Uncategorized

How to Implement the Text-to-Text, Text-to-Self, Text-to-World Teaching Strategy in Your Classroom

Description

Reading comes alive after we recognize how the concepts in content connect to our experiences and beliefs, events happening in the world, our comprehension of history, and our knowledge of other content. The text-to-text, text-to-self, text-to-world method helps learners develop the habit of making these connections as they read. When learners are given a purpose for their reading, they can comprehend better and make meaning of the ideas in the content. You can use this method with any content—historical or literary—and with other media, such as film. It can be used at the beginning, middle, or end of the reading process to get learners engaged with content, to help learners understand the content more intensely, or to assess learners’ comprehension of the content.

Implementation

  1. Select a Text: This method works best with content that raises universal themes that may resonate with learners’ own experiences and with the material they have studied previously. Instructors often give learners their copy of the content so that they can mark it up, although this is not required.
  2. Guide Learners through Text-to-Text, Text-to-Self, Text-to-World: The accompanying handout for this method provides you with sample questions that you can give learners to guide them through this learning activity. The questions included in the instructions are general but can be easily modified to connect to the material your class is studying. For instance, you may ask learners to connect what they read to particular contents or to events you have studied earlier in the school year.
  3. Debrief: Learners gain a deeper comprehension of the content and the world around them when they have the opportunity to discuss their responses with peers. Learners can share their answers with a partner, in small groups, or as part of a broader discussion.

Modifications

  1. One Connection: If you are short on time, you can give learners the option of writing about one connection they have found between the content and their lives.
  2. Mapping Relationship: Social maps are a visual way to illustrate connections between people, but they can also be used to show relationships between ideas and events. An extension of this learning activity would be to have learners draw the connections they find between the content and other ideas, occurrences, or experiences. Learners can work on these maps in groups, noting the relationships among their responses.

How to Implement the Think, Pair, Share Teaching Strategy in Your Classroom

Description

In a learning activity based on the think, pair, share method, learners write and discuss their ideas with a partner before sharing them with the group. This format allows learners to respond to questions in written form thoughtfully and to engage in meaningful dialogue with other learners about these issues. It is a helpful way to give learners time to compose their ideas before sharing with them with the class. The think, pair, share method helps learners build confidence, encourages greater participation, and often results in more thoughtful discussions.

Implementation

  1. Think: Have learners reflect on a given question or write a response in their journals.
  2. Pair: Have learners pair up and share their responses.
  3. Share: When the group reconvenes, ask pairs to report back on their conversations. Alternatively, you could ask learners to share what their partner said. In this way, the method focuses on learners’ skills as careful active listeners.

How to Implement the Town Hall Circle Teaching Strategy in Your Classroom

Description

This teaching method mimics the process of a town hall meeting, where community members take the floor to share their perspective on a topic of concern. Utilizing this format, learners have the opportunity to share their different views by tapping into and out of the group conversation. Learners often come away from this experience with a greater appreciation for how our viewpoint can limit the facts we have at our disposal and the opinions we hold. By listening to others’ ideas, learners broaden their comprehension of the world in which they live.

Implementation

  1. Select Readings: Choose four to six readings on the same subject that embody different perspectives.
  2. Learners Read in Groups: Divide the class into four to six groups (depending on the number of readings) and assign each group one of the readings. Allow learners to read. Some groups may prefer to read the content aloud after each learner has also had a chance to read the content silently. Then have learners discuss the reading among themselves, answering questions such as: What is this reading about? What are the main ideas and facts? Why are these ideas applicable or essential? From whose perspective is this content written? How may that influence the views expressed in the content? Learners appoint one person in their group to summarize their reading to the class.
  3. Town Hall Discussion Part 1: Summaries. Organize chairs in a circle, providing one chair to each group. The learner assigned to summarize for each group sits in the chair. The other learners form a standing circle around the chairs. Make it clear that each learner in the class will have an opportunity to be heard. Learners can only speak when they have entered the circle and are seated. Then, each spokesperson summarizes the reading assigned to the group. No analysis or interpretation must be done after this.
  1. Town Hall Discussion Part 2: Conversations and Comments
    Once the reading has been summarized, encourage learners seated in the circle to comment on what they have heard or to ask one of their peers a question. Learners in the outer ring are then allowed to enter the conversation by “tapping” the muster of someone in their group and taking their seats.
  2. Debrief: After the discussion, allow learners to reflect on the following questions in their journals or through a class discussion: What did you learn from this learning experience? Did your feelings about the subject evolve following this learning activity? What does “perspective” mean? Where does a person’s perspective come from? How does our perspective shape the way we see the world? Draw on particular examples from this learning activity when answering these questions.

How to Implement the Stations: Interacting with Multiple Texts Teaching Strategy in Your Classroom

Description

In a station learning activity, small groups of learners move from station to station to read, watch, and interpret a variety of resources that focus on an event, theme, or question from multiple perspectives. Groups of learners spend an allotted amount of time at each station interacting with the material and either answering questions or engaging in a reflective activity. The station’s learning activity works well to launch a new unit or to explore in more depth something learners have already studied. When the instructor selects from different kinds of content—informational texts, poetry, art, photography, maps, video or audio clips—learners can engage with the material utilizing multiple modalities thus allowing them to reach a deeper comprehension of the event, theme, or question than they might by reading or discussing just one or two pieces of contents.

Implementation

  1. Select Texts and Develop Stations: Determine the number of stations you want to have, the amount of time each group will spend at each station, what activities learners will do at each station, and what texts you plan to utilize. Determine the kinds of media you want to use, so learners have multiple access points to engage with the topic. For instance, you may select informational texts, short videos, images, and poetry. Having some variety is ideal. When collecting resources, learners must complete each station learning activity in about the same amount of time, they are ready to move to the next station together. Copy any necessary materials for each station and place them in numbered or labeled folders. Make enough copies of each envelope so that there is one available for each group member to use while they visit each station. Create directions or discussion questions for each station. You may staple these instructions to the station’s folder. Alternatively, you may select a teaching method, such as a 3-2-1 or S-I-T response, that learners complete in their journals during each station. Decide what type of groups you will create for the stations, or whether learners will be able to select their groups. Prepare your classroom, so there are table groups for every station.
  2. Prepare Learners: Tell learners that they will be working with a group to move through a series of stations where they will learn about a specific topic. Explain to learners the instructions for each station and how much time they have to complete the work at each station.
  3. Learners Move through Stations: Assign each group to begin at a different station and ask the groups to move to their first stations. As learners work, circulate to listen in on their conversations or work with struggling groups if they need help comprehending the content or instructions. Tell groups to move to the next station after the allotted amount of time has passed until all of the groups have visited every station.
  4. Debrief the Stations Learning activity: Debrief the learning activity as a class if you have time. Below you will find some sample questions that you can use during your debrief:
    • Did you draw any conclusions about the subject from the sources you inspected?
    • Where you able to substantiate any of the information?
    • What conflicts did you notice among resources?
    • At what station did you learn the most, and which was the most challenging? Which did you like the most, and which did you like the least?
    • Do you have any questions about any of the stations?

How to Implement the Stick Figure Quotes Teaching Strategy in Your Classroom

Description

The stick figure quotes method provides a creative outlet for learners while engaging them in an intellectually rigorous learning activity of character analysis. Learners collect and use evidence from the content and sort passages or quotations from the content based on the level of importance. This process of character analysis also promotes better comprehension and empathy as learners identify how a character thinks and what is important to them. While this method is often used with literary characters, you could also have learners create stick figures for a historical figure, using the figure’s own words as the quotes.

Implementation

  1. Learners Collect Quotes: Ask learners to identify brief passages or quotations in the content by or about a specific character. You can have learners select a style, or you may assign them one. Tell learners that the quotes they want can include descriptions, dialogue, observations from other characters, etc.
  2. Learners Sort Quotes: Tell learners to sort the quotes or passages they have collected by considering these factors: Which do you think is an essential character’s identity or spokesperson of their core values? Describe how the character impacts the world around them.
  3. Learners Create Stick Figures: Tell learners that they will use the quotes they’ve found to create a stick figure representation of their character.

Modifications

  1. Evolving Stick Figures: You may want to make stick figures at different points in the content to illustrate how a character changes. Ask learners: Do this person’s core values change along the way, or do other aspects of their identity change?
  2. Create a Record: Take a digital photo of each stick figure and record the learner explaining why quotes are placed where they are.

 

How to Implement the Storyboard Teaching Strategy in Your Classroom

Description

The storyboard teaching method helps learners keep track of a narrative’s main ideas and supporting details by having them illustrate the story’s essential scenes. Storyboarding can be used when content is read aloud or when learners read independently. Checking the attention to detail that a learner puts into creating their storyboards is an effective way for you to assess reading comprehension before moving to more analytic tasks.

Implementation

  1. Provide a Storyboard Template: Share with learners the storyboard template in the handout section below or design your own. The model must have several blocks that are big enough for learners to draw pictures with space for captions below.
  2. Learners Draw Main Ideas: Ask learners to draw the main ideas of a story. Learners could do this after hearing a story aloud or while reading a story to themselves. Each drawing must have a short caption explaining what is happening in the picture. You could also have learners utilize applicable quotations from the story as captions.
  3. Learners Share Storyboards: You can ask learners to compare storyboards with a partner or a small group. How are their storyboards similar? How are they different? This discussion can help learners clarify basic ideas in the content and help them analyze which ideas are most important.

How to Implement the Shadow Reading Teaching Strategy in Your Classroom

Description

The shadow reading method provides a formatted way to expose learners to various perspectives on a complex topic, often through first-person accounts from individuals who experienced a particular event or era. It also provides a chance for learners to practice analyzing the concept of point of view.

Implementation

  1. Read All Texts: Each learner reads all of the content included in this learning activity. Often instructors will use only two texts to keep the learning activity focused on the two most common opposing viewpoints on a given issue. However, it may also be appropriate to select more than two texts, depending on the content being used. You must provide guiding questions ahead of time to ensure that learners focus on the parts of each piece of content that provide information about the author or narrator’s perspective on a particular issue.
  2. Compose A Dialogue: Ask learners to imagine a meeting between two authors or narrators with opposing viewpoints. Learners must utilize the texts they examined in the first part of the learning activity to help them compose dialogue for such a conversation. Depending on the content of the texts learners read in the first step, select some of the following questions for learners to answer in the dialogue:
    • How would these two people begin a conversation?
    • What would be the theme of their conversation?
    • What do you believe each person would want the other to know and understand concerning their beliefs and life experiences?
    • How would each person defend their position?
    • What emotions would each person feel, and how would they express them?
    • Is there a common ground that they could discuss?
    • What may they share? What may they want to hide?
  3. Share: Invite pairs to act out their dialogue in front of the class. Next, have learners consider what the conversations have in common. What do they add to the class’s comprehension of the issue or historical period under study?

Modifications

  1. Letter Writing: Instead of creating a dialogue between two people, you can ask learners to adopt one perspective and write a letter to a person with an opposing viewpoint. Once learners have read the texts, ask them to do the following:
  2. Adopt One Perspective: Ask learners to adopt the perspective of the author or narrator from one of the pieces of content. It is best to assign each learner to a specific view rather than allowing learners to select for themselves.
  3. Address an Opposing Perspective: Adopting the perspective assigned to them, learners then address the author of the opposing view, typically by writing a letter in which the learner explains their position on the central issue.
  4. Share: Learners need to hear examples of what people wrote. The easiest way to accomplish this is to have learners read their letters in front of the class. This can lead to worthwhile discussions about perspective and can help call attention to specific ideas or experiences that contributed to the complexity of a particular issue or period. Typically, this step works best when learners hear from alternating perspectives. As learners read, you may want to keep a running list of examples cited on either side of an issue. You may also have learners complete this step in small groups. Using small groups is useful when you are working with more than two pieces of content.
  5. Utilize Another Medium: Rather than having learners analyze a piece of content, you may also have them view or listen to another source that conveys a particular perspective.

How to Implement the Socratic Seminar Teaching Strategy in Your Classroom

Description

In a Socratic seminar learning activity, learners help one another understand the ideas, issues, and values reflected in a piece of content through a group discussion format. Learners are responsible for facilitating their group discussion around the ideas in the content; they must not utilize the forum to assert their opinions or prove an argument. Through this type of a debate, learners practice how to listen to one another, make meaning, and find common ground while partaking in a conversation.

Implementation

  1. Select an Appropriate Text: The Socratic seminar method is based on close textual analysis, so it is essential to select content that provides ample avenues for interpretation and discussion. If you choose simple content where the meaning is relatively straightforward, there won’t be much for learners to discuss. Also, the content must not be too lengthy to read carefully in the allotted amount of time. Often, instructors select content ranging from one paragraph to one page. Examples of content commonly utilized as the basis of Socratic seminar activities include the preamble to the US Constitution, Dr. Martin Luther King’s “Letter from a Birmingham Jail,” and the reading “No Time to Think” from our resource Holocaust and Human Behavior.
  2. Give Learners Time to Prepare: Before beginning the seminar, learners must have time to prepare ideas. Learners must annotate the content before the start of the class discussion. Instructors often assign a discussion leader who generates a few open-ended questions that can be used to begin the session.
  3. Develop a Classroom Contract: Each seminar has regulations that might not apply to other kinds of discussion, so before beginning the seminar, everyone must be aware of the norms. Below are standard rules utilized to format a Socratic seminar learning activity. You can modify these to fit the needs of your learners. 
    • Talk to each other.
    • Refer to evidence from the content to support your thoughts.
    • Ask questions if you do not comprehend what someone has said, or you can summarize what another learner has said for clarification.
    • You do not have to raise your hand for permission to speak.
    • Don’t interrupt.
    • Don’t “put down” the thoughts of another learner. Without judging the learner, you disagree with, state your alternate interpretation, or ask a follow-up question to help probe or clarify a concept.

Common statements or questions used during a Socratic seminar learning activity are:

    • Where does that concept come from in the content?
    • What does this word mean?
    • Can you find some other way to say it?
    • What do you think the speaker is attempting to say?
    • What else could that mean?
    • Who was the audience for this content? How does that shape our translation of these words?
    • Who was the author of this content? What do we know about them? How does that shape our comprehension of these words and phrases?

Prior to the seminar, it is also important to remind learners that the goal of the seminar is not to debate or prove a point but to more deeply understand what the author was trying to express in the content.

During the Socratic seminar learning activity with your students, you can take some time to brainstorm the attributes that would make for a great seminar. These attributes or criteria can be explained on a rubric and utilized to assess the seminar at the end of the class period. Criteria that you may use to assess a Socratic seminar learning activity include engagement, respect, meaning-making, and use of evidence.

  1. The Socratic Seminar: A Socratic seminar learning activity often begins with the discussion leader, a learner, or the instructor, asking an open-ended question. A traditional initial prompt is: What do you think this content means? Silence is fine. It may take a few minutes for learners to warm up. Sometimes, instructors organize a Socratic seminar learning activity like a fishbowl learning activity, with some learners participating in the discussion and the rest of the class having specific jobs as observers. At least 15 minutes must be allotted to the learning activity, and it can often last 30 minutes or more. As learners become more familiar with the Socratic seminar format, they will be able to discuss the content for more extended periods without instructor intervention.
  2. Reflect and Assess: After the Socratic seminar learning activity, give learners the opportunity to assess the process in general and their performance explicitly. Reflecting on the seminar process helps learners improve their capability to participate in future discussions. Here are some questions you may discuss or have learners write about when reflecting on the learning activity:
    • Did the seminar stick to the dialogue? Did it ever “go off script,” and if so, how did you handle it.
    • Were people actively listening to other people’s ideas? What evidence do you have to support this?
    • How has your comprehension of this content been changed by the concepts examined in this seminar?
    • What parts of the discussion did you find most and least interesting?
    • As a participant, what will you do differently the next time you are in a seminar?

How to Implement the SPAR (Spontaneous Argumentation) Teaching Strategy in Your Classroom

Description

In this format debate modeled after an event in forensic competitions, learners frame their argument in one minute and then react quickly to their opponents’ ideas. This method helps learners practice utilizing evidence and examples to defend a position. Because learners aren’t given much preparation time, SPAR is most effective when learners already have background information about the topic. With practice, learners become increasingly comfortable with and proficient in utilizing this tactic to unearth the pro and con sides of controversial issues.

Implementation

  1. Prepare the Class: Separate the class in half. Change one side to assume the proposition and the other side to take the con position. Have learners move their desks, so they are sitting opposite an opponent. Write a debatable proposition on the board. The proposition must relate to the material you have been studying, and learners must already have some background information on the issue.
  2. Learners Brainstorm Arguments: Give learners one to two minutes to write down their arguments and evidence for or against the proposition. You can give the learners a graphic organizer to help them format their ideas and take notes during the debate.
  3. Learners Present Opening Statements: The “pro” learners present a one-minute opening statement making their case, while the “con” learners listen quietly and take notes. Then the “con” learners give a one-minute opening statement while the “pro” learners listen quietly and take notes.
  4. Learners Discuss: Give learners 30 seconds to create ideas and concepts that they will say to their opponents. Next, invite the pairs to engage in a three-minute conversation during which they must question their opponent’s critical thinking or submit new ideas of their own.
  5. Learners Present Closing Statements: Give learners 30 seconds or one minute to prepare a closing statement. “Con” learners present a closing statement for one minute while the “pro” learners listen quietly, and then the roles reverse.
  6. Debrief the Learning activity: Prompts you can use to format a class discussion about this learning activity include:
    • What did you learn by being in this SPAR debate?
    • What were the arguments for both sides of the issue?
    • What is the importance of debating positions that may be contrary to how you feel?
    • What was the toughest about participating in this kind of debate? What did you like about it?

Before facilitating a class discussion about any of these questions, allow learners to respond in their journals.

Modifications

  1. Research SPAR: SPAR could be adapted to include time for learners to gather more evidence to support their positions. Research can be as informal as giving learners time to look through their notes (possibly as a homework assignment the night before) or can be as extensive as a formal research project.
  2. Jigsaw SPAR: Learners can first meet as “expert” pro and con groups to create ideas together before starting the debate.
  3. Fishbowl SPAR: Half the class participates in the debate while the rest observes. Then the positions switch. In this adaption, all of the learners can debate the same issue or problem, or they can discuss different plans in each round. The observers can make a note of the most credible arguments on either side.

How to Implement the S-I-T: Surprising, Interesting, Troubling Teaching Strategy in Your Classroom

Description

A learning activity based on the S-I-T method provides a quick and straightforward way for learners to demonstrate their engagement with a piece of content, image, or video. In this learning activity, learners identify what they find surprising, exciting, and troubling about the material. Because the learning activity allows learners to process and articulate a short response, it’s especially useful when learners are encountering content they find shocking or an outcome that is counterintuitive. Having learners complete a S-I-T learning activity can be an effective way to help them prepare for a class discussion in which you want everyone to have something to contribute. It can also be a useful prompt for an exit card at the end of a learning activity about an emotionally challenging historical topic.

Implementation

  1. Select a piece of content, image, or video that you expect learners will find engaging and will want or need to discuss after reading or watching.
  2. After reading, observing, or watching this stimulus, ask each learner to identify the following:
    • One surprising fact or idea
    • One interesting fact or idea
    • One troubling fact or idea
  3. Allow learners to share and debrief their S-I-T responses, either in pairs or as a class discussion. Or collect their answers and read them to find out how learners are feeling about and comprehending the material presented in class.