Uncategorized

Pass or Fail: The Importance of Early Intervention

In this multi-part series, I provide a dissection of the phenomenon of retention and social promotion. Also, I describe the many different methods that would improve student instruction in classrooms and eliminate the need for retention and social promotion if combined effectively.

While reading this series, periodically ask yourself this question: Why are educators, parents and the American public complicit in a practice that does demonstrable harm to children and the competitive future of the country?

How important do you feel early intervention programs are? Should more resources be put toward these types of programs, focused on reaching children with delays or disabilities, before they begin their academic careers?

Pre-School Intervention

The importance of early intervention has to do with the relationship between academic success and the ability to function – behaviorally, emotionally, socially, physically, and intellectually – in one’s environment.

It is well documented that students can experience disruption to their learning as a result of behavioral issues and lack of skill in key learning domains. In other words, they may struggle academically because they can’t function well in their environment. This is especially true for young children entering school for the first time. In the areas of language, early literacy, mathematics, socialization, and self-care, young children may experience delays that cause them to lag behind in their studies. For children with diagnosed disabilities, including the now astonishing number of students with autism spectrum disorder, the supports of early intervention help to prevent additional developmental difficulties and make existing development conditions better.

Early Intervention Benefits

Beyond this, there are also the positive and direct aims of early intervention, which include the promotion of early learning opportunities and the enhancement of basic knowledge and skills for students. Early intervention strategies, according to available research efforts, support these positive aims. A significant amount of research confirms the success of all types of early intervention programs. As a result of their successes, early intervention programs of various types are widely accepted as having both a preventative and a positive impact on child development, with particular emphasis on the management of special needs and promotion of school-readiness.

Other specific benefits of early intervention programs include fewer referrals to special-education services in schools. At least one major study suggests that there are gains in developmental outcomes for all children in inclusive early childhood settings. The success of early intervention is not unqualified, though. With most programs, obvious challenges exist with intervention implementation and effectiveness.

The Key to Success

There are two keys to unlocking intervention strategy success. First, the support programs depend on identifying children early on who need extra help. Second, they depend on providing some ways for students to receive that necessary support. There is growing evidence that intervention programs can prevent problems from occurring in later grades.

The importance of identifying issues early on is logical. The earlier a challenge is identified, especially with regard to development and its relationship to learning, the faster it can be resolved. By establishing any academic issues related to the delay, problems can be addressed, or even prevented.

Most developmental issues have a direct impact on learning. The importance of early intervention is simply that it can decrease certain problems, limiting academic delays caused by the developmental issue. Indeed, this is one of the reasons why early intervention from birth to three years, and even between three and five, is so crucial.

Most children do not enter a formal school setting until around the age of five or six. This depends on a variety of factors, but primarily on calendar age and maturity. A child who receives intervention to address delays before he or she enters formal schooling, is far more likely to succeed academically than a child who does not receive such interventions. Unfortunately, interventions introduced later in a child’s school career, when he or she is already struggling, have limited impact.

Do you feel most parents are aware of the importance of early intervention? Are enough resources available to parents of pre-school aged children, regarding developmental delays, assessments and early intervention?

Pass or Fail: The Importance of Early Intervention Programs

In this multi-part series, I provide a dissection of the phenomenon of retention and social promotion. Also, I describe the many different methods that would improve student instruction in classrooms and eliminate the need for retention and social promotion if combined effectively.

While reading this series, periodically ask yourself this question: Why are educators, parents and the American public complicit in a practice that does demonstrable harm to children and the competitive future of the country?

If a child is behind developmentally, do you feel our current early intervention programs do enough to get them “up to speed” prior to entering school?

The importance of early intervention cannot be emphasized enough. Young minds are constantly learning new behavioral, emotional, physical and social skills. When the ability to function appropriately in one or more areas is hindered, challenges in other areas often follow. How the child interacts with their environment will have a direct impact on their academic success. Early intervention seeks to address developmental delays and disabilities before a child begins school, as a step toward advanced preparedness.

School Supports

In some cases, delays and disabilities are not identified until a child is of school age. In this case, the primary objectives for intervention in a school-based setting would be twofold. The child would require assistance to address their diagnosed delay. They would also need to maintain an appropriate standard of academic performance and help keeping up with peers. Any knowledge that had been lost in the time between the developmental issue becoming apparent, and the point at which it was actually addressed, should be focused on with appropriate interventions.

Due to the natural logistics of the system, there is often at least a sixty-day window before adequate data can be collected about the needs of a student. Sufficient information is needed for school teams to create Individualized Education Plans. Data collection is the general purpose of the 504 document that serves as a monitor for a child’s academic progress and general developmental growth.

Early Childhood Intervention

Early intervention should be considered together with the system’s objectives. From birth to pre-kindergarten-aged children, those objectives are to develop IFSPs or IEPs that target the development of positive socio-emotional skills, the ability to apply appropriate behaviors to meet needs, and the development of skills related to knowledge and skills acquisition.

For children birth to pre-K, knowledge and skills in the general areas of early language development and communication are emphasized. Language and communication skills serve as a foundation for more advanced developmental learning. Other proficiencies targeted for children in this age range include problem-solving skills, basic number concepts, and basic reasoning skills.

Intervention Goals

In child-centered terms, the goal of early intervention is to ensure that children entering school have the necessary skills to succeed academically: to meet the demands of the classroom learning experience, as well as the specific demands related to knowledge and skills acquisition. Students are often retained because they have failed to master some level of knowledge or certain skills, especially with regard to basic literacy. If early intervention helps to reduce the number of students who are retained, its use is justified. Early intervention is a crucial tool for the development of literacy and communication skills. Intervention also focuses on development of appropriate socio-emotional and behavioral skills, all of which have an important, if indirect, impact upon educational experience.

Indeed, early intervention does what the No Child Left Behind Act cannot do: it does what is necessary so that no child is left behind. Whereas NCLB demands that schools demonstrate that students are learning, early intervention serves to transfer skills to students to ensure that they can learn, identifying those students who have not developed particular skills, or who are likely to need assistance in developing specific skills.

Early intervention also removes ideas of student accountability, at least insofar as it is applied to students before they enter school, when learning is very much a natural process, undertaken in the natural environment, most notably, in the home. From the perspective of early intervention, the fact that certain children do not develop certain skills or acquire certain knowledge is not necessarily the fault of the child or their environment. It may be that fundamental developmental processes and various foundational skills must be developed before a higher level of learning is possible.

Do you feel our current early intervention programs are truly effective at preparing children with developmental delays or disabilities for elementary school life? What changes to intervention programing would you make to illicit more successful outcomes?

Pass or Fail: Thoughts on Intervening Early and Often

In this multi-part series, I provide a dissection of the phenomenon of retention and social promotion. Also, I describe the many different methods that would improve student instruction in classrooms and eliminate the need for retention and social promotion if combined effectively.

While reading this series, periodically ask yourself this question: Why are educators, parents and the American public complicit in a practice that does demonstrable harm to children and the competitive future of the country?

How challenging do you imagine it is to create a program inclusive of early intervention and special-education supports?

Reconciling the different needs of special education children with “normal” or “gifted” students is sometimes inflammatory. “Special education” has acquired the status of a stigma because of fears and misunderstandings of education and its possibilities.

The efforts to standardize education and students, have not created a culture of acceptance for those who learn differently or who have specific disabilities that impact their learning. Thus, one of the major benefits of a multiage, student-centered learning model for public education is the possibility that all students, whatever their intellectual assets or liabilities, can be helped to reach their full potential. The objective is that students learn within a common classroom, and ultimately, are molded into caring human beings for a productive life.

Inclusive Classrooms

Inclusion, all students in a common classroom, would be that much easier in a multiage learning environment, and for precisely the same reasons that multiage classrooms benefit children and teachers with a background of traditional schooling. In a multi-age learning environment, there is less anxiety associated with the school experience because both student and teacher know they have the opportunity to develop meaningful, durable relationships. At the same time, teachers know that they will have the time and opportunity to learn the requirements of their special needs students.

Research has overwhelmingly supported the notion that early intervention – and the earlier, the better – is the key to helping exceptional students achieve school-readiness and strategies for success. The early intervention model proposed here not only embraces that principle but seeks to celebrate it as a focus of collaboration between those responsible for the early interventions (preschool-age interventions) and the schools, which take charge as a child transitions to school-age programming.

Collaborative Efforts

Promoting collaboration as well as early and frequent interventions is a strategy that builds community support for education, and for public education specifically. It seeks to emphasize the need for supports across all settings and the benefits for that comprehensive support model. The strategy eliminates the need for children to be segregated based on special needs. Rather, the only streaming that should be practiced would be based on academic abilities and learning preferences. Schools could easily support the streaming of groups with certain abilities without targeting students with special needs.

Student-Centered Focus

A student-centered focus allows for a flexible and ethically sound approach to supporting students with exceptional needs, whatever they may be. While it is well established in law, for instance, that there can be no discrimination against students based on a variety of factors, including age, family background, disability, and economic status, the reality is that there is at least indirect discrimination within our education system. School-district funding is highly competitive, and there are certain districts around the country that essentially act without regard for the best interests of students or higher principles of equality established by law.

In the current system, the “politics” of public education can be detrimental to the needs of exceptional students, and very often is. The problem is largely the result of the emphasis on test-taking and on increased levels of support for schools that test well. Of course, supporting students to produce exceptional results in standardized tests is not the domain of specialized instruction. The realm of that educational model is to support students to ensure that they can obtain an education – free, appropriate, and minimally restricted.

The proposed model of frequent and intensive interventions, especially in the early years, allows for a focus on quality education beyond such false parameters as tests. The emphasis can be placed on skills for learning, rather than static knowledge. This allows that students may learn best throughout their careers if they are supported in the development of solid reasoning skills, critical thinking skills, and a range of fundamental skills that relate to actual function within the school environment.

Can you imagine if the proposed model of intensive interventions were the norm for American children? How much better off would our education system be if we were able to effectively address delays and disabilities prior to children entering elementary school?

Pass or Fail: Intervention Approach Alternatives

In this multi-part series, I provide a dissection of the phenomenon of retention and social promotion. Also, I describe the many different methods that would improve student instruction in classrooms and eliminate the need for retention and social promotion if combined effectively.

While reading this series, periodically ask yourself this question: Why are educators, parents and the American public complicit in a practice that does demonstrable harm to children and the competitive future of the country?

How can early intervention programs and school supports increase attentiveness and participation among children?

Just as regular school programs should seek to engage students in regards to their interests, early intervention programs and school-based support systems should, as well. As has often been pointed out, the most effective teachers are those who develop learning environments and relationships that promote the cultivation of individual passions.

MATCH

MATCH is an early intervention program based in Boston, MA, that seeks to give students the tools they need to get into college. Almost all the students in the program are minorities, most are from families below the poverty line, and the vast majority with deficiencies in reading and math. Principal Jorge Miranda says that the school uses rigid discipline and a hefty set of rules to keep students in line. The day begins before 8:00am and ends at 5:00pm. Signs posted around the school regulate everything, the dress code, unexcused absences, tardiness, and poor posture in class, to name a few.

Classes are small at MATCH, a key feature of schools that implement early intervention effectively. Another important element is the one-on-one tutoring for students who specifically request it. The MATCH Corps tutors receive a small stipend that is partially funded through AmeriCorps when they make a one-year tutoring commitment.

Intervention Impact

Though adjusting to the school can be difficult, it has worked for an overwhelming number of students. The program not only turns students’ lives around, it also turns them into stellar scholars. In fact, the school had the highest scores in math on the state standardized test, and many students had scores high enough to obtain free tuition at any state university in Massachusetts. All of the graduates of its first four graduating classes were accepted into four-year universities.

Early intervention programs and school-based programs must align to promote the interests of all students and foster this kind of student-centered learning model in special-learning programs. In particular, if students and specialist staff have the benefit of working within a relatively stable environment, one that does not involve a child transitioning to a new classroom every academic year, then the opportunities for the development of a child-centered learning model and child-centered support systems are endless.

Collaborative Environments

Schools and early-intervention organizations can likely manage the costs of providing special-education supports by enhancing the efficiency of those supports delivered in the early years. However, they must work together countrywide toward the achievement of equal-opportunity, student-centered learning models. With parameters in place and clear guidelines for child-centered supports, schools, and early intervention programs can work together to go beyond budgetary considerations.

If early intervention programs and schools are able to work collaboratively, then the needs of the individual students and their families may be better served. Indeed, some responsibility to remove negative views of early intervention and special-education support must fall on schools and early intervention units. These groups are ultimately responsible for supporting students at either end of the academic spectrum, gifted students and those with learning disabilities.

Inclusive Learning Model

There are ethical considerations regarding the integration of exceptional students in traditional classrooms. The legal requirement to provide a free and appropriate education to all students in the least restricted environment is frequently extended to children with special needs. In turn, this mandate implies that integration or “push-in supports” in a traditional classroom produce higher levels of learning than models that remove students with special needs to separate classrooms where they are taught “life skills.”

While not every student will benefit from an inclusive education, the vast majority will. There is a need for promoting the idea that inclusion is the preferred model for learning. Early intervention programs and schools must work toward this by collaboratively promoting parent education. Supporting programs related to the delivery of special-education services in inclusive environments is key. Opportunities for training teachers and establishing regularly integrated supports for students with special needs are more easily and efficiently implemented in schools that de-emphasize standardized testing and graded learning.

Just as you might connect with a person who has common interests, so may a child to educational strategies designed to appeal to them uniquely. Can you picture a program in which all students are involved, engaged and participation is sky-high? How can we begin to alter our current system so that we are taking steps toward the aforementioned setting?

Pass or Fail: Early Intervention Supports and Strategies

In this multi-part series, I provide a dissection of the phenomenon of retention and social promotion. Also, I describe the many different methods that would improve student instruction in classrooms and eliminate the need for retention and social promotion if combined effectively.

While reading this series, periodically ask yourself this question: Why are educators, parents and the American public complicit in a practice that does demonstrable harm to children and the competitive future of the country?

How is it determined that a child struggles in a particular area? How can teachers and therapists develop the most effective intervention plans possible? The answer lies with the use of diagnostic tools for data collection and analysis.

To develop an effective early intervention model based on supports and strategies, two distinct elements are necessary. First, early intervention depends on diagnostic procedures, which rest on clear strategies. Second, the system also hinges on distinct rules for selecting and implementing supports and strategies, in light of student needs and diagnostic findings.

Functional Behavioral Analysis

Several investigative tools have been developed to assist early intervention. For students demonstrating emotional, social, and behavioral delays and dysfunctions, one of the most important diagnostic tools is the functional behavioral analysis (FBA). As researchers, Robin Hojnoski and Brenna Wood point out, educators are increasingly aware of the connection between the social behaviors of children and early academic skills.

In particular, research has consistently shown that young children who demonstrate challenging behavior may experience disruption to their learning. Negative conduct may interfere with opportunities to learn and effectively interact with peers in classroom situations. Research also recognizes that certain classroom activities, particularly structured activities, place high demands on children who already struggle with behavioral challenges. Investigative studies show that children may engage in challenging behavior as a means of avoiding demands placed upon them.

As a tool, an FBA is a direct and indirect procedure for collecting data related to problem behaviors. Direct data collection methods include classroom observations, while indirect methods of assessment include interviews with parents and teachers and the use of rating scales to assess actions. The subsequent analysis of such data identifies behavioral triggers and their antecedents, the reasons why the behaviors occur, and the functions and consequences of the behavior.

Tools for Data Analysis

Beyond FBA, other diagnostic tools also make use of observation. Occupational therapists will, for example, generally observe students to identify the daily tasks with which children have difficulty. Some diagnostic tools, such as questionnaires, may also be used for occupational therapy assessment, as well as language and behavioral evaluation. Parent participation and preschool involvement may be important in the use of such tools. However, the best observations and data tend to be collected from individual students in a classroom context, subjected to the academic, social, emotional, and general behavioral demands of the classroom environment. Even self-care and language skills can be better assessed in a classroom than in the home or community, and early intervention acts on this knowledge.

Drawbacks of Diagnostic Tools

Despite the strengths of existing diagnostic tools, they still have their weaknesses. For instance, many school districts administer FBAs indirectly, rather than directly. When FBAs are administered indirectly, they concentrate not on direct observations of children in classrooms, but indirect observations. Indirect observations tend to lack multiple elements that, in regular assessment procedures, would include efforts to gather information about instructional variables and early academic skill development.

Criticism of FBAs conducted within early education settings is that the same interview form is used by parents and teachers for students spanning a wide range of ages, with only a few modifications made for different age groups. The actual developmental differences, and therefore the questionnaires themselves, do not allow parents and teachers to accurately describe specific behaviors in sufficient detail to definitively assess developmental appropriateness.

In their assessment of FBA tools, Hojnoski and Wood note that the two interview forms, the forms used for elementary school and the form used for older children, include two general questions to identify areas where skills are lacking. There is, however, little effort to gather data to identify areas of concern related to the development of academic skills relevant to early-childhood and elementary education.

Assessment Goals

For diagnostic procedures to be effective, a variety of tools should be used, and these tools should reflect age-appropriate analytics for language, social and behavioral interactions. Early intervention might benefit from specifically targeting the problems that most commonly cause academic delays and disruptions in the classroom. With this information in hand, it could be useful to focus on identifying, or otherwise developing, age-appropriate tools to test skills and knowledge. Perhaps even developing a means to identify those students who are most at risk of deficits within certain areas. The goal of early intervention should not be to simply stop or reverse academic delays, but as much as possible, to prevent them entirely.

Are you familiar with the use of diagnostic testing from an early intervention perspective? Would you alter how the evaluation tools are currently being utilized?

Pass or Fail: Early Intervention Resources

In this multi-part series, I provide a dissection of the phenomenon of retention and social promotion. Also, I describe the many different methods that would improve student instruction in classrooms and eliminate the need for retention and social promotion if combined effectively.

While reading this series, periodically ask yourself this question: Why are educators, parents and the American public complicit in a practice that does demonstrable harm to children and the competitive future of the country?

With early intervention and school-based program resources being scarce, how should service type and delivery be determined?

Intervention Service Delivery

The number of early intervention issues addressed requires the use of a corresponding number of supports and strategies to meet those needs. Several types of professionals, some of them educational specialists, are also employed by early intervention units and by school districts to offer supports. For instance, special educators and itinerant teachers may work alongside speech pathologists and occupational therapists, to name a few.

For early interventions to be effective, there is considerable need for quality service delivery, and service standards should be put in place. The issue of establishing superior services for early intervention supports and strategies has received much attention. One study considered the work of occupational therapists with regard to early interventions and outlined some of the ways in which OT can be most effectively applied.

Another study showed that family-centered and routine-based service delivery was effective in early interventions, but the best approach consisted of a combination of delivery models. Push-in models and pull-out models within school settings can be appropriate for both occupational therapy support and service deliveries. One of the deciding factors, however, is the integration of particular supports within the natural environment, as well as the transfer of specific skills to students, their family members, and other educators and community members. These skills provide the means of facilitating a smooth school transition and long-term academic success.

Early Intervention in the U.S.

The U.S. early intervention model needs to have greater consistency in its supports and strategies. In particular, there is a high variation among school districts and regions regarding resources made available to students based on need. The United States desperately needs national guidelines with regard to levels of support and methods of delivery for students who qualify for early intervention services. There should be some effort to scale need against resources. Identifying students, in all regions, who have the highest level of need, and coordinating supports to ensure those students with the most substantial needs are receiving services accordingly. A related necessity is the development of measures that ensure the proper resources are provided to individual students with specific developmental issues.

The Future of Early Interventions

The interventions need to be able to address behavior, language and communication, emotions, physical conditions, social interactions, and self-care supports, if the needs of all students are to be met. An examination beyond purely academic elements must be made. A child with an autism diagnosis, for instance, and thus a social communication disorder, may not be deemed to have social and communication issues that significantly impact his or her learning. However, based on the usual arc of the disorder, it is probable that such a child will develop academically or educationally significant issues as he or she matures. This occurs as the demands for communication, and socialization increase as the child’s fellow students mature.

A different type of “grading” or “social promotion” policy will emerge if early intervention and school-based supports do not look beyond the immediate situation. Programs must address the outcomes that can, over time, undermine a child’s academic development. Thus, providing social and communication supports in school or early learning environments, in the natural setting where social and communication demands exist, will be an investment in the long-term success of the child.

Would changing the landscape of early interventions and school supports help to cut back on problems associated with retention and social promotion?

 

 

Two Creative Ways to Engage English Language Learners

Educators share their strategies for teaching academically challenging (and fun) lessons that support native and non-native English speakers.

By Karyn Lewis and Yvette Ramirez

Transitions can be challenging for any student, whether that is moving from elementary to middle school, or moving to an entirely new school district. For English language learners (ELLs) the challenges are even greater. Not only do these students have to learn how to speak, read, and write a new language, they have to adjust to a new culture, all while keeping up academically with native English speakers. The challenge for these two educators, whose classrooms include native and non-native English speakers, is to make sure their lessons are academically challenging, while also teaching these lessons in a way that provides extra support for ELLs. Here’s how they do it.

Karyn Lewis: Music, Dance, and Movement

When working with toddlers during a weekly story time I held for the community at my school library, I often came across barriers such as language and cultural differences. Many of these children were shy ELLs. It was then that I discovered the magic of music to bridge the language gap. The songs I played would instantly perk these kids up and get their attention. Students are naturally motivated by music, so we couldn’t help but sing, clap, and dance along to the many books we read together.

When putting together a summer school lesson plan for my pre-K ELLs, I turned to the Cantata Learning books, which include songs and rhymes that make reading fun and easy for a wide variety of students. There are many great books about science and history concepts, including famous scientists, the water cycle, and the planets. I used the books with my pre-K and kindergarten ELLs once a week to work on building vocabulary and a love of books.

Through the songs, pictures, and movements, the students were quickly able to make connections to the content in each book, which helped them learn and remember the words at an accelerated rate. The more engaged students can be during the reading of the book and song, the better, so we would often stand up, dance, and make up motions for the songs together. This process involves several of the learning modalities (audio, visual, and kinesthetic) and therefore helps students have multiple ways to access the information later.

I particularly remember the book “Head, Shoulders, Knees, and Toes” being especially engaging for the students, and a lesson the teachers also enjoyed. I started the lesson by telling students we were going to learn a new song to help us remember the words for different parts of our body. They pointed to their head, shoulders, knees, and toes (with the help of their teacher assisting in Spanish, if needed).

As I played the song, the students stood up and followed the directions in the song to touch the different parts of their body, mirroring my movements. When the song finished, we listened to it one more time. This time, the students were singing the new words and confidently pointing to the body parts as the song played. At the end of the lesson I asked them to find many of the new parts of their body mentioned in the book, and they were able to find them and point to them easily.

This sort of activity has helped my students build academic vocabulary in an engaging and non-threatening way. The music and rhymes make learning fun for the ELL students. Students loved them so much that they often requested to play the songs again and again.

Yvette Ramirez: Project-Based Learning and Cultural Variety

I teach English as a second language (ESOL) at Hunter’s Creek Middle School in Orlando, FL, where we have 165 students in the ESOL program. These children speak 32 different languages, and are gaining confidence and language skills using STEM and project-based learning (PBL).

A common approach to teaching ESOL students is to pair a student with stronger language skills with a struggling student. PBL facilitates this kind of collaborative learning, and gives students an opportunity to dive deep into a topic and really spend time with it. They also get to practice their language skills in a variety of ways, including listening to and watching videos, reading articles, and writing their own content.

To implement PBL in my STEM lessons, I use Defined STEM, a K-12 resource that provides educators with hundreds of engaging, relevant, cross-curricular PBL tasks. Defined STEM allows students to access the lesson directions and rubrics in many different languages; all of the articles, videos, and other supporting content are in English. The format makes students feel more comfortable when engaging in a project because they read the directions in their own languages, but must use their English skills to actually complete the assignments.

Last year, my students engaged in a performance task focused on culinary art and sustainability. The goal of the project was for students to create their own farm-to-table restaurant, including deciding where to locate the restaurant geographically, what to farm, how to farm, and ultimately what the menu would be. Students used provided resources to research healthy recipes, figure out what kind of gardens they needed, and decide where in the country they needed their gardens to grow.

The project culminated in students presenting their findings through commercials and TV interviews they created to showcase their unique farm-to-table concepts. The ESOL students have influences from around the world, which shined through in their menu and food choices. While the project helped them build their English skills and gain knowledge about American culture and geography, the students were able to incorporate a bit of home, too.

Karyn Lewis is a pre-K–5 librarian at Meadow Wood Elementary in Houston, Texas.

Yvette Ramirez is the ESOL teacher at Hunter’s Creek Middle School in Orlando, FL.

Revolutionary Teaching Projects Recognized by IMS Global Learning Consortium

A California school district is using a revolutionary writing improvement technology in a revolutionary new way – teaching teachers instead of grading students – an approach that may score the district coveted recognition from the IMS Global Learning Consortium Learning Impact Awards for creative applications of education technology.

According to the IMS, the award sponsors, the prestigious recognitions are intended to, “recognize outstanding, innovative applications of educational technology to address the most significant challenges facing education.”

And what the Newport-Mesa Unified School District is doing with Turnitin Revision Assistant applies. Even though Revision Assistant was designed to provide real-time feedback on student writing, which it does, the Newport-Mesa district is also using it help teachers score writing assignments more consistently across the district grading rubric.

Based on the district’s award submission materials, the results appear impressive. “The benchmark scoring process became much more efficient in time and cost,” the paper reported. And, it continued, when “applied in training,” Revision Assistant, “greatly increased confidence that teachers were using and understanding their rubrics.”

“We’ve been delighted to help Newport-Mesa pioneer new applications for our technology,” said Sean Tupa, education program director at Turnitin. “And it’s been very exciting to see how our systems are being creatively used to improve the work of both teachers and students. It’s a trend that we hope will continue and expand.”

Learnosity is also an award finalist in a different category for their assessment APIs – Application Programming Interfaces. According to their award documents, Learnosity, “enables any organization to quickly and easily incorporate interactive question types along with authoring, reporting and analytical capabilities into any digital product, whether new or existing.”

“Obviously it’d be a massive honour for us to win it,” Learnosity CEO Gavin Cooney said of the IMS award in a company press release announcing their selection.

Newport-Mesa/Revision Assistant and Learnosity are two of 38 organizations and projects in 13 education categories to be designated as finalists for the IMS Global Learning Consortium Learning Impact Awards. The 38 are:

  • CTU Mobile by Colorado Technical University
  • Hawkes Learning Partners with the University of Louisville on an Emporium Approach to Intervention Courses in Algebra
  • InQuizitive use at State College of Florida
  • Connect2 Open Learning Platform for Higher Education–International
  • MyInternshipBuddy@WORK at Republic Poly
  • IBM’s Open Badging Program
  • Development and Verification of an e-Learning System that Augments Interest and Inner Motives
  • Learnosity Assessment APIs
  • org–A New Learning Ecosystem and Portal for Personalized Competency-Based Education
  • Follett Discover Suite of Products to Support Academic Success
  • Building an Ecosystem Using IMS Standards
  • OpenSALT
  • The IMDA Singapore PlayMaker Programme: Unleashing Creative Confidence in Children through Play and Maker-Centred Learning
  • FLVS Playbook
  • Robots for Early Childhood Education
  • Texas Gateway CMDS
  • KANTAN (Easy) cloud-based e-learning authoring and delivery service
  • M2B System for Data-Driven Education and Learning-Learning Analytics Center
  • Texas OnCourse CBE Micro-credential System
  • Behavioral Analytics Driving Student Outcomes
  • Nebula: A New Design For Canvas Discussion Boards
  • Info-communications Media Development Authority (IMDA) Lab on Wheels
  • LIVE (Learning Immersion in a Virtual Environment) Effectively Reaches Global Audience and Measures Engagement
  • Bluepulse 2 – Integrated
  • HISD’s Analytics for Education (A4E) Dashboards and PowerUser Reporting Environment (PWR)
  • Pilot on IoT@Schools – Promote Inquiry-based Learning with Real-World Data
  • Transforming learning at scale: How Saint Leo University unified its learning ecosystem for better results
  • LMS Dynamic LTI Handler
  • LMS LTI Integration with Adobe Connect Virtual Classroom Platform
  • Scope by Purdue: A lesson in using the Caliper Specification
  • Integrated Learning Analytics for Video using LTI and Caliper
  • Penn State Digital Badging Platform
  • Nudging Student Success with UMBC’s Check My Activity (CMA) LMS Feedback Tool
  • College for America at SNHU: Degree Programs that Work for Working Adults
  • Universal Design Online Content Inspection Tool (UDOIT)
  • Norming student essays using Turnitin Revision Assistant to inform instruction at Newport-Mesa USD
  • PowerUp: Taking Technology Integration to the Next Level in K-12
  • Access Manager

All finalists have been invited to present their materials and outcomes during the  2017 Learning Impact Leadership Institute in Denver, Colorado, May 16-19 and public voting on the projects is open until May 17. Winners will be announced May 18.

Disclosure: This preceding post was sponsored. We were compensated by the sponsoring company, and consider this to be an advertisement. However, we only endorse or recommend services or products that we think would be a good fit for our readership. We are disclosing this in accordance with the Federal Trade Commission’s 16 CFR, Part 255: “Guides Concerning the Use of Endorsements and Testimonials in Advertising.”

 

 

Pass or Fail: Mixing Ages to Accommodate Developmental Differences

In this multi-part series, I provide a dissection of the phenomenon of retention and social promotion. Also, I describe the many different methods that would improve student instruction in classrooms and eliminate the need for retention and social promotion if combined effectively.

While reading this series, periodically ask yourself this question: Why are educators, parents and the American public complicit in a practice that does demonstrable harm to children and the competitive future of the country?

Promoting or holding back students based on age alone is not a helpful to the student — or our overall student population. If age were taken away as a factor in retention and social promotion, what would our classrooms look like?

Multi-age or mixed-aged classrooms offer an alternative to graded classrooms and are a key part of the redesigned schools we talked about in the previous chapter. To create these classrooms, schools will need to change not only the structure of the curriculum and application models but also the management of classrooms and the use of teaching strategies.

Multi-age classrooms group schoolchildren who differ in age by two or more years into the same classroom. The goal of this grouping is to make the best use of the educational potential inherent in such a mixture of ages.

Multi-age classrooms are nothing new. For much of the history of the American education system, in fact, multi-age classrooms were the norm. The one-room schoolhouse is a classic example.

Definitions of multi-age classrooms have, however, been quite fluid. Before the common school reforms of the 1830s and 1840s, the multi-age classroom was considered to be a single classroom in which all students within a school, no matter what their age, studied as separate grades or subject groups. The historical multi-age model did involve whole-group teaching some of the time, but administrative or economic reasons were often behind this particular use of the classroom.

The graded, curriculum-centered approach to classroom organization, as outlined in Chapter One, become the standard in the United States toward the end of the 19th century, after its introduction in the mid-19th century. Its rise was triggered largely by the nation’s rapid economic development and massive waves of immigration.

In fairness, there were some genuine education-centered efforts to reform the public education system. These efforts attempted to create child-centered education models that reflected developmental variability and made use of teaching environments that were more social and congenial.

Although the multi-age approach has received some modest support from educational innovation in the past, more recent developments have provided unequivocal support for multi-age education.

Should we be looking at eliminating age-based retention and social promotion completely?

Pass or Fail: Multi-Age Classroom Program Models

In this multi-part series, I provide a dissection of the phenomenon of retention and social promotion. Also, I describe the many different methods that would improve student instruction in classrooms and eliminate the need for retention and social promotion if combined effectively.

While reading this series, periodically ask yourself this question: Why are educators, parents and the American public complicit in a practice that does demonstrable harm to children and the competitive future of the country?

Should our public school classrooms accommodate more than one or two ages together? Would multi-age classrooms benefit all students?

The Kentucky Education Reform Act of 1990 (KERA, House Bill 940) sought to implement multi-age classrooms in public schools across the state of Kentucky. The details of the act made it more than a revision, however. In fact, it radically altered the financing of education in the state, but went further than financial reformation to establish key changes to curriculum and governance.

Significant changes to the curriculum outlined in the KERA targeted the reconstruction of primary schools, especially kindergarten to third grade. Standardized testing was to be implemented throughout the state. At the same time, though, the KERA recommended ending kindergarten to third grade and replacing them with a “primary school program” that would include “multi-age and multi-ability classrooms,” eliminating or at least reducing the separation of students by grade.

In line with the different demands of a multi-age and multi-ability classroom, the KERA also outlined new and expanded requirements for curriculum content and assessment. In particular, the act outlined the need for a “performance-based” approach, with students creating a portfolio of writing and mathematics work in the fourth grade (writing only), eighth grade, and twelfth grade. Qualitative assessments, including written reports assessing students’ performance, were to replace the traditional letter-grade system.

Although these are not necessarily the precise elements that should be part of the multi-age classroom, they point to the changes that must emerge. In fact, the KERA ultimately established a statewide, ungraded program for elementary-school-aged children, the goal being to emphasize the delivery of multi-age and multi-ability experiences. The change was implemented in 1990, and modified in 1996 to allow schools greater freedom to structure programs. Further legislation passed in 1992 outlined specific attributes to be included in each primary program. The seven elements were (1) developmentally appropriate educational practices, (2) multi-age and multi-ability classrooms, (3) continuous progress, (4) authentic assessment, (5) qualitative reporting methods, (6) professional teamwork, and (7) positive parent involvement.

The KERA established regional service centers in 1992, including a primary program consultant to offer professional development for school district personnel (a support service discontinued in 2003 due to a lack of funding and support).

According to the Kentucky Demographic Survey of the Primary Program used to evaluate the primary program between 2001 and 2007, the multi-age program did improve the academic performance of students. It also increased teacher preparation time before classes and offered various types of assessments, improving parents’ involvement in the education of children.

Kentucky was not the only state to start using a multi-age program. In 1994, the Michigan State Board of Education announced that it was going to establish non-graded contin­uous-progress programs for students in multi-age classrooms. Multi-age classrooms were very successful in Michigan for a period beginning in 1995, when the state’s department of education estimated that one in five districts was implementing multi-age settings.

Within three years, by 1998, more than half of Michigan’s school districts had begun or were expanding their multi-age models. The approach was dropped in 1999, however, because funding was stopped. The following year, the Michigan Department of Education would also stop the initiative and support for multi-age grouping, despite evidence that the approach helped students make progress. The key reason for the discontinuation, according to the state board of education, was the incompatibility of multi-age classrooms with the grade-level content and annual testing.

Recent years have seen a discontinuation of multi-age programs in those states where they were implemented, mostly due to the grade-level standards and test requirements established by the No Child Left Behind Act. This is ironic, as states were also subjected to accountability laws.

On the flip side, of course, schools and educators with experience in the multi-age classroom have found that they want to embrace the multi-age philosophy. Some schools continue to use the multi-age classroom as alternative learning environments for students. Other states have gone about using these classrooms school-wide as an internal, school-specific policy, primarily because of the obvious benefits.