Johnson will replace Kim Bottomly, who announced last April that she would step down after nine years as president of the women’s university. Dr. Johnson will begin her role on July 1, 2016.
Johnson is a professor at Harvard Medical School and is chief of Women’s Health at the medical school and Boston’s Brigham and Women’s Hospital. She has furthered research that explores how women respond differently than men to diseases and treatment. She was elected to the National Academy of Medicine, one of the highest honors in the fields of health and medicine. She also is the recipient of numerous awards recognizing her groundbreaking achievements on behalf of women.
Dr. Johnson has spent her career and life improving the health and lives of women, says Charlotte Harris, a Wellesley senior, in a statement. Harris went on to say that Johnson understands the issues of inclusion, equity, and well-being that are important to Wellesley students.
Johnson, 56, said in a statement that she sees the role as a capstone to her career. She also said that she felt a special responsibility as the college’s first African-American leader and believes that student diversity is one of Wellesley’s strengths.
It’s great to see not only a women, but also an African-American woman appointed to lead a college. It’s fitting for Wellesley, as a woman’s university, to have an internationally renowned and innovative leader serve as its president.
Dr. Johnson attended Harvard and Radcliffe Colleges, and she received her MD and MPH degrees from Harvard. She trained in internal and cardiovascular medicine at Brigham and Women’s Hospital. She’s a Brooklyn, New York native, and now lives in Brookline, Massachusetts, with her husband, their son and daughter, and a puppy.
Wellesley College is a private, women’s, liberal-arts university in Massachusetts that serves 2,400 students. Johnson will be the college’s 14th president.
Four educators, Preston Green from the University of Connecticut, Bruce Baker from Rutgers University, Joseph Oluwole from Montclair State University, and Julie Mead from the University of Wisconsin all present information that shows how a bubble may be forming around charter schools, and that it mirrors the subprime mortgage crisis.
What’s worse is that the bubble may pop in urban centers, or black neighborhoods, across the country. If so, then we truly are headed down a dangerous path.
The bubble that the authors are referring to is one created by what they describe as misaligned priorities from varying parties with interests in the success of charter schools.
Basically, many charter schools are run by third-party groups. The goal of those groups is to either raise revenue or slash costs. Doing so means that students will suffer as the outside entity will likely look to cut expenses at any turn, such as making students that are deemed as a drain on the school’s financial resources go to other schools.
In addition to what these third-party groups are doing with charter schools, state legislators are being lobbied to expand charter schools, and to do so without much oversight. Almost a deregulation of the process, if you will.
Because so many charter schools are either in low-income neighborhoods or tend to go after students with poor financial means, these neighborhoods and students will be heavily impacted if the bubble pops.
The study doesn’t come without solutions. The authors suggest that now is the time for state governments, and the federal government, to ensure that checks and balances are put into place so that a big bubble isn’t formed.
It’s an interesting study — but one I question based on the fact that charter schools are all competing against each other, really. Why would any of them put themselves in a situation to lose students, or funding?
Time will tell, I suppose, but at least for now, it appears that many charters are doing exactly what they set out to do: provide innovative education options to students who need them.
Duke Energy is putting its financial support behind Historically Black Colleges and Universities.
By way of Prnewswire.com, the energy giant gave a grant of $35,000 to the North Carolina organization The Institute to supports its new HBCU Leadership Exchange.
A non-profit that supports business diversity, The Institute will soon launch the HBCU Leadership Exchange to help support and forge relationships between corporations and students enrolled at HBCUs in North Carolina.
In short, The Institute’s new program will look to connect students at HBCUs with jobs in corporate America. It’s not a bad program to build as diversity within the corporate field–specifically technology–is always a hot button topic.
The Institute has a track record of aiding minority business development as the group offers services to assist the growth of small businesses. As The Institute has been around for more than three decades, the HBCU Leadership Exchange is starting off with strong backing.
Also–Duke Energy gives close to $30 million in grants each year in areas such as education, economic development, the environment, and much more.
But this new program has potential to serve a grand number of black students. While the grant from Duke Energy isn’t substantial, it at least gives The Institute a portion of the starting funds needed to help launch the program.
With no reason to believe that the exchange will not have success, Duke Energy will likely to continue to provide financial support that will only grow in the future.
As mentioned previously, the goal of this new exchange is to foster relationships between corporations and HBCU students.
Students who are looking for jobs in a specific area will likely be paired with mentors or given the opportunity to meet and greet leaders from certain industries.
With growth and limitless potential on the horizon, students at HBCUs in North Carolina should be excited about this new venture.
The presentation by Deb deVries and Kathy Hurley attracted hundreds of educators from around the world
(CAMBRIDGE, MASSACHUSETTS) February 17, 2016 – Girls Thinking Global (GTG), dedicated to connecting nonprofits that serve adolescent girls and young women around the world, has launched a monthly series of webinars, hosted pro bono byedWeb.
In the first webinar, “Fostering Leadership in Women and Girls,” Girls Thinking Global’s founders Deb deVries and Kathy Hurley used Real Women, Real Leaders, a book recently co-edited by Hurley, to lead a conversation about the latest research on the strengths of women as leaders.
deVries and Hurley also shared real-life experiences of women who have achieved significant leadership roles in education and business, and polled attendees about what topics GTG should cover in future webinars. The most popular response, given by 54% of attendees, was “examples of programs that foster girls’ leadership in school.”
The live broadcast attracted 220 educators from around the world, and the presentation is archived in the GTG community on edWeb. To view a recording of the webinar, click here.
“We were thrilled with the attendance and feedback from GTG’s first webinar,” said Lisa Schmucki, the founder and CEO of edWeb. “We are strong believers in their mission and their leaders, and we hope that by providing this platform pro bono, we can help empower girls and women around the world.”
GTG’s next webinar, “Lessons in Leadership,” will feature Ann McMullan, an education consultant who previously served as the executive director for educational technology in the Klein Independent School District, which is located just outside Houston and serves nearly 50,000 students. For more than 16 years, Ann led the district team that provides professional development on 21st-century instructional strategies to more than 4,000 professional educators. Ann’s presentation will focus on basic principles of leadership that will strengthen abilities and help assure success in any stage of life.
The “Lessons in Leadership” webinar will take place on February 23 from 5:00 – 6:00 pm ET. To register for the webinar, click here.
You can also join the GTG community on edWeb to engage in discussions or get information about future webinars by clicking here.
Based in Newton, MA, Girls Thinking Global (GTG) is a 501(c)(3) non-profit dedicated to creating a global community of organizations serving girls and young women by leveraging technology to create a collaborative space that connects best practices, knowledge, and expertise between non-profits.
About edWeb
edWeb.net is a highly acclaimed professional social and learning network that has become a vibrant online community for exceptional educators, decisionmakers, and influencers who are on the leading edge of innovation in education. edWeb members are teachers, faculty, administrators, and librarians at K-12 and post-secondary institutions. edWeb is a place where educators who are looking for ways to improve teaching and learning can gather and share information and ideas with peers and thought leaders in the industry.
Collaboration provides the NSBA with an innovative tool to gather and analyze data for its state benchmarking studies
(HERNDON, VA)February 17, 2016 – K12 Insighttoday announced a partnership with the National School Boards Association (NSBA). As part of the agreement, NSBA will use K12 Insight’s Engage survey solution to listen to and understand the needs of its more than 90,000 school board members across the country.
Specifically, NSBA will use K12 Insight’s fully managed survey solution to gather and analyze data for its state benchmark studies. K12 Insight will conduct seven surveys and provide data analysis delivered to the NSBA in four customized reports.
K12 Insight, in turn, will be a Platinum-Level sponsor of NSBA’s Annual Conference, to be held April 9–11 in Boston.
In addition to its featured position at the conference, K12 Insight will engage in several thought leadership collaborations with NSBA throughout the year, including columns and interviews in American School Board Journal and a whitepaper that will be featured on the NSBA’s website The Hub. In all of these publications, K12 Insight will share examples of best practices in successful districts, highlight the resources it offers, and showcase its research on the benefits of community engagement. K12 Insight will also host a series of webinars in conjunction with the articles it contributes.
“NSBA is pleased to partner with K12 Insight, an organization committed to improving education,” said Thomas J. Gentzel, the executive director of the National School Boards Association. “The Engage survey solution provides an innovative approach to gathering and analyzing data that can benefit our advocacy efforts for positive education outcomes for all students.”
“K12 Insight is thrilled to partner with the National School Boards Association. NSBA is a tremendous advocate for public schools and our nation’s public school children,” said K12 Insight’sFounder and CEO Suhail Farooqui. “We are pleased to be a Platinum Sponsor of the 2016 Annual Conference. And we’re excited to have NSBA use our Engage survey solution to better understand and meet the needs of its members and constituents.”
About K12 Insight
K12 Insight, based in Herndon, VA, works with more than 30,000 school administrators to strengthen the relationships that power education. Our custom solutions combine technology, research, and expert training to help school leaders build trust and drive positive change in their local communities. Learn more at K12Insight.com.
About Engage
Engage, from K12 Insight, combines the latest research and technology with expert analyses for an inclusive community survey experience unmatched in K12 education. Invite stakeholder feedback and participation ahead of critical school decisions. Promote your survey to ensure it reaches the widest possible audience. And get strategic recommendations to help you take next steps.
About the National School Boards Association
NSBA represents state school boards associations and their more than 90,000 local school board members. We believe education is a civil right, and public education is America’s most vital institution. Learn more at NSBA.org.
It’s been almost a half-decade since education communities started pushing for an iPad for each student in classrooms. The amount of individualized learning available on tablets that are equipped with Internet technology is virtually limitless, making customized learning more possible than ever. Many school districts are still trying to reach this standard, of course, but in the areas where the iPad-to-student ratio is 1:1, that connectivity is making a positive difference.
Recently, Carl Hooker, the creator of iPadpalooza and director of innovation and digital learning at Eanes ISD (TX), was honored as 2016’s Thought Leader of the Year by PR with Panache!Hooker was recognized for his district’s personalized learning initiative that has put iPads in the hands of 8,000 students. He’s also the founder of iPadpalooza – an event that brings together global education leaders to talk about the role of technology in classrooms and beyond. Hooker is the author of the Mobile Learning Mindsetseries that approaches the technology of learning from a positive place.
In 2014, Hooker was also named Leader of the Year by Tech & Learning.
What leaders like Hooker are getting right is this: technology can benefit teachers and students when it is implemented correctly. Screen time can never replace the benefit of one-on-one teacher contact — but in classrooms where individual attention is scarce (and that’s most of them), tapping technology for customized learning can be a complete game-changer. Finding ways to extend technology resources to the schools that need it the most should be a goal of any progressive education advocate because within technology is the capability to reach more students with more customized learning experiences.
Many of the world’s leading economies can do more to help struggling teenagers to get a better level of education that will equip them for later life. A new report from the Organisation for Economic Co-operation and Development (OECD), looking at why low-performing students fall behind at school, has found that much remains to be done to reduce the number of children that perform poorly in maths, reading and science skills.
One of the most striking aspects of the report is just how many children are low performers, even in highly-developed nations such as the UK, Australia, or the US. I find it shocking that one in six children in the UK has a low level of reading comprehension skills – 17% of those tested in both the UK and US, and 14% in Australia.
The new report is based on data taken from the OECD-funded Programme for International Student Assessment (PISA), the world’s largest and most influential educational survey. It aims to raise educational standards by providing detailed information about successful and less successful educational systems.
Every three years, 15-year-old children around the world take the two-hour PISA test. It focuses on some of the most fundamental academic skills: reading comprehension, mathematics, and science literacy. The new report is based on the 2012 PISA round, in which nearly half a million children participated.
The average score in OECD countries for each skill is around 500 PISA points. For example, in the UK, children’s scores in reading comprehension ranged from 121 to 788 points, with a national average of 499 points. Low performance is defined as a score below (approximately) 400 PISA points. According to the OECD, a low performer does not have the skills required to participate fully in a modern society.
The numbers of low performers in mathematics are worse than in reading – 22% in the UK, 20% in Australia and 26% in the US. Of course, it is possible that a child is a low performer in only one of the skills, but the numbers of children performing poorly in all of the three skills is still worryingly high: 11% in the UK, 9% in Australia, 12% in the US and 13% in France.
Which countries do best
There are considerable differences between countries. Those that generally score highly in PISA are, unsurprisingly, also the countries with the fewest low performers. Generally, East Asian countries and economic regions are successful in PISA(with the Chinese cities Shanghai and Hong Kong leading the league table) and have relatively few low performers. But there are European countries that have a similar level of success. For example, Estonia has one of the highest PISA scores in Europe, and only 3% of children are low performers in all three skills, leading the European league table.
There are no simple explanations for why some countries do better than others – many factors play a role. These include the educational levels and income of parents, their engagement, and whether or not children live in an urban or rural area. We should not only look at the leaders of the league table, but also at countries which are culturally and geographically similar.
Take Ireland, for example, which has 10% low performers in reading and 17% in mathematics and has seen a considerable reduction in low performers between 2006 and 2012. In Ireland, only 7% of low-performing children skipped school at least once in the two weeks before the PISA test, compared to 27% in the UK and 45% in Australia. Ireland’s data also shows a lower level of segregation by educational achievement. Such comparisons suggest that dealing more effectively with truancy and a more equal distribution of low performers across schools might help to drive down the numbers of low performers in other countries.
These gender gaps are also reflected in the new report. As the graph above shows, more boys than girls are low performers in reading and science, whereas more girls are low performers in mathematics. Policies aimed at reducing gender inequalities have so far not been effective in resolving these gaps. A new approach is needed.
One of the problems that the report does not address is that countries with a larger mathematics gap often have a smaller reading gap and vice versa. This is enormously challenging, because some of the countries, such as Iceland or Finland, that are able to eliminate the mathematics gap affecting girls, have a particularly large reading gap affecting boys.
How to raise achievement
The final chapter of the report lays out a series of policies to tackle low performance levels. It gives examples of successful approaches, which include language training for non-native speakers and improving the quality of pre-primary education, which has happened in Germany. It also suggests that schools could foster high academic expectations, and use networks of schools to disseminate best practise.
It concludes that the percentage of low performers in any country can be reduced within a couple of years, if government is willing to reform the education system. While the number of low-performing children in the OECD is disappointingly high, with the appropriate educational reforms, based on evidence, a lot can be done to improve the situation.
For many of us, access to the Internet through a variety of means is a given. I can access the Internet through two laptops, a tablet, a smartphone and even both of my game systems, from the comfort of my living room.
However, this access is unequally distributed. Although nine out of 10 low-income families have Internet access at home, most are underconnected: that is, they have “mobile-only” access – they are able to connect to the Internet only through a smart device, such as a tablet or a smartphone.
This leads to limited access: A third of families with mobile-only access quickly hit the data limits on their mobile phone plans and about a quarter have their phone service cut off for lack of payment.
So, what impact does this type of access have on youth learning?
What changes with a computer connection
My research has explored underserved youth’s use of technology to discover and participate in content related to their interests. Having access only through their mobile devices means that low-income families and youth do not have the same access to the Internet as those with other Internet connections.
One-fifth of families who access the Internet only through their mobile devices say too many family members have to share one device. This means that the amount of time each individual has to access the Internet is limited.
This can be a barrier to learning for young people. It can limit their access to resources to complete their homework, as well as create barriers for other learning. Thirty-five percent of youth who have mobile-only access look online for information about things they are interested in. But this goes up to 52 percent when young people have access to an Internet-connected computer.
When young people have access to an Internet-supported computer, it facilitates their learning. leah, CC BY-NC-ND
When young people have their own access to the Internet, they have an opportunity to engage in connected learning – learning that is based on interest, is supported by peers and has the potential to offer better opportunities for the future.
A 2014 paper on the use of digital media as a learning tool highlights how learning around interests can be supported through online resources.
The paper tells the story of Amy, a participant in an online knitting community, Hogwarts at Ravelry, which combines both interest in knitting and the Harry Potter series. Amy finds inspiration in the vast knitting pattern library of the group and receiving support from others in the community. She begins to develop, design and write patterns of her own. And, as a teenager, she begins selling her patterns online.
Amy’s access to a stable Internet connection and her own dedication allowed her to dive deep into the activities of the community. Over time, it allowed her to become more active and engaged in knitting.
Another example of what youth can accomplish online comes from my 2014 research on a professional wrestling fan community, a set of forums where professional wrestling fans get together virtually to discuss the many facets of professional wrestling.
Maria, a professional wrestling fan, seeks out an online community because she lacks local support for her interest. Through her participation, she realizes her deep enjoyment of writing. She carries this back into her English class and the school newspaper. This eventually leads her to take creative writing as a second degree in college.
Maria spent hours on her computer carefully crafting her narratives while participating on the forum. With a mobile-only access, she would not have had the amount of time online, or the amount of bandwidth, required for this work. This is supported by the fact that only 31 percent of childrenwith mobile-only access go online daily as compared to 51 percent of those with other Internet access.
How low-income youth get left behind
Mobile-only access to the Internet can create serious barriers for youth who want to access content and educational supports.
As part of my research, I have been conducting workshops in libraries located in low-income communities, using an online coding program that is not yet available on mobile devices. In one of the workshops, students needed to work on projects outside of the sessions.
Because of the limited technology access at home, the librarian held additional open hours so the youth participating in the workshop could work on their projects outside of the workshop hours. A few youth had access to their own computers, but the majority had only mobile access.
Young people who have computer access create may better projects. Jeff Werner, CC BY-NC-SA
The youth with computer access at home created more complex projects. This was partly because they had more time to develop, modify and problem-solve their projects. But it was also because the coding program was available to only those with computer access. These youth also seemed to develop a deeper interest in coding potentially due to this greater level of exposure.
Need for better understanding
What becomes evident from the data from “Opportunity for all? Technology and learning in low income families” and from the examples from research is that having access to the Internet only through a phone can have an impact on young people’s access to learning opportunities.
Designers, educators and researchers need to be aware and continually create more equity through mindful decision-making.
Amanda Ochsner, a postdoctoral researcher at the University of Southern California who studies how underrepresented groups of young people engage with games and digital media, argues that when designers and developers take the time to understand young people’s digital lives, they are ultimately able to make better tools. As she said to me:
In offices where the most recent models of laptops, tablets, and iPhones are abundant, it’s far too easy for those of us who develop educational tools and technologies to misjudge the technological realities of the young people the education tools and technologies are designing for.
Just how young people access online, in other words, matters – a lot.
As presidential candidate Donald Trump continues to insist upon banning Muslims from entering the U.S. and espousing a need for a wall along the Mexican border, heating up anti-immigration and racist rhetoric, it’s essential we consider this: one in four students under the age of eight in the U.S. has an immigrant parent.
Classrooms are getting more diverse as the percentage of minority students increases. In the fall of 2014 there were more minority students in the the public education system. According to a report from the Pew Research Center, 50.3 percent of students in 2014 were minority, whereas 49.7 percent of all students were white. By 2022, 45.3 percent are projected to be white, and 54.7 percent are projected to be minority.
How can classrooms become more culturally responsive in their teaching practices in classrooms and foster respectful behavior?
As a music educator and music teacher educator focused on culturally responsive teaching, I believe a music classroom is an ideal place to begin. Music is an experience found across all cultures, and music classrooms are a logical place where difference and respect can be recognized, practiced and celebrated.
Music programs lack diversity
Music education programs in the high school setting typically bring to mind the images and sounds of bands, orchestras and choirs. In the elementary context, general music classes are viewed as places where children sing, dance, and play the recorder and other classroom instruments.
Each of these experiences is rooted in either a Western view of music that is focused on placement of Western classical music as the highest form of musical experience, or on methods of teaching that grew out of European music education practices.
In my research, I found that the reliance on a method of general music instruction within a classroom where the majority of the students were the children of Mexican immigrants resulted in a the creation of an inherent bias against the students’ culture and a sense of isolation for the students. This bias was the result of the the teacher’s views, which created an environment that did not support the integration of cultural, linguistic and popular music experiences.
This finding was supported by music education professor Regina Carlow, who found that when the cultural identity of students in a high school choir setting was not respected or even acknowledged, students developed a sense of isolation.
This isolation can result in an unfair learning environment.
Teachers lack diversity
So why don’t classrooms engage students in musical practices that are rooted in their cultural and musical backgrounds? The answer can be found in the traditions of American music education.
In 2011, music education researchers Carlos Abril and Kenneth Elpusfound that 65.7 percent of music ensemble students were white and middle class; only 15.2 percent were black and 10.2 percent were Hispanic. These data demonstrate that white students are overrepresented in high school music ensembles. Students for whom English was not their native language accounted for only 9.6 percent of ensemble members.
The majority of teachers are white and middle-class. Andy Bullock, CC BY
Adding to this reality is the fact that the process of becoming a music teacher is rooted in the Western classical tradition. Though the National Association of Schools of Music (NASM) does not stipulate a classical performance audition, it is required in a majority of cases.
Based on my experience as a music education professor, aspiring music teachers must pass a Western classical performance audition with an orchestral instrument, classical voice or classical guitar in order to even begin down the path of becoming a music educator, even though no school explicitly states that.
Given this, music education programs not only primarily reflect Western European classical music, but they also create a self-perpetuating cycle.
Start with understanding music
In fact, music curriculum can be an ideal place to start culturally responsive teaching. Music crosses cultures and is an experience that can be considered universal.
Education researcher Geneva Gay describes culturally responsive teaching as a practice that supports learning through and about other cultures.
This includes cultural values, traditions, communication, learning styles, contributions and how people relate. It is not just taking a week or month to study the folk music of Mexico. It is about building a curriculum that enables students to experience, discuss, and perform music that is culturally and socially relevant.
This happens when teachers draw on musical styles and genres that are varied. For example, learning to sing the folk song “Frog Went a Courtin’” based on its American variant, then comparing and contrasting it to the Flat Duo Jets’ rock version of the song.
The cultural values and contributions of diverse musicians and genres provide the perfect avenue to explore and learn about the “other” in a classroom environment. Additionally, the chance to sing, play and listen to the music of other cultures creates an understanding that transcends personal experience, and creates a more global perspective.
Reimagine and reconfigure
This is not to say that we should forgo the current practices. Band, orchestra, and choir programs provide wonderful educational experiences for students throughout the country.
And these programs should continue.
However, there are other music programs that focus on guitar as a popular and folk instrument. Such as this one:
And there are programs that run rock bands within the school day. Then, there are programs where students learn to write songs, sample and compose. In addition, there are music education blogs that celebrate the many “other” ways that students learn about music, outside of band, orchestra and choir.
These programs can help us reimagine and reconfigure.
Building walls and excluding groups do not engender respect and democratic growth in our classrooms or in our political arenas. Rather, they foster fear and prevent equality and opportunity. Music classrooms can and should become the places where diversity is embraced and integrated.
Standardized tests have become the primary tool for determining a student’s academic ability. Legislators and administrators use test data to evaluate the effectiveness of schooling on children and create curriculum.
Their use is supported by two fundamental assumptions: that the tests do not have a bias, and that they accurately assess a student’s academic knowledge.
A typical standardized test assesses a student’s knowledge base in an academic domain, such as science, mathematics or reading. When taking a standardized test, it is assumed that the substance of the test and its administration will be the same for all takers. The tests are identical, with identical degrees of difficulty and identical grading methods.
Despite these goals in the creation of standardized tests, recent research I conducted in collaboration with Hans Henrik Sievertsen (of the Danish National Center for Social Research) and Marco Piovesan (of the University of Copenhagen) identifies one potential source of bias: the time at which students take the test.
Why timing matters
We used data from a context in which the timing of the test depends on the weekly class schedule and computer availability at the school. Thus, students and teachers do not choose when the test occurs: the test time depends on factors outside of their control. Though our data come from Denmark, the same conditions often exist in the case of tests in other countries across the globe.
But does the time of the day when students take the test make a difference in terms of their performance on the test? We thought it would.
After all, people’s ability to perform effectively on various tasks is not constant across the day but shows temporal variation. In fact, research has argued that individuals’ cognitive functioning (e.g., memory and attention) is at its peak at their optimal time of day and decreases substantially at their nonoptimal times. Others have suggested that time-of-day effects on performance depend on external factors that occur at particular times (e.g., meals) or vary depending on the nature of the task itself.
Students become increasingly fatigued as the day wears on. This affects test results. CameliaTWU, CC BY-NC-ND
Given these various theories about how time of day affects performance, we had a unique opportunity to put these hypotheses to a test as we gained access to data on the full population of children in Danish public schools from 2010 to 2013.
As the day wears on, students (as we all do) become increasingly fatigued. So, we reasoned, “cognitive fatigue” (i.e., when the brain has to work harder to concentrate on tasks) can lead students to perform worse on tests taken later in the day and that breaks can recharge students’ energy.
So, “cognitive fatigue” negatively impacts test performance. But a break can counterbalance this negative effec. For example, during a break, children in school can have something to eat, relax, play with classmates or just have some fresh air. These activities recharge their energy.
How timing matters
Our results are consistent with these hypotheses.
To test whether our intuition was right, we linked two million standardized tests taken in Denmark by children between the age of eight and 15 with the time the test was administered.
In Denmark, these tests are computer-based: to test the students, teachers have to prebook a test session within the test period (which runs from January to April of each year). Therefore, the test time is determined by the availability of a computer room and students’ class schedules. And, in fact, our analysis confirms that students are allocated to different times randomly.
Our analyses led to three main findings: 1) The later in the day the time of the test is, the lower the performance on the test; 2) breaks cause a significant improvement in performance; 3) the effect of time of day and of breaks are not homogeneous – low-performing students are more affected by breaks (and also by the time of the day when the test is taken) than high-performing students.
Here is how to think more concretely about the size of our results:
We found that when the standardized test is taken an hour later in the day, it causes a deterioration in a student’s test score that corresponds to parents having about US$1,000 less in their household annual income or students going to school for 10 fewer days every year. A break causes an improvement in a student’s test score that corresponds to parents earning about $1,900 more in their household annual income or students going to school for 19 extra days every year.
We were able to identify these estimates based on additional analyses of our data that we conducted to better understand the impact of taking the standardized test later in the day to find concrete numbers to compare our effects to.
The effect sizes may seem small, as these estimates suggest, but they are quite sizable compared to the influence of individual characteristics on students’ test performance and the implications of these findings.
When’s the right time?
In reading about these results, one may be tempted to interpret them as evidence that the start time of the school day should change to later thus allowing students to sleep in – a topic that is currently debated quite oftenin the United States among other places.
Results are better if students are allowed to sleep in. Alberto G., CC BY
One may reach this conclusion since, by starting the school day later and getting some more sleep (which is well-known) to be a way to restore one’s mental energy), students may be able to perform better on their tests and other school activities throughout the day.
Our results should also not be interpreted to say that schools tests should be administered earlier in the day.
Rather, the message of this research for policy-making is twofold.
First, when policymakers or schools administrators make decisions regarding the length of the school day and the frequency and duration of breaks, “cognitive fatigue” should be taken into careful consideration. Longer school days can be justified, our research suggests, as long as they include an appropriate number of breaks. Second, it is important for school accountability systems to control for the influence of external factors on test scores.
We rarely ask the question of whether it is the right time to take a test. But, our research suggests, this may be an important question to ask going forward given that, as the day wears on, students (like all of us) become increasingly fatigued and consequently more likely to underperform on a standardized test.