Uncategorized

Why Are So Many Colleges in Danger of Closing?

According to a study by Vanderbilt University, an average of five non-profit colleges and universities closed every year between 2003 and 2013.

This is a disturbing trend and it is likely to continue and even accelerate over the next few years. But how could so many universities be closing when it’s the students who are drowning in debt?

According to Moody’s, it’s because one-third of all American higher education institutions are on a path of financial instability – and that path is not projected to be sustainable over time.

There’s no one reason that American school’s finances have reached this state. Rather, it’s a whole list of reasons and each impacts individual colleges differently.

Declining Enrolment

College enrolment is declining and this is impacting colleges across the board – both big and small.

Part of this is caused by the fact that high school graduation rates have flat-lined. But the lackluster graduation rate isn’t the only cause of enrolment woes.

Enrolment began declining during and after the 2008 crash, but it also hasn’t recovered in part because tuition and student loan debt have both grown at rates that create for wary prospective students.

Students are looking for a return on such a large investment and many of them aren’t seeing it in the marketplace.

While all colleges are affected by declining enrolment, it’s the smallest colleges that struggle the most with these figures, particularly if they don’t have trusts to rely on and must navigate their financial woes.

Smaller Market Shares

Small private colleges have traditionally held a unique place in the higher education landscape of the United States.

But that landscape is changing dramatically, and those colleges have failed to keep up with what students now want and need from colleges, particularly for the price demanded by these institutions.

New, online institutions and traditional universities deploying online programs are tuning in to what students want, and smaller colleges struggle to gather the finances to compete. Combined with dwindling college enrolment, small private colleges are struggling to maintain a piece of a shrinking market.

Will Small Colleges Go Extinct?

Small colleges may suffer financially over the next few years, but the idea of extinction remains alarmist.

First, the Moody’s report considers closures and mergers of small colleges to be the same thing, but they derive from very different natures. In fact, mergers can be positive for both parties because they drive what is most important – providing students what they want in a small setting.

Indeed, if one considers that small colleges are changing – not closing completely – the landscape looks slightly more positive.

The higher education landscape will continue to be challenged by new trends and just as in any sector, those institutions that fail to adapt risk failure. Learning lessons from the schools failing now will only make them stronger in the future.

 

What Universities Have the Highest Rates of Sexual Assaults Per Capita

As sexual assault rightly dominates the media, you might be wondering where else sexual assault and predators run rampant.

But finding these numbers is difficult because most sexual assaults aren’t reported to the university or the police. Although colleges receiving federal funding are required to keep records of all crime on campus, colleges won’t report a crime that isn’t reported to them.

But as women have started to report sexual offenses in greater numbers, there is some data on the schools with the highest rates of forcible on-campus sex offense per 1,000 students. Nick Selbe at Graphiq put together a list of the 25 colleges with the most sexual assaults per capita, and we’re sharing the top four results here.

The results may surprise you.

Dartmouth College

Dartmouth is a prestigious private school in New England; it’s closely associated with Ivy League institutions but doesn’t make the cut.

Students who attend Dartmouth typically fall into an SAT score range of 2000-2340, and the campus is competitive. Only 6,350 students attend the college in the middle of the woods in New Hampshire.

But Dartmouth reported 153 on-campus sex offenses in 2014 with a per capita of 2.3356 per 1,000 students.

Princeton University

Princeton University is an Ivy League private school in New Jersey. It reports an acceptance rate of 7.1% and is home to only 8,138 students with another 1,300 freshmen added every year.

But the number of sexual assaults? It’s high. Princeton reported 124 forcible on-campus sex results with a rate of 1.5316 per 1,000 students.

Vanderbilt University

Vanderbilt University is a prestigious private institution located in Tennessee. It has a student body population of 12,567 and an acceptance rate of 11.7%.

How many on-campus sex offenses were reported there? The answer is 140, which means its per capita is 1.0531.

Ramapo College of New Jersey

Ramapo College is a small college in New Jersey. It’s good school – incoming freshman typically have a composite SAT range of 1485-1800 and the acceptance rate is 53.2%.

There are just over 6,000 students on campus at Ramapo College of New Jersey. Still, the campus reported 64 sex offenses last year and a per capita of 1.0085 sex offenses per 1,000 students.

The colleges filling out the top ten include:

  • University of Rochester
  • Brown University
  • Yale University
  • California State University – Monterey Bay
  • Northern Michigan University
  • Emory University

Remember, these figures only include reported data – they do not include the many sexual assaults and harassment cases that go unreported both to the school and the authorities.

Does this list of schools surprise you? Share your thoughts in the comments below.

 

Do Divisive Figures Have the Right to Speak at Your University?

The last few years have been marked by news about divisive figures attempting to speak at universities. In most cases, these are far-right public figures attempting to speak at left-leaning college campuses or campuses in liberal cities.

With all the chaos they create, you might be wondering whether these divisive figures have the right to speak at universities.

The answer to this question is complicated, but we’ll try to break down the answer (as it currently stands) here.

Note: This answer applies to public institutions. Private institutions are not covered by the First Amendment and do not have a constitutional responsibility to uphold in regards to the First Amendment.

Free Speech Is a Right – Right?

Free speech is protected by the First Amendment of the United States Constitution. That has been affirmed by the courts over and over again. And the Supreme Court has affirmed this right for students speaking on college campuses.

But it’s not clear how that applies to speaks like Richard Spencer, Milo Yiannopolous, and Ann Coulter.

Universities that receive public funding are technically a public forum, which means that divisive personalities have a right to speak there, but that right is not unlimited.

The court considers a public college campus to be a “limited public forum”, which is different to a street or public park.

Because your campus is a “limited public forum”, your university is legally allowed to create rules for speakers when they apply to speak at the school. However, the university can’t discriminate; the rules that apply to former-President Barack Obama would also need to apply to Fox News commentator Sean Hannity.

So, campuses can force all speakers into a certain hall or schedule them for times when the campus would otherwise be empty, but those rules have to apply to all speakers.

Can My University Say No to Speakers?

Public schools generally can’t say no to speakers.

If a student organization invites a speaker to campus, there is a legal precedent that says it’s a school’s “constitutional responsibility” not to interfere with the request by denying it or by using discriminatory rules.

Your university can say no to speakers. But it can only say no if there is reason to believe that the speaker will advocate for violence against the government or against the institution they’re speaking at. However, even when there are threats of violence, it is tricky to block speakers if it looks like the university is blocking a specific point view.

What About Hate Speech?

Hate speech is covered when schools are allowed to stop speakers who will promote violence against the government or institution. However, this speech must be intended to produce violence, must be a true threat, or must use fighting words that are personally abusive and are spoken in a face-to-face matter.

Questions about controversial speakers aren’t going away, and the answers may someday become clearer. Did this article answer your questions about free speech on campus? Share your thoughts in the comments below.

 

 

Verified Service Learning Feeds the “Whole Student”

Teachers and schools and school districts track grades. We all know, or can find out pretty easily, what mark a particular student made on a specific assignment or in a class. Generally, educators are meticulous about such things.

There are many good reasons to have a similar system to track what students are doing outside of school too.

Foremost is that young people really benefit from diverse experiences and learning environments – they see and do things that simply cannot be replicated in a classroom. That’s an essential ingredient in the “whole student” approach to education which incorporates things such as maturity, emotional intelligence, discipline and community engagement with traditional academic metrics to paint a more complete and robust assessment.

Further, when students see that their grades and conduct are tracked and recorded with hyperattention and there’s nothing even remotely similar for service, they infer what’s really important. If schools want their students involved more deeply in their communities, if that’s important, schools may need to invest in systems and procedures that reflect that importance. Just saying it’s important may not be enough.

Fairfax County Public Schools (FCPS) in Virginia is convinced. FCPS, like many other states and districts, agrees that service learning is an important part of an education and invested in making student service experiences a prominent piece of their education mission. For example, FCPS Portrait of a Graduate places an emphasis developing skills, such as Ethical and Global Citizenship, so students can be successful in the workforce of the future.

But in doing that, they could not simply dump a renewed focus on community engagement on their teachers and other school personnel. No district can.

So, Fairfax utilized  x2VOL to do for service learning what learning management systems (LMS) do for academics – even more, in fact. Like an LMS, x2VOL can track progress and assess learning outcomes but can also create a permanent, verifiable service record, like a service transcript. And do that in a way that makes the process simpler, more effective and efficient for students, teachers, counselors and the community organizations.

According to Mallory Joiner, the Service Learning Resource Teacher for the Fairfax County Public Schools, it’s working. “We’re now able to see that students are engaging in diverse types of experiences in our communities,” she said. “And while that could have been the case before, each school was tracking in a different way, with different criteria and with different emphasis. Now we do things like share ideas and opportunities school to school and tie those service opportunities to school curriculum in a way that was impossible before.”

“It’s nice,” she said, “because students can not only record their hours but find new opportunities and teachers can create opportunities for students – not just finding, but creating those experiences for others.”

School personnel like it too, according to Joiner, because x2VOL isn’t just a numeric counter. It prompts students with school-approved reflection questions about their service, supports students with finding service opportunities that align with their career goals and interests, and automatically sends verification e-mails to the community leaders for their one-click verification or for added comments. Students and community groups can even add photos or other notes. And, once approved, the completed record goes to the school for approval and inclusion in the student’s permanent record of service.

Having a permanent, verified service record can be important and far easier when students apply to colleges. But the service record also helps districts and states recognize and incentivize service achievements, as Virginia does with the special Virginia Board of Education diploma seal for excellence in civics education, which requires at least 50 hours of community service.

For Fairfax and other districts, a community service management system like x2VOL is a giant leap forward from telling students volunteering was important but leaving the entire process, from finding opportunities to recording them, to them. At best, that system was a disconnected, disorganized afterthought whereas now it can be a highly connected part of the education experience – not just connected within the school but connected to it and the community.

Knowing exactly what a student did in their community, for how long, at what level and what they took from those experiences is an obvious game changer for mentors, counselors, teachers and colleges who understand the value of out-of-school service. But it’s also every bit as important for the school leaders who are engaging, supporting and challenging students today. With tools like x2VOL, teachers who review a student’s service can connect in-class assignments with life experiences and suggest related areas of study or assignments that can open eyes and new career paths. Counselors can discover and support hidden student interests and passions. Or merely offer words of encouragement.

Schools may never get to the point where community service is as important as academics. But many, like Fairfax, are doing more to stress that service is important in its own way – making those opportunities more visible, more accessible, more connected to learning, easier to manage and more rewarding.

 

 

The Changing Role of the CTO (Chief Technology Officer) in School Districts

In every school district, the role of the CTO is changing.

The modern Chief Technology Officer’s role has metamorphosed from that of part-time teacher/part-time repair person to one of a visionary leader. The change positions the district and its shareholders to understand how to use technology effectively as a tool rather than learn it as a standalone subject.

Today’s CTOs are:

More collaborative than ever

The CTO advocates for the integration of technology. In doing so, this school officer must understand the needs and concerns of students, teachers, administrators, the school board, and the community. Any hardware and software selected for use must align with the district’s mission and vision. Often, CTOs will find themselves communicating with their district teams, other CTOs, state agencies, and federal program directors to build the kind of comprehensive technology infrastructure needed for daily business and learning.

No longer facilitators

The role of the CTO has changed as much as that of teachers in the last two decades. CTOs are now the “guides on the side” rather than the “sage on the stage.” They are expected to build partnerships through trust, and much of the Chief Technology Officer’s work consists of coaching users in fast-paced digital environments.

Security experts

Technology has permeated every part of education in school districts, from GPS and WiFi on school buses to the hardware and software used in classrooms. With this technology has come security and privacy concerns, thanks to outside phishing schemes and data hackers seeking access to personal information.

FERPA and HIPAA requirements are exacting; therefore, CTOs must position themselves and their technology teams as gatekeepers who protect the personal data of not only students but also the adults who work with them.

The CTO ensures that the environment in which everyone learns and works is secure.

Dynamic leaders in fluid environments

The Chief Technology Officer who still believes that every school must be hard-wired wired “just in case” is probably living in the past as much as the person who hopes that 8-track tapes will make a comeback. Technology is never static; it continuously evolves, and the CTO must change with new trends and demands. The CTO must also be a visionary who can set short- and long-term goals. He or she doesn’t need to know how to repair equipment or install classroom whiteboards, but this person must be able to lead a team of experts who can.

The changing role of the CTO is a beneficial one. By identifying, guiding, and nurturing the integration of technology, the Chief Technology Officer will have the greatest role in the future of school districts.

Stop Supporting Digital Tools that Have Not Been Tested and Proven

The research behind a particular product is especially crucial for districts who are investing large amounts of money into new edtech programs and digital tools. Unfortunately, many districts continue to purchase digital tools that have yet to be tested and proven in the classroom setting. Looking at research could easily prove whether a program is going to have a major impact on the academic status of students as a whole.

If you are unsure why data might be important, here are a few things you can learn from looking at the numbers.

A program might be effective but not for your school district.

Without the proper research, it can be difficult to determine who the digital tool is supposed to support. You might believe that all students are created equal, but the research proves that this isn’t the case. Some programs can boast great results when used with white students from middle-income families, but they might have different results with minority students or schools that cater to lower-income families.

A program that has been tested and proven should have found a way to address racial gaps and discrepancies based on family income. However, a digital tool that has not been tested and proven might not even realize that this disparity exists. Those in charge of purchasing decisions should be aware of the makeup of their district and the students that this program will serve. The testing and research results should identify a clear fit for the district.

Materials are not always from reputable companies.

Many of the companies touting online lessons and digital instruction are from the leading manufacturers that schools have trusted for years. Pearson, Houghton Mifflin Harcourt, and others still lead the way when it comes to instructional resources. However, other companies have been able to jump into the game with these digital lessons. They might provide only a few lessons or cover a very specific topic. Without research that demonstrates that their curriculum is tested and proven to be effective, school districts may just be wasting their money.

Not all digital tools are made in America.

We must keep in mind that not all of the emerging digital tools are made with the American education system in mind. Other parts of the globe, including Asia, are contributing heavily to this sector. With that awareness, we will need more data and research to prove that it can fill the need we have in our own education system. Otherwise, we might be mistakenly led to believe that our edtech is for a particular grade or teaching style that doesn’t match our unique needs.

Digital tools definitely have their place in the modern classroom, but we must proceed with caution. It does school districts no good to purchase digital tools and edtech that cannot serve their students well. Making sure that every program is tested and proven to be effective at generating positive outcomes is essential to making wise use of our school budgets.

2023 Best and Worst Colleges for Free Speech

Free speech is a treasured right granted by the Constitution of the United States. Taking this right for granted or allowing it to be usurped puts our country and especially citizens in danger of losing not only their First Amendment Rights but other rights as well.

In his fable “The Bear Who Let It Alone,” humorist James Thurber said, “You might as well fall on your face as lean too far backwards.” Good universities can make bad decisions that have them leaning too far backward, especially when silencing free speech.

Worst colleges for free speech

Colleges and universities should uphold and encourage free speech, but three schools have earned a place among the worst for free speech according to the Foundation for Individual Rights in Education (FIRE). Each university mishandled a situation involving free speech.

  • Georgetown University – This school has earned notoriety for clamping down on free speech several times. Most recently, the school preventing students from campaigning for presidential candidate Bernie Sanders, citing their tax-exempt status as the reason. Perhaps more egregious is that the university ignores its free speech policies.
  • California State University, Long Beach – University leaders clamped down on free speech when they forced the closure of a play that made fun of racial stereotypes and showed how race defines a person. The actors in the play were minorities themselves, but the university refused to allow for artistic expression that mentioned race.
  • California State University, Los Angeles – Not to be outdone by a sister school in the same system, the university mishandled a speaking engagement by conservative Ben Shapiro by offsetting the cost of security on students, requesting a panel of opposing speakers, and imposing a tax on controversial speech.

Best colleges for free speech

Other universities serve as best examples of how free speech rights can be an integral part of the higher education experience. These schools include:

What sets apart the best colleges for free speech?

The best colleges for free speech develop clear policies and follow them. Schools that remain true to their founder’s ideas regarding free speech have had the best success in handling divergent thought and its expression.

Universities have long encouraged diverse thinking, and they must continue to do so. Students enrolled in institutions of higher education should learn how to listen to uncomfortable ideas and develop their own worldviews. The caveat is that college students are becoming less open-minded toward free speech, according to a Brookings Institute study.

Helping these students accept and encourage free speech is something to which every university should aspire.

2023 Best and Worst Colleges for LBGTQ Students

Selecting the right college is a matter of personal preference, and many factors come into play when choosing a school. While academics are important, so is college life – the environment and cultural milieu in which students attend classes.

Most students, regardless of race, ethnicity, religion, or sexual identification want to know they’ll be attending a university that will be safe. Some Lesbian Bisexual Gay Transgender Queer/Questioning (LGBTQ) students have difficulties finding a school that accepts their lifestyle choices.

LGBTQ students may want to make a note of the best and worst colleges for students who are non-heterosexual or non-cisgender.

Best colleges for LGBTQ students

Universities that rank among the best institutions of higher education for LGBTQ students have one thing in common. These schools provide full support of their non-heterosexual, non-cisgender student population by allowing for the development of support groups, clubs, and mentors. In some cases, the resources even include campus housing for LGBTQ students.

  • Princeton University – This college addresses LGBTQ student needs with non-gendered restrooms, education panels, and cultural events.
  • Tufts University — LGBTQ students who attend Tufts, as well as the faculty, have plenty of resources including mentors, internships and scholarships, and cultural events designed to support them. This campus even includes LGBTQ housing choices.
  • University of Pennsylvania – This school offers a variety of support groups for LGBTQ students and encourages peer mentorships. This Ivy League school is considered the best college in the United States for LGBTQ students.

Worst colleges for LGBTQ students

More than one hundred colleges are considered among the worst for LGBTQ students, but a handful stands out because of their unwillingness to create a safe harbor for students with non-traditional sexual orientations and identities.

Many of the LGBTQ-unfriendly universities are Christian-based institutions.

  • College of the Ozarks – The college openly refuses to accept LGBTQ student behaviors based on philosophical beliefs aligned to the Bible.
  • Auburn University – Less than ten years ago, Auburn did not have a non-discrimination policy for LGBTQ students, making this school unfriendly for students.
  • University of Tennessee – This institution maintains the Pride Center for LGBTQ students, but has succumbed to political pressure to pull funding support for its operation.
  • Baylor University – Considered blatantly opposed to LGBTQ students, Baylor referenced homosexual acts as a violation of the student code of conduct as recently as 2015.

Colleges and universities willing to provide ample resources and support systems for LGBTQ students can attract an untapped market by aspiring to be one of the best colleges for the LGBTQ student population.

Congratulations! If you represent a college or university that is included in this list, please collect your seal below.

These Universities Present a Challenge to Ivy League Schools

The hallowed halls of Ivy League institutions are revered for their academic rigor, exclusivity, and the longevity of their reputations. After all, many Ivies are some of the United States’ oldest universities.

While Ivy League schools maintain stellar reputations and are considered to be the epitome of higher education both in the United States and around the world, they do not stand alone. There are many schools in the United States that have the same reputation but are not considered to Ivy League.

In other words, there is more to life than Harvard, Princeton, and Yale.

Here are a few of the challengers – each with a pristine reputation, exclusive admissions process, and incredible student opportunities:

1.   California Institute of Technology

Caltech is quickly becoming the premier destination for STEM subjects in the United States and around the world. The school isn’t Ivy League, but it was the top school in the world for five years from 2012 according to the Times Higher Education World University Rankings.

Caltech is dedicated to teaching pure science (and engineering) in small classes. How small are these classes? The acceptance rate is only 8% and there are only 979 undergraduates studying there.

2.   Massachusetts Institute of Technology

MIT isn’t an Ivy League school, and at this point, it’s unclear why.

If you’re a STEM student, then there’s no better place in the United States or the world (with the exception of Cal Tech) to study. MIT is more than a name; it offers students the opportunity to not only be taught by the world’s best researchers but to participate in researcher programs even at the undergraduate level.

3.   University of Chicago

The University of Chicago is known not only for academic rigor in obscure disciplines but also for the general quirkiness that can only be afforded to high-level institutions. From the bizarre admissions questions to the infamous ScavHunt, it’s the place for those who don’t fit the cookie cutter mold of traditional Ivies to thrive.

UChicago is the place to study economics in the United States. It’s home to 5,500 students and has an acceptance of rate of 7.9%, so it’s exclusive as they come. It just hasn’t been awarded the title of Ivy League.

Ivy institutions aren’t the be all and end all of the universities. In fact, they’re not even the top universities in the world and there are many other universities outside of the three listed here that are coming for their top spots.

Are you considering an alternative Ivy? Why or why not? Share your thoughts in the comments below.

How Do Colleges Know How Much You Can Afford?

If you’ve ever had a conversation with students at a private college, you’ve probably realized that you all pay different rates of tuition – even though there is one official rate.

Different students pay different rates because colleges apply a method of pricing called price discrimination.

Price discrimination is a method of pricing where a product is sold based on the price the customer will pay. You might recognize it from the way an airline sells seats on a plane or a hotel sets the price of a room.

There’s a floor price and a ceiling price, but the final price offered to a student is the greatest price they’d be willing to pay for tuition so that the college can still sell them tuition.

How Do They Know What to Charge You?

Airlines use search history, customer profiles, and algorithms to sell a plane ticket. But how do colleges determine whether to charge a student the full rate of tuition or tuition at a 62% discount?

According to Ian Fillmore at VoxEU, colleges use US financial aid data from FAFSA to determine a student’s willingness to pay. This isn’t a violation of the data: FAFSA asks colleges to partner with the government in distributing financial aid to students.

Colleges have access to the six colleges an individual student applies to. They can then see the range in tuition the prospective student is considering it and can compare it with the student’s financial data.

As Fillmore points out, this works in the college’s favor because the government collects the data for them and it’s high-quality because there are punishments associated with lying on your FAFSA.

What Does This Mean for Students?

Price discrimination seems like a minor, esoteric detail in the grand scheme of higher education.

But there are consequences of price discrimination in colleges. Fillmore’s article provides insight into this through hard data.

If colleges couldn’t use FAFSA data, price variation among students at the same college would likely fall by 17%.  Moreover, the price of tuition at an elite college would drop by $825 per student every year and there would be improvements in student welfare.

However, if colleges couldn’t use this data, it is more likely that tuition for students from low-income backgrounds would rise. It’s possible that 12% of students attending private elite colleges would be priced out of their school.

Ultimately, colleges decide how much to charge you based on your real income. Whether you like it or not, it is an important part of the current education system and the way tuition and financial aid are designed will need to take it into consideration in the future.