Uncategorized

Four Tough S’s in Education: Search, Seizure, Suspension, and Student Rights

Sometimes, students pose a danger to themselves or to others. It’s a situation that most educators hope to never face, yet so many will. It’s important that you understand your district’s policy for dealing with those situations, what your role would be, and what rights the student or students in question would have. This article talks about the legal concerns of two common safety situations:

1. Search and Seizure

Protection against being subjected to unreasonable searches and seizures is provided to all American citizens by the Fourth Amendment to the Constitution. Students, as citizens, enjoy that right. School officials are less limited than police with respect to searches and do not have to procure a warrant or a probable cause to initiate search. They can conduct a search based on the presence of reasonable suspicion. With the increasing need to address issues such as the elimination of drugs and weapons, laws with respect to search and seizure have become more diversified. Newer means of detection of banned items have emerged, which has made search and seizure more complicated. On the whole, a search by school officials can be justified as long the following guidelines are adhered to:

  • The school employee must have reasonable grounds to conduct the search, and the circumstances have to justify the action at its inception.
  • The authorities conducting the search must be careful about the reasonableness of their actions in terms of the situation and the age and gender of the students.
  • For any search to take place, a reasonable basis of suspicion against the student must exist. Mere doubts do not give the license to the school authorities to conduct searches.
  • The routine search of lockers and desks is acceptable and can be a part of the normal procedure. Parents should be informed about the policy beforehand.
  • The more invasive a search, the stronger the probable cause should be.

Authorities must also take certain precautions when conducting a search. For example, a male official cannot conduct a physical inspection of a female student, as that could amount to sexual harassment. If backed by a reasonable cause, searching students’ purses, book bags, lockers, packages, and automobiles parked on school property is completely acceptable. But in the absence of strong suspicion, any search is utterly unacceptable. Personal searches are required to be carried out in private and by an official of the same gender as the person being searched. Also, the provision of alternate clothing for the accused while the search is being carried out is a must. As mentioned earlier, drug testing for student athletes participating in sports activities is a common practice by schools and is legitimized by law. The use of “sniffer dogs” when a reasonable suspicion exists that a student is carrying drugs is allowed.

2. Due Process in Suspension and Expulsion
The right to education for every student is the major consideration of the U.S. Supreme Court when dealing with issues concerning due process and suspensions and expulsions. This was clearly illustrated by the Supreme Court’s decision in Goss v. Lopez, in which the court ruled that the due process requirement regarding cases dealing with suspensions of 10 days or less must include a proper and timely written or oral communication to the student outlining the charges against him or her. Furthermore, the school must provide the student with the opportunity to present his or her side of the story during any proceedings related to the suspension. The inherent guiding principle is that all students have the right to an education, which is secured for them under state laws. 
While the Goss decision dealt primarily with dismissal from school for disciplinary reasons, the scope should be broadened in the future to outline the due process requirements in cases involving the suspension of students for academic reasons. 
In order for schools to remain within the confines of the law as it pertains to due process, they should adhere to the following guidelines:

  • There must be an attempt to reach to a consensus over the real basis of fact.
  • The provision for future review of any decision must be present.
  • The justness of all procedures appropriated in reaching any decisions regarding the case must be established in entirety.

In real-life situations, however, the essentials listed above translate into the following:

  • Provision of a timely notice to the student revealing all charges against him.
  • Providing ample opportunity for the concerned student to be able to speak in clarification of the charges against him or her during the hearing.

Take, for example, a situation when a student becomes so rowdy and disruptive that his or her removal from the school becomes necessary. While the school ideally has a policy outlining options in such circumstances—which may range from short-term or long-term suspension to permanent expulsion of the student—it is the institution’s moral obligation to choose the action that most aptly applies to that particular student. For minor disciplinary actions, schools can use their discretion depending on the gravity of the act. Short-term suspensions should be preceded with some sort of a notice to the student and a chance to tell his or her side of the story. This notice must bear tangible proof of being served, in case the student denies the charge. This places the school in a strong position to explain the evidence in the best possible manner.

Long-term suspension or expulsion must be backed with concrete reasons and proof of the student’s offending behavior. It is the school’s responsibility to ensure that the punitive actions imposed do not violate the student’s rights. To guarantee that students’ rights have been protected, educators at a minimum should:

  • Provide the student with a written notice of the alleged charges against them.
  • Provide a full and detailed notification of the time and place of the hearing well in advance.
  • Share with the student a clear-cut description of the procedures to be followed at the hearing.
  • Furnish a list of evidence to be presented as well as the names of witnesses who will be called for 
the hearing.
  • Make sure the student has an opportunity to cross-examine witnesses, and can bring his or her own witnesses.
  • Keep the option of appealing the final decision open for the student against whom the charges are being put.

Again, laws are not fixed, and amendments are made when needed to adapt to changing social norms, viewpoints, and thought processes. A good example is the way schools have changed in dealing with teen pregnancy, as discussed earlier. While teen pregnancy is still discouraged, school authorities can’ restrict these students’ rights to an education. The underlying assumption is that students, being citizens first, are provided with their substantive and procedural due process rights.

Search, seizure, and suspension are all serious issues that can be emotionally and mentally difficult to face. Still, you owe it to your students and yourself to be thoroughly educated on the process for each. Should the worst happen, you’ll want to have the procedural knowledge right at your fingertips, for everyone’s sake.

Educational Reform: Finding a Solution for a Nation at Risk

The education system of the United States is in grave danger of falling far behind other industrialized nations. But why? Why are our schools lagging behind as compared to our international counterparts?

In 1983, National Commission on Excellence in Education published A Nation at Risk: The Imperative for Educational Reform, which suggested that the nation’s education system was not reaching the standards of excellence and rigor necessary. It also opined that other problems with the U.S. education system placed the nation at risk of falling well behind other industrialized nations. The “risk” in the title referred to the consequences of a failing education system to the economy, and the ability of the nation to compete with other nations. The Nation at Risk report stated that the nation “in effect [had been] been committing an act of unthinking, unilateral educational disarmament.”

The National Commission on Excellence in Education attributed the declining state of education to problematic situations in four areas: the high school curriculum, expectations of students, the use of time, and the quality of teachers. According to the commission, the high school curriculum had become diffused and diluted and lacked a central purpose. A decline in expectations of students was exemplified by a reduction in assigned homework, weakened college admissions requirements, and a decline in the expectation that students would enroll in courses in math, science, and foreign language. When the commission analyzed how American students used education-related time compared to that of peers in other industrialized nations, they found that American students spent less time on schoolwork and spent this time ineffectively. The commission proposed that the quality of teaching was in jeopardy, principally because more academically capable students were not being attracted to the teaching profession, and teacher education programs needed to be overhauled. They also mentioned that key subject matter areas (e.g., mathematics and science) had serious teacher shortages.

A Nation at Risk was published in an era of mass discontent with the public education system and had a considerable impact. The nation set about introducing reforms based on the recommendations in the report. Changes included extended school hours and, in some instances, extended school years; the introduction of more challenging learning materials; more careful monitoring of requirements for and progression toward graduation; and teachers’ assigning more homework and examinations. The report also forced many states to improve teacher qualifications and to overhaul teacher education programs that prepared teachers for licensure.

A Nation at Risk precipitated a number of reforms well into the 1990s. Many states adopted standardized academic content within the framework of a curriculum in conjunction with standardized tests to assess student performance. The intent was to increase student performance while preparing them to meet nationally defined standards. The reforms of the 1990s were characterized by the use of high-stakes tests, defined as tests that have specific consequences for the test taker, along with impassioned arguments for and against increased use of standardized tests. An example of a high-stakes test is a state-required test that students must pass before they can receive a high school diploma. Students unable to pass the test are denied a diploma.

These reform efforts were the target of criticism from teachers and other education advocates. Teachers feared that their classroom autonomy was being reduced, because they were now required to conform to national standards. They also criticized the fact that national standards were not necessarily relevant to the learning needs of students in their local communities. Some critics argued that the use of standardized tests adversely affected minorities, because the tests were rarely made culturally appropriate and were written for the majority. Critics maintained these changes would be a detriment to students who did not perform well on standardized tests for any number of reasons. The most negative aspect of standardized testing associated with standards-based education is that it represents a one-size-fits-all approach to measurement and does not account for differences among learners, schools, and districts.

There’s no contesting that the scores show that U.S. academics are falling behind international standards. However, the jury’s still out as to what to do to bring those scores up. Standardized testing may be a way to uniformly measure one type of success, but it’s definitely not a final fix, nor a very speedy start. If anything, it’s only highlighted that there is a problem – and education needs to do its homework and find a solution.

Educators: What You Need to Know About the Legal Rights of School Districts and Corporal Punishment

As you can imagine, districts must be highly attuned to the law, as well as to the legal rights and responsibilities of the district. Most districts employ an attorney to ensure that they are within their legal rights as they initiate policies, procedures, and practices to guide the district’s schools.

Corporal punishment is still prevalent in school districts across the country. But the legality of corporal punishment is not clear, and the matter has been left to the states to work out. Corporal punishment was put under the spotlight in 1979 when two states initiated its banning. Today, a whopping 31 states are opposed to corporal punishment for students. From a teacher’s perspective, several aspects must be considered when faced with the potential of delivering corporal punishment. These include:

  • Teachers should have complete knowledge of existing state and school district’s rules and regulations on corporal punishment.
  • Teachers should have knowledge of the conditions under which corporal punishment can be directed.
  • Teachers should only use corporal punishment in moderation, and only when it’s completely necessary to maintain control in the classroom or school environment.
  • The punishment must be strictly driven by motives of maintaining discipline in the class or for the student’s betterment. Punishments triggered out of revenge, spite, or anger are unacceptable.
  • The scale of the punishment given must be in strict appropriateness to the misbehavior.

If corporal punishment (wherever it is allowed) is considered to exceed acceptable punishment, a teacher could be liable to a lawsuit. In deciding whether the act was within the bounds of law or not, courts will look at such factors as the instruments of punishment and on the body parts on which the punishment was inflicted. Needless to say, the use of fists, switches, or canes in delivering punishment is simply unacceptable. Likewise, blows inflicted on body parts that are highly susceptible to injuries are not acceptable. Apart from that, before punishing a student in any manner, but particularly before using corporal punishment, ethical considerations must be taken into account.

All in all, in states where no definite rules on the issue exist, teachers must apply discretion and ethics in the matter of corporal punishment for students.

What Educators Must Know About School Districts and Sexual Harassment

Sexual harassment is a serious and unfortunately commonplace issue that school districts face. As a teacher, it’s imperative that you know what falls under the category of sexual harassment and how your district handles the issue when it comes up.

According to a 2011 study by the American Association of University Women (AAUW), around 50% of U.S. students in seventh through twelfth grade experienced sexual harassment. It’s interesting to note that most cases involved student-to-student harassment, as opposed to teacher-to-student harassment. Females were in a worse position, with 56% reporting that they had faced sexual harassment; with boys, it was 40%. The nature of harassment inflicted on female students included unwanted physical attention and touching. For male students, the challenging of other boys’ sexual orientation was a common form of sexual harassment.

Deciding what falls under the label of sexual harassment and what doesn’t is very subjective, but it may be considered generally to be unwelcome behavior of a sexual nature that disrupts a person’s life. Because of the ambiguity and variety of definitions, schools’ responses differ. For example, a 6-year old boy was suspended for sexual harassment in North Carolina in 1996 for kissing a female classmate on the cheek. But there are more serious cases such as Davis v. Monroe County Board of Education, in which a male fifth grader started groping a female classmate with the stated intention of sleeping with her. The school failed to take any action against him despite repeated complaints from parents.

The problem of sexual harassment in schools is persistent. Schools can act more responsibly on the issue by formulating proper and specific sexual harassment policies and providing special training programs for teachers, students, and other administrative staff. Seeking the support of parents is also beneficial. The challenges around implementing sexual harassment policies are made even more difficult because students shy away from reporting incidents, for fear of suffering additional consequences or being ridiculed.

The solution is to create a safe environment in the school so that such instances of harassments simply do not take place and the students feel secure, although this is often easier said than done.

Educators: How to Understand Religious Freedom and Your School District’s Rights

The question of “religion and public schools” is one that still rages hot across the country. How to talk about religion (or whether to talk about religion) brings up the questions around reconciling the internal conflict of the First Amendment. Should more be allowed, or less? What does “being just” really look like in this situation?

Allowing students religious freedom is part of ethical teaching. A great deal of importance was not attached to religious freedom until public schools made it mandatory for students to take part in religious practices such as saying prayers. This was in fact constitutional until Abington School District v. Schempp case brought the issue to the forefront and the Supreme Court ruled that forcing Bible reading and prayer on students was unconstitutional. This verdict came after the Engel v. Vitale verdict, in which recitation of a nondenominational prayer and Bible reading were regarded as violating the clauses of the First Amendment. According to the ruling, the distinction between compulsory and voluntary participation in religious activities was blurred, and that could not be tolerated in the legal sense. Students could under no circumstances be pressured into participating in such activities.

The law’s stance on recitation of prayers in public schools was tested in the Supreme Court in the Lee v. Weisman case. The case involved a student who opposed the recital of a benediction and invocation by a rabbi at a middle school graduation function. The court made its decision based on more than one factor in this case. First, it considered the fact that exercises like graduation ceremonies are not obligatory for students in terms of attendance and, as such, a student may choose not to attend on the basis of his or her opposition to the benediction. The court also considered that a graduation is such a huge event in a student’s life and represents the culmination of many years of hard work, so in that context, it is hardly only voluntary. The case was not decided solely on this point, however. The court concluded that including clergy and prayers as part of public school graduation ceremonies was unconstitutional. And because the religious inclinations of the particular school official in this case directed his decision, he was to be held responsible for the unlawful act.

Another consideration in this discussion pertains to situations where students, and not school officials, select the prayer or the person who is to deliver the prayer at after-school events. Santa Fe Independent School District v. Doe sheds light on this situation. The court ruled in this particular case that even student-initiated prayers at football games were a violation of the law, for the same reason indicated in the Lee v. Weisman case. In the court’s opinion, the public event required the mandatory presence of a large number of students, and thus could not be used as a means for religious expression. Extracurricular religious clubs operating in American public schools are, however, legal in the eyes of the law. While a U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals did contest the decision in one case, the Supreme Court decided that the existence of these clubs in American public schools is acceptable. As a result, under the Equal Access Act, there is nothing unlawful in schools providing a venue for student religious groups for their meetings. Two premises add weight to this view:

1. The school is providing a limited public access for other noncurriculum student groups, which makes access for these groups completely just.

2. The act does not lead to the violation of the constitutional separation of church and state in any manner.

Good News Club v. Milford Central School District supports the Equal Access Act. The case revolved around the running of a private Christian organization’s activities for children in a school building after school hours. The court maintained that because the school district had already adopted a policy of broad community access to its schools, the operations of the Good News Club on school premises was acceptable. The verdict also made it clear that the decision would stand despite the fact that adults and teachers, and not students, in this case directed the club. 
The use of religious texts has also been a concern when looking at religious freedom. It has been clearly asserted that while religious texts could not be used for teaching or advocating religion per se, they could be used to shed light on the relationship between religion and other areas of study such as literature and history. This decision was made in view of the fact that religion plays a part in learning about social life, literature, history, and politics in different historical periods.

So what about
religious freedom and secular humanism?

The perception among many Christian groups that public schools propagate secular humanism is more than just a superficial belief. The public school as a site of secular humanism is very controversial, with a plethora of issues that find their way into many aspects of schooling, including the curriculum. For example, there have historically been debates on what should be taught about the origins of the human race in public schools. One of the most famous of these cases was the 1927 Scopes case in Tennessee, in which John Scopes, a biology teacher, was charged with breaking a state law by teaching the theory of evolution to students. Scopes was found guilty. However, the verdict was overturned on a technicality, and he never served jail time for breaking the law.

Rather than make teaching evolution theory unlawful, states moved to have both evolution and creationism taught in public schools. The 1981 passage of the Balanced Treatment for Creation Science and Evolution Science Act in Arkansas and Louisiana required public schools to teach both creationism and evolution side by side. The laws were contested as unconstitutional. The U.S. District Court of Arkansas’ ruling in McLean v. Arkansas Board of Education declared that creation science was a religion and violated the Establishment Clause of the First Amendment. The Supreme Court later concluded that Louisiana’s Balanced Treatment Act also violated the Establishment Clause. Efforts to have multiple views of the origin of the human race taught in public schools have not subsided. Today, debates take place on whether evolution and intelligent design should be taught in public schools alongside each other, or whether evolution should be taught alone. While evolution theory is devoid of religious connotations, it has been argued that intelligent design is a circuitous way of substantiating the existence of God (because God is believed to be the intelligent designer) and having this view presented in schools.

Because debates on whether evolution, creationism, or intelligent design should be taught in public schools have not abated, it’s likely that we haven’t seen the final legal contests and decisions on this issue. Contention still exists between those who believe public schools have become anti-religious and are promoting secularism and those who are opposed to schools’ teaching a religious point of view.

In 1997, the White House directed the Department of Education to issue a directive on religion in the public schools as a step to settle the matter. The guidelines state:

1. Public schools should remain detached and secluded from the religious beliefs of students or their families.

2. The mode of conduct in public school environments should accord respect to each religion and should allow all forms of religious expression that are permissible by law and do not hurt anyone’s religious sentiments.

3. Under no circumstances should teachers or school officials advocate any particular religion in the school premises.

4. Routine student prayers are not acceptable, but the provision of a moment of silence before the school begins in the morning should be made to students for silent prayer. School religious clubs are legitimate and can hold meetings on the school premises. And expression of their religious sentiments through, for example, school newspapers and bulletin boards is acceptable.

These guidelines have succeeded in finding a new common ground between religious expression and religious freedom and have done much to correct the perception that schools are hostile to religion.

Figuring out how to best incorporate the beliefs of students and their families into a public school setting is a process that will take time. In the mean time, teachers should be aware of what their school’s specific guidelines are, and should do their best to support all students in being themselves and learning to their fullest potential.

Educators: Do You Know These Important Facts About The Legal Rights of Parents?

While they may not be as present in the classroom, the importance and influence of parents to schools is still a major factor that plays into legal strictures. Just like students and educators, parents have school-related rights as well.

Censorship, secular humanism, and evolution are among the key areas that have recently been at the center of discussions on parents’ rights. The foremost question has been whether or the scope of parents’ rights includes protecting children from exposure to school services and other academic material that parents may find objectionable. This question was asked in Newkirk v. East Lansing Public Schools. The student attended school in Michigan’s East Lansing school district and apparently had problems interacting with other children and teachers. Despite the parent’s refusal to give permission for the student to receive counseling, school authorities sent the student to the school counselor. The parents sued the school district, alleging that exposure to counseling sessions and related psychological tests caused their child to have panic attacks and separation-anxiety attacks. The stance of the U.S. Supreme Court was that the school had not done anything wrong and that the Newkirk’s parental rights had not been violated in the process.

Echoing similar sentiments was the decision of the Supreme Judicial Court of Massachusetts in Curtis v. School Committee of Falmouth. The Falmouth School District adopted a policy of making condoms available to junior and senior high school students, along with AIDS-prevention pamphlets. Condom vending machines were installed in the restrooms. Some parents objected to the policy, alleging it to be violation of the Free Exercise clause of the U.S. Constitution (“Congress shall make no law respecting an establishment of religion, or prohibiting the free exercise thereof ”). The court asserted that as long as students were not being forced to take the condoms, and parents were not compelled to advise their children to take part in a personally objectionable proposition, then the objection to the public school programs was unacceptable.

A similar situation was faced in a Chelmsford, Massachusetts, high school, where the parents of two students took the school to court, outraged that they were not allowed to prevent their children from attending the AIDS Prevention and Awareness assembly organized by the school. The court’s verdict was again in the school’s favor, and the parents’ appeal in support of alleged breach of their rights was rejected outright.

Be sure you understand what rights parents in your district have. Parents may turn to you as a resource for understanding their own legal recourse, or you may need to use your knowledge in order to protect your students, or yourself. The more you know about the legal in’s and out’s, the better prepared you’ll be should an issue with a parent arise.

A Look at Student Rights and What They Mean for Educators

Students are the focus of school operations, but they are also the most vulnerable population within school districts. Students are minors, which gives them the least legal independence of any school population, and also means they require the most protection from outside authorities. However, the rights of a student as an individual can also cause tension when butted against the rights a district, or a teacher, does or does not have to impose rules and regulations on a student’s day.

School dress code is an ongoing issue in American schools, and one that often poses a conflict between a student’s rights and the school district’s policies. Many schools have dress codes that prohibit wearing certain types of clothing to school. Inappropriate garments may include tank tops or tube tops, low-riding, hip-hugging pants, Capri pants, overalls, pajama tops or bottoms, sweatpants, shirts with slogans or offensive illustrations, athletic jerseys, hats, and hooded sweatshirts, to name a few.

To avoid problems pertaining to dress codes, many school districts have introduced school uniforms. New York, Chicago, Houston, Philadelphia, Miami, and Los Angeles currently have school districts with uniform policies. As might be expected, requirements to wear school uniforms have not been well received by many students, and in several cases students sued school authorities over this issue. Some students view the imposition of uniforms as an abridgement of their First Amendment rights to free expression, as in Blau v. Fort Thomas Public School District, Breen v. Kahl, and Canady v. Bossier Parish School Board. In each of these cases, the judge asserted the school districts’ right to create and enforce a school uniform policy.

Zero-tolerance policies have won favor from certain sectors of society and have been praised for bringing greater order and discipline to schools. These polices have also faced a degree of criticism. Recently there have been a number of highly publicized incidents, including one where a second grader was suspended by school authorities for biting his pop tart into the shape of a gun. Incidents such as these have led the public to question the wisdom of the policy, particularly when decisions based on zero-tolerance policies have severed students’ rights to access to an education for seemingly frivolous infractions. It has been suggested that school policy should never substitute for an educator’s common sense when dealing with students.

Disciplinary problems have posed the greatest nuisance for school authorities since the establishment of education outside of the home. The problem has escalated recently, with issues like teen dropouts, drug abuse, and the rise of school violence. These issues require schools to be on their guard at all times, and to implement stricter rules for management. School authorities and staffs must also keep in mind that certain students are more demanding (physically, psychologically, or both) and might need special attention and care.

Schools are, however, not powerless in the face of student misbehavior and have several disciplinary alternatives provided by law. These include in-school suspension, out-of-school suspension, or expulsion. The degree of punishment in all three alternatives varies. Schools can deliver punishment that is appropriate for the severity of the misbehavior, to maintain a safe learning environment. Early Warning, Timely Response: A Guide to Safe Schools, published by the U.S. Department of Education, is helpful to both school authorities and students for understanding the legal issues involved in dealing with behaviors believed to be disruptive to safe learning environments and those likely to attract some type of reprimand.

To learn more about the rights of students and how that affects your authority as an educator, check out our other articles on the topics of today’s students and their legal standing.

Your Legal Rights as An Educator: Certification and Employment

As an educator, it’s important that you know the legal aspects of your job through and through – especially if you work at a public school. You need to know the legal strictures governing your behavior as a teacher – and you need to know what legal standing you have recourse to as a professional.

State-specific laws and regulations address the basic requirements for the certification and employment of teachers. Certification is a tool to ensure that a teacher has the preparation to be competent in the profession. Teaching certificates are issued for specific time periods, such as a 5-year or a 10-year term, and limit a teacher to teaching specific subjects and ages. Most states require ongoing professional development to upgrade skills and knowledge and maintain competencies. Failure to do so could result in ineligibility for certificate renewal and consequent job loss.

The requirements for teacher certification are standardized for all applicants and are tested in the courts before their implementation, so the procedure is fair and just. Nonetheless, the law does not intervene in the specific requirements for teaching certification by individual states and intervenes only in instances of violation of human personal rights. A good example of such a violation is the case of United States v. State of South Carolina, in which the court defended the use of National Teacher Examinations as a certification requirement and in determining salaries, even though the test was proven to be biased against minorities. Likewise, in Bay v. State Board of Education, the court took a stern stand and ruled that any applicant convicted of burglary in the past could be lawfully refused a teaching certificate.

In the case of State v. Project Principal, Inc., the Supreme Court of Texas ruled that gainfully employed teachers with permanent certification were required to pass a teacher’s examination to prove their competence for continuing their employed status. In this instance, the court supported the state’s right to replace or nullify existing conditions for renewal of certification and to set up new conditions. Likewise, the verdict of Kelly v. Bonney et al. ruled that permanent certificates held by teachers could be replaced with certificates of a 5-year duration that could be renewed only if the teacher successfully completed additional training.

Every state has an established set of rules and laws for cases involving questions about revoking or extending a teaching certificate. These rules and laws contain clear descriptions of reasons, situations, or actions that could amount to suspension of certification. Reasons for certification suspension are quite varied, ranging from poor moral conduct or being physically or mentally unfit for teaching, to having a criminal conviction. The revocation of one’s teaching certification and loss of employment are not synonymous. While the former certainly leads to the latter, the latter does not necessarily have to result in the former. But teaching certificates are suspended nearly 100% of the time after a teacher’s dismissal and the subsequent request for certification revocation by the school district’s board.

You teaching certification is the crux of your job. Make sure you understand the legal precedent you need to uphold in order to keep that licensing – and, thus, your ability to find a job.

Teacher Liability: Your Rights As An Educator

As a teacher, you carry the weight of several types of responsibility. You are responsible for your students’ welfare, safety, education, and health. You are responsible in a moral sense – and in a legal one. Because of that legal responsibility, you also face a lot of liability.

In Sheehan v. St. Peter’s Catholic School, the Minnesota Supreme Court ruled regarding the liability of teachers in America. Liability can be defined as something that someone is responsible for. The case involved an eighth-grade student who had suffered an accidental eye injury during an athletic field trip organized by the school. Even though the primary culprits were clearly other boys in the class who, in the teacher’s absence, began throwing stones at the girls present, the student alleged that it was the school’s responsibility. There was a monetary judgment against the school.

The criteria for a teacher’s liability for student injuries are more clearly stated in Teachers and the Law, written by Fischer, Schimmel, & Stellman. According to these experts, accidents that fall within a teacher’s liability include those occurring under the following conditions:

The teachers’ failure to protect the student from injury causes the injury.

Negligent behavior on the teacher’s part.

The teacher’s carelessness in appropriating due care to ensure student’s safety.

The student’s persistent attestable injuries.

A discussion of the issue of teachers’ liability for student injuries is very important because cases of teachers being sued for monetary damages are common. Consequently, teachers should have some form of professional liability insurance to safeguard themselves against such situations. The coverage for such insurance is generally provided by teachers’ unions. Make sure to check with your union about what coverage you have.

Malfeasance, Misfeasance, and Nonfeasance: Are You Unwittingly Committing One of These?

In today’s increasingly litigious society, teachers need to know that they are liable for injuries and mishaps that happen to the students under their care. Teachers may be sued for misfeasance, malfeasance, and nonfeasance, and it is important that they know the difference between the three.

1. Malfeasance

This occurs when a teacher hurts or causes bodily harm to a student on purpose. For example, if a student is being disrespectful to you and you strike that student, you’d better get yourself a good lawyer: you’ll probably be sued, be arrested, and lose your job. Remember, you’re in a position of power, and children are vulnerable. Society has no pity or tolerance for people who injure children.

2. Misfeasance

This happens when a teacher neglects to provide information or guidance that could have prevented bodily injury to a student. For example, a science teacher fails to teach students proper safety measures and guidelines for an experiment, and a student subsequently spills chemicals on his or her skin, resulting in a second-degree burn. To protect against misfeasance, teachers must provide explicit, clear instructions that students understand. The safety of students in the classroom ultimately falls to the teacher.

3. Nonfeasance

This occurs when a teacher does not adequately perform his or her supervisory duties, and as a result a student is hurt. For example, a teacher leaves the classroom to drop something off at the office, and two students engage in a fight in the interim. The teacher is guilty of nonfeasance because it’s the teacher’s duty to never leave students unsupervised under any circumstances.

Check your daily teaching routine. Are you at risk for potentially committing one of these three all-too-common acts? You may be able to slide by sometimes, but it’s both poor ethics and legally risky to count on always doing so. You want to be the best teacher you can be – and that means being prepared to take responsibility for all of your actions, no matter what. Make sure your teaching behavior is one that you would be proud to stand up and defend.