responsibility to find, and defend, the truth. As parents, we can help them learn how to seek out knowledge for themselves – and get them on board with vetting information, instead of simply consuming it.

 

 

Teaching Your Children How to Protest Responsibly, Part 1

The United States has a storied history of using peaceful protests—including student protests—to affect change. American students have launched protests against the military draft, the Vietnam War, apartheid, the war in Iraq, school curriculum, and more.

Today, we’re seeing a new and unprecedented wave of student protests inspired by former NFL quarterback Colin Kaepernick. While student protests have historically been concentrated on college campuses, students as young as kindergarten have participated in the current movement by sitting or kneeling during the National Anthem and Pledge of Allegiance.

Much like Kaepernick’s original protest, these acts have caused controversy. Some students, particularly student-athletes, have faced disciplinary action for protesting. So what are students’ rights when it comes to protesting in schools? And how should parents respond to children who feel passionately about these issues? In this four-part series, we will discuss how parents can teach their children to protest responsibly. Let’s start with Part 1.

How Did the Protests Begin?

On August 26, 2016, then-San Francisco 49’ers quarterback Colin Kaepernick sat during the pre-game National Anthem. A photo was tweeted, and a massive debate ensued.

Kaepernick addressed the media two days later, explaining, “I am not going to stand up to show pride in a flag for a country that oppresses black people and people of color. To me, this is bigger than football, and it would be selfish on my part to look the other way. There are bodies in the street and people getting paid leave and getting away with murder.”

The quarterback’s assertion that he was making a statement about racial inequality and police brutality did nothing to calm the controversy, with many believing Kaepernick was disrespecting U.S. war veterans.

Throughout September and for the remainder of the season, other NFL players joined Kaepernick. Players kneeled, sat, linked arms, or raised fists to symbolize their support of the protest.

In March of 2017, Kaepernick opted out of his contract with the 49’ers, becoming a free agent. He has yet to be picked up by another team, with many alleging his protests are the reason. President Donald Trump tweeted, “NFL owners don’t want to pick [Kaepernick] up because they don’t want to get a nasty tweet from Donald Trump.”

President Trump added more fuel to the fire during a September speech in Alabama, commenting, “Wouldn’t you love to see one of these NFL owners, when somebody disrespects our flag, to say, ‘Get that son of a b**ch off the field right now. Out! He’s fired. He’s fired!’”

In response, many more NFL players joined the protest. Entire teams kneeled, sat, or linked arms. Some players wore T-shirts in support of Kaepernick, raised fists after scoring touchdowns, or continued warming up during the anthem. The Steelers, Seahawks, and Titans remained in the locker room for the duration of the anthem. Even team owners and those who sang the anthem joined in on the protests.

Well, that’s it for Part 1. In Part 2, we will discuss how students joined the NFL protest.

Click here to read all 4 parts of this series.

Teaching Your Children How to Protest Responsibly, Part 2

In this 4-part series, we are discussing how parents can teach their children to protest responsibly. In Part 3, we will discuss how students joined the NFL protests.

How Have Students Joined the Protest?

Soon, these protests of racial injustice filtered down to students as well. Student-athletes began sitting or kneeling as the National Anthem played before games, and students as young as six remained seated during the morning Pledge of Allegiance.

Responses from school administrators varied. While some schools asserted their students’ right to protest, many others threatened or dealt out punishment.

Some schools released statements or passed policies requiring students to stand during the National Anthem. Student-athletes faced the loss of playing time or removal from the team. These decisions were often appealed and revoked, but some student protestors continued to face death threats, including threats to use students as “target practice” or to “lynch” them.

A student in Chicago alleged that a teacher attempted to physically pull him from his chair when he would not stand during the pledge, while another student had her participation grade lowered for choosing to sit. Still, more students claimed they were sent to the principal’s office or sent home from school.

Well that’s it for Part 2. In Part 3, we will discuss students legal right to protest.

Click here to read all 4 parts of this series.

Teaching Your Children How to Protest Responsibly, Part 3

In this 4-part series, we are discussing how parents can teach their children to protest responsibly. In Part 3, we will discuss student’s legal rights, as it pertains to protesting.

What Are Students’ Legal Rights?

Are schools allowed to take disciplinary action against students who choose to protest peacefully? Do students’ First Amendment rights protect them at school?

Student Rights in the Classroom

For the most part, students do have the right to sit or kneel if they are not disrupting the operations of the school. Many of the disciplinary actions above were imposed by individual teachers, who were then reprimanded by their school districts. The National Council Against Censorship (NCAC) has written letters to schools, speaking out against policies that limit students’ freedom of expression.

The executive director of the American Civil Liberties Union of Louisiana, Marjorie Esman says, “The law does not permit schools to forbid students from expressing their views, and all schools should be on notice that these policies are in fact unconstitutional.”

Indeed, there is legal precedent for this situation. One Supreme Court case, in 1943, centered on a group of Jehovah’s Witnesses who had been expelled from school for not reciting the Pledge of Allegiance. The Court ruled that students could not be forced to stand for the pledge if it conflicted with their religious beliefs.

“To believe that patriotism will not flourish if patriotic ceremonies are voluntary and spontaneous instead of a compulsory routine is to make an unflattering estimate of the appeal of our institutions to free minds,” wrote Justice Robert Jackson in his majority opinion.

In December of 1965, thirteen-year-old Mary Beth Tinker and a group of friends decided to protest the Vietnam War by wearing black armbands on their arms at school. When Mary Beth wore her black armband on December 16th, she was asked to remove it. She refused and was sent home.

Four other students were suspended, and the students couldn’t return to school until they removed the armbands. The ACLU represented Mary Beth and the other students in a legal battle that went all the way to the Supreme Court.

The Supreme Court ruled in Tinker v. Des Moines on February 24, 1969. In a 7-2 decision, the Court declared that students “do not shed their constitutional rights to freedom of speech or expression at the schoolhouse gate.” Unless it disrupted the educational process, schools could not censor student speech.

Private schools, on the other hand, do not receive funding from the government and have more freedom to select their own rules and policies. In New Jersey, for instance, the Diocese of Camden, which runs a Catholic school system, released a statement against protests. It read, “We are not public institutions, and free speech in all of its demonstrations, including protests, is not a guaranteed right.”

Student Rights on the Court or Field

The right of student-athletes to protest at games is a bit murkier.

Rachael Jones, a legal research fellow and First Amendment scholar at UNC’s Center for Media Law and Policy, explains that student-athletes are “held to a higher standard because it becomes the school’s message and not the student’s message” if they choose to protest. Student-athletes wear the school’s jersey and represent the school in the community.

Jones says that the response to student-athlete protests will vary by school and region. Other experts agree that participating in sports is a privilege, not a right, and this privilege can be revoked if students don’t comply with school policies.

Frank LoMonte, former executive director of the Student Press Law Center, disagrees. LoMonte says that schools’ authority to discipline students for non-disruptive protests is not heightened if students are partaking in a privilege. He argues, “You can’t condition a privilege on forsaking your constitutional right any more than you can condition a right or a benefit.”

Courts have determined that public institutions can’t withhold privileges, such as employment if employees exercise their right to free speech. LoMonte believes that this should apply to schools as well.

The bottom line?

Public school students have the right to sit or refuse to recite the Pledge of Allegiance. Private school students, on the other hand, are bound by the rules and policies of their schools. Student-athletes may exercise their First Amendment rights on the field, but the official response to their protests may differ by school.

Well, that’s it for Part 3. In Part 4, we will discuss how parents can teach students to protest responsibly.

Click here to read all 4 parts of this series.

Teaching Your Children How to Protest Responsibly, Part 4

In this 4-part series, we are discussing how parents can teach their children to protest responsibly. In Part 4, we will discuss how parents should frame the conversation.

What Should Parents Do?

Some schools may choose not to take advantage of this teachable moment, but you can certainly have some enlightening conversations at home.

Use these protests to spark conversations with your child about race, racism, and prejudice, policing, the First Amendment, good citizenship, protests and their ability to affect change and more. If your child has questions, do your best to answer them or to find helpful resources.

You can also educate your child about America’s history: the history of racism and the civil rights movement, athletes as activists, and dissent that has inspired change over the years. Talk to your child about the military, the military history of black veterans, and what our servicemen and women genuinely fight for.

The NFL protests have been portrayed as disrespectful to the flag and military veterans. However, numerous veterans have stated that these protests represent precisely what the military is fighting for: the freedom to voice our opinions and assert our rights as citizens of this nation. It’s possible to show pride in your country and want better for the United States and its people.

Teach your child that all emotions, even anger, frustration, and sadness, are acceptable. What matters is how people respond to these feelings. Peaceful protests, therefore, are a positive way to express anger and frustration and potentially make a change.

What if your child feels passionate about these issues and wants to participate in the protests?

Discuss pros and cons with your child. What are the benefits of joining the protest? Why do they feel so strongly about joining? What possible consequences might they face? Viral news stories or social media posts could result—Are they prepared for this? Could the record of this protest impact their future?

If your child is at a public school, you may choose to let them make the final decision for themselves. Encourage your child to think independently, express their beliefs, and then have the strength to deal with potential consequences. Teach them that while it’s important to follow school rules, their constitutional rights do supersede school policies in this case.

However, if your child attends a private school, you may want to encourage caution. Consider the rules of your child’s school. Could they face suspension or expulsion for protesting? Explain these consequences to your child, and ask if there’s anything else they can do to join the protest symbolically.

Maybe this is a moment of truth for you as a parent. Do you want your child to continue to attend a private school that limits their constitutional right to free speech and peaceful protest? It may be time to weigh your options. There are likely public or private educational alternatives that you could explore.

Children need the support and approval of their parents. If your child is an independent thinker with the conviction to voice his opinions, view this as a positive, and don’t be afraid to stand—or sit—behind him.

Conclusion

Like other peaceful protests in American history, the national anthem protests have fueled crucial conversations across the country. These protests have the potential to influence public thinking and inspire change.

As young people have gotten involved, these protests have also raised questions about student rights on school property and at school events. At public schools, students’ Constitutional right to freedom of expression and speech do not stop at the classroom door. Private schools may make their own rules, and athletic events are a murky area.

For parents, these protests create an opportunity to talk to your child about important ideas and the history of our country. Ask and answer questions of your child, and explain that dissent is not unpatriotic. Most importantly, support your child if they wish to express their opinions about racial injustice through peaceful protest. After all, protesting is about as American as it gets.

Click here to read all 4 parts of this series.