Uncategorized

Pass or Fail: Multi-Age Classroom Development Recommendations

In this multi-part series, I provide a dissection of the phenomenon of retention and social promotion. Also, I describe the many different methods that would improve student instruction in classrooms and eliminate the need for retention and social promotion if combined effectively.

While reading this series, periodically ask yourself this question: Why are educators, parents and the American public complicit in a practice that does demonstrable harm to children and the competitive future of the country?

How can the contemporary pass-fail classroom setup transition to one that accommodates different ages and ability levels?

Paula Carter teaches in a multi-age classroom at Rita Cannan Elementary School in Reno, Nevada. Many of the students’ parents are involved in the low-income unskilled jobs associated with the gambling industry. Seventy percent speak a language other than English at home, and 88 percent qualify for free or reduced-price school lunches. Because of the nature of the work in the city, the transience rate is close to 50 percent. To counter this, Rita Cannan Elementary requests that parents keep their children in the school for at least three consecutive years.

Carter’s classroom incorporates first-, second-, and third-grade students. When asked why the school does this, she responds: “I can’t think of a good reason not to,” and goes on to say that “multi-age grouping builds strong relationships among teachers, students, and families.” Carter had experienced a model multi-age classroom in her university training at the University of Nevada-Reno, and always knew it was something she wanted to try.

“Older students bring new students into the fold by showing them how the classroom works,” she says. “We hear them coaching the younger children: ‘Try it again! Don’t forget to use your strategies. Get your mouth ready to say the word.’ We also hear them comforting students: ‘That’s OK. You’ll do better next time. An 80 percent isn’t a bad grade.”

One ingredient that makes Carter’s classroom a success is the fact that she team teaches with Theresa Crowley, who speaks fluent Spanish. This assists not only in communicating with the students, but also with the parents, many of whom speak no English at all. Initially, Carter and Crowley spent much of their time in planning. However, as their relationship has grown, it has changed and deepened. Carter says: “Now we see ourselves as observers of children, looking at what has transpired in the classroom and what needs to occur to support each student every day.”

Some outsiders question whether it is possible to implement a multi-age classroom. Students from first grade, they say, will have different abilities than students in third grade. However, Carter notes that student abilities differ widely even within a single grade. In her classroom, they group students for various tasks and various purposes, noting that she wants the students to feel as though they are a part of a family. The multi-age classroom, in her estimation, works. Recently, she was able to compare students who had spent two years in her classroom with their peers in a single-age classroom. The students in her classroom were more fluent readers, justifying her approach.

The lack of recent academic studies validating the academic benefits of multi-age classrooms, as perceived by teachers and other educators, appears to contribute to the general doubts surrounding the workability of multi-age programming. While many seem ready to accept the philosophies of the multi-age classroom, skepticism about the potential obstacles of switching from the single-age model appears to be something of a stumbling block. This skepticism is at least one reason we are still on a path of standardized testing, grade retention, and social promotion policies, and focus on having students regurgitate knowledge rather than actually learn.

Lauer discusses the research literature on multi-age classrooms and explains how multi-age classrooms operate. She considers the example of a low-performing and predominantly Native American school district as it adopted multi-age classrooms. The adoption of the multi-age model, in this example, is described as a primary reform strategy.

According to Lauer’s summary, several researchers observed thirty-seven classrooms and interviewed principals and district administrators to collect data on implementation of multi-age classrooms. Data was also collected and analyzed from a nearby district for comparison. The chosen district had successful multi-age classrooms.

The study showed that teachers were unhappy that multi-age classrooms were essentially being forced on the school, and that the decision to use multi-age programming was made by district administrators. The findings also showed that teachers tended to feel incompetent and lacking in training and development, as well as materials and resources needed for such classrooms. According to Lauer’s summary, it was also felt by teachers that insufficient time was offered for collaboration and there was little effort to actually prepare the teachers for the switch to multi-age (hence the reported feelings of incompetence and the demand for professional development).

From this one example, we can confirm that it does not work to simply try to enforce multi-age classrooms suddenly. Such a move will be neither popular move nor practical. Aina writes on this matter, outlining how learning may be maximized in early childhood multi-age classrooms to benefit students, teachers, and parents.

 

 

Pass or Fail: Parents’ Role in Multi-Age Classroom Development

In this multi-part series, I provide a dissection of the phenomenon of retention and social promotion. Also, I describe the many different methods that would improve student instruction in classrooms and eliminate the need for retention and social promotion if combined effectively.

While reading this series, periodically ask yourself this question: Why are educators, parents and the American public complicit in a practice that does demonstrable harm to children and the competitive future of the country?

Change within classrooms isn’t best spearheaded by teachers, or administrators, or researchers. Change takes place when parents put their support behind it.

According to some researchers, parents are particularly prone to dissatisfaction and rejection of new models for the education system. They often have concerns for the long-term stability and academic success of their children, and rightly so. Schools should not be an environment in which there is considerable experimentation with standards and procedures.

Yes, teachers and administrators – and even students – should be prepared to experiment a bit to understand what models and approaches work best in a specific situation, but even this level of experimentation is expected to occur within academic standards. The last thing most parents want is to have their child participate in an experimental change in education standards, only to find the experiment a failure.

Many parents are not fully aware of the philosophies of multi-age classrooms, or of the wealth of research supporting them. Many parents have concerns about their children being grouped with other children of different ages and are often worried about the quality of instruction. Such concerns are not unreasonable. As part of the strategy for ending grade retention and social promotion, the teaching profession also needs to be refreshed. Above all, teachers must be given adequate support and professional-development training before they can be expected to be successful at the implementation and integration of a new educational model of any type, and especially one that is entirely different from the one they have been used to.

It is also striking that parents are sometimes not included in the decisions to change direction in education; nor are they necessarily informed. Parents of older students, according to the research, sometimes feel their children may learn less in a multi-age classroom, while parents of younger ones worry that their children might be challenged too intensely. Loss of confidence in learning abilities is also a concern. Again, though, such concerns are usually rational, and can be addressed and lessened with the right supports.

Research has demonstrated that parents who are more involved in school life are usually the ones who prefer to have their children in multi-age classrooms. At the same time, the involvement of parents can produce multi-age classrooms that are full of privileged and wealthy students, with the possibility that the group becomes less diverse, and thus not in keeping with a philosophy of multi-age education programs.

If American classrooms are truly going to change to a more inclusive, supportive place for all students, parents must be open to the shift. This is true with  multi-age philosophies and so many others when it comes to educational outcomes for students.

Pass or Fail: Teacher Preparedness and Multi-Age Classroom Development

In this multi-part series, I provide a dissection of the phenomenon of retention and social promotion. Also, I describe the many different methods that would improve student instruction in classrooms and eliminate the need for retention and social promotion if combined effectively.

While reading this series, periodically ask yourself this question: Why are educators, parents and the American public complicit in a practice that does demonstrable harm to children and the competitive future of the country?

Before classrooms can transition to successful multi-age models, teachers have to be willing and ready.

When it comes to the success of a multi-age classroom model, teacher buy-in is paramount. Teacher preparedness is also an important point that must be addressed in the plans for placing multi-age classrooms in settings where they are new. Many teachers featured in reports on multi-age classrooms say they received little preparation for teaching students of different ages.

Winning teachers over to the educational philosophy of multi-age classrooms is another necessary step for successful implementation. According to one study, eight in ten teachers oppose differentiated instruction. Again, though, adaption of the curriculum to meet the needs of all students in this type of context is difficult. They doubt their own abilities and are unsure of the supports at their disposal to assign groups with different work and to teach the material.

Efficiently creating group work among students of different abilities and age is another area where teachers find themselves struggling. Increased workload is also an issue. Teachers are reported to often accept the arguments in favor of multi-age grouping and appear to be happy to undertake the teaching of multi-age classrooms. Still, some misunderstand the program and do not go about implementing it correctly. Relations between staff members can become strained without the proper supports in place to minimize tensions and make criticisms and challenges constructive.

Since teachers with more extensive training and professional development tend to have the opportunity to teach multi-age classes, the experience gap between those who teach single-graded classes and those who teach multi-age classes can become a problem. That gap is identified as potentially leading to feelings of superiority in multi-age groups. Teachers who are opposed to change can undermine well-meaning multi-age classroom teachers.

Administrators can also struggle with the concept and the management of multi-age classrooms. However, their issues are mainly due to the federal and state accountability laws that require students to take standardized tests by grade level, as already outlined.

Because multi-age classrooms tend to blur the grade level standards and do so deliberately (at least to some degree), it can also be difficult to fairly administer standardized tests. Many principals have reported that it can be difficult to operate two types of structures in one school. But this problem is solvable if graded classrooms are entirely or at least mostly removed, and if the federal and state accountability laws requiring standardized tests are revised to effectively end or reduce that requirement.

Principals have reported that it is challenging because multi-age groups often need special field trips, school schedules, and equipment. There can also be a need, on occasion, for two separate groups for the events, designed for specific grades. All of these considerations create challenges for the school administration and budget management. The takeaway is that multi-age programs do not fit neatly into the traditional organization for schools; they are not designed to. A multi-age program should push a school past its norms to provide the best fit of an education for the students participating, and that will take some upfront and continuing work on the part of teachers and administrators.

Pass or Fail: Obstacles in Multi-age Classroom Development

In this multi-part series, I provide a dissection of the phenomenon of retention and social promotion. Also, I describe the many different methods that would improve student instruction in classrooms and eliminate the need for retention and social promotion if combined effectively.

While reading this series, periodically ask yourself this question: Why are educators, parents and the American public complicit in a practice that does demonstrable harm to children and the competitive future of the country?

In a lot of ways, multi-age classroom options in our schools make a lot of sense, and research backs that up. Like any part of the educational puzzle, however, there are some complications.

Having single-age and multi-age classes in a single school can result in some inequality, according to research. Better teachers, more advantaged students, and other factors that go into a better education can lead to the sense that students in multi-age classrooms are superior to those in single-age classrooms.

On the other hand, some schools tend to use multi-age classrooms as a sort of graveyard for students who are deemed to be falling too far behind. Such students are the same as those who would be impacted by retention or social promotion policies, but using multi-age classrooms for this purpose is not at all consistent with the guiding philosophy. It is hardly surprising, then, that the application of the model in this way can create low self-esteem in affected students.

Because of the above-mentioned factors, the ideal model of multi-age classrooms is not easily implemented and is not aligned with current regulations and policies. This should hardly be surprising. However, even with these various limitations, there are countless reports of the successful application of multi-age classrooms. Schools that operate multi-age classrooms effectively do so by planning ahead, taking the time to properly introduce the program to parents, and ensuring that teachers are educated and have plenty of ongoing professional development.

Although the multi-age classroom is not perfectly aligned with the current policies, many schools have implemented multi-age classrooms. They have also shown rapid progress by doing so in the correct way, ensuring that the multi-age philoso­phy and child-centered approach are central considerations.

Current grade-based academic standards and high-stakes testing are designed to correlate to curriculum-centered instruction, but it is hopeless to apply the same curricula or even to use the same grade-based academic standards and tests to teach or assess a diverse group of students. It is already clear that this grade-based approach and the use of high-stakes testing neglect the needs of many students, including high and low achievers. An alternative curriculum and assessment model is needed. Alternative academic standards are needed, together with a focus on multi-age classrooms. Indeed, the application of multi-age philosophies to classrooms and implementing differentiated teaching strategies allows teachers to meet the needs of all students.

According to the research, certain student demographics reap the greatest benefits from multi-age classrooms. The demographic that benefits most is one that has both disadvantaged students and high-ability students. In other words, the multi-ability element is important in the multi-age classroom, too. Of course, this creates a further problem. There are specific challenges to establishing and managing multi-age programs in high-poverty schools. It is difficult to organize classes to include a sufficiently diverse group of students in terms of ability. Careful planning can lead to success, however.

In particular, a clear benefit of multi-age classrooms is that struggling students can benefit from the resultant learning environment; an environment that is typically caring and supportive of diverse learning. High-ability students also benefit, however, because of the resultant variety and because opportunities are not limited to students who struggle academically. While the various programs for high achievers exist in a vari­ety of forms – and some of the examples mentioned in the research include after-school activities, summer camps, and honor classes – being involved in a diverse population of vari­ous ages is also important. Multi-age classrooms require the considered development of differentiated curric­ula and instructions. They require the development of a curriculum that is specifically designed to meet the needs of all students.

Precisely because of the relatively minimal current research on the outcomes and benefits of education, it is crucial that multi-age classrooms maintain consistency in its objectives and focus on the guiding philosophy of student-centered and project-based learning. Setting aside the mixed research from the mid-1990s, the importance of this is apparent, especially because of the wide range of ways in which multi-age education has been implemented historically.

It has been difficult for researchers to generalize about the academic impact of multi-age education because of the diversity of implementation strategies, and because of the natural shift away from what should be the basic focus and philosophy of the system. When implemented with an awareness of the best practices for management of multi-age classrooms, positive outcomes emerge and students have the opportunity to do well.

Outlining recommendations and requirements for multi-age classrooms, however, it is important to note as well that positive outcomes are not guaranteed. Certainly they are not guaranteed in the absence of appropriate administrative and instructional support, which must be implemented alongside a considered multi-age curriculum and classroom model.

High-quality research must to be done to assess not only the effects of multi-age education in a modern context, essentially updating the research that has already been done, but also to validate, through research and randomized control trial and quasi-experimentation, exactly what are the optimal procedures and policies for multi-age education. Research is needed, in other words, to determine precisely what the best practices for multi-age education ought to be. Research is also needed to determine exactly what type of curriculum would best serve the multi-age classroom environment, and how accountability in terms of academic standards and curriculum might be defined and implemented.

Researchers will also need to look at patterns for teaching language development, reading, and mathematics in multi-age classrooms, outlining what the expectations ought to be and how they ought to be defined. Assessment of the average accelerated gains of students in these areas within the multi-age classroom will also be a requirement. Armed with this information, though, multi-age classrooms have the potential to change outcomes for students in K-12 classrooms for the better.

 

Pass or Fail: Preparing Teachers, Parents and Administrators for Multi-Age Classrooms

In this multi-part series, I provide a dissection of the phenomenon of retention and social promotion. Also, I describe the many different methods that would improve student instruction in classrooms and eliminate the need for retention and social promotion if combined effectively.

While reading this series, periodically ask yourself this question: Why are educators, parents and the American public complicit in a practice that does demonstrable harm to children and the competitive future of the country?

Any large change in K-12 education in America will need backing from teachers and parents.

Both of these stakeholders tend to lack full understanding of the multi-age education, though. Parents often express resistance when faced with the possibility of switching to a multi-age classroom. Teachers also tend to indicate that they have not received adequate training to be confident teaching multi-age groups. The two problems tend to go hand in hand, and parents also worry about the multi-age environment because of the potential issues with instruction quality.

Parent education and teacher education are thus two crucial components of a successful multi-age classroom system, especially one on the scale envisaged here; one that will replace the graded approach and, among other things, remove grade retention and social promotion from the American public-education system.

The processes for parent and teacher education are different, and the focus of the education must likewise be different. Parent educa­tion and teacher preparation are essential but must, to be effective, target the respective groups independently. Parents must be educated about the multi-age classroom and its benefits and challenges from an educational perspective. They must receive information and support to help them understand not only what the benefits and challenges are, but also what the process will be for the implementation of a multi-age classroom.

It is necessary to make sure that parents have the opportunity to be involved in the process of reviewing implementation plans for establishing multi-age classrooms as the standard for education in America’s public schools. Furthermore, the elements of curriculum and teacher training and support should be understood by parents. Parents must be reassured that teachers will be able to meet the needs of all students.

It has been stated that age-balanced classrooms containing students of a similar level cannot be achieved easily if parents do not fully understand and support the philosophy it depends on upon, and this should also be a consideration in the implementation of a multi-age strategy.

Teachers, for their part, must be educated and prepared to manage multi-age classrooms and given intensive support to maintain an appropriate level of professional development over time. It is not enough to promise that there will be support available. The support must be in place and made use of effectively. Honesty and accountability are key factors.

As in any other educational environment, students may not enjoy optimal benefits from multi-age classrooms if teachers cannot implement best practices. In this instance, students may not enjoy the benefits of the educational model if teachers don’t have the ability to put differentiated instruc­tional strategies, environments, and assess­ments in place. Offering professional-development workshops on multi-age edu­cation and supporting differentiated instruction for teachers, as well as providing detailed information for parents, can help students implement multi-age programs successfully.

Learning from both current and past issues, alignment of the multi-age program with curriculum must be emphasized at all points of contact. Multi-age classrooms are often not aligned with graded and curriculum-centered educational agendas in the United States, and this contributes to the challenges of making the necessary shift.  One of the greatest difficulties for administrators looking to implement the multi-age pro­gram in traditionally organized schools is that they have to operate two different programs in one school or have to operate a program that is incompatible with the legal state and federal requirements of accountability.

Administrators, like parents and teachers, must be supported to make the shift and go beyond what has been acceptable in the past, in a bid to “make room” for multi-age classrooms. Whereas school administrators have gone about creating space for multi-age classrooms in the past, trying to force them into what already exists, administrators must instead be supported in creating multi-age classrooms that exist outside the graded system. Based on research, some of which is mentioned above, there is little argument that multi-age classrooms cannot fit within the traditional graded school system. To make multi-age classrooms benefi­cial to all students, administrators should envision the classrooms as a “school within a school.”

School administrators must do more than apply multi-age education as a quick-fix solution for the underserved or for those who are not succeeding in the traditional classroom. Multi-age classrooms should not be used as a dumping ground but should be considered, as part of an established multi-age program, to be something more substantial. Indeed, administrators must essentially revise their thinking to ensure that multi-age classrooms are seen as the best option for providing students with an excellent education.

Finally, there is the problem of federal and state accountabif5lity and how the existing systems of accountability depend on standards, assessments, and school performance accountability. Creating a K-12 education system that emphasizes the achievement of all students and the academic, social, and emotional development of students is crucial, but also something that cannot be rushed. The accountability issues currently manifest as supports for a system that emphasizes the achievement of the “bubble kids,” or stu­dents just below the passing rates or cut scores on standardized testing.

Of course, there should be an emphasis on students who are on the outside of the distribution of abilities, whereas the current emphasis is at the expense of students in these bounds. The lowest achievers and high-ability students don’t have a place with the current model, and creativity and innovation, of course, are lost in the drive to have students demonstrate a level of minimum competency.

Shifting to multi-age classrooms should also concentrate on this notion of providing individual students with access to challenging but developmentally appropriate instruction. More than this, though, there should be a clear effort to embrace the potential for creative and innovative learning. The opportunities for this learning and the obvious need for it should be emphasized as one of the principal reasons for the shift to multi-age classrooms.

The need to embrace the true principles of education is central to all the benefits, challenges, and subsequent recommendations for multi-age classroom development and management.

 

Pass or Fail: Multi-Age Classrooms — The Verdict

In this multi-part series, I provide a dissection of the phenomenon of retention and social promotion. Also, I describe the many different methods that would improve student instruction in classrooms and eliminate the need for retention and social promotion if combined effectively.

While reading this series, periodically ask yourself this question: Why are educators, parents and the American public complicit in a practice that does demonstrable harm to children and the competitive future of the country?

As outlined in all of the strategies for ending grade retention and social promotion considered so far, there is a need for substantial and systemic change, not just an end to the specific policies regulating retention and social promotion. Indeed, the strategies discussed in this series are not exclusively or even primarily concentrated on the ending of grade retention and social promotion; these problems are merely symptoms of a greater disease. The true focus should be upon putting an end to the graded education model and the related problems of standardized assessments and graded curriculum; problems that hamper student learning, often leaving the most vulnerable and the most talented of our students without a place in the educational system.

It is clear that multi-age classrooms can be an opportunity for developmentally appropriate, innovative, creative, and engaging educational opportunities. The multi-age classroom also has tremendous potential as an educational approach if supported by skilled, qualified, and dedicated professionals in various capacities.

It bears repeating, though, that an added layer of engagement, challenge, and innovative thinking is needed before a multi-age classroom can be implemented that is both effective at achieving specified educational goals for all students and maximizing learning for individuals.

Many aspects of development relate to socialization, behavior, communication, and physical development. Students in schools need the opportunity to work on these other areas of development as much as they need the opportunity to develop intellectually and academically. Students need to be able to interact appropriately with their peers and with adults. Behavioral considerations come into play both with emotional and social developments.

Given that there is evidence of the benefits of multi-age classrooms with specific reference to these areas, it seems one of the added benefits of the educational model must be that graduating students are not only better prepared academically; they are also better equipped with opportunities to mature socially and emotionally. Behavioral problems may be more effectively addressed in the multi-age classroom setting, affording students better opportunities for engagement that come with exposure to more mature students.

What will it take for multi-age classrooms to become a reasonable norm, though? It starts with parent and teacher support of the idea and also calls for research on best practices. From there, multi-age classrooms with strong potential can be formed as a positive way to avoid retention or social promotion – and all the baggage those practices carry.

 

Pass or Fail: A New Plan for K-12 Success

In this multi-part series, I provide a dissection of the phenomenon of retention and social promotion. Also, I describe the many different methods that would improve student instruction in classrooms and eliminate the need for retention and social promotion if combined effectively.

While reading this series, periodically ask yourself this question: Why are educators, parents and the American public complicit in a practice that does demonstrable harm to children and the competitive future of the country?

The practice of passing students to the next grade or holding them back is nothing new. In the often cut-and-dry world of K-12 academics, the fate of a student is based on a shockingly unsophisticated system. The K-12 system seems to be oblivious or indifferent to the impact this pass/fail system has on the lives of the children it affects. Even though all available indices show they are the worse for it, students continue to be promoted by age with no concern for subject mastery or held back regardless of age when metrics are not met. Such irrationality demands an explanation. Why are educators, parents and the American public complicit in a practice that does demonstrable harm to children and the competitive future of the country?

Although this series is about the evolution of pass-fail systems in our schools, it does more than summarize the evolution of retention and social promotion in the American public education system. It’s more important message is a description of the benefits of individualized learning and an explanation of why so many Americans are oblivious to them.  The sad truth is that neither retention nor social promotion have been thought out. They were both simply allowed to happen, paths of least resistance on the journey from the one-room schoolhouse of the historical past to the high pressure, the age-grade system of today.

After critiquing the current pass-fail system, this series goes on to describe the many different methods that would improve student instruction in classrooms and eliminate the need for retention and social promotion if combined effectively. Modified standards, better teacher training, multiple approaches to assessment and a whole new outlook on K-12 classroom design are just a few of the points emphasized and encouraged in the latter half of the series. Replacing the pass-fail system with something equally rigid and simplistic will not improve the public education system in any meaningful way. What is needed is an entirely new approach that is thoughtfully assembled, piece by piece, from the ground up.

The American education system started with the iconic one-room schoolhouse, where students of all ages learned together in a common room. While quaint by today’s sophisticated standards, those rooms did, in fact, represent great educational equalizers. In this light, it is once again important to remind ourselves why they were replaced by a more rigorous, age-based system.

The statistics show a steeply rising trend in both social promotion and retention over time. Clearly, these facts show that the underlying causes of poor academic performance have simply been papered over with reflexive pass-fail standards. Pass-fail systems have been in place for decades without ever being subjected to serious review. What would the K-12 system look like if these policies were eliminated? If retention and social promotion are truly designed to help the individual student, why are students doing so poorly?

This series attempts to answer these questions by examining the actual impact of pass-fail strategies and the harm they do to individual students, their communities, and the U.S. workforce. Unemployment and public assistance is especially prevalent among high school dropouts, who are disproportionately comprised of students who were socially promoted or held back.

This series starts with the admission of failure for the existing K-12 system and moves on to describe and promote concrete alternatives to retention and social promotion. Many of these alternatives consist of various types of targeted intervention for struggling students. Special attention has been given to realistic, cost-effective interventions that can be implemented in public schools with minimal disruption to other students.

To transform the U.S. K-12 system from its current reliance on a pass-fail system will require the integrated implementation of all of the strategies I advocate in this blog series. The solution must be as multi-faceted as the problem.

In light of the multiple problems affecting the K-12 system, I encourage the reader to consider a six-point strategy for eliminating the pass-fail system and for qualitatively improving the efficacy of the U.S. public education system. Click here to see those points.

Pass or Fail: Rewriting Standards to Eradicate Pass-Fail Strategies

In this multi-part series, I provide a dissection of the phenomenon of retention and social promotion. Also, I describe the many different methods that would improve student instruction in classrooms and eliminate the need for retention and social promotion if combined effectively.

While reading this series, periodically ask yourself this question: Why are educators, parents and the American public complicit in a practice that does demonstrable harm to children and the competitive future of the country?

When it comes to getting rid of our current pass-fail system, I have developed six strategies (click to see them all). The first is new standards that pull away from pass-fail initiatives to a better outcome for students.

Clear standards must guide the actions of all stakeholders in the education process. Administrators need clear standards to support policy decisions, just as teachers require a clear description of what they must teach, how they must teach it, and how they must assess their students’ learning. Students also need to know what they must learn and do to demonstrate their learning in an assessment process that does not entail the rigid standardization so characteristic of today’s tests. At some point in their K-12 career, students need to learn how to support themselves or seek out additional support from the school system when they encounter difficulties.

An emphasis on standards in the comprehensive sense advocated here can help to solve many of the existing problems in the K-12 system. As part of a broader strategy, an emphasis on standards can also help to ensure that all key players are on the same page. The ultimate vision is to provide a quality education that prepares students for college and high-level careers. Over the short term, the goal is to ensure students have ample opportunity to achieve success throughout their K-12 school career and to demonstrate their learning by making use of an assessment procedure that suits their temperament and accurately reflects their accomplishments. Clear and comprehensive standards provide a clear pathway to success as well as access to learning resources of proven efficacy.

These standards are needed before any shift away from the pass-fail mentality is possible and the time to start writing them is now.

Pass or Fail: Hiring Qualified Teachers to Reduce the Need for Pass-Fail Systems

In this multi-part series, I provide a dissection of the phenomenon of retention and social promotion. Also, I describe the many different methods that would improve student instruction in classrooms and eliminate the need for retention and social promotion if combined effectively.

While reading this series, periodically ask yourself this question: Why are educators, parents and the American public complicit in a practice that does demonstrable harm to children and the competitive future of the country?

When it comes to getting rid of our current pass-fail system, I have developed six strategies (click to see them all). Hiring qualified teachers who know how to reduce the retention and social promotion rates through pedagogy is one of those points.

Research continues to show that good teachers are the single most effective factor in student success. Unfortunately, not all teachers are adequately prepared to address the rising standards of education in the modern world. The problem lies not so much with the teachers themselves as it does with their lack of training and their lack of access to teaching resources. To avoid both retention and social promotion, teachers must be better prepared. Moreover, they must expect to continue to prepare themselves throughout their careers.

Because the hiring of quality teachers is the second step outlined in our program for change, it is particularly important that the time frame for educational transition be a prominent element of the reform process. On the surface, the hiring of “qualified” and “competent” teachers seems easy enough and should be something that schools are already doing. The problem is that the hiring – and retention – of teachers reflects the standards of a dysfunctional system. While it is probably too harsh to say that schools have no-one to blame but themselves for the teachers they now have, it is certainly true that the effectiveness of teachers in the U.S. public school system is unlikely to improve until hiring standards are revised to reflect the requirements of multiage classrooms, individual interventions, alternative assessment procedures, and other elements of individual-based education. Moreover, schools must be prepared to implement retraining programs for teachers who were selected on the basis of existing pass-fail, age-graded standards. It is not enough, or even fair, simply round up anyone suspected of incompetence.

It stands to reason that if students are changing, teachers need to change too. More specifically, the education that teachers receive needs to be modified to meet the needs of modern K–12 classrooms. There are policy and practice changes taking place all over the world – many driven by teachers – that address the cultural shifts in the classroom. Some of the more promising recent developments in the educational world include the following items:

Subject-specific recruiting by colleges and universities. The book Teaching 2030, written by 13 experts in K-12 classroom pedagogy, calls for education schools to stop admitting anyone so long as they have some education major. Instead, the experts suggest that colleges become more selective to meet the actual needs of today’s students. Young people who want to teach in high-demand subject areas like mathematics, bilingual education, the physical sciences and special education should be given a higher priority by admissions boards of teaching colleges. Such a needs-based philosophy addresses actual voids in the industry and produces teachers who are better equipped to meet students’ needs.

Virtual learning options. Although online college courses have been around for years, K-12 education has also begun to provide distance learning options for students in some areas. During the 2010-2011 school year, 1.8 million students in grades K-12 were enrolled in some distance learning program. That is up from just 50,000 in the 2000-2001 school year, according to the International Association for K-12 Online Learning. This is a trend that teachers-to-be simply cannot ignore. Virtual learning is not reserved only for those who can afford it; 40 U.S. states have state-run online programs, and 30 of those states provide statewide, full-time K-12 schools online. The University of Central Florida is one of the only schools to offer a virtual-school emphasis for education majors that lets students apprentice with Florida Virtual School instructors.

Public education in America needs teachers who are better trained to meet the needs of specific student populations, who understand the necessary role of distance learning, and who are willing to speak up for making real change in the classroom. Without such teachers, it is unlikely that social promotion and retention can be replaced by individual-based learning.

 

Pass or Fail: Multiple Assessments to Determine True Learning

In this multi-part series, I provide a dissection of the phenomenon of retention and social promotion. Also, I describe the many different methods that would improve student instruction in classrooms and eliminate the need for retention and social promotion if combined effectively.

While reading this series, periodically ask yourself this question: Why are educators, parents and the American public complicit in a practice that does demonstrable harm to children and the competitive future of the country?

When it comes to getting rid of our current pass-fail system, I have developed six strategies (click to see them all). Developing a system with varied assessments is one of those points.

Many educators view standardized testing as a necessary evil, and some see it as a completely useless process that never reflects what students know. Proponents of K-12 assessments, on the other hand, contend that there is no adequate way to enforce educator accountability without them.

The majority of states and school districts rely on large-scale assessments when it comes to student grade progression, but this should only be a small piece of a larger analysis of individual students. Multiple sources of information about a student should be used in determining his or her readiness for the next grade, and teachers should make use of them.

Compared to the first two stages of change, the idea of creating multiple assessment measures is very easy. To some extent, public schools already make use of multiple assessment measures. For instance, multiple assessment measures are standard for students with IEPs, and IEPs are not usually changed without making reference to multiple assessment measures. The real key to implementing this stage is not so much the employment of multiple measures as it is the actual selection of those measures and the way they should be administered and interpreted.

The use of multiple assessments including some that do not entail tests makes allowance for that considerable proportion of the student body that does not perform well on tests. Multiple assessments also allow for the possibility that a student simply had a bad day on the day of the test. Finally, the inclusion of some assessment elements that do not consist of a rigid, multiple-choice tests reduces the likelihood of students “overthinking” higher-level questions, and inadvertently providing the right answer to the wrong question.

A combination of assessments is best both for simple assessment of learning and for making decisions about retention. The decision to hold a student back, if made at all, should be made on the basis of multiple measures of performance, and never strictly by a standardized test.