Uncategorized

Your Legal Rights as An Educator: On Contracts and Due Process

The legalities involved with employment account for some of the most fundamental legal issues. Because teachers are not self-employed, and are employees of a particular organization or board or group of trustees, they must be clear about their employment contract well in advance, to avoid uncertainties and legal hassles. Issues include the following: At what point is a teacher actually hired? When is the teacher made permanent after being employed on a probationary basis? And what implications does the tenure of the contract have for the teacher? The employment contract should address these points in an unambiguous manner, and new teachers should be encouraged to take the time to review their contract in detail after they receive it and before signing it.

As employees, teachers must be aware of the details of their contract, be able to abide by the clauses mentioned in it, and therefore live up to the employer’s expectations. Failure to be aware of these issues could result in termination of employment In the United States; it’s unlawful for a teacher to be terminated without just cause. A school district can establish just cause for termination only if it appropriately informed the teacher of his or her deficiencies before termination, created and implemented a plan to fix them, and gave the teacher several opportunities to deal with the issues.

Next, the district must provide documentation of the teacher’s continued infractions or deficiencies. If the issue was related to instructional performance, the district must provide evidence of incompetence or actions that placed students at risk. It’s not enough to say that the teacher was a weak instructor or disciplinarian. If the teacher failed to follow policy, the district must provide evidence that the teacher actually broke the policy in question. It’s not enough to merely state that the teacher is late at least 2 days a week. Authorities must have documented proof that the teacher is indeed late at least 2 days a week.

Finally, the district must present evidence and documentation showing that it followed due process and provided just cause for the teacher’s termination. Also, the district must provide evidence that it follows the same process for all teachers and that it would have taken the same steps with any other employee with the same experience, history, and employment level who engaged in the same infraction or exhibited the same deficiencies. At this point, just cause has been established, and the district can terminate the teacher in question.

So what’s this about due process?

Due process in education means that fairness should be rendered in all areas, and that a teacher’s or student’s rights as individuals should under no circumstances be violated. Due process is important because most court decisions regarding teachers, education, and ethical teaching pertain to the fundamental issue of fairness. All protections and rights pertaining to due process actually emerge from two amendments to the U.S. Constitution:

1. The Fifth Amendment, which states that “no person shall . . . be deprived of life, liberty, or property, without due process of law.”

2. The Fourteenth Amendment, which asserts that “the equal protection of the law” should not be denied to any individual and “nor shall any State deprive any person of life, liberty, or property, without due process of law.”

Typically, due process that is appropriated in the judging of the fairness of an action can be classified under two broad headings:

1. Substantive due process rights, which deals with the issue per se.

2. Procedural due process rights, which delves into the fairness of the process used in delivering 
justice.

For instance, if a teacher was dismissed from his or her duties for treating a child in a particular manner that the child’s parents were not pleased about, an issue of substantive due process is raised. The court’s decision will be based on whether or not the teacher’s actions fell within the lawful bounds of ethical teaching.

Procedural due process, on the other hand, would involve the circumstances and the manner in which the case was handled. Issues such as whether or not the teacher received a fair chance to present his or her side of the story in defense and whether he or she was given an opportunity to question the evidence come into play here. Procedural due process is a broad term, and its meaning changes from state to state, depending on the region-specific laws and regulations. To understand this concept, let’s take a look at the court verdict in Goldberg v. Kelly, which included the following account of the minimum procedural safeguards demanded by basic due process:

  • The provision of an opportunity to be heard, and the date and time for this opportunity should be provided to the concerned individual well ahead of time.
  • A full, detailed account of the reasons for the proposed suspension must be furnished well in advance.
  • The opportunity for the accused employee to defend him or herself and to question the evidence provided against him or her should be provided.
  • He or she must, under no circumstances, be deprived of the opportunity to retain an attorney.
  • The individual must receive the opportunity to cross-examine the witnesses present.
  • It’s compulsory that the decision reached must strictly rest on legal rules and laws and on the 
evidence presented at the hearing.
  • The decision-making body must be impartial and unbiased.

The underlying idea behind practicing and attaching appropriate importance to procedural due process is to ensure that individual students, as well as teachers, are not unnecessarily burdened with arbitrary actions against them by any institution or individual.

Teachers and Your Rights: About Your Private Life…

A teacher’s life outside the school may come under scrutiny. Aspects such as whether or not a teacher is associated with any radical political organizations or groups outside school can be grounds for denial of employment or dismissal from services. New York’s Feinberg Law was adopted in 1949 in view of the alleged communist infiltration of public schools during that time. A list of organizations that were in favor of overthrowing the U.S. government by violent means was created.

Any person who turned out to be a member of any organization on the list was deemed unfit to take any office in the school system. The law helped the court reach several verdicts in later years, even though the Feinberg Law was eventually ruled to be largely unconstitutional. A membership with any organization did not mean that the individual partook in the goals of the organization. At the same time, however, the court maintained that the school boards still had every right to screen employees and dismiss them if their personal views supported the overthrow of the U.S. government.

On the whole, U.S. laws seem to be quite ambiguous about whether or not a teacher’s private life can be a basis for his or her dismissal from school. The general trend has been against the teacher’s interests, and teachers’ private lives have met with disapproval from the courts. Court verdicts have, at times, upheld teachers’ rights, however. An Ohio court ruled that a teacher could not be dismissed for using offensive language in a confidential letter to one of the students. Likewise, in another case, the court observed that it was unethical to dismiss a teacher from on charges of indulging in a homosexual relationship with a fellow teacher. The explanation provided was that unless a teacher’s actions hindered his or her ability to teach, any disciplinary action could not be taken against the teacher.

The bottom line is that unless a teacher’s private life interferes with his or her professional conduct as a teacher, it should not be of concern to school authorities, the court, or society in general. But decision regarding these issues is very subjective, and clear-cut definitions of what is “interfering” and what is not “interfering” do not really exist. The only way to reach a consensus is by way of an agreement between the teacher’s organization and the school district about what is acceptable and what is not.

Six Core Characteristics of Ethical Teaching

Ethics are no walk in the park. While many scenarios are black-and-white, easily solved with clear-cut answers, not every circumstance that a teacher comes across is so simply resolved. As a teacher, you may come across decisions that impact an individual’s entire life, from family to future. You need to be prepared to deal with that.

Regardless of the severity of the dilemma, however, every teacher will need to take action based on a code of ethics. A code of ethics is a personal set of guidelines that you’ll use to determine the right course of action in a given situation. Although the teaching profession has no formally adopted code of ethics, any code of ethics should comprise six basic elements:

1. Knowledge

Possessing adequate and appropriate knowledge is crucial in solving ethical issues. Having adequate knowledge of both the situation in question and what is expected of them helps teachers visualize multiple approaches to ethical dilemmas. After assessing the pros and cons of the consequences of possible actions, a teacher can then make a decision about how best to approach the situation.

2. Empathy

Empathy refers to the ability to appreciate a situation from the point of view of the various participants involved. It enables decision-making that aims to provide the greatest unbiased benefit to all parties. Empathy opens up multiple pathways for reaching a decision that includes perceptions and views of all involved.

3. Reasoning

The ability to logically and coherently analyze situations and perspectives represents an important element of the code of ethics associated with the teaching profession. It’s important for teachers to be able to reflect on a situation or circumstance while taking all aspects into consideration and maintaining moral principles as a gauge for deliberation.

4. Appreciation for Moral Considerations

The ability to identify and analyze conflicting and competing moral interests involved in any given situation is very important when faced with ethical dilemmas. Everyone’s rights should be protected, and no one should be deprived of what they deserve. The most important trait in dealing with moral considerations is the ability to adhere to the truth.

5. Courage

The ideals of ethical teaching, such as appreciation for moral considerations, reasoning, and empathy, are much more difficult to reach if the element of courage is missing. Courage is required to create ethical outcomes appropriate for all parties involved, and it can take the form of willpower, tact, or even street-smartness, depending on the situation. Courage comes more naturally to some people than others. As a teacher, you will be required to display courage in a number of situations, sometimes on a daily basis. It will always help to know that you have the school regulations, or possibly even the law, on your side, but there are very few cases in which you can be completely sure without actually having the courage to bring the issue up with a relevant third party. Keeping your students’ best interests at heart will help to guide you in the right direction.

6. Interpersonal Skills

Even teachers with all of the preceding attributes could still be prevented from acting ethically if they lack the requisite communication skills to make their position known. Even if your understanding of right and wrong is clear and just, and is accompanied by all the qualities of being an ethical teacher, the potential for positive outcomes in your ethical dilemmas is diminished if you lack interpersonal skills. In ethically tinged situations, teachers must know how to formulate their words tactfully and how to use the right expressions and put them forth in frank manner, so they appear neither too harsh nor too feeble.

As a teacher, you’ll find yourself with ethical decisions to make every day. These might involve complex issues like reporting child abuse or censorship. Even if the issues you encounter aren’t so weighty, it’s still just as important to be able to make the right decision even when it may not seem to “really matter.” Center your internal compass on these six values, and your ability to act according to a code of ethics should true, no matter how choppy the moral waters.

A Teachers Code of Ethics: Importance and Implications

While pretty much everyone agrees that it’s important to live according to what’s right and to avoid acting in a way that’s wrong, not everyone always agrees on the what’s right or what’s wrong in any given situation. A code of ethics is personal and different for each individual. It determines an individual’s response to a particular situation and also accounts for the varied responses exhibited by different individuals in the same situation.

An individual code of ethics comes into play in everyday situations that teachers experience, such as when an influential parent asks for special favors for his child, while dealing with an impudent student or an impertinent remark, while dealing with colleagues, or at any point while performing the daily duties of the job. All actions and responses are a function of a personal code of ethics, which is the foundation for differences in teachers’ styles of dealing with students and school-related situations. A well-defined code of ethics will help you negotiate difficult times during the life of your career. It allows you to decipher the right thing to do based on your current perspective and to take responsibility for and stand by your decisions.

Another ideal to be realized in the process of abiding by your code of ethics is to make quick and prudent decisions. Teachers should not delay ethically correct decisions for long periods of time before putting them into practice. If your code of ethics is strong, you should be able to make decisions on the spot and have the conviction to bear the consequences. Too much pondering or hesitation takes the impact out of even the soundest ethical decisions.

Ultimately, the way you respond to what you believe is right and wrong provides insight into your code of ethics. And that’s why a personal code of ethics is not a stringent, formulated code. You can approximate and set guidelines for yourself based on what you think is right and depend on these guidelines to solve dilemmas and complex educational situations. Individual codes of ethics are not formal codes laid out by organizations and institutions to be obligatorily adhered to by their members. They are intangible moral guidelines that individuals appropriate on their own.

Educators: Where Your Code of Ethics Should Stem From

Are individual codes of ethics inborn in humans? Many researchers believe that humans are socialized to possess a vague sense of the moral legitimacy of various issues and situations. The degree of stringency that an individual attaches to these is a result of what he or she has experienced through interaction with others, as well as spiritual and religious wisdom, reasoning ability, and secular guides during the course of life. The process of creating a personal code of ethics involves reflecting on and reviewing these interactions to ensure your framework is flexible enough to function in any new situations you may encounter.

Ethical guidance can be derived from many sources. It can reach you subconsciously through adages heard by chance, or even a bumper sticker you see while driving. Humans learn by imitation, finding role models who provide either direct or indirect guidance when dealing with ethical dilemmas. Direct guidance involves asking a role model for advice in a given situation, whereas indirect guidance involves considering what your role model has done or would do in the same situation, based on what you know about your role model. This model-selection process is observable in children when they begin to imitate their parents, sometimes even wearing their clothes or imitating the way they talk on the phone. Likewise, in adulthood, when one is faced with questions like, “What should I do?” or, “Am I approaching the problem in the correct manner?” it’s natural to reframe the question into, “What would my role model have done?” This happens largely on a subconscious level, but nonetheless plays a part in an individual’s final decision making.

Parents also play a part in a more intentional way, by ensuring that they choose the most morally sound educational tools (e.g., specific schools, teachers, or books) for their children so that their children establish ethical values from “good” examples. Historical or literary figures may provide particularly interesting and useful role models from whom to obtain indirect guidance. These role models may also be derived from religion. For example, some Christians wear WWJD bands to remind them to ask, “What Would Jesus Do?” in a moral or ethical situation. Buddhists find ethical guidance by considering what the Buddha would have done, deriving their insights from teachings passed down through generations, as well as through frequent consultation with teachers, known as the Sangha. The great holy books of religion, such as the Koran, the Torah, and the Bible, may offer various examples of how to cope with ethical dilemmas.

Factors that affect the development of your code of ethics don’t work in isolation. Instead, they work in close proximity to each other and collectively shape the final outcome in the form of problem solving. In the case of ethical codes, it’s from these factors that you’ll eventually select the attributes that go into making your final decision. These internal processes usually happen so rapidly as to appear automatic. When teachers see something happening that their code of ethics doesn’t allow, they probably don’t have to think twice—their inherent code of ethics immediately guides them to make the appropriate decision. This process is so spontaneous that there’s no room for second thoughts about the decision before putting it into practice. For example, if a teacher sees an older girl taunting a younger girl for her looks, the teacher will probably not stop to ponder the situation before stepping in and separating the two. This is especially true if a pattern of behavior has already been established.

It is an absolute must for every educator to develop reflexive behavior that corresponds to their theoretical code of ethics. The difference between having acted rightly or wrongly may come down to the knee-jerk reaction of a single half-second. Make sure your ability to measure up isn’t in question should it all come down to the wire.

Educators: Four Everyday Ethical Practices to Prime Your Moral Compass

It’s inescapable that at some point in their careers, every teacher is faced with ethical and moral issues that require sound judgment. In fact, it would almost be impossible to find a teaching professional who has never grappled with such dilemmas. While developing your skills in good decision making, you’ll need to keep in mind the six elements comprising the code of ethics—knowledge, empathy, reasoning, appreciation for moral considerations, courage, and interpersonal skills. Internalizing these will ultimately lead to appropriate actions. Nonetheless, such cases hardly exhaust the ethical responsibilities of a teacher. The bigger picture has an even more serious and important area to deal with—the everyday ethics of teaching:

1. Keeping Up With Ethics Essentials

While the responsibility for providing children with a strong ethical grounding falls largely on parents, educational institutions also have a big role to play in shaping the moral character of young people. Children acquire knowledge about what’s right and wrong in classrooms where they spend most of their growing years. They can receive many lessons of wisdom in life in school. Experiences from the classroom during the formative years provide children with attributes they apply lifelong in their behaviors and actions. Teachers’ examples leave strong impressions on children, and teachers often serve as role models for their students. Children’s classroom experiences don’t necessarily have to be strong or severe to leave lasting impressions. A teacher’s rude comments to a particular student could trigger responses in students that they’ll keep for their entire lives. Teachers must be aware that they send strong ethical messages to their students by their choices and decisions.

2. Setting a Personal Example

Teachers can, by way of what they do and say, influence students to emulate them. They provide guidance not only through direct lecture, but also by modeling moral behavior. A teacher who encourages children to deal with interpersonal problems, but who confronts students by shouting and making threats, is not modeling the appropriate behavior.

3. Establishing Ethical Dialogue in Classrooms

Establishing an ethical dialogue in the classroom whenever a situation arises is an excellent way to instill moral values in students. Discussing core values such as honesty, truthfulness, and respectability helps students understand good ethical behavior, as well as how to differentiate good from bad. By giving examples from everyday life, and from historical and literary figures, teachers can help students reflect on core values from multiple perspectives. Ethical lessons taught to students often remain with them throughout their lives. It’s also valuable for students to watch their teachers reflecting and updating their own personal code of ethics, because this will provide them with guidelines on how to conduct this process themselves in the future.

4. Creating a Congenial Classroom Environment

The classroom environment also has ethical dimensions. Teachers who create classroom environments with the expectation that students will interact with each other in an open, just, and honest manner set the tone for an ethically inviting learning space.

Ethics are not just for the big, extraordinary scenarios. Ethics are for everyday, commonplace issues, too. Keep in mind the four daily ethical practices we described here, and your moral compass will be primed and ready when the hard hitters come your way.

Five Tips for Preventing Censorship Issues in Education

Once upon a time in America’s schools, librarians, teachers, and the curriculum coordinator decided which books would be used in classrooms and school libraries. Things have changed. Parents and other interest groups are now seeking to have a say in what students are taught and what materials are used to instruct them. This is not something to be feared, because it is a sure sign that parents and the community are becoming more involved with the education of their youth. As a consequence, you will have to deal with censorship issues from time to time, but “an ounce of prevention is worth a pound of cure.” Here are several things you can do to prevent censorship issues from arising in your classroom:

1. Choose your books carefully. Make sure they align with the curriculum that is in place. Also, make sure you can justify their use by explaining why they are necessary and how they will boost student achievement.

2. If a book has caused concern and controversy in the past, save yourself a lot of headache and find an alternative text. Why pick a fight when there is a better way to approach the issue?

3. Be open to and prepared to answer any questions concerning censorship that you may receive, no matter how trivial and absurd they may seem. Make sure that you have introduced yourself to all of your parents and informed them that they can call you with any questions they may have. This can lessen complications, because instead of calling the administration with concerns, they will call you. This way you can dispel any misconceptions without involving the higher-ups.

4. Make sure you talk about the controversial issues from books with your students. Discuss how sections that may seem inappropriate were necessary for the author to get their point across.

5. Always follow your district’s policy on censorship. It’s one thing to take a stand for something that you believe in, but quite another to rebel against the administration and lose your job.

Censorship is a touchy subject in American schools. Various groups have their own views on the matter, but at the end of the day, it’s a necessary evil. The best way to deal with issues of censorship is to prevent them from happening in the first place. With the tips outlined here, you’ll be able to recognize possible issues before they arise and save yourself plenty of grief.

How the ESSA update will impact disadvantaged students

With President Obama signing the new Every Student Succeeds Act, or ESSA, many are wondering what effect the changes in schools will have on minority students, students with disabilities and low-income students.

Some worry the gap between students will not be narrowed with the adoption of the Every Student Succeeds Act. Professor of education at the University of California, Los Angeles and director of the Center for the Study of School Transformation, Pedro Noguera, told NPR that he fears ESSA furthers the belief that we can minimize inequality and increase academic outcomes simply by focusing on schools.

Interestingly enough, ESSA is the most current version of the Johnson administration’s Elementary and Secondary Act of 1965, which heavily addressed poverty and underserved students. During the 1970s, large scale gains were made in closing the gaps in academic achievement as school integration and poverty were focused on abundantly.

The situation is often bleak where poverty is heavily concentrated. Unless as a nation we are able to invest in schools the way we did in the past, we can’t expect to see inequalities disappear. The hope is that with focusing on schools at the local level, officials can more effectively pinpoint issues and in turn determine viable solutions for those problems.

It is in our best interest that all children receive quality education. As a nation, we cannot afford to have  large numbers of individuals who are under-educated and stuck in low-income jobs. The best way to an equitable society is to focus on education and providing individuals with the proper set of skills necessary to enter and flourish in the workforce.

The Every Student Succeds Act may help rebalance inequality. Though many believe it’ll be up to the next President and Secretary of Education and whether they focus more on teaching and learning, versus placing the spotlight on assessment, as we’ve seen so readily in the past.

Click here to read all our posts concerning the Achievement Gap.

Mandatory recess in Florida’s public elementary schools?

A group of central Florida mothers have written a bill that asks lawmakers to consider making recess mandatory in the state’s public elementary schools. The bill would require no less than 20 uninterrupted minutes of recess each school day for public elementary students. Teachers would not be able to withhold recess time as punishment for students if the bill passes. Currently, each school in the district can independently determine how much time to allotted to recess on a daily basis.

Often times recess is the highlight of a student’s day at school. It is a time to mentally and physically recharge from a grueling day filled with primarily sedentary activities. It is often apparent when children do not receive proper recess time and aren’t able to exert energy that tends to build throughout the school day. Palm Beach County Superintendent Robert Avossa says, “We joke and call it the wiggles, we gotta get the wiggles out, they gotta move their bodies.”

Parents and administrators alike believe in the value of recess, the issue seems to be whether or not there are enough hours in the day to make it a daily requirement. So much is packed into the school day already and much of the curriculum and activities are already mandatory. Some believe the only way to incorporate daily recess is to extend the school day.

Florida’s mandatory recess for public elementary schools bill will be reviewed in the state House and Senate and will work through the legislative process next year.

 

Bobby Jindal wanted more education cuts in Louisiana

Higher education in Louisiana faced cuts this past year after the state faced a multi-million dollar budget shortfall.

It could’ve been worse (way worse) for education though. Governor Bobby Jindal reportedly wanted to cut over $600 million from higher education but was rebuffed by leaders in the state legislature.

In speaking with the press this past week, Jindal notes that he was upset that lawmakers didn’t cut from the state’s higher education fund.

To close the state’s budget shortfall, lawmakers used money from the rainy day fund. Despite Jindal’s opposition, the fact that higher education funds weren’t slashed even further is good for just about everyone else.

Despite Jindal’s opposition, the fact that higher education funds weren’t slashed even further is good for just about everyone else.

Nola.com notes that the move saved many schools from being reorganized.

“The Louisiana Legislature voted overwhelmingly last week to draw down around $28 million from the rainy day fund to cope with a midyear budget shortfall. The move allowed public colleges and universities to avoid reductions in the current budget cycle — though the outgoing governor said he would have preferred more reductions.”

Against his will, Jindal compromised and went along with what the legislature wanted. Since Jindal’s terms as governor is up in January, he spoke about the need to reduce the size of the state’s government, which is why he wanted to cut higher education funding.

On the inverse, Governor-Elect John Bel Edwards says that he wants to increase the budget for higher education, which will undoubtedly appease education leaders in the state.