Uncategorized

Balancing Screen Time with Mindfulness

Parents and teachers want what is best for children—but the proliferation of digital learning tools makes it a bit hard to determine what exactly that is. A child using an app can accomplish significant educational gains—but at what cost? Balancing screen time with mindfulness is a bit tricky for educators and parents.

Sometimes, tech tools can be used to solve the problems that other tech tools create. There are a variety of tools that will help limit and control children’s screen time and thus might make it easier for parents and teachers. A strong benefit of these tools is that they reduce the potential for arguments about screen time by largely removing day-to-day decision making. Also, they make it possible to track the sites that children visit so that adults can ensure that children are not accessing inappropriate materials.

Parents and teachers can also specifically teach children techniques to improve mindfulness. A student in possession of these skills will be in a better position to resist the allure of using screen time to cope with unpleasant emotions—they will have other tools to use that are healthier.

Teacher, in particular, may be tempted to overuse edtech tools, since these tools are usually engaging for students, can minimize problematic behavior in the classroom, and often have outstanding learning outcomes. But a child who spends the bulk of their school day in front of a screen is a child who is not learning how to have face-to-face conversations. They are not learning from immersion in the natural world. They are not gaining the benefits of engaging in physical activity or of being outdoors.

It is important for adults to give students both the rationale for and the specific resources needed to limit their screen time. Unless an adult articulates it, a child may be unaware that excessive screen time will make it difficult for them to appropriately engage with other people in conversation or other daily activities. They will be unlikely to understand how this lacuna may negatively impact their ability to succeed in the future.

Further, children may be unaware of how excessive screen time affects the child’s disposition if an adult does not help them observe this. Students are also likely to be unaware of how extra screen time cuts into their time for physical activity, which can have profoundly negative affects on their physical and emotional health, now and in the future. Teaching mindfulness is one way to avoid these outcomes.

The Important Role of Tech in Closing the Degree Attainment Gap

Many of the available jobs in today’s market require a college education. We currently have plenty of students opting to pursue higher education but very few are leaving with a degree. There is a major disconnect between the attendance rates and the graduation rates at four-year colleges and universities. It is shocking that only 32 percent of students enrolled in colleges complete their degrees within six years at open-admission universities. Our education system needs to do something to help close the significant degree attainment gap.

Technology could play an important role in minimizing the number of college dropouts and start closing the gap. With the new programs available to educators and administrators, students might become more likely to stick with school until they achieve a more successful outcome.

Data can determine who is likely to drop out.

The sheer volume of students who drop out of college is unflattering for higher education centers. For years, it was almost impossible to identify the profile of a student who was unlikely to finish their basic education. Now, the data is far easier to manage and can reveal red flags for students who might be at risk of leaving the university altogether. Professors might notice that students with low grades or poor attendance are on the brink of abandoning the university.

This data gives them an opportunity to reach out and attempt to remedy the situation. By retaining students year after year, a college has a better chance of closing the degree attainment gap. They might also be able to develop new systems that can support learning based on the feedback they receive from at-risk students.

Technology gives more support to students.

Most schools require a rigorous bout of standard academic courses to ensure a well-rounded education. Students come to dread some of these classes because they know their own shortcomings with these core subjects, including higher-level math and science. It’s rather common to see students drop out or withdraw from courses before their completion due to failing grades. Technology can help to provide more support and practice for students who need assistance. At some colleges, it lowered the withdrawal rate from 60 percent to 21 percent. Extra support can keep students in class longer and make it more likely that they will attain their degree.

Students need more personalized attention.

Larger schools are unable to give students the time and attention they need in large introductory classes. This means that students who are struggling can often slip just under the radar without a teacher pulling them aside. With technology, universities could change this dynamic. Personalized teaching and tutoring online can give students access to the help they need without the embarrassment of having to ask for it. They can learn at their own pace in a way that is convenient for them without requesting that the professor rearrange their schedule. This can be a great advance for many students who remain quiet in class but are struggling academically.

Universities and colleges could definitely close the degree attainment gap using the advances in technology that are available. They can monitor students that are at risk of leaving school, offer more support for difficult classes, and provide more personalized attention. All of these attributes are going to be key in making sure that students who start college ultimately graduate with their degree in six years or less.

How to Get Reluctant Professors on Board with Mobile Learning

Mobile learning is a growing trend for students who are increasingly searching for ways to take their education with them. They tend to prize flexibility when it comes to their academics, making it essential that professors start to add more mobile learning components to the curriculum. Old-school professors tend to be more reluctant to get on board with the mobile learning options that students love. However, this hesitancy can set them and their students up for failure as they move forward.

How can you get a tentative teacher to start incorporating more mobile learning into their classroom? Here are a few tips to make the idea more palatable to a professor who isn’t quite ready to embrace edtech in the classroom.

Make sure the timing is right.

Educators already work extremely long hours during the school year and even throughout the summer months. They are often overworked and underpaid. All of this contributes to a staff that is hesitant to add one more thing on their plates. They might not have the time to learn how to use and implement a new tool in their classroom. One of the simplest ways to ensure that reluctant teachers have time to learn how to use these tools is to introduce them toward the end of the year. The break in the usual school schedule gives them a little time to practice and play with the new tech they will need to use in the fall.

Allow paid leave to educate your educators.

Are your hesitant staff members worried that they don’t know how to use the tools necessary for mobile learning? Their reluctance may stem more from a feeling of incompetence than a real issue with the platforms. Schools could give their staff members paid leave in order to take classes or attend training that would teach them how to use mobile learning more efficiently. This could convert a reluctant professor into an enthusiastic supporter rather quickly

Remind them that human interaction is still important.

It isn’t unheard of to find individuals who are still afraid that their teaching position will be taken by a robot. With the increased use of artificial intelligence, this can be a real concern for professors. It could explain why they are so hesitant to jump on board with the push for more mobile learning solutions. You might need to remind these unwilling teachers that technology could never be a substitute for real human interaction. Assure them that the students still need their instruction, but they also need to grow and change with the times. Traditional methods and technology are going to be equally important in a modern classroom.

Moving toward a more tech-based classroom can be frightening for teachers who prefer their traditional tactics. Mobile learning is more beneficial to students who want to access and engage with the material while they are on the go. In the end, it will require these reluctant teachers to jump on board with mobile learning so students can have the best of both worlds. It may take a lot of slow work, but all professors can eventually feel comfortable with these arrangements.

 

How Can Edtech Lead School Improvement?

Schools across the country are constantly looking for new ways they can improve education for students and teachers. In this modern age, it makes sense that many school districts would look to edtech for the answers. Is it possible that edtech could lead school improvement and promote better outcomes for students?

The reality is that edtech can be a powerful force in the classroom when it is used appropriately. School officials in charge of the purchasing decisions should really know how they can best use edtech to promote improvement among their students. You must know how to choose the right technology to make the dramatic impact that most schools desire. If you think that a major edtech purchase could improve your school, here are the things you need to know about how to make your purchase more successful.

Create a vision for your school.

Purchasing more edtech doesn’t do your school any good if you don’t know what you are trying to achieve. The first step to improving any school is to cast a real vision for your classrooms and district. You need to decide what needs your students and teachers have before you can move forward. Creating a vision and identifying measurable goals or objectives is the key to buying the right edtech for your classrooms. After all, this helps you identify which problems need to be solved first and narrows down which edtech items you really need.

Look for technology to support your goals.

The market is completely flooded with edtech programs and platforms that promise to help with a variety of needs. Many of these programs are extremely flashy and easily marketable, but they won’t all suit your school’s needs. You need to make sure that every program you investigate will relate directly back to one of your previously identified needs and goals. It may also be helpful to look for scalable technology.

One research study on the Edivate program (a scalable platform that can be adapted to many goals) demonstrated an 18.5 percent increase on standardized assessments. This demonstrates the importance of finding edtech that truly suits your school’s needs.

Search for edtech that has been tested and proven.

Your school isn’t likely to see improvement with programs that have not been thoroughly researched, tested, and proven to be effective. One of the major problems in the edtech community is that no one pays enough attention to the reliability of the systems that schools are adopting. Schools can spend a lot of money on edtech for a very small payoff when it comes to classroom management or test scores. If you want technology to help lead school improvement, it is essential to implement products that are demonstrated to help you achieve your overall vision.

Edtech holds the potential to be extremely beneficial for everyone in the learning community. It can help to improve how a classroom functions and boost student test scores. With the right platform, edtech can definitely pave the way for improvement in the classroom setting. However, schools must identify their own needs and perform extensive research to find the right tools that have already been tested and proven. This is no easy task, but the end results are ultimately worth it.

 

 

Why Edtech Needs a Bit of Humility and Caution

Edtech holds the potential to be extremely versatile and beneficial in the classroom. In many cases, it can create better outcomes and deepen the learning experience for students. Other programs are designed to help educators with classroom management. These digital tools can be a wonderful addition to a teacher’s toolbox, but not all products are useful. Too many programs and tools are designed to be flashy and marketable instead of catering to the teacher and student needs.

Some teachers are beginning to resent the push toward digital learning in the classroom. In fact, only 58 percent of teachers feel comfortable using technology in their classroom according to a recent study. It makes sense that so many teachers would be hesitant to use these tools in their classroom. The products that their districts are purchasing seem like a good idea, but edtech companies are lacking in the humility necessary to create a superior product. Edtech needs a bit more humility and caution in order to make their products more effective for the classroom.

A Growing Trend

It comes as no surprise that edtech is a growing phenomenon. Everyone loves the idea of individualized learning for every student. Children can work at their own pace using tools that are tailored to their learning needs, taking some of the burdens off teachers. Theoretically, this type of program sounds ideal but it often falls short in practicality. Most of the programs designed for classroom instruction were not created by actual teachers.

More and more educators are speaking up and asking edtech companies to stop building what they think teachers need. There’s a growing push for these tech companies to have a little more humility to ask educators what needs they have in the classroom. What gaps could their new products fill to make learning a better experience for teachers and students alike?

Caution and Humility Lead to Success

How do caution and humility contribute to the overall success of an edtech company? When they can slow down long enough to ask thoughtful questions and come up with creative solutions, school districts are bound to sense a company’s ingenuity. You must be willing to approach schools and teachers with a humble attitude. Being ready to learn what it’s like to be involved in the classroom is essential to creating effective technology for teachers and students. Ask lots of questions and move slowly when coming up with solutions instead of jumping head-first into a flashy program.

Be willing to accept constructive feedback as well. Most companies would prefer not to hear that there are areas where their product falls short. However, this feedback is a crucial part of the development phase. Using this criticism and insight to adapt your platform or tool can better develop your company and create a lasting product that truly meets teacher needs.

Pausing before the development of a solution and taking the time to humbly accept criticism is necessary for edtech companies. This is how we create products that have the best outcomes for students and a generation of learners. We cannot forget the importance of these two qualities when starting edtech companies that could help us to create a better future for our students.

 

Why all Community Colleges Should Offer Bachelor’s Degrees

Community colleges have long been recognized as an affordable alternative to four-year colleges and universities. They offered associate’s degrees for two years of study in a program, or they served as a bridge to a four-year program leading to a bachelors’ degree.

Now, however, community colleges in 21 states offer bachelor’s degrees, and that’s a move in the right direction.

All community colleges should offer bachelor’s degrees.

Better access and flexibility

The Community College Baccalaureate Association (CCBA) has long held that community colleges can provide better access and be more responsive to student demands for continued education.

Local community colleges have proven they can create programs of study designed to meet learner needs. If for example, the community need is to train nurses, the school will develop the courses needed for certification.

Community colleges also tend to offer a more flexible and more appealing schedule than many four-year universities. Most community colleges regularly provide night and weekend courses.

Lower costs

One of the most compelling reasons for students to attend a community college is its affordability. Not all students are willing to go into debt for their bachelor’s degrees, and many find a $10,000 degree highly attractive.

Students who finance their bachelor’s degrees from community colleges will have their education paid off long before their peers who attended pricier universities pay off their debts.

Proximity to home

Attending community college is easy because it’s nearby. Many campuses are in convenient locations that students can access after work. Some colleges offer classes at local high schools on the weekends, making attending class even easier.

Less time in getting a degree

Community colleges that offer baccalaureate degrees can help to offset shortages in high need areas such as nursing, Pre-K education, and applied technology. That means students will become part of the professional workforce more quickly. Students attending community colleges are as concerned about extracurricular activities such as sporting events and Greek life. They are willing to give up the extras to get on with their degrees and go to work.

In summary

Lower costs, greater program flexibility, proximity to home, and earning a degree in less time make community college baccalaureate degrees a welcome alternative to traditional four-year university degrees.

Community colleges that offer bachelor’s degrees are responding to the needs of the workforce. They are changing interpretations of what it means to earn a baccalaureate.

Higher education has the responsibility to transform the way in which it meets those needs, and it should embrace the new role of community colleges.

A Digital Architecture for Education: Technology Transformation from Inside Out

By James Hope

Note: James is Head of Digital Strategy at a leading independent boys school Trust in London. James previously worked in Digital Strategy and Transformation at Deloitte, leading technology transformation programmes in data and information strategy for organisations including BP, the European Bank and Cancer Research. For more details you can find James on LinkedIn: http://www.linkedin.com/in/jamesdometthope/

 

Introduction

Having landed on this page you must already have some conviction to the idea that digital technology is a force for good in our schools, colleges and universities. Yet you, like I, will most probably know fellow educators that profoundly disagree with this notion, who rather believe that technology is superfluous in education and how young people learn. Suffice to say that technology in education has been divisive, and as I will come to argue in the following chapters of this book, might have been better conceived and anticipated by governments and educational leaders, for a number of reasons.

I believe that digital technologies will radically transform education in the next 10-15 years. I believe that technologies will change how institutions function, not just in terms of learning and teaching but across their entire operation, to such an extent that how we understand the education market and how young people approach their learning will become remoulded and understood in terms of technology.

I believe too, that schools, colleges and universities have no other option but to embrace the technological future and that to remain competitive and endure, they will need to engage with technology, change and adapt. My conviction to this is simple as I hope you will agree compelling: in an world that is increasingly digital and online, our schools have a responsibility to empower young people with technology, so they can realise its many benefits, not just for learning, but for participation in the global digital society and economy in which they will enter into. Schools, colleges and universities that recognise this can empower the young people in their care with digital technology, and those that don’t will in time be seen to be out of touch with how young people want to learn and the reality of a jobs market that is increasingly digital and technological.[1]

That is not to say that institutions must now embrace all technological innovations and trends; for such a naive approach will, as particularly some schools might readily admit to, lead to a hotchpotch of technologies with no measurable outcomes or clear idea of the value of technology expenditure. Rather, to find ‘their way’ through what is an increasingly complex market offering of educational technologies and offerings, institutions can take a education-first approach to digital innovation and have assurance that expenditure on digital technologies is leading their institution to perform better and improve educational outcomes. In the following chapter I present to you my thoughts on this, as a teacher and technologist, engaged in this great education debate.

Finally, the message in this book is for all educators; for those working in primary, secondary and tertiary education, as teachers, lecturers, tutors, instructors, in supporting roles, in leadership roles and everything in between. We all share a common goal: to improve the outcomes for the young people in our care, and it is in our common interest to understand how digital technology enables us to do this.

 

Chapter 1, What went wrong?

A major and inescapable force driving our schools ever closer to a technological future is an ever growing, international demand for a good school education. Technology in education, in schools, colleges and universities can be of critical importance for governments and schools in meeting this demand and in driving down costs. In this technological future, what might the ideal conditions be for technology to flourish; and, what might be learned from the experiences and approaches taken by schools, colleges and universities in digital technology?

The Science of Learning

It is quite remarkable that in many educational institutions, costly decisions about technology in learning are made with little or no consideration to educational need or the science that supports our modern understanding of learning. If the interface between teaching and learning science is truly broken, then how can institutions make well informed decisions about technology in learning.[2]

For schools, colleges and universities to make sense of the innovations in learning technologies and the choices available to them, they must too, understand what makes learning happen best for their particular learning context. This leads me nicely to my next point, and the importance of innovation in our schools.

Foundations for Innovation

Maintained schools have, until recently, existed under local authority control. Teachers have been, and continue to be, rewarded on the principle of years of service rather than on individual progress or merit. Furthermore, the profession is deeply unionised, although increasingly less so, and reform in schools especially, no matter how seemingly pragmatic and sensible, can be tediously slow. And whilst many schools have chosen to become academies relinquishing local authority control and acquiring new freedoms in the process, the historical inertia within these schools has made it difficult for school leaders to establish new foundations for real innovation and progress.

The systems of control imposed upon schools have been so prohibitive in making technological progress that it is hardly surprising the boldest innovations, in secondary education, have been in the independent sector. One example of this is at Dulwich College, where ‘innovation labs’ with flexible spaces and furniture are enabling teachers to break the mould of the Victorian-esque classroom, challenging teachers to re-think their use of physical space and technology in teaching and learning.[3]

Empowering teachers and instructors with the freedoms and incentives to explore and take risks with technology in teaching and learning is key to fostering a culture of innovation schools, colleges and universities.

Digital Expectations of Young People

Education is, after all, about serving the educational needs and interests of young people. This might seem like a rather obvious statement to make, but if young people love to use technology then why is it that technology is so often left out in how we expect young people to learn?

Indeed, the very fact that young people are engaged by technology in their learning is a powerful answer to the argument made all too often in education: that students already achieve outstanding grades and why should we consider doing things differently. This view might be acceptable if made from a position of conscious competence; in other words, that as educators we understand the learning value of the technologies available to us and to our students, but that we choose to employ low tech means in the confidence that these will benefit learning the most. But in my experience, this argument is rarely made from a position of conscious competence, but rather from a position of unconscious competence, where educators are competent at what they do but simply don’t understand the possibilities that technology has to offer to them and their students.

A position of unconscious competence is easily challenged. Questions, such as, ‘What opportunities have students had to use digital technology in their learning?’, will expose the simple truth of the situation. Such a question might highlight complacency or it might highlight a lack of confidence and support. Either way, educators and institutions that are unconscious to the potential of technology run the risk of being viewed as esoteric and out of touch.

There is a lot that schools can learn about the potential value of technology from the higher education sector and engaging with students about their digital expectations and experiences with educational technology as many universities do, should surely become the norm in all schools and colleges.

IT Governance

As technology has become more important in education and in learning, and as technology innovation continues to gather pace, never have institutions and educators been faced with the prospect of so much change and potential for disruption.

My own experience working as a teacher and technologist in secondary education has been that schools have found the area of IT governance especially challenging, not least because of the demand on time and costs in human resource that effective change in this specialist area can sometimes require. Additionally, in some institutions and in schools especially, IT departments have been run as fiefdoms and simply failed to transition to an IT service that is able to support the complex technology needs and priorities of teachers, instructors and students, to whom technology has become mission critical. Suffice to say that in the absence of effective governance and consultation with end users will almost certainly lead to a situation where technology is not only poorly utilised but contribute to a culture of disengagement from technology altogether, as many institutions and particularly schools will attest to.

For all institutions, but for schools especially, the challenge is balancing educational needs with other priorities. In recognising this, and the strategic value that technology programmes can deliver, an increasing number of schools and colleges now appoint a ‘Director of Technology’ or ‘Director of Digital Strategy’ or similar within the academic leadership team whose responsibility it is to understand and develop educational needs for technology across the curriculum, and oversee change management. The separation of duties between the development of educational requirements and IT service and provision, offers an important check and balance in the governance of technology and leads to overall better decision making.

Systems of governance and change management are therefore of critical importance in successful digital transformation. Firstly, in making sure that technology projects and programmes deliver value to end users, that is the teachers, instructors and other business stakeholders using the technology; and to the institution, by making sure that resource and time invested into projects and programmes can be measured against strategic aims and objectives and that institutions can gain assurance over technology expenditure.

Self-regulation

Helping young people navigate the dangers and risks of online technologies is a challenging area for all schools. The statutory safeguarding guidance Keeping children safe in education, 2015, recommends that governors and proprietors should consider a whole school approach to online safety, but stops short at recommending the sorts of approaches schools should consider.

It is perhaps no surprise that the approach taken in many schools is one of prohibition; young people learn about online safety but are ring fenced from the dangers so that schools can gain assurance over safeguarding obligations being met. Such an approach, in which decisions about what is appropriate or not appropriate are made by the school, will surely fail our young people in helping them to make their own decisions and judgements about the risks and benefits when they use technology outside of school. Moreover, this approach only further entrenches the idea that individual rights and freedoms, when it comes to digital technology, are absolute; when in fact in a world where the digital rights and freedoms are being threatened and eroded, we should be empowering our young people to question the balance of individual liberties with the power of the state.[4]

An approach where young people are not only taught about the risks and dangers of online technologies and appropriate online behaviour, but are able to use online technologies and learn from their mistakes, within the relative safety of a private network, and on enterprise rather than public platforms, is surely a better overall strategy.

Open Standards

The development of content, media and data on proprietary platforms in unportable formats has caused many institutions to become trapped with legacy platforms that no longer serve their best interests or face the prospect of huge disruption. Whilst this might be considered characteristic of an emergent and burgeoning industry market, it is one of a number of risks of being an early adopter of technology, that schools and colleges particularly have failed to anticipate.

Schools, colleges and universities should look technologies that confirm with open standards, particularly where educational data and content is concerned. Open standards means brings two important benefits. First, with the threat of other competing technologies that conform to the same standards, technology vendors are compelled to remain competitive and value their relationship with existing customers. Second, if an existing technology becomes defunct because of bankruptcy, legacy software that is no longer supported or another technology is deemed to be better suited, institutions can port content, media and data to a new system or platform with much greater ease.

 

Chapter 2, Benefits for Education

The increasingly great choice for schools, colleges and universities in technology provision has compelled institutions and educators to think more critically about the value that technology has to offer in education and in learning, discussed in the sections that follow. In Chapter 3, I present an approach to digital transformation in education and learning that puts education and learning first.

Digital Domains of Knowledge

So much knowledge now exists in digital forms and formats, online, on the Internet, on virtual private networks, on open and closed platforms.[5] Not only this, but technology has changed how young people construct knowledge and participate in knowledge creation.

In the curation of content, as learners set about finding and organising information on a particular issue, digital and online technologies are of most obvious benefit. In Bhargava’s The Five Models of Content Curation, the models of curation: aggregation, distillation, elevation, mashups and chronology are not just benefitted but reliant upon technology. Simply, without technology, the curation of content is limited to non-digital forms and the act of finding and organisation information becomes considerably more time consuming.

Suffice to say that how institutions empower young people with the technology, to curate content and interact with digital domains of knowledge, is one of obvious potential.

Access & Reach

Technology is profoundly changing how young people access education and learning. Educational technology is changing the on-campus, in-class experience by extending the learning beyond the walls of the classroom or lecture room so that time on campus can be spent on assessment, discussion and consolidation of what has been learnt. In doing so, it has enabled educators to take an entirely different approach in learning and teaching. We often here about ‘flipped’ learning, an approach to learning which is, to a lesser or greater extent, made possible by technology and in particular, the access to learning and teaching that technology provides.

This has led many schools, colleges and universities to reorganise physical space, to the extent that some institutions the classroom and lecture theatre are being altogether abandoned for open, informal spaces with Wi-Fi where students can access a range of online and individualised learning resources.

But remote technology is working at an even more fundamental level than this: it is reforming the entire demographic of schools, colleges and universities. It is providing young people will more choice about how they wish to learn and be educated. Many universities export learning to open online learning platforms or MOOC’S (Massive Open Online Courses) or learning management platforms. These platforms are allowing educators to reach a global audience of students and institutions to market themselves on a global stage.

Remote learning has its own challenges for institutions, but the idea of affording higher quality teaching to even greater numbers of students, remotely, through virtual environments and classrooms is one that, I would argue, is surprisingly underdeveloped.

How technology is improving and enabling access to learning is, without a shadow of a doubt, a truly transformative force in education and learning.

Personalised Learning

The third area of transformative potential is personalised learning. Modern educational technologies are enabling students to follow learning pathways that are highly differentiated, where the learning is continually adapted suit the individual learning needs and progress of the student. Such deeply individualised approaches to learning are difficult to achieve without technology. And though adaptive learning algorithms give us a glimpse of how machine learning and AI (Artificial Intelligence) might transform education and learning in the future.

AI in education could, in theory, accelerate the natural inequalities in the learning of young people and allow us to do away with our current system of standardisation. AI might also provide students, parents, teachers, instructors and other stakeholders more objectivity about a student’s learning needs or the intervention required than a human instructor could typically provide. Indeed, perhaps human interaction in the learning that happens in universities, colleges and even schools might become rare; leading to a ‘premium’ style of education for those that can afford it. In the current climate of shortages of good school places and teacher shortages, AI is likely to lead to some challenging questions about the future of education in our schools and some difficult decisions for policy makers. But whether AI could offer the same level and type of emotional support that students, and particularly younger students, seem to be benefit, through their relationship with a human instructor or teacher is, as yet, unclear.

 

Chapter 3, Digital Transformation

High quality teaching is as important in schools, colleges and universities as it ever has been, though today, educators have the opportunity to augment technology to leverage the ideas that are so fundamental to learning; to deliver learning in a way that suits the way that young people want to learn, and to enhance learning yet even further. With the EdTech industry forecast to double in size by 2020, institutions will be confronted with an increasingly complex and convoluted market offering of educational technology products. Understanding disruptive technology trends and making sense of an increasingly complex educational technology market presents a formidable challenge for all educational institutions, not least because the most fundamental question of all – how technology makes learning happen best – is dependent upon a specific school or learning context and individual needs for each student. Formulating an approach to digital technology in our schools, colleges and universities that puts education and learning first is more important today than it ever has been.

Chapters 5 – 10 of this book describe such an approach, or a model, for digital transformation. This model enables projects and programmes to be seen in the wider context of a higher agenda of digital improvement; and, conversely, programmes and projects to be prioritised according to strategic aims and objectives. Like all models, they are liable to break or they may not fit precisely. Though the value of such a model, well fitting or not, is in the structure and direction it can provide in project planning and in making decisions about technology.

Digital Capability Model

In this model, transformation is segmented across six broad areas: data, communication, teaching and lecturing, learning, people and culture, and change. These six areas – or Digital Channels – are supported by a seventh channel, infrastructure and networking.

In each channel, institutions progress through five levels of digital capability shown in Figure 1 below.[6]

Figure 1: Digital Channels & Digital Capability

As institutions progress through the levels, the benefits derived from technology become ever more great. For example, at Level 3 and Level 4 in the Data and Communications channels, technology becomes strategically valuable. At Level 3 and Level 4 for Teaching & Lecturing, technology is guided by pedagogy, and for Learning, technology is guided by the learning context.

It is important to note at this point that digital capability, according to this model, is not about how well adopted a particular technology is. Rather, is about technology supports institutions and educators within each channel. At Level 4, for Learning, the technology becomes deeply contextual and it is in fact entirely plausible that levels of adoption may vary more with some types of technologies.

 
Chapter 4, Transforming Data

Understanding performance data is what enables institutions to improve. This digital channel is about utilising digital technology effectively to get the most from data and is being driven by 3rd generation MIS (Management Information Systems) that are enabling institutions to become data-driven and instantly evaluate their performance at every level.

Level 1: Initiated

At this first level, data and management information is recognised as a valued resource in evaluating performance and identifying areas for improvement at all levels within the institution. There is a need to understand and participate in external data benchmarking system.

Level 2: Organised

At this second level, management information systems are utilised as part of a well organised and coordinated approach to managing the collection, analysis and reporting of data across the institution. Practitioners are supported and trained in the use of tools for assessment and performance evaluation.

Level 3: Strategically valuable

At this level, management information systems are utilised as part of a well organised approach to managing data that supports strategic aims and objectives of the institution. Assessment and benchmarking is a valued tool for evaluating performance against strategic aims and targets.

Level 4: Data driven

At Level 4, data about the data or ‘metadata’ drives decision making. In teaching and learning, data informs and in some cases drives decisions about intervention and enables practitioners, curriculum and pastoral leaders to monitor the effectiveness of interventions as well as the effectiveness of the systems that support this.

Level 5: Optimised

At this last, aspiration level, there is a continual drive and appetite for improvement in the use of data to evaluate and improve performance at all levels. Emergent data systems and technologies are continuously and critically evaluated against institutional needs and aspirations through engagement with vendors.

Chapter 5, Transforming Communications

This Digital Channel is about utilising communications technology to better serve the information needs of practitioners, parents and institution leaders. This Digital Channel is being driven by innovations in the next generation of management information systems, enabling institutions to facilitate administrative communication tasks and provide information to parents and student groups instantly and on demand.

Level 1: Initiated

At this first level, there is a realisation that digital technologies can better serve the information needs of parents, practitioners and student groups; improve the efficiency of administrative communication tasks.

Level 2: Organised

At this level, communications technology is utilised as part of an organised and unified approach to communications. Communications technologies facilitate administrative processes for reporting and the VLE and MIS are used in conjunction with other messaging systems to engage students in learning.

Level 3: Strategically valuable

At this level, communications technology enables student groups, practitioners and educational leaders to access information and information about student attainment and progress is accessible on demand, supporting strategic priorities and programmes

Level 4: Data Oriented

At this level, communication is almost entirely targeted and relevant, and increasingly driven by data.

Level 5: Optimised

At this level, there is a continual drive for improvement in the use of communications technology to better serve teaching and learning. The benefits of emergent communications technology and information systems are evaluated through engagement with vendors against institutional needs and aspiration.

Chapter 6, Transforming Learning

This Digital Channel is about embedding digital technology into the learning context to improve learning outcomes.

Level 1: Initiated

At this first level, there is a realisation that technology is creating new opportunities for learning. There is a need to understand how technology can enhance learning traits – collaboration, interactivity, creativity, media literacy, critical thinking, problem solving, global connectedness; and improved participation and engagement.

Level 2: Valuable

At this level, technology is valuable in particular learning contexts. Technology infrastructure is acknowledged as being ‘mission critical’ in teaching and learning, and driving digital practices and innovation. Practitioners are well supported in utilising a wide range of learning tools.

Level 3: Contextual

At this level, the benefits of learning technologies are understood in the context of the institution, subject and curriculum. Practitioners are encouraged and supported in exploring technologies in areas such as student-centred and problem-based learning. Systems and structures encourage learning innovation and use of technology to improve learning outcomes.

Level 4: Deeply Contextual

At this level, technology is deeply grounded in the specific learning context. Physical spaces are re-envisaged to support innovation in learning and adoption of learning tools. Practitioners have a deep understanding of their learning context and are experts in digital pedagogies to improve learning outcomes.

Level 5: Optimised

The institution is effective at identifying and embedding learning technologies that improve learning outcomes as the technology landscape develops and evolves.

 

Chapter 7, Transforming Teaching

Digital technology is improving the way practitioners teach. This Digital Channel is about embedding digital technology in lesson planning and delivery, enabling practitioners to collaborate remotely and develop engaging interactive digital content.

Level 1: Initiated

At this level, there is a realisation that technology is a valuable teaching tool, enabling practitioners with opportunities to collaborate more effectively in the planning of lessons and to develop engaging interactive content.

Level 2: Valuable

At this level, digital technology is used extensively in the planning and delivery of lessons leading to positive teaching outcomes. Training and CPD supports practitioners in the use of technologies including virtual teaching tools, interactive technologies and the creation of digital teaching resources.

Level 3: Pedagogical

At this level, digital technology is informed by pedagogical best practices. Training and CPD in digital technologies lead to digital approaches that are successfully embedded.

Level 4: Deeply Pedagogical

At this level, digital technology is deeply informed and led by pedagogical research and the latest research into learning science.

Level 5: Optimised

At the final level, there is a continual drive and appetite for self improvement in how technology can improve the development and delivery of the curriculum.

 

Chapter 8, Transforming Change

Change is disruptive. This Digital Channel is about winning over support for digital approaches and leading and supporting individuals through change to minimise disruption and to bring about a digital transformation.

Institutions benefitting most will need to be engaged in the big educational questions about the impact of technology in learning. They will need to be open to change; have systems and structures in place that foster innovation and enable the incubation of ideas whilst ensuring that how technology is used is grounded in good practice and is always relevant to the learning context.

Level 1: Initiated

At the first level, there is a need for a digital transformation and change as aims and goals are increasingly reliant upon technology.

Level 2: Co-ordinated

At this level, digital initiatives are well coordinated across the institution. These initiatives are effective in achieving digital approaches that are well embedded and technology that is mostly adopted.

Level 3: Strategically valuable

At this level, change management structures are effective in meeting strategic objectives. Digital project ideas are evaluated against strategic goals; projects are planned leading to digital approaches that are fully embedded and technology that is fully adopted.

Level 4: Business-as-Usual

At this level, change is ’Business as Usual’. Digital technology proposals and plans are routinely informed by and evaluated against pedagogical best practice.

Level 5: Optimised

At the final level, there is a continued effort to improve the systems, roles and responsibilities for change. The outcome of digital change management initiatives are continually evaluated against digital change objectives, and needs are prioritised and supported where necessary.

 

Chapter 9, Transforming People & Culture

A digital culture is what allows digital innovation and creativity to grow and digital initiatives to succeed. This Digital Channel is about changing attitudes and perceptions to digital approaches through enabling practitioners, parents and institution leaders to realise the benefits of digital technologies.

Level 1: Initiated

At this first level, there is a growing willingness to listen to“the technology disruptors” and ideas to drive improvements in teaching, learning and assessment. There is a growing interest in learning technologies in and outside of the classroom and technology systems that offer improved efficiency in facilitating administrative and data intensive tasks.

Level 2: Collaborative

There is a culture of collaboration, exploration and measured risk-taking in the use of digital technologies in the classroom. Practitioners are supported and encouraged to explore digital alternatives to teaching and learning. Digital technology innovations and change are met with caution but persistent efforts in winning over support lead to technology and systems that are effectively embedded.

Level 3: Embraced

There is a growing culture of digital opportunism and support for digital alternatives. Caution is met with digital opportunism, and digital change initiatives are embraced leading in technology that is fully embedded.

Level 4: Adaptive

At this level, approaches to using digital technologies are embraced and technology is perceived as an enabler rather than as a barrier. There is a willingness to adapt to and trial digital approaches in teaching, learning and curriculum development.

Level 5: Optimised

At the final level, there is a self fulling culture of digital innovation and creativity.

 

Conclusion

Technology is transforming education, not just in terms of teaching and learning but in the entire operation of educational institutions and the choices that young people have about how they wish to learn and be educated.

The increasingly great choice for schools, colleges and universities in technology provision has compelled institutions and educators to think more critically about the value that technology has to offer in education and in learning.

A culture of innovation is key.

I hope that by writing this book I have, at the very least, challenged you to consider a few of the opportunities that technology has to offer; to your institution, but most importantly of all, to the young people that you teach.

But I hope I have achieved more than that. I hope that this book has caused you to think about digital transformation and overcoming barriers to technological progress within your own institution.

Thinking deeply about the reasons why technology is good in education and in learning means that transformation in our schools, colleges and universities can be from the inside-out rather than the outside-in; in other words, technology can be strategically valuable to our institutions and intrinsically valuable in learning, for our students and for our purpose as educators.

 

Bibliography

[1]     Education, D. F. (2016). Keeping children safe in education: Statutory guidance for schools and colleges. https://www.gov.uk/government/uploads/system/uploads/attachment_data/file/550511/Keeping_children_safe_in_education.pdf.

[2]     Didau, D. (2016). What If Everything You Knew About Education Was Wrong? (Paperback edition). Crown House Publishing.

[3]     Gray, S. L., & Phippen, A. (2017). Invisibly Blighted: The digital erosion of childhood. UCL IOE Press.

[4]     Bhargava, R. The Five Models of Content Curation. http://www.rohitbhargava.com/2011/03/the-5-models-of-content-curation.html.

 

Notes

[1] Throughout this book, the words ‘digital’ and ‘technological’ are used interchangeably.

[2] This point is made powerfully by David Didau in his book ‘What if everything you knew about education was wrong?’

[3] Flexible space here refers to collapsable furniture with writable surfaces and multiple project surfaces.

[4] This point is powerfully made by Gray and Phippen in their book entitled ‘Invisibly Blighted: The digital erosion of childhood.’

[5] An increasing amount of information and knowledge is only available in digital formats, for example, podcasts.

[6] Digital capability is sometimes also referred to as digital maturity.

 

Want Technology-Literate Students? Start with Their Parents

Teachers, understandably, often focus on their students. And wise teachers recognize that their students will need to be technology-literate in order the succeed in the coming years. But in order to truly accomplish this goal, teachers might be well advised to start not with the students but rather with their parents.

First, once you consider summers and holidays, children will spend more waking hours at home than at school. This means that a technology-literate home environment will benefit students in ways that a classroom infused with edtech will not. This makes it imperative to help parents become technologically literate and motivated to help their students navigate the digital world. Teachers can coach and guide parents to select edtech resources that will increase student learning during those crucial times spent outside of school, particularly during the summer. Parents are also in a position to help their students mesh edtech and real-world experiences, such as with app-guided museum tours.

Second, parents are often very concerned about the quantity and quality of the digital resources that their children are consuming, to the extent that they might disapprove of homework or enrichment assignments that require or encourage their children to spend additional time in front of a screen. It is essential for a teacher to explain the merits of any online assignments that are sent home in order to address this problem, or they run the risk that parents will not support their efforts to harness digital learning resources.

Third, parents are usually key role models for their children. And so if the parents are not using technology well, it is unlikely that their children will either. Many adults have trouble distinguishing “fake news” from accurate information, and they are likely to have children who mirror this situation if there is no intervention. Teachers are perhaps uniquely positioned to help parents, children, and entire families develop the digital literacy skills that they need to navigate the modern media environment successfully. This would include not only the ability to vet sources but also skills in managing their private data.

While it is understandable that teachers would focus their efforts at promoting digital literacy on their students, there is much to be said for a more nuanced approach that does not leave parents out of the equation. After all, today’s parents are usually young enough that they were not taught digital literacy or digital citizenship skills when they were themselves in school. Their children’s teachers just might be the ones who can fill the gap.

Why Cash-Strapped School Districts Should Turn to OER

Open Educational Resources are educational materials that are available online without any copyright restriction. These are a powerful learning tool for every student, but perhaps most especially for those students in cash-strapped school districts. Here’s why:

First, the expense of traditional printed textbooks means that underfunded school districts are not able to replace them frequently. It is difficult for teachers to teach their students when the last two or three presidential administrations are not even included in the student’s textbook. The rapid advance of technology makes this problem even worse, and students have a hard time taking a text seriously if it shows people talking on phones with cords or using computers with monitors the size of minifridges. The great benefit of OER is that it makes it possible for content to be continuously updated and for schools to use the updated versions instantly and at no cost.

Second, there is a level of personalization possible with OER that is simply not imaginable with traditional resources. One of the main purveyors of OER is CK12. Their modular materials make it possible for students to be given precisely the materials that they need. Teachers can select reading materials that cover the same topic at a higher or lower complexity, depending on the needs of the individual student. They can select reteaching and remediation materials based precisely on the learning deficits of each student. They can also permit students to select topics of their choice to study from a wide array of options. And, the variety of materials—from written narratives to videos to interactives to practice questions—ensure that students are able to select materials that are the best match for their particular learning needs. None of this is possible with a traditional textbook.

Third, OER make it possible for students to be exposed to a wider variety of viewpoints. A traditional textbook speaks with one authoritative, correlated voice. But OER allows teachers to, for example, find primary sources and scholars who present multiple sides of an issue or controversy and allow students to analyze and assess these themselves. This kind of critical thinking is essential for today’s students, and OER makes it possible.

Recent research on OER shows evidence of improved learning outcomes: students have higher retention rates and higher grades when provided with OER materials than students who did not have access to OER. OER can supplement, enhance, or even replace traditional instructional materials and will benefit students in a variety of ways.

 

 

What Are the Opportunities and Challenges of Digital Learning?

The Internet has, it is fair to say, changed everything. And, yet, the potential for digital learning has not yet been fully realized in America’s classrooms. There are also challenges associated with digital learning that barely could have been imagined several decades ago.

The opportunities associated with digital learning are immense. Perhaps the most significant benefit of digital learning tools is the ability to personalize learning. Years ago, a teacher could only dream about having the ability to design a curriculum that would be ideally suited to the skills, deficits, and preferences of every single student in the class. Rather, teachers had to be content with teaching to the average—which often meant teaching to no one in particular and leaving many students to struggle with the material. But digital edtech tools make it possible for teachers to target instructional materials to each student. LMS systems can help with organization, data analytics can help with diagnosing student performance in a fine-grained way, and the wealth of digital resources means that teachers no longer need to re-invent the wheel for each activity.

Teachers have long understood that collaborative learning increases not only student engagement but also improves learning outcomes. Digital tools such as Coggle serve as platforms that make it simple for students to brainstorm, research, organize, and present what they have learned.

At the same time, digital tools are not without their challenges. The sad truth is that the research shows that edtech sometimes does not deliver on its promises. One problem is that the life cycle of digital tools is so short that it is nearly impossible for the research to keep up. The second problem is that there is a lot of money to be made in edtech, which means that the field is crowded with purveyors who may not be well-intentioned. Even when their motives are exemplary, they often overemphasize the tech aspect of edtech to the detriment of the “ed” part and devote far more resources to the technical details of their products than to its pedagogical rigor. Further, the proliferation of edtech has made it difficult for teachers to vet materials—something that was not even part of their job description when their only instructional materials were textbooks that, while perhaps dull, had at least been expertly vetted.

The only thing that matches the promise of digital learning tools is their peril—educators and other stakeholders will need to tread carefully to ensure that their students have the best possible educational environment.