Uncategorized

Digital Tools Will Not Magically Transform Your School; You Must Do the Work

The field of educational technology is something like the Wild West: there is great promise, enormous opportunity, and a lot of chaos. The bottom line is that edtech will not work magic. There are three main reasons for this.

The actual data on student outcomes for tech-infused instructional approaches is somewhat disappointing. In many cases, the returns on edtech are minimal—or even negative. This perhaps seems shocking on its face, but a deeper dive into the research suggests some reasons for this. One reason is that lower-order thinking skills are the easiest to present and assess in an edtech context, so those are often the items that are focused on.

Of course, the quest to develop students requires a much greater emphasis on higher-order thinking skills, which are still much trickier to present and, especially, to assess without human intervention. Additionally, some research evidence shows that one of the key factors underlying student achievement is the relationship that develops between the teacher and the student. Obviously, if edtech is an impediment to that relationship, the edtech tool may limit or even harm student achievement.

Students—even digital natives—still need to be taught by humans. This seems obvious, but too many stakeholders seem to be relying on the assumption that anything a human teacher can do can be done better by an app. But a careful analysis of the current state of edtech shows that there is a fatal flaw in thinking that tech tools can replace teachers. The flaw is that it assumes that students find edtech inherently motivating. But why would this be the case? Sure, students might seem to spend all of their time on their smartphones, but they aren’t watching algebra videos on them on their own time.

The assumption that they would find algebra videos interesting just because they find music videos interesting is not rational, once it is examined carefully. Did 1960s children enjoy watching videos of history professors on their black and white TVs just because they enjoyed watching cartoons on those TVs? In other words, edtech enthusiasts may not be paying enough attention to the difference between engagement with a platform and engagement with certain kinds of content.

Finally, every generation of new edtech brings a wave of teacher inertia and even backlash. And it is no wonder: if you have been in the classroom for twenty years, you have probably had to sit through a professional development on using VHS tapes in the classroom. If you are feeling a bit jaded and resistant to the latest edtech “miracle,” that’s understandable.

For all of these reasons, no edtech purveyor can think of edtech as a simple solution. It still requires student engagement, strong student-teacher relationships, and teacher buy-in to the project.

5 Things that Educators Want from Webinars

Continuing education is a necessity for teachers, especially with the rapid rate of change in the classroom. Webinars prove to be a very convenient way for them to access this training from the comfort of the teacher lounge or from home. However, most educators won’t sign up for just any class that happens to be convenient. Each webinar must promise one of these five things in order to capture a teacher’s interest.

Actual Benefits

Teachers must be able to clearly identify what they will gain from attending a webinar. They already feel strapped for time, so they won’t want to waste an hour or more on a webinar that doesn’t offer them anything. If you want to host a successful webinar for educators, you need to be clear and upfront about the benefits of the class.

Freebies

Teachers never have enough money in their classroom budgets for supplies, so freebies can go a long way. Give out a small item that corresponds to the webinar topic. Make sure that the gift you give out will be relevant to the classroom and help them to implement the new skills learned through the webinar. You can give them access to additional content at no extra charge, a small token sent to them in the mail, or any other enticing freebie you can think of.

Engaging Presentation

At the end of a long work day, teachers don’t want to listen to a monotonous voice drone on about statistics. Your webinar needs to have passion, engaging content, and an enthusiastic speaker. Great visual content can also play an important role in crafting an engaging webinar that makes teachers want to come back for future presentations.

Shorter Lengths

Most people prefer webinars that are between thirty and forty minutes long. This gives you enough time to get through a solid amount of material without cutting into an educator’s personal time. Webinars should aim to fill at least thirty minutes of time with their content. If this isn’t possible, then the webinar might not be worth a teacher’s time. Virtual classes that run too long may need to be split up into multiple parts to make them more manageable for educators.

Add a Q&A Section

Educators love to learn more information, and one of the best ways to do that is to ask more questions. Be sure that you leave plenty of time in the end to take a few questions from the crowd. This can help them to gain the information they really need from your presentation and feel more engaged. It may even help you to see new potential topics for your next webinar series.

Why Edtech Companies Need Education Researchers to Be Brutally Honest

New edtech companies are popping up all over the globe on a daily basis. Most of these companies have noble intentions of solving their own perceived problems in the classroom. Unfortunately, they have a difficult time understanding the subtle nuances of teaching without a little insight from experienced educators. Edtech will continue to develop new programs that accomplish very little without the assistance of education researchers.

It’s time for education research companies to become brutally honest with emerging edtech companies. Students and teachers alike need the support of these science-backed facts to help them connect with edtech companies who could create something amazing for the classroom. Currently, edtech seems to be falling short of its potential. Here are a few of the reasons why education researchers really need to step it up with their honesty.

Edtech often opts for just one good study.

School districts often want to see some research supporting a program before they will consider buying into the sales pitch. Edtech companies are willing to indulge them, but they only provide one solid research study that supports their product. Unfortunately, this isn’t enough evidence to ensure that this trial could be repeated with similar results. The answers might have even been cherry-picked to cast the study in a more favorable light. Education researchers need to study these programs long and hard before granting them a seal of approval. This might give school districts pause before spending their budgets on ineffective products.

Engineers aren’t designing programs to solve problems.

Edtech companies are typically founded by engineers instead of educators. They need the brutal honesty of education researchers to help them uncover what problems exist in the modern school. This partnership might make the development of an initial product more difficult, but it can ultimately make a more successful company moving forward. The current solutions offered by edtech don’t always address the most pressing concerns facing teachers, but education research could change that.

Working with education researchers could open the lines of communication.

Becoming successful as an edtech company is extraordinarily difficult due to the amount of competition in this field. A company who chooses to work with education researchers and apply their advice could have an easier time opening the lines of communication at local school districts. Some education consultants are former educators who maintain a relationship with the schools in the area. When they are familiar with a product and can thoroughly support it, edtech companies might be more successful at getting their company off the ground. Companies will have to be committed to applying the honest critiques offered in order for this to be effective.

Edtech companies have the potential to dramatically disrupt the modern education system. However, they are often lacking the knowledge of the classroom and of the various teaching styles to make an effective product. They need the brutal honesty of education researchers to help them navigate these unfamiliar waters. The partnership between edtech and education research is necessary if we want to produce the best outcomes in the classroom.

What are the Long-Term Effects of Edtech Use?

Now that technology has found a home in most classrooms, it is time for teachers and parents to start considering what the trade-off might be for this new advancement. Students have better test scores than before, but what is the ultimate cost for the long-term use of edtech? School districts continue to purchase new digital tools so that teachers can implement more new programs in the classroom. Unfortunately, nobody wants to talk about what the increased use of digital devices could mean for students in the future.

Researchers are still avidly studying the effect that prolonged exposure to technology can mean for students. While the research is far from over, these are just a few of the long-term effects that have already been discovered.

Increased Motivation and Self-Esteem

One of the best things about using edtech in the classroom is how motivated students are to participate. The programs used are far more engaging than the standard textbooks and whiteboards that most students are used to. Many of the programs give them immediate feedback to tell them how well they are doing. They can often use that feedback to modify their behavior when they attempt the program again, always searching for a higher score. Their ability to change the results ultimately increases their self-esteem as well, making them more motivated to participate. It creates an endless positive loop of motivation and improved self-esteem.

Learn More in Less Time

According to a study from researcher James Kulik, students who used computer-based programs often learned more information in less time. It should be noted that his study did not include the gamification that is present in many edtech companies today. Instead, he concluded that students learned more through tech-based tutorials, drill and practice questions, and integrated learning systems. Because they learned more in less time, students also tended to score much higher on tests of standard achievement.

Decreased Attention Span

Researchers have known for quite some time that the amount of time we spend in front of screens dramatically impacts our attention spans. The same is true for students, even when they are using that technology to enhance their education. Exposure to screens makes it difficult for children to learn how to organize information and pay attention for longer periods of time. Some are speculating that the increase in the use of technology could be the cause of the dramatic increase in the number of children diagnosed with attention deficit hyperactivity disorder (ADHD).

While edtech does hold a lot of promise for today’s students, we must weigh our options very carefully. It is possible to have too much of a good thing in the classroom. Educators need to consider whether every edtech program is truly beneficial for their students. Understanding the advantages and disadvantages of long-term technology use will be essential to helping students prepare for a bright future.

 

We Need to Put the Ed Back in Edtech

Edtech continues to emerge as a prominent way for teachers to present individualized learning for their students. Schools are spending more money than ever before on new digital tools and platforms that promise better outcomes for students. Unfortunately, some of these programs are focused more on the flashy design than they are on solving real classroom problems. The actual academic component is missing in many of the new programs being implemented in the classroom.

If we are going to continue to espouse the benefits of technology, we need to put the “ed” back in edtech. The programs and tools that educators are using need to present a real value to their students. How can we move forward with better academics in our edtech? Here are a few items emerging edtech companies should keep in mind.

Add teachers to the team early on.

Emerging edtech companies are often founded by engineers who have no education background to support the programs they design. According to expert Jim Lobdell, many companies attempt to find a product-market fit without input from experienced educators. They save their money and resources for engineers who can help with the physical design of the program instead of teachers who could help with the content and presentation. In order to avoid costly revisions and reduce the amount of time to successfully create a product, teachers should be added to the team early on.

Identify real problems in the classroom.

Engineers don’t know what problems exist in the classroom because they have no experience. Oftentimes, they design a program that solves a perceived need that isn’t actually a priority for teachers. According to the research, only 63 percent of students are using technology to solve a problem, conduct research, or work collaboratively. This number falls painfully short of where it could be if edtech focused more on solving classroom problems.

Offer more streamlined solutions.

One of the issues that major edtech companies and teachers are facing is that few platforms offer streamlined services. Teachers might have to visit a dozen different programs to achieve all of their classroom needs. Keith Westman, the founder of the Otus edtech company, notes that the technology has stopped solving problems and started overwhelming teachers. When they have to use a number of programs, it means that student data and relevant information is scattered all over the place. Teachers need to be able to access this information more conveniently. With all of the numbers right at their fingertips, teachers could start to form a more comprehensive look at where students are struggling or excelling in the classroom.

Edtech still holds the potential to revolutionize the classroom, but it has a long way to go. New companies and industry giants need to remember to keep education at the forefront of their new developments. This can help to ease the burden many teachers feel and improve the outcomes for students. It’s time we started looking a little harder at how we can put the ed back in edtech.

 

 

 

The Power and Promise of OER is the Democratization of Education

Open educational resources, more commonly known as OER, promise a revolution in education. Historically, access to educational resources has been severely limited by the ability and willingness of someone to pay for instructional materials. However, the digital revolution makes it possible to post top-notch educational resources online, making it a reality for almost every student in the world to have access to those resources.

One intriguing use of these resources comes from Modern States, a non-profit group that hosts study materials—including video lectures and OER textbooks—on its website. Modern States makes its courses available for free. Students who complete the courses can take the corresponding CLEP exam and, if they pass, earn college credit. This is the framework for Modern States’ goal of making it possible for a student to earn a year of college credit for free.

Of course, like other MOOCs, Modern States requires a student to have the persistence to take an entire course with no external motivators. This is a pretty tough task for most college-age students, but it nonetheless has the potential to foment a revolution. It really is possible to earn a year of college credit with no more than an internet-connected computer. This is but one example of the democratization of education. Note that, in addition to overcoming the barriers of cost, Modern States—and other OER purveyors—are able to overcome other obstacles to education, such as distance and disability, that can make it difficult for some students to pursue higher education.

Another model is that of Khan Academy. They have become well-known for their video lessons and practice materials. Unlike Modern States, their materials are more atomized and more appropriate to use when supplementing other instruction. But this, too, is an important aspect of the democratization of education: in the past, outside tutoring was usually limited to those students who had parents who could afford it. But now, all students can access additional help through Khan and similar platforms.

OER also makes it possible to keep resource-poor and underserved schools on a more equitable playing field. Complaints about out-of-date textbooks are a perennial problem for poorer schools, but OER helps to bridge that gap. Especially in STEM subjects, this is an important aspect of democratization. Groups such as CK12 mean that no student will need to rely on out-of-date texts.

While there are still challenges, OER presents opportunities to democratize education that simply have no historical parallel.

 

You Need to Understand Learning Analytics to Personalize Learning

Personalized learning refers to the effort to teach each individual student. Historically, most teachers have had little choice save to teach to the average. Of course, no one student is perfectly average. This means that teaching was often not appropriate for many students, who struggled as a result. But personalized learning reframes instruction by using the most appropriate tools, approaches, and content for each individual student. Of course, this is extremely difficult to accomplish without edtech tools. And one of the keys to implementing a quality personalized learning approach—one that is more likely to result in improved student learning outcomes—is a focus on data analytics. In other words, you need to understand learning analytics in order to personalize learning.

Learning analytics refers to the fine-grained analysis of student performance in order to shape future instruction. A teacher focused on learning analytics is not content to see that a student earned a B grade on an exam. Rather, that teacher will closely assess what the student got wrong in order to ensure that the student can master that material. An important component of learning analytics is the analysis of wrong answers in order to determine what misconceptions a student has. Odd as it may sound, analysis of incorrect answers may actually be more important to the student’s future success. This approach requires a radical reorientation away from grades as a final statement of a student’s performance toward focused analysis of performance as a guide to future instruction.

While some teachers have access to sophisticated systems to use for learning analytics, not all districts make that available. But teachers can use free tools in order to use learning analytics to personalize learning. A student response system such as Socrative can be used to, for example, assess a student’s knowledge–before a new unit begins–with a formative assessment.

Teachers can then make assignments targeted at correcting misconceptions and filling in gaps—based on the personalized learning needs of individual students—before continuing with the material. Similarly, a tool as simple as Google Forms can be used to assess student learning; based on their results, students can be directed to instructional activities that are appropriate for them.

Personalized learning is a powerful concept. But, absent focused learning analytics, it can be difficult to implement. In fact, assignments might, in that case, stem more from teacher bias than from student need. But a few simple tools used to conduct learning analytics can make personalized learning a reality in every classroom.

 

 

 

10 Keys to Designing Tomorrow’s Schools

What will the school of tomorrow look like? The short answer is that it will look as much like the school of the past as a mainframe computer looks like a smartphone. In other words, everything will be different. Here are ten keys to designing tomorrow’s schools.

First, it will come as no surprise that tomorrow’s school with be rich with edtech. It is likely that each student will have at least one device—if not more. So tomorrow’s schools need to accommodate that reality, including in mundane ways like having enough electrical outlets for charging devices.

Second, schools are putting an increased emphasis on collaborative learning. The arrangement of learning spaces will be keyed toward making it easy for student groups of various sizes to work together. This requires flexible space and movable furniture, as well as desks that can accommodate various groupings of students.

Third, the emphasis on personalized learning shows no sign of abating. So, learning spaces will need an arrangement that works for students who are engaged in different tasks at the same time, including students who need to focus quietly and others who are working together.

Fourth, community concern over school safety continues. Smart schools will take simple, practical steps to promote the physical safety of their students. The trick here is to avoid making a school look like a prison while still protecting the students.

Fifth, conformity is out. A quick look shows an incredible array of creative classrooms that feature virtually no resemblance to the orderly rows of yesterday.

Sixth, flexibility is the name of the game. It’s hard to know what the future will hold, and so furniture and other elements will need to be able to be used in a variety of ways.

Seventh, the rise of project-based and problem-based learning means that the figurative walls between schools and the wider world are crumbling. Perhaps the literal walls will need to as well. A school that is welcoming to community members will benefit its students in countless ways.

Eighth, for most schools, the cost will continue to be an overriding issue. The school of the future will probably have to do more with less.

Ninth, a focus on STEM subjects means that schools will need increased space and facilities for the sciences, including dedicated maker spaces and labs.

And, finally, tenth: the school of tomorrow will acknowledge, celebrate, and incorporate local traditions and cultures in order to affirm its students.

Using Twitter Chats for Teacher Professional Development

For the broader culture, Twitter is usually perceived as a vast wasteland of gossip, rumor, and incivility. But teachers have transformed their corner of Twitter into something else entirely. Increasing numbers of teachers have been using Twitter chats for professional development. Most chats are specific to a certain subject, but some are regional, and others focus on specific student populations.

While this might seem like a surprising turn of events, there are several advantages to using Twitter. First, it makes it possible for teachers to find like-minded and similarly-situated practitioners. It is a convenient gathering place for teachers from a wide variety of disciplines, and the platform makes it simple for them to join together. It has established the critical mass necessary to accomplish the goal of having a broad enough community to generate useful content.

Further, the length-limited nature of Twitter means that no long-winded colleague can derail the conversation or waste everyone’s time. This means that Twitter chats are useful for busy teachers. Another incredible benefit is that, unlike most professional development opportunities, Twitter chats are free.

Chats are usually held weekly, at the same time each week. A chat will be hosted by one person or group, and they will select a topic for that week. (Don’t forget to check out previous chats for topics that interest you.) Of course, one of the advantages of Twitter is the ability to link to other content, which means that you are likely to find a wide variety of curated materials that will further your knowledge on the topic under discussion. You might want to consider simply observing for the first chat or two so that you can get a feel for the rules, norms, and expectations of the group before you jump in. Also, consider asking questions about areas of concern to you.

If you aren’t already connected to your colleagues on Twitter, it may take a bit of detective work to find your tribe. But several websites host lists of Twitter chats that can help you get started. One edtech journal focuses on Twitter chats that are useful for all teachers, while other lists will help you find a chat devoted to the subject and level of your interest.

You can think of Twitter chats as a virtual gathering place. They are especially useful if you are the only person on your campus in a certain role. Now, you can find colleagues from all over the world who can help you improve your practice.

We Need to End the War Between Traditional and Online Instruction in Higher Education

The percent of students who are taking online classes has exploded in recent years, and it shows no signs of abating. This is perhaps no surprise: online classes offer students a great degree of flexibility. But at the same time, the rise of online classes has led to something of a war between traditional and online instruction in higher education. If you peruse the admissions materials for most online programs, you will notice how careful most are to explain that their degree will not indicate that it was earned online, as if this were a source of shame. But it is time to end the war, for the benefit of all students.

The first step toward ending the war is improving the quality of online education. If online courses were widely regarded as having the same quality as traditional instruction, there would be no cause for conflict. Yet the perception that they are different is what underlies almost all of the conflict. Too many instructors view online classes as an easier teaching assignment, something not worthy of their best efforts.

They may simply post the same videoed lectures and reading assignments to their campus’ learning management system semester after semester and consider that they have fulfilled their obligation to their online students. But as long as the classroom experience is richer, the war between online and traditional education will persist. So, instructors who make their online classes just as rigorous, engaging, and novel as their traditional classes have an important role to play.

Second, universities need to stop viewing online classes as a cash cow. It is, of course, possible to deliver an online class at a lower cost than a traditional class. But as soon as the online students are positioned as the workhorses of the institution—instead of the focal point of the institution—the stage is set to continue the war. Not only that, but disturbing questions about educational equity can arise from such a practice.

Instead, schools should ensure that the same resources are devoted to online instruction as are devoted to traditional classes. This might result in smaller class sizes, improved technology, and improved instructional materials. All of these will make a big difference in the conflict between traditional and online education.

It is true that universities must be prepared for the edtech of the future. This might involve the kind of fundamental rethinking of the structure of a university that has not happened in hundreds of years. But it should result in the end of the war between traditional and online learning—and that will only benefit students and the wider community.