Uncategorized

Educators: Do You Know About Using Effective District Leadership as an Education Reform Strategy?

Highly functional systems are the product of highly functional leadership. For most schools, leadership comes in the form of district command.

However, until recently, there was very little evidence regarding effective leadership and how it functions at the school, district, and state levels. Now evidences indicates that leadership in education is vital to reform efforts. Leadership is a bridge that crosses the divide, enabling teachers to approach reform from the front line of learning. While teachers are naturally vital for education, school principals and district superintendents are advantaged by being able to construct the vision and expectations needed to deliver better teaching and learning experiences. They have the position and capability to enable everyone involved in the education system to realize that vision.

To get the leaders we want and need in every school, it’s not enough to improve their training, as urgent as that is. State and district officials also need to provide the conditions for and set out the expectations of what leaders need to know, and the actions they need to take to improve both teaching and learning. These standards should form the basis for holding leaders accountable for results. On the other hand, leaders should have the data available to inform their decisions and the authority needed to direct resources to schools and students with the greatest needs. All districts should establish policies that not only affect the recruitment, hiring, and placement of school leaders but also are explicit for evaluating leaders.

Each of these core elements for better educational leadership is crucial. And it is equally important that states and districts work together more closely to create more supportive leadership standards, training, and work conditions—to create a cohesive leadership system. Rather than engaging in isolated or uncoordinated efforts on single elements of leadership improvement, collective action by states and districts is the most likely pathway to lasting change throughout the system. Such collaboration has not been the historic norm in education policy.

Efforts at state–district policy coordination remain relatively new and are yielding both early successes and cautionary lessons about the challenges of maintaining the momentum of positive change. Look around ask yourself – is your district effectively leading your school into an era of educational progress?

Are You Strategically Allocating Resources to Support Teaching and Learning?

The purposeful and practical allocation of resources to support equitable access to high-quality learning opportunities is a major component of education policy at the federal, state, and local levels. Leaders at all levels of the education are charged with making decisions about how to effectively distribute and leverage resources to support teaching and learning. Resource allocation consists of more than assigning dollar amounts to particular schools or programs. Equally important is the examination of the ways in which those dollars are translated into actions that address expressed educational goals at various educational levels. In this respect, leaders are concerned not only with the level of resources and how they are distributed across districts, schools, and classrooms, but also with how these investments translate into improved learning.

It’s critical for resource allocation practices to reflect an understanding of the imperative to eliminate existing inequities and close the achievement gap. All too often, children who are most in need of support and assistance attend schools that have higher staff turnover, less challenging curricula, less access to appropriate materials and technology, and poorer facilities.

Below, we give a quick breakdown to serve as a handy guide in thinking about what school districts can look like and what their spread of resources looks like:

1. Rural Districts

Size: smaller

Cultural Diversity of Students: Low in diversity, but diversity growing.

Socioeconomic Status (SES) of Parents: Poverty an issue in many areas.

District Resources: Resources limited. Districts smaller, less complex; innovation and change easier to accomplish.

2. Suburban

Size: Intermediate

Cultural Diversity of Students: Intermediate in diversity; many minority professionals.

Socioeconomic Status (SES) of Parents: Generally high SES, but can vary.

District Resources: Resources generally good due to high tax base.

3. Urban

Size: Largest

Cultural Diversity of Students: High in diversity, both in terms of numbers and types of diversity.

Socioeconomic Status (SES) of Parents: Poverty is a major issue for many students, but this can vary from school to school.

District Resources: Large bureaucracy and resources vary from school to school.

What kind of district do you work in? Understanding the makeup of the area in which you teach will help you better understand what resources you have (or don’t have) at your disposal and the backgrounds of the pupils you’ll be serving.

Three Influential Historical Education Reforms

The current education system in the United States is the product of many historical reforms. Despite changes in the purpose of schooling and the nature of students over time, the effects of these reforms have persisted. Reforms that continue to influence today’s education system have come from:

1. 20th Century Education Reforms

The reforms of one historical period often stimulate the need for reforms in another. Just as the National Education Association (NEA) commissioned the Committee of Ten in the late 1800s to make recommendations to improve high schools, they established a separate committee in 1915 to address outstanding issues. While the Committee of Ten focused on high school as a place to prepare students for college, the Commission of the Reorganization of Secondary Education had a wider view of the requirements of an education system. They wished to ensure that even students who were not college bound would become part of the national workforce. The vision of providing comprehensive education for society at large through providing an adequate high school education began to take shape.

Rather than a committee of college presidents and professors, the commission included a wide cross-section of individuals, including high school principals, professors, and the U.S. Commissioner of Education. The commission members brought more to the table than simply their educational expertise; they also drew on their personal experiences in the real world, experiences that were not predominantly academic. The commission’s report, Seven Cardinal Principles of Secondary Education, was presented in 1918 and heavily influenced the progressive movement. While the commission’s recommendations for high school included an academic component, the commission also recommended that high schools address more diverse aspects pertaining to the life of a postsecondary education individual: health, home ownership, vocation, citizenship, use of leisure time, and ethical character.

Recommendations to reform and improve the high school also surfaced in the 1930s, 1940s, and 1950s. In the 1930s, the Progressive Education Association (PEA) recommended that high schools should incorporate specific aspects into the curriculum that would develop social qualities and personal development. Recommendations in the 1940s and 1950s resulted in further changes to high schools: increasing the number of electives, introducing guidance counselors into the school system, and broadening vocational education programs.

Public high schools have been influenced by different points of view regarding the purpose and goals at the secondary level of education. Reform of public education is grounded in a set of beliefs held by stakeholders, who can also be referred to as decision makers or policy makers, who can advance change. Successive reform has resulted in a combination of both prior perspectives evident in high schools today: High schools can accommodate college-bound students, while at the same time accommodating non-college-bound students, and include curricula that facilitate personal development of the student.
2. The Main Phases of Education Reform in the 1980s and 1990s

Education reform of the 1980s and 1990s can be viewed as three distinct phases of education reform. Each phase represents a different conception of schools and schooling, as well as different proposals for education reform. The first phase of reforms centered on recommendations designed to maintain America’s strong defense capabilities and competitive position in the international economic marketplace. As a result, students needed a more rigorous education and also needed to acquire abilities and skills that would allow them to interact with industries’ increasing reliance on advances in technology.

Another phase of education reform focused on teacher practice rather than solely on the need to maintain economic and technical competitiveness. This phase is best represented by teachers’ reactions to the standards-based education discussed earlier. Teachers felt powerless to use their creativity, teaching skills, and abilities they believed to be at the center of being a teaching professional. Many teachers felt that teacher practice was being dictated to them, because they were required to address the content embedded in specific standards-based content that would later appear on standardized state tests. But standards-based instruction became an integral component of teacher practice, as well as a central component of pre-service teacher education.

A subsequent phase of education reform occurred at the end of the 1980s and the beginning of the 1990s. This reform was unlike the other two phases and was founded on the principle that not all students could afford a first-rate education. Instead of the school system being just about education, reform was based on the provision of a range of services, including health, counseling, and even parent instruction. Instead of school policy, the focus turned to children’s policy. The resulting school models were referred to as full-service schools.

3. The Holmes Group Teacher Training

The Holmes Group consisted of a consortium of 96 higher education research institutions that offered teacher education programs. The institutions were concerned about reform not only of schools but also of teacher education and the teaching profession. The group was initially concerned that some of the most highly regarded universities in the nation had eliminated their teacher education programs, indicating an apparent low regard for teacher education, favoring the more prestigious professional preparation programs. The Holmes Group believed that prominent institutions needed to be intimately involved in the preparation of the nation’s teachers. In 1986, the group published a report titled Tomorrow’s Teachers, which declared that quality teachers provided the best hope for the success of school reform. The report included suggestions for changes that would strengthen the preparation of teachers. Among the areas addressed were the need to improve the intellectual soundness of teacher preparation programs, the need to develop standards for entry into the teaching profession, and the need to create induction and internship programs for beginning teachers. Many of the goals and principles proposed by this group continue to be a part of the teacher preparation process today.

History has seen several major blocks of change in education. However, in order to remain a competitive system, education will need several periods more of progression and pushing forward. As an educator, you have a chance to influence future trends and become a part of America’s much-needed academic revolution.

Three Alternative Educational Systems Produced by Reform Discontent

Despite efforts to reform public education by addressing a number of problematic areas in the system, many with an interest in education have been frustrated with the direction reforms have taken and the time it has taken to make any progress. As a result, proposals for alternative school models have been proposed, and many have been initiated. Disillusionment with the school system and its lack of flexibility can be traced to the 1950s. Milton Friedman, a renowned economist, maintained that schools would work much better if they operated in a free market environment. Friedman believed requiring students to attend the nearest local school was problematic. In this environment, there was no competition among schools and therefore no motivation for one school to do any better than the next school. The only alternative was private school, which many students could not afford. Friedman advocated that school choice should not be limited only to those who could afford it.

The push for greater school choice surfaced again in the 1970s. If schools were going to be desegregated, as required by law, students would need to choose schools outside their local areas. A number of school models emerged in the 1970s that offered families choice beyond the traditional neighborhood school attendance.

Since then, a number of school models have cropped up from discontent around stagnated reform. Three of the biggest alternative systems are:

1. Magnet Schools

Magnet schools were established to attract students to attend a school other than their assigned neighborhood school. Not only did these schools offer a distinctive curriculum; many also offered a first-rate education based on innovative approaches to teaching. Given these educational opportunities, many parents were persuaded to choose magnet schools for their children. There are thousands of magnet schools across the United States. They tend to be more expensive than their traditional public school counterparts to run; however, research indicates they also tend to be more effective. Magnet schools have attracted over 2 million students since their inception. They’ve had a positive influence on desegregation in some school districts, which was an additional goal for the initiation of magnet schools. But in places with deep racial segregation, they haven’t helped with desegregation.

2. Open Enrollment

Another school model that promotes the concept of school choice is open enrollment, enabling students to attend any public school that has vacancies. Minnesota was the first state to introduce the concept of open enrollment in 1988 and was closely followed by a number of additional states. Today, the majority of American states have legislation allowing open enrollment. If school choice is allowed to proceed along its current trajectory, the neighborhood school could very well become a model of the past, or at least be radically altered.

3. Charter Schools

Charter schools operate based on a contract between a school district and the party planning to operate the institution. The contract is in effect for a certain time. If the school performs well, the contract is renewed. Charter schools tend to have some flexibility when it comes to state regulations; hey may not have to follow all regulations required of traditional schools in the state. Most states have student performance expectations that charter schools are required to meet to maintain the charter. Charter schools share other characteristics: they don’t require assessment to gain admission, they are nonsectarian, financial support is in line with student quantity, and existing public schools can adapt to become charter schools.

In 1991, Minnesota became the first state to establish legislation that supported charter schools. While most states have legislation to guide the establishment of charter schools, no charter school legislation exists in Alabama, Kentucky, Maine, Mississippi, Montana, Nebraska, North and South Dakota, Vermont, Washington, and West Virginia. Even among states that have charter school laws, the number of charters available among the states differs. Other restrictions in terms of the types of charter schools may also exist. For example, some states will not extend charters to virtual charter schools. Still, charter schools currently represent one of the most popular school choice models, with over 4,000 schools nation-wide. Charter schools are the most viable rival to the public school model today.

Charter school models differ from traditional schools within the district, although in many states the district has authority over the charter school. Because charter school initiatives haven’t occurred in all states, it’s difficult to generalize or standardize the entire charter school movement. So charter schools must be discussed in the context of a state and local school district. And although some states introduced strong charter legislation, facilitating more autonomy, legislation in other states was weaker and resulted in less autonomy. “Strong” charter legislation refers to significant levels of charter school self-governance, subject only to appraisals and legalities. “Weak” charter legislation describes situations where school boards have significant control throughout the chartering process.

There are also funding implications with regard to a school’s being under strong or weak charter legislation. Charter schools in states with strong charter legislation receive state money, regardless of the group wishing to establish a charter school (e.g., parents, community organization, or a religious group). In contrast, a school established under weak charter legislation must be approved by a local school district, which may not be motivated to support a school that differs drastically from traditional schools in the district.

Four Diverse Educational Models Born from Reform Discontent

While many alternative schools have sprouted from discontent around efforts to reform public schools, some of these new schools feature entirely new models. Why keep trying the same failing pathway? Or so goes the rationale of four of the most pioneering of new schooling forms:

1. Virtual Schools

Instruction is delivered in virtual schools without the need for a physical space or infrastructure, because learning takes place primarily via technology. Virtual schools also offer everything available to students in physical schools, such as rules that must be followed, a teaching staff, organized field trips, and parent–teacher conferences. Although they didn’t surface until the 1990s, the popularity of virtual schools is evidenced by the fact that half of all states in America now offer some type of online learning program. Almost three quarters of a million students incorporate online learning into their education. In fact, due to the need of the current generation to possess online literacy, Michigan recently made it compulsory for students to include online learning as part of their education.

One of the most significant characteristics of virtual schools is their ability to offer specialized programs not offered at conventional high schools. Another unique feature of virtual schools is the 24/7 accessibility, a quality that has proven very attractive to students. There are no set times for class. Virtual classrooms not only tailor classes to students’ individual learning interests by offering specialized courses; they also make it easier for students from anywhere in the world to take part in offered classes and programs.

The initial rationale behind establishing virtual high schools was to supplement conventional high school programs. But the convenience and unique qualities possible with virtual learning formats resulted in the development of fully functioning high schools. From a personnel perspective, the virtual school is a solution to teacher shortages. Perhaps the greatest benefit of the virtual high school model is that it has opened up new possibilities for certain student groups, such as those with disabilities, those who are homeschooled, and even students who attend schools that lack the funding to provide specialized courses.

The virtual high school model has not been without its skeptics. Opponents suggest the virtual model alienates students. They maintain that schools teach social skills as well as academics and that social skills cannot be taught online.

2. The For-Profit Model

The for-profit model exists as a result of discontent by parents and other education stakeholders with the seemingly inability of traditional schools to address achievement and other educational needs of students. The model is based on the notion that a different approach to management of schools would lead to better educational outcomes. Education management organizations (EMOs) are for-profit companies that manage schools from a corporate model. They’re guided by the belief that they must deliver the “product” (i.e., student achievement) to clients (i.e., parents, students, and school boards) to stay in business. And because EMOs receive the same per-pupil funding from states as traditional schools, they must be able to use those funds more efficiently to make a profit. Some schools have been unable to raise achievement levels; EMOs believe they must do so in order to remain viable. EMOs primarily manage charter schools, but they also collaborate with school districts to manage traditional schools.

Edison Schools, Inc., is currently the largest EMO in the nation. EMOs like Edison contend that competition brought about by privatization of schooling would serve as motivation for improved schools that would subsequently lead to improved achievement among students. Given the choice, parents would send students to successful schools, causing organizations unable to run successful schools to go out of business. That’s not the case with government-run schools, EMOs would suggest, because some state- or district-run schools are allowed to operate year after year without improving student achievement.

Edison Schools manages 150 schools with 85,000 students across the United States. Their schools rely heavily on technology, and they often supply both teachers and students with computers. Edison Schools also have longer school days than traditional schools, with students normally attending schools for 8 hours a day. Teachers have more preparation time than is normally granted in regular public school settings. Researchers at Columbia University found that teachers at Edison Schools possessed higher morale than teachers in public schools and were passionate about teaching in Edison-run schools. But EMOs like Edison Schools are not without critics. Some education advocates believe that if schools were privatized, companies might focus more on profit than on the education and well-being of students.

3. Homeschooling

Discontent with traditional schools is also the impetus for the popularity of homeschooling. This is an educational model on the increase, with approximately 1.5 million students being homeschooled across the United States in 2007. That’s an incredible increase when compared to a population of 13,000 homeschooled students 30 years ago. The advent of the Internet has been one of the leading drivers behind this popularity. Apart from discontent over the perceived lack of effectiveness in traditional schools, parents may choose to homeschool their children for other reasons, including perceptions that traditional schools are unsafe and/or a desire for religion to be a larger part of their children’s education than is possible in public schools.

Generally, research suggests that homeschooling is an effective way to educate children. Student performance tends to exceed that of students in traditional schools. Skeptics of homeschooling refer to the negative consequences of social alienation and other social benefits that only a conventional school can offer, such as mixing with children of different backgrounds. This criticism is unfounded, because homeschooling does not appear to have a negative impact on students’ socialization. Homeschooled students appear to be well prepared to continue education beyond their homeschool learning environment and also appear to be more autonomous.

4. School Vouchers

The voucher program, in which school education vouchers allow parents to use federal funds for private tuition, has been toyed with since the 1950s. Many agree with the use of vouchers in theory, but practical problems make it difficult to implement their use. It’s tricky to come up with an equal system when private schools and public schools may have widely varying costs per pupil. And no one has agreed on the requirements for eligibility for particular categories of students. Currently, students can fall into widely divergent categories, depending on the school system involved. Categories could range from students with autism, to students with disabilities, to students grouped by age, income, or residence.

The use of private vouchers, as it turns out, is less popular than the use of vouchers associated with public systems. In the private voucher systems, monies are typically collected from individual donors, such as religious organizations or corporations. The funds are then awarded through grants to low-income families.

A program very similar to the voucher system involves tax credits. Expenses for schooling are credited through the tax system with reimbursements. The voucher and tax credit programs may appear to be controlled by market forces, but that’s not the case in practice. Issues that arise during the administration of these types of programs include limits on particular students allowed to participate, the entanglement of bureaucracy, and financial limits.

There are pros and cons to alternative schooling, but the new systems at least are trying to solve new problems with innovative approaches. Are you up-to-date on the latest news in alternative schooling? How can you use information on its successes (and failures) to help guide your own teaching?

Understanding The State’s Role in School Reform

School reform is a process that occurs on many levels and involves several layers of responsible parties. While the U.S. government is the largest entity involved in school reform, state government often spearheads local decision-making. The role of states in school reform is in two main areas:

1. First Phase: Results-Centered

In the 1980’s, states’ education reform actions were focused on straightforward policies and practices that could be easily be implemented and measured to determine effectiveness. Policies for teacher qualifications and the introduction of testing models fit into what can be described as “results-centered” initiatives. Nevertheless, problems—perceived or real—resulted from the first phase of reforms. Despite the desire of many groups to move away from homogeneity, the end result was a move toward standardization. Another setback of first-phase reforms was due to the reward system offered for high test scores. One example of this involved a teacher who had given students questions on an upcoming test to learn. Other teachers were instructing students with test questions from past exams or giving students similar tests to complete as student activities. Instead of teaching to educate their students, teachers were providing materials that would enable themselves to achieve highly. This meant that students were deprived of a holistic education, exposed to limited knowledge, and provided simply with means to pass the tests.

Despite these problems, reform efforts continued, and many associated problems were largely ignored by the governors of the states. Education reform was so important that governors during the 1980’s strived for the label of “education governor.” This honor was so highly regarded that, following their tenure as governor, many “education governors” ended up in top-rank political positions. And during the 1980s, states were also taking regulatory power away from the federal government. Although conservatives suggested this shift would help reduce regulatory burden, in time, states were perceived as being just as bad at placing demands and directives on local educational units as the federal government. During this same period, federal funding was also more restricted. States now had more power over how funding would be spent but a lot less funding to disperse.

2. Second Phase: Relieving the Regulatory Burden

The second phase of state school reform involvement took place in the latter part of the 1980s. States’ actions were in response to discontent that had arisen from first-phase involvement in the early to mid-1980s. The states’ main goal was to liberate schools from an overabundance of regulation and control from higher authority. Discontent emerged, however, as this reformed model of school administration was short-lived, lasting only a decade and then losing all support.

The method used to reduce regulatory burden was to increase management at the school level. Administration and organization were now the school’s responsibility. This promoted decentralization, as opposed to the top–down, centralized model. The power to make decisions passed predominantly to those on the ground (e.g., teachers and parents). As a working model, it gathered much support from education professionals and was seen as a model of inclusion where power shifted from bureaucratic decision makers to immediate stakeholders.

This site-based model was still centered on the leadership and direction of the school principal. From a state perspective, decentralization was apparent, but on a working level, the inclusive model was merely a shift of responsibility from one layer of administration to another, without providing adequate personnel support. An additional flaw in the model also surfaced. The personnel support was intended to come from staff working under the principal, even though these individuals already had duties and engagements that were not alleviated to allow them participate effectively in the process. Teachers viewed the model as infringing on time they needed to plan and teach. The end result of this lack of coherent, well-communicated reform was that this reformed model of school management received as much criticism and resistance as the previous model with burdensome regulation. Consequently, the site-based model was discontinued in most districts within a decade.

Educators: Why You Need To Know About The 1990s And School Restructuring

Over the past few decades, reform trends have risen and fallen from prominence. However, one early system has had long-lasting effects that likely still resonate in your classroom today. What was this long-lasting change-up? School restructuring.

The notion of restructuring became popular in the late 1980s and early 1990s, primarily in reaction to the failure of previous attempts to improve existing education structures through reform. The goal of restructuring was to change the organizational structure of schools in ways that supported student learning. Three main areas were the focus of restructuring school reform efforts during this period.

First, teachers were to have a larger role in school management functions and also to have greater autonomy and flexibility in choosing instructional methods and materials. With more input into school management, teachers would also have a forum in which to contribute to using the learning environment, school resources, and time at school to improve student learning. Second, student learning and achievement was another area of focus for restructuring efforts. With changes in teacher roles and responsibilities in the learning environment, proponents of restructuring believed students would have increased opportunities to learn and could learn at higher, more rigorous levels. Third, restructuring was to make schools more inviting places that would be more aware of and responsive to the needs of students and their families.

A number of reforms were implemented during the 1990s that were consistent with the notion of restructuring. Stricter requirements for graduation were implemented, which included increases in the number of high school credits as well as changes in course requirements. For example, all students were required to complete courses in math and science, even though levels of difficulty in courses existed. There was general agreement that longer days with more quality instruction were needed to improve student achievement, and a number of schools pursued reforms focused on increasing the amount of time available for students to focus on learning.

Standards-based education also emerged during this period. Based on the requirements of postsecondary education, which were established at the time, specific standards were set regarding what academic and practical knowledge students were required to gain during their time at various stages of school. These requirements have changed since standards-based education was introduced, and accordingly, the test content requires continuous review and updating. Students are tested based on these standards using standardized measures. Student and school performance is used as an indicator of the success or effectiveness of that school, the staff, and the state.

Higher expectations of teachers were also an outgrowth of the reforms of the 1980s and 1990s. It is important for states to ensure teacher competency by determining the knowledge and skill levels of new teachers as they enter the profession. Requiring new teachers to pass tests at the end of training or before receiving a teaching license is one method currently used to evaluate and ensure teacher knowledge. The testing of teachers is surrounded by debates relating to how and what material to test teachers on, as well as whether or not standards are high enough to render teaching licensure meaningful.

The meaning and purpose of restructuring changed in the 2000s, as No Child Left Behind (NCLB) came into being in 2001. Restructuring now refers to an action taken by states for schools consistently unable to meet annual achievement targets as required by NCLB. In this instance, schools are required to develop restructuring plans designed to improve student achievement. Reorganization of the governance structure is required, with options available to the schools such as adopting a charter and becoming a charter school; replacing some or all school staff, including the principal; or contracting with an outside entity (e.g., EMO) to operate the school.

States are required to sanction poorly performing schools under NCLB regulations, although some also feel it prudent and motivating to reward high-performing schools. These actions are likely based on the fact that recognition and reward have been shown to lead to improved performance among teachers, which is more positive and may have more of an effect than extending sanctions. Other states, however, sanction poorly performing schools, even when they are not required to do so under NCLB. In many ways, rewarding schools and providing assistance to poorly performing schools is more in keeping with the teacher empowerment goals of the school restructuring efforts implemented in the 1990s.

Restructuring was an idea that shook up the American school system – and not in an entirely good way. As an educator, you need to be aware of what it was and what it did so that you can deal with any residue still dusting the classrooms of your school district.

What Teachers Need to Know About Student Privacy

There is often conflict between students’ right to privacy and a school districts’ responsibility to keep their students safe. However, most districts now have a set of rules from local, state, and national authorities governing the resolution of that tension.

Personal histories and records exist for every student and teacher at a school. This history, in the form of school records, test scores, and the opinions of teachers and mentors, can have a huge impact on students’ futures. On the basis of these assessments about students’ potential and overall disposition, life-changing decisions are made. Students’ history could determine what colleges they are admitted to, the privileges that they are allowed, or even the jobs they may eventually be able to attain.

Consequently, the proper exchange of this information is very important; the information must be exchanged through transparent and impartial means. This is even more relevant considering the fact that the kind of information that exists in school records may not be completely true and bears the risk of being misinterpreted if it falls into the wrong hands. This was realized in the 1970s, when instances of parents and students being denied access to their school records became public.

The immediate response to this problem was the passing of the Family Educational Rights and Privacy Act (FERPA, or the Buckley Amendment, as it is popularly known) by the U.S. Congress in 1974. The act makes clear who may have access to a student’s records and who may not. The move was largely beneficial for parents who were previously denied access to records that were very likely to affect their children’s lives. The act made it mandatory for schools to share all information about students with their parents, when requested. It also required schools to explain or interpret the recorded observations to parents, with the failure to do so resulting in federal funds being denied to the school. At the same time, the act serves in the best interests of teachers. It clearly denies parents the right to inspect a teacher’s or an administrator’s unofficial records.

The Buckley amendment applies to all schools that receive federal money. The act has been a promising step in ensuring transparency in dealing with and handling student’s records. Aspects of the act, such as the confidentiality granted to both parties, make it stand out as a reformative measure in ensuring the right to privacy for individuals wanting to be educated.

Here is how FERPA empowers parents and guardians and puts them in a better position than they were previously:

  • Parents and guardians can inspect their child’s school records.
  • The act ensures that information about students under 18 years of age can’t be passed on without parental consent.
  • Parents have the right to challenge the accuracy of information at any point in time and to request a hearing to contest such information.
  • A legal route to correct children’s school records and to place a statement of disagreement in student records is now open to parents.
  • Parents can singlehandedly decide who can access the information about their child.
  • In cases where parents find any discrepancies, they can always file a complaint with the U.S. Department of Education to seek relief in the civil courts.

Student Privacy and Drug Testing

In 2002, the U.S. Supreme Court, in the case of the
Board of Education of Independent School District No. 92 of Pottawatomie County et al. v.
Earls et al., examined the validity of the 1998 Student Activities Drug Testing Policy of
the Tecumseh, Oklahoma, school district. This policy asked students to undergo mandatory urine analysis for illegal drugs like cocaine, marijuana, and opiates before participating in competitive activities in school such as choir, athletics, cheerleading, and other extracurricular activities. Offended by this policy, and considering it to be a violation of their privacy, two students named Lindsay Earls and Daniel James of Tecumseh High School took the school authorities to court. Their point was that, in view of the students’ Fourth Amendment rights to protection from “unreasonable searches” and the requirement of “probable cause,” their being subjected to such examinations was a violation of their lawful rights. The premise put forth was that there existed no “probable cause” of drug usage by students participating in extracurricular activities, and consequently the urine analysis that was being imposed on them was an “unreasonable search.”

With respect to “unreasonable search,” the right to privacy of the individual concerned is of key concern for the courts. The court ruled that because students in public schools are in “temporary custody of the state,” their right to privacy is limited in this case. The court also ruled that, in this case, urine analysis is acceptable because the manner in which the school district collected the urine sample was not an invasion of privacy. As for the issue of drug testing and the presence of a “probable cause,” the court’s stance is clear. Several court cases have ruled that a warrant and the presence of a “probable cause” is not required for students in public schools, because that requirement would complicate the matter and interfere with disciplinary procedures. This means that school authorities can search any student who participates in extracurricular activities, without need for a concrete “probable cause.” The only requirement is that the search be carried out in a reasonable manner.

In Board of Education of Independent School District No. 92 of Pottawatomie County et al. v. Earls et al., the court ruled that any public school district can formulate a student drug-testing policy for itself, and that this would not in any way interfere with the Fourth Amendment rights of students. The Office of National Drug Control Policy even went so far as to issue a booklet to local school districts propagating drug testing for students. This has proven to be a great drug-taking deterrent for students in schools. Still, many groups, such as the National Education Association and the American Academy of Pediatrics, were not satisfied with the court’s verdict, as they were concerned about privacy issues and that students could find such testing invasive. Despite this, most school districts have adopted the Tecumseh School District’s stated policies in an effort to stay out of legal troubles.

While students may feel that their school or teacher is just trying to impose rules for no reason, educators know that their boundaries are set for the students’ benefit. As an educator, you must make sure you understand your school’s policies surrounding student privacy and know how to implement those policies in the kindest, most professional way possible.

Three Important Landmarks of Sexuality and Student Rights

How the legal system has dealt with student sexuality has rapidly changed over the years. While the goal at the heart of the rules and regulations around students and their sexual behavior has always been to protect students and keep their learning the central focus of school, how the legal system has gone about doing so has progressed and improved over the years. Three major areas that have seen recent growth include:

1. Pregnant students’ educational access.

In the past, pregnant students were not allowed to attend regular public schools after their pregnancy became obvious. They were denied access to educational institutions because they were believed to be a morally corrupting influence on their peers. In view of the fact that segregation of pregnant girls from their peers hampered their education and constituted a violation of their “right to education,” the law has taken steps to prevent this discrimination. All school rules that prevent pregnant students from attending school, or promote discrimination against them at one level or another, have been quashed by several courts. The judgments passed in several court cases reveal the law’s stand on the issue. 
In McLeod v. State ex. Rel. Comer, the court ruled that unless students are found to be guilty of immorality, misconduct, or bearing negative impact on other students, they can’t legally be banned from attending school. Several other cases later affirmed the rights of pregnant or married students to attend public schools. The accepted rules and guidelines for pregnant students, married students, or students with children follow:

  • All courts have unanimously invalidated rules that prohibited married or pregnant students from attending educational institutions.
  • It’s mandatory for schools and colleges to ensure that married or pregnant students have the same rights as other students in school and that no discrimination is practiced against them at any level.
  • The right to decision-making on whether or not and when exactly a pregnant student should withdraw from school rests entirely with the student’s physician.
  • The law mandates that schools provide homebound instruction for students who withdraw from school due to pregnancy.
  • The only conditions under which a school can deny married or pregnant students participation in school activities and events are when their behavior or presence is established to have a disruptive, interfering, or negative influence on the other students.

2. Gay, lesbian, bisexual, and transgender students.

Recently, the law has come down more strongly in favor of the rights of lesbian, gay, bisexual, and transgender (LGBT) students. For example, a 2012 case in which a school computer system filtered out all search results that might include supportive information on LGBT (though it allowed anti-LGBT results) was decided in favor of the students. The school was forced to remove the discriminatory filter. 
In a case in 2011 that received national, a graduating student, Ceara Sturgis, decided to wear a tuxedo instead of the traditional “drape” for her yearbook photograph. The school then omitted her photograph entirely from the publication. In November 2011, the school caved, settling the case and revising its policies to be more in line with the equal protection clause of the U.S. Constitution.

3. Sexual harassment and discrimination.

The U.S. Supreme Court made it clear as early as 1992 that students who were sexually harassed by school personnel could sue for monetary damages. In Franklin v. Gwinnett, a Georgia high school student alleged that a teacher had sexually harassed her. The Supreme Court upheld the student’s claims and maintained that the practice of supervisors harassing subordinates is unlawful, and that the student–teacher relationship is no different.

Laws that address sexual harassment of one student by a fellow student are also clear. Teachers or schools cannot be held liable for the actions of one of its students, but in some circumstances, schools can still be sued for sexual harassment of one student by another student. A school was held liable in a case where school authorities neglected to inform the harassed student of the right to file a sexual harassment grievance under Title IX of the Education Amendments of 1972, and in a case where the school neglected to eliminate the harassment after it had been reported to the school. Although it’s difficult to hold schools liable for student-to-student harassment, ambiguity persists because of the cases where students have been provided with damages in student-to-student harassment lawsuits.

Make sure you’re familiar with the real-time changes happening to student rights and regulations around sexuality and sexual behavior in school. Educators need to stay up-to-date on the latest ways they can support their students and keep school a safe place for them, no matter what.

Three Hot Topics in the Argument Around Free Speech and Student Rights

The practical interpretation of the First Amendment is a contentious topic across the nation, year after year. In schools, the issue crops up commonly in the form of disputes of what can be read and said. Time and time again, teachers must deal with how the First Amendment dispute affects:

1. Student access to books.

The 1982 case of The Board of Education, Island Trees Union Free School District No. 26 v. Steven A. Pico is an example of a case dealing with student rights to gain access to books. This case involved the suitability of books in a high school library and the school district’s school board’s suggestion that certain books with inappropriate content be removed from the library. This suggestion followed a conference of a politically conservative organization of parents in New York. The case clearly grappled with balancing the right of students to access books in the school library with the school board’s right to decide on which books to introduce and which books to leave out of the library. The final decision favored the school board, and nine books were removed from the library. These books included Best Short Stories of Negro Writers: An Anthology from 1899 to the Present, edited by Langston Hughes; Down These Mean Streets, by Piri Thomas; Go Ask Alice, of anonymous authorship; Soul on Ice, by Eldridge Cleaver; A Reader for Writers: A Critical Anthology of Prose Readings, by Jerome Archer and Joseph Schwartz; Slaughterhouse Five, by Kurt Vonnegut, Jr.; A Hero Ain’t Nothing but a Sandwich, by Alice Childress; The Fixer, by Bernard Malamud; and Naked Ape, by Desmond Morris.

The U.S. Supreme Court fully recognized the role of school authorities in deciding what to teach students and suggested that the matter be kept out of the courts. But the verdict noted that any kind of suppression of ideas advocated by political groups would not be tolerated. One could say that this case fell into this category, because action was taken following the list, which was forwarded by a political organization. This created an air of ambiguity in the matter. The court ultimately decided against the removal of all the books, and only a few very controversial ones were removed. In short, the stand on avoiding the suppression of ideas by any means was adhered to.

2. Student rights to free speech.

Apart from the Fourth Amendment, the most important amendment pertaining to student rights is the First Amendment. The Free Speech Clause prohibits any new law that might curb the students’ freedom of speech. In practice, the issue was illustrated through Tinker v. Des Moines Independent School District. The case involved the sensitive issue of the conflict in Vietnam. Certain students decided to put forth their objections to the war by wearing black armbands. This apparently was not received well by school authorities, and they decided to take the strict action of suspending any student who wore a black armband. The U.S. Supreme Court’s ruling on the matter was groundbreaking, and the school’s stand was criticized outright. At the same time, the court ruled that the right to free speech could be exercised, provided it did not disrupt the educational process in any way. Any protest or activity that interferes with normal school activities, or disrupts the peace of the school, even in the slightest manner, can be curbed lawfully.

This form of censorship was legitimized by law on the basis that it would ultimately be in the student’s favor, because it would help him understand other students’ feelings and have more respect for them. In the 1988 Hazelwood School District v. Kuhlmeier case, for instance, the court ruled that school administrators have every right to control and check the content published in school-sponsored newspapers and magazines. The justification given was that these form a part of the curriculum and everything that could possibly influence students deserves to be scrutinized by school authorities. The case involved a newspaper published by the journalism class at Missouri’s Hazelwood High School. The articles published discussed issues such as divorce and pregnancy, content school authorities determined was inappropriate for high school students. Authorities also feared that the fictitious names used in the articles were not sufficient to guard the privacy of the students whose opinions were published. The court concurred.

While students are, without a doubt, endowed with freedom of speech by the First Amendment, this does not mean that they can behave in any manner they please. It’s very much within the jurisdiction of the school authorities to prevent or prohibit students from indulging in activities that may potentially pose a threat to a school environment conducive to learning.

The Tinker case discussed is pertinent here. The school was denied the right to prevent students from wearing black armbands as a mark of their protest, but at the same time, the school was free to suspend or take suitable punitive action against students who acted in a manner that was disturbing the positive learning atmosphere. If the school caught students indulging in activities such as igniting political commotion or voicing their opinions in a manner that disrupted teaching and learning, the school could justly suspend them.

Similar decisions were made in the case of the Bethel School Dist. No. 403 v. Fraser, in which the court took the clear stance that students’ use of fighting words and threats was prohibited in schools. The category included racial epithets, lewd and offensive speech, immature conduct, or true threats that could possibly lead to harming another person.

Exercising free speech is not just limited to student behavior. It extends to the realms of student newspapers, plays, and literature. While students do enjoy their due rights, teachers have some control. The following falls within the school’s authority to curb freedom of expression that may be disruptive to the learning environment:

  • Teachers or school authorities are required to collect concrete proof against students indulging in indecent speech, potential disruption, or other unacceptable activities before taking action against them.
  • Students must be provided with due process when any sort of punishment is involved.
  • The banning of indecent, inappropriate, and unacceptable material is acceptable by the school when such material contradicts the mission of the school.
  • School authorities have the final word on deciding the time and place of the distribution of certain materials.
  • The school newspaper must be run subject to legally defensible guidelines.
  • The nature of the school newspaper must be decided beforehand. If it’s decided to be an open forum rather than a curriculum-based letter, the students should be provided with due rights to express their opinions.
  • A well-established procedure for reviewing newspaper submissions should exist to make the process smoother.

3. Student prayers.

In 1996, a New Jersey Highland Regional High School student sued the school because of its decision to have a prayer before graduation. The court found that it was unjust to violate the religious rights of students who did not want a prayer at their graduation. In Doe v. Madison School District no. 321, an Appeals Court ruled in favor of a policy of the Madison School District of Rexburg, Idaho, allowing the top four graduating students to make speeches that included recitation of prayers. The difference here was that the control of religious content was in the hands of the individual students, and not the school. The court ruled that because selection of student speakers was based on their academic standing, complete discretion should be awarded to the students to choose the content of their speech.

Another important question related to religious rights is whether it’s legal to allow religious groups to use public school facilities to propagate their religious beliefs. Answering this question is not an easy task. To better understand the concept, let’s take a look at current practice. New York City allows the rental of schools for community activities, which include religious discussions. But the use of school facilities for religious services is prohibited. The court validated this stance by asserting the premise that public schools wish to distance themselves from being identified with a particular religious service and appearing to be advocating one religion or another.

In another instance, the Supreme Court ruled against having student prayers at football events because that violated the Establishment Clause. A particular school district’s decision to conduct a student vote on the issue didn’t meet with the approval of the law. The court maintained that it couldn’t allow such sponsorship of any kind of religious activity. The decisions reached in these court cases shouldn’t lead us to believe that the law is completely against the practice of student prayers. Provisions are made to safeguard the interests of those who practice religion. A section of the No Child Left Behind Act of 2001 entitled “School Prayer” ensures that the U.S. Department of Education plays an active role in making sure that school districts allow for school prayer within the boundaries of the law.

The issue of religion in schools also emerged around the question of whether or not public schools were propagating a religion—that of secular humanism. The issue was raised by those of a different religious allegiance, who contended that they found such a propagation offensive. This was clearly a case of affiliation to strongly held religious values. Christian schools with core fundamentalist Christian values were at the center of the conflict. When state lawmakers required Christian schools to conform to minimal education standards set up by the state, the schools complained that following state curriculum guidelines would be tantamount to teaching secular humanism to their students. Christian schools maintained that the Christian fundamentalist dictum relied heavily on the authority of the scriptures, and not on secular humanism, which was the religion of public schools. The law stood firm. The state minimum standards had to be included in all schools accredited by the state.

Do you know how the free speech argument plays out in your district? Check with your administrators on what current policy is. As an educator, it is your job to make sure that your teaching upholds the highest constitutional standards and allows the greatest access to knowledge.