Uncategorized

Can Small Data Improve K-12 Education?

With the No Child Left Behind Act, yearly students in grades 3-8 and once in high school are tested in mathematics and reading using standardized testing. In addition, states required their own testing for school and teacher evaluation. The information gleaned from these tests are then analyzed and the goal was for data to aid policy-makers in making improvements to our education system. Unfortunately, there is now more data available than can even be consumed and student outcomes have not made any significant improvements in over a decade.

Big data is a term used to describe large amounts of collected information that can only be analyzed via computers. Big data has become a cornerstone of our education system in the U.S. but it doesn’t seem to be working, according o experts. Pasi Sahlberg, a professor at the Harvard Graduate School of Education and one of the leading experts on education practices and school reform tells the Washington Post that he believes a focus on “small data” could make vast improvements in education.

With big data not doing much to fix education in America, a new focus on small data, or a focus on what is happening in individual schools and classrooms, is emerging. As the Washington Post article points out, a better understanding of what quality teaching is and how it leads to enhanced learning in schools should be the concentration of policy-makers. Small data observes the details or small clues that uncover large trends. The idea is that by honing in on the elements that make up relationships and narratives in schools, education can be enriched.

By getting away from student assessments, more energy and resources could go to teacher training and formative school assessments. More autonomy and accountability for students would increase and improve their outcomes.

To improve teaching and learning nationwide, reformers may need to examine small data trends to gain insight into what is occurring in the classroom and how those outcomes can lead to better-quality education. If the standardized method of understanding students on a large scale isn’t working, it must change.

 

Is Competency Based Education the next big thing?

The popularity of Competency Based Education (CBE) programs has increased markedly over the past few years. CBE is self-paced, mastery oriented programs that often include the use of technology. Students must master and demonstrate competency in various tasks and skills, in order to obtain their degree. CBE offers an alternative to traditional courses, whether held in-person or online, for a set amount of time with the goal of earning a passing grade and credit hours that apply toward graduation.

There are close to 600 U.S. institutions working on rolling out CBE programs currently. Though the programs have gained notoriety, they aren’t all eligible for federal financial aid, as the Department of Education doesn’t have appropriate measures in place for evaluating credentialing structures.

Developing entire CBE programs is labor and time intensive, as well as requires a large allocation of resources from a college or university. The question now becomes, is CBE a worthwhile investment? And is CBE as good as or even better than traditional higher education models?

A 2015 study conducted by Hart Research Associates found that employers place most value on a prospective employee’s proficiency of communication, teamwork, decision-making and critical thinking skills. Therefore, an evaluation of these skills is necessary to determine the effectiveness of CBE. In order to determine the worthwhileness of CBE programs, it has been suggested that employers rate employees who have graduated from a CBE program on various work related skills. The College for America in Southern New Hampshire has already begun this evaluation process as a means to determine program effectiveness. The study is needed to determine if the investment of time and resources by the students and university is valuable.

Ideally, data from employers of traditional college graduates will eventually be compared to that of CBE graduates to determine which group has demonstrated the essential workforce skills best.

 

Lessons Gained From Learning to Physically Pull Your Own Weight

**The Edvocate is pleased to publish guest posts as way to fuel important conversations surrounding P-20 education in America. The opinions contained within guest posts are those of the authors and do not necessarily reflect the official opinion of The Edvocate or Dr. Matthew Lynch.**

A column by Rick Osbourne

Question #1: Why would anyone ever feel any need to learn to do pull ups?

Answer #1: It’s always cool to be strong and pull ups are always associated with being strong. It’s also common knowledge that people (including kids) who can do even one conventional pull up, are ALMOST NEVER OBESE. Maintain the ability (which requires decent eating/exercise habits and 30 seconds of practice per week) and you’ll AVOID OBESITY FOR LIFE.

Question #2: If you’re currently unable to do conventional pull ups, how can you systematically go about learning to do them?

Answer #2: First you LOWER THE BAR to a point where you can easily do 10 leg assisted pull ups – jumping and pulling at the same time. Work at that level every other day (1 set per day) until you can do 15 repetitions. At that point RAISE THE BAR ONE INCH and work at this new level until you can do 15 repetitions.

Continue this process of raising the bar one inch, working until you can do 15 reps, over and over again until you finally run out of leg assistance. At that point you’ll have mastered the art of doing pull ups. And at the risk of being overly redundant and repetitious, people who can do even one conventional pull up are ALMOST NEVER OBESE!* That’s really important!

Question #3: Other than being strong, cool, and avoiding obesity for life, what will you have gained from this very tangible, hands-on, physical learning experience?

Answer #3: You will have learned how to SYSTEMATICALLY ADDRESS ANY CHALLENGE by finding a place to begin successfully, increasing the workload in small increments, over time, until you’ve finally mastered the task.**

The task could be academic like learning how to read, write, do math, physics or chemistry. It could be social like learning to get along with people. It could be psychological, aesthetic, or economic. It matters not. You can address any and all challenges, and EXPECT TO SUCCEED by employing the same approach used in learning to do pull ups.***

An Experiential Reference Point

In terms of educational theory, this pull your own weight learning experience qualifies as what Professor David Ausubel calls an “Advance Organizer.” Ausubel contends that when learning anything new, the most important factor is WHAT YOU ALREADY KNOW that can serve as an experiential reference point to which you can compare and contrast the new experience (i.e. it’s similar to or different than). That reference point gives the new experience a context and meaning, as it gradually becomes assimilated into your knowledge base.

More specifically, kids who learn to do pull ups using the method described above will have gained a very tangible experience which they can use to approach any and all new learning experiences. Find a place to start successfully. Gradually increase the workload in small increments over time. And eventually they’ll master the task, no matter what it is.

The Most Important Lesson

In this light, the most important lesson gained from learning to physically pull your own weight is that you NEED NOT PASSIVELY ACCEPT the cards (in this case the inability to do pull ups) that fate has dealt you. Instead you can ACTIVELY CHOOSE to find a place to start successfully (in this case with leg assisted pull ups). Work at it regularly in order to improve gradually, over time until you have finally mastered pull ups, reading, writing, arithmetic, physics, chemistry, law, economics, history, philosophy, art, or love.

In other words, you’ll learn to pull your own weight, to take responsibility for yourself, your actions, and your life. It’s not easy. And it’s not quick. But it is simple. And it is straight forward. That said, learning to do pull ups serves as an excellent “advance organizer” for living, for becoming, and for fulfilling your potential, whatever it may be.

* This is just like lowering the rim, and gradually raising it in small increments, over time, in order to learn how to slam dunk a basketball!

**“Nothing in this world can take the place of persistence. Talent will not: nothing is more common than unsuccessful men with talent. Genius will not; unrewarded genius is almost a proverb. Education will not: the world is full of educated derelicts. Persistence and determination alone are omnipotent.” Calvin Coolidge

***We’re staunch proponents of self-competition (Johnny this week vs Johnny last week) instead conventional competition (Johnny vs Jimmy).

—

Rick Osbourne is former physical educator and a pioneer in the field of functional childhood obesity prevention. He currently serves as President of the Pull Your Own Weight Foundation which is an Illinois based, 501c3, not for profit organization whose focus is functional childhood obesity prevention. He’s written and published three books in this field, the latest of which is entitled Beating Childhood Obesity Now: A Simple Solution for Parents and Educators. He’s the Examiner’s national childhood obesity prevention correspondent. He writes an online column for The Edvocate. And you can connect with Rick via Twitter, Linkedin, or Facebook.

Is North Carolina A&T losing its identity?

North Carolina Agricultural and Technical State University, a historically black college and university (HBCU), is in a bit of a crisis.

The school, formed in 1891 under the name “Agricultural and Mechanical College for the Colored Race,” A&T was recently restructured by the North Carolina Committee on Education Planning, Policies and Programs.

Reorganizing for the school means that the College of Arts and Sciences will be no more along with the School of  Technology. The other school that will partner with NC A&T is the University of North Carolina at Greensboro.

UNC-G and NC A&T came together last year for a joint nursing program, partnered in 2011 to form the Joint School of Nanoscience and Nanoengineering, and in 1997 did so for the Joint Master of Social Work Program.

A history of working together, it makes sense on the surface for the schools to continue its partnerships. But as A&T continues its stride towards efficiency, many have concerns that the school’s rich history will soon be too diluted to notice.

Liberal arts seems to be on its way out and one instructor, Derick Smith, at A&T believes that the school is being marched towards focusing on STEM (Science, Technology, Engineering, and Math) majors, which receives a good amount of funding.

Smith makes a good point about STEM and how the local and federal government has pivoted towards pushing students to a career in the field.

President Obama notoriously chided liberal arts as economically impractical compared to attaining a skill like being a mechanic or painter. He was, for lack of a better term, being pragmatic when it comes to choices in education.

STEM isn’t for everybody, though. Pushing more students to a field that may not fit their interest or skill set is just as dangerous as removing focus from allowing students a vocational education.

It’s also unfortunate that we may be seeing the slow end of NC A&T. As more HBCUs look for ways to increase enrollment and remain culturally viable, each one will also try to straddle the line between keeping its history and moving towards a more diverse future.

Twitter Accusations Strain HBCUs Relationship

In a disturbing string of tweets posted to Twitter last week, an anonymous student at all-women’s Spelman College stated that she was gang raped by students from neighboring Morehouse College, an all-male college.

The schools, both considered Historically Black Colleges and Universities (HBCUs) are unofficially connected and have enjoyed a close relationship for years. Within the Spelman student’s tweets was a disturbing accusation that a school official from Spelman spurred her not to move forward with her accusations as it may damage the relationship between the two schools.

But the Spelman student’s tweets went viral and sparked protests and two widely used hashtags, #RapedByMorehouse and #RapedAtSpelman.

Morehouse said that the allegations of sexual assault would be fully investigated once a formal complaint was filed, but pressure from students and outsiders may have changed things.

This past Tuesday, Morehouse President John Wilson Jr. released a statement saying that a full and thorough investigation will be conducted, though he did not state if a formal complaint was ever filed.

Spelman President Mary Schmidt announced a review of the complaint last week prior to Morehouse launching a probe into the events.

This isn’t the first time both schools have come under fire for allegations of sexual assault. In January, two Spelman students came forward with allegations of being sexually assaulted by students from brother school Morehouse College. Those claims prompted an investigation by the Department of Education into whether both schools have violated Title IX.

It’s important to note that a study released by RTI International found that complaints of sexual assault on Historically Black College and University campuses were much lower than on other campuses.

While the numbers may be lower at HBCUs, one assault on campus is too many as college campuses are supposed to be safe spaces for all students.

Mayor of Houston Celebrates Digital Education Day

Sylvester Turner lauds local educators for their work to transform education and bring equity to learning 

(Houston, TX) May 2, 2016 — On April 21st, the Director of Education for the City of Houston, Dr. Juliet Stipeche, presented the Learning Counsel and all area school districts a proclamation for “Digital Education Day.” On behalf of Mayor Sylvester Turner, Stipeche honored the educators for their united and dedicated work to bridge the equity gap and help all students ready themselves for a 21st-century workforce.

Stipeche, formerly a board member for Houston Independent School District, was appointed by the Mayor just three months ago to create greater collaboration between the city and area schools and to bridge a social divide that is often driven by an inadequate or uncoordinated education system.

“Nothing is more important than a good education for our youth that makes them college and career ready,” stated Stipeche. “There is nothing more honorable than what our Houston area schools and teachers are doing every single day for our children. And what the Learning Counsel is doing with their events to help districts make the digital transition is unique and valuable and is being recognized appropriately today.”

The presentation of the recognition came during the Digital Curriculum Tactics Discussion at Kingdom Builders’ Community Center in Houston. In attendance were 70 educational executives, including representatives from virtually all area school districts: Houston ISD, Katy ISD, Pasadena ISD, Fort Bend ISD, Dickenson ISD, Columbia-Brazoria ISD, Deer Park ISD, and Spring Branch ISD.

“We’re very proud to get this acknowledgement, but it’s really for the school leaders, teachers, and the students who are all part of this important shift in education,” said LeiLani Cauthen, the CEO of the Learning Counsel. “We’ve traveled to 54 cities in the last two years to work with superintendents and their executive teams on the transition to digital curriculum and content. We’re extremely excited about what we’ve seen and the promise of helping millions of students be truly prepared for their future.”

The day ended with a leadership panel, sponsored by Huawei Education Solutions, where equity for all, as stated in the Mayor’s proclamation, was a central theme. Andrew Houlihan, the Chief Academic Officer of Houston ISD, pointed out that every child should have the right of anywhere, anytime access to digital learning materials in order to be successful. “In many schools, we will soon have no more textbooks at all. So when a student can’t get to their laptop or iPad and have it be connected, what is he to do? At the end of the day, these devices and the digital curriculum are the new textbook, so you can’t withhold that from them.”

About The Learning Counsel

The Learning Counsel is a mission-based organization focused on helping education professionals in the K-12 sector gain context on the shift to digital curriculum. Serving as an intermediary between schools, curriculum publishers, and high tech companies, the Learning Counsel provides perspective and organizational tools on the transition to digital for school systems across the country.

For more information about the Learning Counsel, please visit TheLearningCounsel.com.

Read all of our posts about EdTech and Innovation by clicking here. 

New Report Details Rising Cost to Attend College

Breaking news: college is expensive. A new report by the Institute for Research on Higher Education at the University of Pennsylvania details just how high the cost of college truly is for students.

But a few revelations within the report may shatter some of the thoughts we had about the cost of college. For example, community colleges, or two-year institutions of higher learning, are not that cheap for many students.

In Mississippi, families that make $30,000 or less will pay nearly 50 percent of their yearly income to attend a community college. Mississippi is one of the poorest states in the nation because it has one of the highest poverty rates in the country.

The most expensive state to attend college is New Hampshire where the poor have to shell out close to 160 percent of their income for admission into a non-profit, private college.

Alabama isn’t much better. For admittance into the University of Alabama, poor families have to pay 90 percent of its income to attend. Alabama, like Mississippi, is one of the worst states in terms of the number of residents who live in poverty.

The average loan amount to attend a public two-year college in Massachusetts is over $4,000, and for a private four-year non-doctoral school, the average in Wyoming is close to $10,000.

The news gets worse as the report reveals that financial aid hasn’t kept up with the rising cost of college, so it’s no longer a powerful purchasing tool to attend college. Just as wage stagnation has dogged many workers across the country, the same may be said for financial aid.

This is all compounded as many states, especially in the south, have moved to cut money from higher education, which has contributed the boom in college costs.

But the report notes that because many lawmakers have vowed to help bring down the cost of college that all is not lost. Only problem is it may be too late as many families have already been priced out of sending their kids to college.

Report shows that more blacks attending, graduating college

The cost of college may be high and rising, but that hasn’t stopped many students from attending and graduating from college. Specifically black students, the number of African-Americans going to college has increased.

According to a new study by the Pell Institute for the Study of Opportunity in Higher Education, blacks attending institutions of higher education has been on the rise for years despite some being priced out of attending college.

With an improvement in the economy since the 1970’s, more black Americans have better jobs and more access to income. More black students have high school diplomas and have the opportunity to go to college.

But with any study, there is nuance. While more black students are attending college and attaining degrees, there is still room for improvement. The Pell Institute’s study suggests 16 ways to improve access to college for many students as there is still a wide education gap in America.

One way to close the gap is to increase funding for low-income students. As another study notes about the affordability of college for some students, the cost to attend a two-year higher education in some states is out of range for many families.

In Mississippi, the cost is so high to go to a community college that poor families may have to pay up to 50 percent of their income to send a member of their family to college.

Carving out additional funds for students who may have issues paying for college is important, but as many states have cut funding for higher education, that money may not be readily available.

Another controversial measure would be making two-year colleges free as well as allowing students who attending four-year colleges to go for free their first two years.

This means that the price of college has gotten so high that the only way to make it accessible for poor students is to make it free because the market has priced too many students out of gaining a college education.

NFL, HBCUs partner to create more opportunities for black students

The National Football League and two Historically Black Colleges and University conferences have partnered to create opportunities for minorities interested in pursuing a career in football administration.

The NFL will start its partnership with the MEAC (Mid-Eastern Athletic Conference) and the SWAC (Southwestern Atlantic Athletic Conference) and will provide support and assistance to both conferences.

Within the partnership, the NFL/SWAC/MEAC will ensure that more black students have chances to become part of the front office personnel for NFL clubs as well as chances to become coaches, general managers, scouts, and etc…

Some of the schools included in the partnership include Howard University, Grambling State University, Florida A&M University, Alabama State University, North Carolina A&T State University, and many other prestigious HBCUs.

There is certainly a need for more diversity in NFL coaching ranks as an ESPN The Magazine report detailed just how dire the situation is and how badly the league needs more coaches of color.

While the NFL has instituted the Rooney Rule to ensure that at least one minority candidate is interviewed for an open head coaching position, it does not go far enough apparently. A study completed by a consortium of college professors found that white coaches in the NFL are twice as likely to be promoted than black coaches regardless of performance.

The numbers have gotten better but there is still room for improvement. There are less than 10 black head coaches in the NFL with 32 teams in the league.

The NFL’s partnership with the MEAC/SWAC is hopefully a way to honestly improve the number of black head coaches in the league as well as general managers and not just a way to fill open jobs that aren’t within the realm of decision making.

But this new alliance will create a canal for minorities who want access to the NFL but would have problems getting in the traditional way.

South Carolina School Bans Transgender Boy from Bathroom

Last week, the Transgender Law Center threatened to sue Horry County Schools in South Carolina for unfair treatment of a student. The school system suspended a high school age transgender male student for using the boys’ restroom at his school, according to The Washington Post.

The group now says that the school district has changed their tune and agrees to erase the suspension from the boy’s record and permit students to visit the restroom that matches their gender identity.  In addition, Horry County Schools consented to notify the faculty of the restroom access rights for transgender students’.

Kris Hayashi, executive director of the Transgender Law Center, thanks the school system for doing what is right and treating the transgender students in a fair manner. Hayashi highlights that it’s illegal to ban students from utilizing the bathroom that matches the gender he or she lives as on a daily basis.

Restroom access has recently become a hot topic in the fight over LGBT rights and has led to many debates in various states in the U.S.

The Obama administration argues that Title IX defends the rights of students to use restrooms in agreement with their gender identity.

A Socastee High School statement said that schools in Horry County have not altered the restroom policies for students, but came to the conclusion that students who are transgender, and their parents, can ask for restroom rights that support the latest court ruling. The school administrators, with the students and parents, will decide what is fair and legal in order to obey with the law and reflect on the rights of each student.

The law center said that the student has used the boy’s restroom since middle school, and his freshman, sophomore, and junior years at the high school. In his senior year, the student was told to instead use the girls’ restroom, and was suspended for using a boys’ bathroom in the middle of a pep rally.

After the suspension, the student decided to finish his senior year at an online school.

The student said he is in school to learn. He pointed out that he should be able to use he restroom when he needs to without fear that teachers are following him or policing which restroom he uses.

It’s a shame the South Carolina school went as far as to suspend the student for using the restroom in accordance with his gender. I am glad that after the incident, the school made it a point to inform teachers of the bathroom access rights, but find it frustrating that the student was punished and ended up leaving the school as a result of the way he was treated.