Uncategorized

Educators: Is Your Grading On-Point?

Grading is at the crux of educational evaluation. It’s a major factor in designating student success, and it’s a vital skill that every educator needs to have firm hold of. Are you grading effectively? Are you grading correctly? Read on to find out how you measure up on grading competence.

Succinctly, grades represent the extent to which the learner has met the defined objectives. Teachers generally define these objectives at the beginning of the year, aided by benchmarks, such as statewide academic achievement standards. Grading is an emotionally laden procedure that implies more than the degree of compliance with the goals.

Before beginning to teach a class, teachers should think of and choose the grading criteria; students appreciate a grading system that is fair, consistent, and easy to understand. Grades serve the following purposes:

1. Provide feedback to students on their rate of achievement.
2. Help students evaluate their own strengths and weaknesses.
3. Properly used (not inflated), grades serve as a positive motivating factor by rewarding students 
for their progress.
4. Communicate student achievement to others, including potential employers and graduate schools.
5. Select students for special programs (such as remedial or advanced).

You’ll need to be familiar with different grading methods according to what you’re required to compare or measure. For example, if the principal asks you to send a report of the students’ best and worst grades, you’d probably need to use a norm-referenced grading model. On the other hand, if the principal wants to know to what extent all the students in the class have reached the goals set at the beginning of the year, you’d probably use a criterion-referenced model.

In a norm-referenced grading model, the students are ranked against each other comparatively. In a criterion-referenced grading model, the students are not compared to a norm group, but rather are required to reach a predetermined standard.

You’ll be required to adhere to your school district’s grading policy, which will be provided to you. These policies may also differ from one district to another. You will find out that grading comes with its own set of challenges. For instance, as teachers, we may encounter the following dilemma: Should we take into account each of our students’ motivation and effort when grading? Is it fair for those who have no academic issues? This controversy has been heatedly debated and will continue to be a contentious subject.

School authorities often insist that work on values, ethics, citizenship, and cooperation should be fostered in class and formally included in the yearly syllabus. However, these topics are not considered in the yearly achievement tests or standardized tests discussed in this chapter. School curricula are structured to grade students on the meeting of objectives but not on the progress made during the year, and this might not be the appropriate perspective for the assessment of learning.

We cannot base grading solely on motivation and effort at an early stage (grade inflation), because reality dictates that students will be measured by standards later in life. Imagine hiring a lawyer, then discovering some days later that he never actually passed his exams at college, but that he was so pleased to attend classes that professors always passed him and he finally got his degree. How would you feel about it? Grades represent the means by which students judge their own academic achievements and are judged by others.

A classroom teacher will always be confronted with this conundrum, and students will test the limits of the teacher’s propensity for grade inflation. Therefore, teachers need to be committed to conscientious grading. When grading, teachers should assess whether the learner has acquired the necessary content. Values, group work, ethical behavior, and motivation should be taken into account; however, they should not deeply influence grading. A balance should be struck between humanistic and academic matters, laying emphasis on the learning goals defined in advance, so that grades reflect the achievement objectives established at the beginning of the year.

Think about the students in your classroom and the academic and personal goals they have. Does your grading focus on evaluating those aspects? Make sure your evaluations fit what really needs to be brought to light.

Tips and Tricks for Providing Quality Performance Feedback

Feedback is a highly nuanced skill that every educator needs to develop. While grading is often guided by outside standards or easily quantified metrics, feedback has less structure around it. What kinds of feedback are out there? How do can you, as an educator, give feedback effectively?

Giving feedback is disseminating information to students about their progress. Sometimes feedback is given to the whole class; at other times it is given to small groups or individuals. The aim of performance feedback is to help students understand where the problem is and what they can do to solve it.

Two types of feedback need to be differentiated: performance feedback and correction feedback. Performance feedback is concerned with the information that students receive after completing an assignment. The teacher shows the students the extent of their success and failure and gives them advice. Correction, on the other hand, may occur during the process of completing the assignment. Later in this discussion, you’ll explore different techniques for appropriately applying performance feedback and correction.

As mentioned, feedback can either tarnish or boost a student’s self-concept, and it can depend on whether you deliver the information about their performance positively or negatively. You should share your expectations with the students, including what you require of them on a day-to-day basis, what goals they’re supposed to reach, and what steps they can take to reach those goals. This is considered the heart of effective classroom feedback.

You should also bear in mind that feedback needs to be balanced. In other words, you should tell students what they’ve already been able to master and then move on to telling them of other areas that still need revising, as well as the best way to go about it. Praise is important when giving feedback. It may be as simple as saying “Nice job!” or could involve a more detailed analysis. This type of encouragement is of great importance for less-confident students. Feedback criteria should be defined according to the teacher’s expectations for individual students. Some students may need lots of encouragement to speak up in class, and therefore a teacher should avoid overcorrecting the student too frequently, while confident students may be able to handle more correction.

In this article, we talk about the basics and take a look at the category of “performance” feedback. However, that’s not the only kind of feedback out there. Educators also need to know how to deliver “corrective” feedback. If you’re unsure of what that means, or how to give it, check out our follow-up article, “Educators: Ensure Your Corrective Feedback Is Top-Notch.”

Educators: Ensure Your Corrective Feedback Is Top-Notch

Giving feedback isn’t just about indicating errors – it’s about prompting improvement, too. “Corrective” feedback refers to exactly that kind of commentary. But what does that look like, practically?

Sometimes you’ll need to correct grammatical mistakes in assignments. Some teachers assume that this will hurt students’ feelings and that they will consequently have a negative reaction toward learning. Corrective feedback, if delivered thoughtfully and kindly, will usually not undermine a student’s self-confidence. The best way to encourage students to correct their mistakes is to provide them with a correct example. Moreover, for feedback to be effective, it should be focused on the area where the student excelled or made a mistake, whether its math, science, writing, etc. For example, “Have another look at this word, there’s a problem with spelling,” instead of “There’s a mistake in your essay.”

Here are several ways of providing students with corrective feedback; corrective feedback should be done privately whenever possible, and can be done both verbally or in writing:

1. Explicit correction: The teacher points out what was wrong and provides the student with the correct version. This technique does not leave room for peer or self-correction. Therefore, the correction may not be recorded, due to embarrassment or lack of interest.

2. Reformulating: The teacher reformulates the chunk of the sentence in which the mistake was spotted. This type of correction has a negative impact on the learning process.

3. Elicitation: The teacher asks the student for reformulation or clarification. For example: “What do you mean?” or “Could you please explain that again?”

4. Metalinguistic clues: The teacher helps the student to spot the mistake by supplying extra information or asking questions related to the student’s answer.

5. Repetition: The teacher corrects using intonation to show where the mistake is.

Feedback about student errors may be given in several ways; different techniques are used for different types of mistakes. For oral correction, gestures or facial expressions are useful to avoid interrupting and simultaneously show students they’ve made a mistake. The gestures you can use may depend on the cultural background of the group you’ve been assigned to, so try to familiarize yourself with what your students are more comfortable with. “Echo correcting,” which involves repeating the error with emphasis, is also a useful technique when the teacher wants to point out a slip has been made without actually saying, “You’ve made a mistake.” You should also ask for help from another student if the student in question cannot spot the mistake, but remember to do so in a sensitive manner.

You can choose to ignore certain mistakes while the activity is in progress and make notes for later feedback. You should probably ignore mistakes that are beyond the student’s scope of understanding or are far from classroom goals. By doing this, you’ll allow students to gain confidence and, consequently, fluency. You’ll have to choose what’s appropriate for the learning purpose, the individual, and the context, and often this can only come from experience. Remember, feedback is closely related to monitoring, and feedback can be offered while students are engaged in pair work or group work, or right after the lesson.

Corrective feedback can be a magnificent tool when implemented well. It’s doubly powerful when combined with performance feedback. Check out our article, “Tips and Tricks for Providing Quality Performance Feedback” to learn more about the latter category and how you can effectively bring it into play in evaluating students.

Three Handy Rubrics for Assessment Creation

When it comes to creating classroom assessments, educators have a lot of leeway as to form, content, and length. Sometimes, the breadth available can be a little overwhelming. If you’re stalling when it comes time to draw up evaluations for your students – don’t fear! We’ve got a set of handy guides to help you get your assessment-brain inspired!

Rubric 1 – Seven Forms of Assessment:

1. Forced Choice

  • Multiple choice, matching, true/false, fill-in-the-blank
  • Can be scored objectively
  • Most common form of assessment
  • Choose from among alternatives given

2. Essay

  • Good for assessing thinking, reasoning, and expression skills
  • Opportunity to demonstrate knowledge of relationships
  • Gives information on how students process knowledge
  • Scoring can be subjective

3. Short Written Responses

  • Mini-essays
  • Brief explanations of information or processes
  • Scoring more objective than for essays

4. Oral Reports

  • Assess student speaking ability
  • Similar to essay but more impromptu
  • Require acute listening skills to score

5. Teacher Observation

  • Informal
  • Best for process-oriented and non achievement factors
  • Good when linked to interview
  • Teacher notes used to record observation results

6. Student Self-Assessment

  • Most underused form of assessment
  • Helps develop higher-order metacognitive skills
  • Assessment conference allows student to clarify own level of learning

7. Performance Tasks

  • Require student to construct responses, apply knowledge
  • Require more than recall of information
  • Can assess a variety of forms of knowledge and skills
  • Scoring dependent on task
  • Rubric 2 – Examples of the Types of Questions that Encourage Students to Show Different Ways of Knowing:

1. Analysis Questions

What are the key parts?
Which parts are essential and why?

2. Comparison Questions

How are these alike?
What specific characteristics are similar?
How are these different?
In what way(s) are they different?

3. Connections/Clarification Questions

Into what groups could you organize these things?
What are the rules for membership in each group?
What are the defining characteristics of each group?

4. Constructing Support Questions

What data can you cite that support this conclusion?
What is an argument that would support this claim?

5. Deduction Questions

On the basis of this rule, what would you deduce?
What are the conditions that make this inevitable?

6. Inferring and Concluding Questions

On the basis of these data, what would you conclude?
How likely is it that this will occur?

7. Abstracting Questions

What pattern underlies all of these situations?
What are the essential characteristics of this thing?

8. Error Analysis

How is this conclusion misleading?
What does not match?

Rubric 3 – Types of Performance Assessment Tasks:

1. Learning logs and journals

What It Is:
Notes, drawings, data, charts, artwork, and other notes written by the student

Uses:
Encourages reflection as one is learning.
Provides a record of questions and thoughts.

Tips for the Teacher for Effective Use:
Generate questions for students to ponder and respond to.
Make the questions as varied as possible.

2. Folios and Portfolios

What It Is:
Folio is the storage bin, box, or file. Portfolio is the organization and presentation of selected folio artifacts for a particular purpose.

Uses:
Documents learning and growth over time.
Encourages self-assessment.
Shows student’s best work.

Tips for the Teacher for Effective Use:
Ask students to explain why they have included the various items.
Require entries to be tied to standards.
Provide feedback.
Discuss the portfolio with students and 
their parents.

3. Interviews

What It Is:
Peers and/or the teacher asking a set of questions.

Uses:
Helps determine what has been learned.

Tips for the Teacher for Effective Use:
Use a variety of question types to obtain a range of responses.

4. Observation with anecdotal record

What It Is:
Observing and note taking during day-to-day activities.

Uses:
Provides documentation of performance and learning over time.

Tips for the Teacher for Effective Use:
Conduct observations on a regular basis.
Write notes clearly and include specific 
descriptions of what was observed.
Review notes.
Distinguish carefully between facts and 
interpretations.

5. Student Products and Projects

What It Is:
Specific products such as lab reports, presentations, and digital productions.

Uses:
Provides cumulative evidence about the extent of learning.

Tips for the Teacher for Effective Use:
Display student work.

Next time you need to create an assessment but are coming up empty-handed, pull out one of these rubrics to help you think up the best test for your students! If you need more than just an outline to help you brush up on assessment creation, check out our full set of articles on what goes into classroom assessment and how you can make the most of your evaluations!

Report: School funding lower than before Great Recession

A new report on public school funding in the U.S. finds that most states now receive less support per K-12 student than prior to the 2007-2009 Great Recession. In addition, some states continue to decrease funding.

Published by the Center on Budget and Policy Priorities, a nonprofit research and policy institute, the report cites what is says is the most current data available on each state and local funding. After adjusting for inflation, it found:

  • In at least 31 states, the funding provided was less per student in the year ended in 2014 than in the 2008 school year prior to the recession taking hold. The cuts surpassed 10 percent in at least 15 states.
  • In at least 18 states, local government funding per student fell over the same period. In at least 27 states, local funding increased. Very few of the states increased funding made up for the initial cuts in support. Total funding nationally declined between 2008 and 2014 in states where comparable data exists.
  • While comprehensive data on the current (2016) school year is unavailable, it is known that at least 25 states are providing less “general” funding — the primary form of state funding per school — per student than in 2008. The cuts surpassed 10 percent in seven states.
  • Most states raised the “general” funding per pupil slightly this year. However, 12 states imposed new cuts in funding, despite evidence that the economy has continually improved. The states, including Wisconsin, Oklahoma, and Arizona, experienced the deepest cuts since the recession hit.

The report says that the consequences of K-12 state-level spending include weakening a key funding source for school districts, slowing the economy’s recovery form the recession, and impeding reforms widely acknowledged to boost students achievement, such as improved teacher quality and reduced class sizes.

4 Things High School Students Should Know Before Graduation

As the stakes rise regarding the necessity of a high school diploma for lifelong success, so do the standards to earn one. High school graduates today must know more than the generations that came before them, both in academic and real-world applications. All of the lesson planning from Kindergarten forward funnels student information into the end goal of high school and college graduation.

While rigorous academics can certainly prepare students for college, which is just one facet of what I believe they should know. There is no way to totally prepare a young adult for the realities of the college experience and what it will mean for his or her long-term success, but there are some things that high school educators should emphasize, including:

The cost of a college education. We are so quick to push our students towards a college education that we often forget the practicalities. While in most cases a college degree will pay off in the end, it is expensive upfront and can have an impact on the early years of adulthood. It is flawed thinking to assume that young people with very limited experience with their personal finances will truly be able to comprehend the cost and sacrifice of a college education. Any efforts to better inform students about the responsibility and reality of a college education should not be undertaken as a discouragement but rather as a way to inform them of what those things will mean in real-life settings. Things like estimated college loan repayments, and for how long, should be discussed and put in terms of how many hours of work that money will end up equaling.

The importance of a college degree. While it does come at a cost, a college degree is well worth it over the course of a lifetime. People with bachelor degrees earn nearly $1 million more over their lifetimes than their peers who receive high school diplomas. People with master’s degrees earn closer to $1.3 million more. So even the most expensive colleges, if paid out of pocket and through loans, still do not tally up to the lifetime earnings potential of a college graduate versus a high school one. A college degree holds more than financial value though. There is the issue of job stability and security too. By 2018, over 60 percent of jobs will require a college degree and that number is sure to rise. This next generation of K-12 students simply cannot afford to bypass college learning and this should be emphasized to high school students whenever higher education is discussed.

The outlook in the industry of interest. From a young age, children are asked the inevitable “what do you want to be when you grow up?” question. With stars in their eyes, they talk about the jobs that seem the most glamorous – firefighters, movie stars, doctors and maybe even teachers. While all of these are noble career choices, high school students should have a firm grasp on the field they want to pursue in terms of job opportunities and earning potential. Again, this is not to discourage students from following what they believe to be their calling – but it is a way to guide them into their field of interest with eyes wide open.

Alternatives to college. What if a student cannot afford to go to college; what do they do then? We have to explain to students that sometimes life throws you lemons, but that doesn’t mean you should just give up and settle for less. We have to teach them that here are other ways to get the education they want without shelling out huge amounts of cash or placing themselves in debt.

Short diploma courses, like the diploma of community services from BCA National are geared towards offering practical learning, without the huge price tag. The best thing about short courses, particularly online ones, are that they are affordable and offer tremendous flexibility as well as a real diploma that people can use in their job applications. Students may want to consider obtaining this type of practical training if they need to gain skills that will be useful in various types of positions.

What else should high school students know after high school?

Read all of our posts about EdTech and Innovation by clicking here. 

Do American sex education classes make the grade?

The Center’s for Disease Control and Prevention recently released grades rating U.S. schools sex education programs. American high schools received good marks, though there is room for improvement in some areas.

According to the report, 94 percent of high schools taught students the benefits of abstinence, 92 percent covered how family, friends and our culture can influence sexual behaviors, 95 percent of schools discussed what an STD is and how they are spread, while 85 percent covered how to receive products and services to aid in STD and pregnancy prevention.

High schools didn’t do as great a job providing specific information regarding condoms. Seventy percent of schools discussed the importance of condom usage, 60 percent explained how to procure condoms and 54 percent actually demonstrated how to properly use a condom.

Public health officials stress the importance of teaching sexual education in schools, specifically in an effort to reduce students risk of contracting HIV or other STDs. Teens and young adults account for nearly half of the 20 million new sexually transmitted infections reported yearly. Effective sex ed courses can also reduce the teen pregnancy rate, which increases the likelihood of females dropping out of school and places their children on a path of decreased health and lower achievement.

A few states, Delaware, New Hampshire and New Jersey, scored 100 percent for providing information on abstinence and an additional 15 states scored a 95 percent or higher. However, just 56 percent of Arizona high schools discussed the benefit of abstaining from sex, as did a mere 60 percent of Alaska schools.

Only 46 percent of high schools in America covered all 16 topics relating to HIV, other STDs and pregnancy prevention. Generally, we need to be more intentional and direct in providing the next generation of young people with the skills and information necessary to protect their health.

 

Missouri bill aims to stop college players from striking

A proposed bill in Missouri would impose a penalty on college athletes who decide to strike.

According to Chicagotribune.com, Missouri Republican Rick Brattin submitted a bill that “would strip scholarships from any athlete who calls, incites, supports or participates in any strike.”

The bill also calls for colleges and universities to hand down fines to any “coaching staff who encourage or enable such student protests.”

Brattin’s bill is in response to Missouri football players striking, or standing in protest, with students on campus who were upset at how the university mishandled complaints of racial mistreatment that many black students have been subjected to.

One graduate student, Jonathan Butler, staged a hunger strike until former University of Missouri President Tim Wolfe resigned. It eventually worked as Wolfe stepped down not long after the story made national headlines.

But Republicans in Missouri are looking for order to be returned to the university. Another proposed bill may cut the school’s budget if the school is besieged by protests again.

These bills raise the larger issue of the options that students have if their concerns aren’t being met. Students, specifically black students, felt that their voices were not only being muffled, but they were completed muted.

Because the school’s administration failed to address the concerns of the students, many felt that protesting was the only way to make a change.

Suspending that ability and threatening to take scholarships away isn’t going to change a rotten culture by proposing legislating to make the problem worse.

How the ESSA update will impact disadvantaged students

With President Obama signing the new Every Student Succeeds Act, or ESSA, many are wondering what effect the changes in schools will have on minority students, students with disabilities and low-income students.

Some worry the gap between students will not be narrowed with the adoption of the Every Student Succeeds Act. Professor of education at the University of California, Los Angeles and director of the Center for the Study of School Transformation, Pedro Noguera, told NPR that he fears ESSA furthers the belief that we can minimize inequality and increase academic outcomes simply by focusing on schools.

Interestingly enough, ESSA is the most current version of the Johnson administration’s Elementary and Secondary Act of 1965, which heavily addressed poverty and underserved students. During the 1970s, large scale gains were made in closing the gaps in academic achievement as school integration and poverty were focused on abundantly.

The situation is often bleak where poverty is heavily concentrated. Unless as a nation we are able to invest in schools the way we did in the past, we can’t expect to see inequalities disappear. The hope is that with focusing on schools at the local level, officials can more effectively pinpoint issues and in turn determine viable solutions for those problems.

It is in our best interest that all children receive quality education. As a nation, we cannot afford to have  large numbers of individuals who are under-educated and stuck in low-income jobs. The best way to an equitable society is to focus on education and providing individuals with the proper set of skills necessary to enter and flourish in the workforce.

The Every Student Succeds Act may help rebalance inequality. Though many believe it’ll be up to the next President and Secretary of Education and whether they focus more on teaching and learning, versus placing the spotlight on assessment, as we’ve seen so readily in the past.

Click here to read all our posts concerning the Achievement Gap.

Mandatory recess in Florida’s public elementary schools?

A group of central Florida mothers have written a bill that asks lawmakers to consider making recess mandatory in the state’s public elementary schools. The bill would require no less than 20 uninterrupted minutes of recess each school day for public elementary students. Teachers would not be able to withhold recess time as punishment for students if the bill passes. Currently, each school in the district can independently determine how much time to allotted to recess on a daily basis.

Often times recess is the highlight of a student’s day at school. It is a time to mentally and physically recharge from a grueling day filled with primarily sedentary activities. It is often apparent when children do not receive proper recess time and aren’t able to exert energy that tends to build throughout the school day. Palm Beach County Superintendent Robert Avossa says, “We joke and call it the wiggles, we gotta get the wiggles out, they gotta move their bodies.”

Parents and administrators alike believe in the value of recess, the issue seems to be whether or not there are enough hours in the day to make it a daily requirement. So much is packed into the school day already and much of the curriculum and activities are already mandatory. Some believe the only way to incorporate daily recess is to extend the school day.

Florida’s mandatory recess for public elementary schools bill will be reviewed in the state House and Senate and will work through the legislative process next year.