Uncategorized

Einstein’s formula and childhood obesity prevention

**The Edvocate is pleased to publish guest posts as way to fuel important conversations surrounding P-20 education in America. The opinions contained within guest posts are those of the authors and do not necessarily reflect the official opinion of The Edvocate or Dr. Matthew Lynch.**

A column by Rick Osbourne

E = MC2 is probably the world’s most famous formula. With it, innovator, scientist, physicist, mathematician, and overall genius Albert Einstein took a plethora of factors into consideration and boiled them all down into his famous formula which turned out to be the key to calculating how much stored up energy is in any given volume of matter.

In other words Einstein took many different factors into account, consolidated and simplified them down in a formula that could be used to create nuclear plants that power the future, and (much to his dismay) nuclear weapons that could destroy it. His genius was found in his ability to organize, relate, consolidate, boil down, and simplify disparate pieces of a large and complex puzzle, and to transform all that information into a usable tool for the benefit of mankind.

Keep it Simple Stupid

The same could be said of other great innovators from Gutenberg who invented the printing press, to Whitney who invented the cotton gin, Thomas Edison who invented electricity, Bell who invented the telephone, to Gates and Jobs who invented the modern world of computers. Each of them took a multiplicity of yet to be organized ideas, pulled them together, tested and retested them in various combinations in order to validate their predictability. Then they expressed their findings in relatively simple and user friendly terms.

While the FORE Score Protocol is certainly no E =MC2, it still represents a simplification of the complex, confusing, and often frustrating problem of childhood obesity prevention. On the other hand, it addresses America’s Number One Health Threat (according to the US Surgeon General) so we’re not dealing with chopped liver either.

Let Me Count the Ways

Now then, how many variables are we dealing with? For starters, it’s calories in VS calories out, eating less/better and exercising more. Then you factor in the modern day fast food diet that’s exacerbated by working moms who lack the time to cook for their kids and opt for McMeals instead. Throw in the TV, the video games, the computer, and cell phone that all conspire to make sure 21st century kids are physically less and less active. Add to this list the constant advertising and propaganda that brainwashes kids into wanting sugary foods, the lack of daily physical education in school, the genetics and the economics that all play a role, and you’ll see how things can get real complicated real fast.

Let’s Simplify

In contrast, OPYOW makes one simple observation. Kids who can do pull ups are ALMOST NEVER OBESE. Therefore, as kids learn to physically pull their own weight, they learn to actively eliminate obesity from their own lives. In the process they learn to take responsibility for themselves in a world that so often systematically discourages self-determination and self-respect.

In other words, despite the fast food, the TV, video games and computer, the advertising, lack of PE, the genetics and the economics, show me ten kids who can do even one pull up and I’ll show you ten kids who are not obese! That’s not to say what these kids eat, or how much they exercise plays no role. It’s not to say that these infinitely researched parts of the childhood obesity puzzle play no role. They do play a role in everything, including the ability to do pull ups!

Actionable Solutions VS Hand Wringing

On the other hand, if we can simplify all this down into whether or not kids can do pull ups, I contend that we’ll have an obvious piece of knowledge around which to rally the childhood obesity prevention troops. We’ll have a plan on which to take action TODAY, not next week, next month, or next year. It takes us out of the talking phase and throws us into the action phase. And I for one favor getting to the action phase ASAP!

All this infinite talk inhibits progress. We must decide on an action plan and implement it. If we fail to do so the childhood obesity epidemic will continue to grow and to undermine kids around the world. So let’s bring in the fire trucks now before it’s too late!

In the words of Leonardo deaVinci, “Simplification is the ultimate sophistication.”

___________________________________________________

Rick Osbourne is a former physical educator and a pioneer in the field of functional childhood obesity prevention. He currently serves as President of the Pull Your Own Weight Foundation which is an Illinois based, 501c3, not for profit organization whose focus is functional childhood obesity prevention. He’s written and published three books in this field, the latest of which is entitled Beating Childhood Obesity Now: A Simple Solution for Parents and Educators. He’s the Examiner’s national childhood obesity prevention correspondent. He writes an online column for The Edvocate. And you can connect with Rick via Twitter, Linkedin, or Facebook.

HBCU students donate 5,000 books to prisoners

Perfectly timed for the season of giving, students at the Historically Black College and University (HBCU) Grambling State University have started collecting books for a prison near the school. The drive has attracted the attention of other HBCUs across the country who have also decided to get involved, resulting in nearly 5,000 books being donated to prisons.

According to knoe.com, students in Grambling State’s psychology and sociology club decided to start collecting books for the correctional facility after seeing the dearth of books in its library.

Knoe.com reports:

“The HBCU Book Challenge began as an effort by Grambling State University’s Psychology and Sociology Club members to bring more reading materials to inmates in Louisiana. After seeing a small prison library with a shortage of books, club members were inspired to organize a book drive last spring that collected 225 books for the inmates at Richwood Correctional Center in Monroe.”

This isn’t the first time Grambling has held the book drive. it was actually the great results from the first one that made students decide to do it again and give it the official title of  HBCU Book Challenge.

Other HBCUs got involved, including Alabama State University, Alcorn State University, and Savannah State University.

All four schools collected almost 5,000 books “for prison libraries in Louisiana, Mississippi, Alabama, and Georgia.”

The book drop offs began on December 1st and will continue to be distributed throughout the month.

With the success of this program, it is likely to continue next year and for years after. I love the outreach these students have taken upon themselves, and I hope their acts of generosity improve the educational outlook for the prisoners they’ve gifted.

Read all of our posts about HBCUs by clicking here.

No new governing board for University of Tennessee

Tennessee Governor Bill Haslam has a plan that would “create independent governing boards for the six universities overseen by the Tennessee Board of Regents.”

That does not include the state’s flagship school, the University of Tennessee (UT).

Haslam presented his plan last month to the delight of many of the state’s lawmakers as they have asked for years to create independent governing boards for some of the state’s colleges and universities.

But there was speculation that UT may be included in that shuffle.

Haslam put those fears to rest at a press conference on Tuesday, stating that because UT is so different, it will continue to operate as such.

“The UT system is very different than TBR,” Haslam said. “You got 46 [TBR] institutions versus either four or six, depending on how you define UT with three campuses, the med school, the two institutes.”

The governor did, however, talk about the uniqueness of the University of Tennessee–Chattanooga.

Because the school has thrived under the UT system–its enrollment “has more than doubled to more than 10,000”–there are discussions of creating an independent board for the school.

Not sure if it is likely to happen, but because the school’s president believes that it has its own identity under UT’s belt, it may be just fine as it stands. I just hope this initiative of Governor Haslam makes the intended impact and that in the end it helps educate the disadvantaged students of the state, giving them a shot at an affordable college education.

Tips for training your brain to become a faster study

**The Edvocate is pleased to publish guest posts as way to fuel important conversations surrounding P-20 education in America. The opinions contained within guest posts are those of the authors and do not necessarily reflect the official opinion of The Edvocate or Dr. Matthew Lynch.**

A guest column by Brooke Chaplan

Every student wants to learn faster, but it seems like your brain doesn’t always cooperate. Along with healthy living and brain health supplements, developing smart study habits can really make you a more productive study. Studying effectively and keeping those facts stored and ready to access is a skill not many are privy to. If you want to further define and develop good study and memorization habits, following the four tips below can help.

Regular Exercise
Research from Harvard Medical School shows that regular exercise improves both memory and thinking skills. Researchers have long known that regular exercise has excellent emotional and physical health benefits. However, exercise not only gets the heart pumping, but also temporarily boosts the size of the hippocampus, which is the brain’s memory and learning center. Additionally, intense exercise also stimulates the body to release important chemicals, such as endorphins that fight stress, and other chemicals that stimulate brain cell and blood vessel growth. Exercising also reduces common cognitive impairments, such as stress, anxiety, and poor sleep quality.

Brain Workouts
Weight training involves increasing muscle mass through controlled, repetitive movements. The brain also grows through cognitive exercises and students should practice memorizing new information according to their own personalized system with custom pneumatic techniques. For example, you can practice quickly memorizing other people’s names or things you see in public. In a boring class you could practice memorizing details about students and then trying to recall them. This is important because the brain naturally resists information overload through protectively ignoring random details. Try to systematically train your brain to memorize this unfamiliar information instead.

Explore Different Skills
Learning new skills or information actually creates new neural pathways. The famous cognitive psychologist Howard Gardner postulated that there are actually different types of intelligence, such as spatial, logical, and kinesthetic intelligence. Therefore, IQ tests inaccurately reflect an individual’s intelligence because they primarily test factual knowledge. However, music expands a students’ ability to translate visual information to physical performance. On the other hand, studying art or architecture increases the students’ spatial comprehension. Therefore, students should explore different skill sets in order to increase the time and quality of their brain’s learning.

Academic Training
One of the most comprehensive ways to become a better learner is to formally study education. A degree in education is a great way to learn the fundamental principles of education through teaching others. In fact, an education degree will lead to greater understanding of the socio-cognitive learning processes. Students will learn the most effective techniques for increasing memory, creativity, and comprehension. For example, education degree programs and education masters degrees online provide students insight into how the learning process is highly individualized and as a result, you will be able to assess and understand your own learning preferences.

Clearly, there are proven ways to increase the brain’s learning effectiveness, such as exercise, memorization, skill expansion, and studying education. Don’t fall behind this year in school. If you take the time to rewire your thinking system, you can find new ways of studying faster.

_______________________________________________

Brooke Chaplan is a freelance writer and blogger. She lives and works out of her home in Los Lunas, New Mexico. She loves the outdoors and spends most her time hiking, biking and gardening.

Virginia’s Liberty University to permit firearms in residence halls

A rule that prohibits students from bringing firearms into residence halls will soon end at Liberty University in Lynchburg, Virginia, according to The Washington Post. School president Jerry Falwell, Jr. shared this announcement this week in what he calls “a measure to increase campus safety.”

This announcement stirred controversy as the nation debates gun rights and gun control.

The school president shared the news during a gathering of several thousand students at the evangelical Christian school, which generated heavy applause. He encouraged students to get training from school authorities to enable them to get a permit to carry concealed weapons.

“I take very seriously my responsibility to keep you safe in an increasingly dangerous world,” Falwell said during his announcement.

Liberty has allowed students, faculty and staff to carry concealed guns on campus and in all buildings, with the exception of residence halls, since 2011 as long as they have the proper state permits.

Residents may obtain a concealed-carry permit if they are 21 or older, under the state’s law. More than 900 people at Liberty now have concealed-carry permits, according to Falwell, and hundreds more have recently signed up for a training course to obtain a permit.

After his announcement, Falwell said he received several messages of support from the campus community.

Quincy Thompson, Liberty’s student body president, stated that he and many fellow students support Falwell’s view on allowing firearms in residence halls. He is considering obtaining a concealed-carry permit in the upcoming semester.

“I believe we have the safest college campus in America. We also have students who have been given the opportunity to defend themselves,” said Thompson.

Erich Fromm’s Concept of “Productiveness” for Educators

**The Edvocate is pleased to publish guest posts as way to fuel important conversations surrounding P-20 education in America. The opinions contained within guest posts are those of the authors and do not necessarily reflect the official opinion of The Edvocate or Dr. Matthew Lynch.**

A column by Rick Osbourne

Philosophically speaking Erich Fromm starts with the contention that, by his very nature man is curious, interactive, and productive, as opposed to lazy, slothful, depraved and sinful as some contend. And from an ethics perspective, anything that cultivates and encourages this productive nature is good, while anything that impedes or distorts this nature is evil.

The term “productiveness” as used by Fromm* refers to a specific way in which a person relates to himself, to others, and to the world around him. It’s an orientation, a context in which human life has the potential to become meaningful, consequential, and worth living.

Respectful, Interactive, and Creative

A productive relationship for Fromm begins with a deep respect, a reverence for life in general, including and especially for one’s self and one’s fellow humans (regardless of gender, ethnicity, race, religion, nationality or socio-economic status). In contrast, the lack of respect and reverence for life results in the misunderstanding (undermining) of oneself and the exploitation of one’s fellow humans, which in turn makes the productiveness experience impossible.

This mutually respectful, productive relationship is also interactive (in the sense that it’s something a person does, mentally or physically with others and/or things around them) instead of passive (in the sense that it’s something that’s done to a person, mentally or physically by others and/or things around them). In other words, productiveness is self-motivated, and self-directed instead of being motivated or directed by anything outside of oneself.

This mutually respectful, interactive relationship is also creative in that it produces something new whether it’s an idea, an appreciation for, understanding of, or an actual physical entity. In this sense the experience of productiveness is Godlike in its capacity to create, recreate, and multiply itself exponentially in the lives of those who understand and practice it.

Ends and Means

And finally, productiveness is an end in itself instead of a means to an end outside of itself. So if it’s done for sake of money, fame, or any other extrinsic reward, it’s not productiveness in the way that Fromm uses the term. That is to say, productiveness itself is the reward, the motivator. One practices this art because the experience all by itself is so rewarding, so fulfilling.

To the degree that a person relates productively to himself, others, and the world around him, his life will be meaningful, purposeful, and full of possibility. To the degree that a person fails to relate productively to himself, others, and the world around him, his life will be stale, empty, mechanical, impotent, meaningless, and boring. For Fromm then, productiveness, or the power to interact creatively characterizes human existence in its fullest and best sense.

The Powers of Reason and Love

According to Fromm, reason is the vehicle with which a person penetrates and comes to understand the world of things. On the other hand, love is the vehicle with which a person penetrates, and comes to understand himself and his fellow human beings.**

Thus through the power of reason, a person has the potential to penetrate, understand, and interact productively with things in the world around him. In the process of doing so, he has the potential to improve his own circumstances and the circumstances of his fellow humans.

Through the power of love a person has the potential to penetrate, understand, interact with, appreciate, and to connect creatively with himself and his fellow humans. The powers of reason and love are thus the vehicles through which man can express and experience productiveness.

Happy and Strong VS Depressed and Weak

Therefore, when a person uses his powers of reason and love to interact creatively and productively with himself, his fellow humans, and the world around him he will live a life worth living. When a person fails to use his powers of reason and love to interact creatively and productively, when his potential is stunted or impeded, a person’s life will lack meaning and purpose. It will be a distorted, perverted edition of what it could and arguably should be.

To the degree that his life is filled with productiveness, a person feels strong, fulfilled, potent, and happy. To the degree that his life lacks productiveness, a person feels weak, empty, impotent, depressed, anxious, and powerless (all forms of mental illness).**

Conditions Encourage or Discourage Productiveness

Let’s add one more factor. The possibility of relating to the world productively depends largely on one’s circumstances. That is to say, it’s almost impossible to relate productively to the world when one is in dire need of food, drink, a roof over one’s head, or clothes on one’s back.

On the other hand, when such basic necessities are met, the possibilities of relating productively are enhanced exponentially. So when he has discretionary time, when he is legitimately free to choose, man is naturally productive (not lazy, slothful, depraved or sinful***).

And historically speaking productiveness, when given the opportunity to breathe freely, has resulted in the development of human culture ranging from language and history, to religion, art, science, and sport. On the other hand, without discretionary time and the freedom to choose there would be no Socrates, Plato, or Aristotle, no Jesus, Allah, or Buddha, no Michelangelo, Shakespeare, Mozart, Beethoven, Einstein, Elvis, Muhammed Ali, or Robin Williams. For that matter, without the freedom to choose, the very concept of morality becomes meaningless.

*The concept of “productiveness” is discussed in great detail in Erich Fromm’s book entitled Man For Himself: An Inquiry Into the Psychology of Ethics.

** In “The Art of Loving” Fromm’s best known book, the concept of love is explored in detail. 

***Mental illness, generally speaking, is the result of man’s productive nature being impeded. The antidote to depression, anxiety, and ennui according to Erich Fromm is productiveness.

__________

Rick Osbourne is a former physical educator and a pioneer in the field of functional childhood obesity prevention. He currently serves as President of the Pull Your Own Weight Foundation which is an Illinois based, 501c3, not for profit organization whose focus is functional childhood obesity prevention. He’s written and published three books in this field, the latest of which is entitled Beating Childhood Obesity Now: A Simple Solution for Parents and Educators. He’s the Examiner’s national childhood obesity prevention correspondent. He writes an online column for The Edvocate. And you can connect with Rick via Twitter, Linkedin, or Facebook.

Insight Education Group Appoints Don Rescigno President of Insight ADVANCE

Award-winning publishing and ed tech industry veteran will lead the human capital management division

(Encino, CA) December 8, 2015 — Insight Education Group, a national leader in educational consulting and ed tech with a mission to support the growth of teacher and school leaders, today announces the hiring of Don Rescigno as President of Insight ADVANCE.

Launched in 2014 with a focus on ADVANCEfeedback™, Insight ADVANCE is a three-product human capital management system that accelerates educator growth. Through live or video-based observations, ADVANCEfeedback enables observers to provide meaningful feedback, to identify and share specific examples of great teaching, and to organize support resources to promote educators’ practices. In 2015, the platform won Tech & Learning magazine’s Award of Excellence and was a finalist for EdTech Digest’s Cool Tool Award.

“We’re thrilled to welcome Don to the Insight ADVANCE team,” said Dr. Michael Moody, the founder of Insight Education Group. “His extensive experience and track record of success in creating and promoting education products for more than 16 years will be key to growing the division. We’re eager to continue expanding our impact on the field, and know Don will lead us in our mission to provide educators with the best support and tools they need for professional growth.”

Rescigno is an experienced marketing and business-development executive and product innovator. He has created, marketed, and sold award-winning products recognized by Google, SxSW, District Administration magazine, Tech & Learning magazine, and others. He is widely known for being the creator of StrataLogica™, a product used in schools around the world. Don also served for 15 years as Vice President of Marketing and Product Development for Herff Jones | Nystrom, where he took a 100-year-old, print-based social studies publisher and helped navigate market shifts like NCLB and CCSS, while converting the product line to digital. Don was recently a featured speaker at the annual EdNET Conference, the education business industry’s premier networking event.

“I couldn’t be more excited to join Insight ADVANCE as President,” said Rescigno. “Our team has created a high-impact suite of products that are making a difference for educators and administrators. ADVANCE can truly empower teachers to improve and help enhance the quality of feedback, moving districts and schools to the next level of teaching and learning. I look forward to working with the entire Insight team to serve our customers and grow the business.”

About Insight Education Group

Insight Education Group is a national educational consulting and ed tech company that supports the growth of teachers and school leaders. Since 2000, it has specialized in developing deep partnerships with school leaders to understand their unique challenges and work together to design and implement large-scale educator-effectiveness solutions that drive lasting change. For more information, visit http://www.insighteducationgroup.com.

Read all of our posts about EdTech and Innovation by clicking here. 

Important Ways Assessment in the Classroom Impacts Testing and Curriculum

Assessment has become a central part of education. While lifelong learning should always be the main focus of a classroom, the pervasive knowledge that at some point, there will be testing, from the local scale to the national, has also become a backdrop in curriculum development.

Standardized testing has long been part of the K–12 scene, but since the enactment of No Child Left Behind (NCLB) in 2001, student results have been used by the federal and state governments to determine the level of funding schools receive. The salaries and job security of teachers and administrators are also determined, at least in part, by the results of student achievement on standardized tests. As a result, a “teaching to the test” mentality has emerged in public schools throughout the country. The benefit to curriculum and lesson plans that focus heavily on anticipated test material is that a core standard for all students is established. The particular skills that are deemed most important are targeted, providing a blueprint for what students throughout the country should be learning.

The Center for Public Education, however, notes that the pitfalls of basing curriculum and in-class lessons on standardized testing are wide-ranging. When a narrow scope is applied to what is taught in K–12 classrooms, other valuable lessons are excluded. There is also the issue of spending too much time prepping for the test itself and learning test-taking skills during time that could be devoted to broadening an actual knowledge base.

In a best-case scenario, individual schools would base curriculum and instruction decisions on the performance of their particular student body on standardized testing. This does not mean excluding information that is relevant but may not appear in a multiple-choice format; it means taking a look at the broader areas where a student population suffers and finding ways to strengthen them. If a school or district sees lower math scores than average, it should consider that a sign that stronger math initiatives need to take place across the board. As such, standardized testing should be seen as an aid in curriculum development and modification, but not the entire teaching plan.

Figuring out how to make assessment and curriculum work synergistically is still a work in progress. As an educator, it will be a responsibility of yours to be a part of the effort. Talk to the other teachers in your district to see what’s working and what’s not. Put ideas to the test, and keep honing in on what yields the best results for your students.

A Look At High-Stakes Tests: The Pro’s and Cons

Education today is run rampant with evaluations. Classroom tests, national standardized assessments, even scores that reflect international performance – students from elementary school through high school face all of them. Of the most important of today’s educational assessments are a set known as “high-stakes tests.”

High-stakes tests are assessments that have a high-impact outcome, where, for example, passing the test would allow the student entry into a grade or permission to graduate. The assessments that are part of NCLB are considered standardized high-stakes tests. The act states that if state-run schools are to receive federal funding, students should be given (and must pass) certain assessments. Ultimately, students’ futures and school funding rely on these standardized test scores. Some subjects, such as foreign languages and humanities, are not included in the tests.

Those in favor of high-accountability tests claim that there is no serious method of measuring student achievement other than standardized tests. They assert that this is the best way that equality in education can be ensured across the United States. Supporters cite the fact that NCLB was created to raise the standards of achievement and close the gap between students of different races and class distinctions. NCLB has gained many advocates in congress, who all make the point that failure should also be measured, to detect areas that need improvement.

On closer examination, a clear gap between reality and federal educational goals still exists. NCLB might be overlooking the disparity that exists in America’s educational system, because many students are not reaching the standards that the tests are evaluating. Some of the reasons people oppose high-stakes tests include:

1. Unfairness

The same test is administered in a well-supplied, sophisticated school and in an under-funded, ill-equipped school, and all students are expected to measure equally regardless of race, poverty, access to resources, and language differences. Wealthier students may not be more intelligent than deprived ones, but they are more likely to have access to resources that contribute to the acquisition of the competencies that are required to pass the tests. National data show that minority groups tend to have a higher chance of failing high-stakes standardized tests.

2. Dropouts increase

High-stakes testing is likely to result in increased numbers of dropouts among less-confident students or students with special needs. To make a good impression and avoid being sanctioned by the state, teachers tend to focus on students who are likely to reach proficiency on standardized tests. They often forsake weak students, who are at risk of becoming dropouts. The National Research Council found that low-performing elementary and secondary school students who are not promoted do not achieve better standards the following year. In fact, they generally become resentful and, as a result, are much worse off. Some states have chosen to implement high-stakes tests as a requirement for graduation, which has resulted in a higher dropout rate.

For example, in Massachusetts, 71% of African American students graduated the year before the tests became a graduation requirement, but only 59.5% did so the next year. For Latino students in Massachusetts, the rate went from 54% to 45%, and for Asian students, it dropped from 89% to 81%.

3. Redefinition of Teaching

Teaching is now inclined to focus on preparation of students for these tests. This technique may show an increase in high grades, but it does not ensure acquisition of knowledge. And subject syllabuses suffer changes. Some subjects are clearly given less attention in these evaluations and are sacrificed in favor of extra time for test practice. A study by the Center on Education Policy found that about 62% of school districts increased the amount of time spent in elementary schools on English, language arts, or math (these are the subjects to be tested by order of the state), while 44% of districts cut time on science, social studies, art, music, physical education, lunch, or recess. Teachers admitted that they spent a fair amount of their time instructing for test-taking skills and using mock exams for this purpose, instead of applying formative assessment techniques to gain an understanding of student motivation, level of knowledge, abilities, or grasp of the subject. Research has shown that when teachers devote more time to test preparation, students may become more efficient on standardized tests, but other test scores often drop.

4. Low Reliability

Even expert-constructed tests may contain flaws. Sometimes responses are keyed in incorrectly and not revised, which may result in inaccurate scores.

5. Teacher Stress

Studies have shown that 7 in 10 teachers have complained about becoming stressed due to test-preparation activities, which are generally nonmotivational and not aligned with the objectives of a class. The incessant drills students have to endure make them more inclined to lose interest and complain about boredom, fear, or isolation. Preparing students for a test is not the only stressing factor; teachers must guarantee that students are sufficiently prepared to face the tests and that all the techniques have been mastered. Many teachers have become frustrated by not being able to practice high-quality teaching and have therefore chosen to leave state-run schools and apply to private schools, where high-stakes tests do not rule the curriculum.

In the midst of all this controversy, teachers at state-run schools need to find ways to meet federal requirements while fostering motivation and learning among students. Many may contend that high-stakes tests are not efficient or reliable enough to measure student achievement; however, they continue to be part of teacher concerns these days. In the light of their reality, teachers have come to terms with NCLB, by finding ways of engaging students, combined with mastery of the material and techniques that will help when preparing students for standardized exams.

Educators: Do You Know About These Alternatives to High-Stakes Tests?

How to best quantify educational achievement and recognize academic progress is a continually hot debate. Standardized tests are too uniform and broad in scope to consistently measure individual competence, and high-stakes tests can put too much importance on a single data point of success or failure.

Many believe that authentic assessments, and not high-stakes standardized tests, are the most appropriate tools to collect information on student learning and progress. They argue that assessing student responses to real-world scenarios or tasks is more meaningful than standardized testing. Authentic assessments provide the additional benefit of pin- pointing where and why a child may be struggling. It is important to take into account that learning is developmental and therefore will occur in any circumstances. Learning occurs naturally when the learner finds there is a purpose behind it. When the subjects being taught are seen as isolated pieces of information, without association or context, learning becomes meaningless.

Much of the current thinking regarding alternative forms of student assessment derives from the concept of higher-order thinking skills first introduced in Benjamin Bloom’s 1956 taxonomy of educational objectives. Bloom noted six levels of thinking skills: knowledge, comprehension, application, analysis, synthesis, and evaluation. Higher-order thinking skills are those skills in the top three levels: analysis, synthesis, and evaluation.

For deep and meaningful learning to occur, teachers must create lessons and activities that develop and routinely assess these skills. Higher-order thinking skills are used when people run into unfamiliar problems. When a person can apply higher-order thinking skills to these occurrences, their decisions are much more likely to engender positive results.

For students to develop higher-order thinking skills, they must first have the ability to use prerequisite lower-order skills such as retaining facts and discriminations. You can help your students develop higher-order thinking skills by providing supportive, effective lessons and structuring assessments that allow them to use those skills.

Authentic assessments encourage students to analyze and interpret their own learning experiences. They generally require students to use higher levels of thinking, integrate the knowledge they have constructed in different areas, and use it for problem-solving situations. It is important to realize that these assessments, while very useful in the classroom setting, may not be appropriate for wide-scale testing, because they are suited for comparatively limited content. They are, however, very well suited to more frequent use than ordinary standardized tests.

Two important authentic assessments are portfolios and exhibitions. A portfolio allows the display of a particular set of skills and knowledge in response to a realistic set of requirements. Often students will be given a chance to prepare in advance for portfolio submissions, which gives the teacher a chance to adequately communicate what is required from the student in the portfolio. The selection of portfolio content and material should be based on goals and standards, and should include a broad range of accomplishments (including products, essays, quizzes, hobbies, etc.). Student portfolios can take many forms, including paper or electronic.

An exhibition requires students to display their understanding of a course or experience as a whole, often without defined requirements. This work is often judged (evaluated) by a panel, or may even be displayed in front of the student’s parents or peers, and thus requires a great deal of preparation. These forms of assessment require teachers to be highly objective during grading, because each portfolio or exhibition will be assessed individually, rather than against set criteria. The teacher will establish a reliable rubric for the assessment of individual work during planning and will communicate the parameters for assessment to the students clearly and unambiguously.

Assessments that are designed to be more individualized or specifically focused in structure can give a much more authentic read of how an individual student is doing. They may take more effort, but the more accurate results they yield also seem to be well worth the extra work.