Uncategorized

There’s a new addiction on campus: Problematic Internet Use (PIU)

Susan M. Snyder, Georgia State University; Jennifer E. O’Brien, University of North Carolina – Chapel Hill, and Wen Li, University of North Carolina – Chapel Hill

Problematic Internet Use is now considered to be a behavioral addiction with characteristics that are similar to substance use disorders.

Individuals with PIU may have difficulty reducing their Internet use, may be preoccupied with the Internet or may lie to conceal their use.

A recent study that I coauthored with UNC Chapel Hill doctoral students Wen Li and Jennifer O’Brien and UNC professor Matthew O. Howard examines this new behavioral addiction.

Perhaps not surprisingly, individuals with PIU have been found to experience several negative mental health problems which could include depression, attention deficit/hyperactivity disorder (ADHD), hostility, social phobias, problematic alcohol use, self-injurious behavior and trouble sleeping (i.e., sleep apnea, nightmares, insomnia, and struggling to stay awake during the daytime).

Our study is the first to look at how PIU affects family relationships among U.S. university students. Intriguingly, we found that college students with PIU report effects that are both negative and positive.

Measuring PIU and its problems

To better understand PIU, we focused on students whose Internet use was excessive and created problems in their lives.

Study participants were undergraduate or graduate students enrolled at UNC Chapel Hill. We required that participants be individuals who were spending more than 25 hours a week on the Internet (time that was not related to school or work). Additionally, participants had to report experiencing at least one health, relationship or emotional problem due to PIU.

To recruit our participants, our team sent out an email on a Friday evening. We were not sure if this would be a good time to reach students, but we were surprised that within two hours, 39 students responded. Of those who responded to our email, 27 students attended our four focus groups and completed our questionnaires.

Roughly half (48.1 percent) of our participants were considered “Internet addicts.” These participants answered “yes” to five or more of our eight questions (e.g., preoccupation; inability to control use; lying about use; depressed or moody when trying to stop).

Half of the participants of the study were considered to be Internet addicts.
Southern Tier Advocacy & Mitigation Project, Incorporated, CC BY-NC-ND

Another 40.7% were considered to be “potential Internet addicts.” These participants answered “yes” to three or four items. All of the participants met the criteria for PIU using the Compulsive Internet Use Scale, a 14-item scale that included items like difficulty stopping; sleep deprivation; neglect obligations; feelings of restlessness, frustration or irritation when Internet is unavailable.

We used focus groups, which are group conversations guided by a facilitator, to discuss shared experiences or knowledge regarding PIU. Each focus group had six to eight participants.

Here is what we found

Three key themes emerged in the conversations: (1) family connectedness, (2) family conflict/family disconnection, and (3) Internet overuse among other family members.

We had examples of positive connections. Some participants reported that the Internet connected them to their families. For example, participants discussed using Skype, Facebook or email to maintain relationships with family while they were away at college.

A student we call Hannah explained:

But like using Skype helps keep you connected and also when we are at home we watch a movie together, it’s like family time, you know. And um, like you know, if we read the same, like article, then we can talk about it on Skype.

Another student, Lisa said:

I hate talking on the phone. So, that allows me a way to stay connected and especially with my mom who would… Normally, I would just not respond to her at all, but now we have an email dialogue going. That helps us stay more connected.

Despite the positive consequences that participants discussed, we found that across the focus groups, participants spent more time talking about the negative consequences of Internet use.

For these participants, Internet use caused family relationships to disconnect or become conflicted.

Instead of interacting with their family when they were at home, participants reported that they were “on the computer the whole time.” One participant described ignoring her family during her visits home as a result of her Internet use:

My grandma and my parents will complain about my Internet use because I will be sitting in front of the TV and I’ll have my laptop and so will my little sister. We’ll be sitting in front of the TV on our laptops not talking to each other. So, my parents will complain about that.

Andrew said,

I think for me, this year I went home and one of the reasons was just was to have more family time, but what I ended up really doing was staying on my computer pretty much the whole time, which was kind of defeating the purpose of actually going home.

Steve described how his Internet use affected a visit with his brother and his friends at a sports bar:

At one point we’re all watching the basketball game, and all four because we’re all on our phone, and he looked at us and he said, ‘Really guys, I am here for two days, you all just wanna [sic] be on Twitter and Facebook?’ So, while it can enhance with setting up social situations, it can also detract from them once you were actually in them…Yeah, he was very just like…He flew out for the weekend. You know he spent US$300 on an airplane ticket just to sit there and watch me on Facebook.

It’s not just the students

It may not be surprising that college students with PIU reported that members of their families also overuse the Internet.

Some participants expressed frustration at the lack of boundaries or rules in place for their younger siblings or other relatives. A participant we called Melissa shared about her little brother:

He just turned four, but they got him an iPad. Like, which I don’t agree with. I think it’s so stupid, but he is always, always on it. He gets really defensive if you try to take it away or put boundaries on it or something like that.

Small children are getting addicted to their devices as well.
Tia Henriksen, CC BY

Hannah, for example, described a cousin whose Internet gaming has impaired his vision, but he is unable to stop playing:

My cousin, he is addicted to video games. And he’s like, I think he is like 10, 12, something like that, I don’t remember. I feel like it’s a stupid game, there’s no deepness to it. You kill someone. They die. You get killed, it starts over again. He can play that for eight hours straight without moving. His eyes are really bad right now. He can’t control himself.

Participants described their parents’ PIU as well. Several participants described their parents as “constantly checking email” for their work. Others described their parents as regularly on computers, phones or iPads “on Facebook” or “browsing.”

Sarah likened her Internet use to her mother’s:

It’s not just the students who are addicted.
Chris Owens, CC BY-NC-SA

My mom talks about me using the phone at the table when we’re eating, cause like if there’s a break in conversation, ‘Oh, Facebook opportunity’ [others laughed and she laughed too]. And then, like, somehow in my mind [the] conversation is over, but it’s really not. So then she’s like ‘You’re always on your phone, what are you doing?’ But then, like two minutes later, she is checking the weather. So I don’t know [she laughed].

A few participants shared that they were the only ones in their family with PIU.

Cindy explained that her family was from another country, which may explain their low Internet use,

I find that I don’t really have family members with an Internet problem, and I am the only one who grew up here. So, that might be…

Gina said,

My parents are technophobes. They don’t even know how to turn on computers.

Although our sample size is small, we followed rigorous approaches to ensure that we obtained the best possible data. We conducted focus groups until we achieved data saturation, which means that when we reviewed the final focus group no new themes were discovered.

The conclusions come through loud and clear. PIU exists and it affects family relationships. While those effects may be both positive and negative, those who suffer adverse consequences from PIU may have difficulty addressing their PIU because of requirements to use Internet for classes via online assignments (e.g., writing blogs), online courses and materials accessed online.

All names have been changed to protect identity.

The Conversation

Susan M. Snyder, Assistant Professor of Social Work, Georgia State University; Jennifer E. O’Brien, Ph.D. Student, University of North Carolina – Chapel Hill, and Wen Li, Ph.D. Student, University of North Carolina – Chapel Hill

This article was originally published on The Conversation. Read the original article.

Read all of our posts about EdTech and Innovation by clicking here. 

How LRM is transforming teaching and learning

Behind every successful adult is at least one person who pushed him or her to greatness. If you ask some of the world’s highest achievers what motivated them to keep going, they usually mention a specific person who inspired them along the way – a parent, a teacher, a mentor, a coach.

Think about the people in your own life who made a positive impact when you were young. If you are an educator, it was probably a teacher of your own who inspired you to take that next step and answer the call to teach. There were likely other less-direct influences on your career choice, and others who influenced other parts of the positive parts of your adult life.

Now imagine what it would look like if all of those mentors – those teachers, those coaches – had been able to combine their efforts for a singular purpose: guiding you on the road to successful adulthood. It’s a pretty amazing thought, right? But most of those people were probably from different circles of your life with you (a kid) being the only connection between them. Technology is changing that though, by better aligning the important relationships in a student’s life.

More specifically, Learning Relationship Management is delving deeper into how mentors like teachers and coaches help guide all students to success — both academically, and in other areas of life. The Learning Relationship Management Alliance is a leader in this student-friendly technology that can also be applied to other groups that benefit from mentor support, like senior citizens in assisted living.

The LRM Alliance created this infographic to summarize exactly what the vision is for this relationship technology, including a need to cultivate authentic relationships, personalize learning, streamline content, and connect networks in a student’s life. Take a look:

 

So how is the LRM Alliance progressing these ideas in a coherent way that any district can implement? By combining the strengths of several leading companies to raise awareness about the many benefits to this learning setup. This group of edtech innovators is changing the way students succeed through electronic means that extend beyond academic pursuits. The five companies that make up the LRM Alliance are:

Through community-enabled mentorship, the strengths of a variety of people associated with each student is tapped. This includes, and is not limited to, parents, teachers, sports coaches, and more. Even older siblings can be included in the community to help encourage, monitor and ultimately guide the student to positive learning outcomes.

When it comes to personalized and blended learning, LRM allows K-20 brick and mortar schools and online schools to move from small pilot programs to large, full-scale implementation. Teachers and administrators have more information on how students are progressing and can tailor lessons to better fit their needs and learning styles. Personalized learning paths are in turn supported through learning relationship management and strengthened by the mentors outside the classroom who are in the student’s network. Learning Relationship Management does not just setup personalized and blended learning lesson plans; it gives students the tools to execute those plans.

Learning Relationship Management is not just about prescriptive methods, though, or simply handing out assignments. The students themselves are an integral part of the process of goal-setting, intervention planning and the communication that takes place about them. Every student can benefit from LRM tools because it does not dictate what people must take part. If a student lives with grandparents, or has a drama teacher but no sports coaches, or even has a trusted teacher he wants to keep in the system even when class has ended, LRM technology makes all of that possible.

Learning Relationship Management has the potential to combine what schools are already doing right with a stronger support group outside the classroom. There can be numerous people (invited by the student and overseen by the lead adult administrator) who weigh in on the goals, benchmarks and activities of the student. There is a lot of power in the community-enabled coaching model and the more people who can contribute to the success of a student — in a streamlined, productive way — the better that student will fare in school, and in life.

You can learn more about the Learning Relationship Management Alliance and its member companies at the organization’s site.

Read all of our posts about EdTech and Innovation by clicking here. 

Study: Black boys affected by racial stereotypes

A new study produced by researchers at the University of Iowa reveals that black boys are seen as more threatening than white boys.

While that’s not necessarily breaking news, the research was conducted to investigate why so many black men are shot and killed by the police. In doing so, they found that racial stereotypes play a large factor into why incidents of that nature happen.

But their research also revealed that the racial prejudices we show against black men really begins much earlier. The study found that racial stereotypes are first felt by black men when they are just boys.

Delving deeper into the study, the findings get even more disturbing. The researchers polled more than 60 white college students and showed them separate pictures of five-year old black and white boys.

As they were shown the images of the children, the students were also given pictures of a gun or a toy.

The analysts revealed that the white college students were more likely to partner the photo of a gun with a black child and the picture of a toy with a white kid.

While white children are seen as less threatening, black children face the crushing weight of being racially stigmatized.

This study explains why so many black students are suspended from school compared to that of their white counterparts. It’s why Oakland started a program geared towards black boys in order to help deal with the crisis of black students being disproportionately kicked out of school.

It’s also why President Obama has a plan to try to decrease the number of black kids who are expelled from school.

But I’m not sure that a national program will change the way we view black children. We often associate innocence with the face of children, but the reality for black kids–at least according to this study–shows that we believe them to be dangerous and a threat to our safety.

Even if that child is just five years of age.

Alabama scientist proves need for more minorities in STEM

Dr. Hadiyah-Nicole Green is a physicist from St. Louis, Missouri who teaches physics at Tuskegee University. Earning her bachelor’s degree from Alabama A&M University and her master’s and Ph.D from the University of Alabama at Birmingham, Green is the living embodiment of what Historically Black Colleges and Universities (HBCU) are capable of producing.

But more than that, she finds herself in rarefied air. There are less than 100 black women physicists in the nation, and she’s one of them.

She was recently awarded a grant of more than $1 million to continue development of a new treatment for cancer. Instead of using radiation and chemotherapy to target and kill cancer cells, she cultivated a way to mark only the cancer cells in one’s body instead of the healthy ones that surround them.

Green did this using lasers.

She’s been advancing this proposed treatment for more than seven years, and the grant will allow her to continue to work on it.

Yet even with her success and potential breakthrough in finding a new treatment that’s safer for cancer patients than radiation, she’s still just one of less than 100.

Black women have a place in science–more specifically STEM (Science, Technology, Engineering, and Math education). Showcasing Green’s achievements and how she’s carving her own path in the field proves that we need more black women in the field.

But it’s hard, and not because black women lack intelligence, it is because we fail to give them the proper opportunities. By way of information provided by mic.com, there was a jump in the number of black women who received Ph.D’s in computer science from 2002 to 2012. The number went from eight to 16.

For white men in the same field, there was an increase from 198 to 436.

Those numbers aren’t much better in other areas of STEM and are only slightly improving.

To combat the problem, we have to continue to showcase the success of black women like Dr. Hadiyah-Nicole Green and the close to 100 others who are making a way in STEM.

It is at least one pathway to show little black girls that there is room for them in STEM.

Read all of our posts about EdTech and Innovation by clicking here. 

Harvard to offer free online classes to promote religious understanding

Making religion palatable isn’t easy but Harvard is going to give it a shot. Starting March 1st, professors from Harvard Divinity School and Wellesley College will host free online classes to better explain world religion and enrollment is open to the public.

Did I mention that the classes are free?

The classes are being offered to give depth and better understanding of different religions around the world, and to potentially make them more appetizing. But not for reasons of acceptance, more for compassion.

Because of geopolitical behavior in the Middle East and other parts of the world, many believe the instability is due to religion. Religious intolerance abounds — mainly as a result of those who describe factions of Islam as radical and apply it to the entire faith. There are misconceptions about other religions too, even mainstream ones in the U.S. like Christianity.

The courses will not only talk about the history of each faith, but what makes each distinct and complex.

 

Students of all ages, and mainly adults, should be encouraged to register for the free courses. During a presidential year where the history and point of Islam is being debated as if its the breakfast special at a local diner, the course on the topic of the Islamic faith is needed.

To combat that religious bigotry, Harvard is will present courses on five different faiths including Buddhism, Hinduism, Judaism, Islam, and Christianity.

Each class will run four weeks and the first one will start March 1st. For more information on each course, or to register, visit courses.edx.org. The courses are being offered through edX, an online learning tool developed by Harvard University and Massachusetts Institute of Technology (MIT).

Why BMI is not a smart health measurement for teachers

**The Edvocate is pleased to publish guest posts as way to fuel important conversations surrounding P-20 education in America. The opinions contained within guest posts are those of the authors and do not necessarily reflect the official opinion of The Edvocate or Dr. Matthew Lynch.**

Guest post by Rick Osbourne

Anyone familiar with Operation Pull Your Own Weight already knows we contend that using BMI as the measurement tool of choice represents a major obstacle when it comes to making any progress on the ongoing obesity epidemic. I’ve personally railed against BMI on one too many occasions – particularly when it relates to kids.

But I recently received an email from a friend named Dr. Wayne Wescott of Quincy College in Quincy, MA which made the case against BMI when used on adults so eloquently that I thought our readers would find it compelling. Allow me to quote Dr. Wescott:

“Take for example a 65 year old male who has performed no resistance training and weighs the same 165 pounds that he did at age 25. Of course his BMI would be the same and his physician would say that he’s in great shape. However, his body composition has actually changed by at least 50 pounds (25 pounds less muscle – at 6 pounds/decade reduction rate from sarcopenia – and 25 pounds more fat).”

Let’s dig into this example a little deeper just for fun. Let’s say this male teacher’s percentage of body fat was 20% back when he was 25 years old. That means 33 of his 165 pounds of body weight was made up of fat back then (165 lbs. X .20 = 33 lbs.). So he’s in pretty good shape.

Four Decades Later…
Now as Wescott suggests, let’s flip the calendar ahead forty years and see that this teacher’s body weight is still the same 165 pounds. And his height is also the same. That means his BMI will be exactly the same at age 65 as it was when he was age 25. No change at all!

But now we learn that this gent has done no resistance training during those four decades. This means he’s lost a bunch of muscle mass (approximately 25 pounds, at six pounds per decade due to sarcopenia). In order to weigh the same 165 pounds he’s replaced the lost 25 pounds of muscle mass with 25 pounds of body fat. That’s the only possibility.

That means at age 65 this gent now carries 58 pounds of body fat instead of the original 33 pounds of body fat (33 + 25 = 58). Since his body weight remains exactly the same, 165 pounds, his actual percentage of body fat has now ballooned from the original 20% to over 35% (58/165 = 35%). In other words, he’s actually gone from being in pretty good shape at age 25, to being OBESE (30% body fat or higher) at age 65…despite what his BMI indicates.

A HUGE Discrepancy!

Let me say it this way. That’s no small discrepancy! That’s a huge discrepancy!! This guy is now carrying 25 MORE POUNDS OF BODY FAT and he has 25 FEWER POUNDS OF MUSCLE MASS (horsepower) with which to carry it. To make matters even worse, this 25 pounds of muscle mass loss has caused his metabolism (his ability to burn calories) to drop like a rock. That means in order to maintain his 165 pounds, he can’t eat as much as he used to eat.

Is it any wonder this guy can no longer get up and down a flight of stairs the way he could when he was 25? He can’t run, jump, climb, or do anything with the same efficiency as he was able to do forty years ago. Yet BMI DETECTS NO DIFFERENCE AT ALL!!! *

The big question in the minds of many of us non-bureaucrats out here on Main Street is how in the world can anyone expect to make any progress on the obesity epidemic if the powers that be continue to endorse a measurement tool that’s unable to distinguish ten pounds of body fat from ten pounds of muscle mass from ten pounds of dog food, or bubble gum?

You may as well attempt to play the Super Bowl without any yard lines on the field, and a game clock that doesn’t work. If we’re unable to measure changes accurately and we continue to do nothing about it, why don’t we just confess out loud that we really don’t give a damn about beating the obesity epidemic? After all, many major corporations are making boatloads of profit because of the epidemic. And the bottom line after all…is the bottom line.

*There is a cost effective alternative known as a FORE Score (Functional Obesity Risk Evaluation Score) in case anyone is actually interested in accurate body comp measurement without breaking the bank.

**UCLA recently published a longitudinal study of over 40,000 people which is described by its author, Dr. Janet Tomiyama as “The final nail in the coffin of BMI.” This development certainly represents a step in the right direction.

_____

Rick Osbourne is a former physical educator and a pioneer in the field of functional childhood obesity prevention. He currently serves as President of the Pull Your Own Weight Foundation which is an Illinois based, 501c3, not for profit organization whose focus is functional childhood obesity prevention. He’s written and published three books in this field, the latest of which is entitled Beating Childhood Obesity Now: A Simple Solution for Parents and Educators. He’s the Examiner’s national childhood obesity prevention correspondent. He writes an online column for The Edvocate. And you can connect with Rick via Twitter, Linkedin, or Facebook.

4 Tips for Creative Writing in Class

**The Edvocate is pleased to publish guest posts as way to fuel important conversations surrounding P-20 education in America. The opinions contained within guest posts are those of the authors and do not necessarily reflect the official opinion of The Edvocate or Dr. Matthew Lynch.**

A guest post by Michael Yarbrough

What it’s like to be a teacher? You present new material to students, keep track of their academic progress, and manage their behavior in the classroom. If that’s all you did, you might be considered a good teacher. But if you want to be a great teacher, you have to add something to that list: inspiring students to be creative. When it comes to writing instructors, this is an especially important thing to cultivate.

Creativity is the most essential thing for writing classes. Here students learn where to find new ideas, how to structure their story, what writing techniques to choose, and so on. Students certainly can learn all these things, but if they aren’t inspired, if they don’t see how you personally love writing with all your passion, they won’t learn to love it themselves.

The starting point for you to assist students in releasing their creativity is to show them your own love to writing. Teachers are models for their students, so it’s absolutely fine if students imitate their educator and treat writing the way their teachers do. In cases where the classroom environment is friendly and pleasant, and a teacher is a good mentor to every student, there’s a strong chance students will be happy to follow the example of their educator and adopt positive attitudes about writing.

Also, you should certainly let students know about great authors and their best works. Talk about what inspired famous writers, how they gained their writing success, what strange habits they had, how they treated writing, and many other interesting details. Always emphasize that students must not try to copy the writing manner or style of other authors. Each student must develop and cherish his or her own unique writing voice.

And of course, suggest that your students do a few helpful writing exercises. Choose any of the following:

Free Writing. Introduce your students to a topic and tell them they will free-write during some specific period of time (such as five minutes). Students are supposed to write without stops and without over-thinking – they write whatever is in their heads at the moment. They can disregard punctuation and spelling as well as storyline. They shouldn’t edit anything at the time, though you’ll have enough time to discuss their free-writing a bit later. This exercise is perfect as a writing warm-up, and you should do it at the beginning of the class.

Associations. Distribute sheets of paper among your students on which you have written a list of words. Their task is to write the first association that comes to mind for each one. Again, students mustn’t think about it at all, they should note immediately what image they see or whatever association pops into their minds. Since this exercise is good for increasing imagination and expanding vocabulary, use it at the beginning of the class as another warm-up that gets them ready to work.

Group Writing. Have your students write a story together. You will be the first to start. Jot down a thought provoking sentence and let your students continue the story. Each student contributes one sentence to the story. The rule is that every single sentence should move the plot forward. Finally, read your group writing aloud so students can enjoy the work they created together.

Role-playing. In this exercise your students get the chance to become fictional characters for a while. Your task is to choose characters for each student. Don’t take just protagonists or antagonists, use plenty of minor characters from well-known novels as well. Students need to describe some of the novel’s major events from the point of view of the character they take on. Thus, you will be able to see alternative points of view concerning events in the plot.

A few final tips: Don’t be afraid to experiment while teaching how to write, listen to the unique writing voices of your students, and don’t forget that if you love what you do, students will love it too.

________

Michael is a former school teacher, currently working as an ESL tutor. Teaching is his favorite way of finding inspiration. In spare time he enjoys volunteering and provides a lot help to wild and homeless animals. Connect with Michael via Twitter and Linkedin.

Reading Horizons Incorporates the Lexile® Framework for Reading in K-3 Literacy Platform

North Salt Lake, UT- Feb. 23, 2016 — Reading Horizons and MetaMetrics® are thrilled to announce the expansion of their partnership with the addition of Lexile® measures in the Reading Horizons Discovery™ program. Reading Horizons and MetaMetrics, developer of the widely adopted Lexile® Framework for Reading, first announced their partnership in May 2015 when Lexile measures launched in the Reading Horizons Elevate reading program.

Reading Horizons Discovery is a strategy-based reading solution designed for students in Kindergarten through third grade that incorporates multi-sensory, Orton-Gillingham principles of instruction and a unique marking system that delivers superior results. The effective, easy-to-use software utilizes the most current technology and instructional best practices to deliver assessments and skill-based lessons for each grade level, K-3. Initial assessments ensure that teachers have an accurate measure of each student’s ability and the software adapts to meet the needs and skill levels of those students and provides differentiation as they progress through the program.

The software includes formative assessments as well as vocabulary, games, and activities. Reading Horizons Discovery fulfills 92% of the standards for foundational reading skills for students in K-3, as well as other standards outlined by the Common Core State Standards, and is correlated to the findings of the National Reading Panel.

“We consistently strive to provide the most robust literacy solutions possible for our customers, including the ability to adjust instruction in order to meet readers where they are,” commented Reading Horizons’ President and CEO Tyson Smith. “Adding the Lexile® Framework for Reading in Reading Horizons Discovery immediately provides educators with yet another layer to truly assess where their students are at and how to best support their learning moving forward.”

The assessment’s initial Lexile measure serves as a benchmark for gauging both a student’s reading ability and the complexity of text so that appropriate reading materials can be matched to the student as they progress. Reading Horizons Discovery automatically unlocks reading passages in the software library as additional skills are mastered. Each book in the library has been measured by MetaMetrics and has an official Lexile level. 

“I applaud Reading Horizons for extending their use of Lexile measures to K-3,” stated Malbert Smith III, Ph.D., president and co-founder of MetaMetrics. “More than that, Reading Horizons is measuring their readers at the start of their academic career. This allows for early detection of struggling readers, and then immediate intervention to strengthen the reader’s ability before they fall too far behind their peers. The power of Lexile measures also allows educators to seamlessly track their students reading growth throughout their K-12 progression.”

About Reading Horizons

Founded in 1984, Reading Horizons provides teacher training, direct instruction materials, and interactive software that empower teachers to effectively teach beginning readers, intervene with struggling readers, and provide instruction and support to English Language Learners. To learn more about Reading Horizons, please visit them online at www.readinghorizons.com or follow them on twitter https://twitter.com/ReadingHorizons.

About MetaMetrics

MetaMetrics is focused on improving education for learners of all ages and ability levels. The organization develops scientific measures of academic, achievement, and complementary technologies that link assessment results with real-world instruction. To learn more about MetaMetrics, please visit them online at www.metametricsinc.com.

Read all of our posts about EdTech and Innovation by clicking here. 

How the justice system fails us after police shootings

Caren Morrison, Georgia State University

Two weeks ago, the police officer who shot Laquan McDonald in Chicago was charged with first-degree murder. Since then, the police superintendent was fired, and the Department of Justice announced that it will begin a large-scale investigation into the Chicago Police Department. Meanwhile, in Baltimore, one of the police officers charged in the death of Freddie Gray is standing trial.

You might think these high-profile cases mark a turning point in the nation’s response to fatal police violence. But 1,058 people have been killed by police this year to date alone, and most of the time, no legal charges follow. In my own state of Georgia, 171 people have been shot dead by police since 2010, and there have been zero prosecutions.

As a former federal prosecutor and a criminal procedure professor, I’ve been studying how prosecutors handle police violence cases. How do they deal with the conflict of interest raised by investigating the police departments they work with? Who determines whether a civilian death is justified, as the vast majority are found to be?

The results are not pretty.

A more typical example

The prosecutions in the McDonald and Gray cases are actually quite unusual. Many more cases are like that of Caroline Small, a 35-year-old mother of two who was shot to death in her car by two police officers in Brunswick, Georgia in 2010.

Small was unarmed. She was not suspected of any serious crimes. After a low-speed chase, her car ended up wedged tightly between two police cars and a utility pole. When she tried to pull forward, the officers shot her eight times.

Local TV told Small’s story.

The police officers said that they were afraid that Small was going to hit them with her car. The grand jury found the shooting was justified.

Small would have ended up as just another statistic if Brad Schrade, an investigative reporter from the Atlanta Journal-Constitution, hadn’t tracked down some of the former grand jurors and Georgia Bureau of Investigation agents who investigated the case.

The lead agent called it the worst police shooting he’d ever seen. But that was not what the district attorney, Jackie Johnson, told the grand jury – the people responsible for deciding if the officers should be charged with a crime.

Instead, Johnson showed them a blatantly inaccurate computer-animated reenactment of the scene, produced by the police department. The animation showed Small’s car turning sideways and hitting the officers. But, as one of the Georgia Bureau of Investigation agents swore in a deposition, “There is no way on this Earth that car could have moved in one swift motion through that gap.”

No one was ever prosecuted for the killing of Caroline Small. But the case exemplifies the toxic combination of powerful district attorneys and shadowy grand juries that has undermined public confidence in the criminal justice system’s ability to respond to cases of deadly police violence.

The secrecy of grand juries

Grand juries in all states have the power to investigate crimes, but the way they function is unusual in our mostly open justice system. Prosecutors go into grand juries alone, without opposing counsel, question witnesses in secret, and only release transcripts of the proceedings in limited circumstances.

So when grand juries failed to indict the police officers responsible for the deaths of Michael Brown and Eric Garner, the ensuing protests were not just a reaction to the decisions themselves. They were also a reaction to the way these issues of public concern are decided behind closed doors, without explanation.

In response, California became the first state to bar grand juries from investigating fatal police use-of-force cases, a rule that will come into effect in the new year. Instead, California prosecutors in police homicide cases will now present their evidence at a preliminary hearing before a magistrate judge, a proceeding that is adversarial and open to the public.

The power of prosecutors

But the problem goes beyond secrecy. The real issue is that the prosecutor controls whether a case goes forward at all. This is true whether the case proceeds by indictment or preliminary hearing. Other than public opinion and the possible pressures of reelection, no one oversees the prosecutors.

When a police officer kills a civilian, prosecutors have a number of options. Often, they simply do nothing, letting internal police department procedures handle the issue. No one can force them to prosecute. A prosecutor’s discretion to pick and choose among cases is absolute, and their reasons may not be second-guessed.

Sometimes, if a police killing is highly publicized – like when a dashcam video is released – a prosecutor may feel the need to do something, even if they don’t want to pursue the case.

Going into the grand jury and coming out without an indictment shifts apparent responsibility from the prosecutor to the grand jury. Prosecutors can say they tried, but the grand jury decided against them.

Except that’s not how grand juries work.

I was a federal prosecutor for five years and made dozens of grand jury presentations. Prosecutors see the same grand jurors week in and week out, on all different cases. They control the evidence the grand jury hears. Grand jurors can ask to hear additional evidence, but the prosecutor can talk them out of it. And if – God forbid – the grand jury refuses to issue an indictment, the prosecutor can go back in front of a different grand jury. It’s poor form, but it happens.

So when a prosecutor says, “The grand jury has spoken,” that usually means that the grand jury has reached the only conclusion the prosecutor allowed it to reach.

After the officers involved in Caroline Small’s death were cleared, Johnson commented, “I don’t control the results,“ as if she hadn’t deliberately tanked the case.

A former prosecutor from her office was blunt, telling a reporter, “This was a murder and it was covered up.” But at that time, Johnson was a recently appointed DA, and civil court records show that the police chief had sent a letter to the governor supporting her candidacy.

California’s plan is a start

California’s approach, making prosecutors proceed by public preliminary hearing rather than by grand jury, should help protect against the most blatant forms of sabotage by prosecutors.

But the law stops well short of requiring prosecutors to present evidence in all cases of police homicide. If states were serious about taking absolute discretion out of the hands of prosecutors, they could mandate that all cases of fatal police violence go to a public hearing to determine whether the case should proceed to trial.

After all, we can’t expect investigative journalists to uncover all the mishandled cases.

When a police officer causes the death of a member of the public, it shakes our faith in our public institutions and underscores the fragility of community-police relations. These incidents are matters of intense public concern. A more transparent process, one that addresses all police homicides, not just the ones that make headlines, would be an improvement.

The Conversation

Caren Morrison, Associate Professor of Law, Georgia State University

This article was originally published on The Conversation. Read the original article.

Have for-profit schools preyed on minorities?

Turn on your television to any local station during daytime hours, and you’re sure to see a handful of commercials touting the amazing benefits of enrolling in for-profit colleges. These idyllic spots highlight flexible classes, accelerated programs, online classes available from the comfort of home, and more. Usually the information about the particular college is delivered by a once-uneducated person turned career success – often a working dad, or single mom, whose kids are clearly proud of what the parent has accomplished. Obtaining a college education, particularly from the school mentioned, looks so easy to do.

While the description above may seem like the stuff of marketing clichés, it’s a tactic that has worked for many for-profit colleges. Targeting minorities and other non-traditional college students through commercials like these has been the bread-and-butter of for-profit schools for at least the past two decades and those tactics are just now starting to see some legal pushback.

To be clear, not all for-profit colleges are created equal. There are some that boast high graduation rates and seem to have student success at the heart of their endeavors. The very fact that these colleges exist have actually progressed the entire university system in the U.S. by pushing innovative programs, like online degrees, and showing that there truly is a large market for non-traditional college students.

Let’s not kid ourselves though. The non-profit college push is a very thinly-veiled attempt to enroll a volatile market – often the most eligible for federal loan and grant assistance.

The financial facts speak for themselves:

  • As of 2014, for-profit colleges served just 13 percent of total higher education students but received 31 percent of federal student loans due to the minority, at-risk and low-income statuses of their students. Former veterans cashing in GI Bills also attend for-profit schools at higher rates than traditional colleges.
  • The same report from the U.S. Department of Education reports that half of all students who default on their loans attend a for-profit college.

Which leads to the unavoidable question: Have non-profit colleges preyed upon at-risk students for the sake of making a quick buck?

All the right words

One of the reasons for-profit schools have seen such a surge in enrollment in the past two decades can really be pinned on the smart marketing of two words: flexibility and acceleration. For students who simply did not have the funds, nor desire to incur college debt, right after high school, for-profit schools have stepped up as a second chance, of sorts. These colleges are places where non-traditional students can continue to work and take flexible courses, many or all of which are online. Most for-profit schools also offer a faster route to degree attainment, which piques the interest of students who don’t want to dedicate years of their lives to college aspirations but are looking for a way to advance their careers. The University of Phoenix, perhaps the most recognizable name in for-profit online colleges, recently announced a new initiative to count other course work and work experience towards degree attainment. This initiative, and others like it, are designed to recruit students who don’t want to start from square one and don’t have the time to commit to a traditional college experience.

So what is wrong with either of these options? Nothing, in theory. Flexibility and accelerated degrees are a good fit for many students who otherwise could not chase any sort of college degree. Where many non-profits fail their students, however, is in charging astronomical rates and not offering enough support to keep students enrolled until graduation. In essence, these schools market well enough to get the students enrolled in courses but don’t do enough to guide them to their degrees. All the flexibility in the world can’t help a student understand a difficult concept, or learn better time/study management skills. Accelerated programs without mentorship options run the risk of burning students out, especially if they have no inspiration or focus.

It’s clear that the recent outcry for accountability for non-profit colleges is long overdue. Students deserve better than what they’ve been served by these institutions, and quite frankly, so does the entire American population. It’s time for these schools to deliver on their promise of career success for those who enroll – and that starts with student support that extends beyond recruitment.